RINGEYES inaccessiblethe

The Spectacled Petrel or Ringeye breeds only on the cloud-draped tsummit of . In 1999 the population was estimated to be around 4 000 pairs, but with some 700 killed each year by long- line fisheries, there was real con- cern that it might be on the brink of extinction. In 2004 Peter Ryan and Cliff Dorse went to Inaccessible to see

how the Ringeyes were faring. 

text & photographs by peter ryan

62 kalahari raptors spectacled petrel 63 he lure of Inaccessible Island is repeating a count last made in 1984. irresistible. I first visited for three Worryingly, in 20 years the population hours in 1984, barely long enough has fallen from an estimated 150 000 ATLANTIC OCEAN to see the island’s famous flightless , pairs to just over 30 000 pairs, mirroring south t africa but returned for three weeks in 1987 dramatic decreases in other populations Cape Town to study the rail’s physiology. I was so of this species. The reasons for its almost enamoured with the place that I have world-wide collapse are unknown, but Nightingale been back five times, spending almost are thought to be linked to changes in 40°S a year studying the island’s enigmatic their food supply, possibly as a result of Inaccessible Gough bunt­ings. And I couldn’t resist the global climate change. 10°W 10°E chance to go back there in November– From Gough Island we returned to December 2004 to count Ringeyes. Inaccessible, to find the weather greatly The island’s appeal is subtle. Second improved and the wind swinging to the largest in the Tristan archipelago, south, ideal for a landing at Blenden Inaccessible rises sheer out of the rest- Hall. The next morning we went ashore less South Atlantic, with towering cliffs and despite a few rogue waves, every- around most of the coast. Indeed, the thing was landed safely. It took only Opposite Northern Rockhopper Penguins island was named not so much for the 12 days from leaving Cape Town to get on the boulder shore between the Waterfall difficulty of landing there, but because ashore – a personal record. Previously it and Salt Beach on Inaccessible Island’s it’s almost impossible to go anywhere has taken me up to five weeks just to get eastern shore. Landing is often quite easy once you scramble ashore. Only on from Tristan to Inaccessible! along this stretch of coast, which is shelter­ the exposed western side, where the Once ashore, the contrast to a ship- ed from the prevailing westerlies, but the cliffs are highest, at around 500 metres, based existence is striking. Gone are sheer cliffs prevent access to the plateau. is there relatively easy access to the the restless rocking motion, medley of island’s plateau. Landing in a small boat ship smells and continuous assault of Below A Spectacled Petrel sweeps low at Blenden Hall, the bay named after engine noise and vibration. The calm is over the sea behind the fishing vessel. Like the East Indiaman wrecked there in broken only by the surf crashing onto the closely-related White-chinned Petrel, 1823, requires a blend of patience and the boulder beaches, and the querulous Ringeyes follow vessels persistently, but daring. And once ashore, conditions are ‘sweep’ calls of the irrepressibly curi- tend to remain in warmer oceanic waters spartan, as one lives in either a small ous Starchies (Tristan Thrush) which  than their more southerly cousins. wooden hut or a tent, and washes in the decidedly chilly streams. Tristan can only be reached by sea. We sailed from Cape Town on the Edinburgh, one of two fishing vessels that catch rock lobster around the islands, and arrived off Tristan after seven days. With its peak reaching over 2 000 metres, the island is visible from miles away on a clear day, but with a cold front fast approaching we were almost on top of the island before it appeared as a darker grey wall under gloomy grey skies. After a brief visit ashore to meet up with old friends and borrow a small boat for landing at Blenden Hall, we went back aboard the Edinburgh and on to Inaccessible. Any thoughts of getting ashore were soon dashed by gale-force north-westers, and so began the waiting game. For Cliff this brought the added bonus of a trip to Gough Island, 350 kilometres south-south-east, to deliver spares to the other fishing vessel, the Kelso. We took advantage of this opportunity to con- duct a complete census of Rockhopper Penguins Eudyptes chrysocome breeding in colonies around the coast of Gough, october/november 2005 spectacled petrel 65 sweaty afternoon ensued, as we crashed They are larger than most other ’ Opposite, above A newly-fledged around, trying to force our way through burrows, and usually have a characteristic Tristan Thrush, or Starchy, showing the the thicker stands of the inimitable tus- entrance pool or moat. Most are too long richly coloured primary coverts and sock. But by the first evening, we were for a human to reach into the breed- apricot-streaked scapulars typical of ready to start our work on the summit. ing chamber, so it is not easy to know juvenile plumage. From the hut, the West Road appears whether a given nest is occupied or not. to be a daunting climb. The coastal scarp We used playback of taped calls at the Opposite, below Arm-probing is more than 500 metres high, with no entrance to each tunnel, then inserted Spectacled Petrel burrows is a dirty obvious route up the final, near-vertical an arm into the burrow to try and elicit business, especially in the wetter section. When we set off the following a response from the occupants. Our visit areas. After doing it in 1999, I was morning, Cliff was a tad apprehensive, was timed to coincide with the early more than happy to let Cliff do all especially as the summit was wreathed incubation period, when the highest pro- the probing in 2004! in orographic cloud. But an hour or so portion of nests should be occupied, and later we reached the top and stumbled when incubating adults usually respond into the top end of Ringeye Valley, one well to playback. of the main breeding areas for Spectacled We marked out 100 nests for repeated Petrels. Our first goal was to set up a small checks of occupancy, then systematical- study of marked burrows to ascertain the ly counted burrows across the plateau. proportion of occupied burrows. Although the island is only 14 square Spectacled and White-chinned petrels kilometres in extent and only about half are the largest burrow-nesting petrels in of this is occupied by Ringeyes, a com- the world. Like most smaller petrels and plete census is not a trivial exercise. The shearwaters breeding in the sub-Antarctic, plateau is dissected by a series of river they nest underground and visit the valleys and clothed in dense vegeta- islands mainly at night to avoid the tion, dominated by cycad-like bogferns attentions of the predatory Subantarctic Blechnum palmiforme and thickets of Skuas. Fortunately, Ringeye burrows are island trees . With the distinctive and most are easily located. commute from sea level, it means long 

converge from all points to inspect the reaching the waters off southern Africa strange new flotsam stranded on the in small numbers, but the majority Customised spectacles beach. With Tristan Buntings flitting head west to feed off the coast of South he Ringeye’s distinctive spectacles vary considerably in size and past and Inaccessible Island Rails call- America. Tshape, not only among the themselves, but even on either ing from the adjacent tussock grass, it In 1982 the population was crudely side of the head of some individuals. The basic shape is consistent, was hard to get Cliff moving, but all our reckoned to number about 1 000 pairs. with a white ‘U’ framing each eye and meeting on the forehead, but equipment and food had to be hauled During the 1990s, observers on long- the width of the spectacle varies. Most birds have fairly broad, well- over the boulder beach to the hut. line boats fishing off Brazil estimated formed spectacles (right), but in some individuals they are narrow Fortunately he soon saw his first rail, so some 700 Spectacled Petrels were being and incomplete (right, below). The darkest birds have little more than could focus on the task at hand. killed annually, with more dying off a white forehead, usually with a few isolated white around Uruguay and South Africa. Such high the eye. In some birds the spectacle links with the white chin, but in he Spectacled Petrel levels of mortality did not seem sustain- others it is distinct from the chin. conspicillata breeds only on this able by a small population of a that At sea, Spectacled Petrels are sometimes confused with White- island’s plateau. Recently split takes four to five years to reach maturity chinned Petrels (below) that have white patches on their heads. A tfrom the more widespread White- and lays only a single egg. As a result, a small proportion of White-chinned Petrels exhibit partial leucism, chinned Petrel P. aequinoctialis, it is detailed count was made in 1999, cover- with white areas on the belly, head, wings or tail. On the head, apart characterised by having an incomplete ing the entire island summit. This sug- from exaggerated white chins, the most common area for a white white ring around its eyes, giving rise gested the population was larger than patch is on the hind crown or nape, and these birds can be confused to its local Tristan name of Ringeye. initially thought, perhaps some 4 000 with Spectacled Petrels. However, The type specimen was collected off pairs, but still worryingly small given once you know the structure of the Australia, and bones of an extinct the known long-line mortality. Now, characteristic Ringeye spectacle it is Procellaria petrel found on Amsterdam five years later, we were back to see how quite distinctive. From a distance, Island suggest that the species may have the population was faring. it is usually most pronounced as bred at temperate islands in the south Our first of business was to re- the bird flies directly towards you, Indian Ocean before predators such as establish the path up to the island displaying the prominent white pigs were introduced. But as far as we summit. With no one having used it forehead. At close range, the know, Ringeyes currently breed only since we were last there in 1999/2000, darker bill tip of a Spectacled Petrel on Inaccessible Island. From there, they the route through the head-high tus- also is distinctive. barrie rose forage across the South Atlantic Ocean, sock grass was largely overgrown. A

66 spectacled petrel africa – birds & birding october/november 2005 spectacled petrel 67 Given the scale of the count area, only a crude estimate of the total number of burrows is possible. Once the estimate was complete we checked accuracy by carefully exploring small areas to relate our initial estimates to actual burrow numbers. At the same time, we repeat- edly checked our 100 marked nests to estimate the proportion of occupied bur-­ rows. Even before we had finished the count, it seemed that there were, if anything, more birds than in 1999. Their large size confers Ringeyes some immunity from skua attacks, and many come ashore during the afternoon, well before dark. It was not unusual to see several hundred soaring over a small val- ley, and tens sitting outside their burrow entrances. During previous visits I had Above A Spectacled Petrel in the large days spent scrambling over rugged terrain not seen as many birds during the day. moat that is typical of many breeding and through unforgiving vegetation. But After we had spent two weeks traipsing burrows. the rewards are manifold. Over much of all over the island, our counts confirmed the plateau, counting is only feasible on an increase in the Ringeye population. By November, most Yellow-nosed Albatrosses are reaching the end of incubation, but some Below Most Spectacled Petrels breed in clear days, and the scenery then is com- Almost 9 000 burrows were counted, non-breeders still hang around, courting and establishing pair-bonds by allopreening. Tourism at Tristan discrete colonies, which are characterised pelling. Each valley is different, and the up 50 per cent from 1999, with an by mats of bright green Scirpus sedges twin constants of Tristan and Nightingale occupancy rate in marked burrows of at ourists are allowed to make day-trips among the duller brown bogferns. These are visible in the distance. And the count least 70 per cent. One-off playback trials lthough Inaccessible Island is close to the biological maximum for a Tto Inaccessible and Nightingale islands, Ringeye bogs provide sheltered breeding is enlivened by repeated interactions with at other sites confirmed a high level of currently free of any introduced petrel, given their conservative life his- under the supervision of Tristan guides, sites for other species, including Atlantic Yellow-nosed Albatrosses, Subantarctic occupancy throughout the island. How mam­mals, it has suffered from tory characteristics, but is not unprec- who ensure that visitors don’t introduce Yellow-nosed Albatrosses (chick on left). Skuas, Starchies, Tristan Buntings and can we reconcile this increase with the ahuman impacts in the past. At various edented. Northern Fulmars increased at any alien plants or to the hislands,ph photog raphy Inaccessible Rails. large numbers killed on long-lines? stages goats, sheep, cows, pigs and even around seven per cent annually in the and don’t cause undue disturbance to the a couple of dogs have been left to run north-east Atlantic during much of the wildlife. Landings at Inaccessible Island wild on the island. Of these, pigs had 20th century, and Buller’s Shearwaters are restricted to the sheltered eastern probably the greatest impact on breed- recovered from near-extinction to more beaches at the Waterfall and Salt Beach, ing . Wild pigs are formidable than 200 000 pairs in less than 50 where visitors are confined to a narrow predators and have been responsible years following the removal of feral pigs coastal strip, but this is sufficient to see for wiping out burrow-nesting seabirds from Aorangi Island off New Zealand the Inaccessible Island Rail. Access is on several other islands. Fortunately, (although in the latter case, growth was easier at Nightingale, with a gentle path at Inaccessible the feral population assisted by immigration from adjacent up to the Ponds, where large numbers of appears to have died out early in the Tawhiti Rahi Island). Atlantic Yellow-nosed Albatrosses breed, 20th century, but by this stage they Does this mean we no longer need and the scarce Wilkins’ Bunting is fairly had reduced Ringeyes to a perilously worry about Spectacled Petrels? While easily located in the groves of island trees small population. The Tristan islanders the situation is certainly less dire than it Phylica arborea. only recorded the birds breeding on appeared before the 2004 survey, there The main problem is getting to Tristan in the island in the 1920s, and when the is still cause for concern because demo- the first place. Several cruise ships visit the Norwegian Scientific Expedition visited graphic models suggest that the popu- island annually, usually during reposition- the island in 1937, Yngvar Hagen esti- lation is susceptible to small increases ing voyages of vessels operating in the mated that the population stood at less in long-line mortality. We may have Arctic and Antarctic. However, landing at than 50 pairs. been lucky that it has done so well all the islands is weather dependent, and Once the pigs disappeared, the popu- to date. However, if we can reduce it’s not unusual for a vessel to spend four lation recovered rapidly: there were a long-line mortality, numbers should days waiting at the islands and not get few hundred pairs in the early 1950s, rapidly recover to the original popula- ashore even at Tristan. Small numbers of at least 1 000 pairs in 1982, 4 000 tion size, which probably will mean independent tourists may also visit Tristan pairs in 1999 and 7 000 pairs in 2004. many more Spectacled Petrels reaching for longer periods, if they apply to the Ad- Allowing for differences in count accu- African waters. Inaccessible Island was ministrator for permission, but berths on racy, this suggests that Ringeye numbers declared a nature reserve in 1997 and, vessels to the island are limited. Once on have been growing at around seven per more recently, a World Heritage Site in Tristan, visitors can usually arrange to join cent per year from a very small initial recognition of its spectacular scenery a small boat travelling to the other islands. population in the early 1900s. This is and unique wildlife. 

68 spectacled petrel africa – birds & birding october/november 2005 spectacled petrel 69