DOCSLIB.ORG

COMPARISON of PARENTAL CONTROL TOOLS Resource for Parents and Educators ! Criteria Used for the Evaluation

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
COMPARISON of PARENTAL CONTROL TOOLS Resource for Parents and Educators ! Criteria Used for the Evaluation COMPARISON OF PARENTAL CONTROL TOOLS Resource for parents and educators ! Criteria used for the evaluation Usability • Installation and configuration procedures should be kept simple and explained in plain language. • The software should: - be easy to learn, - follow consistent concepts, - conform with user expectations about how it works, have an appealing design, - provide a good overview on all features. • Blocking • Dialogue with the user should be easy to understand and when directed at children should use child sensitive language. ! Effectiveness • Most tools are usually not very effective in filtering harmful web content. In any case, adult content is not the only threat to children. It is important that such tools also be much more effective with regard to content about violence, racism, self-harm, and, also on user generated content (social networks, blogs, forums, etc.). • Although not distributed anymore, the AOL filtering tool was satisfactorily effective. Thus, it may serve as a best practice example for other software producers. • The database containing the black list should be updated at least with every update of the tool. ! Functionality • After the installation process is completed, default filtering should be in operation even when the user did not perform or finish a configuration. should be transparent to users. • If the creation of user profiles within the filtering tool is linked with the Windows user profile system, parents should be clearly warned (with an alert in a pop-up window or similar) about the need to set-up a separate Windows profile and make the admin account password protected. Even better, if there is only one Windows profile, the parent should be guided in the creation of the other profiles". • Tools should clearly indicate what kind of filtering is performed on social networks. Is the access to Facebook or similar websites blocked? Is the content filtered? Are interactions with other users filtered or blocked? • It should be possible, by default or as an option, to force the child/teenager to search the web using the safe mode of the three main search engines (Google Safe Search, Bing Safe Search or Yahoo! Safe Search). • When a page is blocked, the child/teenager should be able to ask the parent to override the blocking when they feel that the blocked content is not harmful. • Blocking applications: To keep it simple, parents should be provided with a list of applications installed on the computer, for example, in the Windows control panel, instead of having to locate the .exe file on the hard disk. • Blocking personal data (name, address, phone number) being provided by the child/teenager should be implemented in all tools such as MSN and Skype, and also work on websites (blogs, Facebook, webmail). • Very often, blocking categories are based on blocking content in the workplace (i.e. “sports”, “finance”, etc.). Tool providers should consider youth needs when creating the databases for black lists and white lists and provide explanations on what these refer to (to make it more transparent for parents). • The reporting of the online activities of the child/teenager and the blocked content should be simple, concise, and provide the essential pertinent information. Sometimes, information provided appears to be designed for business use and not for home or private users. ! ! !1 ! ! • Communication between children and parents is the most important issue in youth protection, therefore, the child should always be aware of the monitoring of his/her online activities. ! Security • Harmful content should not be accessible through Google Cache or Google Translator. • Creation of a password for administration (and uninstallation) should be compulsory. • The tools should work and be compatible with the most popular browsers, or, alternatively, block the download and installation of other browsers. • The tools should be resistant to some simple hacking or by-passing actions: - Uninstalling the software without a password, - Changing date and time of the computer to override time limits of Internet usage, - Renaming a blocked application, - Closing the software through the Task Manager. ! Note: All scores are the averages of ratings for different age groups from the European Commission Benchmarking of Parental Control Tools SIP-Bench III for all age groups, apart from Netfilter and Qustodio Parental Control 2015 which are estimates set out by Interaxion. !2 Qustodio Parental Control 2015 Description: Impressive parental control system includes almost everything parents could want. Children’s online activity is tracked across multiple devices. Configuration and monitoring can be handled remotely while parents receive email notifications of breaches of conduct. Sites associated with 29 different categories can be blocked while real-time analysis evaluates uncategorised websites upon access. The browser-independent filter effectively deals with secure proxies by blocking access and even filtering any traffic through them. Safe Search is forced on major search engines. Time scheduler limits Internet use for each child, as well as device use and use of apps. Social networking activity is cleverly monitored through an Evaluation* app that the child must install to access the sites, which tracks the child’s posts, pictures and comments on various Overall Evaluation 2,8 sites, although only the identity of friends talked to is Functionality 3,5 reported and not the content of these chats. The Android Effectiveness 2,8 version boasts impressive features like location tracking, call blocking and a panic button. Parents can opt to Usability 3,0 receive daily or weekly reports on their child’s online Security 4,0 activity which breaks it down by categories. * All scores are out of a maximum of 4 Qustodio is among the very best in the market and so only suffers from a few weaknesses. Firstly, the iOS support is very limited in scope. It can filter content and enforce Safe Technical information Search but only if the Qustodio browser is used by the Devices PC/ Mac/ Mobile devices (incl. Kindle) child. There is no tracking of usage, including that of Operating Windows/ Android/ iOS particular apps, which is a serious weak point in. the iOS Systems version. There is no monitoring of games played either on Price (yearly) €35 (5 accounts on 5 devices) the Internet or using Internet connectivity, unlike some Web Address http://www.qustodio.com other systems. Users have also indicated problems with restricting offline time on the computer, dealing with Language 5 majr European languages (English, Spanish, French, Italian and customer support and their computer speed after Portuguese) downloading Qustodio. Qustodio Parental Control 2015 is a pcmag.com Editor’s Choice for parental control. !3 PureSight Owl Description: PureSight is similar to other internet filter software as it boasts basic parental control features like content filtering and Internet scheduling. However, PureSight also addresses the serious topic of cyberbullying on IM and can terminate the conversation, block the perpetrator, and notify parents if necessary. Protection is offered across multiple devices. PureSight also uses artificial intelligence technology to ensure that nothing is missed, as it recognises dangerous sites that are too new to be tagged as such. The parent portal allows parents remote access to information about their children’s online lives and enables them to set rules for Internet use. Evaluation* In spite of its many positive aspects, there are some issues with this system. The online parental control system is Overall Evaluation 2,7 slow to use in comparison with other alternatives. Functionality 3,4 PureSight fails to provide any substantial management of Effectiveness 2,2 social networking which undermines its anti-cyberbullying features. Like the majority of other systems out there, Usability 3,1 PureSight’s site blocking process is weakened by being Security 4,0 unable to prevent evasion through browsing via a secure * All scores are out of a maximum of 4 proxy. The price may not be exorbitant (at €35 per year for protection across 3 devices) but free alternatives offer similar levels of protection without the cost. This system is only available in English and Spanish. Technical information Devices PC/ Mac/ Smartphones and tablets For the fourth year in a row, PureSight ranks highest in the Operating Windows/ Android European Commission Benchmarking of Parental Control Systems Tools SIP-Bench III for all age groups. Price (yearly) €35 (Varies depending on number of devices. Annual and monthly rates) Web Address http://www.puresight.com Language English/ Spanish !4 Norton Online Family Description: An excellent parental control system that emphasises communication over control. Parents configure the “House Rules” online which are then available to view for the children. They can block sites or simply warn their children when accessing them, while children are told to log off once they reach a time limit rather than being forced off. These measures may prove more fruitful in teaching good online behaviour to children, as they are kept involved in the process. The scheduler places limits on computer use. Effective IM monitoring effective allows for both the monitoring of conversations and blocking of friends. Visits to social networking sites are tracked and parents are notified if the child signs up for a Evaluation* new account, submits a false age or posts personal information. “Safe Search” can also be enabled. This set- Overall Evaluation 2,5 up is ideal for a multi-computer household as parents can Functionality 1,8 manage configuration and view reports/ notifications Effectiveness 2,1 remotely. Best of all, it’s free! Usability 3,1 The only problems are quite minor ones. Email notifications Security 4,0 about incidents don’t link to the event in question in the * All scores are out of a maximum of 4 log but instead bring you back to the programme’s homepage. The system doesn’t possess the real-time analysis that quickly evaluates uncategorised sites upon access, although the sites are queried for evaluation and Technical information possible manual review in the future.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Parental Controls 1
    Parental Controls 1 Begin as you mean to go. You can introduce parental software controls to a younger child with more ease than to a teenager. Getting your child used to the idea that the tablet goes off, the video goes off, the TV goes off at certain times is extremely attractive. And with parental control software, you can do just that. Parental controls are usually included in most devices, such as your computer, tablet and smartphone. You need to dive into those settings and dig around to see what features are available to you. If you are based in Europe, the European Commission maintains a website called SipBench.eu which provides benchmarking analysis of parental control software. The findings are available in several European languages and identify the prices, technical requirements, operating system and age of the children to be protected. It is a handy background resource to get you started with parental controls. If you know of other parental control software tools that should be added to this list, please write to me at [email protected] so I can investigate and incorporate them into this resource sheet. Thank you for being a part of our Digital Parenting Community. www.digitalparentingcoach.com 2 Before signing up for parental control software • Read this article from Common Sense Media to help you make sense of the different types of parental control systems. • Confirm that your parental control software will allow you, at the very least, to set screen limits, filter content, block ads, and monitor your child’s online activities.
    [Show full text]
  • Contentprotect User Guide
    ContentProtect Professional Suite Administrator’s Guide © 2009 ContentWatch, Inc. All rights reserved. 2369 West Orton Circle, Salt Lake City, UT 84119 Legal Notices ContentWatch, Inc. makes no representations or warranties with respect to the contents or use of this documentation, and specifically disclaims any express or implied warranties of merchantability or fitness for any particular purpose. Further, ContentWatch, Inc. reserves the right to revise this publication and to make changes to its content, at any time, without obligation to notify any person or entity of such revisions or changes. Further, ContentWatch, Inc. makes no representations or warranties with respect to any software, and specifically disclaims any express or implied warranties of merchantability or fitness for any particular purpose. Further, ContentWatch, Inc. reserves the right to make changes to any and all parts of ContentWatch software, at any time, without any obligation to notify any person or entity of such changes. You may not use, export, or re-export this product in violation of any applicable laws or regulations including, without limitation, U.S. export regulations or the laws of the country in which you reside. Copyright © 2002-2009 ContentWatch, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, photocopied, stored on a retrieval system, or transmitted without the express written consent of the publisher. ContentWatch, Inc. 2369 West Orton Circle Salt Lake City, Utah 84119 U.S.A. www.contentwatch.com ContentWatch Trademarks ContentWatch is a trademark of ContentWatch, Inc. in the United States and other countries. ContentProtect is a trademark of ContentWatch, Inc. in the United States and other countries.
    [Show full text]
  • INTERNET SAFETY PARENT RESOURCES GENERAL RESOURCES • Family Online Safety Institute (FOSI): • Pew Research Center
    INTERNET SAFETY PARENT RESOURCES GENERAL RESOURCES • Family Online Safety Institute (FOSI): https://www.fosi.org • Pew Research Center: http://www.pewinternet.org/ PARENTING • "Parenting in the Digital Age: How Parents Weigh the Potential Benefits and Harms of Their Children's Technology Use" https://www.fosi.org/policy-research/parenting- digital-age/ • Parents and Social Media (PEW Research Center): http://www.pewinternet.org/files/2015/07/Parents-and-Social-Media-FIN-DRAFT- 071515.pdf • Screen time contracts: http://www.screenagersmovie.com/contracts-1/ Common Sense Media – dedicated to supporting parents, kids and families in a world of technology and media: https://www.commonsensemedia.org/parent-concerns CYBERBULLYING • Cyberbullying Research Center: http://www.cyberbullying.org • Stomp Out Bullying: http://www.stompoutbullying.org • A Brave Heart: The Lizzie Velasquez story (documentary about a young woman’s empowering response to horrific cyberbullying): http://imwithlizzie.com/ TEENS • Teens, Social Media and Technology (PEW Research Center): http://www.pewinternet.org/2015/04/09/teens-social-media-technology-2015/ • Tip sheet for parents on popular apps: https://www.fosi.org/good-digital- parenting/app-tip-sheets/ • ‘Screenagers’ movie website with information and resources: http://www.screenagersmovie.com/ TECHNOLOGY CONTRACTS • Guide for developing a screen time contract with your teen: https://www.screenagersmovie.com/family-contract • Sample contract: https://cyberbullying.org/technology-use-contract-2014.pdf 1 SOCIAL MEDIA ‘CLEAN UP’ APPS These apps scan your social media accounts to identify potentially inappropriate post content that could reflect poorly to potential employers, friends, schools, etc. The user reviews flagged content and decides whether or not to edit or delete the content.
    [Show full text]
  • Net Nanny User Guide (PDF Format) Is Available from the Net Nanny Help Menu
    Net Nanny 6.5 User Guide © 2013 ContentWatch, Inc. All rights reserved. 6949 High Tech Drive, Midvale, UT 84047 Legal Notices ContentWatch, Inc. makes no representations or warranties with respect to the contents or use of this documentation, and specifically disclaims any express or implied warranties of merchantability or fitness for any particular purpose. Further, ContentWatch, Inc. reserves the right to revise this publication and to make changes to its content, at any time, without obligation to notify any person or entity of such revisions or changes. Further, ContentWatch, Inc. makes no representations or warranties with respect to any software, and specifically disclaims any express or implied warranties of merchantability or fitness for any particular purpose. Further, ContentWatch, Inc. reserves the right to make changes to any and all parts of ContentWatch software, at any time, without any obligation to notify any person or entity of such changes. You may not use, export, or re-export this product in violation of any applicable laws or regulations including, without limitation, U.S. export regulations or the laws of the country in which you reside. Copyright © 2005-2013 ContentWatch, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, photocopied, stored on a retrieval system, or transmitted without the express written consent of the publisher. U.S. Patent No. 745,591. Patents Pending. Net Nanny User Guide July 2013 ContentWatch, Inc. / Net Nanny User Guide Page 2 ContentWatch Trademarks ContentProtect is a trademark of ContentWatch, Inc. in the United States and other countries. ContentProtect Professional is a trademark of ContentWatch, Inc.
    [Show full text]
  • A Family Guide to Cybersafety by Mark Seguin
    A Family Guide to CyberSafety By Mark Seguin No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and retrieval systems, except as permitted under Section 107 or 108 of the 1976 United States Copyright Act, without the prior written permission of the Publisher. Requests to the Publisher for permission should be addressed to Permissions Department, TBG Solutions, Inc. PO Box 8421, Tyler, Texas 75711 (903) 533-9123, fax (903) 533-0088. TABLE OF CONTENTS Safer Social Networking ................................................................................................................................................................................................... 2 Tips for Parents ........................................................................................................................................................................................................... 3 Tips for Your Kids & Teens ......................................................................................................................................................................................... 4 Cyberbullying .................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 6 Tips for Parents ..........................................................................................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Net Nanny for Mac Manual US
    Net Nanny for Mac User's Manual Net Nanny for Mac User's Manual Page 1 Net Nanny for Macintosh ©2001 - 2008 . All Rights Reserved Net Nanny www.netnanny.com is manual was written for use with Net Nanny software for Macintosh. is manual and the Net Nanny software described in it are copyrighted, with all rights reserved. is manual and the Net Nanny software may not be copied, except as otherwise provided in your software license or as expressly permitted in writing by ContentWatch e Software is owned by ContentWatch, and its structure, organization and code are the valuable trade secrets of ContentWatch, and its suppliers. e Software is protected by United States Copyright Law and International Treaty provisions. Net Nanny for Mac User's Manual Page 2 Contents 1- About Net Nanny for Mac.............................................................................................. 5 What is Net Nanny for Mac?....................................................................................................... 6 Net Nanny's Features................................................................................................................... 7 2 - Filtering Internet Content............................................................................................. 9 A Brave New World................................................................................................................... 10 Types of Internet Content.........................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Stealth Apps & Programs
    Stealth Apps & Programs 1234 This list has been developed for the sole purpose of providing information to parent groups and educators to monitor online information relating to their CHILDREN… this is not intended to promote use for adults and/or spouses. Keep in mind that the feds recently passed a law regarding downloading programs on phones to spy or keep track of adults. It is a federal crime without the other person’s consent. Consult with laws in your state regarding children as well. These are just recommendations and, as we all know can change without notice so do you own DUE DILIGENCE. You may want to consider advising your children as well since they are the authorized possessor of the devices. We DO NOT promote any of these apps, this is merely a resource. **NOTE** There are few FREE apps. Have parents read the fine print before they buy the apps… Most run around $50 annually. Most track location, texts, phone calls, emails, etc. **NOTE** Some of these require that the phone be JAILBROKEN so pay attention to what you are purchasing. #1 PhoneSheriff recommended By LE http://www.phonesheriff.com/ • Real Time GPS Tracking • Internet History • Monitoring Text Messages • Monitoring Call History • Monitoring Apps Installed • Monitoring Contacts and Calendar Activities • View Photo Logs • View Mobile Usage • Backup and Restore Phone Information in case Phone gets Lost or Stolen • Multiple Device Management • Restrict Calls, Text Messages and Internet Usage • Panic Alerts • Instant Alerts and Notifications Pricing: $49/6 months; $89/year NOTE: The iPhone, iPad and BlackBerry versions have been discontinued.
    [Show full text]
  • Internet Safety
    Utah Child Protection Registry Presents Internet Safety A GUIDE FOR PARENTS AND TEACHERS PRACTICAL TIPS TO KEEPING KIDS SAFE ONLINE TABLE OF CONTENTS Section 1: Children Need Supervision Section 2: Age Appropriate Tips Section 3: 5 Steps to Safety Section 4: Tips on Social Media Apps Section 5: Cell Phone Carrier Family Limits SECTION ONE CHILDREN NEED SUPERVISION THERE’S NO SUBSTITUTE FOR PARENTING As a parent or teacher would you allow a young child to go out into the world without supervision? Responsible parents and educators would answer, “No.” Today’s online world can be just as dangerous as sending a child into the streets without supervision. Children need to understand that there are dangers they could face beyond the keyboard. The information they post could pose a risk to their physical well-being and safety or impact future job opportunities. Teaching our children how to become a responsible digital citizen is important they need to know that you as their parent/teacher care and will supervise their activity to assure their safety. This E-booklet will give you tips on setting rules for online use, assist you in learning about popular social platforms and give you ideas on how to make your child's online experience as safe as possible. SECTION TWO Age Appropriate Tips Parents who discuss their family values and expectations for participating in the digital world are more likely to have children whose behavior online reflect their values. AGE APPROPRIATE TIPS 2 – 8 years old • Sit with your children and supervise them closely while on devices.
    [Show full text]
  • Internet Filtering & Monitoring
    Internet Filtering & Monitoring “Your ultimate goal is to raise kids who use the Internet safely and responsibly and think critically about their actions, but a little technical assistance can help. And, as your kids get older, you’ll need to dial down the restrictions to help them develop their own sense of responsibility. —Common Sense Media Monitors and Filters Are Useful, But They Shouldn’t Replace Relationships There’s no question that there’s a lot of filth on the Internet. And it’s pretty easy to run into it, even accidentally. Internet filters are extremely useful tools for preventing you and your children from encountering content that is harmful and disturbing. But in the same way that sending your kids to Christian school won’t automatically make them Christians, setting up an Internet filter won’t in and of itself keep them from online dangers. Why? For two reasons: 1. People on the other end of the Internet are constantly developing new ways to access new people (for various reasons); and 2. If our tech-savvy kids are determined, they will find ways around anything we implement. Because of that, we hope that parental controls are just one part of your overall strategy for protecting your children. Don’t view Internet filters as the safety net that will keep your kids safe. Instead, view them as your first line of defense. Your priority should be training your kids to think critically and discipling their hearts to want to pursue what is good and to hate what is evil. Because Internet filters are a good resource, we want to highlight what we think are some of the most helpful solutions currently available.
    [Show full text]
  • Parental Control Report 2014
    Parental Control Test & Review 2014 www.av-comparatives.org Parental Control 2014 Parental Control Software Test and Review Language: English Last Revision: 14th September 2014 www.av-comparatives.org - 1 - Parental Control Test & Review 2014 www.av-comparatives.org Contents Review and Test of Parental Control Software for Windows, iOS and Android .................................... 3 Introduction ....................................................................................................................... 3 The limitations of parental control software ............................................................................ 3 Review procedure ................................................................................................................ 6 Products reviewed and tested ................................................................................................ 8 Parental Control Test ........................................................................................................... 9 Test results ....................................................................................................................... 10 Summary of parental control products for Microsoft Windows ................................................... 12 Summary of parental control products for Apple iOS devices .................................................... 14 Summary of parental control products for Google Android devices ............................................ 14 Reviews of products for Microsoft Windows ..............................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Benchmarking of Parental Control Tools for the Online Protection of Children
    Benchmarking of parental control tools for the online protection of children FINAL REPORT A study prepared for the European Commission DG Communications Networks, Content & Technology by: Digital Single Market SIP-BENCH III - Benchmarking of parental control tools Final Report for the online protection of children This study was carried out for the European Commission by: INNOVA Srl (Italy) Ms. Antonella Vulcano [email protected] CYBION Srl (Italy) Ms. Rina Angeletti [email protected] Stiftung Digitale Chancen (Germany) Dr. Carola Croll [email protected] Internal identification Contract number: 30-CE-0528769/00-05 SMART number: 2012/0044 DISCLAIMER By the European Commission, Directorate-General of Communications Networks, Content & Technology. The information and views set out in this publication are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of the Commission. The Commission does not guarantee the accuracy of the data included in this study. Neither the Commission nor any person acting on the Commission’s behalf may be held responsible for the use which may be made of the information contained therein. ISBN 978-92-79-70499-4 doi:10.2759/80227 © European Union, 2017. All rights reserved. Certain parts are licensed under conditions to the EU. Reproduction is authorised provided the source is acknowledged. 2 SIP-BENCH III - Benchmarking of parental control tools Final Report for the online protection of children ABSTRACT Today, accessing the Internet has become an essential part of our daily lives. From an early age, children live in a digital environment and grow up using a wide range of interconnected devices for various activities (learning, entertainment, communication with family and friends, pastimes).
    [Show full text]
  • 10 Best Parental Control Apps of 2019
    10 Best Parental Control Apps of 2019 #1 Bark Parental Control App •Monitors 24 social networks •Featured on CNN, CBS News, and TechCrunch •Most coverage of any monitoring app •Automatic parental alerts •Algorithmic monitoring, parents don't have to comb through data •Only $9 a month •FREE 7 Day Trial #2 Qustodio Parental Control Apps •Available in English and Spanish •Tracks calls and texts •Blocks pornography •Time limit controls on selected games and apps •Location tracking and panic button #3 Norton Family Premier Parental Control App •Connect all devices to a single solution •Teach kids not to share personal info •Monitor web browsing and Facebook usage •PC Magazine Editor's Choice •Compatible with Android, Windows, and iOS #4 ESET Parental Control App •Filters access to websites •Automatically block age-inappropriate apps •Set daily time limits for apps •Monitor your child's device usage •Check where your children’s devices are at any time •Create zones that alert you if your child exits them •Send your child a priority message #5 Net Nanny Parental Control App •Available on Android, iOS, Windows, and Mac •Monitor your child's activities on many popular social networks •PcMag.com's Editors' Choice •The National Parenting Center's Seal of Approval •2014 Parenting Publications Gold Winner #6 Family Time Parental Control Apps •Scheduling and blocking services •"Time Bank" and "Fun Time" features •Geo-fencing alerts parents if kids leave safe zones •SOS/Panic button transmits child's location instantly •Speed Alert feature notifies
    [Show full text]