NUMISMATICS: the ART of COINS and MEDALS ABRAM BELSKIE

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

NUMISMATICS: the ART of COINS and MEDALS ABRAM BELSKIE ABRAM BELSKIE NUMISMATICS: THE ART of COINS AND MEDALS at New York Medical College The Belskie Museum is which he held for many years. indebted to have D. Wayne His medical associations led him Johnson, Curator, Numismatic to other sculpture commissions Art, scholar and author, such as The Surgeon, 1962 for catalogue the numismatic Ethicon Building in Somerville, work of Abram Belskie. This N.J. as well as Portrait of Dr. brochure has been written as Robert Dickinson for N.Y. an Introductory Primer on Academy of Science and General Numismatic Art featuring Robert Wood Johnson at Johnson the art of Abram Belskie. & Johnson Laboratories. As a A complete catalogue listing is available upon request. numismatic sculptor he has been praised and honored for D. Wayne Johnson is known as editor and creator of Coin World which he his fifty medal series “Great started in 1960, editor of The Art Medalist for Medallic Art Company Men of Medicine” issued and contributing writer to two internet by Presidential Art Medals, Inc. sites: www.amsamedals.org www.medalcollectors.org The artist best describes his numismatic work as follows: “I like it because it combines both art and science. I don’t think, really, there’s any barrier between ABRAM BELSKIE them. If the combination was (1907-1988) good enough for Leonardo da Vinci, it’s good enough for me.” As an artist and sculptor he was able to combine two disparate disciplines – art and medicine – in which he won acclaim in both From 1952 until 1984 he worlds. In the field of medicine he is re-nowned as a medical designed over 130 medals sculptor for his life-size scientifically correct anatomical models. and medallions which is He worked with Dr. Robert L. Dickinson on the Birth Series, at the focus of this publication New York Medical College and his Heart Series for American Heart and exhibition, Numismatics: Association. His work in this field earned him a Faculty position The Art of Coins & Medals. the wording and image to the very bit at a time – called pellets – then shaped minimum. He does this by making the with special tools. One, called a wire tool, How Abram Belskie image almost a symbol. looks like a wire loop on the end of a pencil. Another is made of wood, a boaster, Made Medals Consider a coin in your pocket. It is made the used for shaping and smoothing the clay. By D. Wayne Johnson same way as a medal, with themes, images, He would have the basic relief formed, lettering and made from a model. A typical Curator, Numismatic Art, Belskie Museum then he would add the lettering. coin is from a half-inch to an inch-and-one- half, from a dime to silver-dollar size. Medals can be any size, but on average, they are one Casting in plaster of Paris. and-one-half to three inches. These are very Once he was satisfied the design was perfect, small areas for the artist’s design. The complete in every way, he would make a artist’s theme must be expressed in a very plaster cast of the clay model. First he would small size. But the artist has an advantage. coat the clay with a release agent to allow the He works oversize, and the mint or medal cast to be removed after it hardened. He would maker reduces his design to the smaller size build a fence around the clay with a metal intended for a coin or medal. strip, supporting it in a way where the plaster There is tremendous advantage in working would not seep out. oversize because the design is reduced for Plaster of Paris is a white powder. It is mixed final production. Facial features and hands, with water, slowly, not to allow air bubbles in Medals are used in many ways, to celebrate an anniversary, to for example, can be more lifelike. Clothing the mixture. Then he would pour a small can be shown with folds much more record some famous person or event, to collect for the sheer amount over the coated clay, slowly, again realistically. Detail adds realism to just not to allow air bubbles on the surface. enjoyment of their beauty! More often, however, medals are created about every part of the image shown on the medal. Ideally the artist wants to ‘Touching up’ is last step. as an award; for example, the Nobel Prize Medal, the Pulitzer Medal design a single theme, make a simple The plaster hardens in an hour or two. The or Olympic medals. In addition to being a life-long sculptor, Abram image – called a device on a coin or medal – but adds as much detail as he plaster cast can then be lifted off carefully. Belskie was also a medalist – a person who creates medals. He was can to make it appear real. But to make sure it is completely hard, it is 39 years old before he started making medals and creating the often put in an oven and baked. models from which medals were made. Medals are like any other Artist interpretation is most important. Casting changes polarity. The positive clay becomes a negative cast. At this stage the The artist must add his interpretation – of art work. They are created by artists who develop an idea in their artist “touches up” the negative plaster. He the person, or the scene, or the image. He sharpens up the lettering or deepens some mind, to become the theme of the medal. can simplify his subject, or strengthen it, or area to emphasize the design. emphasize some element. He must make Medal ideas are first sketched. relief for medals is a special kind, called two designs, each related to the other to Then he coats the plaster cast, again with because it has a flat back. Even emphasize each other, for the two sides. a release agent, and makes a cast from this Like any medal artist, Abram could draw bas-relief negative. This will be a positive, and is what in two ways – on paper as a drawing though a medal has relief on two sides, it sketches he sends off to the mint or medal maker. – or since he is a sculptor he could sketch is made from two flat-back models. The Modeling for a medal. front is called the the back the The manufacturer will reduce it on a in clay – the material he works with most obverse, Abram made pencil sketches as the first step The artist must create a separate pantograph and cuts the dies. The dies are of all. Sketching in clay gives the artist reverse. in his medal designs. Next he would work in model for each side. used to strike the coin or medal in metal, greater freedom but is more involved. clay. He would add clay to a background bronze or silver. For quick sketches Abram drew on paper, Medals have two elements on each side – plate, a smooth disk of plaster slightly larger but in his mind the lines indicated an the pictorial elements and the lettering. So than the size of the model. Next he would outline of relief. If a sculptor creates a the artist must think of lettering in addition prepare the design by modeling. statue he thinks in three dimensions. But it to what he wants to show as the images on He models by adding clay or carving it is said a medalist thinks in two-and-one- each side. There is not very much room for away creating modulated relief, the rise half dimensions, and that is half-joke. The either element, so the artist must reduce and fall of the design. Clay is added a tiny Mary Queen of Scots ,1973 Societe Commemorative de Femmes Celebres series (FM SCS-43) - G - - H - Silver & Striking, Struck - obverse Silver - reverse Brookgreen Gardens - A - - B - th Sketch & Theme - pencil drawing Background Plate & Working Model 50 Anniversary Medal, 1931-1981 1981, bronze, 3” diameter, Medallic Art Company (MAco 78-163), Belskie Museum of Art 1993-123 - C - - D - Observe - negative relief Reverse - positive relief Frederick Douglass Medal, 1969 from the American Negro Commemorative Society Series, silver 1.5” in diameter, Franklin Mint; Belskie Museum of Art, NJ 1993.114 Abram Belskie in his studio, Closter, New Jersey with models for the 1981 Bookgreen Gardens medal - E - - F - - I - - J - Modulated Relief with clay pellets, Device & Sketch - initial pencil Silver & Striking, Struck - obverse Silver & Striking, Struck - reverse Border, Lettering for obverse drawing for reverse Loop. Relief. A ring-shaped attachment to a medal The three-dimensional surface that is so it may be hung from a ribbon, chain the design raising from the base, or such to be worn. background or field; the design is said to be in Modulated Relief. Medal. A metallic piece, of historic, Reverse. commemorative, or artistic design, The back side of a coin or medal. made – by casting or striking – originally Series. in the shape similar to a coin (but without An issue of a number of numismatic or denomination and certainly not intended medallic items with a common theme to pass for money). or design and a continuity of issue. Medallion. Sketch. A large medal, round or nearly so; A two-dimensional drawing or three- 3 3/16-inch (80mm) or larger. The Language of Medal Making dimensional relief prepared by the artist A-Z Model, Modeling. to assist in the designing of a numismatic or medallic item. Medallists speak a language all their own. As with any field it has The permanent form and preparing the three-dimension relief of a new medal special terms and names for processes, techniques, tools and results.
Recommended publications
  • The California Numismatist
    Numismatic Fall 2008 California State Association of V. 5, No. 3 Numismatic Southern California $5.00 Association The California Numismatist The California Numismatist Offi cial Publication of the California State Numismatic Association and the Numismatic Association of Southern California Fall 2008, Volume 5, Number 3 About the Cover The California Numismatist Staff Images from our three main Editor Greg Burns articles grace our cover against a P.O. Box 1181 backdrop relating to a surprising de- Claremont, CA 91711 velopment in the printing of our little [email protected] journal: color! This is the fi rst issue Club Reports Virginia Bourke with the interior pages printed in color, South 10601 Vista Camino though the cover has been in color Lakeside, CA 92040 since the inception of TCN in 2004 [email protected] (starting in 2002 The NASC Quarterly, one of our predecessor publications, Club Reports Michael S. Turrini also started having color covers). North P.O. Box 4104 Please do write and let us know Vallejo, CA 94590 what you think about the new look. [email protected] While the expense is a bit more, Advertising Lila Anderson there’s such an improvement in aes- P.O. Box 365 thetics we’re inclined to keep it up. Grover Beach, CA 93483 [email protected] Visit Us on the Web The California Numismatist has a Web site at www.CalNumismatist.com. You can fi nd the offi cial scoop there in between issues. Also, both CSNA and NASC main- tain their own Web sites at: www.Calcoin.org www.NASC.net 2 The California Numismatist • Fall 2008 Contents Articles Wells Fargo & Company Jim Hunt ............................................................................................................10 Through the Numismatic Glass: This 19th Century Cent Design Lasted for Only One Year Dr.
    [Show full text]
  • Closter Master Plan
    HISTORIC PRESERVATION PLAN ELEMENT BOROUGH OF CLOSTER Bergen County, New Jersey February 2011 Prepared by the Closter Borough Planning Board and Historic Preservation Commission With Assistance From: Banisch Associates, Inc. 111 Main Street Flemington, NJ 08822 __________________________________________________ ________________ Francis J. Banisch III. AICP – Professional Planner #1686 Date Closter Historic Preservation Plan February 2011 Funding This publication has been financed in part with federal funds from the National Park Service, U.S. Department of Interior, and administered by the New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection, Historic Preservation Office. The contents and opinions do not necessarily reflect the views or policies of the U.S. Department of Interior. This program receives federal financial assistance for the identification and protection of historic properties. Under Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, the U.S. Department of the Interior prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, national origin, or handicap in its federally assisted programs. If you believe that you have been discriminated against in any program, activity, or facility as described above, or if you desire further information, please write to: Office of Equal Opportunity, National Park Service, 1849 C Street NW (NC200), Washington, D.C. 10240. In Appreciation This Historic Preservation Plan recognizes the dedicated efforts of the Historic Preservation Commission in collecting
    [Show full text]
  • Highest Honor Awards Given to Numismatists Making a Difference
    FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: Friday, July 27, 2018 CONTACT: Amanda Miller Telephone: 719-482-9871 E-mail: [email protected] Highest Honor Awards Given to Numismatists Making a Difference The American Numismatic Association (ANA) is recognizing several numismatists who not only lead by example, but pave new pathways within the numismatic hobby. Recognized for their dedication, hard work, passion and contributions, these recipients will be recognized at the World’s Fair of MoneyⓇ in Philadelphia, Aug. 14-18. Those being recognized are: Cindy Wibker for the Farran Zerbe Memorial Award for Distinguished Service David J. McCarthy for Numismatist of the Year Abigail Zechman for the Young Numismatist of the Year Mark Lighterman for the Lifetime Achievement Award The Farran Zerbe Memorial Award for Distinguished Service is the highest honor conferred by the American Numismatic Association. It is given in recognition of numerous years of outstanding, dedicated service to numismatics. Cindy Wibker is the recipient of this year’s award. For 25 years, Wibker has dedicated her career to Florida United Numismatists (FUN) as convention coordinator, organizing one of the premier shows in the country. This is no easy task, as FUN’s annual January show regularly draws an average of 10,000 attendees over four days, and its summer event, held each July, welcomes about 3,000 hobbyists. Born in Shreveport, Louisiana, the young Wibker enjoyed filling Whitman nickel and cent folders with pocket change and acquiring specimens through mail-order businesses. However, her mind turned to other pursuits. Growing up she enjoyed spending time outside playing different sports, going to games, spending time with her family and riding her bike.
    [Show full text]
  • Download This Issue
    Your Treasures are in Specialists in high quality ancient, medieval, and early Good Hands with us modern coins and medals. First established as a numismatic trading Auctions in Switzerland, company in 1971, today we have achieved a yearly price list, appraisals, solid reputation among the leading coin and medal auction houses of Europe. More than purchases and sales by 10,000 clients worldwide place their trust private treaty. zürich, switzerland Baltic States, City of Riga. Auction 135 in us. Our company’s fi rst auction was held Under Sweden. Charles X. Gustav, 1654-1660. 5 ducats “1645” (1654). in 1985, and we can look back on a positive Estimate: € 15,000. Price realized: € 70,000. track record of over 180 auctions since that time. Four times a year, the Künker auction gallery becomes a major rendezvous for numismatic afi cionados. This is where several thousand bidders regularly participate in our auctions. • We buy your gold assets at a fair, daily market price • International customer care Auction III • Yearly over 20,000 objects in Ancient Greek, Roman, our auctions Byzantine & Early European coins and medals of the • Large selection of gold coins highest quality. • Top quality color printed catalogues May 10th 2011 Russian Empire. Auction 135 Alexander I., 1801-1825. Gold medal of 48 ducats, 1814, by tsarina in the morning M. Feodorovna for Alexander I. in Zürich Estimate: € 30,000. Price realized: € 220,000. Auction IV The BCD Collection Profi t from our experience of more than 180 successful auctions – of Thessaly. scaled consign your coins and medals! down May 10th 2011 Tel.: +49 541 96 20 20 in the afternoon Roman Empire.
    [Show full text]
  • Numismatics—An Ancient Science
    conttributions from The Museum of History AxVd Technologv: Paper 32 Numismatics—an Ancient Science A Survey of its History EIvn\i EIr\j CLini-Stcj\t)iiHi INTRODUCTION 2 evolution ol- a sciknch .3 beginnings oe coin coi.i.ec'l'inc s middle aces and early renaissance ii renaissan(.:e and CINQLECENTO I5 SEN'ENTEENTH CEN lEIRV 22 EICHIEENTH CENTURY 25 EARLY NINETEENTH CENTURY 34 -11 MODERN TRENDS AND ACCOMI'LISI I M EN TS NUMISMAITCS IN HIE UNI I ED STATES 60 LITERATURE CITED 6S NUMISMATICS-AN ANCIENT SCIENCE A Survey of its History By Elvira EUt^i Clain-Stefaiielli INTRODUCTION This study has been prompted l)y the author's within specific areas. Citations of their books and observation that many people resjard nuinismaties articles are given in shortened form in the footnotes, simply as coin coUectins;, a pleasant hobby for young- willi full references appearing at the end of the paper. sters or retired persons. The holder of siicii a view- Because coin collections have supplied the raw point is unaware of the sco[)e and accomplishments of material for much in\estigation, the histories of some a historical investi<;ation that traces cultural evolution of the major private and public collections also have throus^h one of the basic aspects of everyday human been included in this survey. life: money. Seen as a reflection of past aspirations In my research, I have had an excellent guide in and accomplishments, coins are invaluable sources Ernest Babelon's chapter "l.a nutnismati(]ue et son for scholarly research, but few people are aware of histoire," published in 1901 as part of the first volume the tremendous amount of work done in this field by of his Trailf des monnaies grecques et romaines: Theorie past generations.
    [Show full text]
  • MEDICAL NUMISMATICS* by FIELDING H
    MEDICAL NUMISMATICS* By FIELDING H. GARRISON, M.D. LIEUTENANT COLONEL, MEDICAL CORPS, U. S. ARMY WASHINGTON, D. C. T is said that Billroth, in looking over were struck off regularly by the old Acad- a collection of medical medals, observed emy of Medicine of Paris to commemorate that “hardly a single one of them had the biennial election of each new Dean of been struck off to commemorate any- the Paris Medical Faculty, and copies of thing more than respectable mediocrity.” these jetons, in silver or bronze, were ILike all epigrams and stories of the ben presented to all the members of the Faculty. trovato type, the assertion has a shade of The Dean was not a professor in the Faculty exaggeration and an element of truth. but its chief administrative officer, hence The earlier medical medals tended to a prominent rather than an eminent figure commemorate things rather than people, in the history of early French medicine. later on, physicians prominent on account The Academy of Medicine (Paris) possesses of their connection with institutions and 108 of these rare pieces. The numismatic societies, finally physicians recognized as collection of the Army Medical Museum eminent by reason of their contributions (Washington) has ninety-one. The last to to scientific medicine. The same tendency be struck off was that of Claude Bourru, is noticeable throughout the history of who was Dean for three successive terms medicine with regard to medical authorship. (1788-1793). When, in 1793, the scientific Before Hippocrates, recorded medicine, societies,
    [Show full text]
  • Heritage Auctions | Fall 2020 $7.9 9
    HERITAGE AUCTIONS | FALL 2020 $7.9 9 DREW HECHT Election Season Energizes Collectors of Political Paper Money Movie Posters Auction Previews Memorabilia International Notes Collecting Strategies of Peter Lindeman, Lou Gehrig, Command Top Prices a Hollywood Producer Mike Coltrane, Justin Schiller features 32 Collecting With Style Hollywood producer Mike Kaplan has always had an eye for the elements that make a movie poster great By Hector Cantú Portrait by Deborah Hardee 36 Worldly Treasures As the largest numismatic auctioneer of international banknotes, Heritage Auctions has notched some impressive prices realized By Dustin Johnston 42 Cover Story: Collecting Democracy Upcoming election is a great time to discover how political memorabilia can be affordable, rewarding and fun By David Seideman Portrait by William Thomas Cain 51 To Serve and Protect As long as you have the space and right conditions, consider keeping your precious wine collection at home By Debbie Carlson China People’s Republic 10,000 Yuan 1951 (detail) from “Worldly Treasures,” page 36 From left: New Heritage headquarters, page 10; Lou Gehrig, page 21; Peter Lindeman, page 28 Auction Previews Columns 20 28 57 How to Bid Fine Jewelry: The Private World Currency: Hiding in Plain Sight Collection of Peter Lindeman Designers of Seychelles Rupees created one of 21 Artisan looks back on a career brim- hobby’s more popular collectibles with a little Sports Collectibles: ming with exquisite pieces, acco- subliminal assistance Baseball History lades and special friends By Craig
    [Show full text]
  • Early Christian Numismatics and Other Antiquarian Tracts, Charles W
    467. NUMISMATICS. Early Christian Numismatics, and other Antiquarian Tracts. By C. W. King. Illustrated. London, 1873. Svo, cloth, scarce • • • .$3.50 Cornell University Library BR131 .K52 Early Christian numismatics and other a 3 1924 029 242 041 olln Cornell University Library The original of this book is in the Cornell University Library. There are no known copyright restrictions in the United States on the use of the text. http://www.archive.org/details/cu31924029242041 J Jobbms hth ; EARLY CHRISTIAN NUMISMATICS, OTHER ANTIQUARIAN TRACTS. By C. W. |ING, M.A., AUTHOR OP ' ANTIQUE GEMS,' ETC. 1 Csesaris vexilla linquunt, eligunt signum Crucis Proque ventosis draconum quae gerebant palliis, Eligunt insigne lignum quod Draconem subdidit." Prudentius. LONDON: BELL & DALDY, YOKE STEEET, COVENT GABDEN. : LONDON PRINTED BY WILLIAM CLOWES AND SONS, STAMFOKD STREET AKD CHARING C110SS Constantine, decus mundi, lux aurea ssecli, " Quis tua mixta canat mira pietate tropa;a ! Optatian. PREFACE. T^E little treatise which gives its title to the present volume originated in an application made to me by our Regius Professor of Divinity to point out to him any history of the introduction of Christian types upon the Roman coinage. The only book of that nature to which I was able to refer him was Dr. Walsh's brief essay ' On the Coins, &c, illus- trating the Progress of Christianity in the Early Ages/ published so long ago as 1828 ; and which, so far as I have been able' to ascertain, remains the only work in any language that takes for its ex- clusive subject this truly interesting and fertile province of Numismatics.
    [Show full text]
  • The Back Page Numismatics – Geeks Or Greeks
    The Back Page The Back Page will look at topics and items of interest , but from not quite THE RIGHT ANGLE. Numismatics – Geeks or Greeks ? There was much excitement at the last Regular Meeting as a young inexperienced Office-bearer brought down the latest addition to his collection. An Alexander 3rd. coin. It was about the size of a five pence piece and was in quite good condition. Everyone had a look and an opinion as to what it was. Then a member of the Lodge who is a well known collector (of everything) was asked for his opinion. There was a hush in the committee room as he adjusted his glasses and looking at it closely up to the light and announced “ it could be Greek”. Everyone was stunned by his encyclopaedic mind, until the young inexperienced Office-bearer exclaimed, Alas, Alas, Alasdair, “ Alexander the third wasn`t Greek !” He then gave a machine gun speed resume of Alexander the third King of Scots from 1249 to 1286 ! Including his victory at the Battle of Largs in 1263! The Collector was ruffled, who was this new young Geek – who knew his Greeks ? was he right that Alexander wasn`t Greek ? The Collector in reply said that there was a Greek called Alexander, who was this Greek ? was he a Geek ? ..... Darts. Sharpen your tips ……. The Big Contest is back ……. World Championship Darts here on a Friday night …………… Get your name on Inside this issue. the entry sheet. Lodge St. Bryde News. Freemasonry in Serbia Provincial News Homepage- http://www.stbryde.co.uk 8 Serbia.
    [Show full text]
  • E-Newsletter
    Contents International Numismatic 01 The President’s Note 02 Reports from institutions e-Newsletter 04 Congresses and Meetings 08 Research programs 08 Exhibitions 09 Websites 10 New publications INeN 18 - January 2015 17 Personalia 18 Obituaries 20 INC Annual Travel Grant 21 INeN contribute and suscribe The President’s Note - Il saluto del Presidente Dear INC members, dear colleagues and friends, On behalf of the INC I wish you that in these times of polarization on a multitude of issues all a happy and prosperous about cultural property, we can find common ground and New Year! It is an important collaborate to the benefit of numismatics. year for our Council and for the numismatic community The INC Committee will meet in Taormina in March to at large since it is the year make sure that everything will be ready to welcome you in of our XVth International September and make your participation as productive and Congress, which will take pleasant as possible. I also want to thank the Scientific place in Taormina, September and Organizing Committee for all their work: we are in 21-25, 2015. It is, as you a period of recession and economic instability and the know, the most important financing of this Congress is one of the most challenging event for the INC, and its the INC ever had to face. Governments can no longer organization, as well as the afford to be as generous as Spain was in 2003 and offer Dr. Carmen Arnold-Biucchi publication of the Survey of a spectacular Palace of Congresses for free.
    [Show full text]
  • Legacy Knights Numismatic Society 2019-2020 MEMBERSHIP APPLICATION
    Legacy Knights Numismatic Society 2019-2020 MEMBERSHIP APPLICATION STUDENT INFORMATION (ALL INFO IS REQUIRED—PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY): NAME: GRADE: TEACHER or HOMESCHOOL GROUP: MAILING ADDRESS (STREET OR P.O. BOX): CITY/STATE/ZIP: STUDENT EMAIL ADDRESS (REQUIRED*): (LCA STUDENTS, USE YOUR @LEGACYKNIGHTS.ORG ADDRESS) PHONE#: BIRTHDAY (MM/DD/YYYY): ARE YOU A CURRENT OR RECENT MEMBER OF NO THE AMERICAN NUMISMATIC ASSOCIATION? YES -- ANA MEMBER#: EXPIRATION DATE: *If the student has no email address, please supply a regularly-checked parent email address. REQUIREMENTS FOR MEMBERSHIP: 1) A complete, accurate, and legible membership application (this form). 2) $25.00 cash or check payable to “LEGACY CHRISTIAN ACADEMY”. Dues must be paid to participate in activities and earn awards. Dues are non-refundable. 3) Copy of your most recent grade card that has letter grades on it (A’s, B’s, C’s, etc.) NOTE TO GRADE 3 LCA STUDENTS: Letter grades start this year. Please bring in your first quarter grade card when you get it in October. NOTE TO HOMESCHOOL MEMBERS: A signed statement from instructor/parent indicating homeschool status, homeschool group name, and student’s satisfactory completion of requirements will suffice. OUR SOCIETY’S FOUR RULES: 1. HAVE FUN! 2. BE RESPECTFUL! 3. LEARN SOMETHING! 4. SHARE YOUR KNOWLEDGE! Please review and talk about these rules with your parent or guardian on the other side of this page. TRADING RULES (these rules also apply to buying and selling): We want to honor God, our families, our school, and LKNS by maintaining the highest reputation of being honest, honorable, and fair in all our dealings.
    [Show full text]
  • UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT of NEW YORK ---X Universal Grading Service, J
    Case 1:08-cv-03557-CPS-RML Document 66 Filed 06/10/09 Page 1 of 57 PageID #: <pageID> UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK ----------------------------------------X Universal Grading Service, John Callandrello, Joseph Komito and Vadim Kirichenko, individually and on behalf of others similarly situated, Plaintiffs, 08-CV-3557 (CPS) - against - MEMORANDUM OPINION eBay, Inc., American Numismatic AND ORDER Association, Professional Numismatists Guild, Inc., and Barry Stuppler & Company, LLC, Defendants. ----------------------------------------X SIFTON, Senior Judge. Plaintiffs Universal Grading Service (“USG”), John Callandrello, Joseph Komito and Vadim Kirichenko commenced this putative class action1 on August 29, 2008 against defendants eBay, Inc. (“eBay”), American Numismatic Association (“ANA”), Professional Numismatists Guild, Inc. (“PNG”), and Barry Stuppler 1 Plaintiffs describe two putative classes in their Second Amended Complaint (“SAC”). The first class includes “all companies and individuals who provide coin grading services on [sic] the market for coin auctions to the public at large and who have not been certified by eBay as ‘the authorized grading company’ pursuant to eBay’s Counterfeit Currency and Stamps policy and who are interested in pursuing this lawsuit.” SAC ¶ 82. The class period is from January 2004 to the present. Id. ¶ 83. The second class includes “all U.S. based eBay account holders who utilized coin grading services to sell coins on eBay to the public at large which have not been certified by eBay as ‘the authorized grading companies’ pursuant to eBay’s Counterfeit Currency and Stamps policy and who, as a result, have not been able to list their coins on eBay as ‘certified’ and who are interested in pursuing this lawsuit.” Id.
    [Show full text]