DSpace Institution DSpace Repository http://dspace.org
Water Resource and Irrigation Management Thesis and Dissertations
2018-11-22 AMASSESSMENT ON ECOTOURISM POTENTIALS AND DEVELOPMENT IN KEFFA BIOSPHERE RESERVE: CASE OF GIMBO WOREDA IN SOUTHERN, NATIONS, NATIONALITIES AND PEAPLES REGIONAL STATE.
Sahile, Atinafu http://hdl.handle.net/123456789/9184 Downloaded from DSpace Repository, DSpace Institution's institutional repository
BAHIR DAR UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF AGRICUTLURE AND ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES DEPARTMENT OF FISHERY, WETLAND, AND WILDLIF MANAGEMENT WILDLIFE CONSERVATION AND ECOTOURISM MANAGEMENT GRADGUATE PROGRAM
ASSESSMENT ON ECOTOURISM POTENTIALS AND DEVELOPMENT IN KEFFA BIOSPHERE RESERVE: CASE OF GIMBO WOREDA IN SOUTHERN NATIONS, NATIONALITIES AND PEAPLES REGIONAL STATE.
M.Sc. Thesis Research BY Atinafu Sahile
September, 2018 Bahir Dar
BAHIR DAR UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF AGRICUTLURE AND ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES DEPARTMENT OF FISHERY, WETLAND, AND WILDLIF MANAGEMENT WILDLIFE CONSERVATION AND ECOTOURISM MANAGEMENT
AMASSESSMENT ON ECOTOURISM POTENTIALS AND DEVELOPMENT IN KEFFA BIOSPHERE RESERVE: CASE OF GIMBO WOREDA IN SOUTHERN, NATIONS, NATIONALITIES AND PEAPLES REGIONAL STATE.
M.Sc. Thesis By Atinafu Sahile Main Advisor: Eshetu Moges (PhD) Co-advisor: Gashaw Tilahun (PhD) SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF SCIENCE (M.Sc.) IN WILDLIFE CONSERVATION AND ECOTOURISM MANAGEMENT
September, 2018 Bahir Dar
ii
THESIS APPROVAL SHEET
As a member of the Board of Examiners of the Master of Sciences (M.Sc.) thesis open defense examination, we have read and evaluated this thesis prepared by Mr. Atinafu Sahile W/Silasie entitled “Assessment on Ecotourism Potentials and Development in Kaffa Biosphere Reserve in Gimbo Woreda in SNNPS.” We hereby certify that; the thesis is accepted for fulfilling the requirements for the award of the degree of Masters of Sciences (M.Sc.) in Wildlife conservation and Ecotourism management.
Board of Examiners
______
Name of External Examiner Signature Date
______
Name of Internal Examiner Signature Date
______
Name of Chairman Signature Date
iii
DECLARATION
This is to certify that this thesis entitled “Assessment on Ecotourism Potentials and Development in Kaffa Biosphere Reserve in Gimbo Woreda in SNNPS.” Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the award of the degree of Master of Science in “Wildlife conservation and Ecotourism management.” to the Graduate Program of College of Agriculture and Environmental Sciences, Bahir Dar University by Mr. Atinafu Sahile W/silasie (ID. No. BDU0906281PR) is an authentic work carried out by him under our guidance. The matter embodied in this project work has not been submitted earlier for award of any degree or diploma to the best of our knowledge and belief.
Name of the Student
Atinafu Sahile
Signature & date ______
Name of the Supervisors
1) Eshetu Moges (PhD) (Main Supervisor)
Signature & date ______
2) Gashaw Tilahun (PhD) (Co-Supervisor)
Signature & date ______
iv
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
First and foremost, I would like to honor and extend my sincere gratitude to my God, for providing me the opportunity to make my long term dream a reality and for being with me in every piece of life to accomplish may plan in every hour and minutes. I would like to extend my heartfelt thanks to my major advisor Dr. Eshetu Moges for his valuable advice, insight and guidance starting from the inception of the research title up to the completion of overall thesis Work. I also thank the Bahrdar University College of Agriculture and Environmental Sciences, Department of Wildlife and Ecotourism Management for giving me the opportunity to attend in this Program and support to do this research work. I am again thankful to my co- advisor, Dr. Gashaw Tilahun for his willingness to advise me as well as his valuable guidance and support in shaping my research work. Finally I thank all my family, friends, and classmates who supported me in different ways.
.
v
LISTS OF ACRONYMS/ABBREVIATION
DoFED Department of Finance and Economic Development FAO Food and Agricultural Organization FAS Foreign Agricultural Services GDP Gross Domestic Product IBC Institute of Biodiversity Conservation LUPO Land Use Planning of Oromia M.a.s.l Meter above sea level MCT Ministry of Culture and Tourism NABU Nature and Biodiversity Conservation Union SNNPRS Southern Nations, Nationalities and Peoples of Regional State SPSS Statistical Package for Social Science SRMA Southern Region Meteorological Agency UNESCO United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization UNWTO United Nation World Trade Organization WB World Bank WTO World Trade Organization
vi
ABSTRACT
Ethiopia is rich with varied types of tourist attractions, which gives the country a great potential for cultural and educational tourism. This study has attempted to examine the ecotourism potentials and development in Kaffa Biosphere Reserve in Gimbo Woreda in Southern Nations Nationality and Peoples of Ethiopia. In this study three Kebeles Ufa, Shetta and Wushwush were selected as a principal locations for this study. The three Kebeles were selected purposefully, and the reason for selection was associated with availability of ecotourism potentials in relative distances, accessibility, and limitations of research cost. In line with this 218 sample respondents were selected for inquirers from three kebeles by using simple random sampling method. Qualitative and quantitative data collection techniques were employed to collect the required information on ecotourism potentials and development. Weighted Sum Method (WSM) tool was used among various tools of Multi-Criteria Decision Methods (MCDM) for assessing the tourism potential of the study sites. In addition questionnaire and key informant methods were used to assess the attitudes and perceptions of local community towards ecotourism potentials in the area. Data were analyzed using descriptive statistics and responses compared using the Chi - square test to understand the attitude of the respondents towards ecotourism resources and products Data collected were analyzed by using chi-square test to determine variation of awareness among the respondents. In addition, intra attribute scaling was used to know the level of potential ecotourism in the study area. Having these, nearly, 88% of respondents confirmed that there are high ecotourism potentials in the study area. Apart from this, the study site, Wushush has high attribute scaling on socio-cultural potential than others, while Shetta and Uffa have high attribute scaling on a forest and transport potentials, respectively. The existence of different wildlife in the study area, the presence of historical and cultural resources, the provision of different social service, and the suitability of the nature of environment is the best opportunity for ecotourism development. Finally, promoting and making further study is very important for digging out available ecotourism potentials for sustainable ecotourism development.
Keywords/Phrase: Biosphere reserve, ecotourism, ecotourism potential, ecotourism development, Multi-Criteria Decision Methods.
vii
TABLE OF CONTENTS Page THESIS APPROVAL SHEET ...... iii DECLARATION ...... iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ...... v LISTS OF ACRONYMS/ABBREVIATION ...... vi ABSTRACT ...... vii TABLE OF CONTENT ...... viii LIST OF TABLES ...... x LIST OF FIGURES ...... xi LIST OF APPENDIX FIGURE ...... xii Chapter 1. INTRODUCTION ...... 1 1.1. Background ...... 1 1.2. Statement of the problem ...... 2 1.3. Objectives ...... 3 1.3.1. General Objective ...... 4 1.3.2. Specific objectives ...... 4 1.4. Research Questions ...... 4 Chapter 2. LITERATURE REVIEW ...... 5 2.1. Tourism Potential and products for ecotourism development ...... 5 2.1.1. Tourism resources ...... 5 2.1.2. Potentials of ecotourism resources in Ethiopia ...... 9 2.1.3. Ecotourism Product ...... 10 2.1.4. Opportunities for Ecotourism Development in Ethiopia ...... 11 2.1.5. Physical facilities for ecotourism development ...... 12 2.1.6. Emergences and development of ecotourism ...... 15 2.1.7. Opportunities of Ecotourism ...... 15 2.1.8. Development of Ecotourism in Ethiopia ...... 17 Chapter 3. RESEARCH METHODOLOGIES ...... 19 3.1. Description of the Study Area ...... 19
viii
3.1.1. Location and Socioeconomic situation ...... 19 3.1.2. Biophysical characteristics ...... 20 3.2. Design of the Study ...... 22 3.2.2. Sampling design ...... 22 3.2.3. Sample size for general household questionnaire ...... 22 3.3. Data collection procedures ...... 23 3.3.1. Focus Group Discussion ...... 23 3.3.2. Questionnaire survey ...... 23 3.3.3. Interviews ...... 25 3.4. Data analysis ...... 25 Chapter4. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION ...... 27 4.1. Demographic and Socioeconomic Characteristics ...... 27 4.2 Awareness of the local community about the ecotourism resources ...... 29 4.3. Ecotourism resources and products in Gimbo Woreda .. Error! Bookmark not defined. 4.4. The opportunities for ecotourism development in Gimbo Woreda ...... 39 4.5. Perception and attitude of the respondents towards ecotourism Potentials ...... 41 Chapter 5. CONCLUSİON AND RECOMMENDATİONS ...... 43 5.1. Conclusion ...... 43 5.2. Recommendations...... 45 REFERENCES ...... 46 Appendix ...... 52
ix
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1: Demographic characteristics of the respondents ...... 27 Table 2: Age category and educational level of sample respondents...... 28 Table 3: Local community response towards ecotourism potentials ...... 30 Table4: The attributes under socio-cultural, physical and environmental aspects in Wushwush...... 30 Table 5: The attributes under socio-cultural, physical, and environmental aspects Shetta ...... 34 Table6: The attributes under socio-cultural, physical and environmental aspects in Uffa...... 37 Table7: Attributes and their aggregated sums in selected study sites ...... 38 Table8: Perception and attitude of the respondents towardst ecotourism Potentials and development....……………………………………………...... 45 Table9: Response about changes in the provision of infrastructure ...... 46
x
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1:Types of tourism infrastructure ...... 14 Figure 2 :Components of tourism infrastructure ...... 15 Figure 4: The map of the Study area (Source: by the Author) ...... 19 Figure5: Mean Monthly Rainfall in mm of Gimbo ...... 21 Figure6: Mean Monthly Minimum, Average and Maximum Temperature in oC of the study area ...... 21 Figur7:The livelihood of the sample respondents on the study sites…………………………32 Figure8: Type of potential attributes ...... 39
xi
LIST OF APPENDIX FIGURE
Figure 1: Wildlife’s in Kaffa Biosphere Reserve (Source: NABU Field guide, 2013)……. 53 Figure 2: Raba natural forest (Source: Field Photo by Atinafu, 2017)……………………. 54 Figure 3: Keja natural forest (Source: Field Photo by Atinafu, 2017)……………………...54 Figure 4: Gojeb/Godefoo Wetland (Source: NABUS Field guide2013)…………………... 55 Figure 5:Bird Watching tour in Alemgono wetland (Source: Field Photo by Atinafu, 2017)…………………………………………………………………………………………56 Figure 6: Rivers in Gimbo Woreda (Source: Field Photo by Atinafu, 2017)……………… 56 Figure7: Dadiben holly hot sprig (Source: NABUS Field guide 2013)……………………..57 Figure 8: Bongee shambetoo (Source: Bunoo Magazin 2011)……………………………...57 Figure 9: Historical House and compound of Allaamoo (Source: Bunoo Magazin2011)…. 58 Figure 10: Indigenous qoollee deejoo (ritual practice) and cultural resources (Source: Bunoo Magazin 2011)………………………………………………………………………………59 Figure 11: Accommodation and services near Gimbo Woreda (Source: Sigrum Lange)…. 59 Figure12: Cultural dishes in Gimbo (Source: Bunoo Magazin, 2011)……………………...60
xii
Chapter1. INTRODUCTION
1.1. Background
Tourism is internationally being known since 1950 (WTO, 2002). Currently, tourism is the largest and the fastest growing business, which contributes to a lot of new jobs in both urban and rural areas (Rannersmann, 2003). Because of increasing and fast growing of tourism, currently more than 650 million international tourist arrivals are recorded in the world, and it will be more than 1.6 billion by the year 2020 (Holden, 2003). Africa is the world’s poorest region, with almost fifty percent of its population living with less than $ 1 per day. However, much of its area is recognized by its huge potentials for tourism development (WTO, 2002).
Ecotourism can be described as purposeful travel to natural areas to understand the cultural and natural history of the environment, taking care not to alter the integrity of the ecosystem, and producing economic opportunities that make conservation of natural resources beneficial to local people (Khan, 1997). Ecotourism can bring about social benefits to a local community, and it also empowers and strengthens economic, social, and cultural aspects of the society (Scheyvens, 1999). Empowerment can be brought about by the capacity building and community development that support for sustainable ecotourism development (Stronza and Pêgas, 2008).
Ecotourism can also be able to help local communities’ or youths through the development of language or other skills for future employment, as a way to empower the community’s upcoming generation (Wearing and Larsen, 1996; Delmaro and Bursztyn, 2008). Apart from this, it can also help to revive the traditional culture and cultural pride of an area (Jamal and Stronza, 2008; Reimer and Walter, 2013). Ecotourism assigns a value to cultural traditions and offers that tourists’ effort to learn about the area’s culture has led to a revival of the traditional culture in the incentive to maintain and preserve them (Reimer and Walter, 2013). In general, ecotourism is seen as a viable option for self-sustaining tourism development and tools for sustainable long-term planning that is highly controlled if the necessary natural, cultural and human resources is available (Khan, 1997). In Ethiopia, ecotourism development has emerged as a sustainable form of tourism (Khan, 1
1997). In the Ethiopian context, where most of its rural people are still engaged in subsistence agriculture and living below poverty line, establishing links between tourism activity and poverty reduction as a strategic driver of per capital GDP growth (World Bank, 2006).
Ethiopia possesses numerous tourist attractions, varied in type and appealing to a wide range of interest. The attractions include historical, cultural, archaeological, anthropological, scenic, climatic, therapeutic, flora and fauna resources. Such a unique combination of attractions within a single country has no match on the African continent, or rarely anywhere else in the world (Martin, 2008).The most common tourist destination of the country could be nature based and human made sites such as Semien Mountains National Park, Rock-hewn Churches of Lalibela, Fassil Ghebbi, Lower Valley of the Omo, and Axum, Tiya, Lower Valley of the Awash and the fortified historical town of Harar Jugol (Berhanu, sintayew, 2003).
Recently, the cultural landscape of Konso and Meskel festival (the finding of the true cross) has been included as a world heritage by UNESCO. Ethiopia is extraordinarily rich with varied types of tourist attractions (ETC, 1995; Berhanu, sintayew,2003 and Briggs, 2003), which gives the country a great potential for cultural and educational tourism such as photo safaris, hunting safaris, bird watching, water sports, desert trekking, mountain camping, ecotourism, health tourism and conference tourism (Martin, 2008).Apart from these, the country is endowed with various ecotourism potentials such as the spectacular mountains, which are almost untouched by climbers, various lakes features of great for tourists; birds, wildlife, vegetation, colorful ethnic groups, historical churches and monasteries, unusual geological features, caves, local arts and artifacts of the country are among the major ecotourism resources (Henze, 2000).
1.2. Statement of the problem
As the world largest industry, tourism development strongly needs potential resources in the destination to lead in the sustainable way (UNWTO, 2013). No countries develop tourism without necessary facility and products that makes the difference in the destination (Dabour, 2003). Africa is the world’s poorest region, with almost fifty percent of its 2
population living with less than $ 1 per day; however, much of its area is recognized by its huge potentials for tourism development (WTO, 2002). Even though the continent is endowed with enormous of tourism potentials, there are inadequate facilities and services and infrastructure in many places, which hampers the full use of exploiting these potentials of tourism. Like many other developing countries, Ethiopia, greatly investing in sustainable form of tourism, ecotourism, as the potential and a reliable economic sector (Sefrin, 2012).
Due to the presence of tourism resources, the influx of tourists from every corner of the world to Ethiopia enabled to increase the growth and development of the tourism industry (Mitchell and Coles, 2009). In this regard, Kaffa Biosphere reserve endowed with various natural and cultural heritages, wildlife resources, and attractive geographical sites and many others. However, the tourism resources and product of the biosphere reserve, particularly in Gimbo Woreda were not deeply identified and promoted for the tourism development diversification (Sefrin, 2012). Moreover, tourism development policy of Ethiopia that enacted in 2009 aimed to develop the existing and new tourism attractions and products all over the country (MCT, 2009). Inline to this of this policy direction, the researchers mostly concentrated in the national parks that are easily accessible parks and well known parks like Semien Mountains, Awash, Bale Mountain, Abijata-Shala National Park and necessary national park for their research work (World Bank, 2006).
By studying the potential resources and the challenges with well-developed parks of the country, ecotourism established as the sustainable option in the tourism sector. Similarly, in Kaffa Biosphere Reserve most of the researchers did their study only on biodiversity and forest based potentials of the area. However, ecotourism potentials identification and development are untouched separately in the study site in addition ecotourism development were not fully recognized. Thus, based on these research gaps, the concern of this study is to identify the ecotourism potentials and development of the Kaffa Biosphere Reserve in different sites of Gimbo Woreda, in SNNPRS.
3
1.3. Objectives
1.3.1. General Objective
The general objective of this study is:
To assess ecotourism potentials and development in Kaffa Biosphere Reserve Area in Gimbo District in Southern Nations Nationality and Peoples of Ethiopia.
1.3.2. Specific objectives
The specific Objectives of the study are: to determine ecotourism resources and products for ecotourism development in the area. to assess the opportunities for ecotourism development in study District to identify existing physical facilities for tourism development in the study area. to evaluate the perception and attitudes of the local community towards ecotourism potentials and development in the area.
1.4. Research Questions
In this study, a lot of questions were raised to the respondents in order to foster brainstorming, and for this purpose the following research questions were managed. What are ecotourism resources and products for ecotourism development in Gimbo Woreda What are the ecotourism opportunities of natural and cultural sites around the biosphere reserve? What are the existing physical facilities for tourism development within the biosphere reserve? What are the perception and attitudes of the local communities towards ecotourism potentials and
4
Chapter2. LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1. Tourism Potential and products for ecotourism development
2.1.1. Tourism resources
The economic definition of ‘resource’, resources in tourism may be defined as, all those means that can be beneficially utilized for the purpose of tourism in a given area (Pancic and Kombol, 2000). In addition to primary tourism resources, a resource base is also made up of other direct tourism resources (tourism and catering facilities, related facilities and services, staff, agencies, organization) and indirect tourism resources (preserved environment, geo-transportation position, municipal infrastructure, political stability (Kusen, 2002).
The basic classification of primary tourism resources which is not exhaustive is done according to specific criteria. The most common are being genetic origin, qualitatively and, multiplicity (Baud et al. 1997).In terms of genetics; resources are classified as natural and manmade, and in terms of quality, as direct or indirect (Bilen and Bucar, 2001). A qualitative classification is based on resource evaluation; evaluation is a procedure that determines the level to which a given area is suited to a defined facet of tourism, usage (Coccossis, 1997and Bognar, 2005).
Natural Tourism Resources Natural tourism resources consist of all natural elements and factors that possess a high degree of attractiveness and that reflect their geographical environment and can be valorised for tourism purposes (Djukic, 1999). According to their relevant features, these resources can be classified as geo-morphological, climate-based, hydrographical and bio- geographical, and as a protected natural heritage. This classification has been accepted in resource planning and management and in Croatian tourism.
Geo-morphological resources These consist of all phenomena and processes associated with the genesis, prevalence and contemporary dynamics of relief. As an independent natural factor, relief has a complex role because it preconditions the forms in which all other natural given conditions occur in 5
an area and the manner of their impact. It influences the qualitative characteristics of the surface and near-surface part of the rock complex, as well as the features of climate, soil, vegetation, drainage coefficient. Heights above sea level and various relief forms represent a complex tourist attraction. Heights are a natural component of space that can be artificially changed or created only in exceptional cases and at huge cost (unlike some other natural resources that can be substituted with artificial resources). Although valorisation is rarely based on a single natural element, it should be noted that plains are a spatial feature of monotonous tourism, while mountains are a feature of variable tourism (Blazevic and Knezevic, 2006). Mountains – relief elevations higher than 500 meters above sea level – are a spatially dominating resource. In recent times, winter mountain tourism has developed rapidly (previously, this was health tourism) and other branches of tourism to a lesser extent (mountaineering, rock climbing, paragliding, eco-tourism, speleology). In evaluating a mountain for tourism purposes, heights above sea level and terrain configuration must be taken into account, whereas the quality of an area intended for winter sports tourism is valuated using the so-called relief energy method. In essence, this method consists of determining the degree of deleveling on a given surface, that is, the difference in altitude between the highest and lowest usable points (THM, 2008). Geo-morphological phenomena These phenomena are caused by relatively vigorous tectonic activity and fault lines along which numerous thermo-mineral springs have formed (from the Greek thermos – warm and mineral is usually translated as chemical independence). Thermo-mineral waters commonly have a curative effect, and are used in therapeutic purposes or are bottled and sold. Karst represents a set of relief forms occurring in rocks subject to chemical erosion. As a geo- morphological resource, karst can be found in southern Europe, Latin America, and Carpathians and in China. Karst forms can be classified as superficial and underground forms. The largest superficial karst forms as karst fields and karst plateaus, which are generally a complex tourism resource. Pits and caves are underground karst forms. Caves have an inclination less than 45°; pits, greater than 45° (THM, 2008).
6
Climate resources The climate can be an enabling, as well as a constraining, factor in tourism development in certain regions. The bio-climate affects the stay of tourists in a given area, while the elements characteristic of individual types of climate impact on the development of selective forms of tourism. Obviously, some forms of tourism are less dependent upon the climate, because they take place indoors with air-conditioning. Temperature, wind, air humidity and sunrays affect our feeling of comfort. Hydrographic resources For tourism development, it is of primary importance to ensure water supply to tourists and to take into consideration the tactile (sensory/bathing) properties of seawater and the visual contact of tourists with various forms in which water occurs (THM, 2008).The tourism industry is a large consumer of fresh water used for different needs(THM, 2008). Bio-geographical resources The tourism economy is strategically focused on the natural cycles of healthy food production by restoring specific types of production (wine-growing, olive growing, animal husbandry suited to the special features of an area), as well as on providing protection to biologically vulnerable zones and communities (especially forest and meadow communities that have a preventive function, the sea coasts and highland regions). The multi-meaningful relationship of humans toward nature is the basis for developing the bio-geographical environment in a tourist region. This relationship has sometimes been given such attributes that have made plants or animals a part of a region’s identity. Primarily, flora has a physiological function, as it transforms carbon dioxide into oxygen through photosynthesis. Its aesthetic and curiosity values are related to the diversity of floral species and shapes, and its health-related value, to the evaporation of aromatic oils and other components. Tourist regions seek to enrich unvaried vegetation that is poor in plant species by creating parks with various types of plants. Park architecture seeks to match the features of a region’s landscape. Similar to flora, fauna can also be classified as domesticated animals and all other animals living freely in nature. In the offering, domestic animals include cattle, fowl and house pets, with special focus on fisheries and stud farms, as well as on indigenous breeds (Kusen, 2002). Domestic animals are a vital part of the tourist attraction base for developing rural tourism, and wild animals, for hunting and fishing, as well as for 7
photo hunting that is gaining in popularity. These paces for certain tourist activities are shrinking as numerous animal species have been completely wiped out or can be seen only in protected parks or nature parks (Kusen, 2002). Anthropogenic Tourism Resources Tourists who visit anthropogenic tourism resources usually have a higher educational and cultural value. According to their structural features, anthropogenic resources may be classified as cultural assets, ethno-social resources, artistic resources and environmental resources. Cultural assets The term cultural assets’ is the conceptual successor of the term cultural and historical heritage’. According to their static features and volume, cultural assets may be classified as immovable, movable, and intangible. Especially attractive are the cultural assets listed in the UNESCO list of world cultural heritage. Cultural heritage in the UNESCO list must meet at least one of the criteria of the Convention on the Protection of Cultural and Natural Heritage: a cultural monument must be authentic, it must have a great impact on the culture and development of a specific period, it must be a unique example of a specific style, it must be linked to ideas and beliefs of universal importance, or it must be an example of the traditional way of life, characteristic of a given culture. Artistic resources Artistic resources are generally associated with aesthetics and creativity. Diverse forms of art have been created, based on numerous criteria. The conventional list of arts include six forms (music, drama, literature, painting, sculpture and architecture) to which three more have been added (cinematography, dance and comic strips/sequential art). Each of these macro forms can further be divided into art disciplines, genres, types and sub-types. For example, modern musical art is commonly classified into traditional, classical, jazz and rock music, and literature, into prose and poetry Tourists generally come into contact with works of art through cultural institutions such as museums, galleries, libraries, theatres and concert halls.
8
Ambient resources Ambient resources refer to architectural facilities the aim of which is to complement other tourist attractions in a destination. These architectural and ambient facilities encompass various areas of construction, the most important being hotels, industrial facilities, housing facilities, sacral and sports facilities, as well as traffic routes and horticulture. Geographical criteria ensure rational planning and the use of limited and exceptionally valuable space, as well as ambiental architecture that is congruent with its surroundings and serves to enhance the tourist experience and the overall valorisation of a destination’s space. This helps to ensure the controlled development of tourism and other supporting economic and noneconomic activities and branches.
2.1.2. Potentials of ecotourism resources in Ethiopia
Ethiopia is endowed with unique cultural heritages and attractive natural resources that attract tourists. The oblique, churches, castles, archeological sites, caves are some of cultural resources of Ethiopia. There are also a high diversity of plants and animals in Ethiopia. In addition, there are impressive features such as high mountains, rivers, and lakes in the country (MoCT, 2006). The favorable diversity of climate is the other factor what makes Ethiopia to attract tourists. Having Addis Ababa as the venue of seat for Africa Organization Unity and United Nation Economic, Commission for Africa is also another feature of attractions of tourists in Ethiopia (MoCT, 2006).
The country has several parks and reserves to shelter its flora and fauna which can be visited to sight see these animals and explore their natural heavens. Ecotourism represents an approach to tourism that emphasizes on environmental and cultural preservation. It highlights opportunities for tourists and other visitors to experience aspects of the country’s ecology and natural endowments as well as unique features of its archaeology, history and culture. Ecotourism is responsible travel to natural areas that conserves the environment and sustains the well-being of local people (TIES, 2015).
9
2.1.3. Ecotourism Product
Product attributes The attributes of ecotourism products have been highlighted by many researchers in the past. (Boyd et al. 1995) identified naturalness, wildlife, cultural heritage, landscape and community as important ecotourism criteria based on the regional landscape that it is linked to. On the other hand, tourism’s strength which creates impact is linked with multiple dimensions, including economical and cultural (Dyere et al. 2007), social (Gursoy and Rutherford, 2004) and environmental dimensions (Yoon et al, 2001).Furthermore, most studies in ecotourism product attributes are based on aspects such as culture (Moulin, 1995), naturalness (Otto and Ritchie, 1996), sustainability (David, 2011), history (Nijkamp and Riganti, 2008) , and People (Wang et al, 2010) Natural environment Natural area of tourism represents a very wide category of the alternative forms of tourism (Puczko and Ratz, 2005). Tourism product does not only comprise the quality and productivity, but also the psychological environment, the subjective personal reaction and feelings experienced by consumers when consuming a service (Otto and Ritchie, 1996). Furthermore, the ability of a place to attract tourists depends primarily on its environmental quality (Ceballos andLascuráin, 1996), namely, its natural environment. It has been pointed by Kaltenbom and Bjerke (2002) that tourists visit a destination due to the want to experience and feel the truth of the environment provide these opportunities by bridging tourists with the natural environment in the rural areas. The psychological needs of the tourists to be in the natural environment provide a basis for the attribute. Historical According to Harrison (2002), heritage tourism is one of the most suitable forms of tourism for sustainable economic and social development in the remote regions. There are many positive reasons why historical heritage can be one of the ecotourism attributes. Heritage contributes to national and local community identity (Communities and Local Government,) (CLG, 2009) and at the same time creates jobs by providing leisure, creation and educational facilities (Nijkamp and Riganti, 2008). For different audiences, heritage poses different meanings depending on factors such as class, education, ethnicity and
10
lifestyle (Goulding, 1999; Apostolakis, 2003). Heritage, therefore, needs to be defined in terms of the people or stakeholders who are interpreting it, rather than in the abstract, divorced from the people and their cultural references, values, institutions and norms (O’Reilly, 2005). As a result, different aspects of the heritage “product” can appeal to different types of people (Sable and Kling, 2001; Harrison, 2002). Culture “culture is a critical aspect of mediating and articulating community need, as development is planned and takes shape, through the culture’s potential to empower and animate” Evans (2005). Moulin (1995) states that, cultural tourism is an opportunity for hosts and tourists alike to better know and understand the world by mirroring themselves and developing tastes and emotions That is rich with "place" experiences. In accord with this, cultural experience has been one of the values of ecotourism product through the deep involvement of the tourists with the host community at destination. Community The sense of community plays an important role in fostering community support for tourism development and enhancing its long-term sustainability as a broad basis for tourism development planning (Hall et al., 2005). Bopp et al. (2000) defines sense of community as “the quality of human relationship that makes it possible for people to live together in a healthy and sustainable way”. Thus, developing a sense of community enables people to feel connected and motivated and work together towards common goals. Sense of community can be seen as the capacity of the local people to participate in development activities (Cupples, 2005).
2.1.4. Opportunities for Ecotourism Development in Ethiopia
Abundance of Potential Tourism Resources Most of the researchers who conducted their study in different parts of Ethiopia revealed the existence of abundant cultural, historical and natural tourism resources as an opportunity to develop community based ecotourism development in Ethiopia (Ambelu et al, 2011).
11
Policy Environments It was also found that there are various policies in the country which support and create favorable conditions for ecotourism development as such. For instance, Eshetie, Wagnew (2012) states that ecotourism development is a priority in the Ethiopian Tourism Development Strategy and is also important in Ethiopia’s Plan for Accelerated and Sustained Development to End Poverty (PASDEP) which has laid some solid foundations by establishing relevant strategies and policies to address issues on the wise use of natural resources and an integrated approach for achieving rapid and sustainable growth to end poverty. In addition, the Federal and Regional Government Policy and commitment’s towards Infrastructure Development (Eshetie,Wagnew, 2012; Berhanu, kebede. 2013),the Environmental Policy of Ethiopia (Ayinalem,sintayew, 2013),Ethiopia’s anti-natalist population policy (Eshetie Wagnew, 2012) and the Investment policy of Ethiopia in the travel and tourism industry (Asfaw, 2014), are all stated as policy environments which could offer positive opportunities for developing effective community based ecotourism in Ethiopia.
2.1.5. Physical facilities for ecotourism development
Tourism infrastructure can be regarded as the physical elements that are designed and erected to cater for visitors. The strong relationship between tourism development and infrastructure has been theoretically established by a number of authors (Adebayo and Iweka, 2014). Tourism infrastructure includes ancillary and complementary facilities, equipment, systems, processes, and resources necessary for the functioning of every tourist destination. This primarily includes roads, railways, airports, and the like, which make a tourist destination accessible for tourists. In addition, infrastructure includes health care systems, services, and public services. Building on infrastructure, superstructure includes building facilities, which exist only because of tourism activities. Their main purpose is accommodation and meeting the needs and desires of tourists, in the form of hotels, campsites, restaurants, sports facilities, and the like (Popesku, 2011).
Tourism infrastructure is the basis of tourism development, as well as a base for utilization of destination resources. The importance of tourism infrastructure is reflected in the fact
12
that it can contribute to increasing the efficiency of production and distribution of tourism services, and, in some cases, such as remote destinations, even increase the supply of tourism services. For tourists to be able to reach some tourist destinations there should be the developed transport infrastructure, which is a precondition for consuming other tourism services of the destination itself. The arrival of tourists enhances the efficiency of human resources at the destination; tourists require certain services in order to feel better during their stay at the selected tourist destination (Popesku, 2011). In particular, there is an increase in the demand for infrastructure services in terms of water supply, waste disposal, communication and electricity supply, as the necessary elements for comfortable functioning of tourists at the selected destination. Infrastructure is defined as the provision of public safety, transportation services, medical systems, financial systems, education systems, and other services involved in the population’s, as well as in tourists’ demand (Ritchie, Crouch, 2005).
As a component of the regional tourism product, tourism infrastructure is of special importance for long-term tourism growth and the general progress of tourist destinations in providing the required services to tourists. Literature provides different views on the number and type of components representing tourism infrastructure. Thus, according to the Tourism & Transport Forum (TTF, 2012), tourism infrastructure is the supply chain of transport, social and environmental infrastructure collaborating at a regional level to create an attractive tourism destination.
Transport infrastructure in this chain provides destination access to tourists from the international and domestic markets, and includes roads, airports, and railways. Social infrastructure relates to accommodation facilities in the form of rooms to accommodate tourists and other supporting physical structures for various kinds of activities and services that attract tourists. This infrastructure includes hotels, convention centers, stadiums, galleries, and other necessary facilities. Environmental infrastructure is a natural value, and refers to national parks, marine parks, and reserves, which visitors can tour (Figure1).
13
Environmental infrastructure Social infrastructure
Transport infrastructure
Source: Tourism & Transport Forum (TTF, 2012)
Figure 1 - Types of tourism infrastructure
In addition to above classification, literature often points to the classification of tourism infrastructure into four categories, namely: 1. Physical (Hotels, Motels, Restaurants, Transportation, Communication, Water, and Electricity); 2. Cultural (Culture, heritage, fairs and festivals, Local art and music, dress and dance, Language and food); 3.Service, (Banking facilities, Travel agencies, Insurance agencies, Tourist guides); 4. Governance, (Law and order machinery, Customs and immigration) (Figure 2).
Tourism
infrastructure
Physical Cultural, Culture, Service Governance
Hotels, heritage fairs and banking facilities Law and Restaurants Festivals Travel agencies order ,Transportation Local art and Insurance agencies machinery Communication , music dress and Tourist guides Customs and ,Water dance Language immigration
Electricity and food
14
Source: Raina; (A., Ecology, Wildlife and Tourism Development: Principles, Practices and Strategies, 2005. pp. 192).
Figure 2 - Components of tourism infrastructure
Today, enhancing the construction of tourism infrastructure concerns a large number of countries, wishing to achieve higher tourism results and its significant impact on economic development. Generating the effects of the overall development is conditioned by the way of managing the relationship between tourism infrastructure, tourism, and the local economy (Swyngedouw, 2000).
2.1.6. Emergences and development of ecotourism
According to Boo (1991), "ecotourism is a nature tourism that contributes to conservation, through generating funds for protected areas, creating employment opportunities for local communities, and offering environmental education. Furthermore, Boyd and Butler (1996) who considered it as " a responsible nature, travel experience, that contributes to the conservation of the ecosystem while respecting the integrity of host communities and, where possible, ensuring that activities are complementary, or at least compatible, with existing re-source-based uses present at the ecosystem (Boyd and Butler, 1996).Recently there has been a surge of interest in studying ecotourism and the attempts that have been made gained noticeable results. Jalani (2012) investigated the effects of ecotourism on livelihood generation and the influx of people, and examined the views of the local community on the impact of ecotourism and the importance of natural resource to the tourism industry in the Puerto Princes Subterranean River National Park (PPSRNP) which has been recently renowned as one of the new seven wonders of nature.
2.1.7. Opportunities of Ecotourism
Currently ecotourism is widely hailed tourism, and alternative (Schaller, 1998).It is also a means to be an instrument for rural economic development and environmental conservation (Anderson et al, 1996). (Figure1) illustrates that it is important in poverty reduction and natural resource management.
15
Figure3: the diagrammatic representation of ecotourism opportunities Environmental benefits Ecotourism is relatively less-polluting industry, which can enhance the conservation and promotion of natural and cultural heritages (Anderson et al., 1996). Moreover, ecotourism will foster responsible tourist behavior, conservation of important wildlife habitats and ecosystem. It is a best alternative activity to environmentally damaging activities like farming, logging and mining. Although ecotourism may not be able to preserve these untouched areas as they would if human contact could be prohibited, it can help to protect them from the dangers of destructive agricultural practice, mining and industrialization (Dasenbrok, 2002).It encourages individual conservation efforts- informed tour guides and educational pamphlets can incite tourists to become environmentalists, thereby promoting conservation efforts. It also able to foster small scale infrastructure and the infrastructure demands of the ecotourism industry, primarily include the construction of small scale hotels and transportation systems, thereby maintaining a healthy balance between expanding tourism industry and protecting natural resources. Social benefits
Apart from its economic and environmental benefits, ecotourism might contribute socially by enhancing local community esteem and provides the opportunity for greater understanding and communication among people of diverse background (Agrusa and
16
Guidry, 1999). It also helps for political empowerment of local communities and fosters respect for different cultures (helps to develop tolerance). It is an important vehicle for promoting cultural exchanges (Agrusa and Guidry, 1999).
Although tourism has a significant contribution to economic development and conservation of environmental resources; it has also negative impacts on tourist destination areas. Especially during the past decades because of the interest of business profit of the tour operators to attract more tourists, which is resulted in high negative impacts of tourist destinations, principle of nature-based tourism or ecotourism was not considered. The negative impacts were seen like degraded vegetation, wildlife casualties, pollution of water and atmosphere in tourists ‘destination areas. Consequently, in the 1990s, the attentions for environmental issues in tourist destination areas were increased and ecotourism to be pronounced (Sindiga, 1999). Ecotourism was given more concerns since the world Ecotourism Summit in 2002 because it is expected as a tool for ensuring sustainable conservation of destination areas, satisfying the enjoyment of tourists, benefiting the destination community and contributes to poverty reduction (Theodor’s Atlabachew, 2004). Ecotourism evolved from growing concerns about the negative environmental and socioeconomic effects of tourism development (EGA, 2008).It is “environmentally responsible travel and visitation to relatively undisturbed natural areas, in order to enjoy and appreciate nature (including any accompanying cultural features both past and present), that promotes conservation, has low visitor impact and provides for beneficially active socioeconomic involvement of local populations” (IUCN, 1996).
2.1.8. Development of Ecotourism in Ethiopia
The concept of ecotourism is a new phenomenon to and it is difficult to explain its significance achievement since the approach of ecotourism is not widely disseminated in Ethiopia (Theodros Atlabachew, 2004). The government of Ethiopia also has recognized development and promotion of ecotourism and provided consultancy services for a number of potential developers of ecotourism sites. Although, developers and policy makers do not properly take the idea of ecotourism, some investors started to involve in the development of ecotourism in different regions of Ethiopia. Bishangari Eco-Lodge located in the east of
17
Langano Lake in Oromia Region and Village Ethiopia located in Afar Region (Bilen) is examples of these private ecotourism developments in Ethiopia (Theodros Atlabachew, 2004). In the past few years, LUPO(Land Use Planning of Oromia) aimed to create alternative income generating means such as ecotourism to reduce the pressure on the natural resources of land through conducting a pre-feasibility study of proposed areas on the potentials of ecotourism (Scwenk, 2002)
18
Chapter3. RESEARCH METHODOLOGIES
3.1. Description of the Study Area
3.1.1. Location and Socioeconomic situation
Geographically the study area is located between 70 20’ to 70 40’ N latitude and 350 48’ to 360 14’ E longitude. Gimbo Woreda is bordered by Oromia Region in the north, Decha Woreda in the south, Chena and Gewata Woredas in the west and Adiyo Woreda in the east. It is 436 and 706km far from Addis Ababa and Hawassa, respectively (Figure 4).
Figure 4: The map of the Study area (Source: by the Author)
The area includes an array of rural settlements, traditional land-use patterns and sites of cultural and natural significance. Main economic activities in the area were dominated by agriculture and other sectors include services and tourism, manufacturing and trade.
19
Agriculture forms the backbone of the economy with most of the other sectors being dependent on its strong backward and forward linkages. The key management areas of the biosphere reserve include ; coordination of conservation initiatives with the focus on the protection of the endemic and globally important genetic resources of coffee Arabica and its associated ecosystems , provision of a sustained flow of high-quality water to adjoining regions and the promotion of sustainable development in order to alleviate poverty and inequality.
3.1.2. Biophysical characteristics
Topography The Kaffa Biosphere Reserve has an extremely diverse topography ranging from 1020 m.a.s.l to 3350 m.a.s.l with its lowest point eastwards of Gojeb and its highest mountain range south of Kaka (Angiyo Kolla mountain range). The latitudinal variation results in extreme slope gradients, ranging from the flat lowlands (south of Konda in the Gojeb wetland) to extremely steep areas. Of the total Biosphere spatial extent, around 1.2 percent (8,360 ha) is very steep terrain. Most of the steep terrain was covered by tropical mountain moist forest (Whitmore, 1993) and plantations (80%). But 12% of this Landscape was also covered by agriculture. All other steep areas were Savannah or covered by bush land. Soil According to the major landform map of Ethiopia by (Merla et al.1979), the Kaffa Biosphere Reserve in Gimbo is not influenced by distinct tectonic escarpments nor dominated by volcanoes, canyons or faults (Abbate et al. 2015). Kaffa region is structured mainly by pliocene acidic domes and plugs in the north of Bonga with traversal tectonic lines constitute a prominent and peculiar feature of the southern Ethiopian plateau. According to their relationships with the surrounding vulcanite, they are doubtfully assigned to the pliocene (Merla et al. 1979). The soil types of Kaffa Biosphere Reserve are eutric nit sols and eutric cambisols (FAO, 2014).
20
Climate The study area receives rainfall almost all the year round. From March to September the mean minimum rainfall received was 100mm. The mean monthly rainfall in mm as observed in Bonga station is shown in figure 5.
Source: SRMA Figure5: Mean monthly rainfall of Gumbo Woreda (mm) Temperature The mean monthly temperature ranges between 18 – 21 oC. From January to March the difference between mean minimum and mean maximum temperature recorded increasing, but gradually lower in April. The mean monthly Minimum, Average and Maximum Temperature, as observed in Wushwush station is presented in figure 6.
Source: SRMA
Figure 6: Mean Monthly Minimum, Average and Maximum Temperature in oC of the study area.
21
3.2. Design of the Study
3.2.2. Sampling design
The biosphere reserve includes: Adiyo, Bita, Chena, Cheta, Decha, Gesha, Gewata, Gimbo, and Bonga town. Gimbo Woreda was selected purposively and from this Woreda three Kebeles such as Uffa, Wushwush, and Shetta were selected purposively based on their potentials. Potentials were identified using field site observation and secondary information. Simple random sampling was used to select respondents for interviews and questionnaires.
3.2.3. Sample size for household questionnaire
The total number of household head in this woreda is 18,224. From this figure the researcher used 10% of HH heads to get constant sample to determine the number of individual head of household from each sample Kebele. The constant sample size for HH