Jessica Evaluation Focused Study Regione Toscana
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
JESSICA JOINT EUROPEAN SUPPORT FOR SUSTAINABLE INVESTMENT IN CITY AREAS JESSICA EVALUATION FOCUSED STUDY REGIONE TOSCANA ENGLISH VERSION This document has been produced with the financial assistance of the European Union. The views expressed herein can in no way be taken to reflect the official opinion of the European Union. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY.................................................................................................... 4 1. TUSCANY –INTEGRATED PLAN FOR SUSTAINABLE URBAN DEVELOPMENT .................. 7 2. THE JESSICA FRAMEWORK ................................................................................. 13 2.1. Funding Agreement - Managing Authority, Holding Fund.................................. 20 2.2. Operational Agreement – Urban Development Fund ........................................ 23 2.3. Investment Agreement and procedures ......................................................... 29 3. JESSICA PILOT PROJECT IN TUSCANY.................................................................. 38 3.1. Piombino – IPSID analysis ........................................................................... 39 3.2. Livorno – Dogana d’Acqua and Scoglio della Regina ........................................ 46 3.3. Firenze – former Sant’Orsola monastery and Villa Mondeggi............................. 51 INDEX OF FIGURES Figure 5 – Technological Centres IPSUD projects scores..............................11 Figure 6 – Tourism and Commerce IPSUD initiatives...................................11 Figure 7 – Urban Infrastructures IPSUD initiatives......................................12 Figure 8 – The JESSICA scheme...............................................................14 Figure 5 – The JESSICA scheme...............................................................15 Figure 6 - The JESSICA process in Europe .................................................17 Figure 7 - Urban Development Funds activated and call for tenders..............18 Figure 11 - JESSICA, Funding Agreement..................................................20 Figure 12 - JESSICA, Operational Agreement.............................................23 Figure 13 - State Aid, spread applicable to the basic interest rate ................28 Figure 14 - JESSICA, Investment Agreement .............................................29 Figure 15 - JESSICA procedure ................................................................31 Figure 16 - UDF selection phase I.............................................................32 Figure 17 - UDF selection phase II ...........................................................32 Figure 18 - UDF selection phase III ..........................................................33 Figure 19 – UDF co investor in project vehicles ..........................................35 Figure 20 – UDF lender to project vehicles ................................................36 Figure 21 – UDF borrower to Public Authority ............................................37 Figure 22 – Urban perimeter of intervention ..............................................39 Figure 23 – Relational scheme .................................................................42 Figure 24 – Expected revenues ................................................................44 Figure 25 –Scoglio della Regina building costs ...........................................48 Figure 26 – Dogana d’acqua ....................................................................49 Figure 27 – Dogana d’Acqua building cost .................................................50 Figure 28 – Sant’Orsola monastery surface ...............................................52 Figure 29 – Villa Mondeggi surface and functions .......................................53 Figure 30 – Building costs .......................................................................55 Figure 31 – Sant’Orsola revenues.............................................................55 Figure 32 – Villa Mondeggi revenues.........................................................56 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY JESSICA (Joint European Support for Sustainable Investment in City Areas) is an initiative created by the European Commission, the European Investment Bank (EIB) in collaboration with the Council of Europe Development Bank (CEB). JESSICA is a financial engineering tool created to improve both the allocation and use of European Regional Development Fund (ERDF) resources for urban development, attracting at the same time other financial sources. JESSICA allows the revolving use of Structural Funds (in particular ERDF) for urban development, going beyond the traditional model. Main features of the JESSICA tool are presented as follows: From traditional grants to revolving financial investments the JESSICA scheme foresees an investor/lender role for the Regional Authority. Efficiency and effectiveness in using EU funds JESSICA is not a new source of a financial resource, but a tool developed for more efficient use of Structural Fund resources for urban development. Attracting other resources of finance (both public and private) JESSICA allows attracting private and public investors into the investment process, encouraging public private partnerships. Immediate availability of resources Structural Funds invested in JESSICA are immediately transferred to the JESSICA scheme, overcoming problems of anticipating the cost of projects. International know-how sharing The JESSICA initiative has a European nature and considerable know-how, concerning both procedures to adopt and type of projects to implement. Progress reporting The transfer of Structural Fund resources to JESSICA structures (Holding Fund or Urban Development Fund) allows the progress reporting of those funds. In order to start up the JESSICA mechanism, some structures are needed, in particular: Holding Fund (HF) – Holding Fund is created to invest JESSICA resources in Urban Development Fund that, in turn, will invest them in projects within Integrated Plan for Sustainable Urban Development. The Holding Fund supports the Managing Authority in the UDF selection, JESSICA resource allocation, UDFs investment strategy and monitoring its activity. The Holding Fund is usually established as separate block of finance within the European Investment Bank that can be directly endorsed by the Managing Authority, avoiding passing through a public call for tenders. Currently 16 Holding Funds are active, of which two are in Italy (Sicily and Campania Region), and they are organized as separate block of finance within the European Investment Bank. Urban Development Fund (UDF) - JESSICA resources are conferred to UDF to be invested (as equity, loans or guarantees) in public-private partnerships or in other projects within Integrated Plan for Sustainable Urban Development. UDF is selected by the Holding Fund by means of a call for tenders. In some cases direct award of JESSICA resources to UDFs is allowed. The UDF can be public, private or mixed capital and it can have several JESSICA evaluation study in the Tuscany Region 4 Testo trasmesso a DG-Regio per approvazione levels of organization, in particular it can be established as separate block of finance within a Financial Institution or as independent legal entity. In Italy there are several legal structures that could be used as UDF, such as: financial company, securities investment trust, assets dedicated to a specific transaction, banking convention, etc. Structures dedicated to the realization of Urban Development Projects –JESSICA resources (from the UDF) are invested in projects and these structures are responsible for the realization of the project. It can be a typical structure of public private partnership initiative (i.e. Special Purpose Vehicle) or other structures (i.e. Local Entities). JESSICA resources must be used only for approved expenditures and they must be spent and accounted until December 2015. JESSICA PROCEDURE Procedures that can be adopted for the building and management of projects, within the JESSICA scheme, can be like the ones used in public private partnership initiatives (i.e. project financing, concession, ...) or like the ones typically used by local authorities for urban projects (i.e. public procurement). On the basis of the defined procedure (PPP, procurement, etc.) the UDF can have several roles, in particular: 1. Equity investor in project vehicles – in this scenario the UDF invests JESSICA resources acquiring equity capital of project companies responsible for the building and management of JESSICA initiatives. The UDF will return invested resources by means of capital gains and dividends of project vehicles. Within this scenario JESSICA resources will have a risk and return scheme comparable to other investors, as defined in the State Aid Regulation. 2. Lender to project vehicles – in this scenario the UDF lends JESSICA resources to project companies responsible for the building and management of JESSICA initiatives. In this scenario JESSICA resources will gain an interest rate comparable to market levels, as required by the State Aid Regulation. 3. Lender to Public Authorities – in this scenario the UDF lends JESSICA resources to the Public Authorities responsible for the building of IPSUD projects. Public Authorities will have to return funds plus previously defined interests to the UDF. In this case the State Aid regulation allows UDF to ask for an interest rate eventually lower than market rates. PILOT PROJECTS The Tuscany administrative Region, on the basis of a general analysis