UC Berkeley Perspectives in Medical Humanities
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
UC Berkeley Perspectives in Medical Humanities Title What to Read on Love, not Sex: Freud, Fiction, and the Articulation of Truth in Modern Psychological Science Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/67c9k0q7 ISBN 9780983463962 Author Miyawaki, Edison, M.D. Publication Date 2012-07-12 eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California Perspectives in Medical Humanities Freud, Fiction, and the Articulation of Truth in Modern Psychological Science Photo: E. B. Busenbark This extraordinary work traverses the boundaries of Freudian concepts, religious experience, art, and modern neuroscience to examine the ‘significance of love,’ Edison Miyawaki teaches perhaps the most abiding and important of all human emotions and reflections. neurology and psychiatry at the The book is a treasure with deep significance for everyone. Brigham and Women’s Hospital – Joseph B. Martin, M.D., Ph.D. Edward R. and Anne G. Lefler Professor of Neurobiology and Dean Emeritus, Harvard Medical School Freud, as literature, and Harvard Medical School in Modern Psychological Science of Truth Freud, Fiction, and the Articulation is a guide to love in Boston, Massachusetts. A fresh, lucid, and imaginative look at Freud’s influence on how we read ourselves and His essays for a general readership the work— art and love —we undertake. Miyawaki here engages a complex and elusive subject as the summit of life. have appeared in The Atlantic, that few have ever addressed with a more humane understanding. Edison Miyawaki joins The American Scholar, and, – J. D. McClatchy Editor, The Yale Review himself to that quest regularly, inThe Yale Review. in this heartening He divides his time between Boston and Kansas City, Missouri. University of California and lucid study of Medical Humanities Consortium 3333 California Street, Suite 485 much that still matters San Francisco, CA 94143-0850 www.medicalhumanities.ucsf.edu most in Freud. – Harold Bloom, from the Foreword University of California Medical Humanities Press ISBN 978-0-9834639-6-2 Edison Miyawaki, M.D. www.medicalhumanities.ucsf.edu 90000 Freud, Fiction, and the Articulation of Truth in Modern Psychological Science 9 780983 463962 Cover Design by Miyuki Design Edison Miyawaki, M.D. | Foreword by Harold Bloom Freud, Fiction, and the Articulation of Truth in Modern Psychological Science Perspectives in Medical Humanities Perspectives in Medical Humanities publishes peer reviewed scholarship produced or reviewed under the auspices of the University of California Medical Humanities Consortium, a multi-campus collaborative of faculty, students, and trainees in the humanities, medicine, and health sciences. Our series invites scholars from the humanities and health care professions to share narratives and analysis on health, healing, and the contexts of our beliefs and practices that impact biomedical inquiry. General Editor Brian Dolan, PhD, Professor of Social Medicine and Medical Humanities, University of California, San Francisco (ucsf) Recent Titles Paths to Innovation: Discovering Recombinant DNA, Oncogenes and Prions, In One Medical School, Over One Decade By Henry Bourne (Fall 2011) Clowns and Jokers Can Heal Us: Comedy and Medicine By Albert Howard Carter iii (Fall 2011) The Remarkables: Endocrine Abnormalities in Art By Carol Clark and Orlo Clark (Winter 2011) Health Citizenship: Essays in Social Medicine and Biomedical Politics By Dorothy Porter (Winter 2011) Darwin and the Emotions: Mind, Medicine and the Arts Edited by Angelique Richardson and Brian Dolan (Fall 2012) www.medicalhumanities.ucsf.edu This series is made possible by the generous support of the Dean of the School of Medicine at ucsf, the Center for Humanities and Health Sciences at ucsf, and a Multicampus Research Program Grant from the University of California Office of the President. For SYM in memoriam and EHM Freud, Fiction, and the Articulation of Truth in Modern Psychological Science Edison Miyawaki, M.D. | Foreword by Harold Bloom University of California Medical Humanities Press 2012 First published in 2012 by University of California Medical Humanities Press in partnership with eScholarship | University of California San Francisco – berkeley – london © 2012 by Edison Miyawaki University of California Medical Humanities Consortium 3333 California Street, Suite 485 San Francisco, CA 94143-0850 Cover Art: Leonardo da Vinci, Virgin and Child with Saint Anne and a Lamb (unfinished), Louvre, © Getty Images, with permission Design by Margaret N. Miyuki and Agnes T. Miyuki Figures on page 171: Mona Lisa–Portrait of Lisa Gherardini, wife of Francesco del Giocondo/Leonardo da Vinci/The Bridgeman Art Library/ © Getty Images Virgin and Child with St. Anne/Leonardo da Vinci/The Bridgeman Art Library/ © Getty Images St. John the Baptist/Leonardo da Vinci/The Bridgeman Art Library/ © Getty Images Library of Congress Control Number: 2012934221 isbn 978-0-9834639-5-5 (paperback) isbn 978-0-9834639-6-2 (hardback) Printed in usa Contents Foreword ix Introduction 1 1 Plato’s Memory 16 2 Oedipus 34 3 Narcissus 57 4 Cordelia 85 5 Hamlet 118 6 Leonardo 143 7 Moses 174 8 Postscript 203 Acknowledgments & Sources 214 Index of Authors or Works 241 Foreword taught Dr. Edison Miyawaki at Yale both when he was an undergraduate Iand graduate student of literature. His long-gestated book on Freud moves and delights me. Sigmund Freud’s hope that psychoanalysis would make a contribution to biology was mistaken. Instead, Freud became the Montaigne of his age, a great moral essayist who attained the literary eminence of Proust, Joyce, Kafka, Beckett. The science of love, for secularists, finds its authentic sages in Plato, Dante, Shakespeare, Tolstoi, and Proust. Freud, at his subtlest, is a sixth in that visionary company. The vulgar misunderstanding of Freud, still too prevalent, regards him as a mere sexologist. Miyawaki’s enterprise is to correct this undisciplined view, so as to restore our sense of the Freudian Speculation. Ludwig Wittgenstein thought he deprecated Freud’s theory of mind by calling it a speculation, not a philosophic venture, but to me that mode of wonder is the great strength of psychoanalysis. Edison Miyawaki would agree. Like Wittgenstein, he too shows that love is not a feeling. Love, un- like pain, is put to the test. We do not say: “that was not a true pain, because it passed away so quickly.” Like Freud, Miyawaki is both a neurologist and a literary humanist. If we are to continue our creative apprehension of Freud, we require an under- standing that literature is a way of life. Freud, as literature, is a guide to love as the summit of life. Edison Miyawaki joins himself to that quest in this heartening and lucid study of much that still matters most in Freud. — Harold Bloom ix Introduction mong psychological writers in the last two centuries, Sigmund Freud’s Afundamental originality, as this book argues, had to do with the stories and art he chose to describe our greatest emotion. He used a great deal of clinical material in his writing, as one would expect from a doctor in practice, but he referred often and strategically to works of the imagination, because they were repositories of knowledge as useful as anything he learned from his patients. He once wrote, in a stark irony, that “only rarely” is a psycho- analyst compelled to study art. Yet throughout his career, Freud stole from stories and art like a proud thief, always in the name of science. Today, courses in psychology and psychiatry address brain science; pro- fessionals obsess over their “basis in evidence.” Why should a modern psy- chologist venture away from the lab or clinic, into non-science? The simple answer is that there is data to be found there, especially if one reconsiders Freud’s all-but-forgotten claim that every day, speaking psychologically, we rehearse stories and themes articulated long ago in works that are canonical in the Western tradition. Consider “love,” scientifically. If we aren’t precise about what it is, then a “science of love” will be difficult to conduct. Love is complex (it is not a complex), yet we all claim to know what it is, intuitively and intimately. So why can’t we understand it with thoroughgoing empiricism? If we examine Freud’s career with more charity than some have exhibited in recent years, we might understand at least one very important—and possibly unavoid- able—impediment to knowledge. Sometimes, in studying a phenomenon, we do violence to the very thing that we study, maybe because theory (like Freudian theory) gets in the way. What follows is not a book about the psy- choanalysis of anything. It is a new look at a lesson buried in the depths and sources of Freud’s writings. We will learn about an issue that is acute today: at what point do we approach a limit in articulating what the subject of our scientific study is? Regarding human love, a line of crossing lies somewhere 2 What to Read on Love, Not Sex between calling it a biological drive to perpetuate the species by sexual en- counter on the one hand, and, on the other, some greater, vaguer, and more beautiful complexity involving many affects—call it “love,” which is the best word we have for love. I’ll build a case that a real science of the emotions (ac- tually, any human emotion), is a problem of finding an adequately intricate language to describe the subject in question. It is a writerly conundrum and an artistic one as well, and it’s a problem at the core of modern psychology and psychiatry. Freud had some ideas about whom we might consult on the subject of “adequate” language, and his suggestions aren’t bad—in fact, he offers an extraordinary reading list. I think a new discussion of his sources is worth a short book, intended mainly but not exclusively for psychiatrists and psy- chologists.