EVOLUTION of MOULTING STRATEGIES and ALTITUDINAL MIGRATION of PASSERINES by CLAUDIE PAGEAU B.Sc., Université Du Québec À Chic
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
EVOLUTION OF MOULTING STRATEGIES AND ALTITUDINAL MIGRATION OF PASSERINES by CLAUDIE PAGEAU B.Sc., Université du Québec à Chicoutimi, 2018 A THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF SCIENCE IN ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES The Faculty of Science Thesis examining committee: Matt Reudink (PhD), Associate Professor and Thesis Supervisor, Biological Sciences, Thompson Rivers University Mateen Shaikh (PhD), Assistant Professor and Committee Member, Mathematics & Statistics, Thompson Rivers University Nancy Flood (PhD), Senior Lecturer and Committee Member, Biological Sciences, Thompson Rivers University Tom Dickinson (PhD), Dean of Science and Committee Member, Biological Sciences, Thompson Rivers University Vanya Rohwer (PhD), External Examiner, The Cornell Lab of Ornithology, Cornell University August 2020 Thompson Rivers University Claudie Pageau, 2020 Thesis Supervisor: Associate Professor Matt Reudink ii ABSTRACT Each year, migratory birds need to undertake three main energetically costly events: breeding, migration, and moulting. While most species separate these three events during the annual cycle and share the same moulting and migration strategies, some species have evolved a variety of different moulting and migratory strategies. The goal of my thesis was to understand the evolution of these particular moulting and migratory strategies and which environmental factors or life history characteristics may have driven their evolution. Particularly, I was interested in the evolution of moult-migration, winter moults, and altitudinal migration in passerines (i.e., perching birds). To do so, I used phylogenetic analyses to correct for non-independence among species. My results indicated that arid breeding grounds were associated with moult-migration in North American passerines; the lack of resources during late summer appeared to force birds to migrate to more productive moulting grounds such as the Mexican monsoon region. I also found an association between the conditions on the wintering grounds and the evolution of winter moults for North American and European passerines. Specifically, longer day lengths on the overwintering grounds were associated with a single moult on the wintering grounds and also the presence of a second moult. Overwintering in open habitats was also associated with the presence of a second, winter moult for European passerines; birds experiencing longer day lengths and open habitats are subject to higher UV exposure which increases feather wear and may force birds to moult some feathers a second time. Completely moulting twice during the annual cycle was associated with high primary productivity on the wintering grounds for European passerines. Finally, I examined all passerines around the globe and found that altitudinal migration was associated with diet, but the nature of the relationship varied within regions. In North America, species with a plant and fruit diet or omnivorous diet were more likely to evolve altitudinal migration; in Europe and north Asia, omnivorous species were more likely to be altitudinal migrants. All these results indicate the importance of environmental conditions and life history characteristics in the evolution of moult and migration strategies. Keywords: Phylogenetic analysis, Moult-migration, Altitudinal migration, Winter moult, Prealternate moult. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT......................................................................................................................... ii TABLE OF CONTENTS .................................................................................................... iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ................................................................................................... v LIST OF FIGURES ..............................................................................................................vi LIST OF TABLES ............................................................................................................ viii CHAPTER 1 : INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................... 1 LITERATURE CITED ..................................................................................................... 6 CHAPTER 2 : EVOLUTION OF MOULT-MIGRATION IS DIRECTLY LINKED TO ARIDITY OF THE BREEDING GROUNDS IN NORTH AMERICAN PASSERINES ....... 8 ABSTRACT ..................................................................................................................... 8 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................ 8 METHODS .................................................................................................................... 10 Data Collection ........................................................................................................... 10 Potential Drivers of Moult-Migration .......................................................................... 11 Phylogeny ................................................................................................................... 12 Statistical Analysis ...................................................................................................... 13 RESULTS ...................................................................................................................... 14 DISCUSSION ................................................................................................................ 14 LITERATURE CITED ................................................................................................... 18 CHAPTER 3 : CONTRASTING EVOLUTION OF WINTER MOULTING STRATEGIES IN EUROPEAN AND NORTH AMERICAN PASSERINES ............................................. 22 ABSTRACT ................................................................................................................... 22 INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................... 22 METHODS .................................................................................................................... 26 iv Species Selection ........................................................................................................ 26 Classification Moult Strategies .................................................................................... 26 Data Collection of Predictor Variables ........................................................................ 27 Phylogeny ................................................................................................................... 28 Statistical Analysis ...................................................................................................... 28 RESULTS ...................................................................................................................... 29 Prebasic winter moult .................................................................................................. 29 Presence of a prealternate moult .................................................................................. 34 Presence of a complete prealternate moult ................................................................... 35 DISCUSSION ................................................................................................................ 35 LITERATURE CITED ................................................................................................... 40 CHAPTER 4 : EVOLUTION OF ALTITUDINAL MIGRATION IN PASSERINES IS LINKED TO DIET.............................................................................................................. 45 ABSTRACT ................................................................................................................... 45 INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................... 45 METHODS .................................................................................................................... 49 Data Collection ........................................................................................................... 49 Phylogeny ................................................................................................................... 51 Statistical Analysis ...................................................................................................... 51 RESULTS ...................................................................................................................... 52 DISCUSSION ................................................................................................................ 54 LITERATURE CITED ................................................................................................... 58 CHAPTER 5 : CONCLUSION ........................................................................................... 61 LITERATURE CITED ................................................................................................... 64 v ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS First, I am so grateful for my supervisor, Dr. Matt Reudink. Your guidance, help with my writing, and advice for my future career is immensely appreciated; I did luck out having a supervisor like you. Thank you to everyone in the BEAC lab, you made it way more fun to spend my days in the lab glued to my chair. Aaron and Jared, you can fight to decide who’s inheriting the chair. I would like to thank Stephen Joly for decorating my desk