1

CHARGE SHEET

Police station Dist Charge sheet No 65/08 Date 15-2-08 Name, address & occupation of complainant / informer Shri VK Solanki Service Naroda police station Ahmedabad city. First information report no I CR No 100/02/Date 28- 2-02.

Name address of Name address of Property (including Name and address of Charge or accused sent for trial accused not sent up weapons) found with witness. information name in custody on bail. for trial whether particulars of where, of offence & address and not when by & by whom circumstance addressed found & whether connected with it, including forwarded to Magistrate. in concise detail & absconders under what section (show absconder in of law charged. red ink). 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 1. Babubhai @ Babu Arrested. 1.Complainant him Offence : u/s Vanzara D/o Pappu Sindhi, self. 143,147,148,149, Jethabhai Salat Add. 2. Complainant Shri 302,332,323,395, (Marwadi) Age-34, Kubernagar, Mahemudbhai 396, 397,398, 435, 2

Add.- Naherunagar Naroda Patiya, Abbasbhai Bagdadi 436, 427, 376, 120 Chhapra, Nr. Ahmedabad & resi at Chetandas’s B, 186,188, 153(A) Jaybhavani Colony, other 15 to 17 chali beside ST (1) (A) (B) and part Rajavir, F-Ward peoples mob workshop Naroda 2 of 153 (A) (1) of Kubernagar, Ahmedabad. IPC and U/s 135 (1) Ahmedabad------(Naroda I 111/02). of BP Act, in such 3. Complainant Shri a way that, as the Sumarmiyan incident of burning Muhammadmiyan alive 58 (Hindu) Makrani resi at karsevaks Imambibi’s chali traveling in opposite Nurani express mosque Naroda train had occurred (Naroda I 115/02). at Godhra on past 4. Ummedhasan 27-2-02, Vishva kallubhai Kureshi resi Hindu Parishad at Javaharnagar had given a call of beside ST workshop bandha on Naroda Ahmedabad. 28-2-02. Hence, as (Naroda 17/02). the accused 5. Complainant Smt persons No 1 to 23 3

Abjalbanu w/o of column No 1 and Liyakathusen the arrested Badamiya by cast accused persons Baloch resi at stated in column Hukumsing’s chali no 2 but not Naroda beside ST chargesheeted and workshop Naroda the accused Ahmedabad. persons No 1 to 5 (Naroda police station I under the CR No 127/02). investigation and 6. Complainant the absconding Taufikmiyan accused persons Akbarmiyan by cast no 1 to 21 and the Sumra resi at crowd of about Imambibi’ s chali 15 to 17 beside Naroda ST thousands workshop Naroda unknown persons Ahmedabad. (Naroda I of Hindu 129/02). community, whose 7.Complainant names etc could Akbarmiyan not be known, 4

Jammandmiyan Sumra with intention to resi at Hukumsing’s express anger of chali Naroda patiya. Godhra train (Naroda I CR no carnage upon ST, 130/02). Patiya, Nurani 8. Complainant Shri mosque, alleged Allauddin Adambhai Husennagar chali Mansuri resi at near ST work shop, Husennagar Naroda Javaharnagar, patiya. (Naroda police Saijpur Tower, station I CR No Thakkarnagar, 153/02). Bhagyoday hotel 9. Complainant situate in Naroda Sufiyabanu Yakubhai police station area, Shaikh resi at with intenton to Javannagar Naroda cause to damage patiya. to muslim Complainant of community, to Naroda I 161/02) . succeed in their 10. Complainant criminal Kasamali Akbarali conspiracy, being 5

Saiyad resi at united, formed Imambibi’s chali patiya unlawful assembly, Naroda . in furtherance of ( I CR No 162/02). their common 11. Complainant intention, being Jubedabibi Rashidbhai armed with deadly Shaikh resi at weapons like Javannagar Naroda sword, gupti, pipe, patiya (Naroda I CR dhariya, stick, no 163/02). trishuls and 12. Complainant carboys full of Kamrunnishan inflammable liquid Muradali Shaikh upon the residential (Naroda I CR no houses, shops, 164/02). vehicles and 13. Complainant Nurani mosque of Farukbhai kasambhai muslims in Saiyad resi at aforesaid areas of Husennagar Naroda Naroda police patiya (Naroda police station, uttered station I CR no slogans such as 6

176/02). ‘Jayshriram’, 14. Complainant shouted like beat Hasanbhai cutdown Miyans, Abubakkarbhai Saiyad without thinking of resi at Husennagar any result as to Naroda patiya. communal riots Complainant of would spread to Naroda I CR no create disgrace 177/02). between 15. Complainant communities, Allarakha instigated by Gulamuhammad malice. Malek resi at In which the Badarsing’s chali arrested accussed Naroda patiya (Naroda persons no. 1 police station I CR no Babubhai @ Babu 179/02). Vanzara @ 16. Complainant Jethabhai Salat Mahebubbhai (Marvadi) accoding Muhammadhusen to witness no. 264 Shaikh resi as above. Shokat Nabibhai 7

Complainant of Naroda Mansuri seen him police station I CR no with sword in the 180/02. mob and he 17. Complainant shouted sloguns to Sayrabanu Mahebub cut Muslims. bhai Shaikh resi as According to his above.( Naroda I CR no statement witness 181/02). stated that 18. Complainant damaged his own Basubhai Maiyuddin Gerage By mob & Saiyad. Resi at… do… burnt but also (Naroda I CR no surrounded area of 182/02). the muslims 19. Complainant community . Munirshah Samsuddin Shaikh resi as above. (Naroda I CR no 183/02). This witness 20. Complainant identified the Munirkhan accused as Babu Jahangirkhan Pathan Vanzara in 8

resi as above. (Naroda presence of Exe. police station 184/02). Magistrate. Thus, the accused persons arrested and not arrested of aforesaid column no 1 acuussed No. 1,to …….. & Supl. Chargesheet Colum no. 1 Acussed no. 1 to 8 & as per this Chargesheet colum no. 1 acussed No. 1 & colum no. 2 who are absconding and the persons of crowd of other 15 to 17 thousands committed aforesaid serious criminal act and 9

beat, cut down and burnt alive and caused the death of 83 persons, in which women men and children are included and committed rape upon muslim girls and women and violated their modesty and commited breach of public peace and put human life and physical safety in danger and committed obstruction in the duty of Police officer and 10

employees on duty and made stone throwing and caused hurt and pulled down the houses, house hold articles, vehicles and Nurani mosque of muslims and set on fire and looted and spoiled the same and thereby caused the damage of about 56 lacs and committed the breach of Notiification No U/ GPK/ Visha/ 576/01 dated 27- 12-2001 having been notified 11

from 1-1-2002 to 28-2-02, u/s 37 (1) of 22nd Mumbai Police Act 1951 of the Police Commissioner Ahmedabad and thereby the accused persons no 1 to 23 & 24 to 37 (1 to 14) & 38 to 45 (1 to 8) accused No (46) as per charge sheet column no. 1 is arrested column no 2 being arrested and absconding accused persons no 1 and other unknown persons of crowd of 15 to 17 12

thosuansds ran away and there by committed the offence etc.

21. Complainant Samsuddin Khavajahusen Shaikh resi as above. (Naroda I 185/02). 22. Complainant Abudulkarim Saiyadrasul Shaikh resi at kumbhaji’s chali Naroda patiya. ( Naroda I CR no 187/02). 23. Complainant Shri Usmanbhai Daudbhai resi. at kumbhaji’s chali Naroda patiya (Complainant of Naroda police station I CR no 188/02). 24. Complainant Shri Muhammadsalim Abudlrahim Shaikh resi. at Pandit’s chali opp Nurani mosque Naroda patiya Ahmedabad. ( Naroda police station I CR no 204/02). 25. Complainant Shri Rashidbhai Bashirbhai Shaikh resi opp Nurani mosque naroda ptiya Ahmedabad. Naroda (Complainant of Naroda I CR no 208/02). 26. Complainant Shri Ibrahimbhai Daudbhai Mansuri resi. at Husennagar ‘s chali Patiya (complainant of Naroda I CR no 210/02). 27. Complainant Shri Husenabanu wife of Ajgarkhan Gafurkhan Pathan resi. at Husennagar Naroda patiya Ahmedabad (Naroda I CR no 238/02). 28. Complainant Shri Anishabanu D/o Kasambhai Rehamanbhai Mansuri resi at Naroda patiya Javannagar Ahmedabad. (Naroda I CR no 267/02). (Complainant of Naroda I CR no 267/02). Panch 29. Pancha 1 Narendrabhai Bechardas Kahar, Resi at Raykhad Prasad Mill’s Chawl, 1973/19/C, Jamalpur, Ahmedabad. 30. Panch 2 Abdul Rahim Abdul Gafar Shaikh, Resi at Manekchowk Badsha’s Hajira, 2531/1, Ahmedabad. (Recover Swords from Suresh @ Richard @ Suresh Langdo) 31. Panch 1 Ashish Babulal Shah, Resi. at Shahpur Darvaja Khancha, Chhabila Khadki, Ahmedabad. 13

32. Pancha 2 Kiritsinh Arjunsinh Darbar, Resi. at Shahpur Gate’s Khancha, Sankdi Sheri, Ahmedabad 33. Pancha 1. Ajitkumar Dahyalal Shah resi at 16/12 Harivila flat New Naroda 34. Pancha 2. Rajeshbhai Parsottambhai Patel. Resi at 12/2 Harivila flat New Naroda. (Panchas of scene of offence of place ) (panchas of scene of offence). Naroda I CR no 100/02. 35. Pancha 1. Sanjay @ Dinesh Babubhai Bharvad resi at Bharvadvas Narodagam. 36. Pancha 2 Prakashkumar Ratilal Shah karunesh building D/18 opp Cotton factory Naroda Ahmedabad. (FIR No. 100/2) Supplementary panchnama of scene offence). (Naroda I CR no 100/02). 37. Pancha 1. Bhagvandas Gokalji Yadav resi at 79/1238 Krishanagar H/Colony Naroda. 38. Pancha 2. Gulabsing Shri Swarupsing Rajput resi at Parshavanath Township part 10 House no 42 New Naroda Ahmedabad. (Panchas of scene of offence of Naroda I CR no 111/02). 39. Pancha 1. Rakeshbhai Hashmatrav Sindhi. Resi at F ward 133 kubernagar Naroda. 40. Pancha 2. Bharatsing Chandan sing Tomar resi at Mahakalinagar near Omkar factory Memco Naroda Ahmedabad. (Panchas of scene of offence of Naroda I CR no 115/02, 129/02. 41. Pancha 1 Ajitkumar Dahyalal Shah resi at 16/12 Harivilla flat New Naroda . 42. Pancha 2 Rajeshbhai Parsottamdas Patel resi at 12/2 Harivlla flat New Naroda. (Panchas of scene offence of Naroda I 117/02 and Naroda I CR no 130/02). 43.Pancha 1 kalumiyan Motimiyan Chauhan resi at Husennagar Naroda patiya Ahmedabad. 44.Pancha 2. Muhammadjafar Samadbhai Shaikh resi as above. (Panchas of scene of offence of Naroda I CR no 153/02). 45. Panchas 1Vinod Ramubhai Jadav resi at Parshavanath Township part 7 / 86 New Naroda Ahmedabad. 46. Panchas 2 Rajusing Sayasing rajput Parshavanath Township part 10 House no 42 New Naroda Ahmedabad. 47.Pancha 1 Ranjitsing Vajesing Bihola resi at Punjabhai ‘s Chali Saijpur Bogha Ahmedabad. 14

48. Pancha 2 Vinodbhai kalabhai Babariya resi at Dhanushdhari society Shakti chok Fadeli Saijpur Bogha Naroda Ahmedabad. 49. Pancha 1 Mangilal Bhairulal Dhobi resi at kashiram Mama’s chali near Nurani mosque Naroda. 50. Pancha 2. Baldevsing Vijaysing Zala resi. at Gangotri society near ST workshop Naroda patiya. (panchas of Naroda I CR No I 181/02), I 182/02). 51. Panchas 1 Anilbhai Prakashbhai Marathi resi. at Harivlla flat New Naroda Ahmedabad. 52. Pancha 2. Ompraksh Ramlal Parmar Resi… do…. (panchas of scene of offence of Naroda I CR no 184/02). 53. Pancha 1 Manuji Babarji Dabhi resi at Raypur ta dist Gandhinagar. 54. Pancha 2. Tirthraj Banshidhar Tivari resi at V 1 Parishramnagar Krishananagar Naroda Ahmedabad. ( Panchas of scene offence of Naroda I CR no 185/02). 55. Pancha 1. Gautambhai Rashiklal Chaudhary resi at Hukamsing ‘s chali beside Nurani mosque Naroda. 56. Pancha 2. Rajesh Shivabhai Rathod resi … do…. ( Panachas of scene of offence of Naroda I CR no 188/02). 57. Pancha 1. Bhagvandas Zumkamal Sindhi resi at Shantinagar A/28 Near New chal Saijpur Naroda. 58. Pancha 2 Prakashbhai Ratilal Vyas resi at Limda chok Naroda gam Ahmedabad. ( Panchas of scene off offence of Naroda I 238/02). 59. Pancha 1. Pankajkumar kachradas Shah resi at Parshvanath shopping center D/16 b/h Naroda gam 60. Pancha 2 Narsima Kishanbhai Anjamore (Marathi). Resi at 57 Anshuya society beside Noble nagar Naroda Ahmedabad. (Panchanma of cloths seized from the body of deceased Muhammadshafi A Shaikh). 61.Pancha 1.Savera Ramashre Varma resi at F/102 Sumtinath Prabhu society kathvada road Naroda. 62. Pancha 2. Suresh Revabhai Gohil resi Vankarvas Mudiya gam Naroda Ahmedabad. (Panchnama drawn in respect of earring etc seized from the body of unknown woman. 63. Pancha 1. Virpalsing Ramswarup Chauhan resi B/h Choky Fakir Raval chali Odhav Ahmedabad. 64. Pancha 2. Narendrasing Ratansing Chauhan. Resi at A/73. Harivila society near Parshvanath Saijpur Ahmedabad. 15

(Panchas of cassette of video grapy of scene of offence seized). 65. Pancha 1. Shantilal Ludharmal Chelani resi at Block no 400 Ahmedabad. 66. Pancha 2. Prakashbhai Balchand Gordasanai resi at Juna G ward block no 23 kubernagar. (Panchnama of mobile phone seized. Naroda I 238/02). 67. Pancha 1. MukeshAtamaram Bodana resi at B No 3/20 Chanakyapuri Ahmedabad. 68. Pancha 2. Arvindkumar Maganbhai Chauhan resi at Babunagar B/h Danilimda police choky Ahmedabad. (Panchnama of carboy (kerosene) seized from accused Ratilal @ Jaybhavani). 69. Pancha 1. Dayalbhai Khemchand Lakhani resi at New bungalow area Biscuit gali House no 5 Kubernangar Naroda Ahmedabad. 70. Pancha 2 Dilip Antumal Goplani resi at Block no 16/B B/h Sainbaba temple Sardarnagar Ahmedabad. 71. Pancha 1Abdul Hajij Abudlhamid Shaikh resi at Husenangar Saijpur Naroda patiya Ahmedabad. 72. Pancha 2. Muhammad marufkhan Raufvaliullahkhan Pathan resi at Javannagar Naroda patiya . ( Panchnama of identification of corpse by witness Rajjakbbhai U Shaikh). 73. Pancha 1. Muhammadrajjak Faiyazbhai Kureshi resi at Devjipura Bhangilal’s chali Shahibag Ahmedabad. 74. Pancha 2. Pappubhai Sharifkhan Muhammdalif Chhipa resi at kashiram ‘s chali Naroda. ( Panchnama of identification of corpse by witness Shahnazbhai Navabbhai Kureshi. 75. Pancha 1 Muhammdrafik Allabax Shaikh resi beside ST workshop Nurani mosque Naroda. 76. Pancha 2. Abudlrashid Abudlbhai Shaikh resi at Mahadevnagar Nana Chharanagar Patiya Naroda. ( Panchnama of identification of corpse by witness Jabbarbhai Jamalbhai Sipai ). 76/1. Pancha 1Vijaybhai Vishnubhai Patel, Resi at Rannapark, B/5, Manekbaug Appartment, Ghatlodiya, Ahmedabad. 76/2. Pancha 2 Jasvant Punamchand Chudasma, Resi at Raykhad, Bhatiya Pole, H/no.2021, Ahmedabad.( Recover Swords from Manojbhai @ Manoj Sindhi & Ranumal Kulkarni) 76/3. Pancha 1Dilipbhai Khengarji Chauhan, Resi at Raykhad, Opp. Opera Guest House, Jamalpur, Ahmedabad. 16

76/4. Pancha 2 Ashok Amrutlal Patel, Resi at Jagannath Mandir’s Chawl, Opp. Fire Station, Jamalpur, Ahmedabad. .( Recover Swords from Bipinbhai @ Bipin Autowala & Umedray Panchal)

Inquest panchnama.

77. Pancha 1 Maganbhai Khemabhai Vanzara resi at 1 Bhagirath bungalow Thakkarnagar road Naroda 78. Pancha 2. Arvindbhai Jodhaji Vanzara. resi. at Anil Vakil’s chali Naroda road Ahmedabad. 79. Pancha 2. Jayshukhbhai kalyanbhai Sojitra resi at Dwarkesh dham B no 36 Viratnagar road . 80. Pacnha 2. Vijaykumar Devshibhai Parmar resi at Dwarkeshdham. 81. Pancha 1. Rameshbhai Somabhai Vanzara Premnagar Anil vakil’s chali Memco Naroda road. 82. Pancha 2. Dayalsing Mansing Patel Khodidas’s new chali Asarva Ahmedabad. 83. Pancha 1. Lalbhai Bababhai Patel resi at Saijpur gam Mahadev vali fail Naroda Ahmedabad. 84. Pancha 2. Pravinaba lakhubha Jadeja resi at 86 Gopinath society beside Javaharnagar Naroda. 85. Pancha 1. Abdulkarim Saiyadrasul Shaikh resi at Javaharnagar’s chhapra Naroda patiya Ahmedabad. 86. Pancha 2 Nilesh Umakant Shah resi at 87/1653 Housing colony Krishananagar Saijpur Ahmedabad. 87. Pancha 1 Madhuben Narendrabhai Patel resi at Shahibag Dabarnagar Ahmedabad. 88. Pancha 2 Jitendra Rashiklal Patel opp Civil Khodabhai’s chali Ahmedabad. 89. Pancha 1. Dhalumal Udaram Pavar resi at 839/3 Shiv shaktinagar Ambavadi Sardarnagar. 90. Pancha 2. Madanalal Pukhraj Pavar resi at Bhilvas near Water tank Shiv shaktinagar, S nagar. 91. Pancha 1. Jinaji Maganji Marvadi resi at Madhupura Marvadi’ s chali Opp Police station Madhupura. 92. Pancha 2. Rajesh Thavardas Lalvani resi at Hariyana Kashmir Transport Co Saijpur patiya. 17

93. Pancha 1. Shamjibhai Ganagabhai Gohil resi at Baherampura 29/752 Parixitlalnagar Ahmedabad. 94. Pancha 2. Dineshbhai Rajabhai Sondarva resi at 18/422 Parixitlal nagar near Bhulabhai cross roads Baherampura Ahmedabad. 95. Pancha 1. Popatji Becharji Thakor resi. Opp. Parmeshvar park Chhapra, B/h Civil hospital Shahibag Ahmedabad. 96. Pancha 2. Maharajgiri Keshavgiri Goswami resi at Saijpur Fadeli Shakti chok Naroda road. 97. Pancha 1 Mohanbhai Ravjibhai Harijan resi. near SRP quarters Chhapra Saijpur Naroda Ahmedabad. 98. Pancha 2. Madhuben Vijaybhai Thakor resi near ST workshop Chhapra Naroda patiya. 99. Pancha 1. Prahaladbhai Manubhai Chunara resi near Bal Krishana nagar Chhapra Saijpur Bogha. 100. Pancha 2.Sudhaben w/o Gautambhai Rashiklal Chaudhary resi at Hukumsing’ s chali Naroda patiya. 101. Pancha 1. MuhammadIbrahim Sabayamanpuri resi at Bhikhabhai’s chali B/h Fish market Rakhiyal Ahmedabad. 102. Pancha 2. Muhammadali Samirahmad Pathan resi at Sundaramnagar B/h Gujarat bottling Rakhiyal. 103. Pancha 1.Mustufa Yakubbhai Salat resi at village Mandal Ta. Viramgam Dist. Ahmedabad. 104. Pancha 2.Kanubhai Gandalal Nayi resi at village kalol Juna chora Ganjivas Ta kalol Mahesana. 105. Pancha 1. Abdulbhai Iliyashbhai Kariya resi at Sankalchand Mukhi’ s chali Devjipura beside police line Shahibag Ahmedabad. 106. Pancha 2. Yusufbhai Hasamabhai Kutchi resi at Narmandpura’ s chali Ismail Shaikh’ s chali Shahibag. 107. Pancha 3. Shaileshbhai Vasantrav Dalvi resi at BJ Medical staff quarters C block room no 31 Civil hospital Compound Shahibag Ahmedabad. 108. Pancha 2. Prahaladbhai Khushalbhai Mali resi near Civil hospital B block hostel Shahibag. 109. Pancha 1. Najirkhan Rahimkhan Pathan resi at Dariyakhan Ghummat Relief Camp. 110. Pancha 2. Muhammadiqubal Sulemanbhai Kureshi (Manjothi). Resi …do… 111. Pancha 1. Narbahdur Pratapsang Bhisti resi at Saijpur opp Gayatri society Cheharnagar’s chhapra. 112. Pancha 2. Tejiben w/o Devjibhai Mohanlal Parmar resi at Rohitnagar society House no 26 B/h Civil hospital Shahibag Ahmedabad. 113. Pancha 1. Kasamali Allauddin Kureshi resi at Vajavali chali Hathikhai 114. Pancha 2.MuhammadMunvvar Muhammadramzani resi … do… 18

115. Pancha 1. Mahendra Brijgopal Kanojiya resi at 90 park B/h Samjuba hospital Bapunagar. 116. Pancha 2. Jatinbhai Dashrathbhai Gajjar resi at Bhagvatinagar near Sureliya Estate Amraivadi. 117. Pancha1. Ravjibhai Devjibhai Talpada resi at village Bhalgamda Ta Limdi Dist Surendrangar. 118. Panch2. Maganhai Kalubhai Patel resi at Bhalgamda Ta Limbdi Dist Surendrangar. Punch Of Identification 118/1. Pancha 1Vikramchand Mangilal Pandey, Resi at 32/A, Krushnkumj Society, Opp. Viratnagar, , Ahmedabad. 118/2. Pancha 2 Devjibhai Tulsibhai Vegda, Resi at Opp. Baldevnagar Majkur Gam, Gita Mandir Road, Ahmedabad.------118/3. Pancha 1 Mohammad Javed Mohammad Usman Saiyed, Resi at Fakirbhai Chal, B/h Rakhiyal Po. Sta., Chhapra, Raykhad , Ahmedabad. 118/4. Pancha 2 Mukeshbhai Babubhaui Sonvane, Resi at Opp. Raykhad Bhoiwada Opera Guest House, Chhapra, Raykhad, Ahmedabad.(Accused Babu @ Babubahi vanzara Punch of identification in presence of Exi.Mg)

Public witness 119. Witness Rajiyabanu Anwarhussain Moinuddin Sheikh’ Wife, Resi at Jikarhasam’s Chawl, Naroda Patiya, Ahmedabad. 120. Witness Sarmoddin Khwajahussain Shaikh, Resi at Badarsing’s Chawl, H/No. 1, Naroda Patiya, Ahmedabad. 121. Witness Salimali Roshanali Shaikh, Resi at Javannagar, Naroda Patiya, Ahmedabad. 122. Witness Meblahussain Munirahmed Shaikh, Resi at 511, Javannagar, Naroda Patiya, Ahmedabad. 123. Khalik Noormohammad Shaikh, Resi at Khumbhaji’s Chawl, Room No.17, Naroda Patiya, Ahmedabad. 124. Witness Dildar Umrav Saiyad resi at Javaharnagar Husen chok Naroda patiya Ahmedabad. 125. Witness Najirmuhammad Faizmuhammad resi at Javahrnagar Naroda patiya Ahmedabad. 126. Witness Abdulmajid Muhammadusman Shaikh resi at Javannagar Naroda patiya Ahmedabad. 127. Witness Shakurbhai Tajubhai Shaikh resi at Javannagar Naroda patiya Ahmedabad. 128. Witness Rahemanbhai Shakurbhai Saiyad. Resi at… do… 19

129 Witness Farjanabanu w/o Aeeyubbhai kalekhan Pathan resi at Imamabibi’s chali patiya. 130. Witness Najmabanu d/o Usmankhan Manakhan Pathan resi at Pandit’s chali Patiya. 131. Witness Sharfarzkhan Mahebubkhan Pathan resi at Javannagar Naroda patiya Ahmedabad. 132. Witness Jayedabibi widow of Muhammadmustak Abdullah kureshi resi… do…. 133. Reshmaben wife of Nadim Sharifuddin Saiyad resi at Pandit’s chali Narodapatiya Ahmedabad. 134. Witness Abdulrajjak Imamshah Shaikh resi at Husennagar Naroda patiya. Ahmedabad. 135. Witness Jinnatbibi wife of kallubhai Idubhai Shaikh resi at Javaharnagar patiya. 136. Fatimabibi w/o Muhammadyusuf Ibrahimbhai Shaikh resi at Hukumsing’s chali Patiya. 137. Witness Muhammadashraf karimbhai Bhatti. Resi at Kashrim’s chali beside Nurani mosque, patiya. 138. Jainulabedin Muhammadkhan Shaikh resi at Second lane, Husen’s chali Patiya Naroda. 139. Witness Ibrahimbhai Chhotubhai Shaikh resi at …do… 140. Witness Raishkhan Mahemudkhan Pathan resi at …do… Sixth lane. 141. Witness Lalabhai Nizambhai Luhar resi at… do… Sixth lane. 142.Muhammadshafi Allabax Mansuri resi near ST workshop beside Rationing shop Patiya. 143. Witness Anishkhan Nashirkhan Mansuri resi at Javaharnagar Naroda patiya Ahmedabad. 144. Witness Bashirkhan Nannekhan Pathan resi at Husennagar Naroda patiya 145. Witness Bilkishbanu wife of Yakubbhai Rehamanbhai Mansuri resi at… do… 146. Witness Ishakkhan Sardarkhan Pathan resi at …do… 147. Witness Muhammadajij karimbhai Bhatti resi near Sardar Ice Factory opp Nurani mosque Patiya. 148. Witness Abbasbhai Anvarkhan Pathan resi at Hukumsing’s chali Naroda patiya. 149. Witness Sharfaraz Abbashkhan Pathan resi at …do… 20

150. Witness Shahnavazkhan Abbashkhan Pathan resi at Pandit’s chali Naroda patiya. 151. Witness Pirumuhammad Allabax Shaikh near Nurani mosque Naroda patiya. 152. Dhirubhai kajibhai Vanzara resi at Bhagirath bungalow Opp Bajarang ashram Thakkarnagar, who identified the corpse of Gullabhai Vanzara age 19 years died in firing ). 153. Kulsumben w/o Ibrahimbhai Arabbhai Mansuri resi at Husennagar patiya. 154. Witness Zarinabibi Naimuddin Shaikh resi at Javaharnagar’s chhapra Naroda patiya. 155. Witness Rajiyabanu Muahmmadaeeyub Shaikh resi at …do… 156. Witness Soabmuhammad Aeeyub Shaikh resi at Husennagar Naroda patiya. 157. Witness Shakinabanu D/o Farukahamad Bhatti resi at Javaharnagar Naroda patiya. 158. Witness Muhammadhusen kaiyumbhai Shaikh resi at …do… 159. Witness Ahamad @ Badshah Mahebubhusen Shaikh resi at …do… 160. Witness Muhammdkhalid Saiyadali Saiyad resi at Husennagar Naroda patiya. 161. Witness Muhammadhusen Munirbhai Saiyad resi at Javaharnagar patiya. 162. Witness Rajiyabanu w/o Muhammadaeeyub Abdulgani Shaikh resi at Javaharnagar’ s chhapra Patiya. 163. Witness Parvinbanu w/o Salambhai Abdullahbhai Kureshi resi at …do… 164. Witness Rameshchandra Nathalal Patel resi at C/7 Parasmani Flat Rannapark Ahemedabad, (Owner of Uday Gas Agency Naroda Patiya). 165. Witness Ashokbhai Hemrajbhai Pandit Occu. Photograhy resi at b no 1 Uma park society near Bhargav society Saijpur Ahmedabad, (who took video of scene of offence). 166. Witness Sharifaben w/o Rajjakbhai Valibhai kabadiya resi at Pandit’s chali Naroda patiya. 167. Witness Muhammadmaruf Raufvalikhan Pathan resi at Javaharnagar’s chhapra Naroda patiya. 168. Witness Shehnazbanu w/o Munavarbhai Husenbhai Shaikh resi at …do… 21

169. Witness Rajiyabanu w/o Moinuddin Shamsuddin Shaikh …do… 170. Witness Rajjakbhai Usmanbhai Shaikh resi at Jikarhasan’s chali Naroda patiya. 171. Witness Shehjadbhai Navabbhai Kureshi resi at Javaharnagar Naroda patiya. 172. Witness Shabana w/o Abdulvarish Arahim Saiyad resi at Husen’s chali Naroda patiya. 173. Witness Afshanabanu Rehamanbhai Saiyad. Resi at Javannagar Naroda patiya. 174. Witness Yashin Usmanbhai Mansuri resi at Husennagar Naroda patiya. 175. Witness Sufiyabanu w/o Inayatullah Abdul rahim saiyad. Resi at …do… 176. Witness UsmanbhaiValibhai mansuri resi at … dod… 177. Witness Saberabanu Abdulajij Shaikh resi at …do… 178. Witness Shahjahan daughter of kabirahmad Adamhusen Shaikh resi at Husennagar patiya. 179. Witness Naimuddin Ibrahimbhai Shaikh resi at …do… 180. Witness Shabbirahmad Munirahmad Shaikh resi at Javannagar Naroda patiya. 181. Witness Inayat Abdulrahim saiyad resi at Husennagar Sixth lane Naroda patiya. 182. Witness Mahebubbhai Khurshidahmad Shaikh resi at Kumbhaji’s chali Javaharnagar. 183. Witness Mustakahmad Abdulrajjak Shaikh resi at …do… 184. Witness Iqubalhusen Amirmiyan Kureshi resi at Pandit’s chali Naroda patiya. 185. Witness Nabichand Abdulrahim Shaikh resi at Javannagar Naroda patiya Ahmedabad. 186. Witness Anvarhusen Saiyadsab Shaikh resi at Husennagar Patiya. 187. Witness Muhammadbhai Abdulhamid Shaikh resi at …do… 188. Witness Muhammadazruddin Muhammdyunush Shaikh resi at Pandit’s chali Naroda patiya. 189. Witness Rashidabegam w/o Mahebubbhai Hamjabhai Shaikh resi at … do… 190. Witness Shahinbanu widow of Muhammadhasan Abdul kadar Kurshi resi at Husennagar patiya. 22

191. Witness Jamilabibi widow of Babubhai Imamali resi at …do… 192. Witness Yunushbhai Rehamanbhai Mansuri resi at Pandit ’ s chali Naroda patiya. 193. Witness Aeeyubbhai Muhammadmiyan Shaikh resi at … do… 194. Witness Jummabhai Kalubhai Shaikh resi at Javaharnagar Naroda patiya. 195. Witness Zubedaben widow of Muhammadidrish Ahmadbhai Belim resi at Pandit’s chali. 196. Witness Basubhai Meeyudin Saiyad resi at Badarji’s chali Patiya Naroda. 197. Witness Muhammad jamaluddin Ibrahimbhai Shaikh resi at Husennagar Naroda patiya. 198. Witness Mariyambibi w/o Hasanbhai Abdulkadar Saiyad resi at …do… 199. Abdulajij Allabax Shaikh resi at …do… 200. Witness Tasdikalalm Badruddin Shaikh resi at Hukumsing’ s chali Naroda patiya. 201. Witness Majidkhan Sherkhan Pathan resi at Javannagar Naroda patiya. 202. Witness Ayeshabibi w/o A gaffer Moiyuddin Mallari resi at Jikarhasan’s chali Naroda patiya. 203. Witness Muhammadyunush Abdulbhai Chaudhary resi opp Nurani mosque Naroda patiya. 204. Witness Arifali Kasamali Saiyad resi at Imambibi’s chali Naroda patiya. 205. Witness Pappubhai Sabirali Mansuri resi at Javaharnagar’s chali Naroda patiya. 206. Witness Sardarali Kasamali Saiyad resi at …do… 207. Witness Afzal Abdulrauf Abdal resi at Pandit’ s chali Naroda patiya. 208. Amirmiyan Fakirmuhammad Kureshi resi at …do… 209. Witness Aeeyubbhai Badesab kureshi resi at Husennagnar’ s chali Naroda patiya. 210. Witness Ishratjahan w/o Parvezhusen Barkathusen Saiyad resi at …do… 211. Witness Zulekhabibi w/o Sardarahmad Sarmuddin Chaudhary resi at kumbhaji’s chali Patiya. 212. Witness Muhammdnashim Shaikhluddhu resi at Hukumsing’ s chali Naroda patiya. 23

213. Witness Fatimabibi w/o khavajahusan Abdul rasul Shaikh resi at Husennagar Naroda patiya. 214. Witness Kausharbanu w/o Aeeyubbhai Shaikh resi at Husennagar patiya. 215. Witness Nashimbanu w/o Abdulrehaman Jivumiyan kazi resi at …do… 216. Witness Afsharabegam w/o kabirali Adambhai resi at …do… As above. 217. Witness Abdulsalim Abdulamajid Chaudhary resi at Pandit’ s chali Naroda patiya. 218. Witness Muhammadrafik Muhammaddatar Shaikh resi at Javaharnagar Naroda patiya. 219. Witness Zubedakhatun w/o Rahimbhai Jashubhai Shaikh resi at Husennnagar patiya. 220. Witness Yakubali Kasamali Saiyad resi at Imambibi’ s chali Naroda patiya. 221. Witness Muhammdhusen Kaiyum Shaikh resi at Husennagar Naroda patiya Ahmedabad. 222. Witness Abdulrajjak Imamsab Shaikh resi at …do… 223. Witness Bibibanu widow of Mahbub khurshid ahmad Shaikh resi at kumbhaji’ s chali Patiya. 224. Witness Peshimam Abdulsalam Shaikh resi at upper part of Nurani mosque Naroda patiya. 225. Witness Muhammadhanif Yusufbhai Shaikh resi at Pandit’s chali Nurani mosque Patiya. 226. Witness Nashimbanu wife of Muhammadkhalid Saiyadali Saiyad resi at Husennagar patiya. 227. Witness Taherabanu wife of Muhammadkasam Abdullah resi at kashiram mama ‘s chali Saijpur patiya Ahmedabad. 228. Witness Faridabibi w/o Abdulkadar Rasulbhai Khalifa resi at Husennagar patiya. 229. Witness Abdulsalim Abdulmajid Chaudhary resi at Javanngar Naroda patiya. 230. Witness Gulamhusen Husenbhai Shaikh resi at Javannagar Naroda patiya Ahemedabad. 231. Witness Muhammadbhai Bachubhai Belim resi at Pandit’s chali Naroda patiya Ahmedabad. 232. Witness Usamnbhai Ahmadbhai Pathan resi at Husennagar ‘s chali Naroda patiya. 233. Witness Abdulrahim Abdulvahab Shaikh resi at Millatnagar Shahalam near Muhammadi Madrasa Rahimbhai’s chali house no 18 Ahmedabad. 234. Witness Ahamdbhai Jamalbhai Shaikh resi at Hukumsing’s chali. Naroda patiya. 24

235. Witness Bhikhabhai Habibbhai Mansuri resi at Husennnagar Naroda patiya Ahmedabad. 236. Witness Iqbalbhai Ismailbhai Mansuri resi at …do… 237. Witness Muhammadsaied Abdulmajid Khadkhad resi at Javannagar ’s chali Naroda patiya. 238. Witness Muhammadmurtuza khavajabhai Shaikh resi at Husennagar Naroda patiya Ahmedabad. 239. Witness. Nurmuhammad Samshuddin Shaikh resi at Hukumsing’s chali Naroda patiya. 240. Witness. Muhammdaeeyub Saukilal Shaikh resi at Husennangar’ s chali Naroda patiya. 241. Witness. Aslambhai Shamsherbhai Shaikh resi at …do… 242. Witness. Bashirbhai Usmanbhai Saiyad resi at …do… 243. Witness. Muhammadyusuf Muhamamadmustufa Shaikh resi at Pandit’s chali Naroda patiya. 244. Witness. Nashimbanu w/o Khavajahusen Samshuddin Shaikh resiat …do… 245. Witness. Sattarbhai Muhammadhusen Shaikh resi at Husennangar Naroda patiya. 246. Witness. Ibrahimbhai Ashlambhai Mansuri resi at …do… 247. Witness. Abdulrajjak Abdulrehaman Saiyad resi at Huskumsing’s chali Naroda patiya. 248. Witness. Gulamrasul Saiyadrasul Shaikh resi at Immabibi’s chali Naroda patiya. 249. Witness. Muhammadbhai kalubhai Khalifa resi at Husennangar Naroda patiya. 250. Witness. Sakilabanu w/o Riyazhusen Babubhai Shaikh resi at …do… 251. Witness. Abdulrasul Muhammadbhai Shaikh resi at kumbhaji’s chali Naroda patiya. 252. Witness. Rashidkhan Ahmadkhan Makrani Resi at Pandit’s chali Naroda patiya. 253. Witness. Muhammadimran Imtiyazhusen Momin resi at Husennagar Naroda patiiya. 254. Witness. Babubhai Muhammadhusen Budali Shaikh resi at Hukumsing’s chali Naroda road. 255. Witness. Abdulrahim Ismailbhai Shaikh resi at Pandit’s chali Naroda patiya. 25

256. Witness. Salauddin Abdulkarim Shaikh resi at Javannagar ‘s chali Naroda patiya. 257. Witness. Ibrahimbhai Hasanbhai Shaikh resi at Pandit’s chali Naroda patiya. 258. Witness. Muhammadyunush Abdulshakur Shaikh resi at Javannagar Naroda patiya Ahmedabad. 259. Witness. Muhammadhusen Munirahmad Shaikh resi at Javannagar Naroda patiya Ahemdbad. 260. Witness. Badshah Abdulkadir Kureshi resi at …do… 261. Witness. Maiyudin Ahmadmiyan Shaikh resi at …do… 262. Witness. Babubhai Ahmadhusen Shaikh resi at Hukumsing’s chali Javannagar Naroda patiya. 263. Witness. Altafhusen Abdulrehaman Saiyad resi at Javannagar Naroda patiya. 264. Witness. Shaukat Nabibhai Mansuri resi at Husennagar’s chali Naroda patiya. 265. Witness. Shamsuddin Shahbuddin Rathod (Maniyar) resi at …do… 266. Witness. Faruk Fajluddin Shaikh resi at Javannagar last lane Naroda patiya. 267. Witness. Nurmuhammad Najirmuhammad Shaikh resi at Chetandas ‘s chali Naroda patiya. 268. Witness. Pirubhai Ismailbhai Solapuri resi at Javannagar Last lane Patiya. 269. Witness. Kherunnishan wife of Riyazuddin Gulamuddin resi at Javannagar’s chali 270. Witness. Mahebubbhai Umarbhai Shaikh resi at Husennagar’s chali Naroda patiya. 271. Witness. Raziyabanu w/o Yakubbhai Khavajabhai Shaikh resi at Chetandas ‘s chali Naroda patiya. 272. Witness. Rashidabanu w/o Imtiyazhusen Gulam maiyudin Momin resi at kumbhaji’ s chali house no 147 Naroa patiya Ahmedabad. 273. Witness. Fatmabibi widow of Makbulbhai Maiyudin Shaikh resi at Pandit’s chali Patiya. 274. Witness Ayshabibi w/o Abidali Hamidali Pathan resi at Chetandas ‘s chali. 275. Witness. Jahidabanu w/o Iqubalahmad Nuruddin Shaikh resi at Husennagar patiya. 276. Witness Zubedabibi widow of Shafibhai Husenbhai Bhatti resi at Sundarlal’ s chali opp Excise choky Naroda road Patiya Ahmedabad. 26

277. Witness. Zubedabanu widow of Abdullah Abdulagani Shaikh resi at Javannagar patiya. 278. Witness. Naimuddin Mahbubbhai Shaikh resi at Kumbhaji’s chali Patiya Naroda road. 279. Witness. Rahimhusen Manubhai Mansuri resi at Javannagar Naroda patiya 280. Witness. Sharifabibi w/o Iqubalbhai Badarbhai Shaikh resi at Javannagar patiya. 281. Witness. Jamilabanu w/o Mahebubhusen Ataurraheman Resi. …… 282. Witness Muhammad Gulamrasul Sherkhan Shaikh resi at Pandit’s chali Naroda patiya. 283. Witness. Abdulmajid Abdulrajjak Shaikh resi at Kumbhai’s chali Patiya Naroda. 284. Witness. Afrozbanu Muhammadrajjak Ansari resi at Pandit’s chali Patiya Naroda. 285. Witness. Mujaffarbeg Bahadur beg Miriza resi at Javannagar Naroda patiya. 286. Witness. Salehabanu Sakirhusen Shaikh resi at Masjid’s chali opp Excise choky Naroda roadAhmedabad. 287. Witness. Abdulajij Abdulahamid Shaikh resi at Husennnagar patiya Naroda. 288. Witness. Akbarsubhani Najirahmad Munshi resi at Javannagar Naroda patiya. 289. Witness. Chandbhai Saiyadbhai Shatal resi at Javannagar Naroda Ahemdbad. 290. Witness. Yunush Muhammad bhai Shaikh resi at Husennagar Naroda patiya Ahmedabad. 291. Witness. Salimbhai Mustufabhai Mansuri resi at Pandit’ s chali Naroda patiya. 292. Witness. Gauribi w/o Muhammadmashak Kureshi resi at Javannagar Naroda patiya. 293. Witness. Husenbhai Valibhai Kaladiya. Resi at Imambibi’s chali Patiya. 294. Witness. Abdulrashid Abdulkarim by cast Shaikh resi at Husennagar patiya. 295. Witness. Khushnumabibi w/o Sumarmiyan Muhammadmiyan Makrani resi at Imambibi’s chali opp Nurani mosque Naroda Ahmedabad city. (Witness of Naroda FIR No. 115/02 & 129/02 ). 296. Witness. Kadarahmad Sultanbhai kadri resi at kashiram mama ’s chali beside ST work shop Naroda Ahmedabad. (Witness of Naroda I 115/02, I 129/02). 27

297. Witness. Zubedaben w/o Abdulbhai Ismailbhai Mansuri resi at Sundarlal ‘ s chali opp Saijpur police choky Naroda. (Witness of Naroda I no 129/02. 298. Witness. Nazninbanu w/o Taufik miyan Akbarmiyan Sumra resi at Imambibi’s chali near ST workshop. (Witness of Naroda I 153/02). 299. Witness. Jayeshbhai Vrajlal Makvana resi at Alfa Apartment inside Mohanpark Gordhan vadi tekra Ahmedabad. (Witness of Naroda I 238/02). 300. Witness. Balvantsing kalubha Jadeja resi at Ghanshayamnagar C/116 Noble nagar Sardarnagar Ahmedabad. ( Important Witness of Naroda I 238/02). 301. Witness. Naimuddin Ibrahimbhai Shaikh resi at Husennagar Naroda patiya Ahmedabad. ( Witness of Naroda I 238/02). 302. Witness. Haidarali Najafali Mirza resi at house no 488/02 Sodagar’s pole near Amlivala dehla Jamalpur Haveli Ahmedabad. ( Witness of Naroda I 238/02). 303. Witness. Nadim Muhammadali Saiyad resi at 32 Anvarpark b/h Hariyali society Ahmedabad (Witness of Naroda I 238/02). 304. Witness. Azarkhan Gafurkhan Pathan resi at Husennagar beside ST workshop Naroda patiya Ahmedabad. ( Witness of Naroda I 238/02). 305. Witness. Abdil aahad Abdulrahim Luhari Resi at Javannagar 12th Street, Naroda Patiya, Ahmedabad. 306. Witness Mahammadkhurshid Mahammadnasim Shaikh Resi at Javannagar 12th Street, Naroda Patiya, Ahmedabad. 307. Ruksana D/o Bundubhai Kureshi Resi at ………. As do 307/1 Witness Shivkumar Ramsurat Varma, Resi at Mafatnagar, Bethak Naroda Road, Ahmedabad. 307/2. Witness Abbasbhai Jivabhai Shaikh Resi at Pandit Chawl, B/h Nurani Masjid, Naroda Patiya, Ahmedabad. 307/3. Witness Noorbibi Abbasbhai Jivabhai’s Wife Resi at ……….. As do 307/4. Witness Baldevsinh Vijaysinh Zala Resi at 68, Gangotri Soc., Opp. Nurani Masjid, Naroda Patiya Ahmedabad. 307/5. Witness Hiralal Mangaldas Kanojiya, Resi at Kashiram Mama’s Chawl, B/h Nurani Masjid, Naroda Patiya Ahmedabad. 28

307/6. Witness Firojkhan @ Baba Khwaja Moyuddin Sheikh, Resi at Nr. Masjid Chawl, Mansuri’s Chawl, Naroda Patiya Ahmedabad. 307/7. Witness Laljibhai Shamjibhai Koli Resi at Parvati Park Soc.B/No.17, Nr. Kubereshvar Mahadev, Saijpur Bodha, Naroda Road, Ahmedabad. 307/8. Witness Sayrabibi Abdulkadar Gulamrasul, Anori resi at Pandit chawl, Nr. Nurani Masjid, Naroda Patiya, Ahmedabad. 307/9. Witness Inayat Abdulrahim Saiyed resi at Husennagar Street No.4, Naroda Patiya, Ahmedabad. 307/10. Witness Gulam Mahammad Faijmahammad Pathan resi at Pandit chawl, Nr. S.T.Workshop, Naroda Patiya, Ahmedabad. 307/11. Witness Zulekhabibi Mohammadaiyub Allabax sheikh wido resi at 114, Faizalpark, Nr. Jiya Masjid, Vatva, Ahmedabad. 307/12. Witness Iqbal ahmed Nuruddin Sheikh resi at Husennagar, Naroda Patiya, Ahmedabad. Recently resi 9, Faizalpark, Nr. Jiya Masjid, Vatva, Ahmedabad. 307/13. Witness Bundubhai Mahammadrafik Qureshi resi at Javannagar, Naroda Patiya , Ahmedabad. 307/14. Witness Mahammadaiyub Ganibhai Shaikh resi at Javannagar, Naroda Patiya , Ahmedabad, Recently resi at Pandit Chal, Naroda Patiya, Ahmedabad. 307/15. Witness Hanifabibi w/o Adamali Mahammadbhai Shaikh Wido Resi. at Pandit Chal, Naroda Patiya, Ahmedabad. Recently resi at 112, faijalpark , Nr. Jiya Masjid, Vatva , Ahmedabad. 307/16. Witness Basirahmad mohammadhusen sheikh resi at Kumbhaji’s Chawl, Naroda Patiya, Ahmedabad. (Naroda I CR No.117/02) 307/17. Witness Sufiyabibi w/o Mehbubbhai Khurshidahmad Sheikh wife, Resi at Kumbhaji’s Chawl, Naroda Patiya, Ahmedabad. 307/18. Witness. Mamtaben h/o Ashokkumar Hundaldas Sindhi Resi at 23/3 New G Ward, Gurudvara Road, Kubernagar, Ahmedabad. 29

Witness police officers and persons. 308. Witness. Shri MT Rana Assistant Police Commissioner G division Ahmedabad city. 309. Witness.Shri KK Maysurvala Police Inspector Naroda police station at present CID Intelligence Gandhinagar. 310.. Witness. ASI Dashrathsing Udeshing B No 4877 Service Naroda police station. 311. Witness. ASI Vijaykumar Gimothilal B No 8321 Service Naroda police station. 312. Witness. ASI Ramabhai Parsottamdas B No 3188 Service Naroda police station. 313. Witness. ASI Sajjansing Jashvantsing B No 8491 Service Naroda police station. 314. Witness. Head Constable Devjibhai Jamabhai Patel B No 5657 Service Naroda police station. 315. Witness. UPC Sureshbhai Shridharan B No 6101, Service Naroda police station. 316. Witness. UPC Vijaykumr Laxmanrav B No 7831, Service Naroda police station. 317. Witness. UPC Jivabhai Punjabhai B No 6801. Service Naroda police station. 318. Witness. UPC Babubhai Shakrabhai B No 3965 Service Naroda police station. 319. Witness. UPC. Parbatsinh Vajesinh B.No.4747 Service Naroda police station. 320. Witness UPC. Bharatsing Chanduji B No 5556 Service at present Amraivadi police station. 321. Witness.UPC Ashoksing Laxmansing B No 6773 Service Naroda police station. 322. Witness.UPC. Chhalabhai Chhaganbhai B No 3670 Service Naroda police station. 323. Witness. UPC Pradipsing Ratansing B No 7921. Service Naroda police station. 324. Witness. UPC Jayendrasing Bapalal B No 7592. Service Naroda police station. 325. Witness.UPC Manubhai Madhabhai B No 4387 Service Naroda police station. 326. Witness.UPC Kirankumar Parsottambhai B No 7793. Service Naroda police station. 327. Witness. UPC. Chandravadan Ramjibhai B No 5234. Service Naroda police station. 328. Witness.UPC DIpak Govindram B No.7942 Naroda Po.Sta. 30

329. Witness SRP PSI Vitthal Baburav Devre Group No. 9, D Company, Vadodara City. 330. Witness SRP HC Chandrasinh Mathursinh Bariya B.No.570 Group No.9 D Company, Vadodara City. 331. Witness SRP Constable Manubhai Mohanbhai B No 559 Group 9 D Company Vadodara city, Originally resi at Liliya ta Vijapur Dist Mahesana. 332. Witness. SRP Constable Mandipsing Karising B. No 974 Group 9 D Company Vadodara city, originally resi at Palva Ta Birol Dist Darbhanga Bihar. 333. Witness. SRP Constable Haribhai Mangalbhai Patel B No 909 Group 9 D Company Vadodara city. 334. Witness. SRP Constable Balvan Sukhlal Sankhle Group 9 D Company Vadodara city originally resi at Mishri Ta Dadri Dist Bhivani Hariyana. 335. Witness. SRP Constable Avanish khimjibhai Lalat B No 554. D Group 9 D Company Vadodara city. Originally resi at Limbadiya ta Vijaynagar Dist Sabarkantha. 336. Witness. SRP Constable Balvindarsing Sonsing Khera B No 554 Group 9 D Company Vadodara Original resi at village Nagode ta khadursahil Dist Amrutsar Panjab. 337. Witness . SRP Cosntable Dashrathbhai Damaji B No 659 Group 9 D Company Vadodara city. Resi at village Kudolpark ta Bhiloda Dist Sabarkantha. 31

Executive Magistrate who took DDs

338. Executive Magistrate with original DDs who took total 11 DDs of 1). Afshanabanu Rehamanbhai 2). Yashinbhai Usmanbhai Mansuri 3). Sufiyabanu Inayatali Saiyad. 4). Usmanbhai Valibhai Mansuri. 5). Sufiyabanu Abdulmajid Shaikh. 6). Sabera Abdulajij Shaikh. 7).Muhammadmaruf Raufalikhan Pathan. 8). Shahjahan kabirahmad Shaikh. 9). Naimuddin Ibrahimbhai Shaikh. 10). Farjanabanu Aaiyubkhan Pathan. 11). Shabbirahmad Munirahmad Shaikh, between 13-00 to 18-00 hours on 3-3-02. 339.Witness. Shri V D Prajapati Excuvie Magistrate Metro area Ahmedabad city along with original DDs of Mahebubbhai Khurshidahmad Shaikh and that of Shakinabanu Farukahmad Bhatti taken between 15-20 to 16-20 hours on 4-3-02. 340. Shri KP Shah Executive Magistrate Metro area Ahmedabad city along with original DD of Ahmad @ Badshah Mahebubhusen Shaikh taken on 4-3-02. 340/1 M.A. Mansuri Exe.mg. metro court area Ahmedabad city identified punch nama of accused Ashok Hundaldas Sindhi with original punchnama

340/2 B.D. Solanki Exe.mg. metro court area Ahmedabad city identified punch nama of accused Babubhai @ Babu Vanzara with original punchnama 341. Dr Shri Umesh (Plastic Surgeory) VS hospital Ahmedabad along with original Treatment Certificate No 1151/02 dated 10-4-02 of Ahmed mohammad husen (2) Treatment Certificate No 1152/02 dated 10-4-02 of Sohel Shaikh (3) Treatment Certificate No 1713/02 dated 25-5-02 of Shenazbanu (4) Treatment Certificate No 1716/02 dated 28-5-02 of Raziyabanu Moh. Ayub 342. Dr Yogesh Gupta VS hospital Ahmedabad city along with treatment Certificate No 1. 1405/ 02 dated 27-4-02 of Mustak Rajjak. 343. Dr Shri Aman Gupta VS hospital Ahmedabad city alongwith original Treatment Certificate No 1. Certificate No 1063/02 dated 8-4-02 of Muhammadkhalid. 344. Dr Shri Sunil Mittal VS hospital Ahmedabad (Plastic surgeory) along with Original Treatment Certificate No. 1. 1465 dated 2-5-02 of Bablu Mahebubbhai. 32

2. Certiifcate No 1466 dated 2.5.2 of Yashin Amajid. 345. Dr Shri Ajaybhai (Ortho) VS hospital Ahmedabad alongwith original Certificate No 966/02 dated 2-4-02 of Zarinabanu Naimuddin. 346.Dr Shri Chirayu (Ortho) VS hospital Ahmedabad city along with original Certiifciate No 1. 915/02 dated 27-3-02 of Muhammadhusen Shaikh, 2. Certificate No 913 dated 27-3-02 of Kulsumbanu Ibrahimbhai, 3. Certificate No 914/02 dated 27-3-02 of Pirmuhammad Allabax. 347 Dr Shri PR Vaghela Civil hospital Ahmedabad along with original 1.Certificate No 1906/5 2002 dated 15-3-02 of Bashirahmad Dhobi, 2. Certificate No 1907/5 02 dated 15-3-02 of Shabana Abdulrahim, 3. Certificate No 1960/ 2002 dated 15-3-02 of Vinubhai Navjibhai. 4. Certificate No 1911/5/ 2002 dated 24-7-2 of Kamar raja Pathan 5. Certificate No 1913/5 2002 dated 6-9-2 of Ayeshabanu Moh. Maru Pathan 6. Certificate No 1914/5/ 2002 dated 13-9-2 of Afsanabanu Rehmanbhai Shaikh 7. Certificate No 1916/5/ 2002 dated 24-7-2 of Shabbir Ahmed Munir Ahmed Shaikh 8. Certificate No 2361/7/ 2002 dated 15-3-2 of Sufiyabanu Inayat Saiyed

348.Dr Shri GV Nayak Civil hospital Ahmedabad city along with original 1). Certificate No EPRNo 2013/06/02 dated 20-4-02 for the treatment of Ibrahim Shaikh, 2). Certificate No EPRNo 2014/06/02 dated 20-4-02 for the treatment of Jaitunbanu Ashlammiyan Shaikh, 3). Certificate No EPRNo 2018/06/02 dated 28-5-02 for the treatment of Farjanabanu Aeeyubkhan Pathan, 4). Certificate No EPRNo 2019/06/02 dated 28-5-02 for the treatment of Reshmabanu Aeeyubkhan Pathan, 5). Certificate No EPRNo 2020/06/02 dated 28-5-02 for the treatment of Saberabanu Abdulajij Shaikh. 33

6). Certificate No EPRNo 2004/06/02 dated 29-7-02 for the treatment of Usmanbhai Valibhai 7). Certificate No EPRNo 2011/06/02 dated 29-7-02 for the treatment of Yasinbhai Usmanbhai Mansuri 8). Certificate No EPRNo 2015/06/02 dated 14-8-02 for the treatment of Shahjaha Kabir Ahmed

Doctor performing PM 349. Doctor perfoming PM (1) Dr Shri JV Satapara, (2) Shri VK Pardhi Civil hospital Ahemdabad, who issued PM No 383/02 performing PM of Gulalbhai Kalubhai Vanzara. 350. Dr Shri RB Shah MOPHC Civil hospital Ahmedabad alongwith PM Note No 412/02 dated 1-3-02 of Muhammadrafik Adam Shaikh, PM Note No 573/02 dated 2-3-02 of Abidali Hamidali Pathan. 351. Dr Shri JH Solanki MO RDD Ahmedabad along with PM Note No 417/02 dated 1-3-02 of Sofiyabanu Mahemudbhai Shaikh, PM Note No 574/02 dated 2-3-02 of an unknown corpse. 352. Dr Shri JR Modi Civil hospital Ahmedabad along with 1.PM No 422/02 dated1-3-02 of unknown woman age 30 years, 2. PM Note No 497 dated 2-3-02 of Saiedabanu Ibrahim Shaikh. 3. PM Note no.419/02 dated 1.3.02 Zubedabanu Shabbir Ahmed Shaikh PM note. 4. PM No.426/02 dated 1.3.02 Zarinabibi w/o Bundubhai Mahammadbhai Qureshi with PM Note. 353. Dr Shri HG Panchal M O Civil hospital Ahmedabad city along with 1 PM Note No 423/02 of unknown male child. 354. Dr Shri CK Tanna MO Civil hospital Ahmedabad city along with PM Note No 424/02 of an unknown male person. 355. Dr Shri AH Thakar Mo kavitha Civil hospital Ahmedabad, alongwith 1. PM Note No 425/02 Siddikbhai Salimbhai Shaikh. 2. PM Note No 517/02 Meraj Salambhai Abdulla. 34

3. PM Note No 518/02 of unknown corpse. 4. PM Note No 534/02 of unknown corpse. 5. PM Note No 519/02 dated 2.3.2 shabanambanu w/o mahammadkhurshid mahammad nasim sheikh with PM Note. 356. Dr Shri Hemant D Patel MO Modasa, Civil hospital Ahmedabad along with 1.PM Note No 434/02 of with Samir Salambhai Qureshi PM Note. 2. PM Note No 559/02 with PM Note of Rajiyabanu D/o Nisar Ahmed Pathan. 357. Dr Shri RS Bhavsar MO PHC Vataman Ta. Dholka Dist. Ahmedabad alongwith 1. PM Note No 494/02 with PM note Khwajahusen Abdulmajid Shaikh. 2. PM Note No 543/02 with PM note Shabbir Ahmed Khurshid Ahmed Shaikh. 3. PM Note No 544/02 dated 2.3.02 with PM note Mahammadaiyub Allabax Shaikh. 4. PM Note No 496/02 dated 2.3.02 with PM note Farhana D/o Aiyubbhai Ladesab Kureshi. 358. Dr Shri KR Shah Civil hospital Ahmedabad along with 1. PM Note No 495/02 of Abdulvahab Abdulrafik Shaikh. 2. PM Note No 539/02 of Abdulla Abdulgani Shaikh. 3. PM Note No 545/02 Nasimbanu D/o Bindubhai Mahammed 359. Dr Shri M.H. Samirachara Civil hospital Ahmedabad along with 1.PM Note No 511/02 Salam Abdulla Qureshi. 2. PM Note No 514/02 Shahjahan W/o Sarmoddin. 3.PM Note No 520/02 Sohel Ahmedbhai Aiyubbhai Ladesha. 4. PM Note No 526/02 of Zarinabanu D/o Shakurbhai. 360. Dr Shri SK Patel Civil hospital Ahmedabad city along with 1.PM Note No 512/02 of corpse of unknown person, 35

2. PM Note No 515/02 of corpse of Maiyuddin Hasanbhai Abubakar Saiyed with PM Note. 3. PM Note No 521/02 of corpse of Samshad Rahemanbhai with PM Note. 4. PM Note No 527/02 of corpse of Ruksana D/o Rahemanbhai Saiyed with PM Note. 361. Dr Shri MM Patel Civil hospital Ahmedabad alongwith 1.PM Note No 513/02 of corpse of Rafik Sarmoddin Shaikh with PM Note. 2, PM Note No 516/02 of corpse of Nurjahabegam W/o Ismailbhai with PM Note. 3. PM Note No 522/02 of corpse of Saliyabibi W/o Jenul Abedin Shaikh with PM Note. 4. PM Note No 528/02 of corpse of Mahammadhusen Abdulmajid Shaikh with PM Note. 362. Dr Shri DS Vyas and Dr Shri GS Makvana Civil hospital Ahmedabad alognwith 1. PM Note No 523/02 of unknown Kherunnisha Mohammadmaru Abdulrauf with PM Note. 2. PM Note No 524/02 of Bilkishbanu Mahammadmaru Abdulraufkhan with PM Note. 3. PM Note No 525/02 of Babubhai Varma with PM note. 363. Dr Shri Kalpesh H Parikh MO Gandhinagar, Civil hospital Ahmedabad along with 1. PM Note No. 530/02 of corpse of unknown person. 364. Dr Shri Jayesh B Rupala MO PHC Adarej Civil hospital Ahmedabad alongwith 1PM Note No 533/02 of Mahammadyunus Mahammadrajak Ansari with PM note. 2. PM Note No. 536/02 of Nurjahan Mahammadhusen Munirbhai Shaikh with PM note. 3. PM Note No.490/02 dated 2.3.02 of Mohsin Meblahusen Shaikh with PM note. 365. Dr Shri Mitesh R Patel MO Vadsar Gandhinagar Civil hospitalAhmedabad along with 1. PM Note No 535/02 of Hanifakhatun Abdulvahab Shaikh with PM note. 2 PM Note No 547/02 of unknown person. 36

3. PM Note No 609/02 dated 3.3.02 of unknown female with PM note. 4. PM Note No 492/02 dated 2.3.02 Saminabanu D/o Shabbirahmed Khurshid Shaikh with PM Note. 366. Dr Shri DJ Mankad MO Nandej (Civil hospital) Ahmedabad alognwith 1.PM Note No 538/02 of Salimabanu Sardar Saiyed with PM Note. 2. PM Note No 590/02 of Gulnazbanu Aiyubmiya Malek with PM Note. 367. Dr Smt Gitanjali Pathak ( Falcon) MO Civil hospital Ahmedabad along with 1. PM Note No 540/02 of Mohammadhusen Abdulkadar Kureshi with PM note. 2. PM Note No 489/02 dated 2.3.02 of Irfan Inayat Saiyed with PM note. 3. PM Note No 493/02 dated 2.3.02 Salman Inayat Saiyed with PM Note. 368. Dr Shri DA Silajiya and Dr Shri DS Patel Civil hospital alongwith PM Note No 565/02 of corpse of unknown male person. 369. Dr Shri BS Shah MO Civil hospital Ahmedabad along with 1. PM Note No 567/02 of Ismailbhai Sarmoddin Shaikh with PM Note. 2. PM Note No 598/02 dated 2.3.02 Nurjahan D/o Kabirali Abdulbhai Shaikh with PM Note. 3. PM Note No. 599/02 dated 2.3.2 Sarmoddin Mohammedmunovar Shaikh with PM Note. 370. Dr. JS Kanoriya Civil Hospital, Ahmedabad along with 1.PM Note No 575/02 Kausharbanu D/o Khalikbhai Nurmohammed Shaikh with PM Note. 2. PM Note No 576/02 of Husen Mohammedmasak Kureshi with PM Note. 3. PM Note No 577/02 of unknown female person. 371. Dr Shri R B Joshi Civil hospital Ahmedabad along with 1.PM Note No 578/02 of Subhan Jenul Aabedin Mahammedkhan with PM Note. 2. PM Note No 579/02 of Abdulkadir Abdulrasid Shaikh with PM Note. 3.PM Note No 628/02 of Kudaratbibi Khurshidbhai with PM Note. 37

4. PM Note No 629/02 of corpse of Sarmuddin Khalid Nurmohammed with PM Note. 372. Dr Shri PR Vaghela Civil hospital Ahmedabad along with PM Note No 619/02 of Hajrabanu @ Jadikhala Abdulmahammed Saiyed with PM Note. 373. Dr Shri DC Jagani MOCivil hospital Ahmedabad along with PM Note No 627/02 dated 5-3-02 of Ashif Shabbirbhai with PM Note. 374. Dr Shri HK Rathod M.O. Civil hospital Ahmedabad along with PM Note No 641/02 dated 7-3-02 of Supriya Majid. 375. Dr Shri VKP MO Civil hospital Ahmedabad along with 1. PM Note No 668/02 dated 11-3-02 of Hamidraza Muhammadmaru. 376. Dr Shri TJ Mehta VS hospital Ellisbrige Ahmedbad alongwith 1. PM Note No 204/02 of Shakinabanu Mahbub. 2. PM Note No 206/02 of Mahbub Khurshidbhai. 377. Dr Shri KS Kotharia VS hospital Ahmedabad city along with 1. PM Note No 223/02 dated 10-3-02 of Shakina Babubhai Bhatti. 378. Dr Shri DD Patel VS hospital Ahmedabad along with 1. PM Note No 228/02 dated 12-3-02 of Rajjak Babubhai Bhatti. Witnesses (FSL). 378/1. Dr JV Satapara Civil Hospital, Ahmedabad along with 1. PM Note No 550/02 dated 17-1-02 of Adamali Mahammedbhai Shaikh. 2. PM Note No 568/02 of Vasim Abdulazij Shaikh. 3. PM Note No 438/02 of Salim Abdulazij Shaikh. 4. PM Note No 542/02 dated 2.3.02 of Niloferbanu D/o Ibrahimbhai Aalambhai Mansuri. 38

378/2. Dr DM Savani Civil Hospital, Ahmedabad along with 1. PM Note No 531/02 of Mahebub Abdulmajid Shaikh. 2. PM Note No 537/02 of Unknown Male. 378/3. Dr JM Joshi Civil Hospital, MCPUC Sitapur along with 1. PM Note No 546/02 dated 2-3-02 of Sufiyabegam Abdulaahad Abdulrahim Luhari. 2. PM Note No 591/02 dated 2-3-02 of Firoj Mohammed Aiyub Shaikh. 3. PM Note No 592/02 dated 3-3-02 of Mohammed Shahrukh Zakirhusen Shaikh. 378/4. Dr AM Patel Medical Officer, PHG Kumarkhan Ta.Viramgam along with 1. PM Note No 491/02 Muskan D/o Zenulabedin Mahammedkhan Shaikh. 2. PM Note No 541/02 Shahinbanu Abdulmajid Shaikh. 3. PM Note No 532/02 Lalbibi W/o Abdulmajid Mohammedusman Shaikh.

FSL WItness 379. Shri H B Bhatt Scientific officer Forensic Science Labortary New Mental corner Ahmedabad city along with his original report No FSL/ TPN/ 2002/ C/541 dated 23-5-02 for having examined muddamal. (In Naroda I 238/02). 380. Shri KM Mahera FSL S.O. Mobile van (Inve) Ahmedabad visited the scene of offence on 26- 4-02 in connection with Naroda I 238/02 and submitted that original report. 381. Assistant Director FSL GS Ahmedabad. As the doctor of Civil hospital took 18 DNA specimen from unknown corpses and sent for examination in FSL vide report No FSL/ TPN/ 2002/ DNA/ dated 22-3-02, he examined and gave his report.

381/1. Dr Shri JA Shah SOFSL /TPN/Report No./02/C/541/0/3.10.02 investigated Mudamal With original Report 381/2. Shri RN Shah Scientific Officer, FSL/TPN\ 2002/B/775 Dated 25.11.02 investigated Mudamal With original Report 39

381/3. Assistant Director FSL vide report No FSL/ TPN/ 2004/ B/867/ dated 13.10.04( Swords after investigation who given Certificate )

------

Map maker of incident palce

382.. Shri Hasmukhbhai Thakkar Circle Inspector Naroda office beside Sardarnagar police station Ahmedabad, ( who prepared the map of scene of offence in connection with Naroda police station I CR No 100/02. 383 police comm.. Shri Ahmedabad city Gazattes No.\U\GPK\Visha\576/01 dtd 27/12/10 & a knowledegeble person with thia Gazattes

Who noted Offences

384. PSO who registerd the offence in Naroda police station ( of shift of 20-45 hours dated 28-2-02). 385. Person who dictated information from Civil hospital 1. Police constable Kiranpuri B No 6462. 2. Police constable Ranjitsing B No 7374. (along with information book of Civil hospital regarding injured, deceased persons in connection with Naroda patiya incidents dated 28-2-02, 1-3-02, 2-3-02, 4-3-02, 5-3-02, 7-3-02 11-3-02). 386. Person dictated information from VS hospital. 1. ASI Bhikhaji, 2. HC Jayantilal, 3. HC Bipin Jayantilal (along with information book of hospital regarding injured, deceased persons in connection with Naroda patiya incidents dated 28-2-02, 1-3-02, 3-3-02, 4-3-02, 5-3-02, 10-3-02, 11-3-02). 383. PI Shri KK Maysurvala Naroda police station Ahmedabad, (at present CID Intelligence Gandhinagar). 40

387. First Investigating PI Shri K.K.Maisurwala Naroda Police Ahmedabad. (Now : CID Int. Gandhinagar).

388. Other Investigating officers Shri PN Barot B-Division police Ahmedabad. Assistant Police Commissioner Ahmedabad city. 388/1. PI Shri HP Agrawat, Crime Branch, Ahmedabad City. 389. Third person investigating and making chargsheet Shri SS Chudasama Assistant police Commissoner Crime branch Ahmedabad City. 390. Forth person investigating and making chargsheet Shri GL Singal Assistant police Commissoner Crime branch Ahmedabad City. 391. Fifth person investigating and making chargsheet Shri HR Muliyana Assistant police Commissoner Crime branch Ahmedabad City.

Tips :- 1. The statement of mark of identification and photographs of accused persons arrested are enclosed herewith 2. The arrangement of proper Prosecutor has been made in this case. 3. In this case the permission letter to file the charge sheet under order No SBII/COM/102002/5441 PART-1dated 13-2-2008 (A) of IPC is enclosed herewith. 4. The necessary copies for the Honble Court and for the accused persons are enclosed herewith. 5. 504 witnesses statement of Damages are enclosed in this matter so requested to Summons directly & Submitts when the Prosecution time 6. chargesheet on dtd 4/6/02 againts 1 to 23 accused in this matter which CC No. 982/02 and then Supplymentry chargesheet against acuused no. 24 To 37 on dtd 23/8/02 ahich CC no. is 1662/02 and then accused Supplymentry chargesheet against acuused no. 38 to 45 dtd 10/11/04 which CC no. 1924/04

Forwarded to the Honble Metropolitan Magistrate Court no 11 Ghee Kanta Ahmedbadad City, at 14:00 hours on 15/2/2008. Sd/- (H.R.Muliyana) 41

Assistant Police Commissioner Crime branch Ahmedabad City. Dispatched at am

Pm Date ……………………. Month…………… Signature of Investigating officer.