Quick viewing(Text Mode)

Habitat Regulations Assessment Revision Consultation Statement

Habitat Regulations Assessment Revision Consultation Statement

Eden Local Plan 2014-32: Habitat Regulations Assessment Revision Consultation Statement

August 2018

1

1. Contents

1 Contents ...... 2 2 Introduction ...... 3 3 The Consultees ...... 4 4 Methods of Consultation ...... 5 5 Schedule of representations made to the Consultation ...... 6 6 Appendices ...... 11

2 2. Introduction

2.1 This document sets out how Council has involved the communities and relevant bodies in the Habitat Regulations Assessment Revision Consultation of the Eden Local Plan The Council has undertaken the procedure pursuant to Regulation 25 of the Town and Country Planning (Local Development) () 2012 Regulations (to be referred to as ‘2012 Regulations’).

2.2 The consultation was undertaken following the recent HRA and People Over Wind, Peter Sweetman v Coiltte Tearata High Court case and subsequent European Court judgement. This CJEU judgement changed the way the Habitats Directive is interpreted and means mitigation measures should now be assessed within the framework of an appropriate assessment. A small number of sites in Penrith take into account mitigation measures at the screening stage, therefore, it has been necessary to re-run the HRA for these sites and undertake an appropriate assessment to consider the mitigation measures, the results of which must be made available for consultation.

2.3 The document shows how the Council has complied with requirements of the 2012 Regulations and how it has undertaken engagement in accordance with the 2012 Regulations, specifically Regulation 22 (1).

2.4 In accordance with the requirements of Regulation 22 of the 2012 Regulations, this document details:

Which bodies and persons the Council invited to make representations under Regulation 18;

How these bodies and persons were invited to make representations under Regulation 18;

If representations were made pursuant to Regulation 20, the number of representations made and a summary of the main issues raised in those representations; and,

If no representations were made in Regulation 20, that no such representations were made.

3 3. The Consultees

3.1 The Town and Country Planning (Local Planning) (England) Regulations 2012 prescribe a number of Consultation Bodies with whom the Council should consult during each stage of the Local Plan making process. The list below identifies the organisations and other bodies that the Council considers to have an interest in the Local Plan process:

 Neighbouring Local Planning authorities;  The Civil Aviation Authority;  The Coal Authority;  Constabulary;  Electricity North West Limited;  Environment Agency;  Health Service Providers;  Highways Agency;  Highways Authority;  Historic England;  Homes and Communities Agency;  Natural England;  Network Rail;  Parish Councils within the District;  The Clinical Commissioning Group;  United Utilities  Other relevant gas, electric, electronic communications network providers (such as Mono). 3.2 The Council maintains a consultation database, which includes the details of those who have registered an interest in the Local Plan and would like to be informed when it is available for consultation. A full list of all those consulted regarding Habitat Regulations Assessment Revision Consultation can be found in Appendix 1.

4 4. Methods of Consultation

4.1 The Council used a variety of consultation methods to disseminate information about the proposed Main Modifications to the Local Plan, in order to be as transparent and inclusive as possible. The methods of communication, in compliance with the Statement of Community Involvement, are set out in the table below.

4.2 Community Engagement Methods

Communication Method Action

Consultation documents Relevant documents were made available for inspection at the Town Hall and Mansion House in Penrith, Local Links in and Alston, and the local libraries.

Eden District Council website The consultation documents and response forms, along with further guidance on completing the forms, were made available for viewing and downloading on the Council’s consultation web page.

A news article was posted on the Council’s website at the start of December 2017 about the upcoming consultation.

E-consultation software An online consultation form using Survey Monkey was made available on the website.

Media/Press Statutory advertisement in & Herald

Letter/emails A letter or an email, according to the preference selected, was sent directly to consultees registered on the consultation database. See Appendix 2 for a copy of the letter. These detailed the dates of the consultation and where the relevant documents could be accessed.

5

5. Schedule of representations made to the Consultation

5.1 Comments received and Eden District Council’s response

Consultee Consultee’s Comments EDC response Historic Historic England is the Government’s statutory adviser on all matters relating to the historic No action required. England environment in England. We are a non-departmental public body established under the National Heritage Act 1983 and sponsored by the Department for Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS). We champion and protect England’s historic places, providing expert advice to local planning authorities, developers, owners and communities to help ensure our historic environment is properly understood, enjoyed and cared for. Thank you for consulting Historic England on the above document. At this stage we have no comments to make on its content.

Natural Thank you for your consultation on the above dated 13 July 2018 which was received by EDC agrees – no England Natural England on 13 July 2018. action required. Natural England is a non-departmental public body. Our statutory purpose is to ensure that the The Penrith Strategic natural environment is conserved, enhanced, and managed for the benefit of present and Masterplan is future generations, thereby contributing to sustainable development. currently a non- We have reviewed the changes to the Habitats Regulations Assessment for Eden Local Plan statutory planning 2014-2032 made as a result of Case C-323/17 People Over Wind v Coillte Teoranta (also document and is not referred to as the Sweetman II Judgement) and make the following comments: relevant to this consultation. The 1. Natural England are satisfied with the approach and structure taken in the revised HRA, Masterplan may form which clarifies where there is a likely significant effect (LSE) upon the River Eden SAC the basis for future and then separately considers how this LSE will be mitigated in the Appropriate statutory planning Assessment. documents and a separate Habitat

6

Consultee Consultee’s Comments EDC response 2. The conclusions reached within the Appropriate Assessment are considered to be Regulations satisfactory, with mitigating Local Plan policies and considerations for project level Assessment will be HRA’s being identified. Natural England consider this mitigation to be sufficient to undertaken for these conclude no likely significant effect upon the River Eden SAC/SSSI at Local Plan level. documents if 3. Natural England were previously engaged in an initial discussion regarding a Penrith necessary. Vision Masterplan (March 2018) which proposed an expansion of Penrith with new housing, employment, open space and road infrastructure. However, beyond this initial discussion we are not aware of any further details. This proposal has not been included within the in-combination assessment of this revised HRA, yet does have the potential to have significant impacts upon designated sites if progressed. Clarity should be provided on the position of this proposal and if being progressed, should be considered at the in-combination stage.

We would be happy to comment further should the need arise but if in the meantime you have any queries please do not hesitate to contact us.

Cumbria I refer to your emailed letter dated 13 July 2018 and the attached Eden District Local Plan - The report does County Habitats Regulations Assessment Revision Final Report (July 2018). Thank you providing come to this Council with the opportunity to respond to your consultation. conclusion, stating I consider that the revised report (sections 1 to 7) comply with the requirements of the Habitats that if the local plan Regulations. policies referred to in the Appropriate However, the conclusions (section 8) require amendment. As noted in the third paragraph of Assessment are 7.2.1, “The approach adopted for this Appropriate Assessment is to focus on avoidance of adhered to then this adverse effects on European site integrity rather than mitigation…” Therefore the conclusion mitigation is ‘sufficient should be amended to state that the full and effective implementation of policies of the Local to prevent an adverse Plan are considered sufficient to ensure that there will be no adverse effect on the features of effect on site the SAC. integrity’. However,

7 Consultee Consultee’s Comments EDC response The full and effective implementation of the local plan policies will ensure that the development EDC has no of the allocated sites (in particular E4 Carleton, Penrith and MPC Skirsgill, Penrith) will avoid objections to any adverse effects on European site integrity. incorporating the Should you require any clarification, please do not hesitate to contact me. suggested wording to add further clarity to the conclusion.

Friends of Many thanks for consulting Friends of the on this. No action required. the Lake On this occasion, we have no comments to make. District

Environment Thank you for consulting the Environment Agency on the changes to the Habitats Regulations No action required. Agency Assessment which forms part of the evidence base to the Eden Local Plan 2014 to 2032. We have no comments to make on these changes.

Marine Response to your consultation EDC agrees – no Management The Marine Management Organisation (MMO) is a non-departmental public body responsible action required. Organisation for the management of England’s marine area on behalf of the UK government. The MMO’s delivery functions are; marine planning, marine licensing, wildlife licensing and enforcement, marine protected area management, marine emergencies, fisheries management and issuing European grants. Marine Licensing Activities taking place below the mean high water mark may require a marine licence in accordance with the Marine and Coastal Access Act (MCAA) 2009. Such activities include the construction, alteration or improvement of any works, dredging, or a deposit or removal of a substance or object below the mean high water springs mark or in any tidal river to the extent of the tidal influence. You can also apply to the MMO for consent under the Electricity Act 1989 (as amended) for offshore generating stations between 1 and 100 megawatts in England

8 Consultee Consultee’s Comments EDC response and parts of . The MMO is also the authority responsible for processing and determining harbour orders in England, and for some ports in Wales, and for granting consent under various local Acts and orders regarding harbours. A wildlife licence is also required for activities that that would affect a UK or European protected marine species. Marine Planning As the marine planning authority for England the MMO is responsible for preparing marine plans for English inshore and offshore waters. At its landward extent, a marine plan will apply up to the mean high water springs mark, which includes the tidal extent of any rivers. As marine plan boundaries extend up to the level of the mean high water spring tides mark, there will be an overlap with terrestrial plans which generally extend to the mean low water springs mark. Marine plans will inform and guide decision makers on development in marine and coastal areas. On 2 April 2014 the East Inshore and Offshore marine plans were published, becoming a material consideration for public authorities with decision making functions. The East Inshore and East Offshore Marine Plans cover the coast and seas from Flamborough Head to Felixstowe. For further information on how to apply the East Inshore and Offshore Plans please visit our Marine Information System. The MMO is currently in the process of developing marine plans for the South Inshore and Offshore Plan Areas and has a requirement to develop plans for the remaining 7 marine plan areas by 2021. Planning documents for areas with a coastal influence may wish to make reference to the MMO’s licensing requirements and any relevant marine plans to ensure that necessary regulations are adhered to. For marine and coastal areas where a marine plan is not currently in place, we advise local authorities to refer to the Marine Policy Statement for guidance on any planning activity that includes a section of coastline or tidal river. All public authorities taking authorisation or enforcement decisions that affect or might affect the UK marine area must do so in accordance with the Marine and Coastal Access Act and the UK Marine Policy Statement unless relevant considerations indicate otherwise. Local authorities may also wish to refer to our online guidance and the Planning Advisory Service soundness self-assessment checklist.

9 Consultee Consultee’s Comments EDC response Minerals and waste plans and local aggregate assessments If you are consulting on a mineral/waste plan or local aggregate assessment, the MMO recommend reference to marine aggregates is included and reference to be made to the documents below: The Marine Policy Statement (MPS), section 3.5 which highlights the importance of marine aggregates and its supply to England’s (and the UK) construction industry. The National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) which sets out policies for national (England) construction minerals supply. The Managed Aggregate Supply System (MASS) which includes specific references to the role of marine aggregates in the wider portfolio of supply. The National and regional guidelines for aggregates provision in England 2005-2020 predict likely aggregate demand over this period including marine supply. The NPPF informed MASS guidance requires local mineral planning authorities to prepare Local Aggregate Assessments, these assessments have to consider the opportunities and constraints of all mineral supplies into their planning regions – including marine. This means that even land-locked counties, may have to consider the role that marine sourced supplies (delivered by rail or river) play – particularly where land based resources are becoming increasingly constrained.

10

6. Appendices

11

6.1 Appendix 1 – List of consultees

Title Surname First name Organisation Gooch S Fairhurst Bennett D Mr Lowis N D L B W Associates The Occupier Reed D & M Mr Wharton K J R Wharton and Sons Lawson Kimberley Ainstable Parish Council Mr Nigel Vear Ainstable Parish Council Lawson H Mr Henry Jonathon Miss Mills Zoe Dr Tench Ian Miss Woof I Mr Kerrigan Kevin Borough Council Mrs Johnson Chris Alston Moor Parish Council Miss Dodgeon Caroline Appleby Town Council Preston Stephen Bishop H C and S G Noble Anna Turley Associates Limited Mr Hardt R Hope J Bain Dennis Mrs Askins I E Hogg Peter Thorburn Alison Cater A Young M Neill A & S White L Mr Barnes Christian Asby Parish Council Larkin Sue The Reverend Elliott Ian & Veronica and Mrs Hird J & P Mrs Wright Marion Mr Newbury B Mr Jessop R Roger Jessop Planning Consultants Mr Marsh Steven Marsh Fiona and Steven Mrs Sheppard Margaret Mrs whitehead laura Mr Ladhams T Bainbridge J The Open Spaces Society

12 Title Surname First name Organisation Staude D Mr and Mrs Snaith D K Bellas Caroline Barr Debbie Castle V & C Mr Park P Mrs Stevens J Allison R.E. The Occupiers Craig D Thompson June Turley Associates Mr Eyles M Save our Woodland Heritage Robson Julie Wood Denise Mr and Mrs Harrison K Abbeyfield Society Souter C & B Mr Connell S Talk Talk Robertson Martine Woof A Mr Oldham D Campion Joe Mullett K & G Perry M & A Duckworth Becky Mrs Smurthwaite J Dent / Clarke Katy / Robert Mr Parkinson I W Patkinson Signs Mrs Bowen K Cumbria Council for Voluntary Service Mr Bodger J John Bodger Associates The Occupiers The Occupiers Morrison Janet Tunstall J & L Gibson Christine Lambert G and E Westgarth A & S Walker S The Occupier Mr Hughes Rod 2030 Architects Ltd Mr Bodger John 2030 Architects Ltd Mr Cresswell Peter Mr Searle P D Savage P

13 Title Surname First name Organisation Callan/Brown C & C Weighman J & W Mr Borgogno A Birbeck Elizabeth Strange M Leon Valerie Hill Jenny Nathaniel Lichfield and Partners Mills Jan Hawker Margaret The Occupiers Luck L, B, T & D Mr Gibson J & C Atkinson J Mr Godwin J Mrs Drinkwater Marion Askham Parish Council Mrs Drinkwater Marion Bampton Parish Council Barbara Daniel Roger Butterfield & Clarke E & A Hopkins B & M Leroux L Creighton K & N Mr & Mrs Banks Mrs Dent Sarah Friends of Pategill Backfield Dent C & J Nelson S & J Mr and Mrs Jones D The Occupiers Page G Mr & Mrs Watkin Mr and Mrs Lockley Modlin K & M Northgraves Peter Deborah Fothergill Karen Walker S Scarr MW & CM Betts Jackie Eatock A & L Arneil Erica Parklands Neighbourhood Watch Association Mr Kelly Rachael Bandleyside Parish Council Stone Margaret Mrs Smith Irene Szpak/Pietruszekski A & L Blacklock Susie

14 Title Surname First name Organisation Mr Mitchell D Barton Willmore Lowney R & A Mr Thwaytes L Thwaytes Chartered Surveyors - Mr L Thwaytes Teasdale Mary Williams Stephen McWhirter A & H McWhirter Andrew Mr Tunstall Paul JWPC Chartered Planners Mr Willis Alex BNP Paribas Real Estate UK Mrs Mackey Gill Barton Parish Council Luck Malcolm Mr and Mrs Dawes P M and A Mr and Mrs Ellis Mrs Cross J Mrs Allen P Mrs Forster Mavis Reed J & W Mrs Winder H Bradley Susan Barker Diane Mrs Dean Kirkland Karon The White Ox Partnership Tiffin F & E Jenkinson P & K Mr Willett Rick Richardson V Walton and Co Scott D and J Mrs Cooper H M Leyland Shelagh Bolton Parish Council Mrs Hack Myrtha Bennett G F Mrs Wheatley J Mr and Mrs Grinbergs Mr Armstrong G Woof Rowland and Rachel Hinton F R and D A Robinson A Mr Fox Richard Fox Belinda Wardle R.L. & A Wilson B & S Mr Taylor P & E Mrs Morrison M S Mr Bell T

15 Title Surname First name Organisation Mr Castle Matthew Castle Charlotte Brockbank C Capstick G Riley J & B Mrs Overfield H Bowes Parish Council Watson R & A Ivinson Julie Garner Donna Austin E & D Watson Peter Hannah S The Occupiers Dowson S and I Walton D Mr and Mrs Glendinning Mrs Greenwood K Mr Bousfield L Mrs Davies Marita Dobson G.D. The Occupiers Turnbull D MacKenzie Valerie Mr Digby M J Wilcox C, E & K Mr Frost Graham McIntosh Emily Gibson M & J Boustead Anne Cook Elizabeth Miss Boylan L J Ms Sandell Ann Hadland Jennifer Savills Smiths Gore Mr and Mrs Wright R and E Dent Audrey Richardson B & A Mrs Simpson A Mr Wilson I S Rudd J Mrs Collis Christina Brough Parish Council Collis Christina Kirkup Sarah Brough Sowerby Parish Meeting Mrs Jennings Janet Brougham Parish Council Smith Simon Caldbeck Parish Council

16 Title Surname First name Organisation Ms Crozier J Carlatton & Parish Council City Council Ms Meynell T Castle Carrock Parish Council Mrs Kelly R E Castle Sowerby Parish Council Mr Barbour Frank Catterlen Parish Council Rose Duncan Rose Sarah Batey William and Anne Mr Ward A M Mather Jamie Cash J Mrs Nicholas C E Slee G Denwood Greg Two Castles Housing Association Mr Markey P D Harrison Edna Civil Aviation Authority Bainbridge T Knight Timothy Mr Woodman J Parklands Neighbourhood Watch Association Woodman J Mrs Woodman J Stoddart Edna Edmondson S & K Dowes Elisabeth Stammer Tom / Trudy Mr Wilson G Mr Sission M Carruthers & M & J Faulder Mr Argyll S Mrs Kelly Rachael Cliburn Parish Meeting Musgrove B.R. Mrs Tomlin Parklands Neighbourhood Watch Association Mr Kenyon Ronald Mrs Kelly Rachael Clifton Parish Council Chappelhow Jason Mr and Mrs Banks McNally/Vernon S & D Mrs Graham E M

17 Title Surname First name Organisation Feighan N Parklands Neighbourhood Watch Association Elaine Rigby Architects Atkinson Arthur Wannop H & J Bennett J Alderson Adrian Bryce Caroline Cannon David Ms Mashiter Judith Cotherstone Parish Council Alderson S McKeever Shirley Mrs Gunston Bridget Gallagher/Smallman D & D.J. Murray A & G Labram M & A Mr Mitchell Oliver Planware LTD Sheen Geoffrey Mr Dalton M W Potts Doris Bibby G & A Mr Addis C Mr Artiss Simon Barratt Homes Mason C J Mrs Rayworth N Simpson Tina Mrs Kelly L Crackenthorpe Parish Meeting Mr Hughes N Mr Keogh Stephen Keogh Helen Mr Cole D Mr Metcalfe-Gibson R Tuck L Croud W.J. Hamer D Miss Brown Rachel Centre for Public Health Elizabeth Metcalfe Joanne Mr and Mrs Lea Campbell K.S. Sandamas Mark Hall Jayne Bateman J Bateman Engineering Mr Saunders Stuart Crosby Garrett Parish Meeting Mr and Mrs Ewin R C

18 Title Surname First name Organisation Mr Holliday R C The Occupier Hodgson Hayley Messrs Dudson c/o Swarbrick Associates Mr Swarbrick D Swarbrick Associates Chartered Architects Mrs Little W Hogg Alex The Occupiers Howarth S & B Howarth Matthew Dargue Ethan Barnes Christian Crosby Ravensworth Parish Council Fleming John Culgaith Parish Council Mr Hunton Andrew Currie Richard Mr Buckle Keith The White Ox Partnership Cole J Dixon/O'Mara R & C Annette De Pol Associates Mrs Gradwell M B Mrs Dowson V Baines E & L Tompkins John Impact Housing Assocation Cumbria Constabulary Mr Bulman Hodgson Elaine Mr McGlasson D W Mrs McGlasson Kathleen Wilson T Atric Ltd Mr Ellwood D Mr and Mrs Edwards H M and M G Mr McQueen F Mr and Mrs Gibson I M Bennett S Bennett Thomas Gowling Margaret The Occupiers Mr Rawle David Cumbria County Council Mr Exton Graham Mr Daldry T Mr Wilson David Marston Amelia Childerley S

19 Title Surname First name Organisation Alderson R.B. & K.P. Mrs Jackson C Thompson and Joanna and Thornton Mark Mr Marshall J M Mrs Winter E Parsons Andrew Rev. & Mrs Radford Stephen Radford Heather Yare Lynn Hastwell G & A Smaile Rebekah Slessor M & J Hill S Mr Gibson I Ian Gibson Architecture Ltd Mitchell L Mr Capstick D B Lee A Coleman- T & J Kernan/Kernan McGuire Gillian Mr Parsons Jeremy Cumbria County Council Dixon G Ms Taylor H Whitehead K and C Simpson Pamela and Charles Mrs Sisson R Beckwith K & M Maughan C Walker A & L Haslam Angela Gates P Mortimer Rebecca Hennigan/Collin C & D Mr Game Chris Sorek Elaine Mrs Bowling B Hastwell William Mr Claxton J D Burnetts Solicitors Dent J & M Barker Alan Varty B, R & J Park M Rogerson A & H Reay L Graham Janice

20 Title Surname First name Organisation Mandale Dan Harris J & G Miss Walton J Mrs Alderson J Mr Mellor J Mr George Dennis George Susan Mr and Mrs Deall A M Firth W M and E Deighton Pete Boyd Jo Buchan Cherisse Jura Consultants Barker J & S Parkin Craig Cumbria County Council Mr Best M Slee John Mrs Beck S Thorn W A D Collins Stan Mr Tomlinson J Mrs Holmes P Cumbria County Council Humphreys Alison Mrs Clement M Rawlins W & L Ross Laura Dev Plan Ross Laura Stewart Ross Associates Glasby E The Occupier Mrs Reed J.F. Brown S South Yvonne Beverley Leanne Cumbria County Council Ms Diamond Julie Taylor & Hardy Ltd Reay D Cumbria Disability Network Darke S & D Donnelly Allen Thompson K & M Tyler Peter Hatfield/Young P & J Bakey Tracy Robinson Y Nelson Julie Hindson J Smithson Laura

21 Title Surname First name Organisation Benson C & H Bainbridge Geoffrey Oliver C Mr Burns J Development Planning Partnership Mr and Mrs Blackamore D Mr Winter P PFK Planning Simons Barry NFU (North West) Little Helen National Farmers Union Mr Harrison S Reserve Forces and Cadets Association Mr and Mrs Richardson Mrs Hubbard J Jennifer Hubbard Planning Consultants Mr Ecroyd C Cumbria Local Access Forum Cumbria Local Enterprise Partnership Mr Bendelow Carl Appleby Rural Growth Network Hub Rush J Mrs Wilson Barbara Holder A Taylor Susan School Mr Shuker P White Young Green Planning Boyd G Mr Williamson Nicholas Mr Williamson Nicholas Barlow Janet Paul R Blues Anne Mr Bullard P Cumbria Wildlife Trust Mr Williams David Upper Eden History Society Dr Williams D Cumiskey / Leaver Patricia / Malcolm Mrs Warburton T Day Guy Mr Carlyle D Walton Val Mr Scott S Mollinson Constance A Geer Jennifer Thompson C.J. Professor Baker Gus A

22 Title Surname First name Organisation Professor Jacoby Ann Mr and Mrs Knight A Barr H C and M R Mr Forster C Mr Forster A J A J Forster Limited Jenkin M & C Mr & Mrs Peebles Brown D & E Mr Metcalfe Tony Metcalfe A E Mr Harvey Edward CBRE Ltd Planning Ms Crozier J Parish Council Mr Sharrock David Capstick David Mr MacInnes M MMI Ltd Mr Parsons J JMP Consulting Stamper J K Hardcastle W B Carter Becx Dacre Parish Council Mrs Howland-Davenport Davenport Peter Dr Leslie Danette Ms Milburn S Dalston Parish Council Foster Jill Mr Metcalfe D Shap Wells Developments Mrs Chappell K Mr and Mrs Abbott Mr and Mrs Beattie Hunter Joyce Mr Storey W Mr and Mrs Wilkin C Breaks S Kelso T G Mr Thompson P Mr Askew J D Mrs Watson Sandie Dufton Parish Council Mr and Mrs Balmer N Lowthian S M Mr Ford C CycleActive CH2M HILL McWhirter Janice Mr and Mrs Morris H Morris Judith Mr Raven J Edwin Thompsons Mr Mandle I NFU (North Cumbria) Hendersons Garage Ltd Mr Cairns M

23 Title Surname First name Organisation Field Rebecca Eden Housing Association Mr Hill James Trustees of Mrs E Guthrie 91 Settlement The National Federation of Gypsy Liaison Groups (NFGLG) Mr Parker R Shepherd Estate Durham County Council Messers Buckle & Whitehead Mr Walton F H Eden Access Forum Mr Fawcett LLB J Electricity North West Merrie C Mr and Mrs Little J Mr Hoyle A Mr Pearson David Charles Cumbrian Homes Barbour Alexandra Brooker Katherine DTZ Blackburn Lynda / Richard Blackburn R Coulthard A and M N Ms Lancaster Victoria Prime Mr Ainscough P HIMOR Group Mr Shreeve S HIMOR Group Wilkinson Chris Mrs Burton Sandra Morland A W Mr Trimmer K J Johnson Jennifer Bull JC & TM Mrs Shaw S Mr Staines S FFT Planning (Friends, Families and Travellers ad Traveller Law Reform Project) Mr and Mrs McFarlane J Environment Agency Capstick M Mrs Toward K A Forest and Frith Parish Council Mr Johns P Garsdale Parish Council Mr Taylor P Allen J W

24 Title Surname First name Organisation Coulthard R A Dr Insch O.B.E E Ockenden Eleanor Miss Wilson Pamela Glassonby Parish Council Gowling J Harker A B Airey Diane Mr Bonsall P The Fat Lamb Country Inn and Restaurant Parsons D & S Mr Dudson K G K G Dudson Builders Ms Lewis Rebecca Grayrigg Parish Meeting Mr Neale Terence Ms Lytollis Rachel Great Salkeld Parish Council Mr and Mrs Turvey A Ms Harrison Katinka Mr Meek Alasdair Newton Catherine Bell Ingram Design Limited C/o Ms Newton C Essar Oil UK Grainger W & H Mr and Mrs Scott K W and J A Penrith Residents Holliday J and C Mr and Mrs Whitehead Mr and Mrs Bell K Mr and Currah W

Mr and Mrs Miss Elliott Susan Gubbins Victor Mrs O'Dwyer Norma CAFS Mr Bachem J P Mrs Taylor J A Mrs Tupling R Great Strickland Parish Council Traverse-Healey Nichola Barton Willmore LLP Mrs Kelly Rachael Greystoke Parish Council Mrs Payne Kathy Hartley Parish Meeting Mr Crook S J Crook Cheryl Mr Bell Robin J Mr Bell R J Langley Mr and Mrs Dottridge S and A Mrs Potter D Mr Scott Nigel N Arnison & Sons Ltd

25 Title Surname First name Organisation Mrs Mason J E Mrs Newcombe P Mr Tonkin M Cartwright Francesca Hawes and High Abbotside Parish Council Mrs Hayllar C Helbeck Parish Meeting Grundy G and B Mrs Trimmer K M Cold Keld Guided Walking Holidays Freeman Amee Hesket Parish Council Highways England Mr Dixon D Atkins G Dougherty J Irving E Begg Jon / Jennifer Berry Anne Hrycan Emily Historic England Payne Kathy NHS Property Metcalfe-Gibson C and A Jackson F & O Mr & Mrs Lewis/Eyre P & E Mr Johnstone Keith Mrs Osman D Appleby in Westmorland Society Dr Willshaw Kate Friends of the Lake District Historic England Mr Holdstock D Entec UK Ltd Mr Hewison A Mrs Wharton Armstrong Joan Seip Ann Homes and Communities Agency Mr Crowe A Nathaniel Lichfield and Partners Forestry Commission NW England Mr and Mrs Guthrie J Cousin I R Mrs Iceton C Hunderthwaite Parish Council Mr Waters K Adlington Planning Team Mr and Mrs Smith D C Mr Tomlinson D J Mrs Teasdale Helen Hunsonby Parish Council Jones Ian Hutton Parish Council

26 Title Surname First name Organisation Mr and Mrs Nicholson B Rev'd and Mrs Findlayson Walton B Mr Duckett Louise Kaber Parish Meeting Hopkins W and B Mr Lansberry Peter Parish Meeting Mr Addison R I King's Meaburn Parish Meeting Mr & Mrs Birnie C Mr and Mrs Linsday J M Renewable UK Mr and Mrs Irving W Barnes Christian Kirkby Stephen Town Council Mr Bell Jonathon Harrison Tatiana Ms Wheatley Diane Howarth Aimee Mr Raschen Bill Hanover Housing Association Hartley I & J Mr Thompson M Mrs Sinclair D Cook E Mr Ward B Mrs Hughes J & M Ms Nicholson Lindsay Kirkby Thore Parish Council Mr Exeter J Ms Lytollis Rachel Kirkoswald Parish Council Miss Walton E Knaresdale with Kirkhaugh Parish Council Thompson J Mr Binney S Mr Pattison Richard Lake District National Park Mr and Mrs Howie Mr Nattrass D Mr Johnson M Lakes Parish Council Mrs George M Ostle T.L. & P.J. Nielsens Ltd Mr Dunne J Woodlands Trust Robinson P and F E Mossman G K Mr Allan F Mr Fleming John Parish Council

27 Title Surname First name Organisation Mr Jerred I C Lartington Parish Council Mrs Taylor M.H. Ms Wyatt Rebecca Lazonby Parish Council Higgs S and E Mr Robinson David Robinson Audrey Mr Robinson Alan Mr Robinson D Robinson Rosalind Walker Majorie Parish Meeting Harding Joanne Home Builders Federation Messrs Buckle Messrs Buckle Mr Thompson P The Planning Bureau Limited Mr Todd Adrian Mr Stewart Rory Penrith and The Border Wear E J and N A Mr Calvert M H Mr Harrison Norman Mrs McQue Local Nature Partnership Dalton L and M Dixon Pauline Parish Council Mr Hall Robin Mr Harper A T Mayne Louise / Alistair S.M. Tod Mr Irving M Punch Taverns Mr and Mrs McHugh T Mrs Singleton A Mr Sharp Richard Longsleddale Parish Meeting Mr and Mrs Pratt John and Hazel Ewan / Allcock E / M Mr Collinson I Mr Woof T Upper Eden Community Plan Miss Dolan Jane Miss Dolan Jane Mrs Kirkbride Littlefair Barry and Sandra Mr Ratledge Martin Mrs Ratledge C

28 Title Surname First name Organisation Bowman Patrick Mr Wellock M Kirkwells - town planning and sustainable development consultants Mr Leece JC Lowther Parish Council Mr Jerred I C Lunedale Parish Council Godfrey P M Mr Williams T Miller Homes Limited - Yorkshire Chambers Agnes Mr and Mrs Brennand G H Gregson A & A Plowright Georgina Hartbrights Potter Alan Mr Lancaster W J Mr and Mrs Cleasby Messrs Cleasby M Thompson Lauren Tesni Properties Limited Dr Lindley Bryan C formerly President Penrith Civic Society Dr Heyworth Judith A Metcalf / Paterson Dot / Dave Mr Prentince John Mallerstang Parish Meeting Mrs Haygarth Melanie Allen Antonia Marine Management Organisation Mrs Halsall Chrissie Mr Halsall Joe Capstick Daniel Mr Davis A Davis J A Banister Nicola Mr and Mrs Young Mr Sutton K Mr and Mrs Moore P J Middleton A Sweeney M C Mr and Mrs Scobie-Youngs Mr Shepherd Charlie Penrith Ramblers Mr and Mrs Binks C Mr Ross A The Lowther Estates Mr M Brimmer Martindale Parish Meeting Turner Rosemary Mrs Capstick E Davey B M

29 Title Surname First name Organisation Capstick G Capstick Alison Northern Trust Mrs Atkinson M E Mr Hurford David Hurford Christine Mr Brown D Matterdale Parish Council Mrs Perry J Friends of the Earth Rose Michael Mr and Mrs Morris D W and C A Botterill Elizabeth Mr Willison-Holt A Holt Planning Consultancy Mr and Mrs Wilson F W Mrs Newsham M P Mrs Towler K Mickleton Parish Council Mr Brass D Lakeland Eggs Co. Mr & Mrs Cartmell Mrs Connelly Joan Milburn Parish Council Hill C Cowperthwaite R A Mr Walters R Mrs Huck J Mrs Oliver J M Mr Nicholson M Russell Armer Ltd Mr Turnbull Irvine Ministry of Defence Wilson Carolyn Mobile Operators Assocation, c/o Mono Consultants Limited Mr Cleasby Richard Birbeck Mary Mrs Runkee Andrea Morland Parish Council Tinn Christine Smith Diana Mr Miles A Sustrans Alison Stringer Nick Turner & Muker Parish Council Flemming Christine Mungrisdale Parish Council Mr Hatt John Mr Walker Myles Mr Longworth Nigel Eden Cycle Campaign Major Sawrey-Cookson H Blue J John Coward Architects Ltd Mr Mellon D C Mr Stafford Samuel GVA Grimley Limited Watson June Murton Parish Council

30 Title Surname First name Organisation Mr Stock P North Country Home Group Limited Ilett D Middleton Sarah Nateby Parish Meeting Mrs Papaleo Sarah Taylor & Hardy Ltd S Mansbridge National Grid Action with Communities Cumbria Hassan Alla PlanInfo Duckworth Jean Turner M & T McCarthy W and J Natural England Mr Bendelow C Goode Max Carter Jonas Mr Sandwith F King Sturge LLP Mr and Mrs Baglee K and M Foster Joyce Mrs Balmer J R Clarke Diane Network Rail Mrs Cherry P A Mr Reed C Mr Shannon Stephen Sim/Cook S & N Mr Claxton D Cumbria Association of Local Councils Mr Walker James Newbiggin Parish Meeting Lancaster Kayleigh PFK Mrs Hancock M Newby Parish Meeting Mr McGovern Mark SSA Planning Limited Equality Cumbria Mrs Mackey J Eusemere Farm House Mr Birkett Frank NHS North Cumbria Clinical Commissioning Group Page R, C & D Mr and Mrs Harrison A & M Mr Copper Neill Mr Cope J Littlefair A W Marsh Stuart and Diane Mr Tatters A J Mr Harper P E Mr Ashwin Mike River Eden & District Fisheries Association

31 Title Surname First name Organisation Mr and Mrs Tunstall W Golden M and M Whitfield Lee Richter Mark Mrs Dixon Simpson Amanda Mrs Nicol B J Littlewood R Mr Noblett H Mr Ennion M North Yorkshire County Council Auty J McIldowie S Webb Nicola Hogg & Robinson (Builders) Ltd Miss Farley S Dent Colin Handley Abbie Hodgson A J and A M Fripp D.C. Mr Naples Rob County Council Mr and Ms Grice and Mills J and Z Ms Jennings R L Concept Town Planning Ltd Cooper R Majewski S Mr Tarn A Walkingshaw L Mr and Mrs Hexter P Mr and Mrs Richardson P Young C & S Mr Tolmie Peter Peter Tolmie Ltd Mr and Mrs Allan M and L Mr and Mrs Moore N Northumberland County Council Mr Crawford Lee Persimmon Homes PLC Mr and Mrs Stiles J B and M J Sadler Ian Constantine C Colonel Sewell W A Mr Addis Frank Mrs Addis Julie Mrs Gallagher M H Mr Winter G C Philip

32 Title Surname First name Organisation Mr Thompson B Heart of Eden Community Plan Simpson Joyce Holliday S J Mr Heath J Mrs Longworth M Orton Parish Council Heap Stephen Ousby Parish Council Hodgson G Mr & Mrs Gate D Johnson Michael Patterdale Parish Council Mr and Mrs Ball T Mr and Mrs Jenkinson H C and J Appleby Heritage and Training Centre Robertson Sara Mrs Walton E Miss Clark J Chalmers R F Law Mary J Mr Bashall William William Bashall Associates Mr Garner Chris Garner Planning Associates Mr Hodgson M & R Mr Butterfield S Mr & Mrs Sharp John & Kaite Mr Bailey Nick Manning Elliott Mr Walker M Peacock and Smith Mr Miller Dave North Associates Limited Wright J A S Conway D T Mr Ratcliffe J Mrs Witney A Relph T H Bradney J R River Eden and District Fisheries Association and Yorkshire Fly Fisher's Club Mr Mullen D Cross S and C Derbyshire J Mr Harris Will Mr Cockcroft T M Ewbank C Mrs Tunnadine Viv Penrith Town Council Mr Price D Cable and Wireless Fermer Steve and Val Pattinson Neal Pattinson Hayley Cattermole Judith

33 Title Surname First name Organisation Ms Bond J Taylor Wimpey Strategic Land Mr Thorley A Taylor Wimpey UK Limited Dinnes Louise Ast Signs Union Pub Company Appleby Chamber of Trade Ms Folkard Louise Alston Moor Business Association Mr Gray B M Mr Armstrong-Payne Bruce Bruce Armstrong-Payne Planning Consultant Savage Joan Kirkman Anna Dr and Mrs Taylor M Miss Johnston J Plenmeller with Whitfield Parish Council Mr Elphick Chris Parish Council Godfrey L & D Diggle Claire Hodgson J & S Mr and Mrs Bagot R V Fenwick Ann and Alf Richmondshire District Council Bland Gilpin Mr Thompson T Newton Christine Mr and Mrs Hall J Mrs Parsler J A SOLAR (Save Our Land and Resources) Mrs Horn E Mrs Clement A Mr and Mrs Naylor D Ms Fee Jacquelyn Mono Consultants Ltd Mr Fisher M The Lawn Tennis Association Allison K Kelly Rachael Sebergham Parish Council Mrs Stephenson Young T J.J. Latimer Ltd Mr Hutchinson P Mr Stopford A Mr Martin John Mr Martin J Mr Bell M

34 Title Surname First name Organisation Mr and Mrs Harnwell S R Mr Gill Richard Mr & Mrs Bird Mr and Mrs Kilduff Appleby Alliance Mr Smart Ian IPS Architects Mr Taylor R Ian Basely Associates Ms Hassam J Parish Council Mr and Mrs Raine D Kidd Sylvia Mr Tailford R P Wilding I & W Dr and Mrs Gravil R Scott L Warburg W E Mrs Scott-Smith Jean Shap Parish Council Mrs Johnson C Alston Moor Partnership Dickie R O Nicholson David and Wendy Mr Metcalfe-Gibson M Hilland S & P Rapleys LLP Mrs Kelly Rachael Skelton Parish Council Mr Holliday J Mr Bagshaw C Countryside Consultants Mr Monkhouse G Mr McGuffie R Mr Wyatt M JWPC Limited Graham K Norman (Architect) Ltd S P Dobinson Building & Machinery Barton Hollie NJL Consulting Mr and Mrs Thornborrow J Harvey Margaret Sheppard R and A Edwards Antony Sleagill Parish Council Mason F Finnie M Cropley Brian and Catherine Mr Woodley-Stewart C North AONB Partnership Mr & Mrs Higgins Tonkin Lucy Sleagill Parish Council

35 Title Surname First name Organisation Mr and Mrs Hamlin J G Tidbury Wade Tidbury Fiona Mr and Mrs Weymouth R J Mrs Kelly Rachael Sockbridge and Tirril Parish Council Mr Bryan M Fennell Caroline Soulby Parish Council Mrs Godber A Buckle Iris The White Ox Partnership Buckle I E Dudson S and L J Bentley B Wilkinson John and Brenda Mr Connell S Penrith Congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses Mr and Mrs Szabo K I Mr Thomas D J Mr Swan D Mrs Ewbank P Mr Atchinson D Callaghan Jane Mr and Mrs Scott W F and A Methodist Homes for the Aged Downs A G Mr and Mrs Squires Grant Matthew White Young Green Hastwell Thomas Dr and Mrs Ainsworth G and S District Council Sport England Stephen Sarah Harvey Sarah Mr Richmond A Cumbria Army Cadet Force Abacus Building Design ADK Architects Broatch Hazel St Cuthbert Without Parish Council Appleby History Archaeological Society Architects Plus Architectural Design & Planning Ltd - Mr C Reed Ashton Design

36 Title Surname First name Organisation Turner Barry Atkinson Builders Atkinson Building Contractors AWAZ Cumbria Barden Brian Barden Planning Consultants Bingham Yates & Partners Black Box Architects Ltd Blackett-Ord Conservation Architecture Brier Associates Brooke Planning Consultants Mr & Mrs Lowrey J c/o Garner Planning Ms Carter Becx St Johns Castlerigg & Wythburn Parish Council Carrock Design & Build Church Commissioners for England Mrs Sinclair M E Stainmore Parish Council Percy Andrew Cumberland Building Society Mrs Anderson S Stanhope Parish Council Mrs Longworth M Tebay Parish Council Fennel Caroline Parish Council Ms Lindsley Melanie The Coal Authority Mr Anthony Ross The Theatres Trust Rose Sarah Cumbria Woodlands Edwards S Cumbrian Homes Damson Design Ltd. Day Cummins Ltd. Smith Nicholas District Estates District Estates Ltd Mrs Kelly Rachael Threlkeld Parish Council Carter Becx Underskiddaw Parish Council Eden Architecture: Environmental Design Eden Rivers Trust Eden Valley Railway Trust Edenholme Building & Architectural Surveyors Edwin Thompson Edwin Thompson - Carlisle Gaskell Gemma United Utilities United Utilities

37 Title Surname First name Organisation English Wes Esh Group Foskett Hylton G K D G R Architects Gray Associates Limited H & H Land & Property Ltd Cairns Mark and Paul Mr Sherratt David United Utilities Brailey Elsa Home Group Lees Rosemarie Parish Meeting Mr Hourigan M Hourigan Connolly Ian Cleasby Drafting & Design Willmott Anne-Marie Impact Housing Association JABA Architect Ltd Jock Gordon John Westgarth Howard Anna Johnby Hall Estate Johnston & Wright KDS Mondino Frank Keepmoat Mrs Strong H Parish Council Moffat Richard Lambert Smith Hampton Mr Gordon Malcolm Lazonby Neighbourhood Plan Steering Group Mrs Ingman B West Allen Parish Council Gibson Wendy Lovell Homes M Archer - Eden Architecture Environmental Design Manning Ellliot Architects Martin Boyd Architectural Services Martin Cuthell Ltd Martin Wainhouse Mr Buckingham Stephen Michael CL Hodgson Mrs Tarrant S Parish Council MJN Associates ML Planning Services Ltd. Hall Ginny Mono Consultants Burns Monica National Housing Federation Mrs Trusler E Wharton Parish Meeting Mr Handley John Whinfell Parish Meeting Mrs Johnstone Linda Winton Parish Meeting Davies Gill Oakmere Homes OutREACH Cumbria

38 Title Surname First name Organisation Mr Pallister John PallisterCo Ltd Fazal Amyn Penrith Building Society Cunningham Kate Penrith Chamber of Trade and Commerce Graham Rachael Persimmon Homes Lancashire Planning Branch Ltd. Mrs Jones A Planning Branch Ltd. Planware Lightfoot Rachel Positive Planning Solutions Richard Dryell Architect Yorkshire Dales National Park Brough Gillian Riverside Housing Association Morgan Andy Rowland Royal Mail Group Mr Sutton J RSPB Sainsbury's Supermarkets Savills Smiths Gore Sign Solutions Councillor Hughes Neil Space Designed Solutions Ltd. Stephen Crichton Chartered Architect Ltd Mr Tonge H Steven Abbott Associates Steven Abbott Associates Story Homes Barton Daniel Story Homes Storey Ian Story Homes Mr Taylor Bob Taylor and Hardy Ltd Mr Asplin John Time and Tide Tweddell & Slater Consulting Engineers Fuller Jeanette Two Castles Housing Association TWT Projects Councillor Fearon Helen Unwin Jones Partnership Upper Eden History Society Councillor Carrick Hilary Mr Palmer Adrian Mr Parr David Mr Fox Alan Mr Robertson Alastair Mr Alastair Davis

39 Title Surname First name Organisation Mr Elphick C Landowner Mrs Allen M Allison Peter Aplin Mark Armstrong Susan Mr Armstrong Thomas Arnold Ruth Atkinson Carol Atkinson Kenneth Atkinson Chloe Mr Atkinson S Bailie Lucy Bainbridge Sam Bainbridge Janette Bainbridge Eva Bainbridge Poppy Baker Michael Baker Andrew Banks Robinson Banks Gwen Barbour David Bateman Pauline Baxter John Bell Kath Bell David Bellis Howard Bennett Charles Bohling Sally and Michael Bonsor Kenneth Mr Borgogno Anthony Borrowdale Ian Bowie Stuart Bridge Glenn Bromley Andrew Bromley Rona Brooks Jennifer Brooks Leah Patricia Brooks Paul Herbert Brooks Stella Patricia Brown Roger Brown Marian Brown Adrian Brown Rachel Bulman Iona Burton Nigel

40 Title Surname First name Organisation Butler Clare Campbell George Cann Johnson Carrier Michael Carter T.A Carter A.L. Carter Andrew Carter Alan Carter Melanie Carter Wendy Carter Alan Duncan Chamberlain Christine Chamberlin David Clarke Emma Cleave Margaret Cleave Richard Clifford Carol Coates Edward Colborn David Cole Bernard Collier Dawn Cowan Edna Crossley Steve Cumpstey Joan Cuthell Stuart Cuthell Sherolyn Cuthell Duncan Daltrey Irene Daltrey Alan Davidson Barry Sean Mr Davidson Mike Mrs Davidson Donna Davies Gill Davis-Merry Nicola Dawson Tamsin Daykin Richard de Gruyther Diana Ms Dent Katy Dias Elaine Mrs Dickson Doreen Mr Dickson George Dillon P Doan Jane Dobson Jackie Donald Susan Dorman David Douthwaite Laura

41 Title Surname First name Organisation Duckworth Keith Duckworth Sue Duckworth Stuart Dugdale Michael Duncan Jennie Duthie Liz Edge Peter Mr Edwards Mervyn Edwards Judith Edwards Tony Ellison Allan Ellison Chris Elton Richard Emery Joyce Errington Beatrice Evans Peter Eyley David Falck Eve Falck. Kenneth Farrell Janet Firth Jenny Fisher David Fisher Adam Fitzgerald Marion Flack W Fletcher Sheila Flynn Moya Foote Nicola Fowler Robert Gallimore Terence Gaskell David George Dinah Gill Richard Gill Patricia Mr Gladwell Goddard Richard Gornell Valerie Gornell Noel Goulding Isobel Graham Geoffrey Graham Ken Graham Hunter Christopher Graham Graves J Graves A Graves David Graves Thomas

42 Title Surname First name Organisation Graves E Graves J A Green Wendy Griffiths Anne Mr Griffiths Peter Guise Christine Guise Eric Hall Elizabeth Hall Maynard Hall Colin Hall Marjorie Hall Michael Mr Hall R Halls Elizabeth Halls Anthony Hampson Jo Mrs Harker Sue Harper Paul Harrison Rex Harrison Thelma Harvey Timothy Hatt John Hawley Andrew Haynes Kathleen Haynes Christopher Heaton Jennifer Hetherington F Hetherington F Hinchliffe Stephen Hoare Tanya Hoare E M Hodgson Mark Hogg Tommy Hogg Julie Sir Holdgate Martin Holloway Janet Hudson Christine Hudson David Mr Hughes Dean Hunt Jill Hunt Graham Hurton Derek Hurton Dawn Hutchinson Helen Inglewood Cressida Irving Paul Jackson Andy

43 Title Surname First name Organisation Jackson Jean Jacob Julia Johnstone Gerda Johnstone Tracey Johnstone Judith Johnstone Joan Jolley Anthony Jones Philip Keighley J. Kendall Dorothy Kerrey Liz Kirkbride Tania Kirkby John Mrs Lancaster Sandy Lazenby Eric Lee Ruth Lindsay Garry Lush JA Lush Janet MacKenzie Rod MacKenzie Jennifer Makin Peter Mrs Mallinson S Marsden Lynn Mr Marsden A Marshall Gillian Margot Marshall NW Martin Elaine Martin Jenny Mr Martin J C Mary Barbour Alexandra Matson Keith Matson Paula Mattinson John McAllister Anne McAllister Neil McCall Peter McManus Helen McManus Steven McNamara Robin McQuarrie Robert McQuarrie Barbara Meyfroidt Steve Miller Lynne Miller Lynne Morgan C & H Morley Nicola

44 Title Surname First name Organisation Morley Laura Morley Robert Morris Judith Morris Richard Mortimer G.H. Morton Helen Munnoch Andrew Munnoch Carys Murdock James Mycock Keith Nattrass David Newbery Nigel Nightingale Keith Norman Tom Norman Hilary Mr O'Brien Richard Palmer Rachel Palmer Craig Mr Parkin G Paterson Janet Pattinson Margaret Paxton Charles Payne Kathleen Pearce Catherine Perkins Georgina Petrie Jodie Pincombe Michael Pincombe Michael Piper Brian Colin Pitt Raymond Pitt Sandra Mr Poland John Poland Maureen Porter Simon Porter Allan Prosser Jennifer Pyne Nigel Ratcliffe Ges Ratcliffe Jim Raynes Nicky Reay Deborah Redfern Patricia Renwick-Smith Mark Rickerby P Rickerby Jane Ridgway Susan Ridgway Melvill

45 Title Surname First name Organisation Ridgway Melvill Roberts David Robinson Margaret Robinson Jayne Robinson Peter Robinson Philip Rudd Elaine Mr Rumsey Tony Rylands J K Mr Sansom Paul Sant Philip Sant Richard Sarney Tim Scholefield Nick Scott Miriam Mr Scott Duncan Scott CBE Doug Shaw Raynor Sheffield Jean Shiel Michael Shuttleworth Alan Simms Elizabeth Simpson Quentin Smart Dawn Smith B Smith Lois Smith Mary R Stamper Allison Stannard Elizabeth Steele Andrew Mr & Mrs Bousefield Stronach Jane Stronach John Tattersall Alan Taylor Derek Mr Taylor Steve Telford Paul Thompson Caroline Mr Thompson Stephen Thorne David Ms Thornton Joanna Tidburry Fiona Train Duncan Tratt John Tringham Roger Trotter Annette Tuck Maria

46 Title Surname First name Organisation Turner E Turney Lesley Tweddle John Tyson Helen Walker Norman Walker Sally Mr Ward Peter Wasilewski Susan Wasilewski Eric Wasilewski Alexander Watchman Julia Watson Peter Weaver Owain Whitfield Janine Whittington Andrew Wild L Wilkinson Barbara Williams Paula Mr Williamson Nick Mrs Wilson Linda Wilson Edward Wilson Fiona Woodstrover Allister Woodstrover Jane Woodward John Mr Wright Gary Mr Wright N Wykeham-Martin Julia Greening S Tremayne Clare Mr Reynolds J Dr Greening Phil Mr & Mrs Brown G Councillor Wentworth-Waites Tom Councillor Bell Patricia Inglewood Estates Johnstone Robert Williamson S&S McWilliam Jenny Fai Tok Kaui Lynch Kate Middleton Alan The Sirius Group Phillips Sindy Jones Daniel Planware Ferguson Bradley WYG Councillor Connell Andy

47 Title Surname First name Organisation Councillor Dew Phil Councillor Driver Claire Councillor Whipp David Pilgrim John Education and Skills Funding Agency Brett Sue National Trust Ford Rachel Bowcliffe LLP

48

6.2 Appendix 2 – Letter/email sent to consultees

49

Your Reference: Our Reference: Enquiries to: Planning Policy Team Direct Dial: (01768) 817817 Email: [email protected] Date: 13 July 2018

[Name] [Address1] [Address2] [Address3] [PostCode]

Dear [name],

Habitat Regulations Assessment Revision (2018) Consultation – Eden Local Plan 2014-2032

We are writing to inform you that Eden District Council will shortly be undertaking a consultation on changes to the Habitat Regulations Assessment, which forms part of the evidence base to the Eden Local Plan 2014 to 2032.

We will be accepting representations regarding the Habitat Regulations Assessment revision (July 2018) from 9 am on 14 July 2018 to 9am on 4 August 2018.

The document will be available to view and download from the Council’s website at: https://www.eden.gov.uk/elpconsultation. This document will also be made available at the Council Offices as well as the Local Links and Libraries across the district.

Background information Eden District Council took the decision to undertake this additional work in support of the Eden Local Plan following a change to the interpretation of the Habitats Directive. This came about following the recent Court of Justice of the European Union [CJEU] judgement of the People over Wind & Sweetman v Coillte Teoranta Case (C- 323/17). The ruling stated that ruled that Article 6(3) of the Habitats Directive must be interpreted as meaning that mitigation measures (referred to in the judgement as measures which are intended to avoid or reduce effects) should be assessed within the framework of an appropriate assessment and that it is not permissible to take account of measures intended to avoid or reduce the harmful effects of the plan or project on a European site at the screening stage.

50 Jane Langston BEng (Hons) CEng MICE Assistant Director Technical Services The ruling, and subsequent changes, affects two allocated sites in the Eden Local Plan. As a result, we have revised the Habitats Regulations Assessment for these sites and undertaken further assessment where necessary, the details of which have been published in the Habitat Regulations Assessment Revision (July 2018).

Notifications regarding Planning Policy

You have been sent this notification because your details are on the Planning Policy consultation database. If you no longer wish to receive planning policy notifications please take no action and your contact details will be removed from our database on 31 August 2018.

However, if you would like to continue to receive updates about planning policy please let us know by completing the online form accessible via the consultation webpage https://www.eden.gov.uk/elpconsultation.

Or by completing the form below and returning it to us at [email protected] or Planning Policy, Mansion House, Friargate, Penrith, CA11 7YG

Yours sincerely, pp.

Kevin Hutchinson

Planning Policy Manager

51

Top View