LME Week: Focus On Demand, Economy And

Prices

SPECIAL PDF REPORT OCTOBER 2011

An employee works inside a rerolling mill at Chitra industrial area, on the outskirts of Bhavnagar town, in the western Indian state of Gujarat. /Amit Dave

• Global growth a worry, China to the rescue

• Iron , coal to move to shorter index-based pricing-ENRC

• Johnson Controls sees steady mkt in 2012

• Chinese smelters seek higher TC/RCs for 2012

• Codelco sees stable premiums for copper consumers

• Fair value copper price forecasts jump

• Softs to outperform metals in 2012-Bache

COMMODITIESLME WEEK: FOCUS SHIVER ON DEMAND,AFTER U.S. ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE AND PRICES OCTOBER AUGUST 20112011 Global growth a worry, China to the rescue By Susan Thomas LONDON, Oct 7 (Reuters) - emand for base metals has softened only slightly, propped up by tight supplies and strong Chinese appetite, even while prices have dropped as investors have retreated from markets in fear of a global economic downturn and Europe's debt crisis. D This is the message that echoed through London Metal Exchange Week, the main fixture in the global metals in- dustry calendar, which drew thousands of professionals this week. "There has been some softening in copper demand, but not to the extent seen in the copper price," Richard Adkerson, chief executive of Freeport McMoRan Copper & Inc , the world's largest publicly traded copper miner, said this week. Metals prices have dropped, particularly copper which is down 28 percent from a record high of $10,190 hit in February. "There is a disconnect right now, and that's because investors are concerned about the future. There are huge macroeconomic uncertainties, and it's driven by that," Adkerson said. Despite the global economic slowdown, producers are still selling their products, mostly to China which accounts for some 40 percent of demand for copper for use in construction, electrical wiring and power cables. "We haven't seen any of the early signs of push-back that you tend to get in tough markets, when people try to delay pay- ment," said Clive Newall, president of miner First Quantum , this week. "We haven't seen any of that, and talking to other copper producers, I am not sure anyone is really seeing it," he said. A Chinese return to the market to replenish its metals stocks also is inevitable, he added. The high price of the metal earlier this year prompted China to run down its stocks, and the industry has been anticipating its return to the international market for a top-up, especially with the price of copper at lower levels. "They (Chinese buyers) are opportunistic, and the copper price now is good," Antofagasta Chief Executive Marcelo Awad said. The country's thirst for other metals also remains unquenched. "The wheels are not falling off yet in terms of () demand," Gordon Hamilton, vice president, metal management sales and marketing at Rio Tinto Alcan , said. "We're seeing a slowdown, but it is somewhat regional."

Labourers arrange steel structures at the construction site of a new residential apartment in Hanoi September 20, 2011. VIETNAM-PROPERTY/ REUTERS/Kham 2

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 201120112011 Business in Asia is good, while North America has paused in some sectors, and the softest market is Europe, he said. An executive at Kazakh miner ENRC said the company was still seeing strong demand for iron ore from its Chinese clients and business was robust across its remaining . "We have not seen any issues on demand in China for anything," said Jim Cochrane, ENRC's chief commercial officer. Metals smelters around the globe are running at full capacity as they to try to catch up on the losses caused by strikes and a sharp decrease in investment in mines resulting from the economic downturn in 2008. WARNING The International Monetary Fund last month warned of the risk of severe repercussions on global growth of Europe's sovereign debt crisis and a painfully slow U.S. recovery. "The West faces painful de-leveraging, but emerging economies have a tool-kit to grow their economies," Nick Moore, an analyst at RBS, said in a note. "All eyes on China's imports, and if you listen carefully you can hear the drumming of its hooves riding to the rescue." But there were also whispers of caution this week. "Many analysts fall into the trap of thinking that just because Chinese people are becoming wealthier, they will become more like us in the West. This is a highly dangerous view," Paul Adkins, managing director of AZ China in Beijing, said. "Chinese people will not suddenly stop eating fresh vegetables in favour of pre-packaged (in aluminium trays and foil lids) frozen meals. They will not stop drinking tea or water in favour of canned beverages ... Chinese people will become more mod- ern but not more Western." The IMF also trimmed its forecasts of economic growth for China and other Asian economies due partly to slower growth in the rest of the world, although China's economy is still expected to grow 9.5 percent this year and 9 percent in 2012. "It comes back to China, and managing Chinese swings is going to be increasingly important for the global economy," Jan Haggstrom, chief economist at bank Svanska Handelsbanken, said recently. "The IMF still expects 9 percent growth in China, which is going to support metals demand. If China goes down to 6 percent, however as happened in 2008, then we will certainly see a drop in demand." And worries about the unresolved euro zone crisis will niggle, not least because China needs healthy countries to buy its ex- ports. "I think there's an awful lot of people worried about Europe," said Natixis analyst Nic Brown. "Usually I spend LME week talking to Europeans about what's going on in China, but this week I've spent more time talking to Chinese about what is going on in Europe." ($1 = 1.045 Canadian Dollars)

Iron ore, coal to move to shorter index-based pricing-ENRC By Silvia Antonioli and Clara Ferreira-Marques LONDON, Oct 7 (Reuters) - ricing for steel ingredients iron ore and coking coal is likely to move to shorter-term index-based mechanisms, Jim Cochrane, chief commercial officer of Kazakh miner ENRC , said. The top three iron ore miners Vale , Rio Tinto and BHP Billiton dumped a decades-old annual scheme last year in P favour of quarterly pricing. Although most steelmakers still hope for a return to the annual benchmark, which al- lowed them to better control their costs, shorter-term deals look inevitable to many in the industry.

A boy collects scrap metal to recycle from a sewage drain in Quetta on September 16, 2011. REUTERS/Naseer Ahmed 3

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUST AUGUSTAUGUST 2011 201120112011 "I think the quotation period will come closer to the market," Cochrane told Reuters in an interview. "I believe that an estab- lished market price is here to stay." London-listed ENRC produces iron ore, ferrochrome, alumina and aluminium, copper, cobalt and also owns a coal project in Mozambique. It sells iron ore to Chinese customers using a quarterly price broadly based on the Platts iron ore index while for iron ore sales to Russian steelmaker Magnitogorsk Iron and Steel Works (MMK) it applies the same methodology as Vale. Brazil's Vale uses a quarterly system in which prices are decided by a three-month average of the Platts North China 62 per- cent FE CFR index beginning four months before the relevant quarter. "For me (this mechanism) is not workable in the long term. I just think that they will shorten the period by which they establish the price," Cochrane added. Almost all of ENRC iron ore is sold on long-term contracts rather than on a spot basis. Pricing mechanisms for coking coal and aluminium are also likely to change soon, according to the miner. "I think that over time most prices will move towards a shorter-term pricing mechanism based on indices," Cochrane said. "Probably for alumina as well, although the argument for alumina is less strong because it's effectively market-priced anyway as it varies as a percentage of the aluminium price, but I do think there is some momentum to move to index-based prices." ENRC coal assets in Mozambique are located near coal mines owned by large miners such as Vale and Rio Tinto's Riversdale, and Cochrane said a partnership to build logistics with these companies is very likely. "I do think that you will have to have some sort of partnership for logistics. There will be a solution and it will be a solution of a consortium of the major producers," he said.

Johnson Controls sees steady lead mkt in 2012 By Karen Norton LONDON, Oct 6 (Reuters) - .S. auto supplier Johnson Controls said it expects the market for battery material lead to be relatively stable next year and its customers as yet seem unperturbed by worries over recession in western nations. "I think the outlook for the lead market next year is relatively stable," the company's Vice President and General U Manager for Lead Americas Mike Carr told Reuters in a phone interview. "I don't know that we've heard much in the way of customer concerns about the global economy. Our business is good globally year on year, I would say our battery sales are pretty good." On Thursday, the London Metal Exchange (LME) three-months lead price was indicated at $1,925.25 a tonne, above last week's 14-month lows of $1,800, as investors take heart from efforts by Europe to help its financial sector. But prices are still about $1,000 a tonne below levels seen in April. Johnson Controls produced 120 million lead-acid batteries last year, making it the world leader. Lead-acid batteries, used mainly in cars, account for around 80 percent of world lead demand. As part of its battery business, Johnson Controls recycles old batteries to produce secondary lead, which is then used to make more batteries. It is in the process of expanding its lead output. The company is building a new battery recycling plant in Florence, South Carolina with a capital investment of $150 million. The facility, which is due to start up around next summer, will have the capacity to produce just over 130,000 tonnes per year (tpy) of refined lead, Carr said. Johnson Controls has also applied for a permit to double capacity at its Krautscheid plant in Germany to 120,000 tpy. Mean- while, the company's Garcia smelter in Mexico, which came on stream last November, was very close to full capacity of 130,000 tpy, according to Carr. "We don't have any plans on the board currently to add any other new (recycling) facilities. However we do continually evalu- ate the market. If conditions dictate we have proven we can add capacity pretty quickly," Carr said. All the refined secondary lead Johnson Controls produces is used to make its batteries, but its output does not satisfy all its needs. "We're still buying lead, depending on the region of the world. In North America our stated objective is to be about 50 percent vertically-integrated, so we're still buying quite a bit of lead." START-STOP Carr said new start-stop batteries were making advances and would result in more lead being used because of the heavier demands.

4

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUST AUGUSTAUGUST 2011 201120112011

Laborers are silhouetted at daybreak as they unload steel rods at the site of a bridge construction in Lahore. REUTERS/Mohsin Raza

The technology allows an engine to automatically switch off, when the car stops at traffic lights for example, and spring back to life when the driver presses the accelerator. "Start-stop batteries have really done quite well in Europe and we now believe that's moving to the U.S. and even to China" Carr said. Johnson Controls had made significant investments in start-stop batteries in Europe to get capacity to over 11.0 million units and was also investing in the United States to have the capacity to produce 6.8 million, he said. "For the lead part of the business we do believe it will translate to the start-stop batteries that we produce having more lead in them versus standard batteries." The original equipment market for start-stop batteries was expected to reach 35 million by 2015, he said.

Chinese copper smelters seek higher TC/RCs for 2012 By Polly Yam LONDON, Oct 6 (Reuters) - hinese copper smelters are seeking higher yearly treatment and refining charges for term copper concentrate imports for the full year of 2012 as they expect supply to rise, while trading sources say some global miners may switch to quarterly charges. C For 2012, smelters now want treatment and refining charges (TC/RCs) they receive for converting term concentrate imports into metal of $60-$80 per tonne and 6-8 U.S. cents per pound for the full year delivery, smelter sources told Reuters at a gathering late on Wednesday in London. If set, those charges will be the second straight year smelters win higher TC/RCs from global miners. TC/RCs were set at $56.5 and 5.65 cents for full year of 2011 for standard, clean concentrates, up from $46.5 and 4.65 cents in 2010. In 2011, Chinese smelters for the first time set half-year TC/RCs for term concentrate deliveries with global miner BHP Billiton Ltd and agreed the charges at $72 and 7.2 cents for the first half and $90 and 9 cents for the second half. "Next year's TC/RCs definitely would rise from this year. There would have to be some new and expanded production to come on the stream," a senior executive at a large Chinese copper smelter said.

5

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUST AUGUSTAUGUST 2011 201120112011 "Having considered $72 in the first half and $90 for the second half, the average for this year is over $80. We should have more than that," he said, of next year. The senior executive said the recent volatility in the markets and worries over a debt crisis in developed countries were making Chinese smelters unwilling to rush for any decisions on the TC/RCs for next year, for now. Global mine production is expected to see a bigger rise next year than 2011 and 2010 and Mongolia's Oyu Tolgoi, the world's largest undeveloped copper and gold project located 80 kilometers (47 miles) north of the Mongolia-China border may poten- tially have supply of spot concentrates in late 2012. "If smelters can get $80, they will be very happy," an executive at a smelter said. A trading manager at a smelter said smelters may even be willing to accept $60 and 6 cents since the concentrate market was tight now. Smelter sources said global miners had not made any indications on TC/RCs for next year during the LME Week in London this week. Traders said Chinese smelters may receive similar TC/RCs for 2012 from this year because potential strikes in resource-rich areas such as Indonesia and South America could offset expanded production in the global market. QUARTERLY TC/RCS Chinese smelters also face more frequent talks with global miners on TC/RCs for term concentrates next year. Smelter sources said a large miner was likely to offer quarterly TC/RCs to Chinese smelters for next year, a move that other miners may follow suit, allowing miners more flexibility in pricing their output. For now, smelters are not keen to accept quarterly TC/RCs for term concentrates because that require frequent talks and more work to smelters, a trading director at a smelter said. But some smelters expecting higher spot TC/RCs than yearly benchmark next year are willing to accept quarterly pricing, which is expected to reflect the spot market. TC/RCs are paid by overseas sellers to Chinese smelters for converting concentrate imports into refined metal and deducted from concentrate sale prices based on London Metal Exchange copper prices . Higher charges, typically seen when supply rises or demand falls, cut concentrate import prices. Smelter officials and traders said TC/RCs for spot concentrates to China had changed hands at $45-$55 and 4.5-5.5 cents for standard concentrates and China had increased buying of spot due to the delays of contracted shipments from Chile.

A worker winds aluminium and iron wires used to making electrical power lines at a factory on the outskirts of Jammu September 12, 2011. REUTERS/Mukesh Gupta

6

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUST AUGUSTAUGUST 2011 201120112011 Smelters also had been restocking for the fourth quarter metal production. Offers for spot concentrates are being indicated at TC/RCs of just above $40 and 4 cents versus $50-$60 and 5-6 cents in late September, traders and smelter officials said. Part of Chinese smelters' 2011 shipments for delivery in the second half from the world's No. 1 copper mine Escondida could be delayed to next year, after the Chilean mine, majority-owned by BHP Billiton , lifted a strike-driven force majeure earlier this month, the sources said. Spot TC/RCs fell 18 percent between July and early September.

COLUMN-Aluminium-The dangers of comparative analysis (The opinions expressed in this article represent the views of the author.) By Paul Adkins, Managing Director, AZ China Limited, Beijing. LONDON, Oct 6 (Reuters)- luminium has been traded on the London Metal Exchange (LME) for more than 30 years, and analysts have been charting, monitoring and trying to predict the course of the metal since then. Over those years, a rich history has developed, both within the rises and falls of the metal's price, and within the of- A fices and corridors of those who seek to understand and comment on aluminium. It has helped that often the same commentators have been able to draw on their knowledge of other base metals. Copper and tin for instance, have been traded on the LME even longer. China, on the other hand, is a relatively new market for most analysts. It is fair to say that until China entered the WTO in 2001, most Western analysts simply did not include China in their view of the market. It is natural, therefore, for analysts to turn to their trusty tools when trying to chart, understand and extrapolate the Chinese market. But it is a dangerous assumption to expect that China's primary aluminium industry and the market will follow the patterns that have been evident outside China. For one thing, there is only 10 years of history to draw on, and of that, most years are exceptional rather than typical.

An Iraqi worker inspects iron that has been melted in the oven before pouring it in a frame at a workshop in Baghdad September 13, 2011. REUTERS/Saad Shalash

7

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 201120112011 In 2004, the Chinese government, working through its agency the China Nonferrous Industry Association, moved to close all smelters which were using "Soderberg" technology. An edict was issued, calling for all plants under 50,000 tonnes a year to close. However, many proprietors simply chose to rip out their old Soderberg lines, and replace them with more modern "pre-bake" technology. Since the latter is far more efficient and productive, China's metal production accelerated dramatically through 2006 and 2007 and into 2008. By the end of 2008 however, the boom production period was over. MORE RESPONSIVE, MORE REACTIVE China was the first to cut output in the wake of the global economic crisis, slashing output by 30%. China was also the first to rebound, as the government's RMB4 trillion stimulus package gained traction in the economy. More specifically, the government purchased almost 700,000 tonnes via its Strategic Reserves Board. That was enough to kick-start the industry, and again, China was the first to rebound, with output quickly returning to pre-global financial crisis levels. The point is that, at least on the supply side of the equation, China's market is more responsive, more reactive than what we are used to in the West. Quite simply, it is unsafe to say use historical trends as a guide. There simply isn't enough history to use. A second problem for those attempting to understand the Chinese market is that the official data is often incorrect. There are two major data sources that most analysts use - The China Nonferrous Industry Association (or its daughter com- pany Antaike), or the China National Bureau of Statistics. Using either of these is fraught with danger. Despite its name, the CNIA is a government body. It is the instrument through which the government expects to roll out its policies and rulings. It is headquartered in Beijing, and is a central government agency. As such, not all aluminium smelters bother to keep in touch with the CNIA, and sometimes the CNIA does not talk to certain smelters. Those which have been built without Central Government Planning authority (often those which have been built by provincial governments who feel that they don't need Beijing approval), are sometimes omitted from the CNIA production data.

Men look for metals and other valuables in the waste waters of the city dump in Guatemala City September 7, 2011. REUTERS/Jorge Dan Lopez 8

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 To give an example, when the 2010 year closed, the CNIA came out with a production figure of 16 million tonnes. Most of us inside the country knew this was patently wrong. Our own analysis told us it was 17.5 million tonnes; others came out with estimates between 17.1 and 17.5 million. Finally, about four to five months later, Antaike published a small footnote, adjusting the 2010 production figure to 17.6 mil- lion tonnes. That is no small adjustment. Many Western-based commentators tell me they don't trust the NBS numbers either. It is true that the NBS has had many problems with their data, partly because they are trying to roll up information across dozens of commodities, in time for pub- lishing by the 10th of the following month (CNIA production data comes out around the 20th of the following month.) But their figures are becoming increasingly more reliable. For the record, we use NBS as a starting point, and verify by checking as many smelters as we can each month. One last point about the NBS data - their website has an English version and a Chinese version, but the data available in Chi- nese is much more comprehensive than on the English side. Another reason to be wary of analysts who model China's market after the West is that China is not like the rest of the world. Most analysts agree that aluminium consumption patterns reflect those of a developing economy, with the building and con- struction sector being a principal driver. MORE MODERN, NOT MORE WESTERN However, many analysts fall into the trap of thinking that just because Chinese people are becoming wealthier, they will be- come more like us in the West. This is a highly dangerous view. Chinese people will not suddenly stop eating fresh vegetables in favour of pre-packaged (in aluminium trays and foil lids) fro- zen meals. They will not stop drinking tea or water in favour of canned beverages. They will not suddenly start taking holiday flights overseas, using airliners that have several tonnes of the light metal in them. Chinese people will become more modern, but not more western. That is not to say that packaging, transport and other sectors that dominate Western consumption patterns won't enjoy an increase. Of course they will, but not at the heady rates that some have suggested. I suspect that many people simply don't understand the size and scale of the Chinese primary aluminium industry and market. There are more aluminium smelters in China than in the rest of the world combined.

A blacksmith hammers hot iron to make a sickle at his shop in Kolkata August 18, 2011. REUTERS/Rupak De Chowdhuri 9

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 The industry is owned to a large extent by the central and provincial governments, and even those that are privately owned still have Communist Party committees inside them. Frankly, I don't believe it is possible to get a thorough understanding of the market without being able to speak Chinese, and without being able to talk to people here face to face. STOCKS CONCERNS Some analysts worry about the fact that China's inventory of metal has fallen dramatically over the last few months. It's true that it is down to less than 100,000 tonnes now, but one needs to keep a couple of things in perspective. At its peak, the visible Shanghai inventory was pushing 500,000 tonnes, but many analysts seem to forget that 500,000 ton- nes is not even two weeks supply in China. Sure, 100,000 tonnes is only two days supply, but it tells me that these inventory points are not where a lot of the metal is traded. This is reflected in the fact that prices often moved counter to the inventory trends, going up as stocks also went up. Our experience is that a good deal of metal is sold on a direct basis. Doing so allows producers to gain access to better pay- ment terms - Shanghai is 30 days, but direct sales can attract seven days terms, which assists producers greatly in their cash flow management. Another area where some overseas-based analysts fail to understand the Chinese market is in the area of imports and exports. China will always import some metal, because for many semi-finished applications that are sold into the export market, for instance alloy wheels, it is cheaper for the semi-finished plant manager to import metal, then re-export it as the final product. Most of the alloy wheels that are exported from China are made from imported metal. By doing so, the producer avoids sales tax, which today sits at 17%. Finally, one of the most important reasons why we cannot use our traditional models from the West to understand and predict China is that the structure of the economy and business in China is very different to that of the West. The Communist Party, not the government, drives China's economy, and all its levers, factors, instruments and vehicles. China's banks, finance houses, government departments and even some of China's aluminium companies have their CEOs appointed by the Party, not by boards, HR managers or politicians. People in London, New York or other Western centres sometimes ask me how it is that provincial governments and many busi- nesses in China simply ignore government directives.

A man rides his bike through a gap in a row of metal rods that delineates the line along which the Berlin Wall used to run at the Berlin Wall memorial site in Bernauer Strasse in Berlin, August 9, 2011. REUTERS/Thomas Peter 10

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 The answer is very personal - if you want to enhance your career, you must meet the Party's Key Performance Areas, which are heavily stacked towards measuring your personal contribution to economic growth. So you do what helps your career, and leave the problems for the next person who gets your job when you are promoted. MARKET MANIPULATION Perhaps one area where there is commonality between China's aluminium market and that of the West is in the manmade distortions that sometimes occur. Metal is sometimes withheld from the market, making inventory seem lower and forcing the price up. Market players some- times under report, sometimes over-report. We have seen many instances. One example was in the "Energy Intensity" period in the second half of last year, when the gov- ernment called on smelters to cut back. In some cases, smelters simply ignored Beijing, while in others, provincial govern- ments over-ruled the central directive, ordering plants to stay at full capacity. There are many fine analysts in the marketplace, all with their own views on what will happen in China, and how that will af- fect the rest of the global market. Just make sure that the one you are using is getting his or her data from primary sources and verifying that data, not simply repeating official announcements, and that he/she is not simply using standard analytical tools to come up with their prog- nostications. Challenge their thinking on demand patterns, historical trends, and underlying forces. Hopefully your analyst has done the hard work before they build their models and make their forecasts for you.

Tight copper concentrate a feature for some years By Pratima Desai and Susan Thomas LONDON, Oct 6 (Reuters) - ight copper concentrate supplies and excess smelting capacity for the industrial metal will remain a feature of the market for some years to come, Javier Targhetta, president of Spanish smelter company Atlantic Copper said. But Targhetta refused to be drawn on whether that would translate into lower treatment and refining charges (TC/ T RCs) for the metal used widely in power and construction. "There is copper concentrate tightness and our view is that the tightness will remain for a number of years," Targhetta said. "There is also new smelting capacity, especially in China and India ... Some smelters may not be at full capacity." Benchmark TC/RCs were agreed at $56 a tonne and $5.65 a lb for this year from $46.5 and 4.65 cents respectively in 2010. Annual negotiations for TC/RCs between smelters and miners began this week as the industry gathered for London Metal Exchange week. Chinese copper smelters are seeking higher TC/RCs for copper concentrate imports for the full year of 2012 as they expect supply to rise and trading sources say some global miners may switch to quarterly charges. Smelters are looking for $60-$80 per tonne and 6-8 cents per pound for next year, sources told Reuters. If agreed, those charges will be the second straight year of higher TC/RCs. Global mine production is expected to see a bigger rise next year than 2011 and 2010 and Mongolia's Oyu Tolgoi, the world's largest undeveloped copper and gold project located 80 kilometers (47 miles) north of the Mongolia-China border may poten- tially have supply of spot concentrates in late 2012. Targhetta said the fundamentals of the copper market were strong and that prospects for the metal were good. "Copper's usage is increasing both in terms of growth and in terms of intensity. New applications such as electric vehicles bear twice as much copper as traditional vehicles," he said. "And in turn the traditional vehicle caries twice as much copper as it did 25 years ago." Copper's surge to a record high of $10,190 a tonne on February 15 this year has accelerated the search for substitutes. Bench- mark prices on the London Metal Exchange were trading at around $7,120 a tonne. "But you have heard of copper's antimicrobial properties, how it has been proven that it reduces hospital infections by 40 per- cent. That is very promising." Targhetta agreed that demand for copper for use in hospitals was small, but he said the amounts for this application could be significant in the future. Atlantic Copper is a subsidiary of U.S.-based Freeport-McMoRan Copper & Gold.

11

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 London Mining CEO confident on Sierra Leone LONDON, Oct 6 (Reuters) - ron ore developer London Mining Plc said it is confident about operating successfully in Sierra Leone, amid growing global resource nationalism in the mining industry, because the country is keen to bring in foreign investment. "The government are completely behind developing Sierra Leone's prosperity. They understand that Sierra Leone needs I foreign capital to develop its industries, particularly the resource industries," Chief Executive Graeme Hossie told Reuters on Thursday. London Mining, along with rival AIM-listed iron ore group African Minerals Ltd , both expect to ship their first iron ore from Sierra Leone this year. The West African country is due to hold a presidential election next year, a decade after the end of a bloody 11-year civil war. "They want to show some examples of success and they want to attract capital into the oil exploration field because offshore oil has been found and that requires a huge amount of investment," said Hossie. "They want to make sure they don't do anything that will scare off international investors." Advisory and accountancy firm Ernst & Young said resource nationalism is the biggest threat facing the mining sector this year and Zambia's recent election has again highlighted the problem. London Mining hopes to ship the first iron ore this year from its Marampa operation in Sierra Leone and ramp up production, in two phases, to 16 million tonnes a year. Glencore , the world's largest listed diversified commodities trader, has an offtake agreement that will see it take about 9.5 million tonnes of iron ore from Marampa over five years. Hossie said they can sell more on the same terms or use Glencore as an agent if they choose to sell to steel mills. "We aim to sell with Glencore into Europe as much as we can but we also aim to sell to China." Hossie also said any change of ownership at the surrounding Marampa iron ore project, owned by Cape Lambert Resources , would not affect London Mining's ability to transport ore as it has full access rights. "We are fully self sufficient," he said.

Iron ore is loaded into a pile at Fortescue Metals Cloudbreak iron ore mine, about 250km (155 miles) southeast of Port Hedland in Western Australia state, July 25, 2011. , REUTERS/Morag MacKinnon 12

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 GREENLAND-CHINA LINKS The company also has an iron ore project in Greenland, which like Marampa contains an estimated resource of over 1.0 billion tonnes, that it hopes will start producing in 2015. "The only thing we need to find is a partner to fund the capex," Hossie said, adding that the project is estimated to cost about $2.2 billion to develop. "It makes sense for us to partner with China," said Hossie, adding that the high quality 70-percent iron content of the ore could be used to blend with lower quality Chinese ore. "We are already in talks with Chinese companies and once we finish the bankable feasibility study at the end of this year we will also be talking to Western steel companies as well." London Mining aims to produce more than 30 million tonnes of iron ore within the next five years from Marampa and the Isua project in Greenland. Marampa operated between 1933 and 1975 before low iron ore prices forced the previous owners to close it down. Hossie is upbeat about the outlook for iron ore. "The big three iron ore miners can't keep up with demand and neither can the traditional swing capacity producers which has been Chinese domestic production," "There you see grades falling, they are mining flat out, but the actual concentrate pro- duced is less," he said, referring to Chinese output. He said local producers have gone from supplying about 50 percent of China's needs to below 30 percent in 2008. Spot iron ore prices are down about 5.5 percent from the start of September to around $170 a tonne, but are still about three times the level they traded at in the last global financial crisis. Top consumer China is on holiday this week. "China has huge building programmes, and these are not the things that financial market scares turn on and off. China's de- mand is growing and emerging market demand is growing - India is going to be increasingly coming on the scene."

Prysmian does not see drastic 2012 copper demand slowdown By Karen Norton LONDON, Oct 6 (Reuters) - lobal copper demand in the second half of this year may ease, but a drastic slowdown next year is unlikely, Italy- based copper product maker Prysmian said on Thursday. "We have the feeling copper demand is slowing down globally in the second semester; it's not what it was in the first G semester," Tayfun Anik, the company's chief procurement officer, told Reuters. "It's too early to say for demand next year, but we don't have the feeling there will be a drastic slowdown." To illustrate current uncertainty, Anik said order level visibility had fallen to 80 percent from 100 percent. China, which accounts for around 40 percent of global copper usage of almost 20.0 million tonnes, would be key to copper consumption growth next year, he said. "Don't forget a big chunk that goes into China is for getting out again. If the U.S. and Europe have problems that will definitely have an effect on Chinese consumption." Prysmian, the world's largest cable maker, consumes about 500,000 tonnes a year of copper, 90 percent in the form of copper rods. The fact that the company has 100 factories in over 30 countries helps it to ride out economic downturns, Anik said. "It's a kind of . We don't feel so strongly the ups and downs of the cycle," Anik said. He said Prysmian was fully hedged in terms of its pricing activity and worked with low inventory levels. "We're very working capital conscious, we try to keep our stocks as low as possible, especially on raw materials. We run more or less just-in-time on the physical part." DEFICIT AGAIN Anik said the global copper market would probably be in a slight deficit again next year, due to persistent supply disruptions including potential strike action and falling ore grades at some major mines. On Tuesday, the Lisbon-based International Copper Study Group (ICSG) forecast demand would outstrip supply by 250,000 tonnes next year, following a 200,000-tonne shortfall this year. Against a backdrop of continued tight supply, copper prices could average $8,500 a tonne next year as a broad guess, Anik said. "But $6,000 would be a satisfactory price for everyone in the industry, for miners and for consumers. It would be a price at which miners could still invest," Anik said. Benchmark prices for the metal, used in power and construction, were last indicated at $7,225.15 a tonne and are still high historically despite a recent sell-off which took them to 14-month lows of $6,635 a tonne. Prysmian's Anik said substitution in the cable industry due to the high price of copper compared with aluminium had more or less finished. The company uses around 180,000 tonnes a year of aluminium. The LME three-month aluminium price was last indicated at $2,225 a tonne.

13

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 Supply woes will hold up copper price-First Quantum By Clara Ferreira-Marques LONDON, Oct 5 (Reuters) - iner First Quantum Minerals does not expect copper prices, down almost 27 percent since the start of September, to reach lows hit in 2008 as constrained supply and healthier mining companies underpin the price. "I don't see that happening this time around. The world is very different, and the mining sector is in a very different M place in terms of gearing and availability of cash ... it is in a much stronger (position)," First Quantum President Clive Newall said in an interview. Echoing comments on demand made by other copper producers this week, Newall said there had been no signs of cutbacks from customers and that a Chinese return to the market for restocking was inevitable, though the timing was hard to predict. "We haven't seen any of the early signs of pushback that you tend to get in tough markets, when people try to delay payment," Newall told Reuters. "We haven't seen any of that, and talking to other copper producers, I am not sure anyone is really seeing it." He said the copper price was at the lower end of the expected range but "not dramatically low", though he warned it was get- ting close to or already below the incentive cost for new mines to be developed. "It is going to delay future development if (the price) stayed at these levels for any length of time," he said. First Quantum currently produces the bulk of its output at the Kansanshi copper-gold mine in Zambia, Africa's largest copper mine. Newall declined to comment on expectations for Zambia's new president and on a surprise move by the new government this week to suspend metal export permits. Newly elected President Michael Sata has been concerned that copper exporters are misreporting the amount of ore leaving the country. Last week he said all export payments would have to be routed via the central bank. Newall also declined to comment on market rumours the company would consider selling its Guelb Moghrein project in Mau- ritania. Sources familiar with the matter said last month that Rick Clark, the former chief executive of Red Back Mining, had approached First Quantum with a view to buying the copper-gold project.

A labourer loads coils of steel wire at a steel market in Shenyang, Liaoning province, August 1, 2011. REUTERS/Sheng Li 14

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 One of the sources has since said the First Quantum board is waiting for a firm bid to materialise, though it is unclear whether Clark could raise the financing in current markets. First Quantum also plans to enter the market with the Ravensthorpe and Kevitsa projects, in Australia and Finland re- spectively, in 2012. It has also been actively tapping new copper deposits, with the Sentinel copper deposit in Zambia, where it has locked in deliv- eries for long lead items of equipment and is expecting completion in 2014, and the Haquira copper deposit in Peru, adjacent to Xstrata's Las Bambas. Newall said First Quantum could consider listing depositary receipts on the Lima exchange, increasingly popular with miners looking to develop assets in the region, following its steps in Zambia, where it listed in July. First Quantum is also close to appointing a new chief financial officer, replacing Mark Bolton who resigned in August. Newall said the company had a shortlist of three and would make an announcement "very soon".

Antofagasta sees Chinese restocking move soon By Clara Ferreira-Marques LONDON, Oct 5 (Reuters) - hinese buyers are close to coming back into the market for copper re-stocking if prices stay at or below current levels, Antofagasta Chief Executive Marcelo Awad said. "I think we are getting close. They (Chinese buyers) are opportunistic and the copper price now is good ... if you com- C pare with all the forecasting for the coming months, years," Awad said, adding he expected the price to rise in the short term as a result, up from current levels of around $6,900. "I think we will see $8,000 in coming weeks. (Next year) will really depend on the overall economy." Awad, speaking at the Chilean miner's London headquarters, said the company had seen no order cancellations and no re- quests for delayed shipments. "I can't say yet what will happen with the annual contracts for copper cathode, because we are just starting (negotiations)... but the good news is that we haven't received any requests for cancellations for the remaining months of the year," he told Reuters in an interview.

A metal vendor sits in his shop in Old Dhaka July 24, 2011. REUTERS/Andrew Biraj 15

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 Awad, a copper veteran who has been at the helm of Antofagasta since 2004, said copper fundamentals were strong, with supply continuing to come in below forecasts. The International Copper Study Group said this week it sees a deficit of 200,000 tonnes this year globally and 250,000 next year. Antofagasta, which has been listed on the since 1888, has a string of projects in its $20 billion pipeline from now until the end of the decade, including $1.35 billion Antucoya, which will be put to the board with the aim of begin- ning construction this year, once sulphuric acid supply has been resolved. But the group will consider its spending cautiously in an environment of weaker prices and escalating costs. Antucoya, for ex- ample, will cost more than the market initially expected. "We need to analyse very carefully what we will do for the existing portfolio of projects, especially the one which is first on the list, Antucoya," he said. "We are approaching a crucial decision for the project in the middle of this uncertainty -- but I am confident we will launch the project." He said Antucoya was a clear example of rising costs in the industry. It is the same size and uses the same technology as its producing El Tesoro mine and is also in the Atacama region, but will cost over a billion dollars more, just a decade later. "There is market pressure on all the new projects, even brownfield projects, which is unbelievable," Awad said. The miner's main asset is the Los Pelambres open pit mine, but it also controls El Tesoro and Michilla. It is currently ramping up production at its flagship greenfield site Esperanza, where Awad said output was on target. The group was forced to cut its 2011 production target in June due to slower-than-expected progress at Esperanza. Awad said it was on target to produce 620,000 to 640,000 tonnes. OPTIMISTIC ON PAKISTAN Historically rooted in Chile, Antofagasta has been looking further afield for high quality growth, in Minnesota through its Twin Metals venture with Duluth Metals and in Pakistan, with the $3.4 billion Reko Diq copper-gold project it is hoping to build with partner Barrick Gold . Reko Diq, seen as an example of how miners' appetite for risk is changing in the search for quality assets, has suffered delays and setbacks, most recently objections raised by local authorities to the granting of a mining licence and fresh demands, in- cluding a smelter and refinery. Awad said almost half of the requirements listed in a letter last month to Tethyan -- the joint venture which controls the pro- ject -- were not included in the original agreement, including demands for a smelter and refinery, which remain outside the scope of the project.

A man prepares metal sheets to make storage boxes at a workshop in Lahore July 22, 2011. REUTERS/Mohsin Raza 16

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 Baluchistan, where there has been growing anger about outsiders exploiting natural resources, has said it wants to export a more value-added product, but Tethyan has long indicated it has no plans to build a refinery or smelter. "They are raising that we should have on the feasibility study a smelter and a refinery. We have told them many times... we were not planning to build a smelter and a refinery, (though) we are prepared to support, with a copper concentrate supply, anyone that wants to build," Awad told Reuters. "We are confident we will go ahead with the project, perhaps not with the timeline we have in place, but it is a world class de- posit and a massive geological resource."

Royal Nickel has enough cash for Canada mine By Karen Norton and Pratima Desai LONDON, Oct 5 (Reuters) - oronto-listed Royal Nickel Corp is hopeful the global economy will pick up pace again next year, but said it has raised enough cash anyway to keep it on track during 2012 with its large nickel project in Canada. Benchmark nickel prices were last at $18,500 a tonne. In September they fell below $17,000, their lowest since De- T cember 2009 and down over 40 percent from levels close to $29,500 in February, as demand worries pummeled in- dustrial metals. "There is concern generally about how long it (economic uncertainty) will last and the impact on financing costs going forward, but we have a bit of a cushion to get us through 2012 if we have to," said Tyler Mitchelson, president and CEO of Royal Nickel. "We don't need to go the market right now." The company completed its initial public offering (IPO) last December, raising $45 million in capital. Royal Nickel's Dumont nickel mine in northwestern Quebec is due on-stream towards the end of 2015, with a pre-feasibility study due out in November. The original cost estimate for the mine was $2.3 billion. However, the company is taking a staged approach and is aiming to start the project at about half its production capacity. "We expect that to be somewhere between $1.2-$1.4 billion," said Mark Selby, Royal Nickel's senior vice president, business development, adding that about 50-60 percent of that will come from project finance lenders such as banks and export credit agencies. The company would look to bring in a partner to take a 30-40 percent interest in the project, adding that that partner could be a stainless steel producer seeking to move up stream. "We need someone who's got a good balance sheet, who has a long term strategic view, who will invest in a mine with a 25- year life," Mitchelson said. Royal Nickel is confident of the project's timing because of its location in a politically stable region, with a history of mining, and where the permitting process does not encounter delays. At full capacity it is expected to produce 64,000 tonnes a year of nickel in concentrate, making it the fourth largest nickel sul- phide mine behind those owned by some of the world's biggest producers of the metal, including Russia's . CUPBOARD BARE Royal Nickel is looking beyond the string of nickel projects coming on stream in the next three to five years, which has drawn predictions of a prolonged period of over-supply. "After 2015/16 the (projects) cupboard starts to look pretty bare," Selby said. Large, new nickel sulphide projects are a rarity and Mitchelson said ore grades were falling at many existing sulphide mines, adding to pressure on supply further ahead. Most new nickel projects contain laterite ore which is deeper down and harder to treat than sulphide ore. A number use, or will use high pressure acid leach (HPAL) technology, which has had its share of problems in earlier, and in some cases more recent incarnations. On Monday, Royal Nickel said it had successfully produced a high-grade ferro-nickel product directly from concentrate at Dumont. The process, by avoiding the need to refine, significantly reduces production costs. Aside from Dumont, Royal Nickel may also seek potential deposits in North America, parts of Europe, Australia and possibly Africa. The company would also look at producing copper and group metals. (PGMs). "We are looking to become a mid-tier base metals miner," Mitchelson said.

17

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 Raising delivery rates will not solve warehouse queues-CEO By Susan Thomas LONDON, Oct 5 (Reuters) - aising the minimum daily delivery rate of metals out of London Metal Exchange-monitored warehouses even more will lead to more financing deals and exacerbate queues, LME Chief Executive Martin Abbott said on Tuesday. "Raising the load-out rate could have the perverse effect of making the financing deals even bigger, because faster R access to the metal would makes the deals more profitable," Abbott said in a speech to the LME Week annual din- ner. In July, the LME raised the minimum daily volume of metal that the larger warehouses it monitors must deliver in a bid to un- block long delays. The LME has been reviewing its warehousing operations in response to discontent about logjams in its system, mostly focused on Detroit, where delays to get aluminium can stretch out as long as nine months. Abbott said that while the focus had been on aluminium, there were other metals caught in the queues, and the LME was studying ways to alleviate that. "There is not simple answer, but we are working on it," he said. EXACERBATE The LME recently changed its rules raising the miniumum load-out rate at the warehouses it monitors. Larger warehousing firms, with operations in a single location that store more than 900,000 tonnes will from next April have to load out a mini- mum of 3,000 tonnes per day. "So why don't we raise the load-out rates even higher, rather than merely doubling the rate for the largest warehouses? Be- cause, to do so might actually exacerbate the situation," Abbott said on Tuesday. Financing deals, many forged in the aftermath of the credit crunch in late 2008, have tied up stocks in long-term warehouse rent agreements, where set storage and financing costs fall well below the rising market price of the metals. The deals are lucrative as long as interest rates remain low and metal plentiful.

18

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 "We do understand that consumers see large inventories and expect to pay lower premiums for their metal," Abbott said. "We know that the consumers are frustrated by the fact that the LME stocks do not give them pricing power in premium nego- tiations. But that is a fact of the current macro-economic situation." He said it was not the LME's job to intervene in macro- economics. "Central Bank policy will make the queues go away, and in the meantime the LME will shine a light on the impact of loose money in the market." On the possible sale of the LME, Abbott said any potential buyers would have to show a compelling reason why shareholders should sell. "While that is not impossible, I do hope they are not underestimating the height of the mountain that they have to climb," he said, adding: "The LME has not put itself up for sale." The LME, the world's biggest market for industrial metals, said last month it was considering a sale after receiving "several expressions of interest". Abbott said last week there were more than nine interested parties. "Anybody bidding for the LME is doing so because the LME is good at what it does, and because efforts to do it differently have not worked," Abbott said.

Metals volatile near term, medium term bright-CRU LONDON, Oct 4 (Reuters) - ndustrial metals markets could become more volatile in the next year or so, as continued global economic uncertainty buf- fets prices, but medium term prospects remain strong, consultancy CRU Group said on Tuesday. "Our expectation is that metals prices, if anything, will be more volatile, not less volatile in the next 12 months," said Paul I Scott, manager of CRU's steel team at an LME Week briefing. The positive outlook for metals on a medium term view made it likely that investor participation -- a factor contributing to price volatility -- would grow in the coming year, he added. Bellwether copper prices fell to a 14-month low of $6,635 a tonne on Monday, down around 30 percent from the end of last year and 35 percent from February's all-time high of $10,190. They were last indicated above those lows at $6,818 a tonne, but continue to be undermined by persistent concerns about the euro zone debt crisis, the threat of global recession and the implications for metal demand.

A blacksmith welds iron in his workshop in Rome July 13, 2011. REUTERS/Tony Gentile 19

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 "The next 12 months are loaded with political uncertainty...in the short run the distance between stagnation in Europe and recession and financial contagion is wafer thin, we might already have tipped over," said CRU's economist Nick Mason. But beyond that near term uncertainty the five-year outlook for metals remains bright. "We still believe in strong metals prices...Consumption forecasts remain optimistic across the base metals complex," said Cla- rence Craft, from CRU's Pittsburgh office, who focused on the medium outlook for metals. He expected prices to be bolstered over that period by a weaker U.S. dollar, which makes commodities less expensive for hold- ers of other currencies. Rising production costs due to sharp increases in energy prices and higher wages in top producer China would also play a part. Production costs were also seen as key beyond a five-year horizon. "Investor influence is neutral in the long term. The price is determined in the long run by marginal costs," said CRU's Peter Ghilchik. ON A CUSP For now, the fact that prices for many industrial metals have fallen below costs for marginal producers could lead to curtail- ments. "We are on a cusp... if we get to Christmas and copper is less than $7,000 there will be a significant supply response," said CRU Strategies COO Philip Newman, also referring to other metals. Most copper producers' costs are considerably below this level, but some would be moved to curb output, he said. Meanwhile, nickel prices currently below $20,000 a tonne and lead and prices below $2,000 will be hurting producers of those metals. Around one-third of the power-intensive aluminium smelting industry is already losing money at current levels, analysts have said. European steelmakers have been quick to act and have announced a number of shutdowns in the face of weaker demand. Most recently on Monday, the world's top steel producer ArcelorMittal confirmed it would halt production at its steel plant in Sestao, Spain.

S.Korea's PPS sees lower metals prices in 2012 By Polly Yam LONDON, Oct 4 (Reuters) - outh Korea's state-run Public Procurement Service (PPS) plans to hold more buy tenders for base metals in 2012 than this year as it expects base metals prices on average to be 20 to 30 percent lower, it said on Tuesday. It sees South Korea's copper buying demand at around 1 million tonnes next year, up from 900,000 tonnes this year, S Im Byeong Cheol, PPS director of commodity stockpile division, said. "This year we focused on releasing metals stock to small and medium firms," Im told Reuters in an interview in London. "Next year, due to our lower price forecasts, we plan to focus on buying of metals." The number of tenders the PPS will hold to buy base metals would increase in 2012, Im said, adding that in 2011 the agency so far had bought about 30,000 tonnes of metals. For 2012, Im said the real consumption of base metals in South Korea would be lower than this year but overall buying could rise as lower prices prompted firms to build stocks. Im said the agency planned to hold an international metals conference in South Korea next year to provide more information to small- and medium domestic firms, the buyers of the service's stocks. STOCK-BUILDING PLANS PPS plans to expand South Korea's stocks of base metals for emergency needs such as earthquakes and wars, Im said. Previously, PPS kept stocks for 60 days of the country's import demand for base metals. Now, it separates stock levels for each metal, with copper being set at 80 days of import demand and aluminium at 40 days, Im said. PPS is conducting a programme to encourage private companies to build up their inventories, Im said. As part of this process, a physical-metal backed exchange-traded-fund (ETF) is expected to be launched in the country in the fourth quarter of this year or the first quarter of 2012. PPS did not set a target amount of stocks for private firms to hold but Im said it hoped storage space of 15,000 square metres at a bonded warehouse in Busan port would be filled up within two years. The space is enough for 100,000 tonnes of copper or 70,000 tonnes of primary aluminium. Bonded warehouses typically are located near ports and store imports before the imported goods are assessed for the local tariffs.

20

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 Aluminium demand slowdown not dramatic-Rio Tinto Alcan LONDON, Oct 4 (Reuters) - emand for aluminium is slowing but not dramatically, with Asia holding up well, North America flat and Europe faring worst, a Rio Tinto Alcan executive said on Tuesday. "The wheels are not falling off yet in terms of demand. We are certainly seeing a slowdown, but it is somewhat re- D gional," Gordon Hamilton, vice president, metal management sales and marketing, said at a London Metal Ex- change Week event. "Business in Asia is good, North America has paused in some sectors...(and there is) a high degree of softness in Europe." The auto industry was the star performer, he said, while construction remained weak. Although the aluminium market was in a surplus this year, "through the rest of the decade demand growth means there will be a net shortfall", he said. The average of 22 forecasts in a Reuters poll in July showed the aluminium market would have a surplus 575,000 tonnes this year and 237,000 tonnes in 2012. In a January survey the forecasts were 383,000 and 202,250 tonnes respectively. Hamilton said longer term the outlook for aluminium was good, and forecast compound annual growth rate (CAGR) for the metal of 4.25 percent over 35 years. "This is the sort of growth rate we would expect to see," he said, citing industrialisation in China and other emerging econo- mies. Aluminium consumption is around 20 kg per capita in developed markets, against 1 kg in India, 5 kg in Brazil and 12 kg in China. Substitution would also boost demand for aluminium, as industries seek cheaper and lighter alternatives to copper, zinc and certain steel products. Prices for three-month aluminium on the London Metal Exchange recently hit one-year lows below $2,150 per tonne, down from peaks of over $2,800 in May, and it traded around $2,170 on Tuesday. By comparison, copper was around $6,780 per tonne on Tuesday. On the supply side, Hamilton said there were relentless pressures on costs, with capital costs, alumina/bauxite and energy and carbon rising. "We are constantly striving to be at the bottom end of cost curve," he said. "We have to grind it out and reduce costs as much as we can," he added. "There is no question in my mind that (fundamentals) matter, though there are moments like this when it is tough."

Porters transport metal pipes on a wooden handcart at an industrial area in Mumbai July 12, 2011. REUTERS/Danish Siddiqui 21

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 Doe Run sees lead in modest surplus in 2012 By Karen Norton LONDON, Oct 3 (Reuters) - he global lead market will be in modest surplus again in 2012, but demand will increase despite global economic con- cerns, helped by growth in new applications, U.S.-based Doe Run, a privately held integrated lead producer, said. Lead prices fell towards $1,900 a tonne on Monday in line with other industrial metals, undermined by Greece's ad- T mission that it would miss its deficit target and still disappointing Chinese economic data. "Obviously what happens in the global economy will have an impact on demand next year. We see the market in modest sur- plus again...but we think global demand is really positive in coming years. Lead is finding new applications," said Jose Hansen, Doe Run's vice-president of sales, in an interview with Reuters. Earlier on Monday, the Lisbon-based International Lead and Zinc Study Group (ILZSG) said the global market for battery ma- terial lead would see a surplus of 97,000 tonnes next year, following a predicted 188,000 tonnes surplus this year. Hansen said he agreed broadly with predictions he'd come across that world lead usage would rise by 5-6 percent next year. He was optimistic for the potential for growth in the telecommunications industry, E-bikes, hybrid cars as well as in the storage and transport of nuclear waste storage. Hansen was not perturbed by the fact that inventories of lead in London Metal Exchange (LME) warehouses were close to re- cord highs at just under 375,000 tonnes. "If you consider the world uses around 10 million tonnes a year of lead, to have LME stocks of nearly 400,000 tonnes is noth- ing compared with global usage," he said. NEW TECHNOLOGY Hansen said Doe Run, the second-biggest lead refiner in the West, hoped to complete tests on its new lead technology by the end of the year. The feasibility study would then be presented to the board and a decision should be made in early 2012. The technology replaces traditional, high-temperature lead smelting with a wet chemical process to selectively dissolve mined lead concentrates into solution. A plant using the new more environmentally-friendly process is due to start up in 2013, replacing the company's Herculaenum smelter, in Missouri, which is scheduled to close in December 2013. Hansen said Herculaneum, the sole primary lead smelter in the United States, will produce around 117,000 tonnes of refined lead in the year ending October 31, while its Buick recycling facility will produce 145,000 tonnes of the metal. Output at the two plants, which feed about 18 percent of U.S. lead demand, is expected to maintained at these levels in 2012.

Copper producers face premium pressures By Pratima Desai LONDON, Oct 4 (Reuters) - inancial and economic turmoil are likely to undermine attempts by producers to charge more for their copper next year but expectations of a supply deficit will help buttress premiums for the metal, a Reuters survey showed. The straw poll of analysts was carried out over the last few weeks ahead of a gathering this week of the metals indus- F try for London Metal Exchange (LME) Week. The average of eight forecasts showed Chinese consumers could pay a premium of $113 a tonne over the LME cash price in 2012, little changed from $115 a tonne this year. With the European economy most likely to see a recession, premiums for consumers in the region could see the deepest cuts, analysts said. Forecasts were for around $88 a tonne in 2012, down from $98 this year. Europe's sovereign debt crisis, rising chances of default, frozen money markets, economic slowdown in the region and the con- sequences for world growth are the subject of a heated debate. Analysts agreed a slowdown was inevitable, but opinion varied on whether that would turn into a recession. "There are uncertainties about the big picture, the global economy, euro zone debt and questions about recession in the euro zone, how will it affect the United States and Asia," said Robin Bhar, analyst at Credit Agricole. "On the other side of the coin isn't copper tight? In a supply deficit? That should help to support the market." Premiums for Japanese consumers are forecast at $96 a tonne for 2012 from $98 a tonne this year. Benchmark copper on the London Metal Exchange was trading at around $6,800 a tonne on Tuesday, off the lowest levels since July 2010. The metal, used widely in power and construction, was down some 30 percent from the record high of $10,190 a tonne on Feb. 15.

22

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 REAL DEMAND DICTATES Chile's Codelco, the world's top copper producer, normally starts premium negotiations with European customers around the time of LME Week, which started on Sunday. Negotiations with Chinese and Japanese consumers normally take place in November. Premiums agreed with Codelco serve as regional benchmarks in Europe and China, which is the world's top copper consumer accounting for 40 percent of demand estimated at around 20 million tonnes this year. "I don't think real demand in China is necessarily going to be that strong ... certainly imports of copper into China could poten- tially be very robust," said Carl Firman, analyst at VM Group. "But that's not going to transmit into premiums for physical metal, which are actually dictated by actual real, physical consumption." China has been been trying to slow its economy and fight inflationary pressures for nearly a year now with tighter monetary policy. The resulting slowdown has for some months been reflected in surveys of purchasing managers in the manufacturing industry. "The shaky macro economic situation won't encourage buyers to place big orders for annual supplies. Consumers in Asia and Europe are working hand to mouth," said Nicholas Trevethan, analyst at ANZ. "Copper will remain in deficit next year, but economic uncertainty may result in lower premia, especially in Europe which will likely see a greater reduction than Japan or China." Japan accounts for about 5 percent of global copper consumption and Europe for about 15 percent.

REUTERS INSIDER (Click on the headlines to view the show)

• LME courts multiple suitors; CEO says no conflict of interest on warehousing

Vapour pours from a steel mill chimney in the industrial town of Port Kembla, about 80 km (50 miles) south of Sydney July 7, 2011. REUTERS/Tim Wimborne 23

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 Anglo American says copper fundamentals still strong By Clara Ferreira-Marques LONDON, Oct 4 (Reuters) - alling copper prices may already have over-reacted to macroeconomic worries, given robust underlying demand from China and constrained supply, a top Anglo American executive said, adding the miner had not seen any customers cancel orders. F Copper prices have dropped by more than a quarter since the end of June, with benchmark prices on the London Metal Exchange falling to 14-month lows of $6,635 on Monday, as the threat of Greece's debt default increased. "We are seeing a lot of volatility in the copper price for other reasons... but it comes back to the fundamentals, and the funda- mentals look strong. China has been the driving force behind demand for the last five or 10 years, and that remains strong," Anglo American's head of copper, John MacKenzie, said. "The amount the copper price has fallen has very little to do with the fundamentals of supply and demand... probably if we were looking at only the fundamentals, it should not have come down as far as it has," he said in an interview. MacKenzie, who took the reins of Anglo American's second-largest division in 2009, echoed comments made on Monday by rival Freeport McMoRan , the world's largest listed copper miner, and said Anglo continued to see good demand despite mar- ket volatility and falling prices. "We haven't seen any cancellations in any orders. We are not seeing at this point any impact on our sales. In fact, what we are seeing in China right now is the concentrate market becoming fairly tight," he said, adding that was due to Freeport mine strikes but also due to the fact less scrap was available. MacKenzie said demand in China had been partially masked this year by destocking activity after the stockbuilding that fol- lowed the last market crash. "There is no reason to think that, with prices having dropped as they have, the Chinese will not be getting in again and restock- ing. There is evidence they are already doing this," he said. "They are opportunistic." On the supply side, copper has also been underpinned by constrained supply, as miners face challenging new operations, lower grades, higher costs and tougher permitting conditions. Lower prices, MacKenzie said, would make it even tougher. "With a lower price environment, and a lot of the projects in the industry pipeline being far more marginal than existing opera- tions, it places them in a very precarious position," he told Reuters at Anglo's central London headquarters. Anglo is forecasting a deficit in the copper market in both 2011 and, though to a lesser extent, in 2012. BETTING ON COPPER MacKenzie -- speaking at the start of London Metal Exchange week, a key event in the metals industry calendar -- said Anglo's flagship $2.8 billion Los Bronces expansion was all but complete and ready for first production this quarter. Los Bronces, where output will jump to 490,000 tonnes per year over the first three years, is expected at peak production to be one of the world's largest and lowest-cost copper mines. Los Bronces will help the miner hit its production target of more than 900,000 tonnes of copper by 2012. Beyond Los Bronces, Anglo is eyeing medium-term growth from expansion at Chile's giant Collahuasi mine, owned jointly with Xstrata , after increasing reserves and resources there, and from its Quellaveco project in southern Peru. Chile's state copper company Codelco has an option that would allow it the right to purchase up to a 49 percent stake in An- glo American Sur properties -- Anglo's south Chilean properties, which include Los Bronces and El Soldado mines and the Chagres smelter -- up to 2027. Codelco passed up the option in 2009, but has said it would reexamine the option at the next window, in January 2012. "This is something we will discuss with Codelco," MacKenzie said, declining to comment further. Miners operating in Chile have been dogged by power worries, after a devastating earthquake last year and years of under- investment have left the energy grid creaking. MacKenzie said Anglo had extensive talks with the government on its power plan, but was increasing its energy efficiency and had also held discussions with private power producers. "Ultimately, for the large projects, you need large chunks of power, but we are confident the government's plan is robust." Copper has been the prime vehicle for Anglo's attempts to diversify away from South Africa, but MacKenzie said the copper division could return to Africa, providing the asset is right. Anglo is exploring in areas beyond Latin America, including the Democratic Republic of Congo and Indonesia, but would also consider acquisitions, especially given current prices. "We have been through a phase where it was far more expensive to buy than to build, but as asset valuations come down, one would certainly expect to see some buying opportunities," he said. "But there are not a huge number of highly attractive tar- gets out there."

24

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 Softs to outperform metals in 2012-Bache By Melanie Burton LONDON, Oct 4 (Reuters) - nvestors should raise exposure to fertiliser and sugar as climate change stunts production, while cutting exposure to met- als, Marc Bailey, President of Jeffries Bache Limited said on Tuesday. Risks for copper and gold are to the downside as dwindling confidence in the global economy saps consumers' desire to I restock, and as investors lock in profits where they can. "The big trade on the book for the last ten years has been the fertiliser trade and I think that trade is still on," Bailey told Reuters in an interview. "Clearly climate issues are having an impact on crop production at a time when population is still growing and the wealth of the population continues to increase," he said. "The risk is to the upside on core agricultural materials." U.S. investment bank Jefferies Group Inc acquired Prudential Bache for approximately $430 million at the start of July includ- ing Bache Commodities in the U.K. "I think yield enhancement is the trade and the fertiliser is very much part of that," he added. Yield enhancement is where plots of land are made more productive. There are still vast tracks of land, in India for example, in which yield per hectare still significantly lags Europe and the U.S., said Bailey. Raising exposure to such areas that are supported by infrastructure beats expansive farming strategies because of the time it takes to build infrastructure, said Bailey adding that sugar would be one commodity he would buy on dips. In top sugar producer Brazil, crops are being planted further inland, away from train lines and ports. "Until that infrastructure is built, you have the continuing risk of supply chain disruptions," he said. ICE raw sugar futures hit a 30-year high of 36.08 cents a lb in February and have since fallen to trade around 24 cents a lb as commodities have tumbled on European and U.S. debt worries.

Afghans work at a blacksmith shop in the old part of Kabul June 15, 2011. REUTERS/Omar Sobhani 25

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 BLEAK OUTLOOK Fading confidence in the global economy is undermining consumer appetite to purchase metal, and also removing a plank of support for copper prices which could fall as far as $6,000 a tonne, Bailey said. "I think it's unlikely we will see over-optimism about the global economy in the early part of 2012, which is what you would need to see record prices in copper," he said. "I think the sharp guys have started to get out. I don't think that everybody is out yet so I think you can see more of a technical movement on the downside," he added. Benchmark copper on the London Metal Exchange tumbled to its lowest in 14 months on Monday at $6,635 a tonne before cutting losses to trade at $6,845 a tonne at 0913 GMT. Bullion could also be subject to a steep pullback, as investors look to lock in profits from one of the few outperforming assets. "We're coming in to the end of the year, a difficult year, liquidity has dried up and I think (trade) is becoming very technical," he said. "One of the only asset classes in which people have got profit to take is bullion." A break of $1,490 in gold could trigger setback down to $1,200, Bailey said. "If you saw a draw down in bullion below that level of support, you could see around the $22-$23 mark," Bailey added. Gold was bid $1,669.79/1,671.15 on Tuesday, having tumbled from a record high of $1920.30 on Sept 6. Silver was bid last at $30.87/30.92, having plunged by 38 percent from a record high of $49.51 on April 28. Graphic of asset returns in 2011 and 3rd quarter: http://link.reuters.com/daj24s Bailey said that politicians had yet to win public confidence that austerity measures could successfully rescue Europe from a default and the U.S. from a double dip recession, undermining the confidence of consumers buy metal. He also said that signs of funding stress seen in 2008 had not returned. "Credit is a key part of the commodities business cycle and vital to the smooth operation of our business model," he said. "In 2008 credit for margin and commodity finance was badly stressed, so far we have not seen a return to these stress levels -- but never say never," Bailey added.

REUTERS POLL-Fair value copper price forecasts jump By Marie-Louise Gumuchian LONDON, Oct 4 (Reuters) - ncentive price forecasts for copper have jumped by a fifth compared with last year, with analysts citing strong demand from emerging markets and rising production costs in a world of tight supply pushing prices higher in the years ahead, a Reuters survey showed. I The poll carried out over the last four weeks ahead of a gathering of the metals industry for London Metal Exchange (LME) Week, found that forecasts for incentive or fair value prices for all six base metals have increased. A survey of 16 analysts showed the average price forecast for copper rose 19.9 percent from last year's Reuters poll figure to $6,200 a tonne. A survey of 11 analysts showed tin forecasts jumping 22.2 percent to $17,725 a tonne, also supported by a fi- nite supply outlook. Long-term or incentive price forecasts are used to evaluate the feasibility and potential profitability of future projects. Forecasts for battery material lead rose 11.8 percent to $1,900 a tonne while nickel prices forecasts increased by 10 percent to $18,711 a tonne. "We believe that long-run copper prices will have to trade at a much higher level than in the past in order to incentivise producers to invest huge amounts of capital to bring on enough production to meet the growth in demand," Bar- clays Capital analyst Gayle Berry said. Falling ore grades, increased resource nationalism and reduced investment are also adding to cost pressures -- all while de- mand from the developing world charges ahead. Analysts expect that as top copper consumer China, and other key developing countries like India and Brazil, industrialise over the next decade, demand for metals will expand at a faster pace than supply. China is estimated to consume about 40 per- cent of global demand, which is forecast at around 19 million tonnes this year. "With that, you've also got India on the rise over the next 20 years, you've got other emerging markets - Asian markets on the rise and elsewhere in Latin America, and I think that's going to put a lot more demand for raw materials and that's going to transmit to higher prices," VM Group analyst Carl Firman said. Strikes could keep the heat under copper prices next year as workers, seeing mining companies reap fat profits from the ex- pected high prices and tight market, try to rewrite expiring contracts.

26

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111

"Copper will face increasing supply issues from industrial action and changes in government policy in the developing world," Shayne Heffernan of Heffernan Capital Management said. ", particularly gold and copper are seeing increasing costs, from labour to government taxes, as markets recover in late 2011 and early 2012. We do expect to see increased supply disruptions and shortages driving prices higher." Graphic on poll results: http://r.reuters.com/her24s 'FAIR VALUE' Benchmark copper on the London Metal Exchange traded at around $6,800 a tonne on Tuesday, off the lowest levels since July 2010. The metal, used widely in power and construction, is down some 30 percent from the record high of $10,190 a tonne on Feb. 15. The survey's incentive forecasts -- based on future cost expectations plus profit needs -- tend to be conservative, given inves- tors will not commit to a project that only makes money if prices are high. "We have raised our assessment for long-term pricing and that reflects the assessment of the capital and operating costs at the margin," Macquarie analyst Jim Lennon said. "When we look at the projects and what they're costing, there has been a huge inflation rate in capital and operating costs and we're updating our numbers to reflect the likelihood that these trends will continue for a number of years and you are not go- ing to get a massive correction downwards in energy prices over the medium-term." Tin , which has fallen from a record high of $33,600 a tonne hit in April, is seen supported by an expected rise in demand from China's manufacturing and electronics sectors as well as a tight supply outlook. Indonesia's plan to halt tin exports will offer long-term price support only if smelters stick to the ban, which is not certain. Smelters in the main producing region of Indonesia, the world top refined tin exporter, agreed to impose a ban on tin ingot shipments from Oct. 1 until global prices recover to above $25,000 a tonne. While lead stocks at LME warehouses have hovered around record highs, rising battery demand is supportive to prices. Price risks remain, however, despite the expected pull on new supply and investment. Forecasts for aluminium and zinc were little changed, rising 2.2 percent to $2,425 a tonne and 1.6 percent to $1,949 a tonne respectively. The aluminium market is structurally over-supplied and expected to remain so for years to come.

27

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 Codelco sees stable premiums for copper consumers By Pratima Desai and Julie Crust LONDON, Oct 4 (Reuters) - he world's largest copper miner, Chile's Codelco expects next year's premiums for copper consumers in Asia and Europe to hold steady, Diego Hernandez, the company's chief executive told Reuters on Tuesday. Financial market turmoil, economic slowdown and fears of recession in Europe has fuelled market talk of lower copper T premiums -- the amount copper consumers pay above cash prices on the London Metal Exchange. But Hernandez declining to give any numbers said "premiums shouldn't be too different this year". "Clients, especially from Asia are quite keen to purchase similar quantities for next year," he said, adding that Europe could see lower premiums. "There are more issues in Europe, but the quantities being negotiated are not too different from last year." Negotiations with European consumers have already started and in Asia talks will begin in November. Copper premiums for European consumers last year were $98 a tonne and for Chinese consumers $115 a tonne. "This year China bought less cathode than in 2010 (but) if they keep current levels (for next year) we will be happy," Hernandez said, adding that prices should not fall towards $2.50 a lb ($5,510 a tonne) because fundamentals were good. "You don't have much hope of new copper coming to the market next year ... The current copper price doesn't reflect the mar- ket. The big issue is what will be the Chinese reaction to current prices when they come back." Benchmark copper on the London Metal Exchange at around $6,800 a tonne is down more than 30 percent since a record high of $10,190 on February 15. China is on holiday this week. TAP FINANCIAL MARKETS Tight power supply in Chile has damaged the competitiveness of Chile's mining industry compared with Peru and other coun- tries, but Hernandez said the problem was not yet critical and that the government was looking at the problem.

A labourer attaches iron rods to a column at the construction site of a flyover in Lahore May 26, 2011. REUTERS/Mohsin Raza 28

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 However, power was a concern for the company as it is a cost that is not linked to the copper price. Power accounts for about 12-20 percent of the company's costs, up from around 6-8 percent, although labour is still the miner's biggest cost. Chile's mining sector, which produces a third of the world's copper, consumes a third of the country's power and industries have urged the government to improve the grid and reduce high energy costs that have boosted bills at miners such as BHP Billiton and Codelco. Hernandez expected Codelco to end 2011 with $6 billion of debt, similar to last year, but said the company will likely increase its debt by about $2-2.5 billion next year. "For next year we need to tap the financial markets because we have quite a demanding investment programme. We need to refinance $1 billion and then to increase the net debt to $2-2.5 billion, it depends how much the government will reinvest." The government makes a decision every June on whether to reinvest some profits of the state-run company, which has seen production drop in four of the last five years. Only $376 million of Codelco's 2010 profit of $5.8 billion was returned and the government did not recapitalize profits at all the previous year so that it could focus on rebuilding efforts following a devastating earthquake. Codelco plans to invest about $17.5 billion on increasing copper production to 1.8 million tonnes by 2014 and 2.1 million by 2020, but Hernandez said the company does not want its debt levels to go beyond $9-10 billion. Codelco, which produces about one tenth of the world's mined copper, has struggled in recent years to sustain output levels as aging mines and dwindling ore grades hit yields Hernandez expects output this year to be slightly higher than the 1.688 million tonnes produced in 2010, but lower than 1.7 million tonnes, and anticipates average cash costs in the second half to remain similar to the $1.048 per pound level seen in the first six months. He denied that the company had delayed the expansion of the Andina copper mine, but said the feasibility study had been extended to review the design in an attempt to keep costs under control. It will make a decision on whether to proceed with the $6.2 billion expansion project early in 2013. Reuters Insider television interview with Codelco CEO http://link.reuters.com/pam24s Reuters survey of fair value prices, copper demand growth

China growth not enough to alone boost metals -CRU LONDON, Oct 3 (Reuters) - hinese growth prospects remain healthy but at lower rates and the world's top copper consumer cannot boost com- modity markets on its own the way it did some three years ago, metals consultancy CRU said on Monday. Paul Robinson, Group Manager Non Ferrous Metals at CRU, told a London Metal Exchange (LME) Week seminar that C China would not build up stockpiles of the red metal as it did then. The metals market had been anticipating China's return after running down inventories of base metals, particularly copper, but a slowdown in the auto and housing sectors is seen capping demand. Beijing's monetary tightening measures were also impacting the short term outlook, Robinson said. "China funded our recovery in the commodity world ... China has been the commodity story," he said. "We don't believe it can step in and give the commodity markets the recovery it saw in 2008 ... (China is) overall positive but not fantastically positive ...Chinese growth rates remain healthy but at lower rates." Aluminium will post the best consumption growth rate out of all non-ferrous metals, CRU's Paul Robinson tells Reuters In- sider TV: http://link.reuters.com/jyj24s China is estimated to consume about 40 percent of global copper demand, which is forecast at around 19 million tonnes this year. "We don't see China building stockpiles of copper like they did in 2008 and 2009," he said, citing the reason as being that Chinese stockpiling boosted copper prices and ultimately Chinese buyers ended up paying more for their materials. Ranking base metals in terms of consumption growth prospects, Robinson put aluminium first, followed by nickel, zinc, cop- per, lead and lastly tin. "Aluminium is both a nation-building metal and emerging middle class metal," he said, adding said that the beverage sector, for which aluminium is used in packaging, and the transport sector were strong. Robinson said growth in copper consumption was capped by three elements -- a lower growth rate in Chinese consumption, a substitution into aluminium and mine constraints. He also said no significant impact on copper was seen from this year's unrest in the Middle East and North Africa.

29

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111

A worker operates an electrolysis furnace, which produces aluminium from raw materials, at the Rusal Krasnoyarsk aluminium smelter in the Siberian city of Krasnoyarsk, May 18, 2011. REUTERS/Ilya Naymushin Insights into uncertain metals market Oct 3 (Reuters) - he metals industry gathers in London for the annual LME Week, with many participants hoping for an insight into commodity markets after a torrid few weeks due to global economic uncertainty. T Here are some analysts' views of what could lie ahead: MACQUARIE "The price crash has been driven by fears of a double-dip economic slowdown over concerns of a financially driven crash in Europe and weaker U.S. and Chinese growth prospects. "The most extreme fears are a repeat of the situation at the end of 2008 and 2009, when demand collapsed amid a freezing in credit markets. This seems unlikely, but so long as uncertainties over the European debt and banking bailout remain, con- cerns about a repeat of 2008 will remain. "For China, the persistence of the credit tightening throughout 2010 (many including ourselves had thought it would have ended by now) is leading to growing concerns of a deeper and more prolonged China slowdown. We think that this is unlikely since inflationary pressures are likely to abate rapidly in China as the rest of the world slows and growth eases in the coming months. "On the supply side, the appalling performance of supply growth (especially in nickel and copper) will come under the micro- scope, and debate about how quickly new projects will ramp up will be to the forefront." MORGAN STANLEY "Global financial and commodity markets have become even more risk averse since the publication of our Global Metals Play- book: 3Q11 on July 26. "Driving this are increased risk of a renewed recession in the U.S. and Europe, greater global financial uncertainty because of a worsening debt crisis in Europe with attendant pressure on banks, and concerns about a hard landing in China. "Although adverse outcomes to all such risks is not our base or even our bear case, the risks of a developed market (DM) re- cession have risen sufficiently in 3Q11 for us to adopt a bear-case price scenario to reflect a DM recession, with a probability weighting raised to 40 percent for base metals prices.

30

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 "With the rapidly diminishing prospect of global growth being robust enough to deliver stronger base metals prices next year, we have lowered our base price forecasts in 2012 by 16.1 percent on a weighted average basis and cut our copper price forecast 17.4 percent." ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND "RBS have for some time argued that underlying demand for industrial commodities in China is holding up well and that this will likely continue, even if western economies move into recession. "The caveat is the possibility that a recession in western countries impacts on Chinese growth more than we have factored into our base case. RBS forecasts 2012 Chinese GDP growth to be 9 percent, in our opinion if growth is less than 7 percent year-on- year, then that would give us great concern. "A lower price environment may bring the respite consumers need - as long as the changing macroeconomic backdrop does not lead to an offsetting collapse in end-user demand." BARCLAYS CAPITAL "Concerns about the risk of a repeat of the 2008-09 crisis and slowing growth mean further weakness in prices looks likely and the road ahead bumpy. But we believe that if the European situation can be stabilised, then the conditions for a price re- covery may start falling into place. "We have revised all of our price forecasts lower to reflect the weaker demand outlook and the collapse in senti- ment. This has reduced the tightness in some market balances, with the copper stocks-to-consumption ratio, for instance, no longer signalling either extreme tightness or exaggerated upside price moves. "Provided the global economy misses recession and China engineers a soft landing, as our economists expect, we believe that prices should recover later in the year. However, the outlook has rarely appeared so uncertain, with the potential for a domino effect from a single event risk." DANSKE RESEARCH "The commodities sell-off seen late summer has been fuelled by a remarkable change in sentiment towards the industrial cycle, the dollar and risk appetite in general. "Although we had predicted a summer lull in prices, the magnitude of the declines has surprised us, but we still see demand recovering in Q4. Together with a weaker dollar eventually, this should imply an end to the recent widespread sell-offs. "We have lowered our base-metals forecasts somewhat. However, copper could still hit $10,000 during the course of next year"

A worker walks amidst high purity aluminium ingots at the Rusal Krasnoyarsk aluminium smelter in the Siberian city of Krasnoyarsk. REUTERS/Ilya Naymushin

31

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 BofAML GLOBAL COMMODITY RESEARCH "After months of little progress in policy-making in the U.S. and the euro zone respectively, the deep structural problems in those two geographical areas remain largely unsolved. Not surprisingly, private sector confidence has fallen sharply and ad- vanced nations are at the doorstep of yet another recession. "Although we have argued before that any contraction may be less deep compared with 2008, though it may last longer, this is not a bullish environment particularly for cyclical assets like the base metals. "Acknowledging the current cyclical headwinds, we have downgraded base metal price forecasts already twice this year (in March and July) and we maintain our cautious stance towards those commodities at least until policymakers in the US and Europe take tangible action."

TABLE-Copper demand growth forecasts for 2011 LONDON, Oct 4 (Reuters) - Following are forecasts for copper demand growth for this year.

Demand Growth F' Cast for 2011 in pct Total Demand In 2011 Millions tonnes Demand Growth F' cast for 2011 in pct from Jan Mean 3.8 19.9 4.5 Median 4 19.9 4.4 Highest 5.4 20.3 5.8 Lowest 2 18.9 3.5 No of Forecasts 15 15 15 Barclays Capital 3.5 19.86 4.2 CPM Group 4 20.09 5.3 Credit Agricole 3 20 3.5 Deutsche Bank 2.9 19.93 4.1 EIU 4 19.9 3.7 Fairfax 4 20.247 4.7 GFMS 5.4 20.321 5.8 Harbor Intelligence 2 19.72 5 Heffernan Capital Mgt 4 19.8 5 Macquarie 4.2 19.85 4.5 National Securities 4.9 20.3 4.4 Raw Materials Group 4 20.08 4 Standard Chartered 2.1 18.9 4 UBS 4.3 20.064 4.3 VM Group 4 19.93 4.8 The survey of 15 analysts was carried out over the last few weeks ahead of a gathering of the metals industry for London Metal Exchange (LME) Week.

Norilsk sees debt crisis cutting world nickel output By Polina Devitt MOSCOW, Oct 3 (Reuters) - bout 10 percent of world nickel producers are losing money at current prices and could cut output by as much as 30,000 tonnes in the fourth quarter of this year, Norilsk Nickel's head of marketing, Viktor Sprogis, said in an inter- view. A The Arctic miner, the world's largest producer of nickel and , remains profitable, Sprogis added. "The level of $18,000-$18,500 per tonne is loss-making for a string of companies," Sprogis said. Last month, the London Metal Exchange (LME) three-month nickel price fell to $16,800 a tonne, its lowest since December 2009 as global economic worries grew. On Monday, it was trading around $18,049 a tonne compared with February levels close to $30,000 a tonne. It has been the hardest hit of the LME base metals, falling over 28 percent year to date on concerns that weakening demand for nickel could tip the supply balance, which has been teetering on the brink of surplus due to slow intake by key consumers such as stainless steel producers. Norilsk, controlled by mining tycoon Vladimir Potanin's Interros consortium, controls 20 percent of world nickel output and about 2 percent of copper, but is hoping to increase its share of the copper market. UC RUSAL, the world's largest aluminium producer is also a major shareholder and has clashed with Potanin and Norilsk's chief executive over strategy and management, in part over its preference for long-term contracts. Norilsk defends that practice over spot sales, saying it gives the company stability of revenue that allows it to plan investments and yields a healthy premium over LME prices. PROJECTS

32

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 Sprogis said that $18,500 per tonne was the level at which losses began for blast furnaces working with poor nickel pig iron, with a nickel content of 2-6 percent, as well as for Russian, Europe, and Japanese producers of ferronickel. The reduction of nickel production could amount to 100,000 tonnes next year if prices did not rebound, Sprogis said, adding only a major global economic shock could send prices lower. The International Nickel Study Group (INSG) said it expects the world nickel market to be in a surplus of around 70,000 ton- nes in 2012, after a surplus of about 30,000 tonnes this year. At greatest risk, Sprogis said, were new nickel projects due to come on line in the next few years. Expected increases in output levels have been another factor keeping LME nickel under pressure. "If prices stay at current levels and forecasts show a down- trend, then we'll see what we saw in 2009," Sprogis said. "We are one of the world's lowest-cost producers in our Russian production base. But we have foreign assets which have a high cost of production and they are at risk." In 2009 Norilsk Nickel stopped its Johnson Lake concentrator in Australia in re- sponse to a collapse in commodity prices. The unit, capable of producing 9,500 tonnes per year of nickel, was restarted late last year. Despite a steep fall in copper prices, however, Sprogis said copper producers were not yet at risk of losses, though new pro- jects could be delayed in copper, too. "The majority of leading copper producers have costs of $4,000 per tonne," he said. LME copper was down 4.7 percent at $6,690 per tonne at 0610 GMT. He said copper stocks were also unlikely to rise for fundamental reasons in the final quarter of the year, but low output levels could lead to a shortfall in production unless demand starts to slow in China and some developed markets.

TABLE-Forecasts of copper premiums for consumers LONDON, Oct 4 (Reuters) - Chile's Codelco, the world's top copper producer, normally starts premium negotiations with Euro- pean customers around the time of London Metal Exchange week, which started on Sunday. Negotiations with Chinese and Japanese consumers typically take place in November. Premiums agreed with Codelco serve as regional benchmarks in Europe and China, which is the world's top copper consumer accounting for 40 percent of demand estimated at around 20 million tonnes this year.

Workers walk near some of the copper stills in the Roseisle distillery in Moray, northern Scotland March 1, 2011. REUTERS/David 33

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 Premiums are paid above LME cash prices . Following are analysts' forecasts for the premiums that consumers in China, Ja- pan and Europe could pay next year for copper. Copper premiums in dollars per tonne for Chinese consumers for Japanese consumers for European consumers Mean 111 94 87 Median 113 96 88 Highest 131 112 104 Lowest 80 75 70 No of Forecasts 8 7 8 ANZ 112 96 82 Credit Agricole 115 95 95 Fairfax 125 100 80 GFMS 80 75 70 Heffernan Capital 131 112 104 Management Macquarie 115 98 98 National Securities 100 - 98 VM Group 110 85 75 LME deal not seen before end-Q2-CEO By Harpreet Bhal LONDON, Oct 3 (Reuters) - ny potential deal to sell the London Metal Exchange (LME) is not likely to be concluded before the end of the second quarter next year, the LME's Chief Executive Martin Abbott said on Monday. Speaking at a seminar at the beginning of LME Week, Abbott said the exchange is in the process of registering inter- A est from bidders and will set up a "data room" -- opening the books to would-be buyers -- by December. The 134-year old LME, the world's biggest market for industrial metals, said late September it was considering a sale after receiving "several expressions of interest." "If and when the board is satisfied that there is something serious that the shareholders should see I can't imagine that is go- ing to happen before the end of the first quarter, possibly the beginning of Q2," Abbott said at the LME Week seminar. "If shareholders decide that there is something they want to take up... I can't see that (a deal) come to a conclusion until the end of Q2."

A kangaroo looks on while standing on iron ore rocks close to the Dampier port at the Pilbarra region in Western Australia April 19, 2011.REUTERS/Daniel Munoz 34

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 In an interview with Reuters last week, Abbott said interest in the LME as a takeover target has snowballed and the number of suitors has risen to double digits because business is booming with volumes at record levels. There is market speculation that the list of potential acquirers may include CME Group Inc , the largest in the United States, IntercontinentalExchange and UK-based broker ICAP . "COMPELLING REASON" TO SELL The LME was established back in 1877 above a hat shop in Lombard Court, and is now one of the last bastions of open outcry trading. Trading houses and banks that use the market also own it. Metal industry sources have said the bid could be worth a potential 1 billion pounds, if shareholders are persuaded to sell. "We're (the LME is) not for sale, we have been approached. We don't need to sell," said Gavin Prentice, managing director and global head of sales at LME shareholder Spectron. "If we sell or not there has to be an incredibly compelling reason for us to do so," Prentice said during a panel discussion at the LME Week seminar. Major LME shareholders include companies such as U.S. banks Goldman Sachs and JP Morgan and trading firms including Amalgamated Metal Trading and Metdist. INDUSTRY GATHERS The metal industry is gathering in London this week for the annual LME Week event. Speaking at the panel discussion, LME's head of business development Chris Evans said is potentially a very lucrative area for members and users of the LME, adding that it was not a surprise that other exchanges have also identified it. "It probably isn't a coincidence that there has been interest in purchasing the exchange after we made our announcement," Evans said, on the LME's decision to investigate setting up its own clearing system. "What we've done is we've identified... potentially a very important and lucrative area. It's an area where we quite feasibly weren't extracting value for our members and users of the market. And it is no surprise other exchanges have also seen this." Commenting on new products, LME Asia's Managing Director Liz Milan said the exchange is looking at additional products for steel. "The LME is looking at additional upstream and downstream products," said Milan. "We are also looking at index, cash- settled products," she said.

Copper could hit $5,000/T if economy worsens-INTL FCStone By Harpreet Bhal LONDON, Oct 3 (Reuters) - opper prices could dip to as low as $5,000 a tonne if the global economy goes through further shocks, with high volatility likely to be a lingering feature in markets, commodity brokerage firm INTL FCStone said. Benchmark copper on the London Metal Exchange (LME) lost more than 25 percent in September as global reces- C sion fears and demand worries prompted investors to dump the metal used in power and construction. As panic gripped stock markets on fears of a possible Greek default and economic slump, investors liquidated positions in commodities to cover margin calls resulting in copper prices plunging as much as $600 a tonne intra-day in late-September. "If we get one more piece of disruption for the market, a genuine Greek default or another country saying they can't pay, that would send a second set of shock waves off," said Malcolm Freeman, Europe sales director at INTL FCStone "I don't think it's impossible for copper to go down to$5,000 or $5,500 a tonne were the bad news to line up and result in a black swan event." Copper fell to its lowest level since July 2010 on Monday, after Greece admitted it would miss its deficit target. It traded as low as $6,635 a tonne, off more than 30 percent from a record high of $10,190 a tonne hit in February. Freeman said the slowdown in western economies was also likely to crimp China's demand for raw material. Some analysts had expected demand from China to help cushion an economic deterioration in the west, but the country has been slow to dip back into the market in the first half of the year. China accounts for about 40 percent of global consumption of copper, estimated at around 19 million tonnes this year. VOLATILITY TO STAY Freeman said investors will need to get accustomed to volatility as a feature in metal markets as more managed money and algorithmic trading activities take place. "If you are a physical client trying to price metal it's a pretty hard one to do a budget for. It is a major problem," he said. "I would suggest that if we have a continued run of this volatility they (the clearing house) will raise margins again." London clearing house LCH.Clearnet raised the margin for copper and tin contracts traded on the LME to $750 and $3,200 a tonne respectively, effective Sept. 29. 35

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 Freeman added that the increased volatility in metal markets has prompted some investors to use more sophisticated hedging strategies to protect their investments. "More people now are looking at specialist market products that allow a more flexible method of risk management," he said. INTL FCStone, which bought Ambrian Commodities in April, was approved as a Category 2 member of the LME on Friday. Associate broker clearing members, also known as Category 2 members, of the LME have all the privileges of ring dealing members, except that they may not trade in the ring. Commenting on the possibility of a Chinese party applying to become a clearing member on the LME, Freeman said it would be a logical step. "It is logical that they would put one or two of their major banks banks forward to be a clearing member of the LME. I am sur- prised they haven't already done so," he said.

Freeport sees good demand for copper By Karen Norton LONDON, Oct 3 (Reuters) - reeport McMoRan Copper & Gold Inc said on Monday the recent sharp fall in copper prices does not reflect the mar- ket's fundamentals, and it continues to see good demand for the metal. "The drop in the copper price doesn't reflect the fundamental situation... We still maintain a positive view of copper F markets," Chief Executive Richard Adkerson told Reuters in an interview, adding "We anticipate being able to sell all of our products." Benchmark copper prices on the London Metal Exchange (LME) fell to 14-month lows of $6,635 a tonne on Monday, knocked by Greece's admission that it would miss its deficit target and improving but still disappointing economic data from China. Copper was last indicated at $6,796.25 a tonne. Adkerson expected China, which accounts for some 40 percent of global copper demand, to remain the engine of growth for the metal used in power and construction. "China has the financial resources, it has committed to invest infrastructure, the internal economy is getting larger. That's all very supportive for copper demand," Adkerson said.

People sell scrap metal at a yard in Detroit, Michigan April 5, 2011. REUTERS/Eric Thaye 36

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 If the economic situation does continue to deteriorate, he said Freeport would be prepared to act by curbing output, as it did in the 2008 global downturn. "We have the ability to adjust to adverse conditions...if required we have prudent plans to deal with it. But today we're not hav- ing to make changes to our operating plans or our capital expenditure," he said. The company's capital expenditure this year is put at just under $3 billion with similar levels expected next year. The company's average cost of production are around $1 a lb (around $2,204 a tonne) this year, according to Adkerson, well above current prices. SALES TO RISE Adkerson said Freeport McMoRan, the world's largest publicly traded copper miner, with annual sales of around 4 billion lbs of copper, could boost sales by another 1.0 billion lbs annually, based on existing projects. The company plans to triple capacity at its Cerro Verde mine in Peru and also to expand its El Abra mine in Chile and Tenke Fungurume operation in the Democratic Republic of Congo. (http://bond.views.session.rservices.com/mpd/) According to Reuters Metals database Cerro Verde currently produces around 300,000 tonnes a year of copper from its mine and leach operations. Freeport is contending with strike action by workers at both its Cerro Verde mine in Peru and at its Grasberg mine in Indonesia. Adkerson said the company was working hard to achieve a resolution at the vast Grasberg copper-gold operation. The company said it is continuing to produce and ship copper concentrates at reduced levels from the mine, while the union said it will extend the strike for another month. These industrial disputes have exacerbated a tightness in global copper mine supply, which has characterised the copper market and helped to underpin prices for a number of years. Many analysts say 2012 will be no different and Adkerson did not disagree. "The world still has an excess of smelter capacity relative to concentrate production levels...our concentrates are actively sought after and we expect to see that continuing over time," he said.

A labourer works at an iron factory on the eve of International Labour Day, or May Day, in Lahore April 30, 2011. REUTERS/Mohsin Raza 37

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 Aluminium prices can't fall much further -RUSAL By Polina Devitt MOSCOW, Oct 3 (Reuters) - lobal aluminium prices cannot fall much further, with as much as two-fifths of global production already unprofit- able and demand likely to hold up, a senior executive at RUSAL , the world's largest producer of the metal, told Reuters. G "Prices for aluminium, in contrast to copper, have reached their minimum," Oleg Mukhamedshin, RUSAL's director of corporate development, said in an interview ahead of LME Week in London. "At current prices, 30-40 percent of global production is either loss-making or close to breakeven. That applies to some Chi- nese producers and some plants in Europe and the United States," he said. "To sink further is not possible; there will not be a significant further fall." Prices for three-month aluminium on the London Metals Exchange recently hit one-year lows below $2,150 per tonne, down from peaks of over $2,800 in May on fears that the West's sovereign debt crisis could depress the world economy. But compared with other base metals, aluminium has shown relative resilience. The three-month LME contract is down just over 10 percent so far this year, while nickel is down more than 28 percent. As evidence of persistent physical demand in spite of financial market concerns about a downturn in demand, Mukhamedshin said physical aluminium was still selling at a healthy premium to LME cash prices . "Everything will become clear after the meetings with traders at LME Week, but right now we do not see any radical reduction in demand," Mukhamedshin told Reuters. MARKET BALANCED Mukhamedshin said he did not see any evidence that LME aluminium stocks were likely to rise, which confirmed his view that supply and demand were broadly in balance and that there was no fundamental reason for demand to weaken. High exchange stocks have been one factor weighing on aluminium prices in recent years, although prices have received some support from a fall in stock levels from a May peak of 4.71 million tonnes. "What is happening in the world is linked to the risks stemming from the debt crisis in countries that are not major consumers of aluminium," he said. China's supply and demand is a guidepost for aluminium, a key input for the construction business and carmakers and an es- sential element in production of light electronics devices such as the Apple iPad. News out of the Chinese market in recent months has played to aluminium bulls such as RUSAL and has been characterised by annual declines in production. RUSAL says China will become a net importer of aluminium in some quarters of 2012.

An employee works in a ferronickel smelter owned by state miner Aneka Tambang Tbk at Pomala district in Indonesia's southeast Sulawesi province March 30, 2011. REUTERS/Yusuf Ahmad 38

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 Potential for China to loosen its monetary policy is another factor underpinning the case for greater stability in metals prices. RUSAL says it maintains a significant cost advantage over Chinese producers. Smelters on both sides of the border are coping with significant increases in electricity costs, their most sensitive input, but RUSAL says it is in a better position. RUSAL has hedged its electricity prices against a fall in aluminium by linking power prices to LME aluminium prices in long- term contracts with electricity generators near RUSAL's Siberian production bases. "In addition, we expect a gradual devalua- tion of the rouble to 36-38 to the dollar by the end of next year, which will make Russian exports more efficient," Mukhamed- shin added. RUSAL last week signed a new deal to refinance $9.33 billion in debt to foreign creditors, the remainder of a debt that threat- ened to sink the company after the 2008 debt crisis. It has $1 billion in debt to Russian creditors on its balance sheet, which is yet to be refinanced. "That will conclude the process of refinancing, based on which we don't have any redemption payments to make until 2013," Mukhamedshin said. Cash flows will be enough to cover debt payments and modernise its plants, including expanding its casthouses to produce high-value alloys and upgrading old potlines to a less costly and emissions-prone version of their older technology. It has taken out new loans to finance construction of two new smelters in Siberia, at Boguchany and Taishet.

Mine capex to rise in 2012 despite economic wobbles By Karen Norton LONDON, Oct 3 (Reuters) - iners will splash out more on building new mines in 2012, despite recent falls in industrial metals prices, in the belief that new projects are needed in coming years to satisfy China's voracious appetite. Metals markets have plummeted on worries that weak economic growth may hurt demand. Benchmark copper M fell to a 14-month low of $6,635 a tonne on Monday, down nearly 35 percent from February's peak of $10,190. But for now, the expectation is that beyond near-term uncertainty, top metals consumer China and other emerging economies will still take increasing amounts of metal and raw materials for their infrastructure needs.

A worker melts bronze in one of the few factories that still produces hand-made bronzeware in Bangkok March 4, 2011 REUTERS/Sukree Sukplang 39

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 "The signs for China remain strong ... and while we continue to have belief in emerging nations and the mid-term story for China, then we think we will see the investments continue," said Paul Robinson, group manager for non-ferrous metals at con- sultancy CRU Group. "The indications from miners are that none of them are letting up in terms of their investment portfolio. None is saying they're not going to invest in their projects going forwards on the basis of the economic outlook," he added. Stockholm-based industry consultants Raw Materials Group predicts that capital spending by miners will rise almost 11 per- cent to $155 billion next year, matching the 2008 peak. This year, RMG puts expenditure at $140 billion, up from $126 billion in 2010. Most money is being poured into iron ore, cop- per, gold, coal and potash. There is some concern that mid-tier and smaller companies might run into difficulties if the finan- cial situation deteriorates much further. But most planned spending is by the big miners. "The major capex projects stem from larger companies, and they're committed to these projects ... They're relying on their be- lief that the economy will be able to rectify itself," said Damian Brett, a project manager at RMG. RMG estimates 80 percent of capital spending is by large mining firms. A lot of companies also learned from the last financial crisis in 2008/2009 and the speed with which demand recovered and will try to avoid shelving projects for fear of losing out. "Putting projects on hold put them in a worse position. So if they can, and most have strong balance sheets, they should be able to maintain their funding and development of these projects," Brett said. NO LUXURY FOR SMALL MINERS Smaller companies do not have the luxury of strong balance sheets and have much shorter time horizons. "I'm more concerned about exploration and the mid-tiers and juniors. If cash were to dry up in lower price scenarios, the play- ers more at risk are those living month to month," said CRU's Robinson. "They're probably more susceptible. Essentially they're in no different a position than they were in the last downturn. They're probably closer to the high quartile (of production costs) and need external investors who believe in the commodity story, and they need cash." The fact that the copper market is in supply deficit and likely to remain so until around the middle of the dec- ade should mean spending on copper projects is not affected even in a recession. Supplies of the metal -- used widely in power and construction -- have been constrained for years by a combination of falling ore grades at some of the world's biggest mines, delayed projects and industrial disputes. Some analysts expect the global copper market to be in a deficit of around 300,000 tonnes this year, which will come on top of a shortfall of nearly half a mil- lion tonnes last year. "The projects that were put on hold or suspended last time were mostly other base metals, and the assumption is that would happen again. If things get worse you could see a couple of expansions in zinc put on hold in the short term," said Brett. For now, analysts broadly expect outlays on new mines and expansions to keep rising unless the global economy takes a dive. "If there's a recession, we will see a pull-back (in mine spending). But let's see where the markets are going before coming to any conclusions," said Carl Firman of Virtual Metals.

Metalloyd ready to step up as banks retreat By Pratima Desai LONDON, Oct 3 (Reuters) - K-based Metalloyd plans to expand its iron ore and coal trading and production businesses, aiming to fill a gap that may be left by banks under pressure to curb activities in physical commodities. Moves to limit banks' trading activities mean more opportunities for experienced management in well-financed U trading companies such as Metalloyd, which is majority-owned by entrepreneurs David and Simon Reuben. "Bank to bank lending has virtually ceased; their liquidity is heavily squeezed and subsequently their appetite for business that they consider as risk is more and more curtailed," Managing Director Mel Wilde told Reuters. "This along with pending legislation has forced some of the banks to start reducing their physical trading activities, we can see this with some heavy redundancies and cutbacks." Banks are shedding jobs worldwide as stricter regulations and a tough second quarter for trading income take their toll. Banks that have announced job cuts include UK-listed HSBC , U.S.-based Bank of America Merrill Lynch and Swiss-based Credit Suisse . Metalloyd's strategy echoes the likes of the world's largest commodity trader, Glencore and Trafigura "We have taken steps to become a producer/trader with the ultimate intention of having up to 50 percent of supply from our own in house sources," Wilde said. "As an example we have acquired a 50 percent stake in an iron ore mine in Morocco that was previously worked by the French and abandoned 40 years ago." 40

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 The Moroccan mine already has some infrastructure in place including a rail link to Jorf Lasfar port and it has proven reserves of 88 million tonnes with a further 400 million tonnes in estimated reserves. Other mining interests include a large talc and calcite deposit reserve in Morocco -- minerals are used in the , paper, paint and cosmetics industries. The group also has mining interests in the United States and Asia. "On the manufactured goods side we have always been keen to promote the recyclability of steel and have linked this to green energy opening our first group company, Ventower, in Detroit manufacturing steel wind towers, sold to energy companies in the United States," Wilde said. "There are plans for more of these across the United States." Metalloyd also jointly owns Erus, a warehousing business with Barclays bank . Both Metalloyd and Barclays own 47.5 percent, while Erus management own five percent.

China 2012 base metals demand seen up, hinges on credit By Polly Yam HONG KONG, Sept 30 (Reuters) - hina's base metals consumption growth rate could slow further next year as exports fall, even if Beijing starts to loosen monetary policy after the first quarter. A possible debt crisis in developed countries and Beijing's credit tightening are the two major factors that could slow C demand in the world's top consumer and producer of most base metals. Still, with the country having run down stocks during a period of high prices, imports of refined copper may see an increase after falling sharply so far this year. The State Reserves Bureau, which manages state reserves, may take advantage of any fall in prices to add stocks that industry sources estimate stand between one million and 1.3 million tonnes and target to 2 million tonnes by 2015. "If this year's demand growth is 6 percent to 7 percent, the growth rate in 2012 could be about 5 percent," Jing Chuan, chief researcher at Hua Tai Great Wall Futures said, referring to consumption of all six base metals. He said the the debt crisis in the euro zone had been raising worries about a slowing of the global economy next year. Such worries could cut private investment in China and therefore domestic demand, while a slowdown would hit China's exports of metals. "We are not very optimistic about next year. Demand from small and medium-sized copper fabricators is weak and credit is very tight," an executive at a large copper smelter said.

Copper cooking pots still in use today, some dating back to King George IV, sit on racks in the kitchens at Buckingham Palace in London .REUTERS/Nick Ansell 41

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 The Chinese government would try to keep economic growth at 7-8 percent or above to keep unemployment in check, Jing said. He added that a stable social and economic situation in China would be particularly important next year when a new leadership is set to emerge. The International Monetary Fund forecasts China's GDP will rise 9.5 percent this year and 9 percent in 2012. COPPER, SRB China's copper consumption may rise to 7.8-7.9 million tonnes in 2012 from 7.38 million tonnes expected this year, with de- mand from the power sector set to remain strong, Yang Changhua, copper analyst at state-backed research firm Antaike, said. "We see a rise of 6-7 percent next year, compared to a gain of 8.5 percent this year," Yang predicted. He said China's need to build and reform its power networks would continue next year, even if tight monetary policy remains. Grace Qu, China-based copper consultant for U.K.-headquartered CRU, told Reuters on Tuesday that the firm may adjust down its copper demand growth forecast of 5 percent for next year due to the economic situation in the United States and the euro zone. A trading manager for a large copper tubes producer said the firm would produce about 400,000 tonnes this year from 375,000 tonnes last year, and hopes for a similar rise in 2012. Like many end-users in China, the manager said the firm would build copper inventory only when it sees a stable outlook in the market. The State Reserves Bureau however would pick low prices to build stocks, industry sources said. Hua Tai's Jing said he expected the SRB to import copper at about $6,000, a level not seen since October 2009. An industry source with links to the SRB also pointed to the $6,000 level, who said this had been the target level in late 2010. The last large orders for copper imports the SRB placed were in late 2008 to 2009 at about $3,000-$6,000 a tonne, with the bulk being purchased below $4,000, industry sources said. While still well above this level at $7,048 a tonne on Thursday, benchmark LME copper prices have lost nearly a quarter of their value this month. LEAD The worst performer next year may be refined lead after China closed hundreds of lead-acid battery factories this year. China started a crackdown on lead polluting operations after a lead-acid battery manufacturing plant in Zhejiang province was identified as the source of a local outbreak of lead poisoning. By the end of July, 583 lead-acid battery producers, processors and recyclers were phased out and another 1,015 plants were temporarily closed. Reduced production of lead-acid batteries, accounting for about 70 percent of the country's consumption of refined lead, have supported battery prices in the second half of the year, spurring large battery makers to boost production. But overall produc- tion remains lower than last year. Many small and medium battery makers that were closed would not be allowed to reopen next year due to environmental concerns and would trim lead demand, a sales manager at a large lead smelter said. "There is a low chance that lead demand will rise in 2012. Additional production from large battery makers cannot fully cover lost production from those smaller ones," the sales manager said. ALUMINIUM, NICKEL, ZINC, TIN Primary aluminium demand growth may slump to single digits in 2012 after rising some 12-13 percent to 18-19 million tonnes this year, industry sources said. "China's demand is there, it won't go anywhere. The issue would be whether end-users have money to buy aluminium," said a manager at an aluminium smelter in Guizhou province. For nickel, demand is expected to slow in 2012 from a rise of up to 20 percent expected this year due to smaller output growth in stainless steel production, the top nickel user in China, said Fan Runze, analyst at Antaike. He sees nickel demand at 580,000-600,000 tonnes this year, with stainless steel output at 14 million tonnes from 11-12 mil- lion tonnes in 2010. Antaike also sees tin consumption growth at less than 5 percent next year, after growing 2.5-3 percent to about 155,000 ton- nes this year, analyst Ran Jun said. Consumption for refined zinc may rise 8-9 percent to 5.4 million tonnes in 2012, compared to a gain of 5-6 percent expected this year, Lei Xiaoli, zinc analyst at Shanghai-based information provider SMM said. She said power shortages and tight environmental checks to zinc alloy plants and zinc galvanizing plants had cut zinc de- mand this year and those conditions would improve next year. China's building of affordable houses also would boost demand for zinc galvanized steel, Lei said.

42

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 COLUMN-The short-term outlook for iron ore (The opinions expressed in this article represent the views of the author. They should not be seen as necessarily reflecting the view of Reuters.) By Paul Gray, principal iron ore analyst for Wood Mackenzie LONDON, Oct 3 (Reuters) - ith financial markets in turmoil and most exchange-traded industrial commodities in free-fall, it's hard to give a positive short-term view on spot iron ore prices. W The key negative risks for iron ore revolve around two factors: First, the possible failure of Chinese steel prices to pick up following national holidays, which could lead to a fur- ther squeeze on what are already thin margins, and/or a major bout of de-stocking by European steel mills. Also significantly tighter monetary conditions in China would make it more difficult for steel mills to obtain sufficient credit for a large re-stocking phase ahead of the winter. Indications from the OTC SWAP market certainly paint a negative picture in the short term with the forward curve pricing in a further $20 a tonne drop by year-end. Wood Mackenzie's research concurs with the view that prices have further to fall in the short term, but our three-month view is more positive. Chinese mills, many of which have been operating with excessively low raw material stocks for several months, will return to the import market in force from mid-October at price levels some 10 percent below the September peak. An acute shortage of Indian cargoes and constraints on Chinese domestic ore production will give the major ore shippers the upper hand in pricing as we progress through the fourth quarter. However, in contrast to the situation this time last year, when spot iron ore was trading at a wide premium to quarterly con- tract prices, we do not anticipate a major upside break from implied fourth-quarter contracts, which net back to approximately $165 a tonne FOB Australia, basis 62% Fe.

An employee works in a ferronickel smelter owned by state miner Aneka Tambang Tbk at Pomala district in Indonesia's southeast Sulawesi province. REUTERS/Yusuf Ahmad 43

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 COLUMN-Demand and supply matter for base metals ( The opinions expressed in this article represent the views of the author ) By Ian Morley, director at metals trading firm Condor LONDON, Oct 3 (Reuters) - o quote the old cliché, all that glitters is not gold. In these troubled times even gold is glistening a little less than be- fore and the industrial metals are beginning to look a bit tarnished. T The fundamentals of base metal strength had begun to reach the point of irrational market levels. Nothing new there. As always with bubbles the selective use of demand and supply arguments seem to make even the most extended prices seem reasonable. Add on to that the mystique and insights of the sages who read charts and technical analysis, the profound wisdom of trend followers and the potency of the economic iliteracy of the financial pages of the popular press and the crowd needs little per- suading that they should buy now before it's too late and too expensive. All this feels similar to the gravity defying levels that oil reached in 2008. While the rest of the markets had crashed oil contin- ued to go up. It was not just speculation but oil traders also began to believe the same hype and so everyone was long of the major com- modity for energy as the global demand for oil was falling. A lot of people who ought to have known better lost a lot of money. The effect of crowds even on the rational can be unpre- dictable. A similar story is now unfolding with metals. Fiat,(paper) currencies gyrate around in global panic allowing the price of gold to reach dizzying heights. Maybe the price of gold reflects the ultimate barometer of the trust people have in politician's ability not to print money as their way out of economic crisis? If so, then perhaps buy on any falling opportunity. The same is not the case with base metals. Demand and supply do matter here. Real demand has fallen. That's what happens as you enter a recsssion. Eastern, read Chinese demand has fallen. The Chinese have destocked a bit because they overbought. And despite Asian growth being better than Western growth it is also now coming under pressure from bubbles in asset prices and classes, inflation and corruption. Copper is normally seen as the gold of base metals. It's not a bad story from a fundamental standpoint. Problem is the price was all in the good news and had risen way beyond the costs of production. Mr Bernanke may well print money to build infrastructure products that require lots of base metals. If this happens then at least temporarily they may go up again. Then again, they are priced in U.S. dollars and not Aussie dollars so they may just go up to reflect the inflation of the U.S. cur- rency. If all this ends in recession and depression we could need all these base metals to make new Anderson shelters in our gar- dens. I am old enough to remember ours after the last war. On that happy note I am off to my local store to buy some.

COLUMN-Recycling the key to a balanced lead market (The opinions expressed in this article represent the views of the author. They should not be seen as necessarily reflecting the view of Reuters.) By Huw Roberts, lead specialist at CHR Metals Limited LONDON, Oct 3 (Reuters) - he global lead industry can justifiably congratulate itself on the extent to which recycling satisfies demand for the metal. T Lead is recovered from scrap, principally batteries, and also from a range of other industrial residues and wastes. CHR Metals forecasts that global refined lead output in 2011 will exceed 11 million tonnes for the first time and that 65 percent of this production will be from secondary sources. Taking China out of the equation lifts the share of secondary production to 77 percent. With lead-acid batteries accounting for 85 percent of global lead demand, and with almost all these batteries likely to be recy- cled at the end of their useful lives, the proportion of secondary production will inevitably increase over time, reaching at least 70 percent worldwide by 2015.

44

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 Moreover, this forecast benefits from a degree of certainty unusual in metal markets in that many of the batteries that will be recycled in the years up to 2015 are already in use, and therefore the quantity of lead available to be recovered in due course is, to a large degree, already known. Economic conditions will have some impact on the volume of lead recycled in any one year, a sharp downturn resulting in fewer replacement batteries being purchased and, hence, fewer being scrapped and available for recycling. This, from the perspective of the market, means that lower demand is likely to be offset to some degree by lower production of recycled lead. The reverse also holds true. Taken in isolation, price developments affect recycling activity less than primary mining and smelting, where low prices may force closures and high prices encourage new developments. With batteries the dominant end-use of lead and given the very high recycling rates now achieved, it is unlikely that the lead market faces any near-term shortfall in supply. Foreseeable incremental demand can, and will, be met from primary produc- tion. World lead mine production is expected to be over 4.1 million tonnes in 2011. Allowing for processing losses, this means that primary smelter production from concentrates, not allowing for any stock change, will be around 3.9 million tonnes. Assuming that lead-acid batteries account for 85 percent of demand, this implies, given consumption in 2011 of almost 11 mil- lion tonnes, that 9.3 million tonnes of lead will be used in an application that will, in time, be more or less fully recycled. Much of the balance of consumption, 1.7 million tonnes, will either be used in non-recyclable applications or recycled only after a considerable span of years. But this 1.7 million tonnes is considerably less than the 3.9 million tonnes expected to be supplied to the market in 2011 from primary production. The difference, over 2 million tonnes, is supporting incremental growth in lead consumption in batteries this year. In other words, over half of primary production fills the gap between the supply of recycled lead, reflecting consumption in batteries some years earlier, and current demand for lead to be used in the manufacture of new batteries. Primary output also makes up for small, but inevitable, losses in battery collection and metallurgical recoveries.

Miners ride an elevator to the underground in a pit-shaft at Polkowice-Sieroszowice mine in Polkowice near Lubin, southern-western Poland. REUTERS/Kacper Pempel

45

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 Taken as a whole, the global lead market looks to be adequately supplied for the foreseeable future, an observation supported by significant increases this year in exchange-traded stocks in both London Metal Exchange (LME) warehouses (to a record level) and in China (Shanghai Futures Exchange). However, there is still scope for temporary regional imbalances to develop. Consumption is currently growing rapidly in the industrialising/emerging economies in Asia and South America. In many of these countries the existing "inventory" of lead in batteries available to be recycled falls well short of the amount of lead required to meet expanding demand for batteries. The Basel Convention largely prevents scrap batteries flowing from the mature economies to those countries with a deficit in lead supplies. Instead, those countries with a lead deficit are currently net importers of refined lead and/or batteries, with many of these being manufactured in China. China is unable to export its surplus stocks of refined lead due to stiff export taxes but can export lead in batteries. CHR Metals estimates that, in recent years, China has exported, on average, just under 300,000 tonnes a year of lead in bat- teries. This has been an important factor in maintaining the lead market outside China in a state of modest surplus since 2008. Any significant change in the volume of China's lead-acid battery exports in the future would, therefore, also have an impact on refined lead market balances.

COLUMN-The tarnished outlook for industrial metals (The opinions expressed in this article represent the views of the author) By Frances Hudson, global thematic strategist at Standard Life Investments LONDON, Oct 3 (Reuters)- here is broad agreement amongst analysts and mining companies on the market outlook for industrial commodities - weak demand in the short term but stronger medium and long-term prospects. Supply constraints are less discussed against such a background. T However, it is probably just as easy to make the counter argument that the short-term outlook is too negative but me- dium-term demand will be subdued as the debt and deficit deleveraging process plays out and the EU and the US attempt to put their economic houses in order.

Workers are seen through a steel tube at a steel products market in Hefei, Anhui province September 20, 2011. REUTERS/Stringer

46

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 Weak demand has naturally followed from an economic slowdown and has been exacerbated by the disruption caused by the March 11 Japanese tsunami and earthquake. How quickly and whether demand picks up on a sustained basis depends on policy decisions in several major economies. Be- cause so much is politics and policy dependent, the call on timing is difficult. A decision by China to reflate would help, while further quantitative easing by the U.S. would tend to promote commodities along with other risk assets. Fundamentally, it is clear that incremental demand should come from increased infrastructure expenditure in the wake of natural disasters. Also, technical failings mean some of the rapidly constructed projects in China will need re-doing in a more robust fashion, requiring more industrial-metal content. China's share of the industrial metals market has increased from 23 percent of global consumption in 2005 to around 42 per- cent today, according to Barclays Capital. However, in China's case it is not clear to what extent metals such as aluminium, copper, lead, nickel and zinc are being stock- piled rather than used. Net imports of copper have been reduced by more than a third in 2011, suggesting that China has been canny about restock- ing, i.e. buying on the dips and recycling when prices are high. The outlook for the copper price near term is dominated by sentiment over Greece and the Euro situation as well as financing pressures in China, but plans to increase stock of social housing in China should underpin demand further out. New supplies of refined copper from the Democratic Republic of Congo, India and Mexico, and new mined supplies from Mon- golia, Congo and Zambia, could balance the market in the medium term. For the developed world, prospects of a sustained economic recovery seem to be receding and the timing of elections will hamper progress on some infrastructure initiatives, leading to softer demand for a range of metals. As far as supply constraints and inventory levels are concerned, industrial metals' prices have become increasingly irrational. Aluminium and nickel have been in abundant supply for some time. This raises the question of why prices have only recently corrected along with other commodities.

Workers prepare for a blasting operation in a quarry at the Ariab mine. REUTERS/Mohamed Nureldin Abdallah 47

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 Possible explanations include markets trading away from fundamentals or that inventories are not real, in the sense that they are being used as collateral in an environment where financial credit is constrained by policy, and are therefore not available for commercial use. Another potential drag on the supply of base metals is higher taxation. By the end of 2010 specific taxes on mining activity featured in a dozen countries. Both the incidence and levels of taxation are increasing. Australia introduced a carbon tax. In Chile and Peru taxes and royalties on operating profits are used to fund welfare spend- ing. Zambia and Tanzania have imposed windfall taxes on 'super' profits in addition to mining royalties. With volatile prices, governments will need to calibrate their levies so as to avoid discouraging activity. Traded volumes for industrial commodities look healthy, but much of the trade is speculative rather than commercial and is subject to sudden reversals. Evidence comes from data on speculative positioning and the changing relationships between prices across the commodity complex. Speculators have retreated from recent extremes, but are still long of commodities and are moving from short to neutral positioning on the dollar. Cross-commodity correlations have risen with investment interest in commodities as a hedge against financial risks. In particular, the rise in index trading via Exchange Traded Funds has contributed to three-month correlations increasing from 0.34, measured by Absolute Strategy Research over a decade, to 0.48 for the past three years. For copper the correlation with other commodities is 0.55 on the shorter time frame. All of which muddies the waters further.

COLUMN-China's FDI in mining -threat or opportunity? (The opinions expressed in this article represent the views of the author.) By Magnus Ericsson, Professor of Mineral Economics at Lulea University of Technology in Stockholm, senior partner Raw Ma- terials Group LONDON, Oct 3 (Reuters) - he Chinese scramble for mineral resources in Australia, Africa and around the world is seen as one example of a Chi- nese strategy to take control of vital resources. T But how important is the Chinese influence over world mine production? China has become the world's largest mining nation, overtaking Australia and rapidly increasing its domestic produc- tion during the past 5-7 years in particular. In 2008 China accounted for 14.8 percent of the total value at the mine stage of metals produced in the world. Australia is in second place followed by Chile and Brazil. If coal were included, China's lead would increase as it is by far the most important coal producer. The total value of metal production controlled by Chinese-based companies outside China in 2009 is however considerably less than 1.0 percent of the total value measured in the same way as above. This is much less than that controlled by Canadian, Australian or UK-based mining companies, for example. Included in this figure are only mines which are already producing and in which Chinese owners have at least shared control. The overwhelming majority of Chinese investments in operating mines have been made in its neighbouring countries: Mongo- lia, Vietnam; Afghanistan for example, as well as in Australia, mostly in search for iron ore deposits. The Chinese influence over non-fuel mineral production in Africa, which has often been highlighted as the continent on which the Chinese focus in their scramble for resources, is only marginal, probably below 0.1 percent. But perhaps the present situation is changing rapidly and many more Chinese-controlled projects will come into operation in the near future? Even if we look at the projects, which at present have Chinese investors with controlling interests but which are not yet in pro- duction, the number and size of these future mines do not give support to any scary scenario. The Chinese are far from taking control over the mineral resources of Africa and definitely not the world. Given the present strong push for further investments into overseas mining operations, it is probable that the Chinese influ- ence over world mining will increase but it will take years before Chinese companies and China become a powerful global player in the mining industry. From the viewpoint of African and other mineral-rich emerging economies, strong demand for metals from China and con- cerns in the industrialised countries that their future supply might be threatened open opportunities to create a competitive situation where they could get better deals than before. These emerging countries must, however, have the internal capacity, competence and resources to manage their mineral re- sources and the rents they generate. The lack of human resources is often the weakest link. 48

COMMODITIESGOLDGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDS WILL ECONOMY, FOCUS RISK SHIVERBATTERED AVERSION ON ON PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BY BANISH DEBT INSHARPEST U.S. FOCUS ECONOMY CREDIT DOWNGRADE CORRECTION AT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY CORRECTION FEARS OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST 2011201201120111 COLUMN-Supply deficits to help copper rebound (The opinions expressed in this article represent the views of the author.) By Paul Dewison, Bloomsbury Mineral Economics (BME) LONDON, Oct 4 (Reuters) - opper prices have been pounded by worsening economic news from both sides of the Atlantic, a slowing in China, dire warnings from the IMF and a collapse in equities. So, where does that leave us now? Given that bad news items tend to follow hard on the heels of each other, copper may well be buffeted further on the C macroeconomic tide. With the perception that prices may fall further, buyers of copper could hold off until they are more certain that they can buy it at a bargain price. Hence, in coming days and weeks, further falls are not at all unlikely. There is some concern that copper may have further to fall than other base metals. After all, so the argument goes, copper prices are higher in relation to production costs, so can accommodate a larger drop without de-railing the project pipeline and hence creating future market shortage. We believe that this view is over-pessimistic. So long as there is not a wholesale flight of investors from commodities, cop- per's market fundamentals are strong enough to ensure a price rebound in coming months with most, if not all, lost ground regained. First, look at the market balance. We forecast deficits of 476,000 tonnes in 2011 and 219,000 tonnes in 2012. These figures are based on modest copper use growth of 4.0 percent in 2011 and just 2.6 percent in 2012, with which few are likely to argue. The healthy deficit in 2011 is achieved mainly because of very low mine output growth and despite high scrap use. Our 2012 deficit incorporates a 5.4 percent rise in mine output, a rate that history has shown the copper industry is unlikely to exceed. Secondly, look at liquid stocks. Repeated market deficits have meant a sharp drawdown in available stocks, especially in consumer yards. Future deficits are likely to see these stocks drawn down to a critical level. Thirdly, take a look at scrap. The era of high prices has meant scrap content rising in smelting, refining and fabricating. It now accounts for around 38 percent of the supply chain. Some argue that more scrap is now being used than can be generated, despite today's high copper prices. Even if this is not true, a fall in prices will mean lower scrap generation and merchant holding of stock. The net results -- increased concentrates content in refined metal, more refined metal use at the expense of scrap, and an even larger market deficit.

Workers prepare for a blasting operation in a quarry at the Ariab mine. REUTERS/Mohamed Nureldin Abdallah 49

SINGAPOREGOLDCOMMODITIESGOLD:—————DEMAND,LME WEEK: REBOUNDSHITSHOVERS WILL ECONOMY, RECORDFOCUS RISKINTERNATIONAL SHIVERBATTEREDNEAR AVERSION ON ON HIGH RECORDS PRICES JAPAN DEMAND, AFTER BYABOVE BANISH DEBT INSHARPESTENERGY U.S. ON FOCUS ECONOMY $1,622/OZ CREDIT DOWNGRADE U.S. CORRECTION WEEK—SPECIAL ATDEBT LOSS DOWNGRADELME AND WOES SINCE WEEK PRICESDESPITE FEARS? MAY PDF CORRECTION FEARS NOVEMBER OCTOBER AUGUSTAUGUST AUGUST JULY 20112010 20112011

REUTERS INSIDER (Click on the headlines to view the show) • Copper prices to rally sharply on China demand: Macquarie • Aluminium Growth Prospects to Outshine Peers: CRU • Asian appetite for copper stays firm, price to rise: Codelco CEO • Long-term copper prices to jump by 20 pct: Reuters Poll • Chile cuts mining deaths by 50 pct, mining minister says • Commodity warehousing: the new gold mines

EDITORIAL: THOMSON REUTERS COMMODITIES NEWS BRIEFS & PUBLICATIONS: Clarence Fernandez ( Senior Sub Editor, Commodities & Energy ) +65 6870 3861, [email protected] NEWSLETTERS:

Richard Mably (Global Editor, Commodities & Energy) • Inside Commodities +44-207-542-6280, [email protected] • Inside Agriculture • Inside Oil Veronica Brown (Editor, Commodities and Energy, EMEA) • Inside Oil – (Americas) +44-20-7542-8065, [email protected] • Inside Metals • Inside Dry Freight Jonathan Leff (Editor, Commodities & Energy, Americas) • Biofuels & Renewables Weekly +1-646-223-6068, [email protected] • Freight Monthly

• India Agriculture Monthly Sambit Mohanty (Editor in Charge, Commodities & Energy, Asia), +65-6870-3084, [email protected] • Oil Swaps Forward Curve Monthly • Trading Carbon

SUBSCRIPTION:

If you have not already registered and would like to receive future copies of this or other news briefs and publications from Thomson Reuters click here

FOR MORE INFORMATION:

Learn more about our products and services for commodities profes- sionals, click here PRIVACY STATEMENT: Send us a sales enquiry, click here To find out more about how we may collect, use and share your personal information please read our privacy statement here Contact your local Thomson Reuters office, click here

© 2011 Thomson Reuters. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Thomson Reuters content, including by framing or similar means, is prohibited without the prior written consent of Thomson Reuters. "Thomson Reuters" and the Thomson Reuters logo are trademarks of Thomson Reuters and its affiliated companies.

50 8” 7” SAFETY

“RIGHT NOW, I’M NOT SEEKING FAME, FORTUNE, OR A CORNER OFFICE. I’M LOOKING FOR THE OTHER HALF OF MY IDEA.” 10” SAFETY 10” 10.75”

Created for a new generation of financial professionals, Thomson Reuters Eikon is more comprehensive, more intuitive, and more collaborative than anything you’ve ever worked with. Now you can navigate effortlessly from news to analysis to communication to action — whenever, wherever you do business. See the demo at thomsonreuters.com/eikon NEW ERA. NEW TOOLS.

©2010 Thomson Reuters.

P4CB SIZE A SINGLE PAGE NON-BLEED Creative: AMI NON-BLEED: 8.5” w x 11.5” h; TRIM: 8” w x 10.75” h; LIVE: 7” w x 10 ” h