BC Law Magazine Spring/Summer 2008 Boston College Law School
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Boston College Law School Digital Commons @ Boston College Law School Boston College Law School Magazine 4-1-2008 BC Law Magazine Spring/Summer 2008 Boston College Law School Follow this and additional works at: http://lawdigitalcommons.bc.edu/bclsm Part of the Legal Education Commons Recommended Citation Boston College Law School, "BC Law Magazine Spring/Summer 2008" (2008). Boston College Law School Magazine. Book 32. http://lawdigitalcommons.bc.edu/bclsm/32 This Magazine is brought to you for free and open access by Digital Commons @ Boston College Law School. It has been accepted for inclusion in Boston College Law School Magazine by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ Boston College Law School. For more information, please contact [email protected]. A STEELY MEGA-DEAL | LAB TRIUMPHANT AT 40 | THE INDOMITABLE MEL ROBBINS BOSTON COLLEGE LAW SCHOOL MAGAZINE | SPRING / SUMMER 2008 PSowertar Hollywood’s Patric Verrone Symbols of Summer The Boston Garden swan boats are a perennial attraction. Contents SPRING / SUMMER 2008 VOLUME 16 | NUMBER 2 DEPARTMENTS 2 In Limine 3 Behind the Columns 4 In Brief 10 Gallery 12 Point of View 13 Legal Currents EMPOWERING EUROPE’S CENTRAL BANK 20 A question of authority THE OLD CHURCH-STATE DEBATE ROB DUNLAVEY Religion’s role in elections UNSHEATHING A SECRET WEAPON Statistics and racial profiling FEATURES 30 Faculty SCHOLAR’S FORUM 16 Writing Wrongs A new view of tax relations Guild West President Patric Verrone ’84 PROFILE: James Repetti ’80 leads striking screenwriters to historic victory BENCHMARKS By Vicki Sanders ACADEMIC VITAE 38 Esquire 20 Nerves of Steel ALUMNI NEWS Mark Leddy ’71 helped assemble an CLASS NOTES international mega-deal of daring gambits, deft defenses, and steely resolve 54 Commencement By Chad Konecky 55 Reunion Giving Report 24 Seeking Justice, One 60 In Closing Tough Case at at Time Though the BC Legal Assistance Bureau is turning forty, its lessons in advocating for the poor never grow old By Jeri Zeder On the Cover: Photo by Kevin Scanlon 42 KATRINA WITTKAMP SPRING / SUMMER 2008 | BC LAW MAGAZINE 1 STEVE DUNWELL [ I N L IMINE] SPRING/SUMMER 2008 Growing Pains VOLUME 16 NUMBER 2 Dean John H. Garvey Community emerges stronger, smarter Editor in Chief Vicki Sanders ([email protected]) t has been interesting—and sometimes painful—to observe over the past year the Law School’s growth spurt, a surge in energy unlike any Art Director Ichronicled in the pages of this magazine in the last decade. The period Annette Trivette was filled with challenges of all sorts, among them upset and ultimately widespread acceptance of changes to the alumni association; heated de- Contributing Editor bate over the choice of commencement speaker Attorney General Michael Deborah J. Wakefield Mukasey; the decision to join a Boston College capital campaign by com- mitting to raise $50 million for the Law School; preparations to launch an Contributing Writers online community with historic alumni networking capabilities; and reex- Christine Bang ’10 amination of policies over such things as law review membership and Steven Blau ’08 awarding the Founder’s Medal. Jane Roy Brown As is often the case with change, the various tests of mettle, courage, Natalie Engler and communications that many people endured have positively altered Chad Konecky how the school relates to alumni, faculty, and students—and vice versa. April Otterberg ’06 Some examples: There will be more faculty and student involvement in Tracey Palmer the selection of commencement speakers in the future (see related stories Judy Rakowsky Pages 3 and 4), and law reviews will be staffed by more diverse student David Reich editors (see story Page 5). As part of the alumni association restructuring, Jesse Stellato ’08 a broader group of graduates will lead and populate nearly a dozen com- Jane Whitehead mittees on admissions, career services, annual giving, advocacy programs, regional chapters, and the like, all of which will be held to new Melissa Whitney standards of responsibility and accountability (see story Page 41). Jeri Zeder Scholarship dollars are up, admissions recruitment efforts are Photographers expanding, and public interest liaisons are being identified in each chapter to mentor students interested in such careers. The Business Suzi Camarata Advisory Council is actively reshaping the business law curriculum Kevin Scanlon TIFFANY WILDING-WHITE (see story Page 39). By unanimous vote, the Board of Overseers Charles Gauthier committed itself to helping raise $50 million by 2013 with strategic Justin Allardyce Knight emphasis on faculty hiring and research, the LL.M. program, and loan Jason Liu repayment assistance, among other initiatives (see story Page 40). Tim Morse These many transformations and transitions are not surprising when Dana Smith one remembers that a future-facing posture is part of BC Law’s heritage. It is evident in the achievements of Patric Verrone ’84. His insights into Design & Printing the impact of new media on the fortunes of screenwriters inspired one of Imperial Company recent history’s most successful union strikes and will have ramifications Boston College Law School of for decades to come (see story Page 16). The Legal Assistance Bureau, Newton, Massachusetts 02459-1163, begun forty years ago, continues to pioneer new programs and methods publishes BC Law Magazine two times a year: in January and June. BC Law in clinical study (see story Page 24). And few lawyers today are as far out Magazine is printed by Imperial Company in front of global transactions as is Mark Leddy ’71, who was integral in West Lebanon, NH. We welcome to a steel industry deal of epic proportions (see story Page 20). readers’ comments. Contact us by phone at 617-552-2873; by mail at Boston Not yet a decade into the twenty-first century, BC Law is behaving College Law School, Barat House, 885 very much like a law school of the times. Centre Street, Newton, MA 02459-1163; or by email at [email protected]. Copy- Vicki Sanders right © 2008, Boston College Law Editor in Chief School. All publication rights reserved. Opinions expressed in BC Law Magazine do not necessarily reflect the views of Boston College Law School or Boston College. 2 BC LAW MAGAZINE | SPRING / SUMMER 2008 [ B EHIND THE C OLUMNS] Academic Freedom The Commencement Challenge by Dean John Garvey his year we invited Michael Mukasey, the Attorney General of the United States, to be our commencement speaker. Mukasey used to be the Chief Judge of the Southern District of New York and was, by some accounts, the best federal trial judge in the country. His presence at commencement Twas intended to solemnize the occasion. And be- time.) They felt that it was wrong for the Law cause he has given years of public service in high School to invite him, because our invitation could offices in the executive and judicial branches, he be understood as an endorsement of a position he would be an example of aspiration and achievement stood for in the public mind. Let us call this the for our graduates (see stories Pages 4 and 45). endorsement effect. It is an objection to our mes- Not everyone saw it that way. After Congress sage, not the speaker’s. Barack Obama declined to held hearings in late January on the treatment of invite the Reverend Jeremiah Wright to speak at his detainees in the war on terror, we heard complaints campaign kickoff because he was worried about the from some alumni and students. A number of facul- endorsement effect. He wasn’t afraid that Wright ty wrote the Attorney General urging him not to would persuade his audience. He was concerned come. They felt that he had become a symbol for that the invitation would reflect badly on him as a practices, like waterboarding, that were immoral presidential candidate. I think there is force to the and illegal, and that it was improper for us to hold claim that disinviting a commencement speaker does him up for emulation. This letter drew approving not violate academic freedom if the reason is a con- notices in the Boston Globe. The Wall St. Journal, cern about the endorsement effect, rather than the on the other hand, condemned it as a denial of persuasion effect. academic freedom and a left-wing version of Nor is it right for the Journal to suggest that only thought control. the left is concerned about the endorsement effect. Was it? I am on the opposite side of this matter When we have a commencement speaker who is from the objecting faculty, but I think this criticism pro-choice, people in the pro-life movement object is unfair. One reason to censor speech is the fear that we are endorsing values inconsistent with the that a speaker may persuade his audience to accept mission of a Jesuit, Catholic university. For at least his point of view. Let us call this the persuasion the last decade, and maybe longer, demonstrations effect. Milton, Mill, and other proponents of the and critical letters, blogs, and emails have been the free market of ideas argue that we should never norm around every graduation ceremony at the Law silence a speaker because we fear the School. The objections, from both persuasion effect. The best test of sides of the political spectrum, are truth is its power to find acceptance similar in form: By conferring honors in the market. If we have a better on our speakers, we endorse the idea, let us put it out there too, and positions they stand for. let our audience decide. Of course, there are a number of But the Attorney General’s oppo- wrinkles and qualifications in this nents on the faculty did not object to idea.