A Dual-Level Approach to Instanton Theory Arxiv:2009.04309V1
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
A Dual-Level Approach to Instanton Theory Jan Meisner and Johannes K¨astner∗ Institute for Theoretical Chemistry, University of Stuttgart, Pfaffenwaldring 55, 70569 Stuttgart,Germany E-mail: [email protected] Abstract rate constants. An efficient yet accurate com- putational method to incorporate atom tunnel- Instanton theory is an established method ing is semiclassical instanton theory.1{5 Instan- to calculate rate constants of chemical reac- ton theory can be understood as a quantum tions including atom tunneling. Technical and mechanical analog to transition state theory methodological improvements increased its ap- (TST), thus, referred to as harmonic quantum plicability. Still, a large number of energy and transition state theory.6,7 The idea of instanton gradient calculations is necessary to optimize theory is to include nuclear quantum effects by the instanton tunneling path and 2nd deriva- statistical Feynman path integrals. Partition tives of the potential energy along the tunneling functions are approximated by the steepest de- path have to be evaluated, restricting the range scent approach, i.e. optimizing the most likely of suitable electronic structure methods. To en- tunneling path, the so-called instanton, which hance the applicability of instanton theory, we is a 1st order saddle-point of the Euclidean ac- present a dual-level approach in which instan- tion SE, and taking fluctuations into account ton optimizations and Hessian calculations are within the harmonic approximation.8{14 It is performed using an efficient but approximate a successful compromise between accuracy and electronic structure method and the potential computational efficiency as it does not require energy along the tunneling path is recalculated a global potential energy surface, but can be using a more accurate method. This proce- used in combination with on-the-fly electronic dure extends the applicability of instanton the- structure calculations.15,16 ory to high-level electronic structure methods The applicability of instanton theory to the for which analytic gradients may not be avail- quantification of atom tunneling in molecular able, like local linear-scaling approaches. We systems has been frequently demonstrated in demonstrate for the analytical Eckart barrier the past decade.16{31 While traditionally in- and three molecular systems how the dual-level stanton paths were often guessed or approxi- instanton approach corrects for the largest part mated using further assumptions,32{35 a mod- arXiv:2009.04309v1 [physics.chem-ph] 9 Sep 2020 of the error caused by the inaccuracy of the effi- ified Newton{Raphson (NR) instanton opti- cient electronic structure method. This reduces mizer9 allows efficient instanton search for the error of the calculated rate constants signif- molecular systems with many degrees of free- icantly. dom.9,22{31,36 In practical applications, the instanton path Introduction yinst is discretized into P replicas or images. From these, the Euclidean action SE = S0=2 + The accurate description of atom tunneling is crucial for the calculation of precise reaction 1 Spot can be calculated with The zero-eigenvalues are left out of the prod- uct, thus the prime in the product sign in equa- P P X 2 tion (4). Together with the instanton optimiza- S0 = (yk − yk−1) ; (1) β~ tion, the calculation of the Hessians is the most k=1 time-consuming step in computational applica- and tions of instanton theory. In one example de- P β X scribed below, a sixteen-atomic molecular sys- S = ~ V (y ): (2) pot P k tem (i.e. N = 48), the instanton is discretized k=1 into P = 100 images. This leads to a 2400- Here, yk are the N mass-weighted coordinates dimensional optimization problem (because the of the kth image, ~ is the reduced Planck's con- instanton, a closed Feynman path, covers the −1 stant, β = (kBT ) , T is the temperature, and same line in configuration space twice, forward kB is Boltzmann's constant. The reduced ac- and backward). Even though the instanton op- 9 tion S0 is a measure of the path length and the timization often requires just a few iterations, distribution of the images along the path, while for every iteration P=2 = 50 energy and gradi- Spot basically averages the potential along the ent evaluations are required. For the rate con- instanton path. The potential V (yk) at each stant calculation, 50 Hessian calculations have image k is obtained from electronic structure to be carried out. These computations provide calculations. the rate constant for one value of the temper- Instanton theory is, in its standard form, ap- ature. It is obvious that instanton calculations plicable only below a system-specific crossover involve a significant computational effort. temperature In this paper, a dual-level approach to in- ~!b stanton theory is presented where for the time- Tc = (3) 2πkB consuming calculations a fast approximative which depends on the absolute value of the method is applied to calculate V (y). Subse- imaginary frequency of the transition state !b. quent energy calculations with a more accurate Methods to extend it to above Tc are avail- electronic structure method improve the quality able,12{14,37 but will not be used here. of the calculated rate constant significantly. The instanton rate constant is obtained by Three different molecular systems were used to illustrate the performance of the dual-level s s QNP RS instanton approach: the isomerization of HNC S0P l=1 λl kinst = 0 × to HCN, an intramolecular [1,5] hydride shift, 2πβ~2 Q NP jλinstj l=1 l and the bimolecular hydrogen atom transfer re- SE(inst) − SE(RS) exp − : (4) action of NH2 + H2 ! NH3 + H. For each sys- ~ tem, reaction rate constants were calculated us- ing the dual-level approach and are compared Here, S (inst) refers to the Euclidean action E to the results of the conventional instanton the- of the instanton path, while S (RS) is the Eu- E ory at both the basic and accurate electronic clidean action of the reactant state. In the potential. latter, the optimal Feynman path is collapsed to the minimum on the potential energy sur- face, i.e. S0(RS) = 0 and SE(RS) = β~V (yRS). Background and Computa- The eigenvalues λRS and λinst refer to the sec- l l tional Details ond derivatives of SE with respect to all co- ordinates of all images. To evaluate the lat- In computational chemistry, the evaluation of ter, Hessians of V (y ) have to be calculated k the electronic potential energy is often the most for all images along the instanton path. One time-consuming step. One possible compromise eigenvalue λinst is negative, seven are zero (six l to obtain reliable results within a reasonable for linear molecules), all others are positive.15 time is a dual-level approach. An approximate, 2 but less demanding computational method is Hitherto, different studies combined approx- used for geometry optimizations and Hessian imate instanton methods with dual-level ap- calculations in what will be referred to as the proaches33,34,42 or used basic-potential instan- basic potential in the following. Subsequently, tons as initial guess for the optimization of the potential energy is calculated using a more high-potential ones to obtain tunneling split- accurate, but more time consuming electronic tings.43,44 Only an instanton path fully opti- structure method, which provides the refined mized on the same potential energy surface as potential. The fundamental assumption is that the one used for the Hessian calculations en- inst the basic potential is still able to reproduce the sures the proper eigenvalue structure of λl . molecular geometries of the stationary points Thus, in this work, instantons are optimized in sufficiently accurate. Thermochemical results all dimensions using the basic potential, i.e., obtained in this way generally agree very well they are true 1st-order saddle points of the Eu- with results obtained with the refined potential. clidean action SE. The refined potential is then Also some calculations of rate constants us- used to correct Spot. ing different tunneling corrections such as SCT For dual-level approaches in quantum chem- and µOMT utilized a dual-level approach suc- istry, the nomenclature cessfully.38{40 Dual-level or even multi-level ap- Method /basis set // Method /basis set proaches have been used for the calculation of A A B B potential energy surfaces necessary for the com- is used. Here, A labels the level of theory and putation of vibrational spectroscopy.41 basis set of the refined potential and B refers Here, we show that the dual-level instanton to the basic potential. For simplicity, the ba- approach leads to excellent results in terms of sis set declaration is omitted in the shorthand accuracy and computational effort. First the notation discretized instanton is optimized on the basic potential. Hessians of the potential energy are MethodA // MethodB also calculated using the basic potential, pro- when possible. RS inst viding λl and λl . Subsequently the energies In this work all geometry optimizations, in- at all images, V (yk), as well as V (yRS) are cal- cluding intrinsic reaction coordinates (IRCs) culated on the refined potential. Note, that no and instantons, as well as rate calculations were geometry optimizations at the refined potential performed using the DL-FIND optimization li- are necessary, just energy calculations. From brary45 interfaced to Chemshell.46,47 IRCs were these, Spot is obtained using the refined poten- optimized using a Hessian-predictor-corrector tial. This is assumed to correct the error caused algorithm.48 Instantons were optimized un- by the inaccuracy of the basic potential. The til the maximum component of the gradi- working hypothesis is that the basic potential ent is smaller than 1 · 10−8 atomic units is able to reproduce the shape and image distri- (scaled relative to the electron's mass) using bution of the instantons qualitatively well.