Beyond Wealth and Status at Archanes-Phourni
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of Pennsylvania ScholarlyCommons Publicly Accessible Penn Dissertations 2018 A Truth Universally Acknowledged: Beyond Wealth And Status At Archanes-Phourni Sarah R. Linn University of Pennsylvania, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://repository.upenn.edu/edissertations Part of the History of Art, Architecture, and Archaeology Commons Recommended Citation Linn, Sarah R., "A Truth Universally Acknowledged: Beyond Wealth And Status At Archanes-Phourni" (2018). Publicly Accessible Penn Dissertations. 2770. https://repository.upenn.edu/edissertations/2770 This paper is posted at ScholarlyCommons. https://repository.upenn.edu/edissertations/2770 For more information, please contact [email protected]. A Truth Universally Acknowledged: Beyond Wealth And Status At Archanes- Phourni Abstract In the Pre- and Protopalatial periods, Minoan burial practices were communal, interactive, and sustained, creating complex tomb assemblages that span several hundred years. Small-scale taphonomic analyses of mortuary contexts indicate that secondary treatments of human remains were variable and frequent while large-scale regional studies suggest greater diversity among Early Minoan (EM) and Middle Minoan (MM) communities than previously believed. These nuanced approaches to variability, however, have not been fully realized at the mid-range, intra-site scale. Diversity in tomb architecture and object assemblages has continually been interpreted as evidence of hierarchical social structure and increasing social complexity before the appearance of the Minoan palaces, often ignoring other aspects of these contexts that contradict this interpretation. This dissertation focuses on social interaction rather than social structure, and proposes a methodology for considering complex tomb assemblages and intra-site variability using the well-known site of Archanes-Phourni as a case study. It provides a detailed, contextual re-analysis of the 23 communal and long-lived burial contexts dating from EM IIA to MM II (ca. 2700-1700 BCE), highlighting chronological and spatial variability related to changing burial practices and distinct group identities. Using quantitative and qualitative analytical methods, and drawing on contemporary theories of time, materiality, personhood, and value, this work offers an interpretation of the diverse and interactive burial practices at Archanes- Phourni at multiple scales. Contextual analysis of these tomb assemblages indicates that there was significant variety in spatial structure, methods of interment, and object deposition but that these individually variable practices occurred alongside long-lived, communally shared traditions. The frequent interactions with burial deposits that served to maintain connections between the living and the dead throughout the Prepalatial and into the Protopalatial period, diminished in MM II, suggesting a new approach to burial and to the cemetery. Degree Type Dissertation Degree Name Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) Graduate Group Art & Archaeology of Mediterranean World First Advisor Lauren Ristvet Second Advisor Thomas Tartaron Keywords Minoan Subject Categories History of Art, Architecture, and Archaeology This dissertation is available at ScholarlyCommons: https://repository.upenn.edu/edissertations/2770 A TRUTH UNIVERSALLY ACKNOWLEDGED: BEYOND WEALTH AND STATUS AT ARCHANES-PHOURNI Sarah R. Linn A DISSERTATION in Art and Archaeology of the Mediterranean World Presented to the Faculties of the University of Pennsylvania in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy 2018 Supervisor of Dissertation Co-Supervisor of Dissertation ________________________ ________________________ Lauren Ristvet Thomas Tartaron Associate Professor of Anthropology Associate Professor of Classical Studies Graduate Group Chairperson _______________________ Thomas Tartaron, Associate Professor of Classical Studies Dissertation Committee Lauren Ristvet, Associate Professor of Anthropology Thomas Tartaron, Associate Professor of Classical Studies Joanne Murphy, Associate Professor of Classical Studies ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This project would not have been possible without the support of many people. I would especially like to thank my committee. My profound thanks to Lauren Ristvet for her unceasing encouragement of this research and her incredible support when I needed it most. Thomas Tartaron offered much-needed guidance during the formulation of this project and sound advice throughout the process. I am also thankful to Joanne Murphy for sharing her knowledge of Minoan burial practices and for generously giving of her time, expertise, and humor. Over the last nine years, I have benefitted greatly from the support of several other faculty at Penn and elsewhere. I would especially like to thank Philip P. Betancourt for giving me the opportunity to excavate a Minoan cemetery, Cam Grey and Jeremy McInerney for showing me the joys of teaching, and Kimberly Bowes for making archaeological theory interesting. I am also fortunate to have worked with several remarkable scholars and mentors, both in the field and at home. I thank especially Mary Voyatzis and David Romano for their incredible support and for bringing me to the mountains of Arcadia, and Ann Brownlee for her encouragement in pursuing a museum career. I am immensely grateful for the opportunity to spend a year at the American School of Classical Studies in Athens, made possible with the generous support of the Penn Museum. The community at the ASCSA and traveling around in Greece renewed my passion for archaeology. I thank especially Samantha Henneberry, Marya Fisher, Chelsea Gardner, and Stephanie Kimmey. This community of friends and colleagues in Greece is paralleled only by that in Philadelphia. I first thank Sarah Beckmann for her ii friendship from day one of this program, as well as Kate Morgan, Lara Fabian, Kurtis Tanaka, Lucas Stephens, Katherine Burge, and Olivia Hayden for their unstinting support, guidance, and friendship. Several people contributed directly to this project. I am grateful to Lucas Stephens for his help with the maps of Archanes, Kyle Mahoney for innumerable hours of help with Greek translations, Dallas Simons for his assistance with the multivariate statistical analyses, and Eli Storch, my wonderful husband, for the beautiful plans and images. I must also thank my parents for their love and support throughout this process. And finally, I thank my husband for his unending patience and support, and without whom this project would not have been possible. iii ABSTRACT A TRUTH UNIVERSALLY ACKNOWLEDGED: BEYOND WEALTH AND STATUS AT ARCHANES-PHOURNI Sarah Linn Lauren Ristvet Thomas Tartaron In the Pre- and Protopalatial periods, Minoan burial practices were communal, interactive, and sustained, creating complex tomb assemblages that span several hundred years. Small-scale taphonomic analyses of mortuary contexts indicate that secondary treatments of human remains were variable and frequent while large-scale regional studies suggest greater diversity among Early Minoan (EM) and Middle Minoan (MM) communities than previously believed. These nuanced approaches to variability, however, have not been fully realized at the mid-range, intra-site scale. Diversity in tomb architecture and object assemblages has continually been interpreted as evidence of hierarchical social structure and increasing social complexity before the appearance of the Minoan palaces, often ignoring other aspects of these contexts that contradict this interpretation. This dissertation focuses on social interaction rather than social structure, and proposes a methodology for considering complex tomb assemblages and intra-site variability using the well-known site of Archanes-Phourni as a case study. It provides a detailed, contextual re-analysis of the 23 communal and long-lived burial contexts dating from EM IIA to MM II (ca. 2700-1700 BCE), highlighting chronological and spatial iv variability related to changing burial practices and distinct group identities. Using quantitative and qualitative analytical methods, and drawing on contemporary theories of time, materiality, personhood, and value, this work offers an interpretation of the diverse and interactive burial practices at Archanes-Phourni at multiple scales. Contextual analysis of these tomb assemblages indicates that there was significant variety in spatial structure, methods of interment, and object deposition but that these individually variable practices occurred alongside long-lived, communally shared traditions. The frequent interactions with burial deposits that served to maintain connections between the living and the dead throughout the Prepalatial and into the Protopalatial period, diminished in MM II, suggesting a new approach to burial and to the cemetery. v TABLE OF CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ................................................................................................... II ABSTRACT .......................................................................................................................... IV LIST OF FIGURES ............................................................................................................... X CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................... 1 ARCHANES-PHOURNI .................................................................................................................. 5 CEMETERIES IN MINOAN SCHOLARSHIP