On from Russia with Love
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
On From Russia With Love ANDY WRIGHT In the novel From Russia With Love (1957), SMERSH agent Kronsteen’s plan (to bait the British secret service !ith the Spektor #ecoding machine an# to entrap %ames Bon# in a political se& scan#al that !ill r'in both his an# his servi e’s rep( 'tation) is !holl) #epen#ent 'pon one prin iple: the conceit of the English, Kro( nsteen !ages (correctl)) that as long as the British secret service vie!s the plot as an eccentri challenge, the) are li"el) to take the bait - in spite of it being lear +rom the beginning that it is Soviet trap, .ith so $'ch at ris", in l'#ing the rep( 'tations of both British an# R'ssian secret services, as !ell as Britain’s stat's as a major s'perpo!er, Kronsteen’s plan, !hich, in ef+ect, calls +or both British an# R'ssian secret services to #issi$'late all "no!ledge of the political plo) in the +irst place, invokes the #eadlock of the historical 0ol# .ar aroun# !hich 1lem( ing set his stor), an# in !hich both .estern an# Soviet po!ers +o'ght a sort of closeted !ar against one another, Kronsteen’s plan is predicated on the #octrine of M't'all) Assured 3e( str'ction, the logi of !hich #'ring the 0ol# .ar prevented either the Soviets or the .est +rom laun hing a militar) of+ensive against the other +or +ear of their opponent emplo)ing the same +orce. It !as in the interests of neither si#e to pre( ipitate their o!n annihilation b) mounting an attack on their opposing n'mber, 4he logi of M't'al Assured 3estr'ction !as consi#ered to be a per+ect strategy of maintaining or#er, as both si#es 'n#erstood that i+ one !ere to la'nch against the other, there !o'l# be +'ll an# irrational retaliation 567789:;7<8=>>?@8ABACAB?DE Andy Wright is an independent James Bond scholar. Vol. 1, Issue 2 · Spring 2018 ISSN 2514-2178 DOI: 10.24877/jbs.32 Distributed under CC BY 4.0 UK In this !a), a tentative peace !as maintained, Ho!ever, the +la! of the MAD strategy is that, in acting Frationall),G the aggressor, or !homsoever laun hes the +irst attac", assumes that their enem) !ill si#e !ith reason an# !ill +orego $'t'al #estr' tion b) re+raining +rom retaliation, 4hat is logical, !hereas $'t'all) as( s'red #estr' tion is based on the ver) illogicalit) of t!o opposing si#es mount( ing the same #estr'ctive attack against one another, 1or this reason, neither So( viet nor .estern +orces ris"ed even conventional !ar+are, +or +ear of of+ering the opposing si#e a FrationalG ca'se to stri"e +irst, Ho!ever, it is the F+la!G of this strategy that made the logi behin# the #octrine of M't'all) Assured 3estr' ( tion so ef+ective. Kronsteen’s plan to h'miliate the English an# to #estro) their secret ser( vice, itsel+ another Fper+ectG plot, the logi an# success of !hich #ictates that nei( ther Britain nor R'ssia provoke the other into an) open con+lict, shares the same +la! as the MAD #octrine. 0onsi#er, +or a moment, Bon#’s s'ccessf'l attainment of the Spektor, 1rom the R'ssian’s perspective, Bon#’s successf'l capt're of the Spektor is encoded into an# accommodated +or in their plan (an# in the plot of the novel)H the R'ssian plan to h'$iliate Bon# an# to bring #o!n the British se( cret service onl) s'cceeds i+ Bon# himsel+ thin"s he has succeeded in stealing a!a) the #ecoding $achine. 4he R'ssians inten# to 'se this theft an# Bon#’s se&'al #alliance !ith the SMERSH )pher ler", 4atiana Romanova, !hich the) !ill secretl) +ilm, as a means of embarrassing Bon# an#, 'lti$atel), #estabilising Britain’s secret service. 4h's, in or#er +or the R'ssian’s plan of entrapment to s'cceed, Bon#’s success, or at least the ill'sion of his o!n success, is necessar) to bring about Britain’s #efeatH it is Bon#’s success that !ill, !ithin Kronsteen’s plan, result 'ltimatel) in both his #eath an# the #estr'ction of his secret service. B) embarrassing Bon# an# his s'periors, British intelligence !ill be h'miliated in the national media, an# the R'ssians !ill have ensured that global con+i#ence in Britain’s ef+i ien ) !ill have #iminished, In ef+ect, Kronsteen’s plan is inten#ed to cripple Britain’s secret service !itho't R'ssia ever having p'blicl) $oved against it, Ho!ever, on the other han#, +rom the point of vie! of the British, the su ( cess of Bon#’s mission is predicated on ho! ef+ectivel) Bon# is able to navigate the evi#ent perils of the Soviet’s trap in or#er to make of+ !ith the Spektor #e( coding machine. 4hat Bon# is able to s'ccessf'll) +oil the R'ssian’s plot to en( trap hi$ (or, at least, extricate himsel+, the Spektor, an# 4atiana +rom the +ra) at precisel) the right moment) s'ggests, i#eologicall), that the reader is supposed to celebrate Bon#’s cra+t) #efeat of the Soviet’s plans, an#, moreover, that Britain is 'ltimatel) $'ch better placed than R'ssia to engage in the "in# of 0ol# .ar 2 International Journal of James Bond Studies · Vol. 1, Issue 2 · Spring 2018 espionage !hich the novel portra)s. 1'rthermore, Bon#’s 'ltimate success in the novel can also be seen as a some!hat politicall) i$possible one: in evading h'( $iliation an# #eath at the han#s of the R'ssians !hilst managing to successf'll) appropriate the Spektor #ecoding machine, 1leming has positioned Bon# not onl) as an ef+ective i#eological )pher, !ho alone has #ealt a ret'rn blo! to the R'ssians, b't as one !ho ef+ectivel) breaks o't of an# evades the logical #ead( lock of the strategy of M't'all) Assured 3estr'ction, Bon# r'pt'res a major ar$ of the R'ssian’s plans, b't he #oes so !hile maintaining the silence of the 0ol# .ar bet!een East an# .est, R'ssia cannot p'blicl) attack either Bon# or the British secret service, +or to #o so !oul# req'ire them to openl) ac"no!ledge their o!n +ail're in this enterprise. .ere Bon#’s acts of co'nter-espionage part of an open hostilit) bet!een Britain an# R'ssia, the Soviets ma) !ell have 'sed the theft of the Spektor as a premise +or mo'nting a strategi of+ense against their ene$), Ho!ever, because of the tentative logi of the MAD #eadlock, in !hich neither si#e !ishes to of+er their opponent a reasonable premise to attack, the R'ssians are +orced to I'ietl) sustain their #efeat at the han#s of Bon# an# the British, 4his is the catastrophi break in Kronsteen’s logi * after sustaining an act'al loss, the R'ssians $'st react rationall) an# accept their #efeat !ithout re( taliating in t'rn, +or +ear of being sho!n to be either a political aggressor or as an impotent pa!n in the game of global espionage. Bon# manages to out!it Kron( steen’s logi b) engaging the t!o superpo!ers in an act of !ar, b't one in !hich an) act of irrational retaliation is ren#ere# impossible. 3'e to the lan#estine nat're of the 0ol# .ar in From Russia With Love, in !hich it is in the interests of both the British an# the R'ssians to #eclai$ in( volvement in an) "in# of espionage, the onl) real threat, then, is to Bon#’s #ig( nit), .ere Kronsteen’s plan to succeed, an# !ere SMERSH to release the secret +ootage of Bon# an# 4atiana in bed together, Britain’s h'miliation !o'l# be re( #'ced to a tabooed se&'al #Jtente bet!een their agent an# a misused Soviet )pher cler"H there is nothing the British secret service co'l# #o bar accept their embarrassment an# clai$ their #ead sp), In this instance, the onl) !a) to ab( solve the g'ilt of one’s co'ntr)’s actions !o'l# be to of+er 'p one’s embarrass( ment - one’s #ead agent - an# to #ecr) his actions as transgressive. Ho!ever, some!hat ironicall) perhaps, the transference of an entire secret service’s g'ilt onto a single sp) (in this case, %ames Bon#) s'ggests, onversel), not the 'ltimate cessation of British espionage b't rather the p'bli sacri+ice necessar) in or#er to ens're the contin'ed s'rvival of British Intelligence. In other !or#s, Bon#’s +ail're in this $ission !o'l# necessaril) be labeled b) his o!n government as A. Wright · On From Russia With Love 3 transgressive, an# Bon# himsel+ !oul# be bran#ed as someone !ho has trans( gressed the +ragile bo'n#s of 0ol# .ar East(.est relations. In this instance, Bon# !oul# become the sacri+i ial lamb to Britain’s contin'ed engagement in 0ol# .ar politics. It is +or precisel) this reason that that the onl) thing on the line in From Russia With Love is Bon#’s #ignit)* !hether Bon# s'cceeds or +ails, the British se( cret service !ill prevail, Bon#’s rep'tation is the onl) thing that is act'all) at stake in the novel (F1rom R'ssia !ith LoveG LM1N), 4his ma"es the !hole li+e of a sp) as 1leming sees it a tr'e sadist’s game.