Ornl-Tm-3151
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ORNL-TM- 3151 Contract No. W-7405-eng-26 Reactor Division A STUDY OF FISSION PRODUCTS IN THE MOLTEN-SALT REACTOR EXPERIMENT BY GAMMA. SPECTROMETRY A. Houtzeel F. F. Dyer AUGUST 1972 NOTICE This document contains information of a preliminary nature and was prepared primarily for internal use at the Oak Ridge National Laboratory. It is subject to revision or correction and therefore does not represent a final report. OAK RIDGE NATIONAL LABORATORY Oak Ridge, Tennessee 37830 operated by UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION the NOTICE for report was prepared as an account of work U S. ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION sponsored by the United States Government. Neither the United States nor the United States Atomic Energy Commission, nor any of their employees, nor any of their contractors, subcontractors, or their employees, makes any warranty, express or implied, or assumes any legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, com- pleteness or usefulness of any information, apparatus, product or process disclosed, or represents that its use would not infringe privately owned rights. iii CONTENTS Page ACKNOWLEDGMENT ......................... vii SUMMARY.. ........................... 1 1. INTRODUCTION TO THE MOLTEN SALT REACTOR EXPERIMENT. ..... 3 1.1 Molten-Salt Reactor Concept .............. 3 1.2 Description of the MSRE ................ 4 2. OBJECTIVES OF THIS GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY STUDY ....... 11 3. DESCRIPTION AND PERFORMANCE OF EQUIPMENT. .......... 13 3.1 Background ...................... 13 3.2 General Description .................. 14 3.3 Detector and Amplifier ................ 17 3.4 Analyzer ....................... 17 3.5 Collimator Assembly .................. 18 3.6 Setup of Experimental Equipment ............ 20 3.7 Locational Equipment ................. 21 3.8 Shielding ...................... 21 3.9 Calibration Setup ................... 24 4. ANALYSIS OF SPECTRA ..................... 27 4.1 Purpose and General Procedure ............. 27 4.2 Problems ....................... 28 4.3 Table of Isotopes ................... 30 4.4 Computer Programs ................... 31 5. CALIBRATION. ........................ 33 5.1 General.. ...................... 33 5.2 Source ........................ 34 5.3 Slit Experiment - Source Strength ........... 35 5.4 Single Source Experiments ............... 43 5.5 Heat Exchanger Calibration .............. 44 5.6 Calibration of Shielding Materials .......... 48 5.7 Calibration for Fission Gases in the MSRE ....... 52 6. MEASUREMENTS ........................ 53 iV . Page 7 . RESULTS ............................ 57 7.1 Group A Spectra ..................... 57 7.1.1 Heat exchanger .................. 58 7.1.2 Main reactor off-gas line ............. 64 7.1.3 Main fuel lines .................. 64 7.2 Group B Spectra ..................... 67 7.2.1 Main reactor off-gas line ............. 67 7.2.2 Heat exchanger .................. 68 7.3 Group D Spectra ..................... 68 7.4 Group E Spectra ..................... 68 7.5 Group F Spectra ..................... 69 7.5.1 Main reactor off-gas line ............. 70 7.5.2 Heat exchanger .................. 84 7.5.3 Drain tank .................... 96 7.6 Group G Spectra ..................... 99 7.6.1 Heat exchanger .................. 101 7.6.2 Main reactor off-gas line ............. 112 7.6.3 Fuel pump bowl and fuel lines ........... 115 7.7 Group 9 S?ectra ..................... 119 7.7.1 Heat exchanger .................. 123 7.8 Group I Spectra ..................... 134 7.9 Group J Spectra ..................... 134 7.10 Group K Spectra ..................... 136 7.11 Group L Spectra ..................... 136 7.12 Group M Spectra ..................... 138 8 . CONCLUSIONS .......................... 141 8.1 Data Collection and Analysis ............... 141 8.1.1 Gamma spectrometer system ............. 141 8.1.2 Calibration ................... 142 8.1.3 Computer analysis program ............. 143 I 8.2 Results -General .................... 143 8.2.1 Metal surfaces in direct contact with the fuel salt .................... 143 8.2.2 Main reactor off-gas line ............. 145 V Page 8.3 Elements and Nuclide Chains ............... 146 8.3.1 Niobium ...................... 146 8.3.2 Ruthenium-rhodium ................. 148 8.3.3 Antimony-tellurium-iodine ............. 151 8.3.4 Extrapolation back to reactor shutdown time .... 154 9. EPILOGUE.. .......................... 155 Appendix A. TABLE OF RADIONUCLIDES ................ 161 Appendix B. PRODUCTION AND STANDARDIZATION OF lornAg IN SILVER TUBING FOR MSRE GAMMA SPECTROMETRY ......... 181 Appendix C. ABSOLUTE EFFICIENCY CURVES OF THE GAMMA-RAY DETECTION SYSTEM USED FOR THE CALCULATION OF ABSOLUTE AMOUNTS OF NUCLIDES DEPOSITED ................ 188 Appendix D. CALCULATIONS OF COUNTING EFFICIENCIES FROM FIRST PRINCIPLES ..................... 194 vii W 4 ACKNOWLEDGMENT The authors gratefully acknowledge the contributions of the many per- sons who were instrumental in the proper execution of this experiment, es- pecially in the design of the equipment, the recording of the spectra, and the analysis of the results. In particular, we appreciate the valiant help of the following persons. R. Blumberg, for the very helpful efforts in the design of the equip- ment and the recording of the spectra. J. R. Engel, for his wise advice during the course of the experiment. A. F. Joseph, for his effort in making the spectrum analysis program operable on the ORNL computers. J. L. Rutherford, for the help in analyzing the computer results and preparing the figures. L. P. Pugh, for the assistance in the design of the equipment. J. A. Watts, for his help in analyzing the computer results and preparing the figures. SWRY The operation of the Molten-Salt Reactor Experiment (MSRE) has demon- strated that a mixture of fluoride salts is a practical fluid fuel that is quite stable under reactor conditions. The chemistry of the fission prod- ucts is such, however, that some of them leave the circulating fuel salt and appear on the moderator graphite in the core, on the metal surfaces ex- posed to the salt, and on the metal surfaces in the off-gas system. Xenon and krypton fission gases are stripped in the off-gas system, where they decay to daughter nuclides. Some other elements (Mo, Nb, Ru, Te, and Sb) appear to exist in the metallic state and tend to plate out on metal or graphite surfaces or be carried out into the off-gas system as particles. Because it is important in the design of larger molten-salt reactor systems to know where and in what proportion fission products are distributed throughout the system, considerable efforts were made to obtain this infor- mation in the MSRE. A technique was developed at ORNL to locate and measure fission prod- uct depositions on surfaces exposed to the salt and in the off-gas system of the MSRE by the intensity and energy spectrum of the emitted gamma rays. A gamma-ray spectrometer was developed, consisting of a Ge(Li) detector, a 4096-channel analyzer, and a lead collimator to permit examination of small areas. This device was usually positioned with the MSRE portable mainte- nance shield over the different reactor system components, with precise alignment and location achieved by a laser beam and surveyor’s transits. Measurements were made not only with the reactor system shut down and drained but also with the fuel circulating and the reactor at several power levels. Altogether some 1000 spectra were taken, 25% of which were recorded with the reactor at some power level (a few watts to full reactor power). Another 400 spectra were taken to calibrate the equipment. Com- puterized data handling permitted this mass of data to be analyzed quali- tatively and quantitatively. Most of the effort was focused on the off-gas system and the primary heat exchanger, the latter because it contains 40% of the metal surfaces exposed to the salt. The off-gas system contained not only fission prod- ucts with gaseous precursors but also metallic elements with their decay 2 products [such as Nb, Mo, Ru, Sb, Te(I)]. The MSRE heat exchanger con- tained mostly depositions of the same metallic elements. It was observed that fission gases form a major source of activity in the heat exchanger when the reactor is shut down and the fuel is drained immediately (emer- gency drain). A high-resolution gamma-ray spectrometer used with proper remote main- tenance equipment and location tools proved to be very versatile in locating and evaluating fission product depositions in a highly radioactive reactor system. 3 1. INTRODUCTION TO THE MOLTEN-SALT REACTOR EXPERIMENT 1.1 Molten-Salt Reactor Concept 9 * The molten-salt reactor concept originated in 1947 at Oak Ridge as a system for jet aircraft propulsion. The idea was to use a molten mixture of fluoride salts including UF4 as a fuel that could be circulated to re- move the heat from the core. Fluoride salts looked promising because of their basic physical chemistry: the vapor pressure of the molten salts would be extremely low and they would not react violently on exposure to air or water. Radiation damage would be nonexistent in the completely ionic liquid fluorides. Since a variety of interesting fluorides (NaF, LiF, BeFz, ZrF4, UF4, etc.) were known to be stable in contact with some common structural metals, a corrosionless system seemed attainable. In addition, high specific heat, good thermal conductivity, and reasonable viscosity made these liquids good heat transfer media. On the other hand, the high melting point of potential fuel mixtures (40C-5OO0C), while no drawback during power operation,