Come Clean About Beauty 2
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
COME CLEAN ABOUT BEAUTY 2 Executive Summary Greenwashing is rife in the health and beauty industry, despite previous Soil Association campaigns which have raised awareness of this problem amongst brands and consumers. Our new investigation has produced a league table of uncertified products which are us- ing the term organic on the labels, and consumer research which provides clear evidence that people feel misled by this. We’re calling on brands to Come Clean About Beauty labelling and use the terms organic and natural responsibly or not at all. We found a range of uncertified health and beauty products with potentially misleading labels which use the terms organic or natural. We showed some of these labels to an independent panel of 1,000 consumers and the majority (76%) said they felt misled when they found out the product was not certified and would not meet organic standards. When they discovered this, most people (72%) also said they would lose trust in the brand. Scope We have not been able to do a comprehensive survey of all beauty products, but our limited research found 13 products from eight different brands that have labels which could suggest to consumers that they are wholly or mainly organic, yet are not independently certified. Several of these products are from brands with one or more ranges which are all labelled in a way that consumers said they found misleading. This means there are hundreds or even thousands of products for sale on UK high streets which make organic claims but contain ingredients which would not be permitted in a certified organic product. We are clear that risking misleading consumers in such a sensitive area as beauty products, even in one case, is completely unacceptable. The confusing terms on the labels we encountered suggest that it is often very difficult for consumers to know they are making the right choice when doing their shopping. The halo effect Our research findings show a direct link between what is on the pack and what people say they think about a product. It is clear from the results of this survey that the use of the word organic on the label has a positive effect on what people think about the whole of the product – with most consumers saying they would assume an organic product was sus- tainably made and that they were doing the right thing for the environment by choosing it. Some of the labels state that one or more ingredients are organic in a way which suggests positive attributes for the rest of the product. While it is obviously a good thing for a manufacturer to be using any organic ingredients, we do not think it is right for companies to highlight that particular organic ingredient on the front of the packaging when only a very small amount is actually present in the product. The majority of people (77%) said they would feel reassured if the product was certified organic and carried a verified symbol. We think that brands know this, because a number of them use a logo of some form or another on their labels, to describe the presence of organic ingredients. Consumers also told us they would think more positively about the brand if the product was genuinely certified organic. Brands and retailers should take note Consumers clearly told us that the misuse of the term organic damages their faith in brands and the retailers that sell them. Most people (72%) said they would lose trust in the brand if they found out that a product which said organic on the label was not certified and could not meet organic standards. 64% of people said they would lose trust in the retailer. The majority of people (69%) also felt strongly that this sort of misleading labelling should be against the law. However the product labels and the ingredients they contain are all legal. While the term organic is regulated in relation to food and drink on sale in the UK and the EU, there is no legislation in place for the use of the terms organic and natural in relation to health and beauty products. We want to change this, so we are asking people to sign our petition which calls on the brands in our league table to truly Come Clean About Beauty and use the terms organic or natural responsibly or not at all. 4 Price is not an issue We found that certified organic products often cost less per 100ml than the uncertified products which are making organic and natural claims. For nine out of the 13 products included here we found a certified organic alternative which costs less per 100ml. Even for the four products where the organic alternative costs more, the difference in price is £1.50 per 100ml or less. By contrast, one of the uncertified products which claims to be organic costs £7.22 more per 100ml than a certified organic alternative. In the Product Profiles section of this report, we suggest a certified organic alternative for each of the products featured. The basis of these suggestions is that the products are widely available in the UK at a competitive price and independently certified to a recognised standard. We are not saying these products contain similar ingredients or function in exactly the same way; they are simply suggestions of certified organic alternatives that consumers might like to consider. Ingredients which would not be permitted in a certified organic product This report contains a snapshot of the products we found which contain ingredients that would not be permitted by an independent international organic and natural health and beauty standard such as COSMOS. When we had identified these ingredients, they were assessed by an independent expert toxicologist who advised us of their potential impacts in wider use on human health and the environment. Together we came up with the Terrible Ten – a list of ten ingredients which consumers should look out for – and which would never be permitted in a certified organic product. There are European standards which require all ingredients used in cosmetic products to be safe, and limits for the amounts of some ingredients which can be used are set to ensure this. So we are not suggesting that the inclusion of any of these ingredients in the products listed means that those products are unsafe. We are talking about the impacts that some of these ingredients have been found to have in wider use – that is when used in higher doses and other product types or applications. Organic standards aim to encourage the use of ingredients which are organic, sustainable and biodegradable, and most consumers said they felt misled when they found out that products which claim to be organic contained ingredients which would not be permitted in a certified product. This shows that the brands which are doing this are in danger of exploiting the reassurance that consumers seek when they choose an organic product. The majority of people (74%) told us they would feel like they were choosing a product which was free from nasties if it said organic on the label. Consumers who want to protect themselves from greenwashing claims such as these should look for a genuine logo which proves the product has been independently certified. For example, the COSMOS or the Soil Association, Natrue and NSF-ANSI all have strict standards for beauty products, and would not allow a chemical on the Terrible Ten list to be used in a certified product. The Terrible Ten Our research found the following Terrible Ten ingredients in health and beauty products which mention organic on the label, but are not certified organic: 1. Ethyl hexylsalicylate 2. Homosalate 3. Imidazolidinyl urea 4. Octinoxate 5. Octocrylene 6. PEGs: PEG-7; PEG-12; PEG-40; PEG-200 7. Polyquaternium 7 8. Polysorbate 20 9. Red 17 artificial colour 26100 10. Retinyl palmitate The ingredients are listed in alphabetical order. Further information on the possible effects of each of the ingredients, and the products in which we found them, is included in Section 4 of this report. Research methodology We worked with an independent researcher to find health and beauty products which claim to be organic, but are not independently certified. We reviewed the ingredients panel for each product and identified whether there were any ingredients which would not be permitted in a certified organic product, using the international COSMOS standard as a benchmark. We then worked with a leading independent toxicologist, Emeritus Professor Vyvyan Howard, to identify the Terrible Ten ingredients found in these, and other non-organic products, which are chemicals that in general use are potentially most harmful to human health and the environment. Following this we undertook some independent consumer research. The researchers spoke to 1000 women across the UK between the ages of 18-65, and a nationally representative sample of socio-demographic grades, employment status and regional representation. All participants were regular buyers and users of a wide range of everyday health and beauty products from body or face washes to after sun creams or sprays. The research was conducted online by market research and brand building company, The Crow Flies Ltd., between 31st March and 4th April 2017. 6 Contents 1. Come Clean About Beauty League Table: This shows the 13 uncertified health and beauty products we found which are labelled in ways that could mislead consumers, and contain undesirable ingredients, including those from the Terrible Ten. 2. Product profiles: Details of the products we found which we think are labelled in ways that could mislead consumers because they mention organic ingredients or use organic on their main labels, yet contain ingredients which would not be permitted in independently certified organic products.