DOCSLIB.ORG

Devyani Khobragade, D/O Sh.Uttam Khobragade, R/O B-21, MEA Residential Complex, Chanakyapuri, New Delhi. … Applicant (By Advoc

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Devyani Khobragade, D/O Sh.Uttam Khobragade, R/O B-21, MEA Residential Complex, Chanakyapuri, New Delhi. … Applicant (By Advoc CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL PRINCIPAL BENCH O.A. No.30/2018 MA No.950/2018 Order reserved on: 01.03.2018 Order pronounced on: 22.03.2018 Hon’ble Mr. Justice Permod Kohli, Chairman Hon’ble Mr. K.N. Shrivastava, Member (A) Devyani Khobragade, D/o Sh.Uttam Khobragade, R/o B-21, MEA Residential Complex, Chanakyapuri, New Delhi. … Applicant (By Advocate: Mr. Sachin Chauhan) VERSUS 1. Union of India Through the Foreign Secretary, Ministry of External Affairs, New Delhi. 2. Joint Secretary, CNV, Ministry of External Affairs, New Delhi. … Respondents (By Advocate: Mr. Rajeev Kumar) O R D E R Hon’ble Mr. K.N. Shrivastava, Member (A): This Original Application (OA) has been filed by the applicant under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 praying for the following main reliefs: a) Quash and set aside the Memorandum dated 04.03.2015; b) Quash and set aside the UPSC Advise dated 10.02.2017; 2 (OA No.30/2018 MA No.950/2018) c) Quash and set aside the Show Cause Notice dated 24.03.2017; d) Quash and set aside the Final Order dated 10.11.2017; e) Quash and set aside the Order dated 27.11.2017; f) Pass an order or direction thereby directing the Respondent/MEA to consider the Applicant for her duly merited promotion as per her service records by opening the sealed cover…” 2. The factual matrix of the case, as noticed from the records, is as under: 2.1 The applicant joined Indian Foreign Service (IFS) in the year 1999 through Civil Services Examination conducted by the Union Public Service Commission (UPSC). She claims that she has been having consistently ‘Outstanding/Very Good’ service records. In support of this claim, she has placed on record some of her Annual Performance Assessment Reports (APARs) (Annexure A-6 colly). 2.2 The applicant has stated that a number of defamatory articles were published by local newspapers in India in the year 2014, carrying false and tendentious information relating to her personal and professional life. Even false claims, relating to her matrimonial life as also those related to her minor girl children identifying them by name in the newspapers, contrary to the journalistic ethics, were made in the said articles. Her husband’s professional life was also adversely commented upon. These defamatory and degrading articles quoted their sources from within the respondent-Ministry. 3 (OA No.30/2018 MA No.950/2018) It was also alleged that the applicant has illegally acquired US Passports for her children. Anguished and hurt by such reports, the applicant requested the Foreign Secretary and Ministry’s Administration to thoroughly investigate the sources behind the defamatory articles and plug the leak of official and classified information. However, the Ministry chose to ignore her request. The applicant waited for almost seven months for the Ministry to act. She was, however, assured from time to time by the concerned officers in the Ministry that they would get the source of leaks, from within the Ministry, investigated but nothing happened. In order to put an end to her character assassination by way of media trials and to save her dignity, the applicant gave an interview on 13.10.2014 to Times Now and another one to NDTV on 12.12.2014. The interviews covered applicant’s dispute with her domestic assistant while she was posted in US as well as the complaints to the US authorities by the said assistant. The interviews also covered the issue of US Passports of her minor children. The applicant claims that the interviews did not deal with any aspects contrary to the interest of Government of India and on the contrary, she appreciated the unconditional help and support provided to her by the Government. Following these interviews, the applicant filed a report with the respondent-Ministry as required under Rule 19 (2) of the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964. 4 (OA No.30/2018 MA No.950/2018) 2.3 The applicant wrote to the respondent-Ministry on 04.05.2014 and 26.12.2014, requesting to investigate the newspapers leaks against her but no action was taken. 2.4 For her interviews in the Electronic Media, the applicant was issued Annexure A-10 Memorandum/Show Cause Notice dated 29.10.2014, which reads as under: “MEMORANDUM A news channel, namely, Times Now telecast an interview with Dr.Decyani Khobragade, Director (TC-II), at 10:30 hours on 14 October 2014. Dr. Khobragade spoke to Time correspondent Ms. Megha Prasad. 2. In the interview, which was of half an hour duration, Dr. Khobragade, spoke about an incident involving her in New York, how she was subjected to physical search by the US Law Enforcing Agency, etc. Dr. Khobragade has been quoted as having stated that “things haven’t moved as such, but I am hopeful that specifically this Government will take it up positively because this is not just my matter, it’s about having a special judicial process against a diplomat.” Dr. Khobragade also informed that there have been certain other developments following which the incident in US on account of which she cannot be posted abroad. She also felt that these issues would get resolved. Apart from giving interview to Ms. Megha Prasad, Dr. Khobragade is stated to have given interview to Mr. Arnab Goswami of Times Now television. 3. Administration has confirmed that Dr. Devyani Khobragade, did not seek prior approval of the Ministry for giving the two interviews on television. 4. As per Rule 9 of CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964, no Government servant, shall, in any radio broadcast, telecast through any electronic media, or in any document published in his own name or anonymously or pseudonymously or in the name of any other person or in any communication to the press or in any public utterance, make any statement of fact or opinion- which has the effect of an adverse criticism of any current policy or action of the Central Government or a State Government. 5. There are separate decisions under Rule 11 of the Conduct Rules which states that officers specially authorized by the Minister are permitted to meet representatives of the Press and give information. Para 113(2) of the Manual of Office procedure stats that only Ministers, Secretaries and other officers specially 5 (OA No.30/2018 MA No.950/2018) authorized on this behalf may give information or be accessible to representatives of the Press. 6. By the above act, Dr. Devyani Khobragade has violated the provisions of Rule 9 and 11 of the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964. Dr. Devyani Khobragade, Director (TC-II), is hereby directed to provide an explanation within a period of ten days from the date of receipt of this memorandum, as to why disciplinary action should not be initiated against her for not seeking prior approval of the Government for giving interviews to a private television channel failing which further necessary action would be taken against her ex-parte.” 2.5 The applicant replied to the Annexure A-10 Memorandum vide her Annexure A-11 letter dated 07.11.2014 denying the allegations contained in it that she had violated the provisions of Rules 9 and 11 of the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964. She also explained that she had told the interviewers that the views expressed by her were entirely her own and not that of the Government and that she would not make any statement of criticism of any policy of the Government which might be capable of embarrassing the relation between the Government and the Government of any foreign State. It was also clarified by the applicant that she did not communicate, directly or indirectly, any official document or any classified information during the course of her interviews. 2.6 In the month of December, 2014. the applicant was relieved of her charge and duties and was put under compulsory wait. She remained under compulsory wait until March, 2015, i.e., for about four months. 6 (OA No.30/2018 MA No.950/2018) 2.7 Not satisfied with the clarification of the applicant, the respondents issued impugned Annexure A-1 Memorandum of Charges dated 04.03.2015 proposing to take action under Rule 16 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. The statement of imputation of misconduct and misbehaviour enclosed with the Memorandum of Charges, besides quoting the excerpts of the interview, inter alia, noted as under: “11. From the interviews given o the media, it is apparent and clear that Dr. Khobragade has (a) Criticised the Government of India, Ministry of External Affairs; (b) revealed to the media the action taken/contemplated to be taken by the Ministry of External Affairs which Dr. Khobragade is privy to in view of her official capacity; (c) projected Government of India, Ministry of External Affairs, being responsible for all her woes; (d) mentioned that FRRO has advised her that it is permissible for her children to retain dual nationality, i.e., retain both the US and Indian passports which is factually incorrect and misleading. (Ministry of Home Affairs, vide it U.O. No.26030/10/2014-IC.I dated 19.56.2014, has confirmed to the Ministry that as per the Citizenship Act, since her children were born in India, the day the children assumed United States of America citizenship by obtaining United States of America Passport, they ceased to be Indian nationals. A copy of the U.O. of Ministry of Home Affairs is enclosed as Annexure VI); and (e) given the interview to build media pressure to resolve her legal case. 12.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Persisting Servitude and Gradual Shifts Towards Recognition And
    A STUDY OF EMPLOYERS OF DOMESTIC WORKERS IN DELHIDELHI ANDAND MUMBAIMUMBAI 01 PERSISTING SERVITUDE AND GRADUAL SHIFTS TOWARDS RECOGNITION AND Institute for PERSISTING SERVITUDE AND GRADUAL Human Development SHIFTS TOWARDS RECOGNITION AND DIGNITY OF LABOUR A study of employers of domestic workers in Delhi and Mumbai 02 PERSISTING SERVITUDE AND GRADUAL SHIFTS TOWARDS RECOGNITION AND DIGNITY OF LABOUR Copyright © International Labour Organization 2017 First published (2017) Publications of the International Labour Office enjoy copyright under Protocol 2 of the Universal Copyright Convention. Nevertheless, short excerpts from them may be reproduced without authorization, on condition that the source is indicated. For rights of reproduction or translation, application should be made to ILO Publications (Rights and Licensing), International Labour Office, CH-1211 Geneva 22, Switzerland, or by email: [email protected]. The International Labour Office welcomes such applications. Libraries, institutions and other users registered with a reproduction rights organization may make copies in accordance with the licences issued to them for this purpose. Visit www.ifrro.org to find the reproduction rights organization in your country. ISBN: 978-922-129677-5 (print) 978-922-129678-2 (web pdf) 978-922-129679-9 (epub) The designations employed in ILO publications, which are in conformity with United Nations practice, and the presentation of material therein do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of the International Labour Office concerning the legal status of any country, area or territory or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers. The responsibility for opinions expressed in signed articles, studies and other contributions rests solely with their authors, and publication does not constitute an endorsement by the International Labour Office of the opinions expressed in them.
    [Show full text]
  • Khobragade's Complaint to Indian Police Re
    FIRST INFORMATION REPORT ( Under Section 154 Cr.P.C. ) ( Internet Copy ) 1. District: SOUTH DISTT P.S.: FATEHPUR BERI Year: 2013 FIR No.: 348 Date: 09-10-2013 2. Act(s): Section(s): (i) IPC 1860 387/420/120B 3. Occurence of Offence: (a) Day: Date From: Date To: Time Period: Time From: Time To: (b) Information received at P.S: Date: 09-10-2013 Time: 10:35 hrs (c) Daily Diary Reference : Entry No.: 15A Time: 10:35 hrs 4. Type of Information: WRITTEN 5. Place of Occurrence: (a) Direction and Distance from P.S: / 0.00Km. Beat No.: 07 (b) Address: DELHI,SULTANPUR, NEW DELHI (c) In case, Outside the limit of the Police Station: Name of P.S: District: 6. Complainant / Informant : (a) Name: DR DEVYANI KHOBRAGADE (b) Date/Year of Birth: Nationality: (c) Passport No. Date of Issue: Place of Issue: (d) Occupation: (e) Address: CONSULATE GENERAL OF INDIA, . NEW YORK, NY-10065 7. Details of Known / Suspected / Unknown accused with full particulars(attach separate sheet if necessary).: (i) 8. Reason for delay in reporting by the complainant / informant: 9. Particulars of properties stolen/ involved(attach separate sheet if necessary): Sl. Property Type(Description) Est. Value(Rs.) Status 10. Total value of property stolen: 11. Inquest Report / U.D. Case No., if any: 12. F.I.R Contents(attach separate sheet,if required): -- 1 -- ( Internet Copy ) District: SOUTH DISTT P.S.: FATEHPUR BERI Year: 2013 FIR No.: 348 Date: 09-10-2013 Sub:- FIR from Devyani Khorbagade, Deputuy Consul, New York From "Dr. Devyani Khobragade" Date Wednesday, July 3, 2013 1:18 To 'CG' , 'V Perumal' , '''G.
    [Show full text]
  • Clatutor GK 1
    CLATutor GK 1 INDEX 1. May 2020 1 – 9 2. June 2020 10 – 23 3. July 2020 24 – 32 4. August 2020 33 – 43 5. September 2020 44 – 53 6. Set 1 54 - 55 7. Set 2 56 - 57 8. Set 3 58 - 59 9. Set 4 60 - 62 10. Set 5 63 - 64 11. Set 6 65 - 66 12. Set 7 67 - 68 13. Set 8 69 - 71 14. Set 9 72 - 73 15. Set 10 74 - 75 ;. CLATutor GK 2 May 2020 a) HCARD b) Warbot c) Vyommitra d) COVIN 1. The central government has brought Cauvery 9. Hema Bharali who passed away in April 2020 is management authority under Jal shakti ministry _________. recently. Who is the Union Jal shakti minister? a) Architect b) Theatre Artist a) Nitin Gadkari c) Folk Dancer d) Freedom Fighter b) Smriti Irani c) Mansukh L. Mandaviya 10. Rudratej Singh who passed away recently is the CEO d) Gajendra Singh Shekhawat of which company? a) Suzuki India b) BMW India 2. The task force on National Infrastructure Pipeline c) Honda Motors d) TVS Motors (NIP), projects total infrastructure investment of Rs 111 lakh crore during a 5-year span of FY 2019-20 to 11. When was International Jazz Day celebrated FY 2024-25. Name the person who heads the task annually? force. a) 26th January b) 28th February a) Arun Goel b) Rajiv Kumar c) 2nd May d) 30th April c) Atanu Chakraborty d) Ajay Kumar 12. “Janaushadhi Sugam” a mobile application 3. The U.S. Commission on International Religious developed by the Bureau of Pharma PSUs of India Freedom (USCIRF) in its Annual Report 2020 has (BPPI).
    [Show full text]
  • Exhibit a 8 U.S.C.A
    Exhibit A 8 U.S.C.A. § 1375b Page 1 Effective: March 7, 2013 United States Code Annotated Currentness Title 8. Aliens and Nationality (Refs & Annos) Chapter 12. Immigration and Nationality (Refs & Annos) Subchapter II. Immigration Part IX. Miscellaneous § 1375b. Protections for domestic workers and other nonimmigrants (a) Information pamphlet and video for consular waiting rooms (1) Development and distribution The Secretary of State, in consultation with the Secretary of Homeland Security, the Attorney General, and the Secretary of Labor, shall develop an information pamphlet and video on legal rights and resources for aliens applying for employment- or education-based nonimmigrant visas. The video shall be distributed and shown in consular waiting rooms in embassies and consulates appropriate to the circumstances that are determined to have the greatest concentration of employment or education-based non-immigrant visa applicants, and where sufficient video facilities exist in waiting or other rooms where applicants wait or convene. The Secretary of State is authorized to augment video facilities in such consulates or embassies in order to fulfill the purposes of this section. (2) Consultation In developing the information pamphlet under paragraph (1), the Secretary of State shall consult with nongovernmental organizations with expertise on the legal rights of workers and victims of severe forms of trafficking in persons. (b) Contents The information pamphlet and video developed under subsection (a) shall include information concerning items such as-- (1) the nonimmigrant visa application processes, including information about the portability of employment; (2) the legal rights of employment or education-based nonimmigrant visa holders under Federal immigration, © 2014 Thomson Reuters.
    [Show full text]
  • Ministry of External Affairs Demands for Grants (2020-21)
    COMMITTEE 02 ON EXTERNAL AFFAIRS (2019-20) 50 SEVENTEENTH LOK SABHA 00 MINISTRY OF EXTERNAL AFFAIRS DEMANDS FOR GRANTS (2020-21) SECOND REPORT LOK SABHA SECRETARIAT NEW DELHI MARCH, 2020/PHALGUNA, 1941 (Saka) SECOND REPORT COMMITTEE ON EXTERNAL AFFAIRS (2019-20) (SEVENTEENTH LOK SABHA) MINISTRY OF EXTERNAL AFFAIRS DEMANDS FOR GRANTS (2020-21) Presented to Lok Sabha on 3 March, 2020 Laid on the Table of Rajya Sabha on 3 March, 2020 LOK SABHA SECRETARIAT NEW DELHI MARCH, 2020/PHALGUNA, 1941 (Saka) COEA NO. 142 Price : Rs. 135 © 2020 by Lok Sabha Secretariat Published under Rule 382 of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in Lok Sabha (__________Edition) and Printed by CONTENTS PAGE COMPOSITION OF THE COMMITTEE ON EXTERNAL AFFAIRS (2019-20) (i) INTRODUCTION (ii) CHAPTER I ANALYSIS OF DEMAND FOR GRANTS 1-26 I. Overall Budgetary Proposals and Allocations II. Classification of budget into ‘Scheme’ and ‘Non Scheme’ III. Review of Past Performance CHAPTER II SECTORAL ALLOCATIONS 27-54 I. Embassies and Missions II. Passport and Emigration III. International cooperation A. South Asian University B. Nalanda University CHAPTER III INDIA’S DEVELOPMENT COOPERATION 55-105 I. Aid to Bangladesh II. Aid/Loans and Advances to Bhutan III. Aid to Nepal IV. Aid to Sri Lanka V. Aid to Maldives VI. Aid to Myanmar VII. Aid to African Countries VIII. Aid to Afghanistan IX. Aid to Latin American Countries X. Indo-Pacific Cooperation XI. Indian Technical and Economic Cooperation CHAPTER IV ORGANIZATIONAL SET UP 106-112 I. Sushma Swaraj Foreign Service Institute Training II. Protectorate General of Emigrants (PGoE) CHAPTER V OVERSEAS INDIAN AFFAIRS 113- 129 I.
    [Show full text]
  • Abuse of Diplomatic Privileges and the Balance Between Immunities and the Duty to Respect the Local Laws and Regulations Under T
    The Chinese Journal of Global Governance 3 (2017) 182–233 brill.com/cjgg Abuse of Diplomatic Privileges and the Balance between Immunities and the Duty to Respect the Local Laws and Regulations under the Vienna Conventions: The Recent Indian Experience S. R. Subramanian Assistant Professor, Rajiv Gandhi School of Intellectual Property Law, Indian Institute of Technology, Kharagpur, West Bengal, India essares AT gmail.com Abstract The successful adoption of the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations is hailed as the ‘landmark of the highest significance in the codification of international law’. It represented the first significant codification of any international instrument since the United Nations was established. However, despite the codification of the above rules, which is largely based on the pre-existing customary international law, the scope of dip- lomatic protection was not free from issues and controversies. In recent times, unfor- tunately, there is a growing tendency amongst the diplomats to abuse their diplomatic status to commit acts prohibited by law and still claim immunity from legal process. The States-parties also aggravate this situation by selectively interpreting the rules in their favor, ignoring the fact that reciprocity is the basis for the successful functioning of the diplomatic protection. In this connection, this paper addresses the problem of abuse of immunities and privileges and its adverse implications on the balance between immu- nities and the duty to respect the local laws and regulations, especially with special reference to the recent Indian experience. It explores the two recent Indian diplomatic confrontations, namely, the arrest of Devyani Khobragade and the travel ban on Daniele Mancini.
    [Show full text]
  • Current Affairs Q&A PDF 2019
    Current Affairs Q&A PDF Current Affairs Q&A PDF 2019 Contents Current Affairs Q&A – March 2019 ............................................................................................................................................... 1 INDIAN AFFAIRS............................................................................................................................................................................... 2 INTERNATIONAL AFFAIRS ....................................................................................................................................................... 46 BANKING & FINANCE .................................................................................................................................................................. 65 BUSINESS & ECONOMY .............................................................................................................................................................. 90 AWARDS & RECOGNITIONS ................................................................................................................................................... 103 APPOINTMENTS & RESIGNS .................................................................................................................................................. 126 ACQUISITIONS & MERGERS ................................................................................................................................................... 149 SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY ......................................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]