DOCSLIB.ORG

Brochure FRER Solutions to Horse Slaughter

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Brochure FRER Solutions to Horse Slaughter for a horse that clearly needs a vet to provide U.S. horse slaughter plants closed in 2007, yet more vide a fund for low-cost gelding and humane humane euthanasia. than 100,000 American horses are still butchered euthanasia programs, as well as to fund inspect- annually in Canadian and Mexican slaughterhouses. ors to ensure that horse owners comply with Summary: For years, federal legislation to ban shipping our having a brand inspection for each horse they Every year approximately one-percent of Ameri- horses across the borders and to outlaw slaughter in own. ca’s horses are sent to slaughter. Even in the the U.S. has been stalled by special interest groups. Currently, breed registries and associations oft- best of economic times, the law of supply and Polls have shown that over 70-percent, and as high en charge less to register a foal, and then increase demand is a driving force determining the mar- as 90-percent of Americans oppose horse slaughter. the fee when the horse is older. Registries should ket value of horses. For every horse sent to U.S. horses are not bred to be food animals and offer reduced registration fees for geldings. slaughter, the horse industry loses tens of thou- their meat contains products and medications which Colts could be registered on the assumption sands of dollars which would otherwise be spent are toxic to humans. they would later be gelded, but if they are bred, during the lifetime of that horse. The horse The solutions to horse slaughter are numerous and their offspring could not be registered. Colts industry needs horses to expand its programs and are the responsibility of the entire horse industry, older than one year would have to be gelded in services. Innovative and practical programs that not just rescues and sanctuaries. Studies have shown order to meet the criteria. curtail excessive breeding, assist with end-of- that more than 92-percent of horses going to slaughter Breed registries and associations should raise their life decisions, and provide for retraining and are in good condition. For every horse sent to re-homing options are key to helping the horses fees, even by just $25 per horse, so that funding slaughter, the horse industry loses tens of thousands could be set aside for use with gelding and euthan- once destined for slaughter. of dollars, when you consider the amount spent on asia assistance and/or re-homing programs. direct and indirect expenses during the course of the To D o n a t e Broodmares and foals should receive handling average horse’s lifetime. Your contribution is greatly appreciated. and basic training. This would make them more Breeding: marketable, because unhandled and untrained Yes, I want to support programs The primary means of controlling the horse pop- horses dumped at auctions are mostly bought to help stop horse abuse. ulation begins with breeding. Putting a stop to by kill buyers. A horse that has undergone basic over-breeding and irresponsible breeding alone handling and training is far easier to place in an My tax-deductible contribution To stand by and do nothing .... appropriate home. An incentive program, is enclosed. would cut the number of horses in the slaughter makes us sharers in the guilt. pipeline by tens of thousands. The highest percent- through breed registries and associations, could be implemented to reward those who comply. Please make your check or money-order age of slaughter-bound horses is in the 3- to 9-year- old range. Veterinary clinics and associations can - and payable to: The following are a few areas where changes can be many already do - offer opportunities for horse Front Range Equine Rescue owners to receive discounts on gelding services A 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization working made. These solutions are provided in general terms but can easily be explained with more detail: to help control the horse population and educate PO Box 307 · Larkspur, CO 80118 to prevent the abuse and neglect of horses owners on responsible breeding practices. Implement a license fee for each horse owned, with through rescue and education. the stallion fee being highest; lower for a mare; and Veterinary schools, where possible, should offer Name: discounted gelding services to their communities. P.O. Box Larkspur, CO 307 · 80118 the least for a gelding. Use part of these fees to Since 2002, Front Range Equine Rescue’s Address: provide assistance for gelding and humane euthan- asia programs. Funding can also be used for quali- ‘Stop the Backyard Breeder’ program has pro- fied retirement, sanctuary programs or safe re-homing vided partial reimbursement to responsible horse [email protected] initiatives. owners around the country for gelding stud colts Phone: www.frontrangeequinerescue.org The states that impose brand inspection fees should and stallions. More programs like this should raise the fee per horse, even by $15 to $20, to pro- be developed and maintained. Email: Copyright © 2011 by Front Range Equine Rescue -8- -2- -3- Anti-Cruelty Laws and Legislation: compromised need to be thoroughly conducted, lessons, leasing a horse, or spending vacations at both good and bad economic times. Many states and those horses restricted from being sold. guest ranches. now have hay and feed banks providing limited It is critical to ensure that abuse, neglect and abandonment of horses are against the law, but Improve tracking of stolen horses and prosecute Develop quality intern/apprenticeship programs assistance to responsible horse owners who are in these violations must also be fully prosecuted. offenders. Programs similar to those of netposse. that would work with domestic and wild horses. financial difficulty. Many horse rescues around Animal control officers should have training in com should be developed and networked around the Many trainers and other horse programs, including the country are providing owner-assistance pro- basic horse-handling and abide by the standards country, because stolen horses can be transported some rescues, offer internship opportunities. These grams as well. FRER offers a horse owner- for body condition scoring. Horses should be across state lines within a short period of time. programs are good outlets for once-slaughter-bound assistance program on a limited basis for hay, feed and basic vet care. reclassified as a special category of livestock be- horses, and allow for more growth in the horse in- Re-Homing and Retraining: cause they are not a food animal yet are often a dustry. Educate about the re-homing of horses (safe part of farm or ranch work. A classification of The equestrian competition industry is a primary Develop more prison and community service pro- advertising, networking, etc.). Most owners ‘companion livestock’ would allow for a shel- source for horses that end up at slaughter. Quarter grams designed to help with retraining of horses can safely place their horses if they advertise ter requirement, yet retain the land use and water Horses and Thoroughbreds make up the largest (i.e., off-the-track horses and mustang programs). through their vet, farrier, feed and tack shops, rights for owners of livestock, as well as not percentage of purebred horses being slaughtered. The existing programs that pair prisoners with boarding facilities, equine websites and even altering rules for boarding facilities and other The Thoroughbred racing industry has made some horses have proven highly successful. Gentled and through fliers posted at local pet stores. The horse-related businesses. progress in taking responsibility for its off-the- trained horses have a better chance for placement in more ‘horse people’ that know a horse needs a track horses - zero-tolerance policies at some race- Strengthen cruelty statutes and ensure enforce- good homes. good home, the better the chance of finding an tracks; retraining programs; and retirement faci- appropriate one. ment; close existing loopholes such as feed and lities - to name a few examples. More programs Education: water requirements. For example, if there is a Horse owners need to understand injury prevent- like these should be implemented around the country. stack of hay on the property, but the horses are Educating new, existing, and potential horse own- ion and available rehabilitation services, so they emaciated, there is no excuse to not prosecute Develop a plan whereby horse-related businesses ers about the responsibilities of horse ownership can improve a horse’s chance of returning to unless the owner can prove they recently received such as therapeutic riding centers, riding academies, cannot be emphasized enough. The horse industry work after being injured, even if the work is those horses in that condition. Also, if there guest ranches, trail riding organizations, equine- must work together to implement programs for modified. Just because a horse can no longer are five horses on a property, for instance, and assisted therapy programs, wounded warrior mili- successful human-horse partnerships. The non- compete in the show ring, for example, doesn’t one is emaciated, that is no excuse to not assist tary programs, youth camps, etc., can take in for- owning, but horse-loving public can be more act- mean that horse won’t become a great trail horse mer slaughter-bound horses. ive than most realize in keeping horses from being for a new owner. that one animal. The excuse, “it’s an old horse” is not valid, with all of the feed products avail- slaughtered. Enhance the quality and increase the numbers of Humane Euthanasia: able for older horses and the availability of pro- riding instructors and trainers who would take on Develop more equine studies programs that bring per dental care. the responsibilities of retraining former competi- more people into the horse industry and into pro- The smallest portion of horses bound for slaugh- ter are considered to be ‘old, sick crippled or Connect animal control officers with qualified tion horses.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • January-2021-Newsletter-4
    JANUARY NEWSLETTER 2021 MESSAGE FROM OUR BOARD 2020! That’s a wrap! Phew, these final few months have been incredibly busy for our team. Between the Memorial service, markets, Purdy’s Chocolate Fundraiser, Santa Pics, and Grinch Tree fundraisers, the end of 2020 helped us recover from our closure earlier in the year. We brought in large numbers of animals since the start of September and adopted out 34 in the last quarter of the year. In total, we finish the year with 48 total adoptions and 14 animals still in care. Just a week into 2021 we have already brought 17 more cats and kittens into our program and committed to bringing 46 dogs from our partner organization in China at the end of January details below. We hope restrictions will ease this year and allow for more events, but as we navigate these challenges, we continue to adapt and try new ways of creative fundraising. If you are looking to get involved, now is the time. We are going to set up a fundraising committee to help with planning and running events. If you would like to get involved, please email [email protected] DATES FOR YOUR DIARY 2021 JAN 11 - PAULS PIZZA FUNDRAISER - SHAWNESSY LOCATION JAN 25 - SLEEP ROVER MINI PHOTOSHOOT JAN 28 - SLEEP ROVER MINI PHOTOSHOOT FEB 1 - PAULS PIZZA FUNDRAISER - AIRDRIE LOCATION ONLINE AUCTION - DATE TO BE CONFIRMED WWW.RESCUEFRIENDS.CA | [email protected] CAN YOUPARTNERSHIP GIVE THIS LITTLE WITH ROCKET SAVINGMAN HARBIN A HOME? DOGS A major new project for 2021 is our partnership with Saving Harbin Dogs in China.
    [Show full text]
  • Dobdrman Secrets
    DobermanDoberman SecretsSecrets RevealedRevealed Love, Life and Laughter. With a Doberman The author has made every effort to ensure the accuracy of the information in the e book. The information provided “as is” with all faults and without warranty, expressed or implied. In no event shall the author be liable for any incidental or consequential damages, lost profits, or any indirect damages. The reader should always first consult with an animal professional. Doberman Secrets Revealed Table Of Contents Topic Page No Foreword 3 Chapter 1.Buying A Doberman 4 Chapter 2. The First Paw-Marks 10 Chapter 3. Choose Your Dobe 12 Chapter 4.An Addition To The Family 19 Chapter 5. Follow The Leader 35 Chapter 6.Protect Him, So He Can Protect You 50 Chapter 7.Doctor, This Is An Emergency 70 Chapter 8. Golden Years 72 Chapter 9. Spaying & Neutering 81 2 Foreword Whoever coined the phrase ‘man’s best friend’ must have had the Doberman in mind. Because, you will not find a better companion in any other breed. It’s long list of qualities (and trust us, if trained right, these will surface) seems a little too perfect. But only a Doberman can lay claim to every one of them. A Doberman is a sensitive dog, keenly alert to your feelings and wishes. He is fiercely loyal, protective to a very high degree and will love you back tenfold. Observe him when someone you like visits you. Again, observe him when someone you don’t particularly care for, visits you. He will be watching the visitor hawk-eyed.
    [Show full text]
  • Quality Breeder Vs. Backyard Breeders
    Swiss Run Greater Swiss Mountain Dogs Quality Breeder vs. Backyard Breeders Try to avoid puppy mills and backyard breeds… We enjoy having a pet in our home are there is nothing wrong with wanting it to be a purebred dog. If there wasn’t a market, puppy mills and backyard breeders wouldn’t be producing puppies. They produce puppies because they can sell them and if they couldn’t sell them, they wouldn’t breed them. The vast majority of dogs should be spayed and neutered and the majority of people do not take the responsibility of breeding seriously. The issue with puppy millers is not that they produce puppies, but that the care and quality involved in the process is lacking and that there is little or no attention to health, temperament or to appropriate home selection. Quality care and quality facilities should be the first step in a breeding program and the puppy millers fall short from the beginning of the process. When profit, current fads and numbers produced become the focus of the breeder rather than the care of the animals and the quality of puppies produced, you end up with poor care, poor conditions, and an overwhelming number of genetically unhealthy and temperamentally unsound dogs. Backyard breeders on the other hand generally have good intention. They generally have a pet they love that is purebred and a reasonable representation of the breed. Through love they either intentionally breed or allow Mother Nature to take its course and the family enjoys raising a litter of puppies and those puppies (assuming they are raised inside and not in the doghouse) are normally well handled and socialized to a normal family household.
    [Show full text]
  • Everything You Didn't Want to Know About the Dog Breeding Industry… …And How We Can Make It Right a FREE Ebook Published B
    Everything you didn’t want to know about the dog breeding industry… …And how we can make it right A FREE eBook published by Happy Tails Books Copyright Information: Mill Dog Diaries by Kyla Duffy Published by Happy Tails Books™, LLC http://www.happytailsbooks.com © Copyright 2010 Happy Tails Books™, LLC. This free eBook may be reprinted and distributed but not edited in any way without consent of the publisher. It is the wish of the publisher that you pass this book along to those who may be looking to get a dog or to anyone who simply doesn’t already know this information. Any organization is welcome to use this book as an educational or fundraising tool. If you enjoyed this book, please consider making a donation to dog rescue through http://happytailsbooks.com. Cover photo: Enzo, by Monique and Robert Elardo, It’s the Pits Rescue Author’s Note: The word “he” was used throughout this document for brevity to indicate “he” or “she.” Contents Introduction .................................................................................................................................................. 4 Section1: The Dog Breeding Industry: What Everyone Should Know ........................................................... 5 Puppy Mills and Backyard Breeders .......................................................................................................... 5 A brief comparison of irresponsible and responsible breeders: ............................................................... 5 What are the most common puppy mill breeds? ....................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Policies to Promote Socialization and Welfare in Dog Breeding
    Policies to Promote Socialization and Welfare in Dog Breeding by Amy Morris B.A. (Sociology), Concordia University, 2008 Project Submitted In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Public Policy in the School of Public Policy Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences © Amy Morris 2013 SIMON FRASER UNIVERSITY Spring 2013 Approval Name: Amy Morris Degree: Master of Public Policy Title of Thesis: Policies to Promote Socialization and Welfare in Dog Breeding Examining Committee: Chair: Nancy Olewiler Director Jon Kesselman Senior Supervisor Professor Doug McArthur Professor Nancy Olewiler Internal Examiner Professor Date Approved: January 16, 2013 ii Partial Copyright Licence iii Ethics Statement The author, whose name appears on the title page of this work, has obtained, for the research described in this work, either: a. human research ethics approval from the Simon Fraser University Office of Research Ethics, or b. advance approval of the animal care protocol from the University Animal Care Committee of Simon Fraser University; or has conducted the research: c. as a co-investigator, collaborator or research assistant in a research project approved in advance, or d. as a member of a course approved in advance for minimal risk human research, by the Office of Research Ethics. A copy of the approval letter has been filed at the Theses Office of the University Library at the time of submission of this thesis or project. The original application for approval and letter of approval are filed with the relevant offices. Inquiries may be directed to those authorities. Simon Fraser University Library Burnaby, British Columbia, Canada update Spring 2010 iv Abstract Dog breeding is an unregulated industry in British Columbia and most of Canada, resulting in poor outcomes in some dogs’ welfare: genetic make-up, physical health, and mental health.
    [Show full text]
  • SURPLUS ANIMALS: the CYCLE of HELL a Study of Captive Wildlife in the United States
    SURPLUS ANIMALS: THE CYCLE OF HELL A Study of Captive Wildlife in the United States BACKGROUND AND HISTORY As recently as the 1960's, the problem of surplus animals was minimal. Traffic in captive wildlife was limited to a small group of breeders/dealers and wildlife photographers who produced animals for documentary programs such as Disney, Wild Kingdom, and other wildlife series. The Hollywood animal industry was just beginning to burgeon, due to the popularity of such television shows as "Flipper," "Gentle Ben," "Daktari," "Cowboy in Africa," and many more. Unfortunately for the animals, money-hungry entrepreneurs saw an opportunity to make big bucks by exploiting the public's love of animals. In fact, it was Ivan Tors, producer of several of the aforementioned television shows, who first had the idea to capture an orca for a theme park. Now approximately 1620 dolphins and whales have been captured for exhibition in hotels and theme parks around the world in the name of entertainment. Hundreds have died. To capitalize on the Hollywood animal craze, a small group of middlemen surfaced who bartered for or purchased surplus animals from zoos to supply film productions, animal trainers, and theme parks. During the sixties, the zoo community was breeding excessively and randomly in order to produce "cute" baby animals for public display and as an incentive for people to visit their institutions. Zoos utilized these roving middle men because they were an effective means of disposing of the "cute" little babies at the end of the season-when they weren't cute anymore. The cycle of "surplus" animals had begun.
    [Show full text]
  • Animal Welfare Position Statements
    Animal Welfare Position Statements Last Update: January 30, 2016. TG Position Statement Page Date Approved Companion Animals: Dogs Devocalization of Dogs 1 Dog Breed Restrictions 2 Humane Training Methods for Dogs 3 Tethering of Dogs 4 Tail Docking and Ear Cropping 5 Companion Animals: Cats Cat Traps 6 Feral Cats 7 Free Roaming Cats 8 Declawing of Domestic Felines 9 Companion Animals: Multi Species Breeding of a Domesticated Animal 10-11 Classroom Pets 12 Pets as Gifts 13 Transport of Companion Animals 14 Sale of Animals in Pet Stores 15 Surgical Alteration of Companion Animals for Cosmetic Reasons 16 Wild and Exotic Animals as Pets 17 Animals in Entertainment Animals Used in Blood Spectacles 18 Domesticated Animals in Recreation or Competition 19 Marine Mammals in Captivity 20 Non-Domesticated Animals in Entertainment 21 Other Euthanasia 22 Farming 23 Improper Psychological Environment as a Form of Animal Abuse 24 Vertebrate Pest Management 25 Wolf/Dog Hybrids 26 Prepared by EHS’ working committee: Miranda Jordan-Smith, Chief Executive Officer Dr. Anthea Smith, Director, Animal Health Dr. Krissia Menjivar, Shelter Veterinarian Dr. Man-Sum Yau, Shelter Veterinarian Travis Grant, Director, Advancement & Social Enterprise Jocelyn Wady, Coordinator, Communications & Marketing Megan Rodgers, Executive Associate 2 Devocalization of dogs Position: The Edmonton Humane Society does not support the "devocalization" of companion animals. Rationale • Devocalization prohibits animals from exhibiting their natural behaviour and hinders their ability to communicate. • Devocalization may result in infections, laryngeal paralysis, and airway stenosis. • Excessive barking may be a manifestation of behavioural illness such as generalized anxiety, compulsive disorder, or separation anxiety. In such cases, the underlying cause should be treated.
    [Show full text]
  • Encyclopedia of Animal Rights and Animal Welfare
    ENCYCLOPEDIA OF ANIMAL RIGHTS AND ANIMAL WELFARE Marc Bekoff Editor Greenwood Press Encyclopedia of Animal Rights and Animal Welfare ENCYCLOPEDIA OF ANIMAL RIGHTS AND ANIMAL WELFARE Edited by Marc Bekoff with Carron A. Meaney Foreword by Jane Goodall Greenwood Press Westport, Connecticut Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Encyclopedia of animal rights and animal welfare / edited by Marc Bekoff with Carron A. Meaney ; foreword by Jane Goodall. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0–313–29977–3 (alk. paper) 1. Animal rights—Encyclopedias. 2. Animal welfare— Encyclopedias. I. Bekoff, Marc. II. Meaney, Carron A., 1950– . HV4708.E53 1998 179'.3—dc21 97–35098 British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data is available. Copyright ᭧ 1998 by Marc Bekoff and Carron A. Meaney All rights reserved. No portion of this book may be reproduced, by any process or technique, without the express written consent of the publisher. Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 97–35098 ISBN: 0–313–29977–3 First published in 1998 Greenwood Press, 88 Post Road West, Westport, CT 06881 An imprint of Greenwood Publishing Group, Inc. Printed in the United States of America TM The paper used in this book complies with the Permanent Paper Standard issued by the National Information Standards Organization (Z39.48–1984). 10987654321 Cover Acknowledgments: Photo of chickens courtesy of Joy Mench. Photo of Macaca experimentalis courtesy of Viktor Reinhardt. Photo of Lyndon B. Johnson courtesy of the Lyndon Baines Johnson Presidential Library Archives. Contents Foreword by Jane Goodall vii Preface xi Introduction xiii Chronology xvii The Encyclopedia 1 Appendix: Resources on Animal Welfare and Humane Education 383 Sources 407 Index 415 About the Editors and Contributors 437 Foreword It is an honor for me to contribute a foreword to this unique, informative, and exciting volume.
    [Show full text]
  • What Do I Look For?
    What Do I Look For? In your search of the internet for a Vizslas you will undoubtedly find many websites that offer Vizsla puppies for sale. Some of these websites will be representing wonderful breeders who are reputable and ethical. A reputable breeder will have the welfare of each of their puppies, and the breed in general, at heart. But for every reputable breeder you find on the worldwide web there will be literally hundreds that are not what they seem. How do you know if the website you have found is indeed a reputable breeder? What should you be looking for to alert you to the fact that they may be looking at a backyard breeder, puppy mill or puppy broker's website? Don't let a website's slick "presentation" fool you. Study the site and keep a pencil and paper handy along with the list below. Check off the "Red Flags" that you encounter as you look at the site. Doing this will help you determine if this is a breeder that will be someone you would like to know more about. Take your time. Remember, the time you take now will save you money and heartbreak later. 1. If they accept PayPal or credit cards.........RUN. 2. If they have several litters all the time........RUN. 3. If they have more than 2 or 3 breeds..........RUN. 4. If they do not show pictures of their dogs in AKC dog events....RUN 5. If they do not belong to AKC dog clubs or organizations......RUN 6.
    [Show full text]
  • When Good People Think Strange Things About Dogs
    When Good People Think Strange Things About Dogs Patrick Burns I am thrilled to be here today among all you canine professionals. You see the folks in this room are more than dog trainers. You talk dogs, sleep dogs, write dogs, and debate dogs. You’re not just dog trainers.... You are also dog debaters, dog listeners, dog commentators, dog bloggers, dog list-serv managers, dog authors, dog newsletter editors…. and yes … even dog conference presenters. You are the people who shape – or could shape – a great deal of dog culture in this country. Dog culture. How many of you have thought about culture in the world of dogs? Perhaps we should think of that more because, I will argue, it is culture that is responsible for the fact that so many good people think strange things about dogs. 1 Strange Things To start, look around. How many people in this room are non-white? A strange question, eh? You thought this session was about dogs, didn’t you? The point is that for most of the world, this discussion is strange. In much of Africa, Asia, and Latin America, dogs are not allowed indoors. Who lets an animal indoors that may have fleas and ticks, and that may eat its own feces? Who allows such an animal on the bed? Who lets it lick a child in the face? No one! So, to put a point on it, this obsession with dogs that we have is, for the most part, a European cultural affliction. Most of the world, believe it or not, does not have this affliction.
    [Show full text]
  • Using Human-Environment Theory to Investigate Human Valuing in Protected Area Management
    USING HUMAN-ENVIRONMENT THEORY TO INVESTIGATE HUMAN VALUING IN PROTECTED AREA MANAGEMENT By Judi Inglis This thesis is submitted in fulfillment of the requirements of the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy Victoria University 2008 This project was undertaken through joint scholarship funding by Victoria University and the Sustainable Tourism Cooperative Research Centre established by the Australian Commonwealth Government. I, Judi Inglis, declare that the PhD thesis entitled Using Human-Environment Theory to Investigate Human valuing in Protected Area Management is no more than 100,000 words in length including quotes and exclusive of tables, figures, appendices, bibliography, references and footnotes. This thesis contains no material that has been submitted previously, in whole or in part, for the award of any other academic degree or diploma. Except where otherwise indicated, this thesis is my own work. __________________________________ Date ___________________________ ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I am very grateful for the guidance and support given by my principal supervisor Professor Margaret Deery and my co-supervisor Paul Whitelaw from Victoria University. Their patience, support and advice throughout the candidature have been invaluable to the completion of this project. The study was funded by Victoria University and the Cooperative Research Centre for Sustainable Tourism without which the study would not have been possible. Both of these organizations have offered invaluable training and guidance programs throughout the project. The open and friendly support of the residents of Mallacoota, Cann River, Bemm River, Genoa and Gipsy Point is gratefully acknowledged. A particular thank you to Jenny Mason for her kind and gracious support and local knowledge in assisting with contacting community members, and also Phillipa Hamilton for her thoughtful and generous flow of information, brochures and books about the national park and the community.
    [Show full text]
  • MAC4 Final Submitted Abstracts
    Author Institution Abstract's title ABSTRACT The idea of animal rights has gained momentum over the past decades. It typically entails the notion of fundamental rights that is universal moral rights that (some) animals have simply in virtue of being animals. The emergence of such human rights-like animal rights is not only reflected in a rise of academic theorizing but also observable in legal practice. In both realms there is an upcoming trend to frame animal’s rights in the language of human rights and to discuss the former as a normative derivation of the latter as 4th generation human rights. This development comes at a time when human rights are still precarious notwithstanding their status as moral legal and political lingua franca. The idea of extending human rights to [4] Saskia Stucki, animals may be seen as adding to the fragile status of human rights as it Juan Perez, challenges one of the few assumption human rights theorists generally Max Planck Institute for Human Rights and Animal Rights: agree upon: that human rights are human. It is thus likely to engender Pedro Sanchez, Comparative Public Law and International Law Divergence or Convergence? considerable criticism adverting to the detrimental effects of the incipient Carlos Navarrete, âdehumanization (and decline) of the humanist project of human rights. Branda Nava Intuitions that animal rights are bad for human rights seem to presume an antagonistic dynamism between these two species of rights. But what if to the contrary human and animal rights converged and were mutually reinforcing rather than inhibiting and asserting animal’s rights would be beneficial to humans rights? This paper sets out to explore such parallelisms overlaps and interrelations between human and animal rights.
    [Show full text]