DO NOT REMOVE Fl co 1 IN THE SUPREME c8 ,~ 6 · f PPEALS OF THE STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA r,:~::::;-;;aM-AY~ ~- - """:(g~~-- 5 2020 0 LAWYER DISCIPLINARY BOARD, EDYTHE NASH GAISER CLERK SUPREME COURT OF APPEALs OF WEST VIRGINIA Petitioner, v. No. 18-0101 McGINNIS E. HATFIELD, JR., Respondent. BRIEF OF THE LAWYER DISCIPLINARY BOARD Rachael L. Fletcher Cipoletti [Bar No. 8806] Chief Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel
[email protected] Renee N. Frymyer [Bar No. 9253] Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel
[email protected] Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel City Center East, Suite 1200C 4700 MacCorkle Avenue, S.E. Charleston, West Virginia 25304 (304) 558-7999 (304) 558-4015 - facsimile TABLE OF CONTENTS TABLE OF AUTHORITIES .... .. ..... ... ..... ..... .... ... .... ... .... .. ...... .. 111 I. STATEMENT OF THE CASE ..... ........ .. ...... ... .... .. ..... ....... 1 A. NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS AND RECOMMENDATION OF THE HEARING PANEL SUBCOMMITTEE ... .. ..... .... ... .... ....... 1 B. FINDINGS OF FACT ... .. .............. .. ..... ..... ... .... .. ...... 2 C. CONCLUSIONS OF LAW . .. ..... .... ...... ... .... ... ..... ..... .. .. ... 8 IL SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT . .. ...... ... ...... ... ..... .. .... ... ..... .... 9 III. STATEMENT REGARDING ORAL ARGUMENT AND DECISION ......... .... 10 IV. ARGUMENT ............ .... ... .. ... ...... .. ..... .. ..... .. ....... 10 A. STANDARD OF PROOF . ...... ........ ...... .. ..................... 10 B. ANALYSIS UNDER RULE 3.16 OF THE RULES OF LAWYER DISCIPLINARY PROCEDURE .................... ..... 11 1. Respondent