Conception: Reception
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
u tin 88 in Association of For information on advertising, membership and distribution contact: February Art Historians A AH Administrator, Claire Davies, 70 Cowcross Street, London EC1M 6EJ 2005 Registered Charity No. 282579 Tel: 020 7490 3211; Fax: 020 7490 3277; <[email protected]> Editor: Jannet King, 48 Stafford Road, Brighton BN1 5PF <[email protected]> www.aah.org.uk TH CHALLENGES FACING ART HISTORY by GEN DOY, MALCOLM GEE AND CHRIS BREWARD bout 40 people attended a joint meeting of the AAH schools members' group was read in her absence. A AAH and the DHS (Design History Society) in A wide range of teachers and researchers in art and November 2004 to consider the issue: 'Are we in Crisis? design history were represented, although it was noted Challenges in Teaching and Research in the New that the majority were from the 'new university' sector. Century7. The meeting was addressed by Jonathan The reason for this was probably that the issues facing Vickery (AAH and Warwick University), Chris Breward new universities as a result of the last RAE and falling (DHS and Victoria and Albert Museum), Barbara student numbers have yet to make an impact on art and Burman (DHS and Winchester), Fran Lloyd (AAH and design history provision in old universities, which have Kingston University). A paper from Carol Jacobi of the tended to do better in terms of money and student numbers. RESEARCH AND TEACHING THRIVING The meeting was stimulating and useful, raising a wide range of issues and proposing possible courses of action in response to the current situation. Overall the sense was that the disciplines are not in crisis - indeed in some respects they are thriving, for example in terms of the quality of research and teaching being carried out by our members. However, at times things looked pretty bleak. Barbara Burman from Winchester reported on course closures and redundancies in the area of design history (several have also closed in art and design history), and hoped that postgraduate provision would continue to thrive, thus ensuring the survival of the subject. Fran Lloyd from Kingston also felt that postgraduate numbers were holding up well, and that this was encouraging for the CD future. However, it was later apparent that both associations have to work hard, hopefully together, to • • ensure the survival and development of art, design and architectural history from school level upwards, and that postgraduate provision alone would not be enough, AAH ANNUAL CONFERENCE nor should it be. AS/A LEVEL NUMBERS CAUSE FOR CONCERN Conception: Reception One particularly concerning factor was that only around 1,000 students take the one existing AS/A2-level in Art History, and of these the great majority are from Bristol 31 March - 2 April 2005 independent schools. (There are only 200 people studying AS/A2-level Art History in the state school see page 21 sector.) Carol Jacobi analysed this depressing scenario: Art History is still perceived as a dilettante subject, AAH Executive Committee, Representatives and Staff Executive Committee Students AAH Representatives Outi Remes ELECTED OFFICERS (VOTING) History of Art Dept (non-voting) Chair University of Reading Treasurer Colin Cruise Blandford Lodge Peter Baitup School of Art and Design Whiteknights, PO Box 217 Temple Farmhouse Staffordshire University Reading RG6 6AH Chapel Street Flaxman Building Tel: 0790 093 7401 Broadwell College Road <[email protected]> Morton-In-Marsh Stoke-on-Trent, ST4 2DE Universities and Colleges Glos, GL56 0TW Tel: 0178 229 4698 Evelyn Welch Tel/Fax: 01451 830199 <[email protected]> School of English and Drama Rupert Shepherd Queen Mary College Hon Secretary (Artists' Papers Register) Christiana Payne University of London <[email protected]> Oxford Brookes University Mile End Road School of Humanities London El 4NS Deborah Cherry Gipsy Lane Tel: 020 7882 3172 (Editor, Art History) Oxford OX3 OBP <[email protected]> (Central Saint Martins College of Tel: 01865 483 582 Art and Design) <[email protected]> <[email protected]> ELECTED 2002 (VOTING) CHAIRS OF MEMBERS' GROUPS Richard Williams Fintan Cullen (VOTING) (University of Edinburgh) (Deputy Editor, Art History) Art Galleries and Museums Malcolm Gee (University of Nottingham) Amy Barker (University of Northumbria) <[email protected]> Sunderland Museum and Winter ELECTED 2003 (VOTING) Liz James Gardens Tom Gretton (Vice-Chair) (Reviews Editor, Art History) Burdon Road (University College London) (University of Sussex) Sunderland Louise Bourdua <[email protected]> Tyne and Wear, SRI 1PP (University of Aberdeen) <[email protected]> Marion Arnold (Honorary Editor, The Art Book) Schools ELECTED 2004 (VOTING) Carol Jacobi Christine Riding <[email protected]> Westminster School (Tate Britain) Dana Arnold Common Room Natalie Adamson (Editor, New Interventions in Art 17 Deans Yard (University of St Andrews) History) London SW1P3PB EX-OFFICIO MEMBERS (VOTING) (University of Southampton) Tel: 020 79631050 Stephen Bann <[email protected]> (Chair of the British National Ed Lilley Independent Art & Design Historians Committee of CIHA) (2005 Conference Organiser, Bristol) Frances Follin (University of Bristol) Fred Orton 20 Norlands Crescent <[email protected]> Chislehurst (2006 Conference Organiser, Leeds) Kent, BR7 5RN Tel: 0181 467 0512 Bulletin contributions Staff (non-voting) <[email protected]> Please send contributions (preferably Senior Administrator in electronic form) to: Jannet King, Claire Davies Editor, Bulletin, 48 Stafford Road, Brighton BN1 5PF, Tel & Fax: 01273 70 Cowcross Street 509653 <[email protected]> London, EC1M 6EJ Tel: 020 7490 3211 Next deadline: 6 May 2005 Fax 020 7490 3277 Conference/fellowship information <[email protected]> and job ads printed free of charge. All other ads contact Editor to discuss price. Association of For queries re material to be posted as an insert with Bulletin, please Art Historians contact the Administrator. Registered Charity No. 282579 Designed and typeset by Jannet King. Printed in Brighton by TJie Print House ISSN 03079163P while in fact the A level is too difficult (so that even of supporting continuing scholarship and a public independent schools are dropping it); the subject has no profile for the work of art, design and architectural presence at all in the pre-16 syllabus. This compares historians. It was also noted that museum-based with 6,000 AS/A level students doing film studies, the research (curating, catalogue writing, exhibition and curriculum of which has been very well structured and gallery development work) was possibly undervalued nurtured, apparently. by some panels at the last RAE by comparison with more 'traditional' book and journal outputs, and that Considerable discussion took place about the 'identity' some work will need to be done to persuade the new of the discipline, and it was felt (not by all!) that the panels to alter their perceptions. notion of 'visual culture' had perhaps diffused the profile and identity of art and design history. It was felt On the positive side, it was noted that 280 students that there should be common propaganda by the DHS enrolled for the MA in art history at the Open University and the AAH to support the public profile of our (though some did not find the course to be what they discipline, in teaching (at all levels), research and in expected/wanted) so there is a demand for the subject at museums. The old problem of the lack of a text book for an advanced level. And when students come into AS/ A level students was raised, but clearly no publisher contact with our subject (which is almost invisible in is going to take this on with a small number of possible schools), for example as part of a general first-year sales in the UK. The key would seem to lie in the US course of study at university, they are very enthusiastic. market. In conclusion it was decided that: Jonathan Vickery, and others, made the suggestion that • a sub-committee of members of the DHS and the advisory bodies could be created to support particular AAH should meet twice yearly to take these issues strategies within the discipline. It seems that university further, and to develop closer links between us vice-chancellors and the like pay attention to the views of businessmen/women interested in the arts, as well as • there should be an annual meeting of Heads of local councillors, MPs and arts council officers. Department and other key representatives of our Advantages of networking could help the position of a subjects small, intellectually lively, and culturally and socially valuable subject area. After some discussion, it was felt • there should be a collection of statistics on numbers that more work was needed to investigate how exactly of courses and students doing art and design history, these advisory/advocacy bodies would work and in as well as an effort made to establish a database of art what context. Toshio Watanabe felt they were best and design historians in the UK suited to specific initiatives, and made the important • the executives of the DHS and the AAH would point that we need to build international connections discuss this meeting and suggestions arising from it, and collaborations. such as the idea of specific project advisory committees, at the next available opportunity. RESEARCH ASSESSMENT EXERCISE The RAE was discussed, of course, and it was felt that The AAH and the DHS would like to thank Ken the RAE was doing exactly what it had been created to Quickenden and the other members of art and design do: result in some teaching-only establishments, the history at UCE Birmingham, as well as the closing of courses, and the retrenchment of the administrators at the AAH and DHS, for their help in discipline away from adventurous interdisciplinary making this meeting possible and ensuring the smooth projects back into very specialist areas, since people running of the afternoon's events.