A publication of the Apartment Association of Greater Los Angeles • August 2018 • $7.50
VOTE NO ON PROPOSITION 10 COUPON Court cost only $495.00 - CALIFORNIANS JUST CANNOT AFFORD THE SO-CALLED LA Rent control or Section 8 only Uncontested eviction cost only special “AFFORDABLE HOUSING ACT” www.votenoprop10.com DTN LA, Van Nuys, Chatsworth, $495 Santa Monica, Lancaster L.A. City Council to The Worst Tales From Sheriff Lock Out included Make Owners Criminals Tenant Nightmares the Hood special conditions apply Page 24 Page 46 Page 52 Page 84 Official publication of the ™ Apartment Association of Greater Los Angeles
The voice of multi family housing since 1917© Serving Los Angeles County, Ventura August 2018 Vol.XLV No.8 County and San Bernardino County
MEMBER UPDATE th 11 Annual CA State Legislator Breakfast 18 8 Message from AAGLA’s President 10 Message from AAGLA’s Executive Director 12 Mark Your Calendar 16 Meet Our AAGLA Members 17 New Members 18 11th Annual California State Legislator Breakfast Statewide “No on Proposition 10” SALES | DELIVERY | INSTALLATION – APPLIANCES, LAUNDRY, ROOM AIR CONDITIONERS & MORE SINCE 1966 Campaign Launches 36 20 Top 5 Reasons to Use RentSpree TTW REPLACEMENT BRAND-NEW, IN BOX AIR CONDITIONERS TOP-MOUNT REFRIGERATOR
00 LOCAL AND STATE UPDATE 8,000 BTU: $359 00 00 24”w X 14½”h $419 NOW 00 $279 L.A. City Council to Make Owners 12,000 BTU: $399 24”w 24 THOUSANDS ALWAYS AVAILABLE YEAR-ROUND! PRICE FOR BLACK ONLY Criminals Over Citizenship Status Question
Local Advocacy Update 32
36 Statewide “No on Proposition 10” Campaign Launches 24”w
Right to Counsel $25900 $34900 $37900 $17900 $50900 $26900 $49900 $57900 $19900 $95900 38 (So-Called “Eviction Defense”) Tips to Cost Recovery for Your 42 Tips to Cost Recovery for Your Earthquake Seismic Retrofit 42 Earthquake Seismic Retrofit FEATURE Your local, independent, family-owned discount distributor
The Worst Tenant Nightmares North Hollywood: 818-769-8000 ApartmentSupply.com Santa Monica: 310-450-8585 46
Authorized Builder Distributor of…
…and many more!
SAME-DAY OR NEXT-DAY DELIVERY AND INSTALLATION AVAILABLE! CALL US FOR MORE INFORMATION PRICES, SIZES, AVAILABILITY & MODELS ARE SUBJECT TO CHANGE ANYTIME WITHOUT NOTICE
2 AUGUST 2018 • WWW.AAGLA.ORG APARTMENT AGE • AUGUST 2018 3 APARTMENT ASSOCIATION GREATER LOS ANGELES
MANAGEMENT IN EVERY ISSUE OFFICES STAFF APARTMENT AGE MAGAZINE
MAIN OFFICE Executive Director Publisher Tales from the Hood Korean News 52 84 621 So. Westmoreland Ave. Daniel Yukelson Custom Marketing Solutions Los Angeles, CA 90005 Ext.322, [email protected] (213) 384-4131 / (213) 382-3970 (FAX) 56 Ask Kari: Driveway Gate Systems Product/Services Council Directory Advertiser Customer Support Team 87 www.aagla.org, [email protected] General Counsel Open Monday – Friday, 8:30 a.m. – 5 p.m. Apartment News Publications, Inc. Dear Maintenance Men Craig Mordoh (800) 931-6666 70 90 Advertising Directory - Category WESTSIDE [email protected] (310) 277-1370 [email protected] LEGAL Director, Finance & Operations Advertising Directory - Alphabetical SOUTH BAY TENANT SCREENING HOURS 93 (310) 803-5325 Matthew Farghum Ext. 315, [email protected] 78 Legal Corner: Q&A SAN GABRIEL VALLEY Monday – Friday, 8:30 a.m. – 5 p.m. (626) 285-6357 Director, Government Affairs Saturday (By Phone Only), 10 a.m. - 3 p.m. SAN FERNANDO VALLEY & External Relations Closed Sunday (818) 780-5611 Janet Gagnon Ext. 309, [email protected] APARTMENT AGE (ISSN 0192-0030) IS PUBLISHED MEMBER SERVICES Apartment Age Magazine is Available Here AAGLA Satellite Offices BOARD OF DIRECTORS Apartment Age Magazine and MONTHLY BY THE APARTMENT ASSOCIATION OF Manager, Membership Database Downloadable Forms Available Here • Governmental Advocacy Feder’s Distributors GREATER LOS ANGELES FOR THE LOS ANGELES OFFICERS Frank Martinez 5720 Lankershim Blvd., North Hollywood COUNTY APARTMENT INDUSTRY. EDITORIAL AND (818) 769-8000 E.G.L. Properties Ext. 335, [email protected] • Free Operational Advice ADVERTISING OFFICES ARE LOCATED AT 621 SO. President...... Earle Vaughan 1543 Pontius Ave. WESTMORELAND AVE., LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA Vice President...... Larry Cannizzaro Mission Valley Bank: Los Angeles, CA 90025 Manager, Accounting • Free Forms 90005, (213) 384-4131. SUBSCRIPTION RATE FOR Vice President/Treasurer...... Joe Patel Karen Truong Sun Valley Sullivan-Dituri Realtors NON-MEMBERS IS $48.00 PER YEAR, SINGLE Ext. 312, [email protected] 2111 Wilshire Boulevard • Free Monthly Magazine 9116 Sunland Blvd., Sun Valley COST PER COPY $4.00. THE PUBLISHER ASSUMES (818) 394-2324 Santa Monica, California 90403 DIRECTORS NO RESPONSIBILITY FOR ARTICLES APPEARING Larry Cannizzaro*...... Los Angeles Manager, Membership & Sales • Low-Cost Tenant Screening Valencia Fast Eviction Services UNDER AN AUTHOR’S NAME AND DOES NOT Jessica Garcia 25060 W Ave. Stanford, Valencia 474 W Orange Show Rd. ENDORSE OR GUARANTEE ANY ADVERTISING Seong “Charles” Choi...... Koreatown Ext. 311, [email protected] • Low-Cost Educational Seminars (661) 775-4112 San Bernardino, CA 92408 OR ADVERTISING CLAIMS. THE CONTENT OF THIS Arnold Corlin...... Los Angeles (909) 889-2000 PUBLICATION MAY NOT BE REPRODUCED WITHOUT HCIDLA Office Locations William Dawson*...... Santa Monica Coordinator, Membership & Sales • Property Management Training PERMISSION. PERIODICALS POSTAGE PAID AT LOS Apartment Age Magazine Available Here RST & Associates Harold Greenberg*...... Los Angeles Alex Paladin 11866 Wilshire Blvd Suite 101 ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90052. POSTMASTER: SEND Ext. 301, [email protected] • Member Discounts Central Regional Office Los Angeles CA 90025 ADDRESS CHANGES TO APARTMENT AGE, 621 SO. Gabriela Litov...... San Fernando Valley (310) 479-2565 3550 Wilshire Blvd., Suite 1500 WESTMORELAND AVE., LOS ANGELES CA 90005-3995 • Outstanding Vendor Referrals Los Angeles, CA 90010 Earle Wasserman*...... Sun Valley Coordinator, Events & Seminars Dyer Sheehan Group Richard Otterstrom*...... Marina Del Rey Dee Travillion • Low-Cost Liability & Workers East Regional Office 808A E Santa Clara St Ext. 307, [email protected] 2215 N. Broadway Ventura CA 93001 Lainy Parry...... Santa Monica Compensation Insurance Los Angeles, CA 90031 (805) 653-8100 Joe Patel*...... Los Angeles Manager, Member Services • On-Line Resources North Regional Office John G. Schulhof*...... Glendale Maureen Farrell, Notary Public Ext. 319, 6640 Van Nuys Blvd. William A. Shaw*...... Beverly Hills [email protected] Van Nuys, CA 91405 Cheryl C. Turner...... Los Angeles Manager, Member Services South Regional Office Irma Vargas*...... Santa Monica 690 Knox St., Suite 125 Mona Begum Torrance, CA 90502 Earle Vaughan*...... South Bay Ext. 304, [email protected] Vic Viereck...... Valley Village West Regional Office Manager, Member Services / 1645 Corinth Ave., Suite 104 Leonardo Wilborn...... Culver City Korean Liaison Los Angeles, CA 90025 Tyrone Vaughan...... Hollywood Jennifer Lee Mark Ridley-Thomas Kari Negri...... Los Angeles Ext. 303, [email protected] Constituent Service Center 8475 S. Vermont Ave., 2nd Floor LIFETIME HONORARY DIRECTORS Manager, Member Services/ Los Angeles, CA 90044 Spanish Liason C.W. Carson* Jack K. Wood* Main Office Maria Arnold 1200 W. 7th St. 1st Floor Shirley M. Dowling* Trevor Grimm* Ext. 314, [email protected] Los Angeles, CA 90017 Jerry Factor* Jon. G. Hanson* Christian Frére Robert J. Sullivan* Reception & Office Manager Diana Alcaraz James R. Howard* Ext. 301, [email protected]
*Past Presidents Sacramento Advocates Jonathan Arambel, Steve Carlson 4 AUGUST 2018 • WWW.AAGLA.ORG APARTMENT AGE • AUGUST 2018 5 Hours of Operation: Monday - Friday 7:00 am to 5:00 pm MULTIFAMILY LENDING Paintcraft Supply Saturday 8 am to 4 pm • Closed on Sundays Low Fees | Great Rates | Streamlined Process & Hardware 2620 Crenshaw Blvd., Los Angeles, Ca. 90016 (323) 733-9157 www.myacestore.com GAS WA TER HEATER 6 year tank & part warranty 30 Gallon $ Reliance 6-30-UORT...... 488 40 Gallon $ Reliance 6-40-UBRT...... 478 JOB QUOTES • DELIVERY • COMMERCIAL SALES BRADFORD WHITE RESIDENTIAL & COMMERCIAL WATER HEATERS ALSO IN STOCK WE STOCK AND ORDER CADET BATHROOM ALL RAYPAK PARTS WALL HEATERS $ 96 ALSO AVAILABLE: Model RBF121...... 139. 1/3HP...... $59.97 1/2HP...... $69.97 Badger 5 disposer $ 97 1/2 HP disposer...... 82. 25,000 btu Monterey $ 00 Badger 1 disposer $ 97 Model 2509822...... 427. 1/3 HP disposer...... 72. 35,000 btu Monterey $ 00 Model 3509822...... 457. Apartment loans done right. SMOKE & CARBON MONOXIDE ALARMS 50,000 btu Monterey $ 00 BRK 9120B Smoke Alarm EXCEPTIONAL SERVICE. REMARKABLY FAST. $ 97 Model 5009822...... 627. with 9 Volt Battery Back Up...... 8. 7010B Photoelectronic $ 97 14,000 btu Direct Vent $ 00 with 9v Battery Back Up...... 17. Model 1403822...... 497. 22,000 btu Direct Vent When we started looking to I called on an ad just like this We have worked with Team $ 00 grow our apartment portfolio one. I was looking for team Ramsey on 13 apartment SC9120B Smoke Alarm & Carbon $ 97 Model 2203822...... 647. Monoxide with 9v Battery Back Up.... we wanted to find a lender who who would handle everything loans over the last 5 years. 34. 30,000 btu Direct Vent $ 00 could grow with us. Five years possible for me, deliver what They really go out of their Carbon Monoxide Detector $ 77 Model W3003822...... 657. Battery Only CO 400...... 17. later we have closed 23 deals they promised and always way to simplify the process, with Team Ramsey. Their flexible make me feel like I am their keep me updated on the prepayment penalties and only client. This team delivers, progress of my loan, and APARTMENT MAILBOX competitive rates have allowed even when I had a purchase they’re always available, US POSTAL APPROVED us to reinvest and expand. with a 21 day escrow! even after the loan closes. – Ed Feo, – Larry Rubenstein, – “Winnie” Uyen Pham Seaward Road Enterprises Meno Mosso, Inc.
710-502 PILOT LUX PSM30 8 OR 10 DIGIT Surface Mount Brass GAS VALVE GENERATOR THERMOSTAT REMOTE $ 50 $ 96 $ 97 $ 97 $ 97 Call Team Ramsey today or visit or Silver Finish...... 32. per door ENGRAVED $ 00 67. 25. 9. 8. LETTER BOX.....125. chase.com/mfl-alisonramsey to learn more. DESERT CLASSIC MAGNESITE SEALER RANGEHOODS White or Almond: $ 96 24"-$47, 36"-$49 Christine DePillo Alison Ramsey Ashley Haas Desert Classic Sealer...... 32. 30"-$47, 42"-$74 Sr. Client Associate Executive Director Sr. Client Specialist $ 96 Stainless Steel: 75 lbs Oxy Patch repair kit...... 97. 30"-$74, 36"-$84, 42"-$124 (949) 475-7220 (949) 833-4867 (949) 471-1969 $ 96 SHOWER STEM OR $ 77 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] 75 lbs Oxy Patch powder only.... 79. LEVITON DIVERTER...... 4. $ 96 GFI LARGE VERVE $ 50 Gallon Magnesite crack filler...... $ 97 HANDLES...... 1. 23. 9. $ 50 +CA RECOVERY FEE FLANGE...... 1. Credit is subject to approval. Rates and programs are subject to change; certain restrictions apply. Terms and conditions subject to commitment letter. Products and services provided by JPMorgan Chase Bank, FOR PRICE PFISTER N.A. ©2018 JPMorgan Chase & Co. All rights reserved. Chase is a marketing name for certain businesses of JPMorgan Chase & Co. and JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A., Member FDIC. 457534
6 AUGUST 2018 • WWW.AAGLA.ORG APARTMENT AGE • AUGUST 2018 7 BOMA Full pg ad_Optimum | Seismic_w-bleed.pdf 1 6/12/17 9:32 AM Member Update
MESSAGE FROM SEISMIC AAGLA’S PRESIDENT ENGINEERING & OPTIMUM | SEISMIC CONSTRUCTION By Earle Vaughan MAKING OUR CITIES SAFERTM EXPERTS
Now that the mid-week July 4th holiday is over and well that have come out in support of our NO ON PROPOSITION behind us, and Summer vacations have officially gotten 10 campaign, including: underway, the focus on Proposition 10 and the repealing • National Association for the Advancement of Colored of the Costa -Hawkins Rental Housing Act (“Costa- People (NAACP) Hawkins”) will only intensify as the November Election • California Business Roundtable Day draws near. The proponents of the Costa-Hawkins’ • California Chamber of Commerce Since 1984, our team has been repeal initiative suffered two defeats this past month, one • California Business Properties Association making California buildings safer, handed to them directly by the electorate in Long Beach • Family Business Association of California and other cities, and another by California’s highest court, • The Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association performing full-service seismic the State Supreme Court. • California Taxpayer Protection Committee • And, hundreds and hundreds more…. retrofit engineering, steel fabrication On July 9, 2018, rent control advocates suspended their Proposition 10 is a very flawed initiative. If Proposition 10 signature gathering operations in the hotly contested City passes, California will face even a greater housing crisis. and construction on soft-story of Long Beach, calling obstacles “insurmountable”– with apartments, historical structures, opposition that included Long Beach’s mayor and members Proposition 10 is not a solution and will only make the crisis of the City Council. It’s instructive that many public worse. Proposition 10: non-ductile concrete buildings, officials see rent control as a fatally flawed solution to the Industry leader real problem of housing availability, which is inextricably • DOES NOT increase funding for affordable housing steel frame and unreinforced masonry linked to affordability. Also, during June and July, rent • DOES NOT facilitate building housing that local Proven expertise control advocates failed to gather a sufficient number of communities have already approved buildings throughout the state of signatures in many other cities throughout the Southland, • DOES NOT provide immediate relief for people facing California. including Pasadena, Glendale, Pomona and Inglewood. high housing costs Satisfied clients Unfortunately, Long Beach and these other cities, along with many other cities will be back in the 2020 election Proposition 10 will stop growth as Local initiatives in cities like cycle pushing for local rent control ballot initiatives. As San Francisco, Berkeley, Los Angeles, West Hollywood and Our business model is built on housing providers, we must remain vigilant. Santa Monica are threatening to implement vacancy control (e.g., you will no longer be permitted to raise rent to market value engineering: a systematic method Also, during the month of July, in an overwhelming 5-1 when a tenant moves out), which could severely diminish of achieving the optimum ratio of position, the California Supreme Court deferred to a state investment in maintenance, rehabilitation and growth. appeals court ruling, ignoring the City of San Francisco’s functionality, safety and cost appeal to reinstate an ordinance that refused to allow Proposition 10 has no State oversight, and it empowers landlords to renovate units they legally removed from unelected rent boards in cities like Long Beach that would effectiveness. the rental market under the state’s Ellis Act. The rationale be empowered to impose new rent control regulations and focused on the punitive burden San Francisco would fees without a local vote of the people or even approval of place on landlords, who already faced restrictions as part elected city officials. We believe that superior customer of the Ellis Act. The Ellis Act allows property owners to remove their rental properties from the rental market so Proposition 10 means less revenue for State and local service is the foundation of any Experts in All Building Types Full-service Team that they are not forced to operate at loses under strict government because it will lead to more than $5.7 billion rent control laws. in lost economic output, more than 38,000 jobs lost, and business, and we customize every Soft-story Multifamily In-house Licensed Engineering, combined state and local revenue losses of up to $1.3 Finally, the Orange County Register’s editorial board billion annually due to reduced property values and less project to suit the individual needs Tilt-up Steel Fabrication & Construction sharply criticized the effort to undo Costa Hawkins. In construction-related economic activity in the state. of our clients. Unreinforced Masonry two biting pieces, the editorial board -- collectively and Since 1984, our team has completed Non-ductile Concrete through an opinion article authored by one of its members Vote no on Proposition 10. more than 1,900 projects -- condemn Costa-Hawkins’ opposition as seeking “short- Steel Moment Frame term, superficial relief” that benefit only the select, lucky And, please help us to win by supporting the Issues PAC of few living in rent-controlled units and punishing the rest AAGLA. Give today before it’s too late! Please contribute of California’s residents by aggravating the existing scarcity generously by mailing your check to Issues PAC of AAGLA of units, undercutting housing production and ultimately c/o Reed & Davidson, LLP, 515 South Figueroa Street, OPTIMUM | SEISMIC, INC. optimumseismic.com leaving fewer rental properties overall. Suite 1110, Los Angeles, California 90071-3301; Attn. C. 323-OPTIMUM Davidson, Treasurer, or contribute online at: https://secure. 5508 S. Santa Fe Avenue Contractor License No. 1012702 Our statewide campaign to preserve Costa-Hawkins is anedot.com/aaglaissuespac/donate. Every dollar counts in 323-678-4686 Vernon, CA 90058 gathering steam. So far, we have had many organizations the fight to save Costa-Hawkins.
8 AUGUST 2018 • WWW.AAGLA.ORG APARTMENT AGE • AUGUST 2018 9 Member Update
VOTE NO ON PROPOSITION 10 IT WILL HURT ALL CALIFORNIA PROPERTY OWNERS
VOTE NO ON PROPOSITION 10 Proposition 10, the California Ballot Initiative coming this November being sold as the “Affordable Housing Act,” if passed, will repeal the Costa-Hawkins Rental Housing Act and harm By Daniel Yukelson the interests of every California property owner. Here’s a quick summary of what’s at stake:
If passed, all types of housing may be subject If passed, the only way to repeal or amend to rent control, regardless of the year built. the initiative will be through another voter California’s voters must reject Proposition 10 for the flaws of rent control. The legislature passed the bi-partisan, initiative. That will take years at best. Your If passed, all protections against onerous rent State Legislature is powerless when it comes following reasons: Costa-Hawkins Rental Housing Act, which protected control laws will be eliminated statewide. to amending and appealing these new burdens Californians from a rental lottery that harmed most and that Property owners will be at the mercy of local that will be placed on property owners. • Renters who want affordability and apartment choices provided subsidies to only a very few, reduced the supply government and special interest groups. say “No.” of apartments, and took away the unhindered rights of If passed, hundreds of millions of your tax property owners to rent their properties. Read more about If passed, public employee pension funds, dollars are at stake. Any court actions to • Single Family Homeowners who do not want their why California ended new rent control in 1995. many of which are heavily invested in challenge its constitutionality will be paid by property rights taken by unelected bureaucrats say “No.” apartment buildings, will decline in value taxpayers. That’s you! and unfunded pension liabilities will increase The Facts: even more. If passed, property values will decline as • Public Officials who do not want to see dramatic reductions owners of rental property will incur significant in property taxes, and reductions in local revenues that will • Proposition 10 does not build new apartments or any If passed, vacancy decontrol will be losses in revenue and will no longer be able negatively impact our schools, and police and fire services housing, affordable or otherwise, and in fact it discourages eliminated, meaning that your local lawmakers to maintain their properties resulting in say “No.” new construction. And the real reason rents are rising is and non-elected rent control boards can limit neighborhood blight. Lower property values because more people want apartments than are available the amount of rent you can charge to new steal badly needed property tax dollars that fund our schools and first responders. • Citizens who do not want to pay for huge new taxes to in California. Proposition 10’s rent control will make this tenants after your old tenants move out. subsidize renters say “No.” problem far worse as apartment owners convert their If passed, rent control can apply to If passed, no new affordable housing units buildings to condominiums or other uses to survive, and condominiums and single-family homes, and will be created, new housing construction Don’t Be Fooled: the fatally flawed Proposition 10 new construction simply stops. not just to apartments anymore. will decline, and construction jobs and trades will raise rents and reduce apartment choices across servicing the apartment industry will be California, while increasing government bureaucracy and • A California Assembly Bill to do the same thing as If passed, many more communities throughout negatively impacted. taxes for everyone. Proposition 10 was defeated in the State legislature by California will be emboldened by rent control activists and special interest groups to pass committee without a single hearing last year, because it Please join the fight today! Vote NO on laws that will severely restrict your property On November 6th, Californians will vote on the fatally was so obvious that it would harm the interests of almost rights and the rent you can charge. Proposition 10 this November. flawed Proposition 10, an effort by self-dealing Michael all Californians. But now, it is brought back by ultrawealthy Weinstein to create a rent control lottery with very few and controversial Michael Weinstein, who is determined to winners…and millions of losers across California. If it impose his personal will on all of Californians. passes, the dramatic loss of property and income tax LETTER TO THE EDITOR proceeds on apartment buildings and property owners • Economists who study the effect of price controls and Dear Editor: could increase everyone else’s taxes as much as 25%, or pricing on supply are almost unanimous in opposing rent
reduce vital services like public schools, first responders control. An overwhelming 98% of Economists opposed rent I enjoyed your article in the May edition of “Apartment Age Magazine” about Michael Weinstein. The reason why (e.g., police and fire) and social services. control in in a survey from University of Chicago, including I am writing to you is if we really want to defeat this ballot initiative, we need to help everybody, including tenants. leading voices from MIT, Harvard, Yale, and Princeton. What the Apartment Association should do in September of this year is to send out flyers to give all tenants (bullet) If Proposition 10 passes, California will return to the dark (http://www.igmchicago.org/surveys/rent-control) In the points (on) how the passage of the initiative would affect them. ages of rent control statewide, where taxpayer funded words of one, “Rent control discourages supply of rental We cannot be dependent on Property owners to take (on) the load of the voters. We need tenant support. bureaucrats imposed arbitrary rules that forced apartment units. Incumbent renters benefit from “capped” prices.
builders out of California and caused the shortage of New renters face reduced rental options.” Or, as a Swedish Very truly yours, available rental housing and ultimately the deterioration economist, Assar Lindbeck, a housing expert, once stated: H. Stoller, Los Angeles, CA of rental buildings that could no longer be economically “Rent control appears to be the most efficient technique maintained. presently known to destroy a city – except for bombing” EDITOR’S NOTE: Mr. Stoller, thank you for your note. I hope and pray that you are incorrect and that property owners, including multifamily, single family and condominium owners, do eventually stand up for their property In 1995, California came together and recognized the fatal Vote “No” on Proposition 10 this November. rights and help us to win in November. Your point about messaging tenants is well taken.
10 AUGUST 2018 • WWW.AAGLA.ORG APARTMENT AGE • AUGUST 2018 11 Member Update
MARK YOUR CALENDAR MEETINGS, EVENTS AND CLASSES
MEETINGS & EVENTS August 9, 2018 Info: Advance registration is necessary. Please September 19, 2018 Cost: $99.00 AAGLA members / $129.00 non- register online at aagla.eventbrite.com or by calling members / $225.00 Individuals cited by the City of Los Event: Seismic Retrofit Seminar Presented by Optimum AAGLA’s offices at (213) 384-4131. This session is Event: Korean Roundtable Meeting Angeles Seismic free to all AAGLA members. Location: AAGLA’s Office – 621 South Westmoreland Info: Advance registration is necessary. Please register Get educated on the latest laws regarding retrofitting Avenue, Los Angeles by calling AAGLA’s offices at (213) 384-4131. No your building. September 1, 2018 Time: 11:00 a.m. – 12:30 p.m. refunds / no exceptions. Location: AAGLA’s Office – 621 South Westmoreland Event: “Evictions!” Avenue, Los Angeles September 24, 2018 September 7, 2018 Time: 12:00 p.m. – 2:00 p.m. Recognizing how an agreement can be terminated and understanding the eviction process. Event: Westside Member Meeting Event: Fair Housing Fridays Info: Advance registration is necessary. Please register (a/k/a, Santa Monica Meeting) online at aagla.eventbrite.com or by calling AAGLA’s Featured speaker, Patty Widget of Fast Evictions. Learn about housing discrimination, protected classes, Location: AAGLA’s Office – 621 South Westmoreland Location: Hulu Building – Community Room housing for families with children, prohibited practices, offices at (213) 384-4131. This session is free to all 2500 Broadway Street, Santa Monica, California 90404 AAGLA members. Avenue occupancy limits and much more! Time: 10:00 a.m. – 12:00 p.m. Time: 7:00 p.m. – 9:00 p.m. Location: AAGLA’s Office – 621 South Westmoreland August 15, 2018 Info: Advance registration is necessary. Please Avenue, Los Angeles register online at aagla.eventbrite.com or by calling EDUCATION Time: Spanish Session – 10:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. / Event: Chinese Roundtable Meeting - NEW AAGLA’s offices at (213) 384-4131. This session is English Session – 1:00 p.m. to 4:00 p.m. Location: AAGLA’s Office – 621 South Westmoreland free to all AAGLA members. August 7-16, 2018 Cost: $99.00 AAGLA members / $139.00 non- Avenue, Los Angeles Event: Manager Boot Camp – AAGLA Rental Housing members Time: 11:00 a.m. – 12:30 p.m. September 4, 2018 Manager Training (Tu / Wed / Th) Info: Advance registration is necessary. Please register Info: Please register by calling AAGLA’s offices at (213) Event: Seismic Retrofit Seminar Presented by Location: AAGLA’s Office – 621 South Westmoreland online at aagla.eventbrite.com or by calling AAGLA’s 384-4131. This session is free to all AAGLA members. Optimum Seismic Avenue, Los Angeles offices at (213) 384-4131. No refunds / no exceptions. August 16, 2018 Get educated on the latest laws regarding retrofitting Time: 6:30 p.m. – 9:30 p.m. your building. Cost: $295.00 AAGLA members / $350.00 non-members September 20, 2018 Event: “Bed Bugs 101” - Presented by Orkin Pest Location: AAGLA’s Office – 621 South Info: Advance registration is necessary. Please register Event: Successfully Using a 1031 Exchange Control Company Westmoreland Avenue, Los Angeles online at aagla.eventbrite.com or by calling AAGLA’s Understand investor motives and the delayed exchange With more than a century of experience and the best- Time: 12:00 p.m. – 2:00 p.m. offices at (213) 384-4131. No refunds / no exceptions. process. Basic rules of a 1031 exchange and provide trained pest specialists in the business, Orkin is the most Info: Advance registration is necessary. Please some background on 1031 rules and the forward, trusted name in pest control. Learn...What are bed bugs? register online at aagla.eventbrite.com or by calling August 14, 2018 delayed exchange process. Why are they in my building? Do they pose a disease AAGLA’s offices at (213) 384-4131. This session is Event: Lunch and Legal Location: AAGLA’s Office – 621 South Westmoreland risk? How are they identified and proper remedies to free to all AAGLA members. Enjoy lunch with us and bring your questions for our Avenue, Los Angeles isolate bed bugs? “Q&A” session with experienced attorney. This is a Time: 12:00 p.m. – 2:00 p.m. Location: AAGLA’s Office – 621 South Westmoreland September 12, 2018 great Opportunity to familiarize yourself with the latest Info: Advance registration is necessary. Please register Avenue, Los Angeles Event: Committee and Board of Directors’ Meetings in landlord-tenant laws and obtain free legal advice. online at aagla.eventbrite.com or by calling AAGLA’s Time: 12:00 p.m. – 2:00 p.m. Location: AAGLA’s Office – 621 South Lunch is provided. offices at (213) 384-4131. This session is free to all Info: Advance registration is necessary. Please register Westmoreland Avenue, Los Angeles Location: AAGLA’s Office – 621 South Westmoreland AAGLA members. online at aagla.eventbrite.com or by calling AAGLA’s Time: 11:00 a.m. – 3:00 p.m. Avenue, Los Angeles offices at (213) 384-4131. This session is free to all Info: Some Committee meetings are not open to Time: 11:30 a.m. – 1:00 p.m. AAGLA members. September 27 and 29, 2018 members – call for more information and updated Info: Advance registration is necessary. Please register times. Event: AAGLA and Los Angeles Community Housing August 29, 2018 online at aagla.eventbrite.com or by calling AAGLA’s and Investment Department (LAHCID) offices at (213) 384-4131. Event: “Make Tenant Screening Simple” - Presented by September 13, 2018 Property Management Training Program (English Session) Rent Spree Event: “Evicted” Novel Discussion Featuring August 23 & 25, 2018 Location: AAGLA’s Office – 621 South Westmoreland AAGLA offers a streamlined tenant screening service L.V. Wilborn Event: AAGLA and Los Angeles Community Housing Avenue, Los Angeles that allows you to easily access all of the information Location: AAGLA’s Office – 621 South and Investment Department (LAHCID) Time: 9:00 a.m. – 6:00 p.m. you need. Learn how to access credit score and report, Westmoreland Avenue, Los Angeles Property Management Training Program (Spanish criminal background check, eviction history, completed Time: 12:00 p.m. – 2:00 p.m. Cost: $99.00 AAGLA members / $129.00 non-members Session) rental application and more! Info: Advance registration is necessary. Please / $225.00 Individuals cited by the City of Los Angeles Location: AAGLA’s Office – 621 South Westmoreland register online at aagla.eventbrite.com or by calling Location: AAGLA’s Office – 621 South Westmoreland Info: Advance registration is necessary. Please register Avenue, Los Angeles AAGLA’s offices at (213) 384-4131. This session is Avenue, Los Angeles by calling AAGLA’s offices at (213) 384-4131. No Time: 11:00 a.m. – 1:00 p.m. free to all AAGLA members. Time: 9:00 a.m. – 6:00 p.m. refunds / no exceptions.
12 AUGUST 2018 • WWW.AAGLA.ORG APARTMENT AGE • AUGUST 2018 13 northoak_ad_apartment_age.psd @ 33.3% (Layer 4, CMYK/8) *
YOUR SUCCESS IS OUR MISSION
APARTMENT FINANCING
Is your retro building now required to retrofit? Bank with a trusted source. Mission Valley Bank has the financing program and expertise to get the job done. FULL-SERVICE BUSINESS BANKING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE LENDING Call us today. 877.394.2306 MERCHANT BANKCARD SERVICES COMMERCIAL LENDING Retrofit EQUIPMENT FINANCING Purchase SBA FINANCING
“We’re proud of our reputation as a Trusted Advisor and Refinance welcome the opportunity to earn your business.” —Tamara Gurney, President/CEO
MISSIONVALLEYBANK.COM
Branches located in: SAN FERNANDO VALLEY SANTA CLARITA VALLEY CORPORATE HEADQUARTERS CENTRE POINTE BUSINESS BANKING CENTER 9116 Sunland Blvd., Sun Valley 26415 Carl Boyer Drive, Santa Clarita 818.394.2300 661.753.5693
14 AUGUST 2018 • WWW.AAGLA.ORG APARTMENT AGE • AUGUST 2018 15 Member Update
Most Notorious 1 War Lord MEET OUR AAGLA MEMBERS 2 Drug Lord By Alex Paladin, AAGLA Professions 3 Overlord Containing the 4 Slum Lord Danielle Elliott—43 Year AAGLA Member Word “Lord” 5 Landlord “Without sufficient representation on the state and local levels, any effort that a property owner makes on behalf of their investment is a waste of time,” Danielle Elliott said firmly. “AAGLA is our voice— “Just Kidding!” without our voice, we have nothing.” Elliott originally heard about AAGLA via word of mouth and it was 5 not long thereafter that she realized the operational advice, forms, and educational events and seminars were only minor A housewife called up a pet store and said, “Send me thirty-thousand cockroaches at once.” “What in the world do you want with thirty-thousand cockroaches?” asked the astonished clerk. “Well,” replied the woman, “I am moving benefits of being a member. “The Apartment Association of Greater Los Angeles has played a key role in educating me as a today, and my lease says I must leave the premises in exactly the same condition I found them…” property owner. As the years have passed, I’ve recognized the increasing need for political representation.”
Shifting focus towards the November 2018 election, specifically Proposition 10 which would repeal Costa-Hawkins if passed, Ms. Elliott was crystal clear as to its impact on her. “The passage of Prop 10 would change everything, and that’s not being overdramatic. Prop 10 is the most serious threat to the real estate industry in the history of California; where goes California goes the rest of the nation.”
Having joined the multi-family rental housing industry at the age of twenty-three, Danielle recalls an era in which women had to push past restrictions and over hurdles in order to invest in real estate. “When I joined AAGLA, I was an idealist and a feminist. I bought the ideology that a woman could do it all—I believed it then and I believe it now more than ever. Up until the Equal Credit Opportunity Act of 1974, a woman couldn’t even get a loan! If a woman received credit it was through her husband.” Understanding this piece of history is paramount in grasping why Danielle’s concerns regarding a Costa-Hawkins repeal stretch beyond the effect it would have on her personally. “Single women, divorced women, AAGLA Welcomes Its New Members
widows, your mother, your sister—it will reduce all of our efforts to the point that we will no longer be able to support Roberto Alfaro Marian Galbraith Alicia M. Macias Herman and Mark Rhynes ourselves,” Danielle said in a tone reflecting the deep and valid concerns she holds. “If Prop. 10 passes, myself and Avila Apartments Gallatin Holdings. LLC MainStreet Management Stalford Homes, Inc. Freeman Baldwin Gibson Judkins Group Inc. Lisa Marques Monica Sim countless other women will find themselves in a situation where everything we’ve worked for will be ripped away from Glenn Brander Jack Graniti Birute Milliron Tijat Property us and we’ll be robbed of our financial freedom. The real estate industry gave us the ability to support ourselves and our Pamela Butler Allison Hall Bradley and Ronald Meer Li L. Ting families….but, Prop. 10 would effectively eliminate the financial independence we’ve fought so hard to achieve.” Xorin Balbes Michelle Han Jon Mok Marilu Mejia and Oscar Cindy A. Benes Frank Hawker Gerald Ngo Valle Robert Cater Cindy X. Ho Odette Company Mark Walters While acknowledging the very real housing crisis, Elliott refuses to assign blame to multifamily rental housing providers. Circa Los Angeles Peter Hulne Oakwood Worldwide Nancy Soluri and Richard Dana Development Group, Rosa M. Ixcotoyac Philip Ogolsky Whelan “Landlords and property owners did not create this problem,” she said definitively. “Opportunistic politicians who have LLC Pamela Jaeckle Alex Olivares Polly Wong no solution and no vision, aside from their own re-election, caused this housing catastrophe. Every study shows that Rent Diane and David Duplanty Chris and Corrine Johnson Patty Padilla Monica Gutierrez Zacarias Control has failed! As a society, we have been there and done that!” According to Danielle: “We need new solutions, not Teresa Esquivel Mary and Christina Young Park Brisas M. Zapata Philip Freeman Kalaydijan Laurence Peters Sophia R. Zuckerman old failures. Now is the time to fight against rent control, not to expand it!” Harold and Alexis Gage Jose A. Lopes Ruby Management Co. AAGLA Welcomes Its New PSC Members During a conversation riddled with the horrific consequences should Costa-Hawkins be repealed, Ms. Elliott has hope that the general public will not be duped into believing what she confidently labels as propaganda. “When people begin to Company Business Type Company Business Type recognize what the so-called ‘Affordable Housing Act’ will actually do, I believe that they will rise up and vote against it.” MVC Agency Marketing Bastion Security Security Services Bear Windows Inc. Window & Doors Share Tech Network Installations Co. Telecommunications Alex Paladin is the Coordinator, Membership & Sales at the Apartment Association of Greater Los Angeles. CleanFund Commercial Capital Financing - Rehabs/Retrofits De Leon Building Maintenance Janitorial Services You can reach him at [email protected] or at (213) 384-4131. Skyguard Surveillance, LLC Security Services
16 AUGUST 2018 • WWW.AAGLA.ORG APARTMENT AGE • AUGUST 2018 17 Member Update
11TH ANNUAL CALIFORNIA STATE
LEGISLATOR BREAKFAST 䌀匀䰀䈀 一漀⸀ ㈀ ㌀㠀㈀ PROUD BIRD FOOD BAZAAR & EVENTS CENTER – JULY 14, 2018
The Apartment Association of Greater Los Angeles held its 11th annual, California State Legislator Breakfast this past July 14th at the Proud Bird Food Bazaar and Events Center near Los Angeles International Airport. The event, which was attended by approximately 150 members and their guests, featured key-note speaker, Brian Glicklich, Chief Executive Officer of Brace Digital Strategies, and Master of Ceremonies and the Apartment Association’s Sacramento based lobbyist, Steve Carlson, Principal of Steve Carlson and Associates.
Mr. Glicklich presented the Apartment Association’s digital and social media campaign plans to defeat Proposition 10, the Costa-Hawkins Rental Housing Act repeal initiative, which will be appearing on November’s ballot. The Apartment Association’s planned campaign will be concentrated within its territory of San Bernardino, Los Angeles and Ventura counties, and consists of, among other elements, social media messaging (e.g., via Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, etc.), written editorials, website and traditional media elements (e.g., radio, television and print). The campaign’s Facebook profile can be seen at “No on Prop. 10” and the campaign’s website is located at www.noonprop10.com.
Mr. Carlson then spoke about the history of the Costa-Hawkins Rental Housing Act and the urgent need for the law at the time of its passage in 1995. He also introduced the state legislators that were present, each of whom were given an opportunity to speak for a few minutes, including: 刀䔀吀刀伀䘀䤀吀䴀夀䈀唀䤀䰀䐀䤀一䜀⸀䌀伀䴀
• Assembly Member Sydney Kamlager-Dove - Assembly District 54 • Assembly Member Autumn Burke - Assembly District 62 • Assembly Member Laura Friedman - Assembly District 43 䤀渀ⴀ䠀漀甀猀攀 嘀愀氀甀攀 • Senator Steven Bradford - 35th Senate District 夀漀甀爀 䔀砀瀀攀爀琀 • Assembly Member Dante Acosta - Assembly District 38 䔀渀最椀渀攀攀爀椀渀最 匀漀氀甀琀椀漀渀 圀攀 搀漀渀ᠠ琀 瀀椀琀挀栀 挀漀漀欀椀攀ⴀ挀甀琀琀攀爀 猀漀氀甀琀椀漀渀猀⸀ 䔀愀挀栀 瀀爀漀樀攀挀琀 椀猀 The Apartment Association of Greater Los Angeles wishes to thank each of the elected officials and its members and their 挀愀爀攀昀甀氀氀礀 攀渀最椀渀攀攀爀攀搀 琀漀 猀椀最渀椀ǻ挀愀渀琀氀礀 爀攀搀甀挀攀 琀栀攀 挀漀猀琀 漀昀 挀漀渀猀琀爀甀挀琀椀漀渀Ⰰ 愀渀搀 眀攀 瀀愀猀猀 琀栀攀猀攀 猀愀瘀椀渀最猀 漀渀琀漀 礀漀甀⸀ guests that were in attendance. 䤀渀ⴀ䠀漀甀猀攀 儀甀愀氀椀琀礀 䌀漀渀猀琀爀甀挀琀椀漀渀 圀攀ᠠ氀氀 爀攀琀爀漀ǻ琀 礀漀甀爀 戀甀椀氀搀椀渀最 焀甀椀挀欀氀礀 愀渀搀 攀ϻ挀椀攀渀琀氀礀Ⰰ 攀渀猀甀爀椀渀最 琀栀攀 栀椀最栀攀猀琀 焀甀愀氀椀琀礀 漀昀 眀漀爀欀 眀栀椀氀攀 最甀愀爀愀渀琀攀攀椀渀最 洀椀渀椀洀愀氀 搀椀猀爀甀瀀琀椀漀渀 琀漀 礀漀甀 愀渀搀 礀漀甀爀 伀甀爀 䔀砀瀀攀爀琀 琀攀渀愀渀琀猀⸀ Asm. Friedman Asm. Kamlager-Dove, Director and State Directors, Earle Vaughan Key-Note Speaker, and Dee Travillion Legislative Chairperson, and Cheryl Turner with Sen. Brian Glicklich Cheryl Turner Bradford and Executive 䄀搀瘀愀渀琀愀最攀 䌀漀洀瀀氀攀琀攀 吀甀爀渀欀攀礀 Director Daniel Yukelson 䘀漀爀 攀瘀攀爀礀 瀀爀漀樀攀挀琀Ⰰ 琀栀攀爀攀ᠠ猀 洀漀爀攀 琀栀愀渀 漀渀攀 搀攀猀椀最渀 琀栀愀琀ᠠ氀氀 洀攀攀琀 琀栀攀 挀爀椀琀攀爀椀愀 漀昀 琀栀攀 匀攀椀猀洀椀挀 刀攀琀爀漀ǻ琀 瀀爀漀最爀愀洀⸀ 匀攀爀瘀椀挀攀 䈀攀挀愀甀猀攀 眀攀ᠠ爀攀 攀砀瀀攀爀琀 攀渀最椀渀攀攀爀猀 愀渀搀 挀漀渀琀爀愀挀琀漀爀猀 眀椀琀栀 圀攀ᠠ氀氀 琀愀欀攀 挀愀爀攀 漀昀 攀瘀攀爀礀琀栀椀渀最⸀ 䘀爀漀洀 琀栀攀 吀攀渀愀渀琀 洀漀爀攀 琀栀愀渀 ㌀㐀 礀攀愀爀猀 漀昀 攀砀瀀攀爀椀攀渀挀攀Ⰰ 漀甀爀 搀攀猀椀最渀 眀椀氀氀 戀攀 䠀愀戀椀琀愀戀椀氀椀琀礀 倀氀愀渀 琀漀 琀栀攀 䌀漀猀琀 刀攀挀漀瘀攀爀礀 倀爀漀最爀愀洀Ⰰ 琀栀攀 洀漀猀琀 挀漀猀琀ⴀ攀ϻ挀椀攀渀琀 猀瀀攀挀椀ǻ挀 琀漀 礀漀甀爀 瀀爀漀瀀攀爀琀礀⸀ 椀渀挀氀甀搀椀渀最 愀瀀瀀攀愀氀猀 愀渀搀 栀攀愀爀椀渀最猀Ⰰ 眀攀ᠠ瘀攀 最漀琀 礀漀甀 挀漀瘀攀爀攀搀⸀ 一攀攀搀 ǻ渀愀渀挀椀渀最㼀 圀攀 挀愀渀 栀攀氀瀀 眀椀琀栀 琀栀愀琀 琀漀漀℀
⠀㠀㐀㐀⤀ 䰀䄀 刀䔀吀刀伀 䌀䄀䰀䰀 吀伀䐀䄀夀 䘀伀刀 䄀 䘀刀䔀䔀 Sen. Bradford and Senator Bradford and Sponsor Fuller Insurance Your AAGLA Team! ⠀㠀㐀㐀⤀ 㔀㈀㜀ⴀ㌀㠀㜀㘀 Asm. Kamlager-Dove Ali Sahabi, Chief Operating 䤀一匀倀䔀䌀吀䤀伀一 ☀ 䔀匀吀䤀䴀䄀吀䔀 and Asm. Acosta Officer of Optimum Seismic
18 AUGUST 2018 • WWW.AAGLA.ORG APARTMENT AGE • AUGUST 2018 19 Member Update
TOP 5 REASONS TO USE RENTSPREE By Alex Paladin, AAGLA Private Investor Seeking Multifamily
Contrary to the deceitful narrative, landlords are not in the eviction business. With the average eviction taking at least Property in Southern California three months, and costs that will surely climb north of $3,000, the notion that a multifamily rental housing provider would intentionally squander time and money becomes amusing if considered for too long. Among the most sought-after characteristics in a prospective tenant are integrity, ambition, cleanliness, and amiability. Acquisition Criteria Simply put, property owners desire that positive contributors to society live in the units they provide. With the average adult telling four lies per day, gauging whether or not a prospective tenant will be a nuisance, or a jewel can be mind • Multifamily (existing or development land) boggling. Wouldn’t it be nice to have a simple, thorough, and trustworthy process for screening tenants? • Priced from $1 million to $40 million Well, put away the Advil and forget the ice pack! We’ve got something to relieve the tension that appears at the • Any Southern California Location intersection of “Vacant Units” & “List of Applicants”—RentSpree! • Value-add, distressed opportunities considered
149 Units - La Quinta, CA 149 Units - La Quinta, CA No Commission We are licensed real estate brokers, but act strictly
as principals. This is not a solicitation for a listing
and there is no commission involved, which could
RentSpree will simplify the rental process and land you better tenants! Top 5 Reasons to Use RentSpree 48 Units - Van Nuys, CA Sole Decision Maker 1. No Cost to You: There is no cost for the service aside from the screening fee, which you can choose to pass on to Sole decision maker with the ability to execute applicants. Applicants pay the screening fee online with credit card, meaning you no longer need to collect or handle payment information. But don’t worry if you want to pay the screening fee yourself. You always have the option to due diligence quickly, and can be flexible with the pay and will enjoy preferred pricing compared to non-AAGLA members. closing to accommodate your exchange.
2. Start Screening in 2 Minutes: You can sign up and start screening tenants in 2 minutes or less thanks to the All properties pictured are owned and operated by simple process. There is no site inspection, setup fee, or on-boarding required. Once you enter the property address, Hanes Properties, LLC all you’ll need to do is enter an applicant’s email address to screen. Contact: 3. Instant Turnaround and 24/7 Availability: As soon as an applicant inputs their information and submits, you will gain real-time access to all requested reports. Yes, that means no waiting for any of the credit, criminal, or eviction Braemon Hanes, CCIM reports. Better yet, the service is running 24/7 so you can even receive reports on nights and weekends. 143 Units - Sun Valley, CA Director of Acquisitions 4. Comprehensive Application Package: With RentSpree, you can receive a full credit report and score, criminal background check, and 50-state eviction history. In addition, you can also collect a completed online rental application. [email protected] This makes for a complete application package with none of the back and forth. RentSpree can also collect applicant (818) 865-8305 | (805) 374-2350 documents and check references for you, helping you to close the loop on the process. Ext. 106 5. Ease of Use: For each vacancy you have, you will be provided with a unique link you can share with applicants who BRE Lic: 01230427 want to apply. Applicants can visit the link to submit materials back to you. The entire process is available on any computer or mobile device for both you and applicants. This makes it easy to access the information you need on the go! Hanes Properties, LLC Visit aagla.rentspree.com to get started or to request a live demo today! 4500 E. Thousand Oaks Blvd. # 103 Alex Paladin is the Coordinator, Membership & Sales at the Apartment Association of Greater Los Angeles. Westlake Village, CA 91362 97 Units - Baldwin Park, CA 112 Units - Duarte, CA You can reach him at [email protected] or at (213) 384-4131.
20 AUGUST 2018 • WWW.AAGLA.ORG APARTMENT AGE • AUGUST 2018 21 Get FREE Vending Machines Placed in Your Building* We’ll place our upscale snack and soda machines in your building at NO charge stocked with the most popular snacks and drinks. There are no contracts. If after 90 days you aren’t completely satisfied, we’ll remove the machines with no obligation. Your tenants will love the convenience! Mention this ad and receive a monthly commission!**
For more information Call David at Snack City 818-257-2810 or email [email protected]
Your Healthy Choice for Vending
*some restrictions may apply as to size of property, number of tenants and other criteria. Minimum 75 units preferred. **commissions are paid quarterly.
22 AUGUST 2018 • WWW.AAGLA.ORG APARTMENT AGE • AUGUST 2018 23 Local and State Update
L.A. CITY COUNCIL TO MAKE OWNERS CRIMINALS OVER CITIZENSHIP STATUS you from” that occurred weeks or months earlier may citizenship status. However, state law limits penalties to QUESTION suddenly be recalled by the tenant as “intimidating” or fines between $100 and $1,000. There is no jail time. as an attempt to “influence” after the relationship has By Janet Gagon, Esq., Director, Government Affairs & External Relations Instead, if a case is brought and a violation is found, then soured due to late rent payments or other issues. It is even the court would be required to refer the issue to the District possible that a tenant may use the new ordinance as a Attorney’s (DA) office for consideration under “extortion”. On April 12, 2018, the Immigrant Affairs, Civil Rights and a tenant, prospective tenant, occupant of a Rental Unit.” means of blackmail against the owner by claiming that Extortion is already a criminal offense and it is appropriate a conversation happened that simply did not occur. An Equity Committee of the Los Angeles City Council proposed to refer it to the DA as the proper agency to investigate owner faced with the possibility of serving jail time may an ordinance that would expose owners to potential jail Further, Section 45.44 (B) states: potential criminal activity. time of up to 6 months for asking a tenant or occupant decide to give into the blackmail. (current or prospective) about their citizenship status. The “...any person who violates any provision of Section In conclusion, neither the state nor federal government proposed ordinance is called the “Tenants’ Information/ 45.42 for the purpose of, or with the intent of, harassing This proposed ordinance is also inequitable towards have said that jail time is an appropriate punishment for Citizenship Status” ordinance (CF17-0461) and is still or intimidating a tenant, prospective tenant, occupant other protected populations. In the same Chapter IV asking a question about citizenship. Even the City of Los pending for an additional hearing in Committee. Members or prospective occupant; retaliating against a tenant, Public Welfare, Article 5.5 regarding Age discrimination, Angeles itself has said that jail time is not an appropriate of the Committee are Councilmembers Gil Cedillo (Chair), prospective tenant, occupant or prospective occupant for it specifically states in Section 45.55(C) “Violations of punishment for Age or Disability discrimination. Yet Nury Martinez, Curren Price and David Ryu. the exercise of his or her rights; influencing a tenant or any of the provisions of this article shall not constitute occupant to vacate a dwelling, or recovering possession a misdemeanor or infraction”. Further, in Article 5.8 these Councilmembers are now proposing that jail time Unfortunately, it seems that Councilmembers Cedillo, of the dwelling; shall be punishable by a fine of $1,000 regarding disability/AIDS discrimination, it specifically states is an appropriate and necessary punishment for asking a Martinez, Price and Ryu fail to recognize that there are and by imprisonment in the County Jail for a period of not in Section 45.90 (D) “Notwithstanding any provisions question about citizenship. Again, they fail to realize that thousands of “mom and pop” small owners that live more than six months. Nothing in this section requires a of this code to the contrary, no criminal penalties shall they are being both inequitable to other protected classes in their communities and regularly communicate with landlord to actually or constructively evict a tenant in order attach for any violation of the provision of this article”. and unreasonably harsh to “mom and pop” small owners tenants thinking of them more as friends and family. As to be in violation.” By including criminal punishment to this newly proposed of rental housing (many of whom are retirees). such, they may engage in casual conversations saying such Section 45.44 for citizenship, these Councilmembers are things as “how are you”, “what’s going on with you”, and Section 45.44(B) removes discretion from a court of law creating a heightened level of remedy over two other Even in the fee structure they fail to recognize that $1,000 protected classes of individuals. “where are you from”. By this proposed ordinance, the to determine whether jail time is appropriate and instead fine may be only a minor deterrent to an owner of a 200+ last question now could put an owner at risk of spending requires jail time be served. This would turn owners into unit building versus a “mom and pop” owning a 4 unit up to 6 months in jail and a fine of $1,000. criminals and take away their civil liberties. Federal Fair Housing laws (existing for 50+ years) recognize building that may not be able to make ends meet with this Age, Disability and National Origin as protected classes. fine and would be forced to either raise rents or go out of Section 45.44 (A) of the proposed ordinance states: These Councilmembers seem to forget that the entire However, they only provide for fines and not jail time. The business (and remove more affordable rental housing from criminal justice system is separate from our civil justice only instances of potential jail time are when a separate the City). Councilmembers Cedillo, Martinez, Price and “Violation of any provision of Section 45.42 shall be system to recognize that taking away a person’s liberty is crime is committed such as assault or battery when “force Ryu need to be reminded that “mom and pop” owners punishable in accordance with Subdivision (m) of Section only to be done in the most extreme instances and by a jury or threat of force” is used. Their list of criminal actions should NOT be turned into criminals and face jail time for 11.00 of the Code”. This section makes it a criminal of their peers. By requiring jail time, Section 45.44(B) implies includes crossing burning, arson, fire bombings, written offense -- a misdemeanor -- subject to up to 6 months that jail time is no big deal and being labeled as a criminal and oral threats and assaults. In such instances, they direct merely asking a question – whether it is about citizenship in jail. is also no big deal. IT IS to our mom and pop owners that individuals to file a complaint with the Criminal Section of or anything else. these Councilmembers are proposing to incarcerate. the Civil Rights Division, which is the appropriate criminal Under Section 45.42 (A) it states, “It shall be unlawful for agency to deal with such matters. The Apartment Association of Greater Los Angeles any Landlord, or any agent, employee or contractor of In addition, they also seem to fail to realize that a tenant’s urges you to call or write to these councilmembers and such Landlord, to do or attempt to do any of the following: memory about a conversation can change over time. An As for state law, as of November 2017 it is illegal to ask let them know you oppose these draconian measures. (A) Inquire as to the immigration or citizenship status of innocent conversation by the owner asking “where are a tenant or occupant (current or potential) about their
24 AUGUST 2018 • WWW.AAGLA.ORG APARTMENT AGE • AUGUST 2018 25 Tenant Problems? Eviction of non-performing tenants and collection of unpaid rent can be a frustrating, time-consuming, aggravating and expensive experience. Choosing the right law firm to handle your eviction and debt collection needs is critical. You NO DUMPING want a firm that has seen it all, that has the knowledge, experience and staff to handle your case right. No excuses, no delays, just the results you want! The Duringer Law Group is one of California's largest and most experienced landlord tenant law firms, and only represents landlords. The firm has successfully prosecuted over 245,000 evictions and has recovered over $155,000,000 in debt since 1988. Our vast experience and outstanding record of success is unmatched.
The Eviction Leader. Do Not Dump Bulky Items
Ask for FREE Tenant Eviction
Efficient and Effective legal representation. We have recovered over $155,000,000 for Don’t be vulnerable! Extensive experience pickup instead. Attorney fees of $95 to $150 plus costs for an our clients. No fee if no recovery. Put the in Asset Preservation strategies for high net uncontested residential eviction. No office visit power of an experienced law firm to work for worth individuals, including domestic and required, start case by email or over the phone. you. off-shore entities and strategies. Residential and commercial evictions handled in Call 1-800-773-2489 all courts and counties throughout California. E cient, Eective, Aordable! Download your FREE Copies! Our highly experienced attorneys and staff have developed procedures and processes that result in tenant evictions on the Eviction & Debt fastest track possible. The same efficiencies are evident in our Collection and Asset Preservation debt collection services. We deliver quality legal representation Strategies at and exceptional value. DuringerLaw.com www.DuringerLaw.com PENALTY FOR ILLEGAL DUMPING Locations Orange County office Asset Preservation Wilmington, 6 MONTHS IN JAIL AND/OR $1,000 FINE. Los Angeles San Diego 181 S. Old Springs Rd., 2nd Floor 28059 Lakes Edge Road Delaware 800.829.6994 800.829.6994 Mailing address: PO Box 28270 Mailing address: PO Box 2489 877.387.4643 Anaheim Hills, CA 92809 Lake Arrowhead, CA 92352-2489 LAMC 66.25 (A), (B), (C) AND LAMC 11.0 (M) Inland Empire Sacramento 714.279.1100 909.336.1160 800.829.6994 800.829.6994 800.829.6994 877.387.4643
26 AUGUST 2018 • WWW.AAGLA.ORG APARTMENT AGE • AUGUST 2018 27 SUCCESSFUL MANAGEMENT TECHNIQUES THAT WILL HELP AVOID LAWSUITS STAGE #1 2:00PM Top Property Management experts Brian and Vincent will share their top ten property management techniques; from marketing vacancies to minimizing your exposure to litigation. Landlords will learn firsthand from southern California's top professionals how to increase profits and minimize loss. This must see presentation will also uncover litigation trends that could save you hundreds of thousands of dollars. BRIAN GORDON & VINCENT MEDINA Lotus Property Services
THE TRUMP TAX PLAN & HOW IT COULD AFFECT REAL ESTATE INVESTORS STAGE #1 3:00PM With the recent changes to our tax code, many are confused as to how it affects them. During this talk, we will take a look at how this tax reform can impact those of various incomes who are in real estate. TONY WATSON Robert Hall & Associates FAIR HOUSING SEMINAR STAGE #2 10:00AM STAGE #2 Housing Discrimination litigation costs the housing industry millions of dollars each year. Learn how to prevent and avoid this from happening to you. Every person has the right to be offered housing or denied housing on the basis of their actions and in the manner in which they have chosen to live, not on the way they appear to you. This training will assist you in minimizing your liabilities. You will learn about Protected Classes, Housing for Families with Children, Prohibited, Practices, Occupancy Limits and much more! DENISE CATO . Fair Housing Council of Orange County The Apartment All Star Experience is like no other event you will attend this year. The unique blend of three national speakers on our stage at WHERE TO FIND HIGH CASH FLOW REAL ESTATE WITH 8-10% RETURNS STAGE #2 11:00AM one time creates an energy force that will be the most exciting time you will spend at a seminar. The reason is that this is not just a seminar, Discover ways to increase passive income, improve tax write-offs, invest with your IRA & add diversification to your Apartment All Stars is an event. This dynamic tour has been igniting the leasing and marketing arena for 11 solid years and only visits 12 cities investment portfolio. each year. We are pleased to welcome the All Stars to the Los Angeles Apartment & Buildings Expo, all new with fresh, up to the moment, ROBERT “RUSTY” TWEED information to win in any marketing! TFS Properties, Inc. STAGE #1 9:30AM RATIO UTILITY BILLING VS SUBMETERING STAGE #2 12:00PM Submetering is complicated and can be costly, however it is the most accurate way of billing a resident. When the cost to submeter exceed the benefit, will RUBS work for you? What is RUBS billing and how does it work? What are STAGE #1 the best practices for implementing a RUBS Billing Program? Would Submetering be an option for my property? What I need to know before submetering my community? Find out the answers to those questions with guest WHY PROPERTY RIGHTS MATTER? speaker Donna Ismajili. STAGE #1 11:30AM DONNA ISMAJILI According to DeWeese, the American system of free enterprise, private property ownership and individual liberty is under attack by a political force that, while plainly out in the open for all to see, is little understood and mostly ignored. National Exemption Service Yet private non-governmental organizations (NGOs), city planners and federal agencies have teamed up specifically to change human society under the banner of Sustainable Development. It is gaining power in every state, county, WANT TO LEARN ABOUT SEISMIC RETROFITTING? DOES YOUR and community under the false threat of Environmental Armageddon, demanding that we completely reorganize our PROPERTY NEED A RETROFIT? economic system, our representative form of government, and our individual lifestyle. STAGE #2 1:00PM During this workshop you can learn more about the basic principles behind retrofit engineering and construction, and Mike Brennan joins Tom DeWeese to make the case that such policies are a war on free enterprise, private property how to minimize the impact on tenants and parking spaces ownership, and individual choice. NAREK EKMEKJYAN MIKE BRENNAN Brennan Law Firm Optimum Seismic TOM DEWEESE American Policy Center THE SPREAD OF RENT CONTROL-PROTECT YOURSELF NOW! CASHING IN ON AMENITIES STAGE #1 1:00PM STAGE #2 2:00PM Dennis Block will explain the impact if the Costa Hawkins Act is repealed. This will affect all cities, even those that What amenities does today's renter want and how can you make more money by providing them? currently have rent control. KARI NEGRI DENNIS P. BLOCK SKY Properties Law Firm of Dennis P. Block & Associates DISCOVER THE EIGHT ADVANTAGES OF SECTION 8 PREMIUM SPONSORS: STAGE #2 3:00PM - How to receive reliable rental income - Take advantage of other benefits offered by housing authorities - What landlords think about the Housing Choice Voucher Program TRACIE MANN Housing Authority of County of Los Angeles MEDIA SPONSORS: FREE ONLINE REGISTRATION BUILDINGSLA.COM
28 AUGUST 2018 • WWW.AAGLA.ORG APARTMENT AGE • AUGUST 2018 29 Wood-Frame Seismic Retrofit $
125