623 P-32.Pdf
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
EUGENICS By A. E. HAMILTON INTRODUCTION: HISTORICAL The bubbling over of Eugenics from laboratory and learned society into the public press has left many of us inquiring, with Rabbi Ben Ezra-" We all surmise, they this thing and I that: whom shall my soul believe? " Chestertonian marriage by the police, Schopenhaurian sterilization of all scoundrels, Nietzschean breeding of supermen to run the human race, and even the popular baby-show are regarded as near of kin to what Conklin calls this "infant industry." Eugenics has been epitomized by Chamberlain ( 6), Field (25), and others, while Davenport (I3), Kellicott (48) and Schuster (86) have presented the subject in greater detail. The volum·e of literature claiming to be eugenic grows daily larger and it is the purpose of this paper to review a part of it. Pre-Galtonian writings of eugenic flavor, such as the Bible with its record of the first wholesale elimination of the unfit in the story of Noah; Plato's Republic advocating a lethal chamber to take the place of Lycurgan rocks; Aristotle's pre natal speculations; the song of Theognis of Megara; Cam panella's utopian city of Platonic pattern; ante-nuptial inspec tions as pictured by Sir Thomas Moore; Malthusian concern for the feeding of the species-all these must be passed by with a mere mention. The present eugenics movement sprang from the great mutation in thought initiated by Darwin's "The Origin of Species" in I859 and had its specific starting point in two articles by Francis Galton in MacMillan's Magazine, June and August, I865. Their thesis, that better men could be bred by conscious selection, was continued in " Hereditary Genius " ( 29) published in I869. This was an elaborate and painstaking study of the biogra phies of 977 men who would rank, according to Galton's estimate, as about I in 4,000 of the general population in respect to achievement. The number of families found con taining more than one eminent man was 300, divided as fol lows: Judges 85, Statesmen 39, Commanders 27, Literary 33, 29 EUGENICS EUGENICS 30 Scientific 43, Poets 20, Artists 28, Divines 25. The strong William McDougal next focused the attention of the Society constellations of interrelated eminence led to the conclusion on Eugenics when, in 19o6, he made "A Practicable Eugenic that heredity played a very important part in achievement Suggestion" (54) in the form of an "Endeavor to introduce and suggested that by selecting from strains that bore emi the custom of remunerating the services of every person be nence, a superior human stock could be bred. longing to a selected class (of the racially fit) ac The attention given to Galton's ideas by Sir Charles Lyell cording to a sliding scale such that his income would be larger in his " Geographical Evidences of the Antiquity of Man" in proportion to the number of his living offspring." He and the welcome they received in Darwin's "The Descent of wished the State would take the initiative so that corporations Man " stimulated eugenic thought and encouraged its leader and philanthropies would follow suit if the measure proved to continue his work. He questioned 180 eminent scientists effective. No satisfactory answer, however, was found to relative to their education, inheritance and relationships, and Benjamin Kidd's inquiry as to what constituted the measure from the data obtained built " English Men of Science: Their of breeding fitness in the intellectually superior. Nature and Nurtur·e" (30) which re-emphasized his conten Two years previous to the reading of McDougal's paper tion that heredity played the greater role in achievement. In Galton had founded a Research Fellowship at the University 1883 came Galton's " Inquiries into the Human Faculty and of London to determine, if possible, what the standard of Its Development" (31), a set of evolutionary and anthropo fitness was, and in 1905 a Scholarship was added. Mr. Edgar metric essays where the word Eugenics was first used in a Schuster and Miss E. M. Elderton held these posts until 1907, new exposition of the author's views. "Natural Inheritance" when Professor Karl Pearson took charge of the research (32) appeared in 1889, being the cream of various memoirs work and, at the resignation of Mr. Schuster, Dr. David published since " Hereditary Genius," dealing with the gen Heron was appointed Fellow. On Galton's death, January 17, eral biological principles underlying the study o~ h~r~dity a~d 1911, it became known that through the terms of his will a continuing the study of resemblances between tndividuals m Professorship was founded and Professor Pearson invited to respect to stature, eye color, artistic faculty and morbid con hold it. This corps of workers constitutes the Eugenics ditions. Laboratory staff, whose purpose is pure research. The product Galton watched the slow spread of his idea quietly until of the laboratory is embodied mainly in two series of publica the year 1901 , when he defended " The Possible Improvement tions, Memoirs and Lectures supplemented by Studies in of the Human Breed under Existing Conditions of Law and National Deterioration published by the Department of Applied Sentiment" (33) before the Anthropological Society. Three Mathematics of Vniversity College. Most of the important years later he read a paper entitled ".Eug~nic s ; i~s Defin~ studies have appeared in Biometrica, first issued in 1901. The tion, Scope and Aims" (34), to the Socwlogtcal Soctety. His hearty co-operation of physicians all over the United Kingdom program, in brief, was as follows: . has been secured and it is hoped that the Galton laboratory 1. Disseminate knowledge of hereditary laws as far as surely may become an effective clearing house for all authenticated known and promote their further study. material on human heredity that may come to light in the 2. Inquire into birth rates of various. strat.a of society fields of pathology and normality. In 1901, Professor Pear (classified according to civic usefulness) m ancient and mod son (73) delivered a lecture on national stability as related to ern nations. heredity which attracted wide attention owing to its timeli 3· Collect reliable data showing how large and thriving ness, coming as it did when England was appalled at her losses families have most frequently originated. in the South African war, to which she had sent much of 4· Study the influences affecting marriage. her best breeding stock. 5· Persistently set forth the national importance of Eu- A notable discussion of the strictly hereditary aspects of genics. · . Eugenics took place before the Royal Society of Medicine (8) The ye?r following, Galton agam. read before t~e Society in 1908, when Professors Pearson and Bateson upheld re (35), suggesting the award <;>f ~ertlficates of q~ahty to the spectively the biometrician and mendelian methods of approach eugenically fit. He also mamtame~ th~t. marnage custom.s to the problem of inheritance. It is regrettable that the con which are largely controlled by pubhc opm10n could be modi troversy between the two schools has not by this time dwindled fied tor racial welfare through a moulding of public sentiment. to negligible proportions, since they represent the obverse and 31 EUGENICS EUGENICS 32 reverse of the same labor to a common end. Perhaps the day one of the many considerations by which marriages are pro will come when the biometrician, dealing with mass values in moted 9r hindered, as they are by social position, adequate the way he is peculiarly fitted by training to do, will be ready fortune, and similarity of creed." to receive, classify, analyze and correlate the data gathered Lester Ward (93) attracted" much attention to Eugenics by the mendelian in his intensive study of individual phe through his vigorous opposition to Galton's idea of the nomena. At the same time, the biologist must be called upon supremacy of nature over nurture. Hobhouse ( 42) sees a to give adequate proof that his data are sound and thoroughly mutually cancellatory process in variation of good and bad tested before they shall be so used. and believes progress to be more dependent on the survival To spread such knowledge of Eugenics as might be gathered of the good than on the elimination of the weak. He sees by specialists, the Eugenics Education Society was formed i~ in the writings of Eug·enists no inductive basis for assuming 1908 with Francis Galton as honorary president and a counctl race deterioration and argues that, "It is not human quality of forty to direct its policy. Its official orga~ is the Eug~nics whether original or acquired that differs profoundly from Review, in which papers read before the soctety and a dtgest period to period. It is the turn given to human quality by of all matters of eugenic import appear. Branches of the so,eial structure." He points out that Spencer's law of the Society have been formed in Belfast, Birmingham, Glasgow, invers.e ratio of fertility and development is no new thing, Haslemere, Liverpool, Manchester, five in New Zealand and and that the race probably always will recruit itself from one in Australia. There is a large membership also in the what are termed the lower strata of society. Not lack of United States. The scope of interest comprises: (a) Biology parental instinct, but consideration for wife and child, he in so far as it concerns hereditary selection, (b) Anthropology holds to be at the root of so called race suicide, and believes as related to race and marriage, (c) Politics, where it bean> education will in due course keep the race from the extremes on parenthood in relation to civic wort~, (d) Ethics in .so f_at of birth limitation.