General Butt Naked DCV2.Pages

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

General Butt Naked DCV2.Pages Cold Open: General Butt Naked. AKA Joshua Blahyi. AKA just one of the many, MANY warlords that would form child armies and battle for power during the tumultuous and bloody First Liberian Civil War, which lasted from 1989 to 1997. During the nineties, most of Liberia was controlled by numerous and incredibly violent rival militias. In the bush, they battled for control of diamond fields and gold mines; in Monrovia, they fought gun battles in the streets. Some of these warring factions were led by - or at least assisted by - brutal warriors and warlords who adopted outlandish names like Chuck Norris, One-Foot Devil, General Mosquito and his nemesis, General Mosquito Spray. And of course - there was General Butt Naked. Perhaps the most brutal of them all. Butt Naked was active for about three years, and he led several dozen soldiers—the Naked Base Commandos—who fought mostly in Monrovia. Many of his soldiers were children - child soldiers fed a steady diet of cocaine and American action movies. Kids forced to kill - and also eat - other kids. Today’s story is so, SO crazy. Liberia in the 90s was so crazy. General Butt Naked said he had a vision when he was eleven years old where he was told by a tribal god that he would become a great warrior and that he should practice human sacrifice and cannibalism to increase his power and become impossible to kill. And he seems to have taken this vision VERY seriously. Or - maybe he made it to try and rationalize and justify all the atrocities he committed to others. About ten after his first major vision - Blayhi claims to have experienced another vision - a divine Christian vision that transformed him from a mass murderer into a man of God. And ever since that event, he’s committed his life to trying to right the wrongs he made in the past. But is he really a man of god? Or his is just a con man doing whatever he feels he needs to do in order to thrive in an extremely difficult place for someone with almost no formal education to just survive? During times of war - he became a warlord. During times of peace - he’s become a man of god. Something about it all feels very convenient. General Butt Naked is a complicated man. And Liberia is a complicated nation. And we explore the man, the country he comes from, and more on today’s warmongering, death-defying, eye-opening, so much insane shit packed into this one, edition of Timesuck. PAUSE TIMESUCK INTRO I. Welcome! A.Happy Monday Meatsacks! WELCOME to the cult of the curious. Work can Wait for this tale. HAIL Nimrod, Hail Lucifina, Praise Bojangles, and Glory Be to Triple M. I’m Dan Cummins, Suck Nasty, Optimus Suck, Suck Norris, and you are listening to Timesuck. How do you all feel about skipping announcements today and getting right into SO MUCH SHOW??? All in favor say Hail Nimrod? Let’s do it. Holy shit I got sucked in hard to this topic this week. Let’s head to Liberia, on the west coast of Africa, to suck a Civil War - two of them in fact - the founding of a nation, and the life of brutal warlord who once went by the name of General Butt Naked, a man who claimed that fighting naked made him immune to bullets. Pretty sure that’s not totally true. But maybe KIND OF true. Seeing a wild-eyed, naked dude - carrying a machine gun or a machete - running at you in an urban war zone might give a lot of people pause and throw their shot off. Before we get to know Mr. Butt Naked - we first will familiarize ourselves with Liberia, where our story takes place - an extremely unique and fascinating and oftentimes completely horrific African nation. A nation that has been a living Hell for far too many of its people to live in. Then, we’ll take a look at Liberia’s culture of warlords and how they operate - how the concept of warlords is not an African thing - it’s a world wide thing - before we then examine the interesting spiritual beliefs that gave Blayhi has said pushed him towards human sacrifice. THEN - we’ll jump into this week’s Timesuck Timeline, following Liberia’s two Civil Wars - both were fought in the past thirty years - and we’ll also follow Joshua Blahyi’s life and get to know some other brutal military leaders. I hope you find all this as interesting as I do today. Yip, yip, yaw! PAUSE TIMESUCK INTERLUDE II. Intro/Establish Premiss: A. Liberia This week’s info is going to take us across the Atlantic to a continent we don’t visit nearly as often as we probably should here on the Suck — Antarctica. Kidding. We’re visiting Africa, of course. We don’t visit Antarctica often and we never will! It is a frozen, barren wasteland - and I don’t care enough about Penguins and seals to talk about them for over two hours. We don’t visit Africa enough! Lots of good stories in Africa. Loads of interesting people and history. Specifically today, we head to Liberia, a smaller African nation along the continent’s west Atlantic coast - just south of Sierra Leone, just North of the Ivory Coast. Liberia is perhaps the most unique nation on the entire continent in terms of its modern origin story. It’s the only Black State in Africa never to have been subjected to colonial rule. It’s also Africa’s oldest republic. And the troubled nation has such a strange origin story. B.Liberian Settlement and the ACS: Liberia was established on land acquired for freed U.S. slaves by the American Colonization Society, which founded a colony at Cape Mesurado [mez uh rah doh] in 1822 - this Cape is located where the capital city of Monrovia sits today. This Society - the ACS - also known as The Society for the Colonization of Free People of Color of America, was founded in 1816 in Washington DC, by one Robert Finley. A Princeton grad - Finley was a Presbyterian minister who worked as a pastor for two decades in Basking Ridge, New Jersey, also teaching at a boys’ academy before becoming the president of the University of Georgia shortly before his death in 1817. And Finley founded - along with Samuel John Mills - a Congregational minister from Connecticut and a Christian Missionary - the ACS in order to relocate free American blacks to a colony in West Africa. The Society quickly gained support from some abolitionists and also from most slaveholders - for very different reasons. Some white abolitionists truly seemed to have noble intentions when it came to African colonization. They believed that African Americans - due to both slavery in the South and discrimination in the North - would never find the happiness, freedom, and fulfillment in America that they could find in their own, new nation in West Africa. Other, much less noble Americans in the North - and slaveholders in the South - just wanted free black Americans to get…. the fuck… out. They feared them. They were worried that - if left to their own devices in America - they might lead slavery rebellions and revolts. OR, they would want equal rights - to vote and own their own land - OR - heaven forbid - black men might want to romantically pursue white women! The horror! Oh my HECK! This notion of the racially motivated exportation of free black people to Africa was actually NOT a new idea. America took a page out of the playbook of its own former colonial masters - the British - for this one. In 1787, Britain had founded the colony of Freetown in Sierra Leone. They sent the “black poor” of London there. The organization that led relocation efforts was called the Committee for the Relief of the Black Poor. Only 38 initial “settlers” were originally shipped off. A few years later, in 1792, 1,100 former American slaves living in then British-controlled Nova Scotia - tired of both the weather and racial discrimination - sailed in 15 ships to Free town. Then, in 1815 - Paul Cuffee, a successful American Quaker ship owner and activist based in Boston financed taking 38 American free blacks to head to Freetown as well. He’s the man who laid the foundation for the American Colonization Society. And until 1961, Sierra Leone would be a British colony. Despite similar beginnings, Liberia’s settlement history has been very different than Sierra Leone’s. It was never REALLY a colony of the US. It received some grant money from the US to get started - but it was never a proper “colony.” More of an experiment, really run by the ACS. The initial American settlement was named Christopolis in 1822. Then, in 1824, the colony around Christopolis was named Liberia - as in Liberty - and the initial settlement was renamed Monrovia after James Monroe - the President of the United States at the time, who was a big supporter of the colony. Monroe was all about sending freed Black Slaves and ex-Caribbean slaves to Liberia. He saw this as preferable to emancipation. So - kind of fucked up that the city is named after him. And that it still is. It’s named after a guy who did NOT want to have freed African slaves living in America - he wanted to ship them out of the States, and back across the Atlantic. https://history.state.gov/milestones/1830-1860/liberia (Monroe) “Thanks for all the help in building our economy and making our nation strong enough to never have to worry about being brought to heel by the British my black brothers and sisters! Now - with all due respect - PLEASSSEEEE….
Recommended publications
  • Scores Dead As Record-Breaking Heat Wave Grips Canada and US 134 Deaths in Vancouver Mostly Related to the Heat
    6 Established 1961 International Thursday, July 1, 2021 Scores dead as record-breaking heat wave grips Canada and US 134 deaths in Vancouver mostly related to the heat VANCOUVER: Scores of deaths in Canada’s ing heat stretching from the US state of Oregon to Vancouver area are likely linked to a grueling heat wave, Canada’s Arctic territories has been blamed on a high- authorities said Tuesday, as the country recorded its pressure ridge trapping warm air in the region. highest ever temperature amid scorching conditions that Temperatures in the US Pacific Northwest cities of extended to the US Pacific Northwest. At least 134 peo- Portland and Seattle reached levels not seen since ple have died suddenly since Friday in the Vancouver record-keeping began in the 1940s: 115 degrees area, according to figures released by the city police Fahrenheit in Portland and 108 in Seattle Monday, department and the Royal Canadian Mounted police. according to the National Weather Service. Vancouver The Vancouver Police Department alone said it had on the Pacific coast has for several days recorded tem- responded to more than 65 sudden deaths since Friday, peratures above 86 degrees Fahrenheit (or almost 20 with the vast majority “related to the heat.” degrees above seasonal norms). Canada set a new all-time high temperature record The chief coroner for the province of British for a third day in a row Tuesday, reaching 121 degrees Columbia, which includes Vancouver, said that it had Fahrenheit (49.5 degrees Celsius) in Lytton, British “experienced a significant increase in deaths reported Columbia, about 155 miles (250 kilometers) east of where it is suspected that extreme heat has been con- Vancouver, the country’s weather service, Environment tributory.” The service said in a statement it recorded Canada, reported.
    [Show full text]
  • War Crimes Prosecution Watch, Vol. 15, Issue 2
    PILPG Logo Case School of Law Logo War Crimes Prosecution Watch Editor-in-Chief David Krawiec FREDERICK K. COX Volume 15 - Issue 2 INTERNATIONAL LAW CENTER March 14, 2020 Technical Editor-in-Chief Erica Hudson Founder/Advisor Michael P. Scharf Managing Editors Matthew Casselberry Faculty Advisor Alexander Peters Jim Johnson War Crimes Prosecution Watch is a bi-weekly e-newsletter that compiles official documents and articles from major news sources detailing and analyzing salient issues pertaining to the investigation and prosecution of war crimes throughout the world. To subscribe, please email [email protected] and type "subscribe" in the subject line. Opinions expressed in the articles herein represent the views of their authors and are not necessarily those of the War Crimes Prosecution Watch staff, the Case Western Reserve University School of Law or Public International Law & Policy Group. Contents AFRICA NORTH AFRICA Libya Declaring commitment to ‘peace and stability’ for Libya, top UN envoy steps down as stress takes its toll (UN News) Libyan Crimes Watch documents violations against judiciary officials in eastern region (The Libya Observer) Haftar’s rocket attack kills two, injures four in Libya’s capital (The Libya Observer) CENTRAL AFRICA Central African Republic Secretary-General Strongly Condemns Killing of United Nations Stabilization Mission Staff Member in Central African Republic (Relief Web) Sudan & South Sudan Sudan central bank announces US sanctions lifted on 157 companies (France 24) ACPJS director: ‘Mixed
    [Show full text]
  • African Immigrants Project Interview Transcription
    African Immigrants Project Interview transcription Massa Washington Interview date: June 18, 2000 Location of interview: Interviewee’s home in West Philadelphia Country of origin: Liberia Ethnic group/language group: Gola Religion: Roman Catholic Profession: Journalist / Job development coordinator Level of education: Bachelor’s degree not completed Location of residence in Philadelphia: West Philadelphia Ms. Washington first fled Liberia, where she worked as a journalist, in 1990. She returned to Liberia after two years, but in 1996 fled again, this time to Ghana. In 1997 she got a visitor’s visa for the United States and went to stay with a friend in Atlanta. She applied for Temporary Protected Status, but returned to Liberia before it was granted in order to participate in the upcoming elections. She fled again to Ghana in 1999, after threats upon her life, and then came to the United States on a visitor’s visa. She applied for asylum and was granted it. Ms. Washington feels that the Liberian associations in Philadelphia recreate the ethnic divisions that exist back home, and she refuses to be a part of them. She is, however, a member of the Association of Liberia Journalists in the U.S. Ms. Washington served a member of the Community Advisory Committee for the African Immigrant Project. Interview Transcription Interviewer: Leigh Swigart (LS) Interviewee: Massa Washington (MW) also present: Vera Viditz-Ward (VW), project photographer [START OF SIDE 1, TAPE 1] LS: Tell me your name, just for the record. So it’s on the tape. MW: My name is Massa Washington. LS: And you are from what country? MW: Liberia.
    [Show full text]
  • Experiments with Truth in Liberia and Sierra Leone Robert Collins Painter Macalester College, [email protected]
    Macalester College DigitalCommons@Macalester College Political Science Honors Projects Political Science Department May 2009 Weak States and Political Constraints: Experiments with Truth in Liberia and Sierra Leone Robert Collins Painter Macalester College, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.macalester.edu/poli_honors Part of the Comparative Politics Commons, Other International and Area Studies Commons, and the Other Political Science Commons Recommended Citation Painter, Robert Collins, "Weak States and Political Constraints: Experiments with Truth in Liberia and Sierra Leone" (2009). Political Science Honors Projects. Paper 20. http://digitalcommons.macalester.edu/poli_honors/20 This Honors Project is brought to you for free and open access by the Political Science Department at DigitalCommons@Macalester College. It has been accepted for inclusion in Political Science Honors Projects by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@Macalester College. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Weak States and Political Constraints: Experiments with Truth in Liberia and Sierra Leone Focusing on truth and reconciliation commissions in Liberia and Sierra Leone, this thesis examines which political conditions typical of weak states had the greatest impact in deciding the different levels of success between the two cases. Two conditions played a central role in determining each commission’s success: the de- legitimization of the state and political fragmentation. Their presence in Sierra Leone derailed that truth commission’s efforts to carry out its mandate. Conversely, their absence in Liberia allowed its commission to operate relatively free of political impediments, leading to greater success. Robert Collins Painter Advised By: Professor Wendy Weber Political Science Department Macalester College ‘09 -1- Acknowledgements Countless people aided me in the completion of this project; far more than this abbreviated format allows me to mention here.
    [Show full text]
  • Press Clippings
    SPECIAL COURT FOR SIERRA LEONE OUTREACH AND PUBLIC AFFAIRS OFFICE PRESS CLIPPINGS Enclosed are clippings of local and international press on the Special Court and related issues obtained by the Outreach and Public Affairs Office as at: Tuesday, 31 July 2012 Press clips are produced Monday through Friday. Any omission, comment or suggestion, please contact Martin Royston-Wright Ext 7217 2 Local News The Case of Prosecutor V. Charles Gankay Taylor…/ Standard Times Pages 3-6 Sierra Leone’s Special Court Offers Lessons for Prosecuting…/ The Nation Pages 7-8 International News Amazing Grace? / Vanity Fair Pages 9-11 State Department Says Obama Official Misquoted on Rwanda / OpEdNews Pages 12-13 3 Standard Times Tuesday, 31 July 2012 4 5 6 7 The Nation Tuesday, 31 July 2012 8 9 Vanity Fair July 2012 Amazing Grace? He’s now an evangelical minister, but in his former life Liberia’s Joshua Blahyi was a warlord and cannibal who went by the name General Butt Naked. And he has a story to tell. By Tom Freston. Of Africa’s 55 nations, I’ve always been the most curious about Liberia, on the southern curve of West Africa. First off, only Liberia and Ethiopia were never colonized. Liberia’s history is in fact unique. The country was founded in 1820 by freed slaves from the United States. The capital, Monrovia, was named after President James Monroe. Then, in true Jim Crow style, those freed slaves (called Americo-Liberians) took what they had learned from the master-slave plantation system in the U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 a Comparison of Post-Conflict Disarmament Programs in Sierra
    1 A Comparison of Post-Conflict Disarmament Programs in Sierra Leone and Liberia Iris Irwin Capstone Advisor: Jennifer Gumbrewicz (SPA) University Honors Spring 2013 2 Table of Contents Abstract………………………………..………………………………………………3 Acronym Guide…….. ………………………………………………………….…….. 4 Introduction: …….. ……………………………………………………………..…… 5 Background Liberia…….. …………………………………………………………….6 Policy Development and Implementation in Liberia………………………………..7 Disarmament Analysis in Liberia…………………………………………………….13 Background Sierra Leone…………………………………………………………….20 Policy Development and Implementation in Sierra Leone…………………………21 Disarmament Analysis in Sierra Leone……………………………………………...26 Conclusions and Comparisons……………………………………………………….34 Endnotes……………………………………………………………………………….38 Works Cited……………………………………………………………………………46 3 Abstract This paper explores the post-conflict disarmament programs implemented in Sierra Leone and Liberia at the end of their respective civil wars. It gives a brief history of each country’s relevant political and historical background leading up to and including their civil wars. It then details the policy developments that led up to the creation of the Comprehensive Peace Agreement in Liberia and the Lomé Agreement in Sierra Leone. These two agreements were the foundation for each country’s successful disarmament program. The paper then explains how each country implemented its disarmament process, followed by an analysis of why each program succeeded. It compares the disarmament programs to each other and concludes that Sierra Leone’s program
    [Show full text]
  • Civil War and State Formation and State Gerdes Civil War
    Liberia was the scene of two devastating civil wars since late 1989 and became widely consid- ered a failed state. By contrast, the country is frequently described as a success story since the international professional Ellen Johnson Sirleaf assumed the presidency following democrat- ic elections in 2005. The book investigates the Felix Gerdes political economy of civil war and democratic peace and puts the developments into histori- cal perspective. The author argues that the civ- il wars did not represent the breakdown of the state but exhibited dynamics characteristic of Civil War state formation. His analysis of continuity and change in Liberia’s political evolution details and State Formation both political progress and persistent structur- The Political Economy of War and Peace in Liberia al deficits of the polity. Mikropo- Civil War and State Formation and State Civil War Gerdes ISBN 978-3-593-39892-1 litik der www.campus.de Gewalt Civil War and State Formation Mikropolitik der Gewalt – Micropolitics of Violence Volume 9 Edited by Klaus Schlichte and Peter Waldmann Felix Gerdes, Dr. phil., is political scientist and specializes in politics of Sub- Saharan Africa and South-East Asia. He currently works as Academic Staff at Zaman University, Phnom Penh, Cambodia. Felix Gerdes Civil War and State Formation The Political Economy of War and Peace in Liberia Campus Verlag Frankfurt/New York Bibliographic Information published by the Deutsche Nationalbibliothek. Die Deutsche Nationalbibliothek lists this publication in the Deutsche Nationalbibliografie. Detailed bibliographic data are available in the Internet at http://dnb.d-nb.de. ISBN 978-3-593-39892-1 All rights reserved.
    [Show full text]
  • SWEET BATTLEFIELDS Youth and the Liberian Civil War
    SWEET BATTLEFIELDS Youth and the Liberian Civil War By Mats Utas Dissertation for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Cultural Anthropology pre- sented at Uppsala University, 2003. ABSTRACT Utas, M. 2003. Sweet Battlefields: Youth and the Liberian Civil War. Uppsala University Dissertations in Cultural Anthropology, 1. 288 pp. Uppsala. ISBN 91-506-1677-3. This dissertation presents an ethnography of youth in Liberia and of how their lives became affected by a civil war which raged in the country between 1990 and 1997. The focus is on the experiences, motivations, and reflections of young combatants who fought for a variety of rebel factions. For these young people, the daily prospect of poverty, joblessness and marginalisation effectively blocked the paths to a normal adulthood; drawing them instead into a subculture of liminality, characterised by abjection, resentment and rootlessness. As opportunity came, their voluntary enlist- ment into one of the several rebel armies of the civil war therefore became an attrac- tive option for many. Based upon one year of fieldwork during 1998, conducted among groups of ex-combatant youths in both the capital Monrovia and in a provin- cial town in the rural hinterland, I describe and analyse the young people’s own accounts of their involvement in the civil war; their complicity in atrocities, their coping strategies in the context of armed conflict, their position as ex-combatants in a post-war environment, and their outlook on their past, present and future. Keywords: Liberia, anthropology, civil war, youth, children, child soldiers, street children, conflict, violence, women in war, West Africa.
    [Show full text]
  • Livelihoods of Ex-Combatants in Monrovia, Liberia
    No Work, No Peace: Livelihoods of Ex-Combatants in Monrovia, Liberia By Michael Pah Forsther Master’s thesis in Peace and Conflict Transformation University of Tromsø, Norway Autumn 2011 1 Acknowledgements I would like to acknowledge the unconditional support and contribution of my family, colleagues and friends, who have helped me during my study at the University of Tromsø. Through the understanding and continues prayer of Kula E. Koroma and the entire Koromas family here in Norway, I have been blessed to complete my master thesis. Special thanks go to my supervisor at the Center for Peace Studies, Oware Percy. This academic achievement would not have been realized without his assistance. The same gratitude goes to the ex- combatants, the redundant AFL soldiers, NCDDRR officials, UNIMIL officers including all those that contributed to this academic work. Thanks to my field escort, Alex W. Debee of the University of Liberia, for his tireless effort during my field work in Monrovia, Liberia. Colossal thanks to my parents, David and Rebecca Pah, who have gave me the foundation for everything that I have achieved to date. I would also like to acknowledge the support of my grandmother, old lady Shunwolu Pah, for blessing me with special knowledge to reach this academic level and not forgetting Nelson Forsther, William Forsther, Shadlene Forsther and Cleopatra Forsther for their moral support. I also dedicate this thesis to every Liberian, including those that have lost their lives as the result of the civil war. 2 Abstract Conflicts undermine state security, cause massive loss of lives, destroy livelihoods and undermine the general well-being of civilian populations.
    [Show full text]
  • Press Clippings
    SPECIAL COURT FOR SIERRA LEONE OUTREACH AND PUBLIC AFFAIRS OFFICE PRESS CLIPPINGS Enclosed are clippings of local and international press on the Special Court and related issues obtained by the Outreach and Public Affairs Office as at: Thursday, 14 April 2011 Press clips are produced Monday through Friday. Any omission, comment or suggestion, please contact Martin Royston-Wright Ext 7217 2 International News Gaddafi Must Face the Music / The Financial Times Pages 3-4 War and remembrance: Confronting ‘General Butt Naked’ / The Sate Pages 5-7 War Crimes Prosecutor: Bosnia Needs Independent Judiciary To Continue Work / Bernama.Com Pages 8-9 Return to Cabinet Possible for Kenyan ICC Suspect William Ruto / Voice of America Page 10 Witness to Testify For Ngirabatware via Video-link from France / Hirondelle News Agency Page 11 3 The Financial Times Wednesday, 13 April 2011 Gaddafi must face the music Christopher Stephen Peace versus Justice; it is an old question for prosecutors at the International Criminal Court and one they are hearing all over again as they plunge into investigations in Libya and Ivory Coast. Both conflicts are now in their endgames and the outside world is trying to decide how to settle things down. One obvious answer is to offer immunity to Muammer Gaddafi if he goes quietly. In an ideal world, he and Ivory Coast’s Laurent Gbagbo would pay for their records of killings, torture, rape and imprisonment. But in the real world, the argument goes, the key is stability, and that is more easily bought by offering exile in exchange for going quietly.
    [Show full text]
  • The Seduction of Football Youth and Sport for Development and Peace in Post-Conflict Liberia
    The Seduction of Football Youth and Sport for Development and Peace in Post-Conflict Liberia A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy By Holly Lindsay Collison School of Social Sciences Brunel University October 2013 Abstract This thesis considers Liberian youth and the concept of Sport for Development and Peace (SDP). Since the early 2000s the notion of SDP has been strongly advocated, accepted and inserted into UN led policies and intervention strategies for uniting societies divided by violent conflict. Whilst little has been done to monitor and evaluate such programmes the notion has grown at an unprecedented pace and has been adopted by the development and humanitarian industry with real vigour. In many ways football has become the face of development in post-conflict societies. However, this fashionable intervention remains a development assumption rather than a tested method of programming. Liberia is a post-conflict society with a large youth population, an active large UN peacekeeping force and a long footballing heritage with a plethora of local NGO’s using SDP initiatives. My intention in this thesis is to question the assumptions of SDP advocates as they are applied in Liberia, in order to provide a better understanding of the social effects of football for Liberia’s youth population. I pursue this goal through an ethnography of one Liberian youth football team, Zatti FC, the community from which the players are drawn and the Catholic youth centre where they play. This thesis is significant as, despite its popularity, SDP has rarely been subjected to academic scrutiny, especially using the detailed qualitative methods I apply here.
    [Show full text]
  • The Truth About Truth Commissions:Why They Do
    SIRLEAF.35.6 (Do Not Delete) 8/1/2014 8:01 PM THE TRUTH ABOUT TRUTH COMMISSIONS: WHY THEY DO NOT FUNCTION OPTIMALLY IN POST- CONFLICT SOCIETIES Matiangai V.S. Sirleaf† Almost forty years after the first truth commission convened and more than sixty-seven others have been employed, there is little clarity on how they contribute to their stated objectives and in which transitional contexts they succeed or fail. This Article uses data gathered from my field research in Ghana, Sierra Leone, and Liberia to develop a theoretical framework for understanding in which contexts truth commissions may be the most effective. Using insights from the legal transplant literature and applying it to the diffusion of truth commissions, this Article finds that truth commissions face greater challenges carrying out their mandates in post- conflict as opposed to post-authoritarian societies. In post-conflict societies, weak institutions to support a truth-telling process combined with large numbers of victims and perpetrators will tend to overwhelm truth commissions. These factors, along with the lack of moral consensus surrounding mass violence, interact to make truth commissions function less optimally in post-conflict contexts. This Article finds that despite their widespread use in post-conflict and fragile states, truth commissions may have more utility in post-authoritarian or even non-transitional states. In sum, this Article argues that the kind of transition should determine the kind of transitional-justice interventions employed. † Assistant Professor of Law, University of Baltimore Law School. B.A., New York University; M.A. University of Ghana-Legon; J.D., Yale Law School.
    [Show full text]