Agenda items for the Thirteenth Goa SEAC meeting held on 7 th March 2013
1. ew project proposals seeking prior EC as mandated under the EIA otification, 2006
A. PROPOSED EXPANSION OF RESIDENTIAL COMPL IN CHALTA NO. 13 & 15 ANDP.T. SH NO. 299 OF NAVELIM IN MARGAO CITY BY M/S SRE ESTATES DEVELOPERS, MARGAO
Sr. Project Proponent Proposed Site specific Project details / specification / salient features Comments of the Goa SEAC members and o. (PP) / Applicant Activity location details its compliance by PP Current Status
1 M/s SRE Estates Proposed expansion Chalta no. 13 & 15 of Total plot area – 8,566 sq. mt. 1. It is understood that the existing structure is proposed Developers, Supreme, of residential complex Petitate Sheet No. 299 Approved Built-up area – 6,958.15 sq.mts. to be demolished and proposed development is an Behind New Telephone (G + 8 floors) of Margao city in Proposed built-up area – 22,386.21 sq.mts. expansion. Total built up area of these existing Exchange, “Supreme Colmorod Salcete taluka of Gross built-up area – 29,344.36 sq.mts. structures is 407.26 sq.mts . Opposite Bombi House, Central” that includes South Goa district. Permissible F.A.R. – 16,932 sq.mts. Comba, Margao – 403 – (i.e. Navelim) FAR consumed – 16,904 sq.mts. 2. The proposed development falls under Margao 601 Open space required – 1,284.90 sq.mts. Municipal Council (MMC). Since the area falls (Post Box. No. 778) 01 –Studios (i.e. Margao Open space provided – 1,580 sq.mts. under C1 (commercial) zone, the maximum height 06 – 1 BHK Municipal Limits) permissible is 24 mts. as per TCP laws. Ph. 0832-2736418 / 19 124 – 2 BHK Expected total occupancy – 702 persons Fax. 0832-2735976 25 – 3 BHK Ph. 0832-2714448 3. South Goa Planning and Development Authority e-mail – (total 156 flats ) Parking proposed – 185 ECS (SGPDA) has issued development permission in [email protected] February 2012. Category 8 (a) – B Geo-technical soil investigation (through three bore-holes drilled Mr. Yogesh Naik – Construction projects upto 10mts.) has been prepared and submitted with the proposal 4. During construction phase, water requirement will be Partner, (conducted by M/s Surbhi Enterprises – a Geotek Consortium, met through proposed open well. As such, may like to Ph. 0832-2736418 Received on 23 rd Mahim, Mumbai .). Accordingly, Groundwater table is encountered specify site-specific details superimposed on a Fax. 0832-2735976 January 2013 at a depth ranging from 1.7 mts. to 2 mts. As such, Raft foundation contour map. It is recommended that water 2 e-mail – has been proposed with allowable bearing pressure of 15 t/m that requirement during construction phase should not be yogeshnaik@sregroupgoa. may result with maximum settlement less than 65 mm. sourced from open well. PP need to make alternate in arrangement for the same. However, on M - 9822100532 Water requirement – operationalization, the PP should mandatorily adapt a. During Construction phase – 20CMD ( 2CMD for domestic rainwater harvesting (RWH) for effective recharging Environmental consultant use and 18CMD for construction purpose ) to be sourced of open well. – PP has communicated that – from private tankers and proposed open well. proposed construction of underground tanks of M/s Aditya 200 cu.m. capacity and septic tanks will be Environmental b. During operational phase – 139CMD (i.e. 63CMD from Consultancy, Mumbai PWD and 76CMD from STP-recycled) designed by a RCC consultant by providing proper upward thrust considering occurrence of Ms. Poonam Moye Wastewater generated – 81CMD of wastewater to be treated in groundwater at relatively shallow depth . Sewage Treatment Plant of 85CMD capacity having Moving Bed Bio-Reactor (MBBR) technology which will generate 76CMD of 5. PP may like to clarify w.r.t. digging of any bore- treated water. Out of this, 32CMD for flushing, 08CMD for well(s) and accordingly, may specify modus operandi gardening, 05CMD for car washings. 31 CMD of the balanced for its effective recharge either through roof-top or STP treated water is proposed to be provided to existing watershed approach as RWH initiatives. – Complied. bungalows / buildings for the purpose of gardening . The PP has proposed dual plumbing system. 6. Total capital cost of EMP is Rs. 75 lakhs and expected operation and maintenance cost is Rs. 9 10kgs. of sludge per day will be generated which is proposed be lakhs. It is proposed to – dewatered, dried and mixed with compost for gardening. a. Capital cost for environmental infrastructure Solid waste generated - to be borne by Developer 1. During construction phase about 1-2 MT /day of debris is estimated to be generated. b. Infrastructure to be operated and maintained by Developer till formation of Society and 2. During operational phase, about 298 kgs./day is estimated to Conveyance. be generated which will be segregated at source into wet and dry garbage. Biodegradable waste ( 50% of the total waste ) is c. Corpus fund to be created for maintenance of proposed to be treated on Organic Waste Convertor (OWC). Environmental Infrastructure @ Rs. 50,000/ Space of 200 sq.mts. has been proposed as per the plan for per flat. segregation of the non biodegradable waste and segregated waste is proposed to be disposed off through scrap dealer for recycling.
Power requirement. – a. Construction phase – 2.5 HP
Operation phase – 2,124 KVA to be sourced from Goa State Electricity Board. In addition, back-up power through 01 DG sets of 625 KVA capacity.
2. As per the “Goa Mineral Concession (Amendment) Rules, 2012” notified by the Directorate of Mines and Geology (DMG) and published in Official Gazette Series 1 No. 24 dated 17 th September 2012, following proposals seeking prior EC for New / Renewal of Quarrying Lease has been received for suitable appraisal / consideration.
Sr. Project Proponent (PP) / Proposed Activity Site specific Project details / Comments of the Goa SEAC members / Current o. Applicant location details specification / salient Status Environmental features Consultant 1. Are these two leases contagious with a common 1 M/s. Joao Lourenco Basalt stone quarry - Survey No. 52/0 of Total plot area (02 leases) – boundary or independent of each other? Baptista Basalt Boulders / (a) No.1/Basalt/04 Ugeum village in (a) 7.150 sq.mts. + (b) 5,080 Stone Quarry (b) No. 4/Basalt/04 Sanguem taluka of sq.mts. = 12,230 sq.mts. 2. Both the leases have Consent to Operate issued by South Goa district the Board and valid upto 31 st December 2014. 3 Mr. J. L. Baptista, (RE EWAL ) Proposed capacity 50 m per H. No. 105/D-3, Behind How many Basalt month 3. Ambient Air Quality Monitoring (AAQM) Reports old RTO office, Arlem, Lease nos. – stone quarries in conducted by MoEF recognized laboratory during 3 Raia, Salcete, Goa – 403 (a) Quarry 56/1495/97- this survey no.? Water requirement – 100 M last year (three times a year), at the nearest 720 Mines/3483 per day residential, area may be submitted. (b) Quarry 34/430/07- What is the Ph.: 0832 – 2741951 Mines/3485 outcome of ‘Order” The site has average 4. PP may like to submit measures proposed to be Mobile - 9764503900 (Validity upto ovember issued in the matter overburden of 2-3 mts. It is adapted for dust suppression / noise pollution. 2012) of PIL Writ proposed to undertake Environmental Appraisal Petition o. vertical excavation at 1:10 th 5. Environmental Appraisal Report (EAR) indicates Report (EAR) prepared by Category 1(a) – B 10/2012 on 14 ratio (6 mts. drop at an angle the usage of explosives during blasting / 0 - June 2012 of 60 ) with bench of 3 mts. excavation. As such, PP may submit the NOC from M/s Sadekar Enviro What about – Proposed to make 7 – 8 such the Authority concerned (i.e. Chief Controller of Francis Xavier Engineers Pvt. Ltd., 1. M/s Danra Metals – benches (i.e. max, depth is 50 Explosives) specifying its validity / usage Carvalho V/s Dept. 310, Dempo Towers, EDC Basalt stone quarry mts.) characteristics. It is also required to maintain of Mines and Patto, Panaji. (10/Basalt/10 11 lease Geology. Material Safety Data Sheets for all explosive 0832-2437048 / 2437164 validity upto 13 th May Excavation/blasting, through material / chemicals be maintained. e-mail – 2013). Suspension cum non-electric shock tubes, is [email protected] 2. M/s Satyappa Gidappa show cause notice carried out through drilling of 6. Modus-operandi for effective utilization of sadekarenviro@rediffmail. Dhangalkar – Stone has been issued by holes of 5 mts. depth – filled organic-rich overburden may be specified. Top soil com quarry (06/Basalt/10 11 the DMG with 25 kgs. explosives upto should necessarily be stacked separately to be lease valid upto 12 th April 3 mts. – remaining is utilized subsequently for landscaping / gardening 2015) stemmed with mud. 10 such or other site-specific purposes. It needs to be 3. M/s Maruksha Stone holes are blasted at a time to demarcated on the surface utilization plan/map. Industry – Stone quarry make metal aggregates of 4. M/s Bharat Farm – different sizes – ½”, ¾”, ¼” 7. PP may like to specify the optimum buffer zone Stone quarry and crush sand. maintained from the outermost lease boundary to 5. M/s Minguelino D’Costa, the nearest excavation within the plot.. C/o Deodita Stone Crushers (06/Basalt/06 – 8. PP may indicate the maximum depth upto which it lease validity expired in is proposing the road metal extraction? ovember 2011 ) Proposal was discussed during the Tenth meeting held on 11 th December 2012. SITE –I SPECTIO YET TO BE CO DUCTED SUBJECT TO RESPO SE FROM PP AS SOUGHT DURI G THE MEETI G STILL AWAITED – status as on 7th March 2013.
2 Mrs. Anila Rege, Basal stone quarry – Survey no. 86/0 of Total plot area – 4,800 1. PP may like to specify environmental mitigative Flat No. 6-3-B, Aquem, 05/Basalt/06 Kotambi village in sq.mts. measures being utilized in case of rainwater Alto, Lease has currently expired Quepem taluka of Total capacity – 1,800 m 3 per collected in the pit. Margao, Goa. in September 2011 and South Goa district. year (18 m 3 per day) Ph. 0832 – 2663160 seeking renewal from 29 th Total mineral reserve is 2. PP has proposed to develop a exhausted pit as a September 2011 for a period of estimated to be about 95,000 water reservoir. As such, may like to ascertain the EMP has been prepared five years (05 yrs.) m3. life of a quarry / pit ( is it 50 years??? ). What is a by present depth of quarry and how deep PP proposes Category1(a) – B to excavate in search of road-metal (is it 10 MSL M/s Sinha Mining ??? )? Consultancy, 21 st January 2013 Mr. P. V. Hegde, 3. PP may like to submit the modus operandi of Reg. no. (RE EWAL ) conducting water and Air monitoring programme at RQP/Goa/162/2003/A three locations along the periphery and within the (IBM) Goa SEAC has inspected the buffer zone of the quarry. e-mail – site on 26 th February 2013. [email protected] 4. PP may submit the existing land-use / land-cover m (i.e. Google image) around 5 mks. radious of the quarry so as to understand the location-specific Mobile – 08805366042 details of other quarries / mines, if any.
PP and Consultant have been directed to submit the proposed quarrying plan as well as EMP prior to process the proposal further.
3 M/s Halarnkar Basalt stone quarry – Lease no. Survey no. 47/1 and Total project area – 12,075 A. As per Clause (8) in Part VIII of the “Form of Industries, 06/Basalt/03 47/2 of Alorna sq.mts. Quarrying Lease – Form D” (refer page 23), Tivim Industrial Estate, (valid upto 7 th September village in Pernem Total quantity – 60 m 3 per Renewal of quarrying lease shall be subject to the Karaswada Industrial 2013) taluka of North Goa day outcome of the decision of the Hon’ble High Estate, district. Court in Writ Petition no. 20/08. Bardez, Goa. Air consent is valid upto 26 th Ph. 0832-2257304 February 2013 The EMP has been prepared by M/s Lila Digital and Environmental Solutions Pvt. Ltd., Panaji. Mr. Meghashyam Category 1(a) – B Halarnkar 1. Quarrying Plan needs to be prepared and 9421242947 29 th January 2013 required to be approved by the Directorate of Mines and Geology (DMG) as per Goa Minor Minerals (Amendment) Rules, 2012. EMP prepared by (RE EWAL ) Mr. Pradip Sarmokadam, 2. May like to submit the Categorization / Zonation Director, Goa SEAC has inspected the plan of the proposed project-site from TCP M/s Lila Digital and site on 28 th February 2013. and/or Forest Dept., as applicable. Environmental Solutions Pvt Ltd., The PP has been directed to submit the project 1st Floor, Rani Pramila specific compliance. Arcade, 18 th June Road, Panaji. 2426250 / 2222496 / 6653250
4 M/r Chandrashekhar Govind Basalt stone quarry – Survey no. 62/1 in Total project area – 5,000 The EMP has been prepared by Mr. P. V. Hegde – Reg. no. th Dessai, NEW LEASE Cordem village of sq.mts. RQP / GOA / 162 / 2003 A (IBM) which is valid upto 16 House No. 166/J, Ghaneshem, Quepem taluka of Total quantity – 18 m 3 December 2013. Gaodongrem, Canacona. Category 1(a) – B South Goa district. per day - 4,200 m 3 per annum. a. Quarrying Plan needs to be prepared and required to be M - 9923397535 24 th January 2013 Toposheet – 48 I/3 Expected life of a quarry approved by the Directorate of Mines and Geology – 05 years (DMG) as per Goa Minor Minerals (Amendment) Environment Management Goa SEAC has Rules, 2012. Plan (EMP) prepared by - inspected the site on th Mr. P. V. Hegde 26 February 2013. b. May like to submit the Categorization / Zonation plan 9822067769 of the proposed project-site from TCP and/or Forest Dept., as applicable considering the location of 3-4 M/s Sinha Mining Consultant, small villages within 5 kms. radius of the lease area. e-mail – [email protected] Committee has decided to keep its decision reserved, 9822067769 / 9405923043 pending submission of project specific compliance with specific reference to proposed on site quarrying plan as well as Environment Management Plan (EMP).
5 M/s Dr. Damodar T. Laterite stone quarry – Survey no. 15/2 Total project area – 4 1. What is the existing land-use / land-cover categorization? Are Gaunker , NEW LEASE of Costi village of ha. there any permanent or seasonal water sources in the form of House No. 5, Sanguem taluka Quantity to be stream / nalla / spring / well? Small seasonal nalla located towards Costi, Kalay, Sanguem. Category 1(a) – B of South Goa extracted per year – south-western part of the lease ( refer pg. 6 of chapter 3 of the district. 1,500 m 3. proposed EMP ) needs special attention as it should not be diverted M – 9011000207 / 1st February 2013 or reclaimed. In addition, analysis of well-water (located around 9011000254 the periphery of the quarry) needs to be analysed on regular basis Ph. 0832-2601234 Goa SEAC has (every three months) as indicated. ( refer pg. 7 of chapter 3 ). inspected the site on e-mail – 27 th February 2013. 2. The proposal indicates about the ‘Reclamation” work ( refer item [email protected] no. 1.10 in Form 1). Project Proponent (PP) may like to specify m the details and purpose of reclamation thereof.
3. PP may indicate nearest distance to the closest settlement area / house / vaddo, etc.
4. PP may like to indicate the water requirement per day / month as well as source of the same.
5. PP may like to ascertain the planned life of a quarry with modus- operandi for disposal of lateritic overburden vis-à-vis environmental considerations, including its stabilization, if any.
The PP has clarified the project specific observations
6 Smt,. Maria Alda Pinto , Basalt stone quarry – RENEWAL Survey no. 70/1 of Santona Existing lease area – 3.360 Ha. 1. The PP proposes to set-up a crusher in the And Shri. Dementro V. Quarry lease no. 05/Basalt/03 (Lease valid village in Sanguem taluka of Rated capacity – 4,500 m 3 per vicinity for which Consent to Establish from Fernandes, upto 30 th April 2013) South Goa district. month - 54,000 m 3 per annum the GSPCB has been obtained on 9 th H. No. 516, Periudak, Santona, November 2012. Sanguem, Goa. Air consent is valid upto 11 th March 2013 Total geological resource – Existing capacity – 180 m 3 per only for extraction capacity of 180 m 3 per 9,23,900 m 3 month – 2,160 m 3 per annum. 2. Mine-waste is proposed to be dumped M – 9049775024 month. outside the lease area which also belongs to [email protected] Total Mineable resource – Expected life of a quarry – 8 years the lessee. Rapid EIA / EMP has been Explosive license is valid upto 31 st March 4,13,600 m 3 prepared by Joshi-Upadhye 2005. 3. PP may like to submit the tentative Associates Site was inspected by Goa conceptual quarrying plan for records. Category 1(a) – B SEAC on 8 th Feb. 2013. 5th February 2013 The PP has clarified the project specific observations
7 Shri. Rumaldo Laterite stones – NEW Survey no. 42/0 of Existing lease are a- 7,180 1. PP is requested to submit the progressive (i.e. Fernandes, Muguli village in sq.mts. year wise) quarry closure plan and/or H. No. 11, Behind Category 1(a) – B Sanguem taluka of Rated capacity of extraction – Environment management Plan (EMP) Sasnguem Church, South Goa district. 800 stones / day proposed to be adopted at the end of life-span Sanguem, Goa – 403 704 8th February 2013 - 6,250 m 3 per annum / of quarry. Proposed land is 700 m 3 per month M – 9823264577 Goa SEAC has inspected the owned by the 2. The nearest settlement is about 300 mts. away site on 27 th February 2013. proponent. Total excavation during the from lease boundary. Consultant – M/s Kurade life-span of a quarry - 25,000 and Associates, Cuncolim. m3 (i.e. 6.15 crores stones) Goa SEAC has kept its decision reserved pending clarification to site specific observations and re Expected life of a quarry – inspection, if any. 15-20 years
8 Shri. Shriram V. Laterite / Rubbles stone quarry Survey no. 38 of Proposed lease area – 15,000 1. PP has claimed that proposed extraction is Gaonkar, – NEW Codar village in sq.mts. above the ground-level and as such, there is no H. No. L-12, Gogal, Ponda taluka of backfilling Near Housing Board, North Goa district. Proposed capacity – 19,200 Margao – 403 601 Category 1(a) – B m3 per annum / 24,000 m 3 2. PP has proposed to utilize the land for Proposed land is (i.e. 1,600 m 3 per month) agricultural plantation (i.e cashew / coconut) at (M) - 9422057061 8th February 2013 owned by the the end of its life-span. The nearest settlement proponent. Total excavation during the is at a distance of 500 mts. from lease Goa SEAC has inspected the life-span of a quarry – boundary. site on 21 st February 2013. 5,80,000 m 3 @ 80 m 3 per day. 3. It is proposed that waste material (i.e. Murrum / broken stones) is proposed to be used for Expected life-span of quarry filling and leveling of low-lying areas. – 20-25 years However, PP is directed not to disturb / divert / reclaim existing water course, if any.
4. PP may specify the maximum depth upto which it proposes to undertake extraction of stones.
The PP has complied with the site specific observations.
9 M/s R.B.S. Basalt stone quarry – Survey no. 11/1(P) Total lease area – 3.42 1. PP has ascertained that total water requirement for green-belt Candiaparcar , RENEWAL of Piliem village in Ha. (2.495 Ha. Has development, and dust suppression is about 15 KLD which is Purushottam Niwas, (Lease no. Dharbandora taluka been unutilized) proposed to be met from accumulated water in the pit. As such, Khandepar, Ponda, 04/Basalt/93) – valid of South Goa may please clarify the source of this water and whether quarrying Goa – 403 401 upto 11 th February district. Rated capacity – 5,000 is being done below the groundwater table. 2013 m3 per annum Mr. Paresh Rejection (i.e. 2. PP may clarify the maximum elevation difference within the Khandeparkar Category 1(a) – B overburden) handling – proposed lease boundary. Ph. 0832-2314918 / 600 m 3 per annum 2318324 The lease does not 3. PP is requested to fence the lease boundary – either with barbed Fax. – 0832-2318567 have a separate Total available wire / bio-fencing and the seasonal nalla along the northern explosive magazine. geological reserves – boundary of the lease should not be disturbed / diverted / e-mail: 3,11,562 m 3. . reclaimed. [email protected] 8th February 2013 om Current depth of the pit 4. PP may please specify and adhere to the bench / terraces pattern as Goa SEAC has achieved – 20 mts. stipulated in the Mines and Safety regulations / guidelines. Consultant – M/s inspected the site on BGL. Kurade and Associates, 21 st February 2013. 5. PP has proposed to backfill the excavated portion of a quarry. As Cuncolim. Optimum depth such, may like to submit the phase-wise action plan. proposed – 30 mts. BGL. 6. The excavated material is manually sized and sent to crushing and screening plant located about 1.5 kms. from lease area. Expected life –span – 7. PP has submitted the area wise statement of present land use 62 years pattern.
The PP has been directed to comply with the proposed quarrying plan in light of the Mines Safety Regulations w.r.t. benches and terraces.
10 M/s R.B.S. Basalt stone quarry – Survey no. 6/2(P) Total lease area – 2.32 ( 1. PP has ascertained that total water requirement for green-belt Candiaparcar , RENEWAL of Piliem village in Ha. has been development, and dust suppression is about 10 KLD which is Purushottam Niwas, (Lease no. Dharbandora taluka unutilized). proposed to be met from accumulated water in the pit. As such, Khandepar, Ponda, 03/Basalt/93) – valid of South Goa may please clarify the source of this water and whether quarrying Goa – 403 401 upto 11 th February district. Rated capacity – 6,000 is being done below the groundwater table. 2013 m3 per annum Rejection (i.e. 2. The maximum elevation difference within the lease boundary is Mr. Paresh Category 1(a) – B overburden) handling – 18 mts.. Khandeparkar 700 m 3 per annum P. O. Box no. 187, The lease has a 3. PP is requested to fence the lease boundary – either with barbed Anant Smriti, separate explosive Total available wire / bio-fencing. Behind Main Post magazine. geological reserves – 4. PP may please specify and adhere to the bench / terraces pattern as office, 2,82,760 m 3. stipulated in the Mines and Safety regulations / guidelines. Ponda, Goa. 8th February 2013 Current depth of the pit 5. PP has proposed to backfill the excavated portion of a quarry. As
Ph. 0832-2314918 / achieved – 20 mts. such, may like to submit the phase-wise action plan. 2318324 Goa SEAC has BGL. Fax. – 0832-2318567 inspected the site on 6. The excavated material is manually sized and sent to crushing and 21 st February 2013. Optimum depth screening plant located about 1.5 kms. from lease area. e-mail: proposed – 30 mts. 7. PP has submitted the area wise statement of present land use [email protected] BGL. th om pattern (as on 30 May 2011). Expected life –span – Consultant – M/s 47 years The PP has been directed to comply with the proposed quarrying Kurade and Associates, plan in light of the Mines Safety Regulations w.r.t. benches and Cuncolim. terraces.
11 Shri. Jaiwas aik, Laterite / Rubbles Survey no. 150 Proposed lease area – 1. PP is requested to fence the lease boundary with poles for clear H. No. 353, Shindolim, stone quarry – NEW (Part-B) of Verna 20,000 sq.mts. demarcation – either with barbed wire / bio-fencing. Sancoale, village in Salcete Proposed capacity – Cortalim. Category 1(a) – B taluka of South 5,000 m 3 per annum 2. PP has proposed that open quarried pit will be back-filled with Goa district. (about 500 m 3 per wastes – murrum / stone wastages and to be used for plantation. M – 7350787380 month – 25m 3 / 60 m 3 - 7350933668 11 th February 2013 Property rights are per day) 3. PP may clarify the provision of accessibility to site with proper with the proponent approach road / transportation route. The nearest human Consultant – M/s Goa SEAC has by way of partition Total expected Laterite settlement is at a distance of about 800 mts. Kurade and Associates, inspected the site on suit bearing no. extraction – 75,000 m 3. 4. Laterite extraction does not involve any blasting operations. Cuncolim. 21 st February 2013. 25/11/III. (within life-span of 15 However, operational timings be restricted from 09.00 a.m. upto years) 6.00 p.m. and be discontinued during monsoon season (04
months).
5. PP may like to submit the existing land-use / land-cover of the surrounding area within 5 kms. around the proposes site.
6. PP may submit the expected maximum depth upto which it proposes to carry out excavation.
The PP has complied with the site specific observations.
3. Any other matter with the permission of the Chair.
Agenda items for the Thirteenth Goa SEAC meeting held on 7 th March 2013
4. ew project proposals seeking prior EC as mandated under the EIA otification, 2006
B. PROPOSED EXPANSION OF RESIDENTIAL COMPL IN CHALTA NO. 13 & 15 ANDP.T. SH NO. 299 OF NAVELIM IN MARGAO CITY BY M/S SRE ESTATES DEVELOPERS, MARGAO
Sr. Project Proponent Proposed Site specific Project details / specification / salient features Comments of the Goa SEAC members and o. (PP) / Applicant Activity location details its compliance by PP Current Status
1 M/s SRE Estates Proposed expansion Chalta no. 13 & 15 of Total plot area – 8,566 sq. mt. 7. It is understood that the existing structure is proposed Developers, Supreme, of residential complex Petitate Sheet No. 299 Approved Built-up area – 6,958.15 sq.mts. to be demolished and proposed development is an Behind New Telephone (G + 8 floors) of Margao city in Proposed built-up area – 22,386.21 sq.mts. expansion. Total built up area of these existing Exchange, “Supreme Colmorod Salcete taluka of Gross built-up area – 29,344.36 sq.mts. structures is 407.26 sq.mts . Opposite Bombi House, Central” that includes South Goa district. Permissible F.A.R. – 16,932 sq.mts. Comba, Margao – 403 – (i.e. Navelim) FAR consumed – 16,904 sq.mts. 8. The proposed development falls under Margao 601 Open space required – 1,284.90 sq.mts. Municipal Council (MMC). Since the area falls (Post Box. No. 778) 01 –Studios (i.e. Margao Open space provided – 1,580 sq.mts. under C1 (commercial) zone, the maximum height 06 – 1 BHK Municipal Limits) permissible is 24 mts. as per TCP laws. Ph. 0832-2736418 / 19 124 – 2 BHK Expected total occupancy – 702 persons Fax. 0832-2735976 25 – 3 BHK Ph. 0832-2714448 9. South Goa Planning and Development Authority e-mail – (total 156 flats ) Parking proposed – 185 ECS (SGPDA) has issued development permission in [email protected] February 2012. Category 8 (a) – B Geo-technical soil investigation (through three bore-holes drilled Mr. Yogesh Naik – Construction projects upto 10mts.) has been prepared and submitted with the proposal 10. During construction phase, water requirement will be Partner, (conducted by M/s Surbhi Enterprises – a Geotek Consortium, met through proposed open well. As such, may like to Ph. 0832-2736418 Received on 23 rd Mahim, Mumbai .). Accordingly, Groundwater table is encountered specify site-specific details superimposed on a Fax. 0832-2735976 January 2013 at a depth ranging from 1.7 mts. to 2 mts. As such, Raft foundation contour map. It is recommended that water 2 e-mail – has been proposed with allowable bearing pressure of 15 t/m that requirement during construction phase should not be yogeshnaik@sregroupgoa. may result with maximum settlement less than 65 mm. sourced from open well. PP need to make alternate in arrangement for the same. However, on M - 9822100532 Water requirement – operationalization, the PP should mandatorily adapt c. During Construction phase – 20CMD ( 2CMD for domestic rainwater harvesting (RWH) for effective recharging Environmental consultant use and 18CMD for construction purpose ) to be sourced of open well. – PP has communicated that – from private tankers and proposed open well. proposed construction of underground tanks of M/s Aditya 200 cu.m. capacity and septic tanks will be Environmental d. During operational phase – 139CMD (i.e. 63CMD from designed by a RCC consultant by providing proper Consultancy, Mumbai PWD and 76CMD from STP-recycled) upward thrust considering occurrence of groundwater at relatively shallow depth . Ms. Poonam Moye Wastewater generated – 81CMD of wastewater to be treated in Sewage Treatment Plant of 85CMD capacity having Moving Bed 11. PP may like to clarify w.r.t. digging of any bore- Bio-Reactor (MBBR) technology which will generate 76CMD of well(s) and accordingly, may specify modus operandi treated water. Out of this, 32CMD for flushing, 08CMD for for its effective recharge either through roof-top or gardening, 05CMD for car washings. 31 CMD of the balanced watershed approach as RWH initiatives. – Complied. STP treated water is proposed to be provided to existing bungalows / buildings for the purpose of gardening . The PP has 12. Total capital cost of EMP is Rs. 75 lakhs and proposed dual plumbing system. expected operation and maintenance cost is Rs. 9 lakhs. It is proposed to – 10kgs. of sludge per day will be generated which is proposed be dewatered, dried and mixed with compost for gardening. d. Capital cost for environmental infrastructure to be borne by Developer Solid waste generated - 3. During construction phase about 1-2 MT /day of debris is e. Infrastructure to be operated and maintained estimated to be generated. by Developer till formation of Society and Conveyance. 4. During operational phase, about 298 kgs./day is estimated to be generated which will be segregated at source into wet and f. Corpus fund to be created for maintenance of dry garbage. Biodegradable waste ( 50% of the total waste ) is Environmental Infrastructure @ Rs. 50,000/ proposed to be treated on Organic Waste Convertor (OWC). per flat. Space of 200 sq.mts. has been proposed as per the plan for segregation of the non biodegradable waste and segregated waste is proposed to be disposed off through scrap dealer for recycling.
Power requirement. – b. Construction phase – 2.5 HP
Operation phase – 2,124 KVA to be sourced from Goa State Electricity Board. In addition, back-up power through 01 DG sets of 625 KVA capacity.
5. As per the “Goa Mineral Concession (Amendment) Rules, 2012” notified by the Directorate of Mines and Geology (DMG) and published in Official Gazette Series 1 No. 24 dated 17 th September 2012, following proposals seeking prior EC for New / Renewal of Quarrying Lease has been received for suitable appraisal / consideration.
Sr. Project Proponent (PP) / Proposed Activity Site specific Project details / Comments of the Goa SEAC members / Current o. Applicant location details specification / salient Status Environmental features Consultant 9. Are these two leases contagious with a common 1 M/s. Joao Lourenco Basalt stone quarry - Survey No. 52/0 of Total plot area (02 leases) – boundary or independent of each other? Baptista Basalt Boulders / (c) No.1/Basalt/04 Ugeum village in (b) 7.150 sq.mts. + (b) 5,080 Stone Quarry (d) No. 4/Basalt/04 Sanguem taluka of sq.mts. = 12,230 sq.mts. 10. Both the leases have Consent to Operate issued South Goa district by the Board and valid upto 31 st December 2014. 3 Mr. J. L. Baptista, (RE EWAL ) Proposed capacity 50 m per H. No. 105/D-3, Behind How many Basalt month 11. Ambient Air Quality Monitoring (AAQM) old RTO office, Arlem, Lease nos. – stone quarries in Reports conducted by MoEF recognized laboratory 3 Raia, Salcete, Goa – 403 (c) Quarry 56/1495/97- this survey no.? Water requirement – 100 M during last year (three times a year), at the nearest 720 Mines/3483 per day residential, area may be submitted. (d) Quarry 34/430/07- What is the Ph.: 0832 – 2741951 Mines/3485 outcome of ‘Order” The site has average 12. PP may like to submit measures proposed to be Mobile - 9764503900 (Validity upto ovember issued in the matter overburden of 2-3 mts. It is adapted for dust suppression / noise pollution. 2012) of PIL Writ proposed to undertake Environmental Appraisal Petition o. vertical excavation at 1:10 th 13. Environmental Appraisal Report (EAR) Report (EAR) prepared by Category 1(a) – B 10/2012 on 14 ratio (6 mts. drop at an angle indicates the usage of explosives during blasting / 0 - June 2012 of 60 ) with bench of 3 mts. excavation. As such, PP may submit the NOC from M/s Sadekar Enviro What about – Proposed to make 7 – 8 such the Authority concerned (i.e. Chief Controller of Francis Xavier Engineers Pvt. Ltd., 6. M/s Danra Metals – Carvalho V/s Dept. benches (i.e. max, depth is 50 Explosives) specifying its validity / usage 310, Dempo Towers, EDC Basalt stone quarry of Mines and mts.) characteristics. It is also required to maintain Patto, Panaji. (10/Basalt/10 11 lease Geology. Material Safety Data Sheets for all explosive 0832-2437048 / 2437164 validity upto 13 th May Excavation/blasting, through material / chemicals be maintained. e-mail – 2013). Suspension cum non-electric shock tubes, is [email protected] 7. M/s Satyappa Gidappa show cause notice carried out through drilling of 14. Modus-operandi for effective utilization of sadekarenviro@rediffmail. Dhangalkar – Stone has been issued by holes of 5 mts. depth – filled organic-rich overburden may be specified. Top soil com quarry (06/Basalt/10 11 the DMG with 25 kgs. explosives upto should necessarily be stacked separately to be lease valid upto 12 th April 3 mts. – remaining is utilized subsequently for landscaping / gardening 2015) stemmed with mud. 10 such or other site-specific purposes. It needs to be 8. M/s Maruksha Stone holes are blasted at a time to demarcated on the surface utilization plan/map. Industry – Stone quarry make metal aggregates of 9. M/s Bharat Farm – different sizes – ½”, ¾”, ¼” 15. PP may like to specify the optimum buffer Stone quarry and crush sand. zone maintained from the outermost lease 10. M/s Minguelino boundary to the nearest excavation within the plot.. D’Costa, C/o Deodita Stone Crushers 16. PP may indicate the maximum depth upto (06/Basalt/06 – lease which it is proposing the road metal extraction? validity expired in ovember 2011 ) Proposal was discussed during the Tenth meeting held on 11 th December 2012. SITE –I SPECTIO YET TO BE CO DUCTED SUBJECT TO RESPO SE FROM PP AS SOUGHT DURI G THE MEETI G STILL AWAITED – status as on 7th March 2013.
2 Mrs. Anila Rege, Basal stone quarry – Survey no. 86/0 of Total plot area – 4,800 5. PP may like to specify environmental mitigative Flat No. 6-3-B, Aquem, 05/Basalt/06 Kotambi village in sq.mts. measures being utilized in case of rainwater Alto, Lease has currently expired Quepem taluka of Total capacity – 1,800 m 3 per collected in the pit. Margao, Goa. in September 2011 and South Goa district. year (18 m 3 per day) Ph. 0832 – 2663160 seeking renewal from 29 th Total mineral reserve is 6. PP has proposed to develop a exhausted pit as a September 2011 for a period of estimated to be about 95,000 water reservoir. As such, may like to ascertain the EMP has been prepared five years (05 yrs.) m3. life of a quarry / pit ( is it 50 years??? ). What is a by present depth of quarry and how deep PP proposes Category1(a) – B to excavate in search of road-metal (is it 10 MSL M/s Sinha Mining ??? )? Consultancy, 21 st January 2013 Mr. P. V. Hegde, 7. PP may like to submit the modus operandi of Reg. no. (RE EWAL ) conducting water and Air monitoring programme at RQP/Goa/162/2003/A three locations along the periphery and within the (IBM) Goa SEAC has inspected the buffer zone of the quarry. e-mail – site on 26 th February 2013. [email protected] 8. PP may submit the existing land-use / land-cover m (i.e. Google image) around 5 mks. radious of the quarry so as to understand the location-specific Mobile – 08805366042 details of other quarries / mines, if any.
PP and Consultant have been directed to submit the proposed quarrying plan as well as EMP prior to process the proposal further.
3 M/s Halarnkar Basalt stone quarry – Lease no. Survey no. 47/1 and Total project area – 12,075 B. As per Clause (8) in Part VIII of the “Form of Industries, 06/Basalt/03 47/2 of Alorna sq.mts. Quarrying Lease – Form D” (refer page 23), Tivim Industrial Estate, (valid upto 7 th September village in Pernem Total quantity – 60 m 3 per Renewal of quarrying lease shall be subject to the Karaswada Industrial 2013) taluka of North Goa day outcome of the decision of the Hon’ble High Estate, district. Court in Writ Petition no. 20/08. Bardez, Goa. Air consent is valid upto 26 th Ph. 0832-2257304 February 2013 The EMP has been prepared by M/s Lila Digital and Environmental Solutions Pvt. Ltd., Panaji. Mr. Meghashyam Category 1(a) – B Halarnkar 3. Quarrying Plan needs to be prepared and required to be approved by the Directorate of 9421242947 29 th January 2013 Mines and Geology (DMG) as per Goa Minor Minerals (Amendment) Rules, 2012. EMP prepared by (RE EWAL ) Mr. Pradip Sarmokadam, 4. May like to submit the Categorization / Zonation Director, Goa SEAC has inspected the plan of the proposed project-site from TCP M/s Lila Digital and site on 28 th February 2013. and/or Forest Dept., as applicable. Environmental Solutions Pvt Ltd., The PP has been directed to submit the project 1st Floor, Rani Pramila specific compliance. Arcade, 18 th June Road, Panaji. 2426250 / 2222496 / 6653250
4 M/r Chandrashekhar Govind Basalt stone quarry – Survey no. 62/1 in Total project area – 5,000 The EMP has been prepared by Mr. P. V. Hegde – Reg. no. th Dessai, NEW LEASE Cordem village of sq.mts. RQP / GOA / 162 / 2003 A (IBM) which is valid upto 16 House No. 166/J, Ghaneshem, Quepem taluka of Total quantity – 18 m 3 December 2013. Gaodongrem, Canacona. Category 1(a) – B South Goa district. per day - 4,200 m 3 per annum. c. Quarrying Plan needs to be prepared and required to be M - 9923397535 24 th January 2013 Toposheet – 48 I/3 Expected life of a quarry approved by the Directorate of Mines and Geology – 05 years (DMG) as per Goa Minor Minerals (Amendment) Environment Management Goa SEAC has Rules, 2012. Plan (EMP) prepared by - inspected the site on th Mr. P. V. Hegde 26 February 2013. d. May like to submit the Categorization / Zonation plan 9822067769 of the proposed project-site from TCP and/or Forest Dept., as applicable considering the location of 3-4 M/s Sinha Mining Consultant, small villages within 5 kms. radius of the lease area. e-mail – [email protected] Committee has decided to keep its decision reserved, 9822067769 / 9405923043 pending submission of project specific compliance with specific reference to proposed on site quarrying plan as well as Environment Management Plan (EMP).
5 M/s Dr. Damodar T. Laterite stone quarry – Survey no. 15/2 Total project area – 4 6. What is the existing land-use / land-cover categorization? Are Gaunker , NEW LEASE of Costi village of ha. there any permanent or seasonal water sources in the form of House No. 5, Sanguem taluka Quantity to be stream / nalla / spring / well? Small seasonal nalla located towards Costi, Kalay, Sanguem. Category 1(a) – B of South Goa extracted per year – south-western part of the lease ( refer pg. 6 of chapter 3 of the district. 1,500 m 3. proposed EMP ) needs special attention as it should not be diverted M – 9011000207 / 1st February 2013 or reclaimed. In addition, analysis of well-water (located around 9011000254 the periphery of the quarry) needs to be analysed on regular basis Ph. 0832-2601234 Goa SEAC has (every three months) as indicated. ( refer pg. 7 of chapter 3 ). inspected the site on e-mail – 27 th February 2013. 7. The proposal indicates about the ‘Reclamation” work ( refer item [email protected] no. 1.10 in Form 1). Project Proponent (PP) may like to specify m the details and purpose of reclamation thereof. 8. PP may indicate nearest distance to the closest settlement area / house / vaddo, etc.
9. PP may like to indicate the water requirement per day / month as well as source of the same.
10. PP may like to ascertain the planned life of a quarry with modus- operandi for disposal of lateritic overburden vis-à-vis environmental considerations, including its stabilization, if any.
The PP has clarified the project specific observations
6 Smt,. Maria Alda Pinto , Basalt stone quarry – RENEWAL Survey no. 70/1 of Santona Existing lease area – 3.360 Ha. 4. The PP proposes to set-up a crusher in the And Shri. Dementro V. Quarry lease no. 05/Basalt/03 (Lease valid village in Sanguem taluka of Rated capacity – 4,500 m 3 per vicinity for which Consent to Establish from Fernandes, upto 30 th April 2013) South Goa district. month - 54,000 m 3 per annum the GSPCB has been obtained on 9 th H. No. 516, Periudak, Santona, November 2012. Sanguem, Goa. Air consent is valid upto 11 th March 2013 Total geological resource – Existing capacity – 180 m 3 per only for extraction capacity of 180 m 3 per 9,23,900 m 3 month – 2,160 m 3 per annum. 5. Mine-waste is proposed to be dumped M – 9049775024 month. outside the lease area which also belongs to [email protected] Total Mineable resource – Expected life of a quarry – 8 years the lessee. Rapid EIA / EMP has been Explosive license is valid upto 31 st March 4,13,600 m 3 prepared by Joshi-Upadhye 2005. 6. PP may like to submit the tentative Associates Site was inspected by Goa conceptual quarrying plan for records. Category 1(a) – B SEAC on 8 th Feb. 2013. 5th February 2013 The PP has clarified the project specific observations
7 Shri. Rumaldo Laterite stones – NEW Survey no. 42/0 of Existing lease are a- 7,180 3. PP is requested to submit the progressive (i.e. Fernandes, Muguli village in sq.mts. year wise) quarry closure plan and/or H. No. 11, Behind Category 1(a) – B Sanguem taluka of Rated capacity of extraction – Environment management Plan (EMP) Sasnguem Church, South Goa district. 800 stones / day proposed to be adopted at the end of life-span Sanguem, Goa – 403 704 8th February 2013 - 6,250 m 3 per annum / of quarry. Proposed land is 700 m 3 per month M – 9823264577 Goa SEAC has inspected the owned by the 4. The nearest settlement is about 300 mts. away site on 27 th February 2013. proponent. Total excavation during the from lease boundary. Consultant – M/s Kurade life-span of a quarry - 25,000 and Associates, Cuncolim. m3 (i.e. 6.15 crores stones) Goa SEAC has kept its decision reserved pending clarification to site specific observations and re Expected life of a quarry – inspection, if any. 15-20 years
8 Shri. Shriram V. Laterite / Rubbles stone quarry Survey no. 38 of Proposed lease area – 15,000 5. PP has claimed that proposed extraction is Gaonkar, – NEW Codar village in sq.mts. above the ground-level and as such, there is no H. No. L-12, Gogal, Ponda taluka of backfilling Near Housing Board, North Goa district. Proposed capacity – 19,200 Margao – 403 601 Category 1(a) – B m3 per annum / 24,000 m 3 6. PP has proposed to utilize the land for Proposed land is (i.e. 1,600 m 3 per month) agricultural plantation (i.e cashew / coconut) at (M) - 9422057061 8th February 2013 owned by the the end of its life-span. The nearest settlement proponent. Total excavation during the is at a distance of 500 mts. from lease Goa SEAC has inspected the life-span of a quarry – boundary. site on 21 st February 2013. 5,80,000 m 3 @ 80 m 3 per day. 7. It is proposed that waste material (i.e. Murrum / broken stones) is proposed to be used for Expected life-span of quarry filling and leveling of low-lying areas. – 20-25 years However, PP is directed not to disturb / divert / reclaim existing water course, if any.
8. PP may specify the maximum depth upto which it proposes to undertake extraction of stones.
The PP has complied with the site specific observations.
9 M/s R.B.S. Basalt stone quarry – Survey no. 11/1(P) Total lease area – 3.42 8. PP has ascertained that total water requirement for green-belt Candiaparcar , RENEWAL of Piliem village in Ha. (2.495 Ha. Has development, and dust suppression is about 15 KLD which is Purushottam Niwas, (Lease no. Dharbandora taluka been unutilized) proposed to be met from accumulated water in the pit. As such, Khandepar, Ponda, 04/Basalt/93) – valid of South Goa may please clarify the source of this water and whether quarrying Goa – 403 401 upto 11 th February district. Rated capacity – 5,000 is being done below the groundwater table. 2013 m3 per annum Mr. Paresh Rejection (i.e. 9. PP may clarify the maximum elevation difference within the Khandeparkar Category 1(a) – B overburden) handling – proposed lease boundary. Ph. 0832-2314918 / 600 m 3 per annum 2318324 The lease does not 10. PP is requested to fence the lease boundary – either with barbed Fax. – 0832-2318567 have a separate Total available wire / bio-fencing and the seasonal nalla along the northern explosive magazine. geological reserves – boundary of the lease should not be disturbed / diverted / e-mail: 3,11,562 m 3. . reclaimed. [email protected] 8th February 2013 om Current depth of the pit 11. PP may please specify and adhere to the bench / terraces pattern as Goa SEAC has achieved – 20 mts. stipulated in the Mines and Safety regulations / guidelines. Consultant – M/s inspected the site on BGL. Kurade and Associates, 21 st February 2013. 12. PP has proposed to backfill the excavated portion of a quarry. As Cuncolim. Optimum depth such, may like to submit the phase-wise action plan. proposed – 30 mts. BGL. 13. The excavated material is manually sized and sent to crushing and screening plant located about 1.5 kms. from lease area. Expected life –span – 14. PP has submitted the area wise statement of present land use 62 years pattern.
The PP has been directed to comply with the proposed quarrying plan in light of the Mines Safety Regulations w.r.t. benches and terraces.
10 M/s R.B.S. Basalt stone quarry – Survey no. 6/2(P) Total lease area – 2.32 ( 8. PP has ascertained that total water requirement for green-belt Candiaparcar , RENEWAL of Piliem village in Ha. has been development, and dust suppression is about 10 KLD which is Purushottam Niwas, (Lease no. Dharbandora taluka unutilized). proposed to be met from accumulated water in the pit. As such, Khandepar, Ponda, 03/Basalt/93) – valid of South Goa may please clarify the source of this water and whether quarrying Goa – 403 401 upto 11 th February district. Rated capacity – 6,000 is being done below the groundwater table. 2013 m3 per annum Rejection (i.e. 9. The maximum elevation difference within the lease boundary is Mr. Paresh Category 1(a) – B overburden) handling – 18 mts.. Khandeparkar 700 m 3 per annum P. O. Box no. 187, The lease has a 10. PP is requested to fence the lease boundary – either with barbed Anant Smriti, separate explosive Total available wire / bio-fencing. Behind Main Post magazine. geological reserves – 11. PP may please specify and adhere to the bench / terraces pattern as office, 2,82,760 m 3. stipulated in the Mines and Safety regulations / guidelines. Ponda, Goa. 8th February 2013 Current depth of the pit 12. PP has proposed to backfill the excavated portion of a quarry. As
Ph. 0832-2314918 / achieved – 20 mts. such, may like to submit the phase-wise action plan. 2318324 Goa SEAC has BGL. Fax. – 0832-2318567 inspected the site on 13. The excavated material is manually sized and sent to crushing and 21 st February 2013. Optimum depth screening plant located about 1.5 kms. from lease area. e-mail: proposed – 30 mts. 14. PP has submitted the area wise statement of present land use [email protected] BGL. th om pattern (as on 30 May 2011). Expected life –span – Consultant – M/s 47 years The PP has been directed to comply with the proposed quarrying Kurade and Associates, plan in light of the Mines Safety Regulations w.r.t. benches and Cuncolim. terraces.
11 Shri. Jaiwas aik, Laterite / Rubbles Survey no. 150 Proposed lease area – 7. PP is requested to fence the lease boundary with poles for clear H. No. 353, Shindolim, stone quarry – NEW (Part-B) of Verna 20,000 sq.mts. demarcation – either with barbed wire / bio-fencing. Sancoale, village in Salcete Proposed capacity – Cortalim. Category 1(a) – B taluka of South 5,000 m 3 per annum 8. PP has proposed that open quarried pit will be back-filled with Goa district. (about 500 m 3 per wastes – murrum / stone wastages and to be used for plantation. M – 7350787380 month – 25m 3 / 60 m 3 - 7350933668 11 th February 2013 Property rights are per day) 9. PP may clarify the provision of accessibility to site with proper with the proponent approach road / transportation route. The nearest human Consultant – M/s Goa SEAC has by way of partition Total expected Laterite settlement is at a distance of about 800 mts. Kurade and Associates, inspected the site on suit bearing no. extraction – 75,000 m 3. 10. Laterite extraction does not involve any blasting operations. Cuncolim. 21 st February 2013. 25/11/III. (within life-span of 15 However, operational timings be restricted from 09.00 a.m. upto years) 6.00 p.m. and be discontinued during monsoon season (04
months).
11. PP may like to submit the existing land-use / land-cover of the surrounding area within 5 kms. around the proposes site.
12. PP may submit the expected maximum depth upto which it proposes to carry out excavation.
The PP has complied with the site specific observations.
6. Any other matter with the permission of the Chair.