Representing Genocide: the Holocaust As Paradigm? Rebecca

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Representing Genocide: the Holocaust As Paradigm? Rebecca Representing Genocide: The Holocaust as Paradigm? Rebecca Jinks Royal Holloway, University of London PhD January 2013 1 Declaration of Authorship I declare that this thesis and the work presented in it is entirely my own. Where I have consulted the work of others, this is always clearly stated. Signed: Date: 2 Abstract This thesis addresses how far the Holocaust and its representation have influenced the representation of other genocides, focusing specifically on the Armenian, Cambodian, Bosnian, and Rwandan cases. At the same time, it also considers how western publics might interpret and respond to these representations, and with what effect. Using literature, film, photography, and memorialisation, the thesis argues that we can only understand the Holocaust’s status as a ‘benchmark’ for other genocides if we look at the deeper, structural resonances which subtly shape many representations of genocide – thereby countering much of the existing literature, whose focus is on explicit references to the Holocaust and the surrounding identity politics. The thesis is divided into five sections, which explore: how genocides are recognised as such by western publics; the representation of the origins and perpetrators of genocide; how western witnesses represent genocide; representations of the aftermath of genocide; and western responses to genocide. Throughout, it distinguishes between ‘mainstream’ and other, more nuanced and engaged, representations of genocide. It argues that these mainstream representations – the majority – largely replicate the representational framework of the Holocaust, including the way in which mainstream Holocaust representations resist recognising the rationality, instrumentality and normality of genocide, preferring instead to present it as an aberrant, exceptional event in human society. By contrast, the more engaged representations – often, but not always, originating from those who experienced genocide – tend to revolve around precisely genocide’s ordinariness, and the structures and situations common to human society which contribute to and become involved in the violence. 3 Acknowledgements First thanks were always due to Dan Stone, for being a brilliant supervisor. His support and guidance have always been a great help, but I value most the ways in which he has taught me to think about history and its writing. Many others have helped shape my work and have given me invaluable support in the academic arena – in particular Helen Graham, who always ups the ante, but also Rudolf Muhs, Daniel Beer, Robert Eaglestone, Andy Pearce, Zoë Waxman, Lars Waldorf, Justin Champion, Sarah Ansari, and James Connolly, who has been a friend, sounding board, and proof-reader since our undergraduate studies. I would also like to thank Marie-Christine Ockenden, otherwise known as The Oracle, for being a fantastic (and very human) postgraduate administrator. Friends have dealt with my general absenteeism in various ways, for which I thank them: Helen, Jess, Philly, Sam, Andy, James, Martina, Maddy, Rebecca, Doerte, and Millie. Various friends accompanied me to far-flung (or less so) destinations during my research, and deserve special thanks here. In particular is Sam Hardie, who has put up with extreme cold and extreme heat, multiple visits to the same museum, and tea deprivation, all while continuing to help me think about the places we visited. Asya Darbinyan was a friend and translator during my stay in Armenia, and both my parents and Helen Graham joined me on various trips to the former Yugoslavia. The final thanks are reserved for my parents, for their love and support, and their constant encouragement. 4 Table of Contents Introduction 6 Chapter 1. Recognising Genocide: The ‘Genocidal Imaginary’ 30 Chapter 2. Explaining Genocide: Representations of the Origins and Perpetrators of Genocide 67 Chapter 3. Witnessing Genocide: Western Protagonists in the Theatre of Genocide 105 Chapter 4. Resolving Genocide: Representing the Aftermath 140 Chapter 5. Responding to Genocide: Attitudes and Platitudes 182 Conclusion 222 Bibliography 225 5 Introduction ‘[T]he Holocaust has become the pre-eminent symbol of evil in the modern world, encouraging other groups to copy its vocabulary and imagery, while sometimes contesting its significance. … Representation of the past and present can thus become a contest … In so doing, they trivialise the Holocaust and the unique suffering of the group they represent.’ – David B. MacDonald1 ‘[F]ar from blocking other historical memories from view in a competitive struggle for recognition, the emergence of Holocaust memory on a global scale has contributed to the articulation of other histories … Ultimately, memory is not a zero-sum game.’ – Michael Rothberg2 A decade into the twenty-first century, the Holocaust appears as a cornerstone of contemporary western culture: ubiquitously memorialised in stone, film, and print, it occupies a central place in our consciousness of the past. Whether or not one agrees with Alon Confino that we are reaching the end of a stage in Holocaust consciousness stretching from the mid-1970s to the present, he is surely correct to observe that the (often moralising) battles over Holocaust memory make sense only within a memory culture that has accepted and internalised the essential place of the extermination of the Jews in European history.3 Although Confino is largely referring to the memory battles fought within the arena of Holocaust memory (over the ‘dangers of forgetting’, and what might constitute ‘sufficient memorialisation’), as my two epigraphs show, battle is also being done over the place of Holocaust memory within wider memory cultures, between those who make reference to the Holocaust when articulating their own histories of oppression and suffering, and those who jealously guard against this sort of plagiarism. While various scholars have speculated as to whether the Holocaust’s ubiquity and prominence might somehow dampen our responses to other atrocities,4 others, such as David B. MacDonald, have inventoried instances of groups ‘cloaking’ or ‘framing’ their own suffering in the ‘vestments of the Holocaust’ in order to seek 1 David B. MacDonald, Identity Politics in the Age of Genocide: The Holocaust and Historical Representation (Abingdon: Routledge, 2008), 15, 196. 2 Michael Rothberg, Multidirectional Memory: Remembering the Holocaust in the Age of Decolonization (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2009), 6, 11. 3 Alon Confino, ‘A World Without Jews: Interpreting the Holocaust’, German History 27:4 (2009), 531- 59, especially 531-4. 4 For example, Scott L. Montgomery, ‘What Kind of Memory? Reflections on Images of the Holocaust’, Contention 5:1 (1995), 71-104; Barbie Zelizer, Remembering to Forget: Holocaust Memory Through the Camera’s Eye (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1998), especially chapters 6 & 7. 6 recognition or reparation – including Armenians, indigenous groups in Australia, America and New Zealand, and ethnic groups in the former Yugoslavia.5 Often implicit within these inventories is a form of border patrol, an indignation at the ‘appropriation’ of the Holocaust in what is seen as a strategy of identity politics. Following the spirit of Michael Rothberg’s Multidirectional Memory, however, I instead want to operate a more open (and, pace Confino, less moralising) approach to the overlaps and intersections between representations of the Holocaust and of other genocides. While Rothberg’s book explores the interaction of memories of the Holocaust, decolonisation, and racism, I am primarily interested in representations of genocides other than the Holocaust. The last few decades have seen an outpouring of scholarly analyses of Holocaust memorialisation, literature, film, photography, graphic comics, and art, often with highly sophisticated analyses and theoretical considerations; few, though, have explored where and how these theories might also be applied to the representations of other genocides. Given the emotional charge attached to the word ‘genocide’, the similar representational difficulties often facing those attempting to represent other genocides, and that there often are congruences in representation, my aim is to explore how representations of other genocides have been constructed, and might be received, when the Holocaust is such a cultural benchmark. This thesis focuses on representations of the Armenian, Cambodian, Bosnian and Rwandan genocides, in film, literature, photography, and memorialisation, and how they respond to the ‘central’ or ‘paradigmatic’ place of the Holocaust in contemporary society. The key questions are: how do representations of genocide engage with, or borrow from, representations of the Holocaust, and when do they show entirely different concerns? How might westerners respond to these representations, given that, as Confino argues, western memory cultures have largely internalised the Holocaust as an essential part of European history? Of course, to speak of ‘westerners’ and ‘the west’ here is to include a vast number of people, infinitely divisible by nation, cultural background, religion, generation, education, politics, and so on. The very range of this divisibility shows that the national is not the only prism through which to view culture 5 MacDonald, Identity Politics, 17. MacDonald suggests an overly slippery slope when he draws a straight line from ‘invocations of the Holocaust’s vocabulary’ to Holocaust denial (6-7). Another example, although more sophisticated, is Angi Buettner,
Recommended publications
  • 20091109 Encuentrohe Agarcia
    Research in Linguistic Engineering: Resources and Tools♦ Ana García-Serrano, José M. Goñi-Menoyo (1) NLP&IR Group, ETSI Informática, Universidad Nacional de Educación a Distancia (UNED) C/ Juan del Rosal 16, 28040 Madrid [email protected] (1) ETSI Telecomunicación, Universidad Politécnica de Madrid (UPM) Avda. Complutense, Nº 30, 28040 Madrid [email protected] Abstract In this paper we are revisiting some of the resources and tools developed by the members of the Intelligent Systems Research Group (GSI) at UPM as well as from the Information Retrieval and Natural Language Processing Research Group (IR&NLP) at UNED. Details about developed resources (corpus, software) and current interests and projects are given for the two groups. It is also included a brief summary and links into open source resources and tools developed by other groups of the MAVIR consortium (www.mavir.net). 1. GSI - UPM Research interests One of our main goals is to explore the usefulness of these systems in real exploitation scenarios, as the web pages of One of the GSI main research interest is the analysis of the a Local government (Mesia project, TIC-07T/0017/1998 current available methods and techniques in the field of Computational Model for Selective Information Multilingual Information Retrieval and their application, Extraction from Short Texts) Technical Support Services especially to the case in which one of the involved (Rimmel, TIN2004-07588-C03-01 Multilingual & languages is Spanish. In addition to that, contributing to Multimedia Information Retrieval and its Evaluation), the application of new techniques, the improvement of Recommended Systems (Advice, IST-1999-11305 existing ones, and the hybridation or combination of all Virtual Sales Assistant for the Complete Customer Service them are also our objectives.
    [Show full text]
  • Yellow Star, Red Star: Holocaust Remembrance After Communism'
    H-Judaic Rice on Subotić, 'Yellow Star, Red Star: Holocaust Remembrance after Communism' Review published on Monday, June 29, 2020 Jelena Subotić. Yellow Star, Red Star: Holocaust Remembrance after Communism. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2019. Illustrations. 328 pp. $29.95 (cloth), ISBN 978-1-5017-4240-8. Reviewed by Monika Rice (Gratz College) Published on H-Judaic (June, 2020) Commissioned by Barbara Krawcowicz (Norwegian University of Science and Technology) Printable Version: http://www.h-net.org/reviews/showpdf.php?id=54856 Holocaust commemoration as an expansion of Holocaust memory studies entered scholarship in the 1990s with the seminal works of Tom Segev (The Seventh Million: The Israelis and the Holocaust [1991]), James Young (The Texture of Memory: Holocaust Memorials and Meaning in Europe, Israel, and America [1993]), and Peter Novick (The Holocaust in American Life [1999]). Michael Steinlauf’s groundbreaking work on Holocaust memory in Eastern Europe, Bondage to the Dead: Poland and the Memory of the Holocaust (1996), complemented these works that dealt, mostly, with Western and Israeli Holocaust remembrance. Since then, the field of Holocaust memory has proliferated in the last two decades, transforming the Holocaust from an event remembered as committed by specific historical agents (Germans and their collaborators) to a symbol of universal evil.[1] The memory of the destruction of European Jews, or, perhaps, its postmemory (considering that its carriers are second and third postwar generations), has acquired cosmopolitan and global qualities, which involve its “universalization, de-territorialization, decontextualization and mediatization.”[2] Surprisingly not included in this globalized trend of Holocaust memory are the countries of Eastern Europe, where the mass murder of the Jews took place.
    [Show full text]
  • Instituciones Participantes Y Entidades Colaboradoras
    Instituciones participantes y entidades colaboradoras PREMIO AL MEJOR LIBRO EDITORIAL # Ayuntamiento de Segovia Casa de Velázquez E Estate Julio Zadik DE FOTOGRAFÍA DEL AÑO CATEGORÍA NACIONAL CATEGORÍA INTERNACIONAL DESTACADA DEL AÑO AUTOEDITADO 20 minutos Ayuntamiento de Zaragoza Catalonia Moratín Edict Europa FM 1998 «Outland» Roger Ballen 50_easy Centro Andaluz de la Fotografía EFTI 1999 «Inferno» James Nachtwey B CentroCentro Ei System F A Facultad de Periodismo CEU 2000 «Vanitas»Cristobal Hara Banco de la República de Bogotá Centro Checo Eizo ABC Banco Espirito Santo Centro Cultural Anabel Segura Ejército de Tierra Feltrero 2001 «Alberto García-Alix (1976-1998)» AC/E. Acción Cultural Española Bank of America Merrill Lynch Centro Cultural Checo El Corte Inglés Filmoteca Española - Cine Doré 2002 Actar por «Very,Very Bad News» de Jordi Bernardó Phaidon Press London por«Martin Parr» / Actes Sud, por «Berlin» de Gabriel Basilico Acciona Baume & Mercier Centro Cultural Conde Duque El Cultural Flamenca ADENA BBVA Centro Cultural de España en Panamá El País FLASH 2003 Steidl por «Home» de Lars TunjOrk Peliti Asociati por «Quelli di Bagueria» de Ferdinando Scianna Adobe Stock Biblioteca Nacional de España Centro de Arte Alcobendas El Periódico del Arte FNAC 2004 TF Editores por «Mujeres, amor y mentiras» Twim Palm Publishers, por «A Story Book Life» AEC Biocombustibles de Cuenca Centro de Arte Caja de Burgos El Profesor Multimedia Fondation Cartier pour l’art contemporain de Carmela García de Philip-Lorca diCorcia AECID. Agencia Española de Cooperación Blank Paper Centro de Arte Dos de Mayo Elle Fondation HSBC pour la Photographie 2005 Editorial Gran Sol – Comunidad de Madrid, por «Manila» Artimo NL, por «Why, Mr.
    [Show full text]
  • Ellies 2018 Finalists Announced
    Ellies 2018 Finalists Announced New York, The New Yorker top list of National Magazine Award nominees; CNN’s Don Lemon to host annual awards lunch on March 13 NEW YORK, NY (February 1, 2018)—The American Society of Magazine Editors today published the list of finalists for the 2018 National Magazine Awards for Print and Digital Media. For the fifth year, the finalists were first announced in a 90-minute Twittercast. ASME will celebrate the 53rd presentation of the Ellies when each of the 104 finalists is honored at the annual awards lunch. The 2018 winners will be announced during a lunchtime presentation on Tuesday, March 13, at Cipriani Wall Street in New York. The lunch will be hosted by Don Lemon, the anchor of “CNN Tonight With Don Lemon,” airing weeknights at 10. More than 500 magazine editors and publishers are expected to attend. The winners receive “Ellies,” the elephant-shaped statuettes that give the awards their name. The awards lunch will include the presentation of the Magazine Editors’ Hall of Fame Award to the founding editor of Metropolitan Home and Saveur, Dorothy Kalins. Danny Meyer, the chief executive officer of the Union Square Hospitality Group and founder of Shake Shack, will present the Hall of Fame Award to Kalins on behalf of ASME. The 2018 ASME Award for Fiction will also be presented to Michael Ray, the editor of Zoetrope: All-Story. The winners of the 2018 ASME Next Awards for Journalists Under 30 will be honored as well. This year 57 media organizations were nominated in 20 categories, including two new categories, Social Media and Digital Innovation.
    [Show full text]
  • Tape ID Title Language Type System
    Tape ID Title Language Type System 1361 10 English 4 PAL 1089D 10 Things I Hate About You (DVD) English 10 DVD 7326D 100 Women (DVD) English 9 DVD KD019 101 Dalmatians (Walt Disney) English 3 PAL 0361sn 101 Dalmatians - Live Action (NTSC) English 6 NTSC 0362sn 101 Dalmatians II (NTSC) English 6 NTSC KD040 101 Dalmations (Live) English 3 PAL KD041 102 Dalmatians English 3 PAL 0665 12 Angry Men English 4 PAL 0044D 12 Angry Men (DVD) English 10 DVD 6826 12 Monkeys (NTSC) English 3 NTSC i031 120 Days Of Sodom - Salo (Not Subtitled) Italian 4 PAL 6016 13 Conversations About One Thing (NTSC) English 1 NTSC 0189DN 13 Going On 30 (DVD 1) English 9 DVD 7080D 13 Going On 30 (DVD) English 9 DVD 0179DN 13 Moons (DVD 1) English 9 DVD 3050D 13th Warrior (DVD) English 10 DVD 6291 13th Warrior (NTSC) English 3 nTSC 5172D 1492 - Conquest Of Paradise (DVD) English 10 DVD 3165D 15 Minutes (DVD) English 10 DVD 6568 15 Minutes (NTSC) English 3 NTSC 7122D 16 Years Of Alcohol (DVD) English 9 DVD 1078 18 Again English 4 Pal 5163a 1900 - Part I English 4 pAL 5163b 1900 - Part II English 4 pAL 1244 1941 English 4 PAL 0072DN 1Love (DVD 1) English 9 DVD 0141DN 2 Days (DVD 1) English 9 DVD 0172sn 2 Days In The Valley (NTSC) English 6 NTSC 3256D 2 Fast 2 Furious (DVD) English 10 DVD 5276D 2 Gs And A Key (DVD) English 4 DVD f085 2 Ou 3 Choses Que Je Sais D Elle (Subtitled) French 4 PAL X059D 20 30 40 (DVD) English 9 DVD 1304 200 Cigarettes English 4 Pal 6474 200 Cigarettes (NTSC) English 3 NTSC 3172D 2001 - A Space Odyssey (DVD) English 10 DVD 3032D 2010 - The Year
    [Show full text]
  • The Lost Executioner: the Story of Comrade Duch and the Khmer Rouge
    THE LOST EXECUTIONER: THE STORY OF COMRADE DUCH AND THE KHMER ROUGE Author: Nic Dunlop Number of Pages: 352 pages Published Date: 04 May 2009 Publisher: Bloomsbury Publishing PLC Publication Country: London, United Kingdom Language: English ISBN: 9781408804018 DOWNLOAD: THE LOST EXECUTIONER: THE STORY OF COMRADE DUCH AND THE KHMER ROUGE The Lost Executioner: The Story of Comrade Duch and the Khmer Rouge PDF Book The narrative of this nonfiction account is engrossing. There was no immediate reaction from the government of Prime Minister Hun Sen, a former Khmer Rouge cadre who rebelled, fled to Vietnam and later helped to drive them from power. It takes a strong stomach to read some of this, but it's worth it. It was Duch. Readers also enjoyed. In Cambodia, between and , some two million people died at the hands of the Khmer Rouge. Upon the death of Comrade Duch, the 1st Khmer Rouge commander convicted of crimes against humanity, we grieve for those murdered under his direction. Nate Thayer the famed US journalist joined him for the final identification of Duch with many of his This is a very simply and well written book on Nic Dunlop's search to find Duch, the man who ran S21 security prison for the leadership of the Khmer Rouge in Phnom Penh through to Also, can there ever be justice in the true sense, when murderers of your loved ones live This is an excellent book-it is about the author's quest to track down the man responsible for running the S prison from where only 7 people survived out of the 20, that entered.
    [Show full text]
  • Adding Value Report Vol.1
    ADDING VALUE a report by Northern Ireland Screen NORTHERN BOOSTING CELEBRATING ENHANCING CONTENTS THE THE THE IRELAND OUR OUR OUR CHILDREN'S ECONOMIC CULTURAL EDUCATIONAL SCREEN ECONOMY CULTURE EDUCATION VALUE VALUE VALUE 08 Large-scale Production 44 Writers 84 Creative Learning Centres 18 Independent Film 46 Short Film 90 Moving Image Arts (MIA) 22 Animation 48 ILBF / CCG 92 After School FilmClub 26 Factual / Entertainment 56 USBF 30 Television Drama 64 Film Culture 34 Gaming and Mobile 74 Heritage and Archive 38 Skills Development 78 Awards 04 05 INTROduCTION As the government-backed lead Of course certain activity intersects In a similar vein, the work of the agency in Northern Ireland for the film, more than one area and the inter- Education Department, with regard to television and digital content industry, connectivity of the agency’s work will its intervention through FilmClub, has Northern Ireland Screen is committed become apparent. For example, the value in both education and culture; as to maximising the economic, cultural development and production funding for children learn through film in a pure and educational value of the screen indigenous projects made in Northern educational sense as well as gain a wider industries for the benefit of Northern Ireland by Northern Ireland film-makers appreciation of film culture and of the Ireland. This goal is pursued through our and shown at a Northern Ireland festival, culture of Northern Ireland through mission to accelerate the development will have value in all areas. An obvious watching content-relevant films. of a dynamic and sustainable screen case in point is the feature film Good industry and culture in Northern Ireland.
    [Show full text]
  • FILM FESTIVAL 22Nd - 29Th November 2012
    UNDER THE AUSPICES OF THE EMBASSY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SERBIA IN PRETORIA SERBIAN ARTS AND CULTURE SOCIETY AFRICA SERBIAN FILM FESTIVAL 22nd - 29th November 2012 NU METRO, MONTECASINO An author’s perspective of the world Film, as a sublimation of all arts, is a true medium, a universal vehicle with which the broader public is presented with a world view, as seen by the eye of the fi lmmaker. Nowadays, due to the global economic crisis, which is ironically producing technological and all sorts of other develop- ments, an increasing number of people are pushed to the margins of average standards of living, and fi lmmakers are given the chance to bring under their ‘protection’ millions of disillusioned people with their fi lmmaking capabilities. Art, throughout its history, has always praised but has also been heavily critical of its subject. Film is not just that. Film is that and so much more. Film is life itself and beyond life. Film is everything many of us dream about but never dare to say out loud. That is why people love fi lms. That is why it is eternal. It tears down boundaries and brings together cul- tures. It awakens curiosity and builds bridges from one far away coast to another. Film is a ‘great lie’ but an even greater truth. Yugoslavian, and today the Serbian fi lm industry has always been ‘in trend’. It might sound harsh but, unfortunately, this region has always provided ample ‘material’ for fi lms. Under our Balkan clouds there has been an ongoing battle about which people are older, which came and settled fi rst, who started it and who will be fi rst to leave and such battles have been and continue to be an inspiration to fi lm producers.
    [Show full text]
  • The Khmer Rouge Tribunal: an Ambiguous Good News Story
    perspectives The Khmer Rouge Tribunal: An Ambiguous Good News Story Milton Osborne A u g u s t 2 0 0 7 The Lowy Institute for International Policy is an independent international policy think tank based in Sydney, Australia. Its mandate ranges across all the dimensions of international policy debate in Australia – economic, political and strategic – and it is not limited to a particular geographic region. Its two core tasks are to: • produce distinctive research and fresh policy options for Australia’s international policy and to contribute to the wider international debate. • promote discussion of Australia’s role in the world by providing an accessible and high quality forum for discussion of Australian international relations through debates, seminars, lectures, dialogues and conferences. Lowy Institute Perspectives are occasional papers and speeches on international events and policy. The views expressed in this paper are the author’s own and not those of the Lowy Institute for International Policy. The Khmer Rouge Tribunal: an ambiguous good news story Milton Osborne It’s [the Khmer Rouge Tribunal] heavily symbolic and won’t have much to do with justice . It will produce verdicts which delineate the KR leadership as having been a small group and nothing to do with the present regime. Philip Short, author of Pol Pot: anatomy of a nightmare, London, 2004, quoted in Phnom Penh Post, 26 January­8 February 2007. Some ten months after it was finally inaugurated in July 2006, and more than twenty­eight years after the overthrow of the Democratic Kampuchean (DK) regime led by Pol Pot, the Extraordinary Chambers of the Courts of Cambodia (ECCC), more familiarly known as the Khmer Rouge Tribunal, has at last handed down its first indictment.
    [Show full text]
  • Denton Record-Chronicle | News for Denton County, Texas | Entertainment: Movies 04/08/2008 08:51 AM
    New releases mostly on the gloomy side | Denton Record-Chronicle | News for Denton County, Texas | Entertainment: Movies 04/08/2008 08:51 AM New releases mostly on the gloomy side 11:15 AM CDT on Sunday, April 6, 2008 By Boo Allen/Film Critic Prepare this week for some brooding intensity: Rare appearances by two distinct artists mark There Will Be Blood, the fifth movie from writer/director Paul Thomas Anderson, his first since 2002. And, in an Oscar-winning performance, Daniel Day-Lewis returns to the screen for the first time since 2005. Lewis plays Daniel Plainview, a turn-of-the-20th-century oilman, mean, single-focused, and devoid of any limiting attributes such as honor, truth, or kindness. Anderson delivers an authentic portrait of this era, as shown in the DVD supplement The Story of Petroleum. Anderson dips into Upton Sinclair’s obscure novel Oil! for his source, staying with Plainview and the chronicling of his fortunes. This love of money sounds cautionary warnings, as the film’s various characters fall under the spell promised by the riches of an oil strike. Despite the film’s almost epic sweep, Anderson stays close to Daniel Plainview, knowing that the conflict buried in this intense man signals the greatest drama. The singular subplot has Paul Dano playing a smugly religious type involved in a constant, ill-fated feud with Plainview, a battle that further defines Plainview and his quest for supremacy. Oscar-winning cinematographer Robert Elswit works with Anderson to render his customary long takes, but the focus stays mostly on the era’s drabness.
    [Show full text]
  • Some Mother's Son in the Grim Chronology of the British Conflict with the Irish Republican Army (IRA) in Northern Ireland
    Some Mother’s Son In the grim chronology of the British conflict with the Irish Republican Army (IRA) in Northern Ireland, the winter/spring of 1981 stands out as a defining moment, punctuated particularly by the fasting death of IRA activist Bobby Sands on May 5, 1981, in the Maze Prison in Belfast. The events leading up to that hunger strike and its eventual resolution form the political context of a splendid new motion picture, Some Mother’s Son. While this actual context gives definition and weight to Some Mother’s Son, the film is much less about contemporary Northern Ireland politics than it is about the personal life-and-death battle of two women for the very bodies and souls of their politically committed sons. It is wrenching as is all real tragedy, with all its inevitability, its struggle, its ultimate calamity--but also its pity and catharsis. The dramatic core of the film, co-authored by Irishmen Terry George (who also directed) and Jim Sheridan (My Left Foot, The Field), is fictional, presenting two Belfast mothers, teacher and widow Kathleen Quigley (Helen Mirren), and farmer Annie Higgins (Fionnula Flanagan), who, though of differing backgrounds and views, come together to support their IRA-member sons in prison after the young men’s capture. There are class and taste differences between Kathleen and Annie: the former is more educated, high- toned, circumspect, and works in sensible heels, while the latter is earthier, tougher, more opinionated and sports rubber boots for work. Kathleen is prudent but no prude; more or less a pacifist, she doesn’t want any trouble.
    [Show full text]
  • The Genealogy of Dislocated Memory: Yugoslav Cinema After the Break
    University of Massachusetts Amherst ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst Doctoral Dissertations Dissertations and Theses April 2014 The Genealogy of Dislocated Memory: Yugoslav Cinema after the Break Dijana Jelaca University of Massachusetts Amherst Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.umass.edu/dissertations_2 Part of the Communication Commons Recommended Citation Jelaca, Dijana, "The Genealogy of Dislocated Memory: Yugoslav Cinema after the Break" (2014). Doctoral Dissertations. 10. https://doi.org/10.7275/vztj-0y40 https://scholarworks.umass.edu/dissertations_2/10 This Open Access Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Dissertations and Theses at ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst. It has been accepted for inclusion in Doctoral Dissertations by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst. For more information, please contact [email protected]. THE GENEALOGY OF DISLOCATED MEMORY: YUGOSLAV CINEMA AFTER THE BREAK A Dissertation Presented by DIJANA JELACA Submitted to the Graduate School of the University of Massachusetts Amherst in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY February 2014 Department of Communication © Copyright by Dijana Jelaca 2014 All Rights Reserved THE GENEALOGY OF DISLOCATED MEMORY: YUGOSLAV CINEMA AFTER THE BREAK A Dissertation Presented by DIJANA JELACA Approved as to style and content by: _______________________________________ Leda Cooks, Chair _______________________________________ Anne Ciecko, Member _______________________________________ Lisa Henderson, Member _______________________________________ James Hicks, Member ____________________________________ Erica Scharrer, Department Head Department of Communication TO LOST CHILDHOODS, ACROSS BORDERS, AND TO MY FAMILY, ACROSS OCEANS ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This dissertation is about a part of the world that I call “home” even though that place no longer physically exists. I belong to that “lost generation” of youth whose childhoods ended abruptly when Yugoslavia went up in flames.
    [Show full text]