The Nter: a Proposed Innovative Propulsion Concept for Manned Interplanetary Missions

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Nter: a Proposed Innovative Propulsion Concept for Manned Interplanetary Missions 4TH EUROPEAN CONFERENCE FOR AEROSPACE SCIENCES (EUCASS) THE NTER: A PROPOSED INNOVATIVE PROPULSION CONCEPT FOR MANNED INTERPLANETARY MISSIONS C. Dujarric European Space Agency, HQ, 8-10 rue Mario Nikis, 75738 Paris Cedex 15, FRANCE A. Santovincenzo, L. Summerer European Space Agency, ESTEC, Noordwijck, Netherlands Abstract proposed at an IAF conference in 1999.[1][7] Following a slow maturation process, a new concept was defined which Conventional propulsion technology was submitted to a concurrent design (chemical and electric) currently limits the exercise in ESTEC in 2007. The pre- possibilities for human space exploration to definition work made clear that, based on the neighbourhood of the Earth. If farther conservative technology assumptions, a destinations (such as Mars) are to be specific impulse of 920s could be obtained reached with humans on board, a more with a thrust of 110kN. Despite the heavy capable interplanetary transfer engine engine dry mass, a preliminary mission featuring high thrust, high specific impulse analysis using conservative assumptions is required. showed that the concept was reducing the required Initial Mass in Low Earth Orbit The source of energy, which could in compared to conventional nuclear thermal principle best meet these engine rockets for a human mission to Mars. A requirements is nuclear thermal. However patent was filed on the concept. Because of the nuclear thermal rocket technology is not the operating parameters of the nuclear core, yet ready for flight application. The which are very specific to this type of development of new materials, which is concept, it seems possible to test on ground necessary for the nuclear core will require this kind of engine at full-scale in close loop further testing on ground of full-scale using a reasonable size test facility with safe nuclear rocket engines. Such testing is a and clean conditions. Such tests can be powerful inhibitor to the nuclear rocket conducted within fully confined enclosure, development, as the risks of nuclear which would substantially increase the contamination of the environment cannot be associated inherent nuclear safety levels. entirely avoided with current concepts. This breakthrough removes a showstopper for nuclear rocket engines development. Alongside already further matured activities in the field of space nuclear power sources The present paper will disclose the NTER for generating on-board power, a low level (Nuclear Thermal Electric Rocket) engine investigation on nuclear propulsion has been concept, will present some of the results of running since long within ESA, and the ESTEC concurrent engineering exercise, innovative concepts have already been and will explain the concept for the NTER Copyright © 2011 by C. Dujarric, A. Santovincenzo and L. Summerer. Published by the EUCASS association with permission. Symposium on Propulsion Physics, Session on Nuclear Propulsion for Exploration on-ground testing facility. Regulations and and without effective means to influence safety issues related to the development and decisively their fate, especially when facing implementation of the NTER concept will non-nominal situations. It is mandatory to be addressed as well. give them a propulsion mean on which they can rely to implement their decisions to Introduction restore their nominal mission or initiate a safeguard alternative and monitor the effect The present paper focuses on inter-orbital of their action within short delay. propulsion, i.e. the propulsion needed to escape earth orbit and conduct space Nuclear propulsion state of the art exploration, including return to Earth. For such missions the optimisation of the inter- Nucleo-thermal rocket propulsion was orbital propulsion is a key driver for the developed both in the U.S. and in Russia overall mission cost, as the slightest aiming to satisfy the simultaneous need for performance gains on the interplanetary high thrust and high specific impulse. transfer engine has huge impacts on the size of the required Earth departure means. The nuclear propulsion development efforts lasted in the U.S. from 1955 until 1972. The typical advantage of chemical Twenty rockets and furnaces were propulsion is to provide a high spacecraft successfully ground tested in the frame of acceleration for a low engine mass, while the KIWI and NERVA programs. The electric propulsion may be preferred for its NERVA-NRX/XE, which featured Uranium higher specific impulse whenever thrust can carbide fuel core coated with Zirconium be applied for a long time without carbide, was the ground-qualified model the detrimental effect on the payload. R&D closest to a flight model. strives to mitigate the shortcomings and pushes the limits of each type of propulsion. However even taking into account the anticipated progresses of these technologies, a part of the long-term space exploration needs may lie beyond the physical limits of those conventional propulsion means. Human exploration of space beyond the Figure 1: the NERVA NTR engine Moon orbit generates mission constraints The nuclear thermal propulsion which neither chemical nor electric development efforts started also in 1955 in propulsion can satisfy. The time of the Russia but lasted until 1989. Several engines interplanetary travel must remain (RD-0140, RD-0411 and RD-410) were sufficiently short to keep the space radiation designed in CIS and their nuclear fuel effects to an acceptable level. The crew elements based on ternary carbide twisted endures not only a cumulated radiation dose ribbons were successfully tested, however proportional to the duration of their travel at not as part of an engine system. first order approximation, but also takes a proportionally cumulated risk of being hit More recent conceptual studies were by a solar flare or meteorite. Furthermore, conducted in the U.S., which are not yet on a long interplanetary ballistic trajectory, tested at engine system level. The core the crew cannot be left in a waiting mode technology investigations led to the Page 2 C. DUJARRIC, A. SANTOVINCENZO, L. SUMMERER: THE NTER: A PROPOSED INNOVATIVE PROPULSION CONCEPT FOR MANNED INTERPLANETARY MISSIONS ceramic-metallic (CERMET) fuel in a fast ESA’s initial proposals to upgrade the neutron reactor. This solution offers better nucleothermal propulsion performance resistance to hydrogen corrosion and a lighter design, but further work is still Several ideas were already investigated in needed to reduce fission gas swelling effects the 1990’s, in particular by Aerojet in the in the fuel. U.S., to take advantage of the unlimited power available from the nuclear core to At system level, bimodal engines were increase the specific impulse of the engine investigated in the U.S. and in Russia to as compared to what is obtained by a simple deliver electric energy to the spacecraft heat transfer to the hydrogen. These studies during cruise for example to keep the were stopped in view of the complexity of hydrogen in liquid state, and also to mitigate the thermal machines involved, and their the hydrogen consumption during the consequent mass. nuclear core start-up/shutdown transients. Along these lines, ESA proposed its first Some conceptual design work on nuclear ideas in 1999, which consisted in using the propulsion also started in Europe with the electric power obtainable from a bimodal French MAPS program in 1995, but this engine to heat the hydrogen plasma effort did not result in any hardware supersonic exhaust by electric induction. fabrication or testing. [1][2] This nuclear inductive concept is recalled in Figure 2: 25% parahydrogen, 75 % orthohydrogen 75 b, 700 K 100 b, 563 K Caesium 68 MW seeding 150 MW catalysised para/ortho 2000 K 2200 K 95 b conversion Pc = 34 MJ/kg 1 bar, 75 K 60 b H=404 kJ/kg 20% ortho 90 b 53K 70 b Alternator 82 MW Inductive heating O2 (shown Impedance & Electric circuitry 100 bar operating loop : 70 MW into gas frequency deep cooling 5 MW acceleration matching parameters are with no Total enthalpy 44 MJ/kg oxygen Expansion ratio 250 feed) 3 b, 725 K Theoretical performance without O2 : Isp= 930 s , Thrust = 64 kNH2 slush 7 kg/s 100% parahydrogen H= -341 kJ/kg Figure 2: the nuclear inductive concept Page 3 Symposium on Propulsion Physics, Session on Nuclear Propulsion for Exploration One particular benefit of the idea was the The NTER concept synergy and efficiency gain, which was achieved by using as a cold source for the From 2000 till 2007 the nuclear inductive Brayton cycle the incoming cryogenic concept went through a slow maturation propellant. Variants of this concept included process during which the inductive heating mixed chemical/ nuclear inductive of the supersonic exhaust plasma was propulsion to increase the thrust when proposed to be replaced by conductive necessary, to the detriment of the specific heating of the hydrogen in the subsonic area. impulse. This change removed all uncertainties and most potential inefficiencies due to the non- The nuclear inductive concept offered some well mastered plasma physical behaviour. advantages, such as a high expected specific impulse (930s) despite a moderate core A major goal of this evolution was also to temperature (hydrogen temperature at the reduce the engine dry mass; therefore the nuclear core exit of 2200K). It produced transmission of energy from the Brayton large thrust (64kN) at the highest Isp, while cycle to the hydrogen had to be simplified. offering the possibility to further multiply In this respect, an innovative device called the thrust level by a factor 3 at the expense turbo-inductor, which is the object of a of a large specific impulse decrease (480s). European patent has been described.[3] This Since the additional energy was introduced new device reshapes the whole engine in the supersonic zone of the exhaust flow architecture, whose name becomes now the where the flow is already cooling down, no NTER (Nuclear Thermal Electric Rocket) part of the engine had to sustain a engine.
Recommended publications
  • Back to the the Future? 07> Probing the Kuiper Belt
    SpaceFlight A British Interplanetary Society publication Volume 62 No.7 July 2020 £5.25 SPACE PLANES: back to the the future? 07> Probing the Kuiper Belt 634089 The man behind the ISS 770038 Remembering Dr Fred Singer 9 CONTENTS Features 16 Multiple stations pledge We look at a critical assessment of the way science is conducted at the International Space Station and finds it wanting. 18 The man behind the ISS 16 The Editor reflects on the life of recently Letter from the Editor deceased Jim Beggs, the NASA Administrator for whom the building of the ISS was his We are particularly pleased this supreme achievement. month to have two features which cover the spectrum of 22 Why don’t we just wing it? astronautical activities. Nick Spall Nick Spall FBIS examines the balance between gives us his critical assessment of winged lifting vehicles and semi-ballistic both winged and blunt-body re-entry vehicles for human space capsules, arguing that the former have been flight and Alan Stern reports on his grossly overlooked. research at the very edge of the 26 Parallels with Apollo 18 connected solar system – the Kuiper Belt. David Baker looks beyond the initial return to the We think of the internet and Moon by astronauts and examines the plan for a how it helps us communicate and sustained presence on the lunar surface. stay in touch, especially in these times of difficulty. But the fact that 28 Probing further in the Kuiper Belt in less than a lifetime we have Alan Stern provides another update on the gone from a tiny bleeping ball in pioneering work of New Horizons.
    [Show full text]
  • Development of Turbopump for LE-9 Engine
    Development of Turbopump for LE-9 Engine MIZUNO Tsutomu : P. E. Jp, Manager, Research & Engineering Development, Aero Engine, Space & Defense Business Area OGUCHI Hideo : Manager, Space Development Department, Aero Engine, Space & Defense Business Area NIIYAMA Kazuki : Ph. D., Manager, Space Development Department, Aero Engine, Space & Defense Business Area SHIMIYA Noriyuki : Space Development Department, Aero Engine, Space & Defense Business Area LE-9 is a new cryogenic booster engine with high performance, high reliability, and low cost, which is designed for H3 Rocket. It will be the first booster engine in the world with an expander bleed cycle. In the designing process, the performance requirements of the turbopump and other components can be concurrently evaluated by the mathematical model of the total engine system including evaluation with the simulated performance characteristic model of turbopump. This paper reports the design requirements of the LE-9 turbopump and their latest development status. Liquid oxygen 1. Introduction turbopump Liquid hydrogen The H3 rocket, intended to reduce cost and improve turbopump reliability with respect to the H-II A/B rockets currently in operation, is under development toward the launch of the first H3 test rocket in FY 2020. In rocket development, engine is an important factor determining reliability, cost, and performance, and as a new engine for the H3 rocket first stage, an LE-9 engine(1) is under development. A rocket engine uses a turbopump to raise the pressure of low-pressure propellant supplied from a tank, injects the pressurized propellant through an injector into a combustion chamber to combust it under high-temperature and high- pressure conditions.
    [Show full text]
  • MULTIPHYSICS DESIGN and SIMULATION of a TUNGSTEN-CERMET NUCLEAR THERMAL ROCKET a Thesis by BRAD APPEL Submitted to the Office O
    MULTIPHYSICS DESIGN AND SIMULATION OF A TUNGSTEN-CERMET NUCLEAR THERMAL ROCKET A Thesis by BRAD APPEL Submitted to the Office of Graduate Studies of Texas A&M University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF SCIENCE August 2012 Major Subject: Nuclear Engineering Multiphysics Design and Simulation of a Tungsten-Cermet Nuclear Thermal Rocket Copyright 2012 Brad Appel ii MULTIPHYSICS DESIGN AND SIMULATION OF A TUNGSTEN-CERMET NUCLEAR THERMAL ROCKET A Thesis by BRAD APPEL Submitted to the Office of Graduate Studies of Texas A&M University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF SCIENCE Approved by: Chair of Committee, Karen Vierow Committee Members, Shannon Bragg-Sitton Paul Cizmas Head of Department, Yassin Hassan August 2012 Major Subject: Nuclear Engineering iii iii ABSTRACT Multiphysics Design and Simulation of a Tungsten-Cermet Nuclear Thermal Rocket. (August 2012) Brad Appel, B.S., Purdue University Chair of Advisory Committee: Dr. Karen Vierow The goal of this research is to apply modern methods of analysis to the design of a tungsten-cermet Nuclear Thermal Rocket (NTR) core. An NTR is one of the most viable propulsion options for enabling piloted deep-space exploration. Concerns over fuel safety have sparked interest in an NTR core based on tungsten-cermet fuel. This work investigates the capability of modern CFD and neutronics codes to design a cermet NTR, and makes specific recommendations for the configuration of channels in the core. First, the best CFD practices available from the commercial package Star-CCM+ are determined by comparing different modeling options with a hot-hydrogen flow experiment.
    [Show full text]
  • Combustion Tap-Off Cycle
    College of Engineering Honors Program 12-10-2016 Combustion Tap-Off Cycle Nicole Shriver Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://commons.erau.edu/pr-honors-coe Part of the Aeronautical Vehicles Commons, Other Aerospace Engineering Commons, Propulsion and Power Commons, and the Space Vehicles Commons Scholarly Commons Citation Shriver, N. (2016). Combustion Tap-Off Cycle. , (). Retrieved from https://commons.erau.edu/pr-honors- coe/6 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Honors Program at Scholarly Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in College of Engineering by an authorized administrator of Scholarly Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Honors Directed Study: Combustion Tap-Off Cycle Date of Submission: December 10, 2016 by Nicole Shriver [email protected] Submitted to Dr. Michael Fabian Department of Aerospace Engineering College of Engineering In Partial Fulfillment Of the Requirements Of Honors Directed Study Fall 2016 1 1.0 INTRODUCTION The combustion tap-off cycle is also known as the “topping cycle” or “chamber bleed cycle.” It is an open liquid bipropellant cycle, usually of liquid hydrogen and liquid oxygen, that combines the fuel and oxidizer in the main combustion chamber. Gases from the edges of the combustion chamber are used to power the engine’s turbine and are expelled as exhaust. Figure 1.1 below shows a picture representation of the cycle. Figure 1.1: Combustion Tap-Off Cycle The combustion tap-off cycle is rather unconventional for rocket engines as it has only been put into practice with two engines.
    [Show full text]
  • Materials for Liquid Propulsion Systems
    https://ntrs.nasa.gov/search.jsp?R=20160008869 2019-08-29T17:47:59+00:00Z CHAPTER 12 Materials for Liquid Propulsion Systems John A. Halchak Consultant, Los Angeles, California James L. Cannon NASA Marshall Space Flight Center, Huntsville, Alabama Corey Brown Aerojet-Rocketdyne, West Palm Beach, Florida 12.1 Introduction Earth to orbit launch vehicles are propelled by rocket engines and motors, both liquid and solid. This chapter will discuss liquid engines. The heart of a launch vehicle is its engine. The remainder of the vehicle (with the notable exceptions of the payload and guidance system) is an aero structure to support the propellant tanks which provide the fuel and oxidizer to feed the engine or engines. The basic principle behind a rocket engine is straightforward. The engine is a means to convert potential thermochemical energy of one or more propellants into exhaust jet kinetic energy. Fuel and oxidizer are burned in a combustion chamber where they create hot gases under high pressure. These hot gases are allowed to expand through a nozzle. The molecules of hot gas are first constricted by the throat of the nozzle (de-Laval nozzle) which forces them to accelerate; then as the nozzle flares outwards, they expand and further accelerate. It is the mass of the combustion gases times their velocity, reacting against the walls of the combustion chamber and nozzle, which produce thrust according to Newton’s third law: for every action there is an equal and opposite reaction. [1] Solid rocket motors are cheaper to manufacture and offer good values for their cost.
    [Show full text]
  • 600 Technology (Applied Sciences)
    600 600 Technology (Applied sciences) Class here inventions See also 303.48 for technology as a cause of cultural change; also 306.4 for sociology of technology; also 338.1–338.4 for economic aspects of industries based on specific technologies; also 338.9 for technology transfer, appropriate technology See Manual at 300 vs. 600; also at 363 vs. 302–307, 333.7, 570–590, 600; also at 363.1 vs. 600; also at 583–585 vs. 600 SUMMARY 601–609 Standard subdivisions and technical drawing, hazardous materials technology, patents 610 Medicine and health 620 Engineering and allied operations 630 Agriculture and related technologies 640 Home and family management 650 Management and auxiliary services 660 Chemical engineering and related technologies 670 Manufacturing 680 Manufacture of products for specific uses 690 Construction of buildings 601 Philosophy and theory 602 Miscellany Do not use for patents; class in 608 Class interdisciplinary works on trademarks and service marks in 929.9 Interdisciplinary collections of standards relocated to 389 .9 Commercial miscellany Class commercial miscellany of products and services used in individual and family living in 640.29; class commercial miscellany of manufactured products in 670.29; class interdisciplinary commercial miscellany in 381.029 603 Dictionaries, encyclopedias, concordances 604 Technical drawing, hazardous materials technology; groups of people 657 604 Dewey Decimal Classification 604 .2 Technical drawing Including arrangement and organization of drafting rooms, preservation and storage of drawings; specific drafting procedures and conventions (e.g., production illustration, dimensioning; lettering, titling; shades, shadows, projections); preparation and reading of copies Class here engineering graphics, mechanical drawing For architectural drawing, see 720.28.
    [Show full text]
  • Intrinsic Mechanical Properties of Zirconium Carbide Ceramics
    Scholars' Mine Masters Theses Student Theses and Dissertations Summer 2020 Intrinsic mechanical properties of zirconium carbide ceramics Nicole Mary Korklan Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarsmine.mst.edu/masters_theses Part of the Ceramic Materials Commons Department: Recommended Citation Korklan, Nicole Mary, "Intrinsic mechanical properties of zirconium carbide ceramics" (2020). Masters Theses. 7956. https://scholarsmine.mst.edu/masters_theses/7956 This thesis is brought to you by Scholars' Mine, a service of the Missouri S&T Library and Learning Resources. This work is protected by U. S. Copyright Law. Unauthorized use including reproduction for redistribution requires the permission of the copyright holder. For more information, please contact [email protected]. INTRINSIC MECHANICAL PROPERTIES OF ZIRCONIUM CARBIDE CERAMICS by NICOLE MARY KORKLAN A THESIS Presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School of the MISSOURI UNIVERSITY OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree MASTERS OF SCIENCE IN CERAMIC ENGINEERING 2020 Approved by: Gregory E. Hilmas, Advisor William G. Fahrenholtz Jeremy L. Watts iii PUBLICATION THESIS OPTION This thesis consists of the following manuscripts which have been or will be submitted for publication as follows. Paper I: Pages 17-30 entitled “Processing and Room Temperature Properties of Zirconium Carbide” has been submitted to the Journal of the American Ceramic Society and is in review. Paper II: Pages 31-43 entitled “Ultra High Temperature Strength of Zirconium Carbide” is being drafted for publication. iv ABSTRACT This research focuses on the processing and mechanical properties of zirconium carbide ceramics (ZrCx). The first goal of this project was to densify near stoichiometric (i.e., x as close to 1 as possible) and nominally phase pure ZrCx.
    [Show full text]
  • July/August 2004 Newsletter
    Environmental Defense Institute News on Environmental Health and Safety Issues ")··..--~~~~~~~~~-,-~~~~~~--"--~~~ I July/August 2004 Volume 15 Number 3 Idaho Cancer Rates Continue to Rise at Record Levels According to the Cancer Data Registry ofldaho Dr. Thomas Pigford which was commissioned by the US there is a steady increase in Idaho cancer rates from the District Court hearing the Hanford Downwinders suit, beginning of data collection through 2002 (the latest both showed that causation for the high rate of cancer in report issued by the Registry). The 2000 report notes an the Northern Idaho Panhandle and Health District 3 increase of 3 59 cancer cases in recent years. "This was (Lewiston area) can be attributed to Hanford emissions one. of the largest single-year increases in cancer following wind patterns up the Columbia and Snake incidence in the history of the Cancer Data Registry of River drainage canyons. Idaho. Cancer sites with notable increases from 1999 to The Hanford· Downwinder litigation won two 2000 were lung, melanoma (in-situ), oral cavity and significant legal wins; 1.) the US 9th District Court of pharynx cancer counts increased over 1999 levels. The Appeals overruled the 1998 Spokane District Court number ofin-situ melanoma cases is 65% higher than for ruling by Judge McDonald that previously rejected the any previous year. The prostate cancer incidence rate is claims of most of the plaintiffs, and remanded the case the highest it has been since the spike in prostate cancer back to District Court for trial, based on Plaintiffs rates in 1990-1993 due to prostate-specific antigen scientific briefs showing significantly more particulate screening.
    [Show full text]
  • PVD Material Listing
    P. O. Box 639 NL - 5550 AP Valkenswaard Tel: +31 (0)40 204 69 31 Fergutec Fax: +31 (0)40 201 39 81 E - mail: [email protected] PVD Material Listing Pure Metals Aluminum, Al Antimony, Sb Beryllium, Be Bismuth, Bi Boron, B Cadmium, Cd Calcium, Ca Carbon, C Cerium, Ce Chromium, Cr Cobalt, Co Copper, Cu Erbium, Er Gadolinium, Gd Gallium, Ga Germanium, Ge Gold, Au Hafnium, Hf Indium, In Iridium, Ir Iron, Fe Lanthanum, La Lead, Pb Magnesium, Mg Manganese, Mn Molybdenum, Mo Neodymium, Nd Nickel, Ni Niobium, Nb Osmium, Os Palladium, Pd Platinum, Pt Praseodymium, Pr Rhenium, Re Rhodium, Rh Ruthenium, Ru Samarium, Sm Selenium, Se Silicon, Si Silver, Ag Tantalum, Ta Fergutec b.v. P.O. Box 639, NL - 5550 AP Valkenswaard Heistraat 64, NL - 5554 ER Valkenswaard Bankaccount 45.80.36.714 ABN - AMRO Valkenswaard C.o.C. Eindhoven no. 17098554 VAT - ID NL8095.60.185.B01 The Standard Terms and Conditions, lodged at the Chamber of Commerce in Eindhoven, are applicable to all transactions. Tellurium, Te Terbium, Tb Tin, Sn Titanium, Ti Tungsten, W Vanadium, V Ytterbium, Yb Yttrium, Y Zinc, Zn Zirconium, Zr Precious Metals Gold Antimony, Au/Sb Gold Arsenic, Au/As Gold Boron, Au/B Gold Copper, Au/Cu Gold Germanium, Au/Ge Gold Nickel, Au/Ni Gold Nickel Indium, Au/Ni/In Gold Palladium, Au/Pd Gold Phosphorus, Au/P Gold Silicon, Au/Si Gold Silver Platinum, Au/Ag/Pt Gold Tantalum, Au/Ta Gold Tin, Au/Sn Gold Zinc, Au/Zn Palladium Lithium, Pd/Li Palladium Manganese, Pd/Mn Palladium Nickel, Pd/Ni Platinum Palladium, Pt/Pd Palladium Rhenium, Pd/Re Platinum Rhodium,
    [Show full text]
  • Nuclear Propulsion
    16 Nuclear Propulsion Claudio Bruno DIMA, University of Rome (La Sapienza), Roma Italy 1. Introduction Nuclear propulsion (NP) concepts go back to the very end of WW II. Scientists informed about the effects of the US atomic bomb thought of exploiting its energy release for applications like commercial electric power generation, but also rockets and space flight [Shepherd and Cleaver, 1948, 1949; Bussard and DeLauer, 1958]. However, space flight was still considered science fiction, and the military had to deal with more concrete things, like the Cold War. Thus, besides power generation, second stages of ICBM, submarine propulsion, long range and long duration airplanes and missiles became the focus of nuclear energy applications. It was the second-stage and airplane application that drove R&D in nuclear propulsion. With the advent of reliable ICBM (the Atlas missile) and lighter fission and thermonuclear warheads, a nuclear-powered second stage became no longer necessary. Airplane applications were found impractical: the Convair NB-36 required such a heavy lead shield for the crew that testing and operation were much restricted. Nuclear-powered missiles were easier to design, e.g., project PLUTO, but still far more complicated compared to conventional. The Soviets investigated airplanes and rockets powered by nuclear power as well, and discarded them too. The history of NP can be found in [Czysz and Bruno, 2009, Chapter 7; Lawrence, 2008; Lawrence et al, 1995; Gunn and Ehresman, 2003; Dewar, 2004] and will not be reported here. Basic technology is also discussed in the references above, in particular reactor design is in [Lawrence et al, 1995].
    [Show full text]
  • United States Patent (19) 11 Patent Number: 5,880,237 Howland Et Al
    USOO588O237A United States Patent (19) 11 Patent Number: 5,880,237 Howland et al. (45) Date of Patent: Mar. 9, 1999 54 PREPARATION AND UTILITY OF WATER- 4.885,345 12/1989 Fong. SOLUBLE POLYMERS HAVING PENDANT 5,071,933 12/1991 Muller et al.. DERIVATIZED AMIDE, ESTER OR ETHER 5,084.520 1/1992 Fong FUNCTIONALITIES AS CERAMICS 5,209,885 5/1993 Quadir et al.. 5,266.243 11/1993 Kneller et al.. DSPERSANTS AND BINDERS 5,358,911 10/1994 Moeggenborg et al.. 5,393,343 2/1995 Darwin et al.. 75 Inventors: Christopher P. Howland, St. Charles; 5,487,855 1/1996 Moeggenborg et al.. Kevin J. Moeggenborg. Naperville; 5,525,665 6/1996 Moeggenborg et al.. John D. Morris, Plainfield, all of Ill., 5,532,307 7/1996 Bogan. Peter E. Reed, Puyallup, Wash.; 5,567,353 10/1996 Bogan. Jiansheng Tang, Naperville, Ill., Jin-Shan Wang, Rochester, N.Y. FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS O5009232 A2 1/1993 Japan. 73 Assignee: Nalco Chemical Company, Naperville, 05070212 A2 3/1993 Japan. III. 05294712 A2 11/1993 Japan. 06072759 A2 3/1994 Japan. 06313004 A2 11/1994 Japan. 21 Appl. No.: 982,590 07010943 A2 1/1995 Japan. 22 Filed: Dec. 4, 1997 07101778 A2 4/1995 Japan. 07133160 A2 5/1995 Japan. Related U.S. Application Data 07144970 A2 6/1995 Japan. Primary Examiner-Paul R. Michl 63 Continuation-in-part of Ser. No. 792,610, Jan. 31, 1997, Pat. Attorney, Agent, or Firm Elaine M. Ramesh; Thomas M. No. 5,726.267. Breininger (51) Int. Cl.
    [Show full text]
  • High-Temperature Mechanical Properties of Polycrystalline Hafnium Carbide and Hafnium Carbide Containing 13-Volume-Percent Hafnium Diboride Nasa Tn D-5008
    d HIGH-TEMPERATURE MECHANICAL PROPERTIES OF POLYCRYSTALLINE HAFNIUM CARBIDE AND HAFNIUM CARBIDE CONTAINING 13-VOLUME-PERCENT HAFNIUM DIBORIDE NASA TN D-5008 HIGH-TEMPERATURE MECHANICAL PROPERTIES OF POLYCRYSTALLINE HAFNIUM CARBIDE AND HAFNIUM CARBIDE CONTAINING 13-VOLUME- PERCENT HAFNIUM DIBORIDE By William A. Sanders and Hubert B. Probst Lewis Research Center Cleveland, Ohio NATIONAL AERONAUTICS AND SPACE ADMINISTRATION ~ For sale by the Clearinghouse for Federal Scientific and Technical Information Springfield, Virginia 22151 - CFSTl price $3.00 ABSTRACT Hot-pressed, single-phase HfC and HfC containing 13-vol % HfB2 were tested in three-point transverse rupture to temperatures as high as 4755' F (2625' C). Hot hard- ness tests were also run to 3200' F (1760' C). Separate effects on the transverse rup- ture behavior of HfC due to the HfB2 second phase and due to a grain- size difference are discussed on the basis of strength, deformation, and metallographic results. The probable mechanisms responsible for deformation are also discussed. In hot-hardness tests of HfC containing 13 vol % HfB2 second phase, a change in the temperature de- pendency of hot hardness at 2600' F (1425' C) is discussed and related to the degree of cracking around indentations. ii H I G H -TEM PERATURE MEC HANICAL PRO PE RTlES OF POLY C RY STALLINE HAFNIUM CARBIDE AND HAFNIUM CARBIDE CONTAINING 13 -VOLUME -PERCENT HAFN IUM D1 BOR I DE by William A. Sanders and Hubert 9. Probst Lewis Research Center SUMMARY Transverse rupture tests were conducted on single -phase hafnium carbide and hafnium carbide containing 13- volume- percent hafnium diboride as a distinct second phase.
    [Show full text]