Who. Owns a Tree? Julia Butterfly Hill Versus Maxxam

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Who. Owns a Tree? Julia Butterfly Hill Versus Maxxam Who. Owns a Tree? Julia Butterfly Hill versus Maxxam i£~¥1::1~'!:~~ or most of its history, northern California's Pacific The ultimate goal of a tree sit is to remain in a tree long Lumber Company was a leader in environmental enough to save it from logging. However, many such actions stewardship. It pioneered the practice of selec­ merely delay the inevitable. Still, activists support tree sits tively cutting some trees on its land while leaving . because they gain time for further legal proceedings and nearby trees intact. Unlike the usual practice of increase media awareness. But Julia Butterfly Hill proved clear-cutting-clearing all the trees from an area of land­ indomitable. In her most famous tree sit, she occupied Luna, a selective cutting allows the roots of the remaining trees to 55-meter (180-foot) redwood tree that was nearly a thousand J.u.li.a ..•.Butterfly. .• ~ i.tl •..• prpved.··.inci<>m.it~·ple ...• tn ..•per.· .mh.~t•famott·stre.e. sit,·.·· .. ·· shepccllpied·.Gunaj.a 5~i-meter{1~Q7fgot}~~t:JwoodJr~e:tttat was· . il~?rty athou$~nqy~at§old~. retain water and hold soil in place. In addition, the surviving years old, and resolved to remain there until Maxxam agreed trees allow forest regrowth that more closely mimics natural to spare the tree. She spent 2 years in the tree without coming succession after a disturbance. Pacific Lumber developed a down once. She stayed through gale-force winds, two winters, 100-year sustainable logging plan that ensured relatively intimidation tactics, the death of another activist, and the cut­ healthy forests as well as job security for the loggers and their ting of most of the trees in the stand that she occupied. Julia's families. efforts were rewarded when Maxxam agreed to protect Luna, In 1986, however, Pacific Lumber was purchased by new and a 61-meter (200-foot) buffer around it, in perpetuity. In a owners and renamed Maxxam. To increase revenue from the separate, complex deal that included many stipulations about company's land holdings, the new management clear-cut hun­ logging practices, Maxxam and another company also agreed dreds of thousands of acres of redwood forests. Because the to sell the U.S. government 3,035 hectares (7,500 acres) of new harvesting method removed vegetation and tree roots, ancient forest for $480 million. That property has now become Maxxam's practices left the forests susceptible to soil erosion the Headwaters Forest Reserve. and landslides. On December 31, 1996, an immense land­ Hill's actions cost Maxxam slide began on a steeply sloped Maxxam site above the town millions of dollars in delays of Stafford, California. The landslide destroyed a number of and lost revenue and brought homes and drastically altered the natural environment. unsustainable logging practices The adjacent uncut land, owned by Maxxam, was home to the attention of many people. to the largest remaining intact forest of ancient redwood Because of its large debt load, trees and to a number of endangered species. Environmental Maxxam filed for bankruptcy activist Julia Butterfly Hill was appalled by Maxxam's forest protection in January 2007, and management practices. In response, she joined a "tree sit" its depleted assets were reorga­ on Maxxam's land organized by the direct action group Earth nized and transferred to a new ! First! i company in 2008. Although ..,.. ~ Julia Butterfly Hill sitting in Luna. ij ! ~ Hea dWaters Forest Reserve. 261 •; . i::.:.\· iill.;j•. 'H' Maxxam's logging practices appeared to have placed profit her as having made a personal sacrifice to save an ancient be.fore sustaTnability, the new company has stated that it will tree and to bring the issue of unsustainable logging practices returrho more sustainable practices with the trees that remain to the public's attention. Others see her as a lawbreaker who on its holdings. trespassed on private property in an effort to prevent a legal The conflict over logging practices raises many questions. activity.~~ Do citizens of the United States have the right to influence Sources: ]. B. Hill, The Legacy of Luna: The Story of a Tree, a Woman, what activities occur on private lands? What if the land is .,t 'i- and the Struggle to Save the Redwoods (HarperCollins, 2000); public? Was Julia Butterfly Hill a hero or a villain? Some see H. Sims, The scion, North Coast journal, July 20, 2006. .
Recommended publications
  • Mr. Floatie, Tree Squatting and Save-Our-Surfers Pierre Walter Department of Educational Studies, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada
    Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 52, Number 1, April 2012 Cultural codes as catalysts for collective conscientisation in environmental adult education: Mr. Floatie, tree squatting and Save-our-Surfers Pierre Walter Department of Educational Studies, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada This study examines how cultural codes in environmental adult education can be used to ‘frame’ collective identity, develop counter- hegemonic ideologies, and catalyse ‘educative-activism’ within social movements. Three diverse examples are discussed, spanning environmental movements in urban Victoria, British Columbia, Canada, the redwoods of northern California, and the coral reefs and beaches of Hawai’i, respectively. The first, Mr. Floatie and his fight for sewage treatment, illustrates how art, humour and drama can be employed to mobilise the public, media and government to action. The second, Julia Butterfly Hill and her 738-day squat in a redwood tree, shows how cultural codes embodied in both tree and woman catalysed social action for forest preservation. The third, the grassroots organisation Save Our Surf, demonstrates the effectiveness of education and activism through immediate, multiple Cultural codes 115 and short-term symbolic appeals for help, leading to long-term success in Hawaiian coastal conservation. Introduction In several decades of scholarship and activism on adult learning in new social movements (the women’s, peace, civil rights, anti-racism, GLBT rights, anti-globalisation, Indigenous rights, environmental and other ‘identity’ movements), one of the central concerns has been, and remains today, the role of social movements in facilitating individual and collective learning, and, conversely, the role of adult learning and activist-educators in advancing social movements (Foley 1999, 2001; Hill & Clover 2003; Branagan & Boughton 2003; Hall & Turay 2006; Ollis 2008; Flowers & Chodkiewicz 2009).
    [Show full text]
  • Self and Other in the Julia Butterfly Tapes
    "I HAVE GIVEN UP MY SOCIETY WORLD SELF:" SELF AND OTHER IN THE JULIA BUTTERFLY TAPES by Geraldine Goldberg A Thesis Presented to The Faculty of Humboldt State University In Partial Fulfillment Of the Requirements for the Degree Master of Arts In Sociology August, 1999 "I HAVE GIVEN UP MY SOCIETY WORLD SELF:" SELF AND OTHER IN THE JULIA BUTTERFLY TAPES by Geraldine Goldberg Approved by: Elizabeth Watson, Ph.D., Major Professor Date John Gai, LCSW, Committee Member Date Jerrold Krause, Ph.D., Committee Member Date Elizabeth Watson, Ph.D. Graduate Coordinator Date Ronald A. Fritzsche, Ph.D. Date Dean for Research and Graduate Studies Abstract "I have given up my society world self:" Self and Other in the Julia Butterfly Tapes Geraldine Goldberg The purpose of this thesis is to provide access to and social analysis of a set of live weekly radio conversations, as a case study of a woman living in a tree, as a nonviolent direct action. The Julia Butterfly Tapes result from the live radio conversations between Julia "Butterfly" Hill and me. As no other research will ever do, the tapes document the historic tree sit of this courageous and outspoken environmental activist. The tapes have been completely transcribed as a verbatim account of a year and a half in Julia's life in the tree from which her point of view may be determined. The information in this account/ethnography has been edited from our live radio conversations to comply with the requirements for the Master's degree. A broader scope of sociological inquiry concerning this unique case study remains for others throughout various disciplines for interpretation, analysis and further understanding.
    [Show full text]
  • Maine Woods-Late Winter 2003-7
    THE MAINE WOODS “In wildness is the A Publication of the Forest Ecology Network preservation of the world.” Henry David Thoreau Volume Seven Number One • Late Winter 2003 Free Acid rain-killed trees on Whaleboat Island in Casco Bay, an island recently acquired by the Maine Coast Heritage Trust. Acid rain is just one of the many disastrous effects of a national energy policy that is reliant upon fossil fuels. See the articles on pages 6-7 and 15. Also see the articles on pages 8 and 16 for other equally disastrous effects of that energy policy. Photo by Paul Donahue War on Environment Not Justified - page 3 “Polite conservationists leave no mark save the scars upon the Herbicide Project Update - page 4 Earth that could have been prevented had they stood their ground.” Leadership Needed Now to Reduce Maine’s Acid Rain & Fog - page 6 David Brower The Oils of War - page 8 War on Life in the Seas? -The US Navy and LFA Sonar - page 10 Forest Ecology Network Cutting and Selling the Gems of Maine’s North Woods - page 12 P.O. Box 2218 NON-PROFIT ORG. Balance Along the Roads - page 14 US POSTAGE PAID Augusta, ME 04338 AUGUSTA, ME An Analysis of Forest Statistics for Maine, 2001 - page 15 http://www.powerlink.net/fen PERMIT NO. 75 Ecuador and Oil - page 16 [email protected] A Birthday in the Treetops - page 20 The Battle Rages While the Old-Growth Dwindles - page 22 Logging the Sequoia Monument to Save It?!? - page 25 Allagash Wilderness Threatened - page 29 THE MAINE WOODS - Late Winter 2003 PAGE 1 A Voice in the Wilderness by Jonathan Carter THERE IS MUCH WORK TO BE DONE It feels good to be back in the saddle at FEN after a be imperative that FEN continues to set the agenda.
    [Show full text]
  • Philosophies of Adult Environmental Education
    Adult Education Quarterly Volume 60 Number 1 November 2009 3-25 © 2009 American Association for Adult and Continuing Philosophies of Adult Education 10.1177/0741713609336109 Environmental Education http://aeq.sagepub.com hosted at Pierre Walter http://online.sagepub.com University of British Columbia This article offers a typology of philosophical traditions in environmental education for adults, based on five philosophical perspectives of adult education described by Elias and Merriam. These five traditions are liberal, progressive, behaviorist, humanist, and radical adult environmental education, respectively. A summary of each philosophy’s main tenets, including the aims of education, beliefs about the nature of learners, the role of educators, and instructional strategies and assessment of learning is given in the article. Limitations of the typology are also discussed. Prominent examples from the environ- mental movement and adult environmental education practice in North America are then presented to illustrate each philosophy. The article ends with a discussion of direc- tions for future research and implications for practice. Keywords: environmental education; philosophies of adult education; environmentalism n recent years, the growing threat of global warming, the resource demands of a Ivoracious world economy, ever-expanding consumerism, and the untold ecological consequences of war have emerged as critical environmental problems. Together with continuing problems of toxic waste, industrial pollution, water contamination, urban sprawl, solid waste disposal, deforestation, the degradation of marine environments and wetlands, the destruction of wildlife habitat, and the loss of biodiversity, these new problems constitute a global ecological crisis (Clover, 2003; Merchant, 2005). This ecological crisis has given a new sense of urgency to environmental education for adults (and children).
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Authored by Julia Butterfly Hill Books
    Prepared 2/6/07 Circle of Life Contents: Books and Journal/Newspaper Articles Page 1 Articles and Books About Julia Butterfly Hill Page 3 Biographical Information (from Contemporary Authors and such) Page 8 Web Sites Page 10 AUTHORED BY JULIA BUTTERFLY HILL BOOKS The Legacy of Luna: The Story of a Tree, a Woman, and the Struggle to Save the Redwoods. 2000, San Francisco: Harper, 256 p. Reprinted: 2001, San Francisco: HarperCollins. ISBN 978-0-06-251659-6 Pages: 288 ISBN: 0062516582 (cloth); 0062516590 (pbk.) Abstract: On December 18, 1999, Julia Butterfly Hill's feet touched the ground for the first time in over two years, as she descended from "Luna," a thousand year-old redwood in Humboldt County, California. Hill had climbed 180 feet up into the tree high on a mountain on December 10, 1997, for what she thought would be a two- to three-week-long "tree- sit." The action was intended to stop Pacific Lumber, a division of the Maxxam Corporation, from the environmentally destructive process of clear-cutting the ancient redwood and the trees around it. The area immediately next to Luna had already been stripped and, because, as many believed, nothing was left to hold the soil to the mountain, a huge part of the hill had slid into the town of Stafford, wiping out many homes. Over the course of what turned into an historic civil action, Hill endured El Nino storms, helicopter harassment, a ten-day siege by company security guards, and the tremendous sorrow brought about by an old-growth forest's destruction.
    [Show full text]
  • Legacy of Luna Pdf, Epub, Ebook
    LEGACY OF LUNA PDF, EPUB, EBOOK Julia Butterfly Hill | 256 pages | 03 Apr 2001 | HarperCollins Publishers Inc | 9780062516596 | English | New York, NY, United States Legacy of Luna PDF Book This society creates rumors that start statewide debates, in which shows that Words and Language can pertain a huge amount of power if used correctly. I feel the fact that someone lived in a tree for two years to save it makes this story worthy of being read. Sign Up. Add to Wishlist. Nov 17, Cynthia rated it liked it Shelves: non-fiction , biography , boring-or-poor-style , usa , female-protagonist , female-author. What do they talk about? Skip to content Life in a tree can be surprisingly busy. I love this story and never get tired of it. Dominic Liddell Mr. According to forest ecologist Dr. Senior Legacy Essay Javascript is not enabled in your browser. You are there. From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. In this sparkling collection, award-winning writer Rishi Reddi weaves a multigenerational tapestry of interconnected lives, Jun 04, Sabrina rated it really liked it. This is a truley remarkable account of Julia's story. Friend Reviews. Community Reviews. Related Searches. Had to look her up, seems like she Poorly written but inspiring memoir about a young woman who sat in a redwood pine for two years to protest and prevent clear-cutting Julia showed resilience and did not just talk the talk but walked the walk or rather sat the sitting. Her upbringing and faith likely influenced her decision to help a defenseless tree and then sustained her during the most difficult days of her tree-sit the longest in history.
    [Show full text]
  • Conflicting Methods of Eco-Activism in California's Old-Growth Forests
    Volume 3, Issue No. 1. Love in the Time of Logging: Conflicting Methods of Eco-Activism in California’s Old-Growth Forests Margaret Maurer Tulane University, New Orleans, Louisiana, USA ÒÏ Abstract: In the winter of 1997 in the Headwaters Forest of Northern California, Julia Butterfly Hill made history when she climbed up into an ancient redwood tree named Luna that the company known as Pacific Lumber had slated for logging. Feeling a spiritual calling to protest tree-felling in the Pacific Northwest’s old-growth forests, Julia lived in Luna’s branches for a record-setting 738 days. Attracting the attention of mainstream media, Julia’s protest ignited awareness in the American public, but also set ablaze conflict—not only with the loggers tasked with felling the tree in which Julia lived, but also with Earth First!, a radical environmentalist group. Earth First!, known for its activism based on civil disobedience, had protested old-growth logging for years before Julia’s arrival and had established Julia’s own protest in Luna’s canopy. Despite this relationship and a shared deep passion for the preservation of old-growth environments, Julia and Earth First! ended up at odds—offering an opportunity to examine how and why conflict arises between activists driven by the same goals. A Web of Conflict in a Web of Life1 On a seven-foot platform made of salvaged materials including duct tape and a windsurfer sail, suspended more than 180 feet above the ground in the canopy of a tree called Luna, Julia Butterfly Hill thought she was going to die.
    [Show full text]
  • Catalysts for Collective Conscientization in Environmental Adult Education: Mr
    Kansas State University Libraries New Prairie Press 2007 Conference Proceedings (Halifax, NS, Adult Education Research Conference Canada) Catalysts for Collective Conscientization in Environmental Adult Education: Mr. Floatie, Tree Squatting and Save-our-Surfers Pierre Walter University of British Columbia, Canada Follow this and additional works at: https://newprairiepress.org/aerc Part of the Adult and Continuing Education Administration Commons This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 4.0 License Recommended Citation Walter, Pierre (2007). "Catalysts for Collective Conscientization in Environmental Adult Education: Mr. Floatie, Tree Squatting and Save-our-Surfers," Adult Education Research Conference. https://newprairiepress.org/aerc/2007/papers/103 This is brought to you for free and open access by the Conferences at New Prairie Press. It has been accepted for inclusion in Adult Education Research Conference by an authorized administrator of New Prairie Press. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Catalysts for Collective Conscientization in Environmental Adult Education: Mr. Floatie, Tree Squatting and Save-our-Surfers Pierre Walter University of British Columbia, Canada Abstract: This study examines how cultural codes in environmental adult education can be used to “frame” collective identity, develop counter-hegemonic ideologies, and catalyze “educative-activism” within social movements. Three diverse examples are discussed, spanning movements in urban Victoria, BC, the redwoods of northern California and the coral reefs and beaches of Hawai’i. In several decades of scholarship and activism on adult learning in New Social Movements (the women’s, peace, civil rights, anti-racism, GLBT rights, anti-globalization, indigenous rights, environmental and other “identity” movements), one of the central concerns has been, and remains today, the role of social movements in facilitating both individual and collective learning (Hall & Turay 2006).
    [Show full text]
  • Download PDF of Complete Issue
    PBerkeley’sEACE Journal of Nonviolence POWER & Conflict Transformation Monks Ordaining Trees in Thailand Taking a Stand for Environmental & Social Justice Also in this issue: Exclusive Interview: Julia Butterfly Hill The Landless Workers’ Movement in Brazil Fall 2007 $3.99 U.S. $4.49 Canada Indigenous Resistance 3 7 5 to Oil Imperialism 5 2 7 Legislation that Matters: 7 Nominee for Best New 2 Publication 2006 0 The Peace Tax Fund 7 4 4 7 0 1 PEACEPOWER Where Is the Intersection of www.calpeacepower.org Volume 3, Issue 2 • Fall 2007 Environmental and Social Justice? Editorial Board lobal warming has been on the tips of everyone’s tongues, from cafés and Carrie Brode • Jenica Cimino Gclassrooms to the daily news. Such concern with rising greenhouse gas emis- Chelsea Collonge • Lara Duncan sions and their effect on the planet has brought much attention to the relationship Caroline Kornfield • Jerlina Love between humans and the environment. In this issue we pose the question: “What Eli Sasaran McCarthy Tal Palter-Palman • Sujal Parikh is the relationship between environmental and social justice?” Jordan Pearlstein Our exploration of this question led us to uncover a wide range of movements, Matthew A. Taylor debates, and struggles that we believe reflect the need to respect the environment when pursuing social change goals, and the importance of employing nonviolent Editorial and Production Staff means to achieve ecologically sustainable ends. John Campbell • Ryan Curtis Anna Kallet • Eui-yun Kim In his fresh take on vegetarianism, John Campbell exposes how factory farming JyaHyun Lee • Corine Stofle contributes to environmental degradation, from hazardous runoff to intense use of resources to increased global warming.
    [Show full text]
  • September / October
    CONCERT & DANCE LISTINGS • CD REVIEWS FREE BI-MONTHLY Volume 6 Number 5 September-October 2006 THESOURCE FOR FOLK/TRADITIONAL MUSIC, DANCE, STORYTELLING & OTHER RELATED FOLK ARTS IN THE GREATER LOS ANGELES AREA “Don’t you know that Folk Music is illegal in Los Angeles?” — WARREN C ASEY of the Wicked Tinkers Didgeridoos and Don’ts A TALKABOUT WITH DIDGERIDUDE JAY ATWOOD BY JOEL OKIDA inside this issue: he mysterious drones and grunts emanating from the didgeridoo The Secret Museum bring to mind the sound one would get if it were possible to goose a humpback whale. Or A Gander perhaps the snorted mantra of a T yak meditating. In reality, the vari- at Gamelan ety of tones can’t really be described in a metaphor. This speaks to the mystical, native Australian origins of the long, tubular instrument called Joan Baez Gets the didgeridoo. There are references, in some northern Aboriginal lore, to its tone being the cumulative sound the crea- Barefoot Again tures in the animal kingdom would make if all were in chorus. Recently, Jay Atwood, solo artist, and didgeridoo player for Celtic band, The Wicked Tinkers, came up for air, and we asked him about the story behind this unique instrument and to PLUS: find out why being long-winded can be a good thing. JOEL: Do you think there’s a connection between the Ross Altman’s didgeridoo made in Australia and the variety of other instru- ments made elsewhere and out of any number of different kinds How Can I Keep From Talking of material? Is there a connection between the pipe and how you play? Larry Wines’ JAY: Yes, there are didgeridoos made from PVC (PolyVinyl Chloride) drain pipe to beautifully made wooden American pipes.
    [Show full text]
  • The Battle Over Headwaters Forest and the Transformation of American Environmental Politics, 1850 to 1999
    ABSTRACT Dissertation Title: DEFENDING GIANTS: THE BATTLE OVER HEADWATERS FOREST AND THE TRANSFORMATION OF AMERICAN ENVIRONMENTAL POLITICS, 1850 TO 1999 Darren Frederick Speece, Doctor of Philosophy, 2010 Dissertation directed by: Associate Professor David B. Sicilia. Department of History The redwoods have long been a source of inspiration and conflict. By the end of the twentieth century, disputes over logging Redwood Country had helped transform American environmental politics. Historians have largely neglected the redwood wars, but their impact on environmental politics was great. After 1945, the redwood wars ended official corporatist timber regulation in California, established a series of legal precedents governing private property management, and prompted the reordering of the federal environmental protection regime. This dissertation describes those transformations in detail, and helps situate the long history of conflicts over logging the redwoods in American history. The history of the redwood wars demonstrates the ways in which local activism influence the development of environmental politics, Northcoast activists complicate our understanding of radical environmentalism and wilderness ideals, and conservation methodologies persist in the priorities of modern environmentalism. The redwood wars were one of the longest and most violent environmental disputes in American history, beginning during the 1970s and lasting into the twenty-first century. Northcoast residents had grown increasingly concerned about the future of the ancient forest, timber jobs, and their rural culture as the rate of clear-cutting increased and as corporate giants swallowed up land. Some residents organized and challenged the industrial logging regime because of its threat to the health of their rural society. Eventually, the Northcoast was awash in daily direct actions, persistent litigation, and intense media scrutiny.
    [Show full text]
  • LUNA: October 2015 by Stuart Moskowitz
    LUNA: October 2015 by Stuart Moskowitz Sixteen years ago Julia Butterfly Hill came down to the ground after her two year tree-sit in Luna, the 1,000 year old Redwood on the ridge high above Stafford, Humboldt County, California. Julia came down because she achieved the primary goal of her protest: that Luna not be cut into lumber by the Pacific Lumber Company or by any future owner. But Julia achieved much more than the protection of one tree and the surrounding three acre grove. Julia Butterfly’s actions turned Luna into a worldwide symbol of sustainable forestry and showed how one person really can make a difference. There were those who said that Luna and Julia Butterfly would be forgotten. Sixteen years later the world has not forgotten. Luna continues to speak and the world continues to listen. Now more than ever! I get asked continuously how Luna is doing. Why me? My name is Stuart and I have been on the Board of Directors of Sanctuary Forest (SFI) since before Julia climbed into Luna’s branches. I was there when Julia came down, I was there when SFI was entrusted with the Luna Agreement, and I have been the primary caretaker and monitor ever since. I last wrote about Luna in 2007. It’s now time (past time) for another update. Luna’s base on a recent monitoring trip I’m not the best storyteller. Thank goodness storytellers remember Luna, too. I’m excited because award winning author and illustrator Jenny Sue Kostecki-Shaw chose Julia and Luna as the subject of her latest children’s book, Luna and Me, The True Story of a Girl Who Lived in a Tree to Save a Forest (Holt-MacMillan, 2015).
    [Show full text]