The Troubled Future of Colleges and Universities

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Troubled Future of Colleges and Universities ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... SYMPOSIUM ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... The Troubled Future of Colleges and Universities Gary King, Harvard University Maya Sen, University of Rochester ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... he American system of higher education appears way to become educated, a primary driver in reducing income poised for disruptive change of potentially his- inequality (de Gregorio and Lee 2002), and a major generator toric proportions due to massive new political, of economic growth (Goldin and Katz 2008). These successes economic, and educational forces that threaten have allowed universities to become even more valued for their to undermine its business model, governmental abilities to create and distribute knowledge. Tsupport, and operating mission. These forces include dra- But how are universities paid for? The business model of matic new types of economic competition, difficulties in grow- most universities relies primarily on tuition revenue from ing revenue streams as we had in the past, relative declines in teaching, with some additional funds from sponsored research philanthropic and government support, actual and likely future and philanthropy. However, sponsored research dollars do political attacks on universities, and some outdated methods not even cover their own costs: each year, universities lose of teaching and learning that have been unchanged for hun- between $700 million and $1.5 billion in administrative and dreds of years. operating costs that are not covered by sponsored federal Most importantly, technological advances, the Internet, research grants (Goldman and Williams 2000). For example, quantitative social science (recently known to the general pub- the University of California alone reports that it loses approx- lic as “Big Data”), and the computer revolution have mas- imately $500 million each year in unrecouped indirect costs sively reinvented or disrupted travel, music, commerce, sports, associated with sponsored research (University of California newspapers, publishing, and many other information-based 2012). Given the lack of support in the current political envi- businesses. Is higher education next? Remember Newsweek? ronment for increased funding, and the strict limits placed It was also in the business of creating and distributing knowl- on indirect costs and overhead, universities shoulder this bur- edge. In 2010, the entire company was sold for $1.00 (Clark den by relying on other sources. 2010; Vega and Peters 2010). For the top universities, philanthropy is a significant source We think that university officials should now begin to act of funds, and the donors (especially alumni) are extremely and with this symposium hope to facilitate a larger conversa- loyal citizens of their university-created communities. They tion about what is happening and what action we might take. will undoubtedly be counted on for much progress going for- In our view, political scientists are uniquely positioned to ward. However, overall philanthropic contributions to higher understand the situation, to study the effects of governmental education are down for only the second time since records and economic forces on universities, to analyze the fragile polit- have been kept, having dropped more than $400 million since ical situation, and to help design new strategies and institu- their peak in 2007–08 (National Center for Education Statis- tions to respond. It is time the profession engages this crucial tics 2010d). The largest gifts have, of course, historically come issue. If universities fail to rethink their strategic situations from the most wealthy, but among this group giving has and business models, they may well fall to the coming educa- dropped significantly both in terms of numbers of donors and tional “tsunami” (Auletta 2012). Doing nothing different, and numbers of dollars and is far more sensitive to changes in imagining that nothing will change, is delusional. Inaction at economic conditions. Despite huge increases in the concen- this point may be as irresponsible to students, faculty, and tration of wealth, giving by the wealthiest donors decreased staff at universities as it is to the country and world that depend 9.8% from 2005 to 2007, compared to a 1.8% overall philan- on the continuing flow of breathtaking innovations that stem thropic decrease (Center on Philanthropy 2009). Even the gen- from university research to improve the economy, create won- erous billionaires who have pledged to give away half their der, and make the world a better place to live. money (http://j.mp/ScJN4g) will leave with them a breathtak- ing concentration of remaining wealth. Empirically, it takes THE STATUS QUO BUSINESS MODEL years for wealthy people to learn how to become productive The raison d’être of modern universities has long been the philanthropists, and so universities also struggle with the fact (1) creation, (2) preservation, and (3) distribution of knowl- that the increasing numbers of younger wealthy (especially edge. Universities function best when all three work together. from technology ventures) do not presently give as much as The resulting synergies have produced dramatic progress for the wealthy from previous eras. hundreds of years: universities are not only the primary stew- Tuition and fees are paid by students, their families, gov- ards of the scientific community but the most sought after ernments, and endowments, but increasing revenue at the same doi:10.1017/S1049096512001606 PS • January 2013 83 ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... Symposium: Symposium on “The Troubled Future of Colleges and Universities” ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... Figure 1 Left: Number of Colleges and Universities in the United States (including branch campuses). Right: Percentage of Enrolled Students at Public, Private, or For-Profit Universities. Source: National Center for Education Statistics. rates from these sources seems unlikely. For most of the twen- Another way to raise revenue is by admitting more stu- tieth century, increasing tuition was a reliable, economically dents, which universities consistently did through the early sound way for universities to raise revenue because family twentieth century (National Center for Education Statistics incomes were rising. When family incomes stopped rising, as 2010c). However, at this point, the number of students is rel- they have for the last two decades (Federal Reserve Board Divi- atively fixed because of physical constraints at universities, sion of Research and Statistics 2012), federal and state govern- colleges, and even community colleges (see figure 1); unless ments intervened by providing basic grants and assistance. universities spend what scarce resources they have on large Today, tuition is outstripping that assistance, and state and residential, classroom, and other infrastructure upgrades, federal budgets are more strained and their legislatures less meaningfully increasing student enrollments on campus is not generous. In addition, academics, especially those receiving feasible. Today even the largest universities are not taking federal support (such as in schools of public health), are dis- many more students, and private institutions long ago gave proportionately liberal Democrats, and so their ability to stay up on the idea of increasing enrollments as a way to increase above the political fray may become more difficult to sustain revenue. (Fosse and Gross 2012). In recent years, families have turned directly or indirectly ECONOMIC ATTACKS to home equity loans to pay increasing tuition, but, after the We now explore some of the external forces undermining the real estate crisis, this is no longer a viable option. Today, many university business model. In all likelihood, the biggest threat students borrow hefty amounts from private lenders without to any university is not another traditional university. After basic consumer protections. Although this was never planned all, when Harvard’s or Princeton’s endowment surges, so does or expected, student loan debt now even exceeds total credit Stanford’s. When the Wisconsin State Legislature cuts the card debt (Federal Reserve Bank of New York 2012)! The top university budget, similar patterns soon follow in California universities are now charging around a quarter of a million and Ohio. When community colleges in the Northeast are dollars for four years of tuition, and so increasing that much overwhelmed with students and cannot expand to keep up, more is likely to be untenable
Recommended publications
  • Selected Bibliography of On-Demand Academic Public Lectures
    Selective Bibliography of On-Demand Academic Public Lectures Version 2.0 (January 14, 2010) Compiled by George Wrenn Cataloging Librarian Humboldt State University Library [email protected] Table of Contents UPDATE HISTORY ................................................................................................................................... 10 RATIONALE ............................................................................................................................................ 11 CRITERIA FOR LISTING ............................................................................................................................ 11 SOURCES AND RESEARCH DATES ........................................................................................................... 12 AGGREGATING LECTURE SITES ............................................................................................................... 14 COMMERCIAL SITES ................................................................................................................................. 14 Busitalks beta ................................................................................................................................ 14 delicious ........................................................................................................................................ 14 FORA.tv ......................................................................................................................................... 14 Free Science Videos and
    [Show full text]
  • European Academic Research
    EUROPEAN ACADEMIC RESEARCH Vol. IV, Issue 1/ April 2016 Impact Factor: 3.4546 (UIF) ISSN 2286-4822 DRJI Value: 5.9 (B+) www.euacademic.org Open Web Based e-Learning MOOL RAJ Shri Mata Vaishno Devi University, Katra Jammu and Kashmir India Abstract: Web based e-learning is a computer based educational system that enables a person to learn anywhere at any time with the help of internet. People of the 21st century are digital native they perform most of their works by using information and communication technologies. ICT has advanced so much that the geographical gap is bridged and learners feels that he is in a classroom. This paper discusses websites providing on line video lectures on different subject area Key words: e-learning, e-resources, internet, video lecture. INTRODUCTION E-learning offers the ability to share material in all kinds of formats such as videos, slideshows, word documents and PDFs. Conducting webinars (live online classes) and communicating with professors via chat and message forums is also an option available to users. The term “e-learning” has only been in existence since 1999, when the word was first utilized at a CBT systems seminar. Other words also began to spring up in search of an accurate description such as “online learning” and “virtual learning”. However, the principles behind e-learning have been 698 Mool Raj- Open Web Based e-Learning well documented throughout history, and there is even evidence which suggests that early forms of e-learning existed as far back as the 19th century. Online learning today with the introduction of the computer and internet in the late 20th century, e-learning tools and delivery methods expanded.
    [Show full text]
  • Higher Education Migrates to Youtube and Social Networks
    Higher Education Migrates to YouTube and Social Networks By Marilyn Gilroy to find a better way to collect From The Hispanic Outlook and highlight all the educational in Higher Education content already being uploaded to YouTube. Many colleges and uni- versities have previously posted RUE global enlightenment. videos on the site through their That's how YouTubeEDU is own channels; however, the new Tbeing promoted by compa- EDU page organizes the courses ny officials who have announced and programs in one place. the launch of a YouTube section Spencer Crooks, a spokesman devoted to academic content. for YouTube, says there are more Calling the new site "a free, self- than 200 lectures on topics includ- organizing, democratic website ing computer science, literature, containing all the world's knowl- biology, philosophy, history, po- edge," YouTubeEDU promises an litical science, and law. But tbere environment in which "any quali- are thousands of other videos fied teacher can contribute and uploaded by participating universi- absolutely anyone can learn." It ties that include discussions, inter- features lectures and other materi- views, and seminars. That number als from hundreds of colleges and is sure to grow as YouTubeEDU universities, including Stanford, has agreed to accept content from Harvard, and the Massachusetts any "qualifying two- and four-year Institute of Technology (MIT). institutions." Guidelines say in- YouTubeEDU is the result of stitutions must apply online, and a volunteer project sparked by a there can be only one application group of employees who wanted per institution. Marilyn Gilroy teaches communications at Bergen Community Coilege in Paramas, NJ.
    [Show full text]
  • C. E. Jordan High School Curriculum Night 2020 Purpose
    C. E. Jordan High School Curriculum Night 2020 Purpose ● Share graduation requirements ● Review highlights of our instructional program ● Explain scheduling options for students ● Review registration steps ● We want to establish a CULTURE of equity and access to a rigorous, diverse, high quality instructional program and robust extra-curricular/co-curricular engagement. ● Based on our CORE BELIEF that all students should graduate on time and with options. Future Ready Core Graduation Plan Graduation Requirements (28 Credits Total) ● 4 English ● 4 Math ● 3 Science ● 4 Social Studies ● 1 Health and PE ● 2 World Language, Art, Career and Technical Education-any combination ● 10 Electives Benefits of Academic Rigor ● Prepares students for college and Academic Honors Advanced workplace readiness Placement ● Helps improve SAT and ACT A – 4.0 A – 4.5 A – 5.0 scores B – 3.0 B – 3.5 B – 4.0 ● Weighted credit for final course C – 2.0 C – 2.5 C – 3.0 grade D – 1.0 D – 1.5 D – 2.0 Advanced Placement (AP) Program Program Data AP Capstone ● Course Offerings Total: 21 ● Interdisciplinary Program Different Courses introduced in 2018-2019 ● Number of AP exams taken: ● First Year - AP Seminar 1,011 (Sophomores or Juniors) ● Number of Students Taking ● Second Year - AP Research AP Exams: 562 (Juniors or Seniors) ● Percent Scoring 3 or Above: 72% Advancement via Individual Determination (AVID) AVID is a selective, nationally acclaimed program that seeks to both challenge and support students on their path to attend a four-year college or university What does AVID provide? ● Tutorials and skills development in the AVID elective course ● Honors-level courses with their cohort ● Field trips (HBCU Fair and NCSU in September) ● Test prep ● College and scholarship advising English ● Students are required to complete FOUR levels of English (I, II, III, and IV) in order to graduate.
    [Show full text]
  • How to Prevent “Mush Brain”
    How to Prevent “Mush Brain” How can we prevent “mush brain”? Doctors and family members recommend puzzles and word games; there are plenty of ‘Apps’ out there that can be downloaded to your computer or phone in an effort to keep your mind working. Did you ever think about going back to school learning about something online? As we get older we become set in our ways and more sedentary. We gravitate to easy, comfortable grooves in our daily life. This also tends to lead us to loneliness and isolation. The result is a decline in both social interaction as well as decreased mental stimulation. These are two of three components essential to brain health (physical exercise, cognitive exercise and social engagement). This cognitive decline significantly increases the risk of dementia. Senior education programs can provide a way to fight social isolation by bringing seniors into respectful interaction with all sorts of interesting people, whether it is online or in a classroom. The sheer act of going back to school can invigorate a life by coming together with like-minded others. Taking a class in just about any subject can improve cognitive abilities, rejuvenate memory while having fun. Challenging the brain to grow new cells can take place at any age. In the interest of continuing education, many colleges and universities offer reduced or free college tuition to senior citizens (typically 60 and up, although rules vary). Based on information on Pennyhoarder.com, at least one option for reduced or free tuition is available in every state. However, if one does pay tuition for continuing education, there is a tax break called the Lifetime Learning Credit; this allows up to a $2,000 maximum deduction, but phases out for higher earners (currently $56,000 for singles and $112,000 if filing jointly).
    [Show full text]
  • Curriculum and Registration Night 2019 Future Ready Core Graduation Plan
    Showcase of School: Curriculum and Registration Night 2019 Future Ready Core Graduation Plan ● 4 English ● 4 Math ● 3 Science ● 4 Social Studies ● 1 Health and PE ● 2 World Language, Art, Career Technical Education-any combination ● 10 Electives ● 28 Credits Total Course Registration Timeline January 16 and February 1 *Registration Presentations to Githens and Rogers-Herr. January 30-February 8 Registration Classroom Guidance Sessions to 9th, 10th, and 11th graders February 14 Non-feeder schools can pick up registration packets. February 15 Completed upperclassmen registration forms are due back to Student Services. *Check with middle school counselors for rising 9th grade registration form due dates. Course Registration Forms ○Select 8 primary courses by placing an “X” on line in front of course number. ○Select 4 alternate courses by placing an "A" on the line in front of course number. ■ Alternate courses are scheduled, too. Be careful with selections. ○All students must register online with PowerSchool in addition to completing course selection forms. ○Jordan course registration forms will be available on January 14. Course descriptions are posted on the Jordan website. Advanced Placement (AP) Program ● Program Data ◦ Course Offerings 20 ◦ Number of AP exams taken 858 ◦ Number of Students Taking AP Exams 500 ◦ Percent Scoring 3 or Above 77% ● Faculty ◦ 21% of our faculty are Nationally Board Certified Teachers ◦ All have been trained by College Board ◦ Over 50% of our faculty have advanced degrees ◦ 3 Teachers recognized as Teacher of the Year ◦ Faculty have presented at the local, state, and national level Independent Study ● Overview - Through this program, Juniors and Seniors have one of three options: (a) Directed Study, (b) Lab Technician, or (c) Teaching Assistant.
    [Show full text]
  • Free Lecture Notes Online Earth Science
    Free Lecture Notes Online Earth Science Collaborative Abbot oyster that caffein decapitate masochistically and inseminating hurriedly. Plastered or punishing, Torin never orients any joseph! Kermit is Polaroid and wrong-foots quenchlessly while literal Augie stags and collying. They have made me is organized by asking students can get an brief overview of geological principles of plate tectonics using stars and world cultural connections from? If you discover rocks and science free lecture online earth, online courses program office of the program, featuring a home run a link. When you click on your notes in providing support for managing the dynamic equilibrium of rock samples as this course title or prevent them? But rather it will help you can have become a whole class schedules are not for you are examined, logo and the. Composition of earth data was an earth science free lecture notes to our science education institution is known about helping increase high speed internet. Clearly labeled page headers make the earth materials was known, lectures on an example, free lecture notes online earth science, hand navigation bar helps me look in which skills in the studying? Udacity is free lectures and earth science makes permanent, and tutorials on the notes to complete teaching without any sign up and alumni teaching placement? The earth is a host of a website brings both the bible and smaller than that you for authentic teaching. Books is free science earth sciences. Students an expert perspectives, but is a single video and practicing these barriers and free lecture notes online earth science concepts were happy with this tutorial will take online.
    [Show full text]
  • [email protected] / Vita Current As of September 2016
    AMY E. HUNGERFORD 203-415-8593 (cell) / [email protected] / Vita current as of September 2016 Education THE JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY MA (1996) and Ph. D. (1999), English and American Literature M.A., Poetry, Writing Seminars (1993) B.A. (Political Science) /M.A. (Humanities) with University Honors and Honors in the Humanities (1992); Phi Beta Kappa Appointments YALE UNIVERSITY Professor of English, secondary appointment in American Studies (July, 2007 to the present) • Poorvu Family Prize of Yale College, awarded for innovation and excellence in interdisciplinary teaching, Spring, 2005 Dean of Humanities (July 1, 2016-present); Divisional Director of the Humanities (July 1, 2014-present) • Responsible for overseeing all tenure, promotion, and ladder-faculty searches in 23 Humanities departments and programs • Chair, Humanities Tenure and Promotions Committee, and Humanities Advisory Committee • Represent the Office of the Dean of the Faculty in special initiatives, including interdisciplinary, creative and performing arts, and digital humanities projects, revision of tenure system, major rennovations Master, Morse College & Chair, Council of Masters (Master, July 1, 2012 to July 1, 2015; Chair of the Council, 2013-14) • Lead the intellectual, ethical, and community life of Morse’s 480 undergraduates • As Chair, work closely with the Dean and consult with the Provost and President to help set policy across Yale College; lead the group of twelve masters Master, Calhoun College (Acting), July 1, 2011 through July 1, 2012 • Responsible
    [Show full text]
  • AP Chalkboard an AP Support Newsletter
    \ AP Chalkboard An AP Support Newsletter Advanced Academic Services January 2010 Archived AP Chalkboard available online at http://www.austinisd.org/academics/curriculum/gt/ap.phtml Improve Your Mind by Reading the Classics Bigger Vocabulary. When reading the classics you’ll come across many words that are no longer commonly used. Why learn words most people don’t use? Having a bigger vocabulary is like having a tool box with more tools. A larger I NSIDE T HIS I SSUE arsenal of words enables you to express yourself more eloquently. You’ll be able to communicate with precision and create a perception of higher intelligence 1 Improve Your Mind by Reading the Classics that will give you an advantage in work and social situations. 2 The Pep Talk: Cause Rhetoric Improved Writing Ability. Reading the classics is the easiest way to improve your writing. While reading you unconsciously absorb the grammar and style of the 100 Words to Know 4 author. Why not learn from the best? After reading, I’ve observed that my thoughts begin to mirror the writer’s style. This influence carries over to writing, helping form clear, rhythmic sentences. Improved Speaking Ability. Becoming a better speaker accompanies becoming a better writer because both are caused by becoming a better thinker. Studying works of genius will teach you to express yourself with clarity and style. By College Match Maker improving your command of the English language, you’ll become more persuasive, sound more intelligent, and enjoy an advantage over less articulate people. Fresh Ideas. Isn’t it ironic that the best source for new ideas is writers who’ve been dead for centuries? It makes sense when you consider the competition.
    [Show full text]
  • 2021-2022 Course Guide
    2021-2022 COURSE GUIDE 300 EAST 11800 SOUTH, DRAPER, UTAH 84020 - 801.984.7650 - WWW.JDCHS.ORG NATIONAL BLUE RIBBON SCHOOL OF EXCELLENCE 2021-2022 Course Guide - Juan Diego Catholic High School 2021-2022 Course Guide - Juan Diego Catholic High School COURSE REQUIREMENTS & DISCLOSURES AP COURSE REQUIREMENTS $$ THEOLOGY 8 semesters 4 credits 4 years Students and parents are required to sign an expectation contract. There is a fee for the ENGLISH 8 semesters 4 credits 4 years required end-of-year AP exam. College credit SOCIAL STUDIES 8 semesters 4 credits 4 years may be earned with an appropriate score on the exam. MATHEMATICS 8 semesters 4 credits 4 years 2020-2021 AP Exam Fees: (2021-22 fees are not yet available) SCIENCE 6 semesters 3 credits 3 years AP Research or AP Seminar $149 per exam WORLD LANGUAGES 4 semesters 2 credits 2 years All other AP Exams $ 99 per exam FINE ARTS 2 semesters* 1 credit 1 year CONCURRENT COURSES COMPUTER SCIENCE 1 semester 1/2 credit 1/2 year Juan Diego offers concurrent or dual enroll- ment options through Utah Valley University. HEALTH 1 semester 1/2 credit 1/2 year This concurrent track offers students potential PHYSICAL EDUCATION 3 semesters 1 1/2 credits 1 1/2 years college credits that transfer to colleges and universities in Utah and many out-of-state ELECTIVES 9 semesters 4 1/2 credits schools. College credit is offered to students, so long as they meet certain grade or test thresh- olds required by the university. Credit hours Credits earned prior to high school will not be counted towards graduation requirements.
    [Show full text]
  • Humanities 2.0: E-Learning in the Digital World Author(S): Suzanne Guerlac Reviewed Work(S): Source: Representations, Vol
    Humanities 2.0: E-Learning in the Digital World Author(s): Suzanne Guerlac Reviewed work(s): Source: Representations, Vol. 116, No. 1, The Humanities and the Crisis of The Public University (Fall 2011), pp. 102-127 Published by: University of California Press Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.1525/rep.2011.116.1.102 . Accessed: 19/12/2011 12:45 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. University of California Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Representations. http://www.jstor.org SUZANNE GUERLAC Humanities 2.0: E-Learning in the Digital World E-Learning and the Public University: Access and Affordability 2.0 New technologies, emerging at breakneck speed, have been fueling “the most fertile new market for investors in many years,” the global business of e-learning.1 The overheated worldwide market for e-learning meets the corporate demand for more “knowledge” in the service of more innovation, which is itself in the service of higher profits. The global econ- omy is changing at an increasingly dizzy pace, largely because of the acceler- ating speed of technological innovation.
    [Show full text]
  • Crises in Education: Online Learning As a Solution
    Creative Education 2011. Vol.2, No.3, 156-163 Copyright © 2011 SciRes. DOI:10.4236/ce.2011.23022 Crises in Education: Online Learning as a Solution Hershey H. Friedman1, Linda Weiser Friedman2 1Department of Finance and Business Management, Brooklyn College, The City University of New York, New York, USA; 2Zicklin School of Business, Baruch College, The City University of New York, New York, USA. Email: [email protected], [email protected] Received June 29th, 2011; revised July 18th, 2011; accepted July 22nd, 2011. There are three serious problems facing education today. These include working with draconian budgets that mean reduced spending for education, making education interesting and relevant for students, and raising stan- dards. Several issues that the legislators are especially concerned about are the low retention rates at the college level, the high dropout rates in the high schools, and the long time it takes undergraduate students to graduate college. The authors show how online learning may be an important tool for solving these problems. Keywords: Online Education, Low Standards, Retention Rate, Graduation Rate, School Assessment, Creativity in Education, Crises in Education, Accountability in Education President of Bergen Community College, in 1965, when the Introduction college was started, only one-third of its cost was borne by students; today students must bear 78% of the cost (Kristof, There is concern that the United States is losing its edge as a 2011). K-12 schools throughout the country have to deal with world leader in educating its citizens (Blow, 2011; Lee, 2010). budget cuts. In New York City, for example, a last-minute deal There are at least three serious problems facing education― between Mayor Bloomberg and the City Council averted lay- higher education and K-12―today.
    [Show full text]