Itinerant Minorities in England and Wales in the Nineteenth
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
t ITINERANT MINORITIES IN ENGLAND AND WALES IN THE NINETEENTH AND EARLY TWENTIETH CENTURIES: A STUDY OF GYPSIES, TINKERS, HAWKERS AND OTHER TRAVELLERS by DAVID MAYALL Vol_ 1" Thesis presented to the Department of Economic and Social History, University of Sheffield, for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy, October, 1981 I Acknowledgements= _ This thesis, like any piece of historical research, relied greatly on the varied assistance of a large number of people. Advice, alterna- tive perspectives and criticism were provided by the familiar faces of my-supervisor, Colin Holmes, and-of fellow researchers and friends, However, there were also many unseen faces; an assortment of. contacts reached only through letters and the numerous workers in libraries and record offices, some of whom assisted in the discovery of. and-access to much interesting and useful material while others laboured at my request in vain. A grateful-thank-you is extended to them-all,. and. also to those who offered additional assistance but which time constraints prevented me from exploiting. Appreciation must also. be expressed to-the staff and students at the Department of Economic and Social History, University of Sheffield; the History Department, Sheffield City Polytechnic; and at Northern College, Barnsley, for allowing me the opportunity to present papers on my research, at its various. stages, and for providing encouragement, ideas and, criticisms. Special. mention-should be given to the following who, in their different ways, gave considerable help and assistance, and for whom no ordering would be fair other than alphabetical. Sincere thanks, then,: to Tony. Delves, John Field, -Elaine Fishwick, Jo Hignett, Anne Jennerf Kath Langstaff, Hughie Mackay, Tony Mason and, lastly, Hosein Piranfar, I: Abstract of; 'Itinerant Mt.nori; tieg to E,n9land and Wales in the Nineteenth, and Early Twentieth Centuries; A Study of Gypsies, Tinkers, Hawkers and Other TravellerO. The term 'Romany' immediately conjures up notions of race and ethnicity, accompanied by images of a separate and distinct culture. Many writers, past and present, have contributed to this essentially mythical, racial construct. Although nineteenth-century travellers were varied in terms of their habits, aspirations, wealth, type of dwelling and the like, the attempt to draw between the travellers cultural lines of divide based on racial determinants contains serious flaws in assumptions, methodology and evidence. f, I- I Moreover, although varied, the travellers were bound together by certain common features, notably by their position as a minority group in relation to settled society. Resultant upon their travelling way of life was a conflict with the 'centre', or with the institutions and structures of a sedentary-based society, in this instance organised around a capitalist political economy. The nature of this relationship with the dominant economic, social and political structures can be explained summarily by reference to the attempts to settle christianise, educate,, and sanitise the travellers, and which were carried with various degrees of coercion and compulsion. 'out Formal and informal upholders and agents of the 'new morality' worked together to bring about these desired ends. position The of travellers was also necessarily affected by general trends'taking place within the economy and society as a whole. Changed perceptions about them, responses to them, and the conditions under which they lived, were a reflection of more general develop- ments.., economic trends'affected their employments, and where they were carried out, which. inturn altered their relations with the sedentary community they served. Similarly, racial theories concerning the 'Romany' assumed a position of pre-eminent status only with the related growth of, and deference to, scientific knowledge from the mid-century onwards. A study of this marginal social group thus touches on many themes that assumed. special significance from around the 1880s, when, in its'main essentials, society took on a shape recognisable to us today, in which the existence of anachronistic social groupings had to be controlled and circumscribed, David Mayall ziz Contents Page No, Acknowledgementsx.. - I Abstract II List of Diagrams V List of Tables VI List of Appendices VII Notes on Footnotes VIII Introduction Travellers in a`sedentary-based society; notions of racial separateness; Gypsy Lore Society; present situation;, major themes; historio- graphical notes., Chapter 1: Itinerancy as a way of life: the 15 nature of travelling and the geo- graphical` distribution of ý travellers .' Travellers and itinerancy; nature and extent of nomadism;: types of sites; pressures; numbers; geographical distribution; locations of camps; London' gypsies. Chapter 2: Itinerant employments: from 114 fortune-telling to scissor- grinding. Economic relationship between travelling and settled societies; sale of goods and services; traditional crafts; seasonal employments; pressures. 4 Chapter 3; '.: Definitions,, impressions and stereo- 164 types of gypsies : Romany or traveller? Romantics and the Romany; gypsy lorists; a 'separate' race; racial stereotypes; gypsy = traveller; nomadic stereotypes; summary of definitions. Iv Page No, Chapter 4: Responses (1): Evangelism and 259 the reforming' mission. Beginnings of concern; sporadic attempts at reform; missionary endeavours, from Crabb to West; London missions; New Forest missions; Stanley Alder; missions to hop-pickers; success or failure? Chapter 5: Responses (2): George Smith of 335 Coalville and the legislative attack. Assimilationist/anti-assimilationist; George Smith: biography, call for reform; Moveable Dwellings Bill; opposition: Liberty and Property Defence League, United Kingdom Showmen and Van-Dwellers' Protection Associa- tion; passage of Bill; failure. Chapter 6: Responses (3): The gypsy versus the 381 magistrates, police and local authorities. 1. Magistrates; police and policing; lords of manors; local authorities; demand for legis- lation; practical responses; evictions: Epping Forest to Llanelly. Conclusion 447 Gipsies = travellers; characteristics and way of life; general changes affecting travellers; pro, gypsy responses; conflict; notion of hierarchy; Victorians and race; mixed stereotypes; forms of responses. Appendices 464 Bibliography 514 Bibliographical guides; archive sources; Govern- ment publications; newspapers; author index; articles. V List of Diagrams Page No. Diagram 1: Number of persons found dwelling 42 in barns and sheds, and in tents, caravans and the open air (England and Wales), 1851-1901. Diagram 2: Total number of persons found 43 dwelling in barns, sheds, tents, caravans and the open air (England and Wales), 1841-1911. Diagram 3: Regional and county populations of 49 dwellers in tents, caravans and the open air (England and Wales), 1891. Diagram 4: Regional and county populations of 50 dwellers in tents, caravans and the open air (England and Wales), 1901. VI List of Tables Page No. Table 1: Persons found dwelling in barns, sheds, 41 tents, caravans and the open'air (England and Wales), 1841-1911. 154 Table 2: Number of 'foreign' and gypsy hop- pickers in the seven main hopping regions, 1906. Table 3: Marriages of the Heron Family with non- 178 gypsies and those of mixed stock. 403 Table 4: Number of dwellers in barns, sheds, tents, caravans and the open air in Surrey, 1891-1911. Table 5: Density of travellers in counties with 427 a nomadic population greater than 750, 1911. VII List of Appendices Page No. Appendix 1: List of gypsy lodgers (winter) in 464 Westminster, Borough, &c. Appendix 2(a): Regional and county populations of 465 dwellers. in barns and sheds, and in tents, caravans and the open air (England and Wales), 1891-1901. Appendix 2(b): Regional and county populations of 469 dwellers in barns, sheds, tents, caravans and the open air (England and Wales), 1891-1911. Appendix 3: List of tent-dwellers in the New 473 Forest, and their trades and handi- crafts, 1911. Appendix 4: Replies of William Bos to a series 475 of questions put to him by Mr. Goddard Johnson of East Dereham, Norfolk, 3 July 1822. Appendix 5: Table of gypsy crimes, 1907-11.477 Appendix 6: List of major legislation relating 480 to gypsies (England and Wales), 1530-1914. Appendix 7: "A gypsy diary of five weeks and a 484 day", 1911. Appendix 8: Statements of Surrey residents as to 492 the nuisance caused by gypsies, 1898. Appendix 9: Illustrations. 495 VIII Notes on Footnotes i. All books were published in London unless otherwise stated. ii.. Where two dates of publication are given, the first is the date of the original publication, the second is the date of the volume consulted. If the place of publication on either occasion is other than London this is also noted. iii. Full location references to Parliamentary Papers -"-appear in the Bibliography but not in the text. .. #. ý_ .- ý. `a. -. ý-.. a .ý-. 1 INTRODUCTION The travelling population of the nineteenth century has been featured only sparingly in historical texts. Some considerable and substantial work has been done on that section of itinerants most closely linked to sedentary society by occupational and cultural ties, the tramping artisan, and the issue of the vagrant and tramp has also merited occasional comment. Yet these are only the beginnings and in any event touch only the fringes of the travelling community. Gypsies, tinkers, hawkers and the like have been heretofore denied academic attention of any serious kind. Yet a study