DOCSLIB.ORG

A Taxpayers' Platform

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
A Taxpayers' Platform A Taxpayers’ Platform Responses from PC Leadership Candidates to 16 Questions from the Canadian Taxpayers Federation November 14, 2006 Scott Hennig Alberta director, Canadian Taxpayers Federation #202-10621-100 Ave NW, Edmonton, Alberta T5J OB3 PH: (780) 448-0159.e-mail: [email protected]: www.taxpayer.com ABOUT THE CANADIAN TAXPAYERS FEDERATION The Canadian Taxpayers Federation (CTF) is a federally incorporated, non-profit and non-partisan, advocacy organization dedicated to lower taxes, less waste and accountable government. The CTF was founded in Saskatchewan in 1990 when the Association of Saskatchewan Taxpayers and the Resolution One Association of Alberta joined forces to create a national taxpayers organization. Today, the CTF has over 68,000 supporters nationwide. The CTF maintains a federal office in Ottawa and offices in the five provinces of British Columbia, Alberta, Saskatchewan, Manitoba and Ontario. Provincial offices conduct research and advocacy activities specific to their provinces in addition to acting as regional organizers of Canada-wide initiatives. CTF offices field hundreds of media interviews each month, hold press conferences and issue regular news releases, commentaries and publications to advocate the common interest of taxpayers. The CTF’s flagship publication, The Taxpayer magazine, is published six times a year. An issues and action update called TaxAction is produced each month. CTF offices also send out weekly Let’s Talk Taxes commentaries to more than 800 media outlets and personalities nationally. CTF representatives speak at functions, make presentations to government, meet with politicians, and organize petition drives, events and campaigns to mobilize citizens to effect public policy change. All CTF staff and board directors are prohibited from holding a membership in any political party. The CTF is independent of any institutional affiliations. Contributions to the CTF are not tax deductible. The CTF’s Alberta office is located at: #202, 10621 – 100 Ave Financial Building Edmonton, AB T5J 0B3 Telephone: 780-448-0159 Facsimile: 780-482-1744 E-mail: [email protected] Web Site: www.taxpayer.com 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS Summary of Questions for the Candidates 4 Introduction 6 Overall Report Card 7 Grade Summary by Category and Question 9 Candidate Responses 10 Revenue (Taxes) 10 Question 1 10 Question 2 14 Question 3 17 Question 4 21 Question 5 25 Question 6 28 Expenditures (Spending) 32 Question 7 32 Question 8 38 Question 9 42 Question 10 46 Democratic/Transparency Reforms 50 Question 11 50 Question 12 53 Question 13 57 Question 14 61 Quesiton 15 64 Health Care Reform 67 Question 16 67 3 SUMMARY OF QUESTIONS FOR THE CANDIDATES Revenue (Taxes) 1. Will you commit to eliminate the health care premium tax? 2. Will you commit to eliminate the hidden sales tax on insurance premiums? 3. Will you commit to reduce or eliminate the education property tax? 4. Will you commit to enact legislation implementing a municipal property tax cap to ensure municipal property taxes don’t increase by more than the rate of inflation without a referendum? 5. Will you commit to an 8 per cent general business tax rate as promised in the 2001 provincial budget? 6. Will you commit to amend the Taxpayer Protection Act such that any new provincial tax or an increase to an existing tax could only be approved through a successful provincial referendum? Expenditures (Spending) 7. Will you commit to introduce legislation capping annual provincial spending increases at a rate of the combined growth in the inflation and population rate? 8. Will you commit to introduce legislation that restricts the government from increasing spending during the fiscal year (other than declared emergencies)? 9. Will you commit to roll back the Fiscal Responsibility Act such that only the first $3.5-billion of non-renewable resource revenues could be used for budgeting and program spending? 10. Will you commit to legislating a minimum of 50 per cent of resource revenues be saved each year? Democratic/Transparency Reform 11. Will you commit to introduce fixed election dates for Alberta’s general elections? 12. Will you commit to introduce legislation giving citizens the right to recall their MLA? 4 13. Will you commit to introduce citizens’ initiative legislation giving citizens the right to initiate and vote in a referendum on issues of importance? 14. Will you commit to disclose a complete list and dollar amount of all campaign contributions you have received during this PC leadership campaign prior to the first ballot vote? 15. Will you commit to introduce legislation requiring pre-election campaign contribution disclosure for all future elections (general provincial, municipal and party leadership elections) in Alberta? Heath care Reform 16. Will you commit to give Albertans the ability to purchase private health insurance to cover costs incurred by those who pay for timely access to medically necessary procedures? 5 INTRODUCTION On October 24, 2006, the Canadian Taxpayers Federation sent each PC leadership candidate a document entitled: A Taxpayers’ Platform: Advice and Questions for Alberta’s PC Leadership Candidates. The document contained 16 questions in for major areas of concern: Taxes, Spending, Democratic reform/Transparency and Health care reform. Each candidate was provided with an opportunity to answer the 16 questions in their own words. All of the eight candidates responded and this sequel document contains their positions, as well as the position of the CTF. The purpose of the Taxpayers’ Platform is three fold: to raise issues with leadership candidates and the public that may have been staying under the radar (or out of their platforms), to inform our supporters – and others who may be interested in these very important issues – on where leadership candidates stand, and to collect commitments from our future premier and cabinet ministers to take action on these issues. The CTF is a non-partisan advocacy organization. It never has and never will endorse a candidate, but in order for readers to quickly digest the candidate responses, each response has been assigned a grade. Each response’s grade was determined by taking the average score assigned to that response by a panel of Canadian Taxpayer Federation provincial directors from across Canada. Grades are averaged for each of the four categories, to provide a quick guide as to where candidates’ strengths and weaknesses lie, as well as averaged for the entire questionnaire. The grades range from A+ to F. The grades were then converted into the 4.0 scale (using the University of Alberta grade system) for averaging. A+ is given for a full commitment F is given for a full rejection of the commitment Grades ranging in-between are given for partial commitments, openness for re- consideration, for expressing support for the fundamental goal or discussion of alternative or tangential ideas worthy of merit. 6 OVERALL REPORT CARD Candidate: Overall Grade: JIM DINNING VICTOR DOERKSEN GARY MCPHERSON DAVE HANCOCK 7 TED MORTON MARK NORRIS LYLE OBERG ED STELMACH 8 GRADE SUMMARY BY CATEGORY AND QUESTION Jim Victor Dave Gary Ted Mark Lyle Ed Dinning Doerksen Hancock McPherson Morton Norris Oberg Stelmach Taxes Question #1 D+ A+ C A+ A+ C+ A+ C- Question #2 F D D C- A+ F A+ C- Question #3 D C C C C C+ D D Question #4 F F D+ C D+ C- F F Question #5 B+ F C+ C- A+ B+ A+ D Question #6 D F D+ C- F F B- F Taxes Avg D D+ C- C+ B- C- B- D Spending Question #7 F B F B+ A+ F B- D Question #8 B+ C- C B- A+ B+ F D Question #9 C+ B- B- C A- A- F D+ Question #10 B C+ A+ C+ B B- B- D Spending Avg C+ C+ C+ B- A- C+ D+ D+ Dem. reform/transp. Question #11 C C B+ A+ A+ A+ D+ C Question #12 F C D+ A+ F D+ A+ C Question #13 F C+ A A+ A+ C+ A+ F Question #14 C C C A F A+ C C Question #15 F C C- B A+ A- C C- Dem. reform/transp. Avg D C C+ A C+ B B- C- Heath care reform Question #16 D C- D C A+ B A+ D Overall Average D+ C- C B- B C+ C+ D+ Top two candidate grades in each category Taxes: 1. Ted Morton & Lyle Oberg (tie): B- Spending: 1. Ted Morton: A- 2. Gary McPherson: B- Democratic/Transparency Reform: 1. Gary McPherson: A 2. Mark Norris: B Heath care reform: 1. Ted Morton & Lyle Oberg (tie): A+ 9 CANDIDATE RESPONSES REVENUE (TAXES) Question 1: Will you commit to eliminate the health care premium tax? CTF’s Position: Axe the regressive health care premium tax Alberta’s health care insurance premium is a regressive tax. For a family earning $35,000 a year, the $1,056 in health care premiums is equivalent to 3 per cent of their annual income. For a family earning $100,000 a year, the $1,056 in health care premiums is equivalent to 1 per cent of their annual income. The CTF welcomed the relatively small increase to the premium subsidy in the 2006 provincial budget. However, this increase was only one-time, “premium-creep” will continue to eat away at the value of the subsidy because unlike the Basic Personal Exemption, the health care premium tax thresholds are not indexed to inflation. The CTF also welcomed the abolition of the health care premium tax for seniors as a first-step towards abolishing this tax for all Albertans. This age-based exemption, put into place in 2004, has created a situation where seniors who are wealthy, no longer raising children or paying off a mortgage, are exempt.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • An Examination of the Causes of Education Policy Outputs in Ontario, Saskatchewan, and Alberta
    Why Do Parties Not Make a Difference? An Examination of the Causes of Education Policy Outputs in Ontario, Saskatchewan, and Alberta By Saman Chamanfar A thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements of the degree of Ph.D. Political Science University of Toronto © Copyright by Saman Chamanfar 2017 Why Do Parties Not Make a Difference? An Examination of the Causes of Education Policy Outputs in Ontario, Saskatchewan, and Alberta Saman Chamanfar Doctor of Philosophy Political Science University of Toronto 2017 Abstract This study seeks to explain why partisanship—contrary to what we might expect based on the findings of other studies concerning social policies—is generally not a useful explanatory variable when examining the primary and secondary education policies of three Canadian provinces (Ontario, Saskatchewan, and Alberta) during two periods (the 1970s and 1990- 2008). Four specific areas of the education sector of the provinces will be examined: objectives of curricula; spending; ministry relations with school boards; and government policies concerning private and charter schools. Utilizing a qualitative approach and building on the findings of other studies on provincial education systems, it will be argued that in order to understand why the three provinces generally adopted similar policies in both periods, regardless of the differences in the ideologies of governing parties, we need to consider the causal effect of key ideas in both periods. In addition, it will be shown that opposition parties in most instances did not present policies that differed from those of governing parties or criticize the policies of such parties. This will further illustrate the limited usefulness of adopting a partisanship lens when seeking to understand the policy positions of various parties in the provinces concerning the education sector.
    [Show full text]
  • Petroleum News 012807
    page Newfoundland premier Danny 8 Williams goes to the mat — again Vol. 12, No. 4 • www.PetroleumNews.com A weekly oil & gas newspaper based in Anchorage, Alaska Week of January 28, 2007 • $1.50 ● NATURAL GAS January Mining News inside Export extension filed Nikiski plant partners Conoco, Marathon apply to extend LNG license 2 years By KRISTEN NELSON Petroleum News ohn Barnes, manager of Alaska production operations for Marathon Oil, broke the news at J The Alliance Meet Alaska conference Jan. 19: Nikiski LNG plant co-owners Marathon and ConocoPhillips had filed for a two-year extension of the export license for the plant. Why the extension application, with concerns about Cook Inlet gas supplies? Barnes said “the industrial use of natural gas in Cook Inlet is good, it’s important, it creates jobs, it creates opportunities.” The Nikiski LNG plant. And, he said, the LNG plant “provides supply extreme cold weather event or upset in the sys- security to Southcentral utilities. Having that plant tem.” running provides for the ability to move gas away Southcentral industrial users will be necessary from the plant to serve local utilities if there’s an see EXTENSION page 19 ● NATURAL GAS Inlet gas usage sets record Enstar, Cook Inlet gas producers scrambled to meet peak; new interconnects planned By KRISTEN NELSON Dieckgraeff said there was a “very Petroleum News intricate dance” the night of Jan. 8, but Mining News stories this month include an interview with Alaska's new DEC commissioner by columnist J.P. Tangen; Earthworks report ook Inlet uses more natural gas on cold days the gas got to Anchorage, although to do on water pollution at mines and industry and agency reactions to it; — and delivering those peak needs is trickier that, gas had to be pulled from the latest on B.C.'s Prosperity project; Wolverine project's prospects come than in the past.
    [Show full text]
  • Annotated Bibliography of The
    Annotated Bibliography of the Cultural History of the German-speaking Community in Alberta Second Up-Date: 1997- 2003 A project of the German-Canadian Association of Alberta 8 2004 Compiler: Manfred Prokop Annotated Bibliography of the Cultural History of the German-speaking Community in Alberta: 1882-2000. Second Up-Date: 1997-2003 In collaboration with the German-Canadian Association of Alberta #203, 8708-48 Avenue, Edmonton, AB, Canada T6E 5L1 Compiler: Manfred Prokop Modern Languages and Cultural Studies, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada T6G 2E6 Phone/Fax: (780) 467-6273. E-Mail: [email protected] ISBN 0-9687876-0-6 8 Manfred Prokop 2004 TABLE OF CONTENTS Overview ............................................................................................................................................................................................... 1 Quickstart ............................................................................................................................................................................... 1 Description of the Database ................................................................................................................................................................. 2 Brief history of the project ................................................................................................................................................... 2 Materials ...............................................................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Dear Friend of the Pembina Institute, We Now Know Albertans Do Not
    Dear Friend of the Pembina Institute, We now know Albertans do not receive a fair share from energy development in Alberta. To see the proof, read on in this document. First, there’s the letter introducing Our Fair Share: Report of the Alberta Royalty Review Panel. — The letter is addressed to Government, but is really speaking to all Albertans. In it, Panel Chair Bill Hunter reminds us that we are the Owners of the province’s energy resources, and that as Owners, we are not receiving our fair share. Next, there’s a primer on Our Fair Share, prepared by the Pembina Institute. — The primer describes the highlights of the Panel’s report, and show you where you can get more information. Finally, there’s a letter I wrote to Premier Stelmach, calling on him to implement the full set of recommendations contained in Our Fair Share. I encourage you to do the same with a letter to Premier Stelmach and your MLA. By spreading the word, and letting Alberta’s government know how you feel, you can help to ensure that Albertans get a fair return on their resources. Siincerely, Marlo Raynolds Executive Director Pembina Institute. “ “Our Fair Share” Pembina Primer The preceding letter was written by Bill Hunter, the Chair of the Royalty Review Panel assigned by the provincial government earlier this year to review and recommend changes to Alberta’s energy royalty regimes. The government-appointed six-member panel is comprised of a former senior executive with an oil company, a chief economist for a Calgary-based energy research firm, two economics professors, a businessman and a forestry executive.
    [Show full text]
  • 2004 Provincial General Election, in Accordance with Section 4(3) of the Election Act
    Province of Alberta The Report of the Chief Electoral Officer on the 2004 Provincial Enumeration and Monday, November 22, 2004 Provincial General Election of the Twenty-sixth Legislative Assembly Alberta Legislative Assembly Office of the Chief Electoral Officer May 31, 2005 Ms. Janis Tarchuk, MLA Banff-Cochrane Chairman, Standing Committee on Legislative Offices Legislature Building Edmonton, Alberta T5K 2B6 Dear Ms. Tarchuk: I have the privilege to submit to you my report on the 2004 Provincial General Enumeration and the November 22, 2004 Provincial General Election, in accordance with Section 4(3) of the Election Act. An overview of the Senate Nominee Election, held in conjunction with the Provincial General Election, has also been included. Additional detail will be provided in “The Report of the Chief Electoral Officer on the 2004 Senate Nominee Election”. Should you require any additional information or clarification on anything contained in the Report, I would be pleased to respond. Sincerely, O. Brian Fjeldheim Chief Electoral Officer Suite 100, 11510 Kingsway Avenue, Edmonton, Alberta T5G 2Y5 Ph: 780-427-7191 Fax: 780-422-2900 email: [email protected] TABLE OF CONTENTS 2004 PROVINCIAL GENERAL ENUMERATION Overview ....................................................................................................... 1 Mapping Activities.......................................................................................... 1 Conduct of the Enumeration.........................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Orange Chinook: Politics in the New Alberta
    University of Calgary PRISM: University of Calgary's Digital Repository University of Calgary Press University of Calgary Press Open Access Books 2019-01 Orange Chinook: Politics in the New Alberta University of Calgary Press Bratt, D., Brownsey, K., Sutherland, R., & Taras, D. (2019). Orange Chinook: Politics in the New Alberta. Calgary, AB: University of Calgary Press. http://hdl.handle.net/1880/109864 book https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0 Attribution Non-Commercial No Derivatives 4.0 International Downloaded from PRISM: https://prism.ucalgary.ca ORANGE CHINOOK: Politics in the New Alberta Edited by Duane Bratt, Keith Brownsey, Richard Sutherland, and David Taras ISBN 978-1-77385-026-9 THIS BOOK IS AN OPEN ACCESS E-BOOK. It is an electronic version of a book that can be purchased in physical form through any bookseller or on-line retailer, or from our distributors. Please support this open access publication by requesting that your university purchase a print copy of this book, or by purchasing a copy yourself. If you have any questions, please contact us at [email protected] Cover Art: The artwork on the cover of this book is not open access and falls under traditional copyright provisions; it cannot be reproduced in any way without written permission of the artists and their agents. The cover can be displayed as a complete cover image for the purposes of publicizing this work, but the artwork cannot be extracted from the context of the cover of this specific work without breaching the artist’s copyright. COPYRIGHT NOTICE: This open-access work is published under a Creative Commons licence.
    [Show full text]
  • Hon. Ed Stelmach, Premier; Hon. David Hancock, Q.C., Minister of Health and Wellness; and Hon
    OFFICE OF THE ETHICS COMMISSIONER PROVINCE OF ALBERTA Report to the Speaker of the Legislative Assembly of Alberta of the Investigation by Donald M. Hamilton, Ethics Commissioner into allegations involving Hon. Ed Stelmach, Premier; Hon. David Hancock, Q.C., Minister of Health and Wellness; and Hon. Lyle Oberg, Minister of Finance May 11, 2007 TABLE OF CONTENTS ALLEGATIONS...........................................................................................................................................1 PERSONS INTERVIEWED/EVIDENCE OBTAINED ..............................................................................2 BACKGROUND ..........................................................................................................................................2 A. LEADERSHIP CAMPAIGNS..................................................................................................................2 B. TRUE BLUE ALBERTA (“TRUE BLUE”)..............................................................................................3 C. CAMPAIGN DEFICITS .........................................................................................................................4 D. MEMBERS’ ROLE IN FUNDRAISING ...................................................................................................5 E. MEMBERS’ FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE ................................................................................................5 FINDINGS....................................................................................................................................................6
    [Show full text]
  • Provincial Legislatures
    PROVINCIAL LEGISLATURES ◆ PROVINCIAL & TERRITORIAL LEGISLATORS ◆ PROVINCIAL & TERRITORIAL MINISTRIES ◆ COMPLETE CONTACT NUMBERS & ADDRESSES Completely updated with latest cabinet changes! 86 / PROVINCIAL RIDINGS PROVINCIAL RIDINGS British Columbia Surrey-Green Timbers ............................Sue Hammell ......................................96 Surrey-Newton........................................Harry Bains.........................................94 Total number of seats ................79 Surrey-Panorama Ridge..........................Jagrup Brar..........................................95 Liberal..........................................46 Surrey-Tynehead.....................................Dave S. Hayer.....................................96 New Democratic Party ...............33 Surrey-Whalley.......................................Bruce Ralston......................................98 Abbotsford-Clayburn..............................John van Dongen ................................99 Surrey-White Rock .................................Gordon Hogg ......................................96 Abbotsford-Mount Lehman....................Michael de Jong..................................96 Vancouver-Burrard.................................Lorne Mayencourt ..............................98 Alberni-Qualicum...................................Scott Fraser .........................................96 Vancouver-Fairview ...............................Gregor Robertson................................98 Bulkley Valley-Stikine ...........................Dennis
    [Show full text]
  • Lac La Biche County
    LAC LA BICHE COUNTY PO Box 1679 Lac La Biche, AB TOA 2C0 Phone: (780) 623-1747 Fax: (780) 623-2039 (County Centre) Phone: (780) 623 4323 Fax: (780) 623 3510 (McArthur Place) emaii: main.offce@,laclabichecounty.com August 30,2007 Honourable Ed Stelmach, Premier of Alberta Room 307 Legislature Building 10800 97 Avenue Edmonton, AB TSK 2B6 Dear Premier Stelmach: This letter is to advise you that effective August 1, 2007, the Town of Lac La Biche and Lakeland County have been dissolved and a new municipal district has formed in the name of "Lac La Biche County". At the August 29,2007 Regular Council Meeting, the Interim Lac La Biche County Council passed a resolution to appoint Mr. Peter Kirylchuk as the Interim Mayor and Mr. Tom Lett as the Interim Deputy Mayor of the newly formed Lac La Biche County. We look forward to the opportunity that amalgamation presents us with to move forward, improve and to enhance this community. We would like to thank the province and Honourable Minister Danyluk for all the support and assistance provided to us in helping to bring this matter to realization. Should you have any questions or concerns please contact me at (780)623-1747. Sincerely, Lac La ~icheCounty cc: Members of Lac La Biche County Council Honourable Ray Danyluk, Minister of Municipal Affairs & Housing Honourable Doug Homer, Minister of Advanced Education & Technology Honourable George Groeneveld, Minister of Agriculture & Food Honourable Janis Tarchuk, Minister of Children's Services Honourable Ron Liepert, Minister of Education Honourable
    [Show full text]
  • Votes and Proceedings
    Legislative Assembly Province of Alberta No. 2 VOTES AND PROCEEDINGS First Session Twenty-Fourth Legislature Tuesday, April 15, 1997 The Speaker took the Chair at 3:00. His Honour the Honourable the Lieutenant Governor entered the Assembly and took his seat on the Throne. Speaker's Address to the Lieutenant Governor Then the Speaker said: May it please Your Honour, the Legislative Assembly have elected me as their Speaker, though I am but little able to fulfil the important duties thus assigned to me. If in the performance of those duties I should at any time fall into error, I pray that the fault may be imputed to me and not the Assembly, whose servant I am, and who, through me, the better to enable them to discharge their duties to their Queen and Province, hereby claim all their undoubted rights and privileges, especially that they may have freedom of speech in their debates, access to your person at all seasonable times, and that their proceedings may receive from you the most favourable construction. 1 Statement by the Provincial Secretary The Provincial Secretary, Hon. Mr. Havelock, then said: I am commanded by His Honour the Honourable the Lieutenant Governor to declare to you that he freely confides in the duty and attachment of this Assembly to Her Majesty's person and Government, and, not doubting that the proceedings will be conducted with wisdom, temperance, and prudence, he grants and upon all occasions will recognize and allow the Assembly's constitutional privileges. I am commanded also to assure you that the Assembly shall have ready access to His Honour upon all suitable occasions and that all proceedings as well as your words and actions will constantly receive from him the most favourable construction.
    [Show full text]
  • Proposed Severance Packages for Alberta Mlas
    Proposed severance packages for Alberta MLAs If the Alberta government approves the recommendations of the all-party Member Services Committee, MLAs who retire or are defeated in 2005 would receive severance packages as per the following list. If the recommendations are approved, MLAs will receive three months’ pay for every year of service after March of 1989, based on the average of the three highest-paid years. Premier Ralph Klein $529,680 Opposition Leader Ken Nicol $356,112 ND Leader Raj Pannu $136,656 Speaker Ken Kowalski $474,816 Cabinet Ministers first elected in 1989 $474,816 Shirley McClellan Deputy Premier and Minister of Agriculture Pat Nelson Finance Halvar Jonson International and Intergovernmental Relations Ty Lund Infrastructure Stan Woloshyn Seniors Mike Cardinal Sustainable Resource Development Pearl Calahasen Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development Cabinet Ministers first elected in 1993 $356,112 Gary Mar Health and Wellness Murray Smith Energy Ed Stelmach Transportation Clint Dunford Human Resources and Employment Lyle Oberg Learning Lorne Taylor Environment Gene Zwozdesky Community Development Victor Doerksen Innovation and Science Heather Forsyth Solicitor General Cabinet Ministers first elected in 1997 $237,408 Iris Evans Children’s Services David Hancock Justice and Attorney General Ron Stevens Gaming Greg Melchin Revenue Guy Boutilier Municipal Affairs David Coutts Government Services Cabinet Ministers first elected in 2001 $118,704 Mark Norris Economic Development Total severance pay for all 24 cabinet members:
    [Show full text]
  • Rough Draft of MAIS-701 Paper
    A POLITICAL DISCOURSE ANALYSIS OF TWO FACTIONS’ VIEWS ON THE ABILITY OF ALBERTA’S PRIVATE POST-SECONDARY INSTITUTIONS TO GRANT BACCALAUREATE DEGREES By REBECCA KNIGHT Integrated Studies Project submitted to Dr. Patricia Hughes-Fuller in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts – Integrated Studies Athabasca, Alberta March, 2007 TABLE OF CONTENTS Abstract iii I. Introduction 1 II. Why Use Discourse Analysis 3 III. The Significance of Order in Council 53/2001 9 IV. Degree Granting Privileges as Part of a Larger Trend 14 V. History of Degree Recognition in Canada and the U.S 19 VI. Present Situation of Degree Accreditation in Canada 24 A. Changes in the Educational Landscape 26 B. Orders in Council by the Alberta Government 28 C. College, University, and PPSI Cultures 29 D. Responses to PPSIs’ Changed Status 35 E. Missing Views of PPSI Students 36 VI. Limitations on the Scope of the Analyses 39 VII. Topics for Discourse Analysis 46 VIII. Quality As It Applies to PPSIs Granting Degrees 47 A. Strategies for Disputing the Quality of PPSI Degrees 47 B. Strategies for Affirming the Quality of PPSI Degrees 54 C. Effects on Quality of Public Post-secondary Degrees 57 1. The Negative Effects of PPSI’ Degrees Pose 58 2. The Positive Effects of PPSI Degrees Pose 61 IX. Choice As It Applies to PPSIs Granting Degrees 63 A. Reduced Choice Due to PPSI Degrees 64 B. Increased Choice Due to PPSI Degrees 65 C. Differing Perspectives on Choice 67 X. Conclusion 68 Abstract In this paper, Chilton and Schnaffer’s technique of political discourse analysis is used to examine discourses produced in reaction to the Albert government’s 1999 decision to allow private post-secondary institutions to grant full baccalaureate degrees.
    [Show full text]