transcript of the hearing on Omnibus Objections to Claims. PRICE & BRUMFIELD, LLP 1 Opposition which consists of a partial Robert H Brumfield, III, Esq., SBN 114467 2 The hearing transcript shows a number of things. First, and most obvious, that no appearance was 2 Kunberly A. Ungar, Esq, SEN 200963 041 Greystone Plaza Building 3 in opposition to the Omnibus Objection to argue Mr Herrera's 3 841 Mohawk Street, Scitl"00 made on behalf of Mr Herrera 93309 Bakersfield, CA 4 the cour's concerns. Second, during the hearing, counsel for the Debtor 4 (661) 323-3400 position and address 5 and inaccurately presented Mr. Herrera's position to the court. Counsel for the Debtor 5 Attorevs for Creditor, Santos Gonzalez Hen-era misconstrued 10 6 attorneys at some point in October 6 states to the court that Mr. Herreraos encuse is that he changed 7 5" bar date. See transcript of hering on Omnibus Objections to Claims, page 7 after the September 8 which was submitted with a Request for Judicial Notice accompanying Debtors 8 IN THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT 33, lines 11-23, 9 9 IN AN9DFOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA Opposition. 10 not accurately state the points of law at iss oe. Due to the SAN FRANCISCO DIVISION At the hearing, the Debtor also did 11 and authorities and the absence of counsel for Mr Herrera at the hearing, the In ren Bky. No. 01-30923 DM absence of any points 12 the equitable inquiry required by Pioneer Investment Services Co. v. gn: 20 PACIFIC GAS A,ND ELECTRIC COMPANY, Chapter I I court did not undergo oration, a California corp Ltd. Partersaip, 507 US. 380 This is a manifest injustice heaved upon REPLY TO DEBTOR'S OPPOSITION Brunswick Associates, SANTOS GONZALEZ Debtor. TO CLAIMANT applied and equitable inquiry HERRERA'S MOTION FOR 14 Mr. Henrere who was entitled to argue that the lenient standards to be Federal I.D No9 94-0142640 RECONSIDERATION OF ORDER :i-• 12 DISALLOWING CLAIM OR 88 to be undertaken militated in favor of allowing his claim. It is not the excuse for the late filing that TO EXTEND TIME ALTERNATIVELY, 13 It is TO FILE PROOF OF CLAIM determines the fate of Mr. Herrera's claim, but the way the scales tip after the equitable inquiry. 16 1 the court fails to conduct the Pioneer equitable inquiry. Batemtan v. Unite 16 Date: November 27, 2002 17 an abuse of discretion if Time: 9:30 a~m. argued Dept.: 22 2218 States Postal Serv., 231 F.3d 1220, 1224 (90 Cit. 2000), Mr. Herrenr has also strenuously 21 19 that cause exists under the applicable Pioneer standard for reversal of the Order at issue. 25 H. THE COURT MAY RECONSIDER ITS ORDER FOR CAUSE 20 t• en i .- rasnsearv'et nfll *t'W 50l vvret1e""•NI&awiV 21 "Mlitis fairly clear that what constitutes 'cause' consielent with the equities of The show-ing necessary to suppor' tl-n c c is vitl- the court s discretion. 22 IUNItER I'}IE IFNIFNT PIONEER STA-NDARD tonoideraioo i.agist be new evidence supporting or icstrovertitg a claim .or that applicable standards for a reversal of the Order." 9 23 cause likely exists undeo the Contrary to Debtor's assernon and lengthy argument following therefrom, Mr. Herrera has Collier on Bankruptcy 15" ed. revised, Chapter 3008, paragraph 3008.01(4]. 23 24 rnsapprehended a The Debtor's Opposition asserts that reconsideration should not be granted because no new 24 made no argument whatsoever regarding attorney Slater's conduct. Debtor has 25 Mr. Herrera has argued that excusable neglect facts or new legal theories were asserted on Mr. Herrera's Motion. However, whether Mr. Herrera 25 significant portion of Mr. Herneras argument. 26 tas asserted new facts or new a legal theory is not dispositive on the issue of whether 26 occurred on two levels. First i attorney Tello's failure to timely file the Proof of Claim; and Omnibus Objection to Mr. Herrera's 27 econsideration should be granted. Regardless, the new facts and new legal theory presented on 27 second, that attorney Tellh failed to adequately oppose Debtor's 28 Mr Hen-era's Motion is supported by Debtor's Request for Judicial Notice in support of its 28 claim.
jetty is nines, tpnwen in OOOijŽOiyOTWOOsoi.flEfJflOSisOinSi jsflflSnfOtoooFObofl ositOteiGOooiOk osejnasnui 70 saTeorTOOt iSitS 750010 0,On
1994); In the Matter of Papp International, Inc., 189 BR. 939, 944 (Dist. Neb. 1995). Mr. Herrera has not misapprehended the test applicable to determning whether the court The Debtor concedes that it would not suffer additional material harm from having to litigate should allow Mr. Herrera's claim. The applicable test in the matter before the court is that set down the underlying claim. Debtor's Opposition at page 8. Debtor's only claim of prejudice is that it will Is in the Pioneer case. Pioneer relied heavily on the factors as enumerated in Dix v. Johnso 95 B.R. incur expenses in opposing Mr. Herrera's Motion to Allow Late-Filed Claim. Mr. Herrem's Motion 134 kB.A.P 9ý Cir 1988). Mr. Hen-era argued in his motion that the U.S. Supreme Court and the to Allow Late-Filed Claim is not a complex motion and Debtor's work has predominantly already Ninth Circuit mandate a lenient standard be applied when determining whether neglect is excusable been performed in opposing other similar motioes in its bankruptcy and in opposing Mr. Herren's and that a liberal construction of excusable neglect is appropriate. It should not be sufficient to state 4 12 Motion for Reconsidermtion. Debtor undoubtedly considered and assumed the risk in becoming that because attorney carelessness is the reason for the filing of a late-filed claim, the claim is involved in such law and motion matters when determining whether to petiton for Chapter 11 disallowed, end of inquiry. See It re Sacred Heart Hospital of Norristown, 186 BR. 891 (E.D. Pa. protection. The court should not find prejudice exists because the Debtor will have to oppose a 1995) A further inquiry is required pursuant to Pioneer. Debtor concedes that the equitable inquiry 18 basic motion. Receiving the benefits of Chapter II reorganization certainly outweigh the relative is required and strenuously argues against Mr. Herers. The argument and dialogue between expense of opposing a motion when the outcome of that motion has no bearing on the He'reca and Debtor on this issue is what should have occurred at the hearing on the Omnibus 2 reorganization wfslhiivt . 17 'bhe'sso and the court has discretion to a'lo'w a foil and fair heanng on the Debtor's objection to 23 fberr is further no pre-'idic t. De'tor so :hat there sill S11on,ci 'rt os 'grcazaton Fl-t orioras .a1-0 the competing proposed Chapter I I Plans provide that pending litioation claims, i94 "III. 14 because both of S'•: 15 2025 inch as Mr. HIenera's, are Class 8 claims. Class 8 claims are to be paid outside of the Debtor's THE EUIJTrIES WEIGH STRONGLY IN FAVOR OF ALLOWING 16 Chapter 11 Plan and hence cannot have an impact on reorganization. MR. HERRERA'S CLAIM 121 17 B. LENGTH OF DELAY AND IMPACT ON JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Contrary to Debtors contention, there were no repeated failures to comply with deadlines by 18 2318 The next item of inquiry before the coon is the length of the delay and its impact on judicial Mir Herrera. Mr. Herrera's attorney, Mr. Tello. missed only the deadline to file the Proof of Claim. 24 proceedings. The length of the delay has not had and will not have any significant impact on There were no other deadlines missed by Mr. Herrera. 20 25 udicial proceedings in Debtor's bankruptcy. Debtor concedes this point. Debtor's Opposition at Debtor's argument regarding what the court should consider when applying Pionl -ris in pat 21 26 page 9. "[T]he mere length of the delay alone is not in any way dispositive, except to the extent that based on cases that were pre-Pionee cases. Further, those same cases were decided by 22 17 the delay affects judicial proceedings'" In re Premier Membership Services LLC, 276 B.R. 709, orisdictionsi that, pre-Pioneer applied a strict standard of excusable neglect which was overruled 23 715 (S.D. Pla. 2002). The "floodgates" argument by Debtor should not be taken seriously when ,yPioneer, 24 there is no evidence that numerous others will file late claims should the cootn allow Mr. Herrera's A. PREIUDICE TO THE DEBTOR 21 25 claim. See Beltrami at 392. Several post-Pioneer cases state that a lack of prejudice is a primary consideration in the 26 Even if Mo. Hen-era's claim had been timely filed, or if the cootn allows Mr. Herrera's claim Pioneer analysis, See Sacred Heart at 897; In re Beltrani Enterprises, 178 BR. 389 (M.D Pa. 27 to be filed late, it will have no impact as it stands now because both of the proposed Chapter 11 28 SThe Circuit Courts that prm-Pioneer applied a strict standard of excusable neglect include Plans indicate that Mr Herrera's claim will be dealt with outside of the Plan and will not involve the Fourth, Seventh, Eighth and Eleventh. Pioneer at 387 4 3 ( I, 4-, 4, I * .i 44.. I ' * 0 " 4--- 4,', 4'
- 4 3
Iotrt 430
*0 11
40
'4 .d Hil '" Ms nf I' ti1 1 p
RIMrIllAMA giMi
jT ~ ~~p ~ 2 4~* ,;g Q'I" u l Hi nfa
31IN 19A~1-14 fz15 Hen15 9841
* 0% 0% 0 '.4 eq '.4 0% 0% 40 N 0% 44 0 -4 eq eq 0% 0% '0 N = -. eq to - 0% '0 N -4 -4 -4 -4 -4 -4 -4 -4 -4 -4 eq eq eq eq eq eq eq eq eq
44%-q444404000%r'.4.4 4414'0fl04
004 .44 *A4440fly S I 3 a-' i 04 a- a4
2> '0 42 >404 43 a sw a ii A 04 2 i-ts' 44 a a l 1H In Ut' Oili .5- 443 2 a-'0 443-332 0404043 '04>7 aJI '; 3y 2 goal-04 - >42 2'> 145 0 404 F MIA 43a3½.42 4,4,4,a 04 A& 243
I A I I ' 2' I __ IN I 43 0422 04 41 h ' I 4- 20443 K 2 -> s 2'>'>! >, >4>3> its 'a 1 3•4382 111 04- -3 04-4 a -i 3 o':3 - 3 >jp 3 Qa04 A.5 O j4 s43 h-I ;4243 ijAQ '035,i 4,'0'53 a , -3 <3j2 ->304>-42 j A 3.1 Ajk' r 04044, I'>04 >4 04>"'>" S 42-3 WH AUI1! I'm42143 &d 1 ½ AlA 3140 4 a'3 42V' 4 2 a-U 04J> 4,>3 043 '0233 '0-52 3> F 4,> 4949< 4404U 044.4444-4, 444204 W2 3a-,<>3A43 W4,-'04 5204< 4,4224,2
- N N 04 - 04 N 04 04 0>0044<0444,0404 04 04 0 - N 4< 04 444 40 N 04
0=1
04 a 3 A 43 104 a 3 P I 1 04 i 2 4' >4 a A 3 2 S 3>4 . 2 I 3 '0 43 '0 S 2a 04 1' >04' '03 a ii 5 4-. 404 12>4 43 2 423242 a-ii '04Ž, -3 04>4;: -42 0 4 " P 25 p04 3 44043 < 04 3-043 4 >1 1 04t45 , 44045 '034, 32 04 '>2 4454, 4-I 33-3 3-3 P42>4 I>] J~ill 5045'2 04a44' >43 '0 >4, 33 a 3:304 j 4, aa- 141 .4>4 25 SNa M 3 04 S 's3., 4'0- ta- ,w 5304 g-243 6,4,-I2 13th) 0444 S 22 <930 [ a 543 >44- 144>046,2 A aU 0 CU-a, >400404>4 Ai:3 1g
A 43 *04 S I 21 j 4 43 I A 433 A 4 543 4, ll A a >4 -3 ,4a -a-ga 43:3 52 32 42 S 2: A% 5 33 04 5 '014a 434
04 - 404 N 04 04 a '0044fl04N 04 N ONNN N N N A A w 0 9 A ý' A I 04~~~ ~~ ...... '4 0 0
I HAMmcM,
'A -~ Ill IA~ I A-Is
Il M-1 1-3 .,-3 Hil Hs BI I-., 4 " jillfl I C9
ur%
EMU ANAI - > I" H
v0 41100t%I1fVS Otdrt
HIM~~ H No Nt N! N N1 N'NiN Aj VIA fV* j -,j I U lV I fl1 .
f ai~ " 4 10%;
- HI I- IM wa- I
is w~~* o N
In% - %- N % % 1 % - %61 1 x4N I % 0 0 o
I 0%OtOOEtOswooerw 0,WONVO Marc Hirschfield Maare G. Boc. K-r6on N R.ucok illian G. Srtofeldt Baiastom Hoth CraigE. Fr FredH jetmeao 1 Tele, gEid & Feei.LCP 11 Pillsboi Whoilip LLP 1 De-,y BBOsilr LLP GrayCary Ware & Freldectnh LLP 72 Sour Fgu ,oaSe, Suoe 2800 1301 Aer ofthe Amrcas 40W 57th Str-, 26t PFIl 1755 Fmbarcadet 2 Nor York, NY 10019 2 Los Anrgelis.Califonuic 90017 New York, N-e York 100196092 [Cesrl forDywnogy Poae- Marketing.tIc Eit Segundo PaloAlto. Califoia 94303 (Counselfor Calpe Corpnomon[ of Bl.c]cal Pa- LLC.Long Beacb Gaidalona LLC; Catrl.1 Poer I [Counselfor tmeeraranalBeohekoeeod 3 Marc S Cohen andLoeal 1245] 3 LLC C,•ro11.Pom- 11,LLC; Dye..gyd Marketing & Trd Workers,Local 47 Aahleigt A. Dart.e MarteaL Fines•er Da,'d WrightTeansoe LLP LLC,W- Co-i LCCI 4 K.a, Schl&c LOP 4 Luda Boyle 1999 Aaealuefthe Suos, Suite 1700 OSnEmbarcadma Cntel. Sarn 600 TimeWece Telecom ac. Kenerth a ReyrcoklsEsq Los Angeles Casfoer•a90067 SanFrarroan Califorma94111 Sutre400 5 5 Keosethb RRyeyokIsIIc 10475 PaskMeado- D-rro, [Conuaelfor Official Cons1 es. ofprcipac, Creditorr [Coriamelfor WheVilab-atnShbata Enegy C ] Way, Suite 210 Larleroec,CO S012, Claam] 2020 Hmiey 6 6 Sacrramerto,CA 95025 MartinL Nelson uAmoyeyforn Mcoam Firwood andHazaod Tr) ConI Scott Marnargarm Weidaell K-tmc Springs, h-c ShastaCounty Treaaure- Tai Cllecorue 7 Sac"mees CematyDeparrnr of FPnance 2890 Cl•enlandArne Suite 8 K.- K Hash P 0 Boo 991330 Sneer, Roam 1310 SacraRosa, California95403 96099 700 H LOP Reddmg,Califarnia See Weo,Cdsaom 95114 Er,.r, Cohen& Jessup 8 9401 Wlihire Boulecand,91r Floor [CoderceCLmaey of ssamemne Richaado Bearly Hills. Caldfanea90212 Lynn. BP Aro andChemicaus So 9 9 [Cursel for Ronald A KarrTecdnologyLiceasmg L P] Ac Products MarkA Sp.ar PO Ban 3092 Buaroes Src5-s A6328 & SHo.de & LC- LCP Houston.Te.ar 77079 Boalensed Stroock KimberlyS Wirck 7201 Hamilton 10 180M.der Lane All-earar, PA 18195 Maye BroaB &Plan Nea York, NY100358 Mary Ann Kilgore GeneralAttmney 722 350 South GrandAvemns, 25th Floor 11 [camsrl forI At.u & Compmay] LonAngeln, Califora 90071 M Dard Mamick Uson PaonfecRaroad Compareey LLP [Cousei for Acea Erergy LLCand Wal FmrenAssociaies PillsburyWithrop MarkC. Elleebiag 1416Dodge Stnra Roam 830 S12 I] 50 FrPnaarsSnee Cadwaslndee,Wickersham & Tad Omaha,Netaska 68179 SanFnratoas, California94105 1201 F Sw NmW,Site I 100 Tlneerorotek Corpmration] Mary B Holland KiehlT Job-. [Cou...l for Wasthegam,D C 2005 10 FinancialConsulrane Logi Diur.o. 12~o [Coansel fTrMBIA] Ofice ofcity Attorney M FreddieReiss Salcon Smith Barney Denye, nt of Wata andPo-a Pr nsreluoCoepenaLLP so Mart Fomeer I1IuSuperioe Av Sutes 1800 Hop, Smers 19 P 0. Bol 51111, Suite 3ef 4OOSouth lnernal Re-.ue See-c, Cleelad. Obi. 94114-2307 90051 Los Angelra.Catlfomi 90071 Bosmesecelf-EanployedDinisrio Coomsl •T•ce for the coantroJ'St Los Angeles.Califoresa 82~ 16 Small [PreparedFinancial Adesor to Conmeree] 160Spear Sarner9th FlPor Edara Hige School] LarreeM Nasbeluky San Frueio, California94105 MO SigaleT 17 Man Holley Momson & FoessterLCP [CoIel fSi the UnitedState of Aimero] 1290Ae u of the Amria, Surep•on"Iha-h & Battles Lds Cepor.a.n Yrk, NY 10104 425 LinmageonAccrue Mark Gortna TWaCorporarioa Way Na 18 peaabdy, MA 01960 [C-.1r forEl Pa Methana EnergyL.P] Nt York. NY 10017 Mary E o0dm [Cms•adfor Duike EneWRy nTedeag saed Markeg] Todd N4Bailey 19 19 l.Docougaa, HaSad & Al42n MBIAS a Carpmame SepheaS. Sparks MashaaS Spa, Iks 533 CapetrlMaSS, NmrPl Faon Anne SPM-PCF Spach& Assaciates.P C 113King Sawne 20 BeyseCare 20 S en. Califoe-a 95114 200Mam Scae S.ara33OO 4675MacArthur Cara Surte550 [Coae.a for Northen CaifmmiarPram Agency] ArsnaskNY 10504 Ka-sar City. Missoun 64105 Hame Besach.Cal n 92660 20 SacI 21 MelanieFPa.m fCnel for City of KamsasCity] [Counselfor Wi llam LyanHoma, Martha E Roamo Lao .fficc Ioarla E RSceni GoenalCcoel liare -Lua 22 Sý-Vce Prtedc & Senar P.:1 Arlme, 5mtcA 22 D'se M.-n & HOckoclr LP ,43 S-uh 260 _-noo R-a , Romo 4CO100 B*c n lvcor0y'qcuincadbie Whirtn, Calidoera90602 Soute500 4200 OneLiberty Pl-c Sao R-eo Celif-ia 94583 i a3377West Olyoieý Boulvd, 23 [Counselfor Secund Credit- Varou Cablforri Coo 23 SA~geln,Cliforeni 90034 Philadlapa. PA 19103 a Calrfaou MellonBank, N.A [C-oe for Tilrun CorimsusoraC ep of Cafdoarn] [Ccunrl forSat Cai ValleyWater Dumer] 24 24 Mars. A. Martno Ana:L Sc.a So-.are L.-n P Ebima ManDaBDar a00So Hope Snt, Rh Fluor 25 C.ste Conpsm• H, Mail,Merel Job. R. Kanal,Ir SuitaA Los Angeles,CA 90071-2896 25 12895 AlmstaBoulnard, MNm•na& Farner Perara Cares& Ellis LLP Sue Ramnoe,Catlfomrna 94583 Mela C Meyers 190OMacArthur Bculnaod 701 Fifrh Avee, Suite5000 26 Seatle, WA 98104 KIatherneD. Ray 26 rtng&Carfolior 92612 (Counselfan PPL Moetans, LLC. Ulity Tree Serve, FPbt 27 Goldberg,Soer, Meyers& Doain 27 Corpany] " MontgoelraySne, Sores2900 S. Frar- , Catlifonia94104 28 28 [Cousel for Modero long..orDirant]
MorganGuaanty Tr•st Caropanyaf NH York o0. B. Cane Weia,Goeshal & Mages LOP Muct.anlMomns 1 A.o CaiS MeidnN, M-rc Lyocn 60 Wall Scwa 701 BEincll Aerao Suit. 2100 & D -mn A.r .ki Ahton HeeMiga, Be•me N- York, NY10260 Miami,.Florida33131 2 Corporaton] 2 World Fam-citl CuoNcrt Tofs 601 SouthFig..aa Snewr,Suite 3300 [Counselfor PG&E 90017 2.O Vbsy Scwr, let Soor Los Acgele., Califre-a Mr DanidBRoersg, Secretary Neryork NrY10201 1310 [Counselfor Southet Califonia Gas Compasy) 3 FederalEnergy Regulatory Caoamsm Pancanadi EnergySorce•s Sc 3 OgtFarst Sa, HNE.,Room I-A 1200 SGathSean Sore 900 dctnlA Bermana MiWctalP Shtoa. Eaq 4 Warsr"mi•nDC 20246 Hxtoon. TX 71002 Smcu•iO and KachageCoess os La .rmE Oscar,Easq Am BEs RSdd LLP 450 Fith Stea, NW (MarlStop 0606) Hatn Loewr& Parks 5 Nany Hocxhlna 3300 BPToa. 200 Public Square Panica S Mar 45 Washingo, D C 20549 TariamRcotb a Cleceland,OH 44114-2301 701 UniireasityAverae, Suite200 M.m-on & Fa-ea LCOP 6 043Marker bcnt, 33edFlor 6 delishalA. Ro...i." S -as, Cafoloma9525 K,,ff D Ross Michtel . Erarghe Foco,rar CA 94105-2482 [CouaaelSo Pradrgy Dcolopmereen,. - n•eee nanch] Ina] atban Done & Cratche LrP Robita & ColeLLP 7 [Coaael toeAES New Energy. 290Trumbull Sneer 7 2100 McKinniy Acle, Surie 1100 NanoyHout.lans Dallas,TX 75201 Harffaod,CT 06103 Train.a Ebtanon Parces S Mar,Esq 8 [Cojaal for NRG Enery,. tan] [C el te GernerSElae Company] 701 Uoo•try A mo Suite200 Momm & Fo-st LLP Sacaraeto, Cafttaa 93825 425 Maikt Scam, 33edFloor MidhdR od 9 Califorma94105-2482 IduZuel B LCbra L Snerw,Inn-] Smnman. 9 Badraxan [Co.eld ft 929 CP Poem Soposr Begtam. WaCuteat LOP Stoaal Pea•n for UnirityBarB [C-annl forA-ara Emerg,In and 1430Willow Pass Road,SaLan 240 10 Company.Sea.] 10 353 Soah SrandAvamue Sare 440D ftaaryIeweren LonAsgehes, Calemmaa 90071 Cancoed,Clffoamia 94520 SBsanhvel&PFnlna"LSP [Ca.sal forRehiant Energy., S.n. 11 333 MarketSteer, 32mdFloor Paul C. Lan--am 11 Michad V Muerthe Their, Reid & Priest LUP MulnnreLoan Coryor airo SaPmrco, Calfaomu940.3 8 12 [Counel for RegocyCente,,e LP) 101Sreond Soul Sb.n 1600 12 ".(lrr,,bralor I It-.zgesrc Fos: Office B.. 1647 Sb F-roi. CWifois 94I05 4191 13g r Btoule]ard [001--c. ri -- trn c- P:,J3 j M~ch~aelF O'Fne ,, 13 Bg H. Laae alifeiaC2315 e NSotarD SFeoc Acry ofrn Reptblr, S..m E petty [Co..sel fOrLun SfhtG0id SGoal& Winer LLP Paul I Peau cI > o11 4 McDoeracr,Will & Emery Ructar, Spnas Ktbbe& Orbi " ".14 1920 Man Strent,Smire 1200 OneChae Manalon Plans rIee Califomia92614 6an l3th So-. N.W. Ne York, NY 10005 Mike 0, Nakagama [Coonselfor Aram.a Public ServcceCoil Wahimgano,D.C. 20003 MNogaeStalyCaprS Group Sc.a] 15 [Coarel feeDK Acqaisitin, Partners] Nakaoaan& Rim, [Coasei for 2335 Capitol OeknDaie, Sotre 130 16 YolandaCiam Msch•elH Almes Sc to, Califarnia95833 909 MeyerSnms, No 24 Pari M. Bards [Counselfor KimballHill Hormes,Ic.] Tmce V Fnsaard ;~17 AMoe,Cahoif.n. 93203 ladsh M Hermesic KimberlyS Fmnerari Baanldk- Koomuk& Shaathan 20.017 Sa at100 OnKa. Mi R. Jutes NetdJ. Rtumme 1011Taerey Sencod 18 95816 Sheppar,Mullrn, Rideh & Hampton Califoria EnergyCr- R. Shiatiday Saosaamel,California Holly and Yaki 1a Foa EmbarcaderoCenater. 17th Floes 1516Nminth Sne MS-22 Aras& Hadd. LOP [Cfnael fSrBrmo Valley ImrgationaDiri Disrmr] sanFosmisin, CnIsaesOr94111 Seanra Catfanmas95814 19 Ta Esbarasdao Ce•ter,5th Floor CountyFlood Contol andWoer Cun.sencuns 1619 [Cou l for GWFPo. System LP; HanfordL.P and San Feu-aoa, Ca•amoia94111 Muchell A,Hardmoa Thermal EnergyDeveiopemar Partnertsp.. LFP.] 20 [CoruaeSafn Assecsmanof BayAd Governmentssod Pete 1. Bmvarut6 DavidPieon ALCANblunA Corp.] Hellar EhnsomWhile & McAuhlffeLIP 25 P SchoenfeldAssea Manageamnt, LLC 333 Bush Street Miecael Haramlto 21 pFeorwa.tounncaopo LLP 1330Ance aftlet Am•nc-s, 341t Floor Ne. W Rst SanFcrenatso, Caltfornia 94104 22 NereYork. NY 10019 A-ens of the Att sa WI-e & CsneLOP 1301 22 NH York, NY 10019 633 WestFilth Saw, Surie 1900 PeterI. Gute. Mutrh0llS SO1aki Jeffrey C. Kmasa 22 [ProposedFaacua Ad-rsonB Coaamsnen[ Los A"Sees,Califra 90071 LosmoencA Lnaroe 23 [Cou.nseJo Darsh BankAG, Ner Yrk Branch] GregoryK. Jona Michael I Blumenfeld King& Spalding Akin.Gump, SiGnous,asesr & FePd 23 Park Suite 2600 Plan, Suite 1675 1185Areue ofthe Amerrc Officeatt Treanm ad Tan Collect. 2029 Ce•tury Fars One Kaiser 24 90067 1heOrdway Buildcg NW York, NY 10036 CoutnyofaM .ed LonAngtie. Calil•-ma 24 [Counsallin MBSA) Oakland.Caldoma 94612 25 2222 M Sne. (C.o•el for Hyp-ow lcorpariad] Mercd, CA 95340 Pass s. Clarkat 25 MitchellSoder DrmSkJ. Bak MichaelL Tohu KramerLo Nanlaiis& FRnakelLOP 26 OffooflthaU.S Trustee ReadSmith. LI.P 26 DnodM Stinc 919 ThirdAcnc Arm Paera Coda 2500 LiberyPla NewYork, NY 12022 Michelle C Campbll 27 25o0MonegomrySUM Sitoe 1000 1650Markd Shoe Philadelphia,PA 19103-7301 27 Kim,Tuctre, Bogdaroff & Sinc LOP Snsraor-c,CA94104-3401 1180 CenturyPark Eart, tries 200 28 28 LosAngele. Calif.au 90067 [Counselfor Castoness Ergy, LLCand FPL EnergyInc I 6 I - I ! I g J 8 id$i 1 t: ii k;tlI iII!'t uad A[ 9a . IS jJJ I 2I g~i~gJ I111 2 I1 II
i A WII I :~4 trvA~1 an (.4 0 -. 0 40 0 0 0 44 0 0 40 0. 0 II - - - 0 0 - 0 0 - 0 0 ( 0 - -4 (4 (4 (40 0 (4 (4 (.4 0 (.4 4.4 0 40 0 0. 0 e4 0 4 0 0 0 c4...-e4e.- S 0 40 0. 0 OSt-0444 404444(4 0400044
44.,-.o.e. OflOfln4 04140444. 04, X(tAt"0fl 4
. I - - *-1- U 4. 1 t -, I- le s Si.- I- . T - 05n0 a'-!
,M 21 0 11 II S j t ! 6 T o q 4 511! 4Iu 1 . 5 U . -ailo i.mU I~h R.11<0 pq I iuffii WI ' " I B5; Ad. S u I o oo~u~hS 11 0 cb~o IAnI ill ½ mA S 4 8 a . % U I Ju -. d 1 J1 j i I ig e 4 ..m .. , Is 1if we.0 M c.1 ½ HHim I t.s I..A k2a . "a
- (4 0 0 0 eC 0. 0 0 0 0 0 0 40 0 0. 0 0 0 - 4 4 0 0 0 0 0. 0 - 44 0 0 0 0 4- 0 0 0 .-4 0 0 0 0 0 4 0 0 0 (4 0 0 0 0 44 0 .4 (.4 - 01 - (.4 (.4 - - - (.4 (4 (4 (4 0 (4 (4 0 (4 I 401-een. 0400n(4 00444044. 4. 44444444404i0 44 04444400 1 WilliamsEnergy Matkeong & TradongCo (Camina) Whtelnbraso hasea.Energy Co Iro TIo. C, W.soh Aom Jeff Sbho-e 20811Itdusory R.d One Will-r Center,I 9th Fluor 0B7Myaos .1 Corosrastlo TXU Enrjgy Trag Comanyoy 1 Aadetnn, CA 96007 Iep t 558 Man SOtr 125Sooo Sooret 1717 P 0 Box 2848 -- stn MAý021:3 Dallas Texas 75201 2 Tloa, Oklaotr• 74101 2 A.te& Ca-, LLP Aten NeI Mitllrd AtemKelly Knooits lI Macredi Tho- Eaanoon Arm: 3 633 West Fifth SL,Suate 1•00 3 OS Bank ZankStnobhd Je-) R Blooc LosAngeleo, CA 90071-2007 CorpoesteTent S-es Coposatcon BSo L Htol.an 4 [Attorneyfor PNY Woo-r Trt CoamPay) moans 4 White & Cae LLP Athe LaDonnaMo...o 1155 Petee Center We.st ISOEaa Fifth St, 3r Floor Atlnta, GA30338 633 WeooFifth Suter, 19th Floor Whlte&Cane, LLP St Paed,MN 55101 5 Los ArgelesCaluoota 90071 Aten Neti MtlthrdICRandolph Fushbbu Zaokenetn-Maodeolle,Ioc 10 (Co-el fot Oildael Enetg" LC] 633 WeanFslf St, Suate1900 NuclearRegulatory Conenestoht 6 D 487 US Los Angeles,CA 90971-2007 P Box Aln- DotmoeomControl Desk Stenkton.Cl.tfoena 95201 Thomas0 Leonta (Atrosey faoBai•k of Ne York) W.lshgtoo, DC 20555-5•01 7 7 JerryR Bnot, B.. L Hol Willam Bat•e ll Lawece M. Jmbonke Aaaocsnton GItlfkeld, elda & JIboso LLP Wh I, & Case LLP US Trot Company,Nanonal MoCoo.s. Doyle,Bran. & Esten, LLP State 2050 8 9060 WilshteeBooloard, FifthFloor 8 b33 AestFtffl SUte, 19th Floor One Eb-adn o.Cnter, 19OGOniversity Avenue ÷3709 BeverlytHills.Catfoe 90212 LooAngoon, Caelrfoa 90071 San Fracniseo.CA 9411 EIa Palo Alto, Calsfomsa94303 -2223 9 [Cos1oseflo TCimmanConsost Corporationof 9 Coasd tosnRspon Cogemeabont, Ian] [Conn.l forReliant Eoesgy, In.] US Bank, Corpoest Trust Seres Calif.-.] L•do•a Momoon Th. Leaoa 10 WilliamC. Monsur-Knox pGo Boo64111 W KelseotEkert WOite& Cas LLP MichaelD Proogh Fo&ers,Bee & Annotase Ftrat UCon F tsol Center St Pala. MyN95164-01l1I 11 Rob- M. Ps, Jr. 4711 Ifighlvay17 South, SOase3 200 South Btoeo Boulevard Msmna-Knon H.oId Mealder& Prougs. LLP Vicor Wain eantgePasl, Flosrda 32073 Masrm.Florda 33131 500Ygnso ValOeyRoad, Suite 45O Lawev,O a,of Victor Witd r 12 [Constanfor CreditoeLadstdnar sger] S12 [Cosel for OldalýeEngy LLC.Wadh EnergyLP. Waloot Crol, Caisfosota94596 I Mdattoee 2625 pan OaS Boulevard,SUoo [Coo l fosNanonal UnioeFire 1--n.ssoe Companyof Sanuanenato,California 95864 -- 13 KeenedySroh Coga LP,KtS-KiOgbhg I] Pntburogh,PA) [Counselfor Kim Creedo] PosterValley isgmtnenDtsmtt Post Ofce Box 186 ThomasE Lamtden o azI 14 WillhamH K9klhofcr II : y 14 Viotoe. Lang Caltfo.ta 95496 RookyHo YaleK KLo PonerValley. PtsoowatstthosasecoopansCCp AT&TCoup StotooB Rich 795 F[dInm Sereet,2nd Floor ArmiesAguilar 199 Feme SeUM KelleyDry. & WarrenLIP San Fecs , CalIfoasa 94107 Gary Cnoers SainF.oto Caltfeta 94a05 777 South Figuoea Street Sute 2700 I• 16 (CososeJfor AT&T Corep] 16 M ltnlAEd.a. [Proposed.PtFooc Ad-stot toCoaMnen] Los Angeles,CA 90017 CalsfornaPublic UOissoCoenasuron [Coo.nai for BP EnergyCompany. BP AMOCO) Cooper 17 LegalDsa M B.ls, W. Asta "Th-ost •amesM, Gardener 505 Va N-a Aganue Duae Mo-na& HOkscshorLLP Will,- I Fly-n & Grderer 18 San e•ninto, CA 94102 109Spear Stere Suite 1500 Cooper Ncsyfat Anderson,FrPetaa, Flyer & Grosboll 18 I-s, Suser10o San FsI- , C.alif... 94105 2535 Cop.a[lOalW. MonogenmarySwans, State 2080 Sancnnto, Cahkfneia95833 "44 JoasepW. Caroonet,Jr [Couonelfor Sant Clarn ValleyWarer Disnct] 19 SanP - , Caltfona 94104 19 [Conel for LarrySlako) Law Office of Joseph W C-on, Ir. [Coanaeltor IBBW Local #1245] P Eo 600 Be-asee A-ue MaCKann Wall. Moedie, 20 "Tsr Spaie& Gslloe LLC P.O. Box 3389 20 Iontd R a Sanvs WglliamM. Gotdhan The Z-tnanaBuilding RedswoodCty. Califort. 94064 Saal Buaeresa.tSelf-EstployedDivioson LogsC Yee 2117 Seond AvenueNorth 21 2 1 1301 nJay,ee, Rdoa 1403S %Tooi& Coodrnt ,CoaonoI-. C-st PlFtat B- ghao Alab -3a 5 503 oaLor £s tma 341'5 932S-,.• o -etE,Too FlooF S...c of •i [Atto--e-s t Drcr rtnJtis. I[no 22 1, -,se fuzýhe U.-ed 5ia:F-v;io, Caadffomi9411 Da-d E K.I. 22 Afn.tflý R-6t Shtlis M Roots-Hoonono Waltl I Lack DeporyCoonsl .TooryF lo.gdoU 23 Plolsip,,Lyrit. sHch-ok,Blame & Houboe 23 Eogatmo,Lipacoorp & Lank CountyGoeoroaest Comte, ExatWing T•hets 1--a andAnontt3 An of -Imies. 437 MaduoneAvnae, 34th Floor 16 70 W.st Heddisg SweetNinth Floor 730 TburmA-• 1010 Santa Morton BInd, Fluor 24 New York,NY 10022 Lea Agdeles,Cahfeora 96067 San lon, Califoerta95110 24 Ne York,N-Y 19017 [CoC-.[ fanHSBC Bak USA] [ccmel fanCOtyl ArmA-]tn [Coowi for Con.ty of SantaClara] 25 25 Tuny0 Heenoog WilliamP W.nensb WentdyL. Hogwtn "f.- LegalDepasrrsent PaohulsoaiSosng Ziehl Young& Jones Kmdm.y S. Wimck Goldnen, Fram & Murphy 26 Mayer,Brown, Rowe & Maw 1 I I1Bagby Satn Powell, Three Ebarcadeo Centor,Suter 1020 26 10thFloor 350 SouthOssod Anaut, 25th Fluor Hoson TX771'02 Sea Frnoo California94111 N.E Les AngeLes,Califnos 90071 191 Peach- Steeoa, 27 [Coonal for PG&ECorp I Alanta,GA 30303 [Coa I fot AcraEnng'y LLq 27 TXU EnergyTrading Canada Limited 1717 M.a Swans [Cot•e for entrt In-) 28 28 Dala, Tea 5'7201
Paul G Kcakotan AimP B-s-nok ltd K, Beley 726 BoaestowtAhnoe, Suite 18 The Law Officeof IondK Selwy 1 1 pryo, Ca.thmo•sShe- & Fi)r LLC Pes, California93704 410 Park Arosue 235 MoosgoosayStnot, Surte 715 SanFracioa Califo.- W4104 2 2 lNewYotk. Nrw York 10022 TourMile [Coo-al for De-ny'sInn) jConsel for WilT•gtun T-n State of Tent 3 I I Fluor,e Adrew Jakson Bldg 3 Th, Dtaheto Taus od, ln terr Ca-ool 4 Nahialle,Te s 37243 Suite20 'I'sareeeC-n1l1 1222 14th AvurSot. 4 4 Bousngham,AL 35205 21701 BigBlnd Rtad %M4stgooryCreek, Califo.r-n 96065 5 5 MeladthrP,Leta Wise & Cate LLP RichardLv-y. Jr An P. Bumtoca 633 WestFith S-t, Suite 1900 6 6 Calofuemt90017 PryteC.slntar Sh a & Flyoe LLP Lea A-gele, (C-nsel for KBCBank] 7 410 ?xokAen 7 New York, NFY10022 [Couoselfor Wilringten Toast] Aodet P Dentiale 8 8 Wiser& Case US' Aorthl"e'a. EugeneK yana-oto 1155 A -- "e" N1e York, NY 10036 9 Law Officesof Eugme K. Yansrmos 9 )Cnawaelfan KBCBRtk] 160 Fraekle,Stree, Suta 206 15 OaklaxndCA 94607 10 .And-t Silverstein 11 Len PCOBrians Serantr& KisaselLIP1 hlast~cete C oanolee One saresy ParnPia Ne' Yotk, NY 100(G ootR ftld, PLC 12 [Coslf BI kts3T-s Cropooy ofCalf-rcaI 12 'AN C-t Alt t c. Ito 11ý ,honi.- •5, 330W RobertF Ftite o 13 13 Wl11- A Bra.dey PoserMoser Btartr Tuns Company Aoe MamreE Tubao Four AlhaeyStuet 14 Leo Offce,,of Willsia k Brandry 2 14 10006 550 Woo C Sweet 1911Floor NewYosk, NY 15 15 S. Greg.California 92101 Brisn M5 atel [Coasal for Motans Franct..o Meamoa ad Lana Matasorer) Book& BookLLP -a 16 1414 SoquelAvenue, Sote 203 95062 Bean'Ste & Co Ito Sta C- Caklfina a- 20.S17 )Cntannsfan KR Loday .t Ia) 18 Ne York,NY 10179 trsoWason 19 Atleumon ThomastBoyce RobertC Shnsfeld 19 RelkyDry. & W-ns L/P 19 Shen M Skeswal 777 SonthFsgan•os Stree. Suiat2700 RnoM C SIerfeld 20 Los Angeles.Caltforma 90017 20 Keley Dry. & W-e, LLP [Counastfoa SatelliteSenior Income FPd] "77Sooth FsgUeraStreet, Stane 2730 21 Los Aageles,Calnfoatn 90017 21 Avd.aVlley Adsoay Council [Co.ntne for Deot•he Bank T-Se CoepTy Arencas] to NeslTaidtff 22 Smith Todtff & Cesdeall 22 WarrenMaite Jr Rikos,Doong. Schlrer, Hyland& PeroossLLP PFolOffoe Boa 1446 23 SanLoa Obi"po.C alsfomsa 93406 23 Hleadqolse PIF [Cosnnelfor Astln ValleyAdnsory Cootcil) DteoSpeedwrlI Avenoe 24 Moestovoo New ery 07962 1901 24 Pam J Kelly )CoC-or foeCmostyn Ho-osts ConyI Anddrane,Hexx & Kely 25 20 Avenue,2Jd Floor le R. Paltgn 577 Samoa. Abdb. M, Won, Campbell,California 95008 26 fos MilesRecttim 26 Penton BanefitG watyCorpmuto [Co-nel Offil of theL "ndCo-1 27 27 1200 K Stet N W Washtgttn. DC 20003 28 28