Public Document Pack

Friday, 18 January 2008

MEETING OF TOWN PLANNING COMMITTEE

Dear Councillor

The above-named Committee will meet in the Council Chamber, 3rd Floor, Adelaide Exchange on Thursday, 24th January, 2008 at 4.30 pm, for the transaction of the business noted below.

You are requested to attend.

Yours faithfully

PETER McNANEY

Chief Executive

AGENDA:

Routine Matters

a Apologies

b Minutes (Pages 1 - 6)

Minutes of the meeting of 10 th January, 2008

2 Routine Correspondence (Page 7)

3 Requests for Deputations

4 Applications Approved under Delegated Authority at Previous Meeting (Pages 8 - 53)

5 New Applications (Pages 54 - 61)

6 Schedule of Applications

a Applications Deferred from Previous Meeting (Pages 62 - 64)

b Applications for Planning Permission (Pages 65 - 101)

c Applications still under consideration (Pages 102 - 116)

Page 1 Agenda Item 1b

G 103 Town Planning Committee

Thursday, 10th January, 2008

MEETING OF TOWN PLANNING COMMITTEE

Members present: Councillor Lavery (Chairman); the Deputy Lord Mayor (Councillor Kelly); and Councillors Cobain, Empey, Hendron, Maginness, McCarthy, Moore, O’Neill, Patterson, Rodway, Smyth and Wilson.

In attendance: Mr. R. Boyd, Members’ Support Officer; Mr. J. Heaney, Committee Administrator; and Mr. P. Montgomery ) Divisional Mr. J. King ) Planning Office.

Apologies

Apologies for inability to attend were reported from Councillors Long, C. Maskey and McClenaghan.

Minutes

The minutes of the meeting of the 6th December were taken as read and signed as correct. It was reported that those minutes had been adopted by the Council at its meeting on 7th January, subject to the omission of the matters in respect of which the Council had delegated its powers to the Committee.

Routine Correspondence

It was reported that correspondence had been received from various statutory bodies in connection with the undernoted items:

Notification from the Roads Service of the making of an Abandonment Order in relation to Devonshire Way.

Notification from the Roads Service of its intention to make an Abandonment Order in respect of lands at Portmore Hill.

Notification from the Roads Service of its intention to create disabled parking bays at 19 Hillsborough Parade and 69 Glencairn Crescent.

Notification of the removal of parking bays at 14 Sefton Park, 20 Redcar Street and 76 Tildarg Street.

Notification of the introduction of traffic calming schemes at the Ballymagarry Lane area and Coolnasilla Park area.

A copy of the Road Service’s Traffic and Travel Information Journal 2006. Page 2

G Town Planning Committee, 104 Thursday, 10th January, 2008

Copies of the Orders, letters and maps relating to the above matters were displayed at the meeting for the information of the Members.

The Committee noted the information provided.

Request for Deputations

The Committee was informed that no requests for deputations had been received.

Revenue Estimates 2008/2009

(Mr. T. Salmon, Director of Corporate Services, attended in connection with this Item.)

The Director of Corporate Services informed the Committee that the estimated total of all Council expenditure, based on the draft estimates which had been prepared by the Chief Officers, had been considered by the Strategic Policy and Resources Committee at its meeting on 8th January. He reminded the Members that, in previous years, it had been necessary to make funds available to enable the Committee to engage consultants or obtain legal advice in connection with the preparation of submissions to public enquiries. The Director reported that provision for such eventualities had been included in the total estimates for the Committee in the sum of £31,400.

Accordingly, it was

Resolved - That the estimate of revenue expenditure as submitted for the Town Planning Committee for the year 2008/2009 be approved.

THE COMMITTEE DEALT WITH THE FOLLOWING ITEMS IN PURSUANCE OF THE POWERS DELEGATED TO IT BY THE COUNCIL AT ITS MEETING ON 1st NOVEMBER, 1973.

Planning Applications

Revised Opinion

The Committee considered the undernoted planning application in respect of which the Divisional Planning Manager had issued a revised opinion.

Site and Applicant Description Divisional Planning Manager’s Opinion

2a Arizona Street, Change of use from Permission Mr. M. Smith commercial building to residential dwelling Page 3

Town Planning Committee, G Thursday, 10th January, 2008 105

Reconsidered Items

The Committee considered further the undernoted planning applications and after discussion, agreed with the Divisional Planning Manager’s opinion thereon:

Site and Applicant Description Divisional Planning Manager’s Opinion

5 Cadogan Street, Two-storey extension Permission Mr. J. White to rear of existing house in multiple occupation

67-75 Victoria Road, Proposed change of Permission Victoria Estates use of dwelling to two (Northern Ireland) apartment units Limited (retaining existing facades) and construction of forty-two new build apartments.

53 Sandhurst Gardens, Change of use from Refusal Mr. R. Mulholland private dwelling to house in multiple 1. The proposal is contrary to occupation with Policy HMO 1 in the draft Houses two-storey extension in Multiple Occupancy subject to the rear plan as it would be detrimental to neighbourhood amenity and would, if approved, along with other similar proposals, be prejudicial to the outcome of the plan process which should properly be taken through the development plan process

Land adjacent to Erection of Refusal 177 Brooke Drive, two-storey dwelling Miss D. Ginley 1. The proposal is contrary to Policy QD 1 of the Department’s Planning Policy Statement 7: Quality Residential Environments, in that the application proposes an unacceptable form of development in that the development does not respect the surrounding context and the site is unsuitable to sustain a dwelling of sufficient size with adequate provision of private amenity space Page 4

G Town Planning Committee, 106 Thursday, 10th January, 2008

Site and Applicant Description Divisional Planning Manager’s Opinion

25 Combe Hill Park, Proposed attached Permission Mr D. Khan dwelling with minor alterations to existing dwelling to accommodate construction

27 Clonallon Park, Retention of two-storey Permission S., S. and C. Jones extension and roof-space extension (including dormer windows) to dwelling house

Applications Withdrawn

The Committee was informed that the undernoted planning applications had been withdrawn by the applicants.

Applicant Proposal

148 Connsbrook Avenue, Change of use from dwelling to MKR Developments Limited three self-contained apartments with three-storey extension to rear and associated alterations including the demolition of existing two-storey return

43 Glen Road, Demolition of detached dwelling Bailey Management and the construction of eighteen two-bedroom apartments in two blocks

Site adjacent to 2 Harland Park, Construction of two-storey Mr. M. Colton detached dwelling

220 Springfield Road, Change of use from vacant RGM Developments Limited office/store to seven apartments with a three-storey extension to the rear of property

Schedule of Applications

The Committee considered the schedule of applications which had been submitted by the Divisional Planning Manager in respect of the Belfast City Council area and agreed to adopt the recommendations submitted in relation to the applications therein, with the exception of those referred to below: Page 5

Town Planning Committee, G Thursday, 10th January, 2008 107

Location Proposal

68-74A Ligoniel Road Demolition of warehouses and erection of forty-eight residential units [Deferred at the request of Councillor McCausland to enable an office meeting to take place]

1 Henderson Avenue Erection of two commercial units and four apartments [Deferred at the request of Councillor McCausland to enable an office meeting to take place]

58-80 (even numbers Erection of fifty-one apartments and one only) Peter’s Hill, retail unit with associated site-works and 77 Brown’s Square and parking 19-25 Gardener Place [Deferred at the request of Councillor D. Dodds to enable an office meeting to take place]

38 Wellington Park Extension to form new entrance hall and disabled ramp [Deferred at the request of the Right Honourable The Lord Mayor (Councillor Rodgers) to enable an office meeting to take place]

12A Knocklofty Park Erection of a detached two-storey dwelling in the side garden of 12 Knocklofty Park [Deferred at the request of Councillor Rodway to enable an office meeting to take place]

733, 733A, 733B and Erection of three apartment buildings 735 Antrim Road comprising fifty-five units with communal garden, basement car-parking for sixty-one spaces and sixteen surface car-parking spaces [Deferred at the request of Councillor Smyth to enable an office meeting to take place]

21 Eglantine Avenue Conversion from ten-bedroom guesthouse to one two-bedroom and four one-bedroom flats including alterations/extension and replacement of store [Deferred at the request of Councillor McCarthy to enable an office meeting to take place] Page 6

G Town Planning Committee, 108 Thursday, 10th January, 2008

Location Proposal

1-5 Belmont Road Mixed use development consisting of ground-floor retail and residential above, with car-parking and associated works and access [Deferred at the request of Councillor Rodway to enable an office meeting to take place]

697 Lisburn Road Change of use to hot food bar/sandwich bar/café with sit-in facilities [Deferred at the request of Councillor Patterson to enable an office meeting to take place]

113 Bloomfield Avenue Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of three one-bedroom apartments with car-parking on street [Deferred at the request of Councillor Stoker to enable an office meeting to take place]

Delegated Authority

The Committee noted a list of planning applications which had been approved on the delegated authority of the Committee at its meeting on 6th December.

New Applications

The Committee noted a list of planning applications which had been received from the Divisional Planning Manager for the Belfast City Council area for the period from 27th November till 24th December.

Chairman Page 7 Agenda Item 2

Town Planning Committee Thursday 24 January, 2008

Routine Correspondence

The Committee’s comments, if any, have been sought in relation to the undernoted items:

Notification of the provision by the Roads Service of a Disabled Parking Bay at 29 St Albans Gardens.

Notification of the making of an Abandonment of a Public Right-of-Way Order at Devonshire Way and Albert Street.

Notification of the intention of the Roads Service to introduce a loading bay on Chichester Street (between Victoria St and Oxford St)

The Committee will be advised at the meeting of any further routine correspondence received.

Page 8 Agenda Item 4

DEPARTMENT OF THE ENVIRONMENT

PLANNING (NI) ORDER 1991

APPLICATIONS FOR PLANNING PERMISSION

COUNCIL Belfast Date 10-Jan-08

ITEM NO1 Deferred APPLIC NO Z/2005/1104/F Full Date Valid 17/05/2005 LOCATION Site to rear of 68-74A Ligoniel Road, Ballysillan Lower, Belfast, BT14 8BY PROPOSAL Demolition of existing warehouses and erection of 48 No. residential units APPLICANT Hunterswood Properties Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 2 APPLIC NO Z/2006/0227/LB Listed Building Date Valid 27/01/2006 LOCATION 11-15, Donegall Place and 7 Fountain Lane, Town Parks, Belfast, BT12 5JJ PROPOSAL Demolition of all internal structures and rear external walls. Retention of main facades (Donegall Place and Fountain Lane). Proposed new development within retained structures APPLICANT Lebreh Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT

ITEM NO 3 APPLIC NO Z/2006/0285/F Full Date Valid 09/02/2006 LOCATION 11-15 Donegall Place and 1-7 Fountain Lane, BT1 5AA PROPOSAL Proposed new four-storey retail development within existing retained facades. New infill elevation at 7 Fountain Lane. APPLICANT Lebreh Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 9

ITEM NO 4 APPLIC NO Z/2006/0333/F Full Date Valid 16/02/2006 LOCATION Lands of Castlehill Manor, Castlehill Road, Stormont, Belfast PROPOSAL Proposed residential development comprising of 1no. detached, 18 semi- detached, 52 duplex apartments and 4 apartments (total 75 units) APPLICANT Pattan Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 21 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 5 APPLIC NO Z/2006/0602/F Full Date Valid 16/03/2006 LOCATION 27 Landseer Street, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 5AL PROPOSAL Conversion from existing HMO to 2 No. Apartments with 3 storey rear extension and alterations. APPLICANT Mr B Fitzpatrick REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 6 APPLIC NO Z/2006/0863/F Full Date Valid 12/04/2006 LOCATION 3 Ireton Street, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT07 1LH PROPOSAL Change of use from HMO dwelling house to 3 no. flats, (1 for HMO use) including three storey rear extension. APPLICANT Mr M Clarke REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy HMO 5 and HMO 8 in particular that part of Policy HMO 5 relating to how the development will cause a net increase in the total number of HMOs in the whole University Policy Area, and the criteria in Policy HMO 8 in relation to:- Extensions/alterations to a house or flat for HMO use do not exceed 20% of the gross floor space of the original property. A number of representations have been made in respect of Policy HMO 5 and HMO 8. The Draft HMO Subject Plan for Belfast 2015 has reached an advanced stage of preparation and approval for this proposal would cumulatively, along with other similar proposals, be prejudicial to the outcome of the plan process by pre-determining decisions about the nature, scale and location of new development which should properly be taken through the development plan process.

Page 10

ITEM NO 7 APPLIC NO Z/2006/1623/F Full Date Valid 04/07/2006 LOCATION Wellington Square, Annadale Embankment, Belfast, BT7 3LN PROPOSAL Erection of new residential buildings consisting of 32 No apartments with basement car parking and 5 ground level external parking bays (College Drive, opposite River House), 3 No. townhouses (College Heights, to rear of Nos. 1&3 Haypark Gardens), 2 No. apartments (between College Heights & rear of Upper Courtyard), associated parking and landscaping, and alterations to the Boulevard landscaping strip, cycle lane, and footpath to create additional car parking APPLICANT The McGinnis Group REPRESENTATIONS 28 Objections 1 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 8 APPLIC NO Z/2006/2044/F Full Date Valid 01/09/2006 LOCATION Olive Tree House, 23-31 Fountain Street, Belfast PROPOSAL Demolition of existing building and erection of new 7 storey building, retail on ground and first floor with offices on upper floors APPLICANT Deramore Property Group REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 9 APPLIC NO Z/2006/2302/DCA Demolition within Date Valid 04/10/2006 LOCATION Olive Tree House, 23-31 Fountain Street, Belfast PROPOSAL Demolition of existing building and clearance of site for erection of a 7 storey building. APPLICANT Deramore Property Group REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT

Page 11

ITEM NO 10 APPLIC NO Z/2006/2311/F Full Date Valid 05/10/2006 LOCATION 35 Grand Parade, Belfast, BT5 5HG PROPOSAL Roof space conversion including alteration to rear roof elevation APPLICANT Mr M Davis REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 11 APPLIC NO Z/2006/2406/F Full Date Valid 16/10/2006 LOCATION 37, 39 & 41 Wellington Park, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 6DN PROPOSAL Change of use from flats and offices to 18no. apartments including demolition of existing returns, erection of 3-storey extensions to rear and alterations APPLICANT Euros Properties Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 60 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 12 APPLIC NO Z/2006/2480/O Outline Date Valid 22/11/2006 LOCATION 109-117 Stockmans Lane, Belfast, BT9 7JE PROPOSAL Site for 4-storey apartment block APPLICANT Mr & Mrs G McGrath REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is unacceptable in that it is contrary to Policy QD1 of Planning Policy Statement 7, in that it has not been demonstrated that the proposal would represent a quality residential environment. The proposal fails to meet the criteria of Policy QD1 in that: - the development fails to respect the surrounding context and is inappropriate to the character of the site in terms of layout, scale, proportions, massing and landscaped and hard surfaced areas; - inadequate and inappropriate provision is made for private open space and landscaped areas as an integral part of the development in keeping with the character of the area; - the proposal represents over development of the site, it is out of keeping with the surrounding area and would cause unacceptable damage to the local character, environmental quality and residential amenity of the area.

Page 12

ITEM NO 13 APPLIC NO Z/2006/2917/F Full Date Valid 19/12/2006 LOCATION 1 Slievegoland Park, off Antrim Road, Belfast, BT36 7PU PROPOSAL Erection of two no. three storey semi-detached dwellings APPLICANT Mr & Mrs J McElhatton REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 14 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0053/F Full Date Valid 29/12/2006 LOCATION Land between No's 63 and 65 Graymount Crescent, Belfast PROPOSAL Construction of 4No. apartments in a two storey development APPLICANT Mr C Shirlow REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 15 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0298/F Full Date Valid 16/02/2007 LOCATION Land east of Queen's Road and Hamilton Graving Dock, Queen's Island, Belfast PROPOSAL College campus and ancillary uses including beauty salon, hairdressing salon, bar & restaurant together with access road, basement (& perimeter) car parking of 329 spaces, provision of new junction, upgrading of Queen's Road & associated site works. APPLICANT Ivy Wood Colleges Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 13

ITEM NO 16 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0679/F Full Date Valid 16/03/2007 LOCATION 19 Clonaver Crescent South, Belfast, BT04 PROPOSAL Two-storey rear extension and alterations to dwelling APPLICANT Mr P Lagre REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO17 Deferred APPLIC NO Z/2007/0753/F Full Date Valid 26/03/2007 LOCATION 1 Henderson Avenue, Skegoneill, Belfast, BT15 5FL PROPOSAL Erection of 2No. commercial units and 4No. apartments APPLICANT ABM (NI) Limited REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 18 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0889/F Full Date Valid 11/04/2007 LOCATION 67 Malone Avenue, Belfast PROPOSAL Replacement of existing apartment building with a new 2½ storey building containing 7 No. apartments (two 3 bedroom apartments and five 2 bedroom apartments) APPLICANT Malone Holdings REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to policy BH12 of Planning Policy Statement 6: Planning, Archaeology and the Built Heritage and policy QD1 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 7: Quality Residential Environments and associated guidance in that it would, if permitted, result in overdevelopment of the site and would harm the character and appearance of the Malone Conservation Area through its inappropriate scale, form, massing and design. 2 The proposed development is unacceptable in that it would, if permitted, harm the amenity of adjacent residents by reason of visual dominance, overlooking and overshadowing. The proposal results in poor outlook from, and lack of natural light within the proposed units for prospective residents. The proposal would therefore fail to create a quality and sustainable residential environment.

Page 14

ITEM NO 19 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1001/F Full Date Valid 26/04/2007 LOCATION 4 Springfield Parade, Springfield Road, Belfast, BT13 3QR PROPOSAL Two-storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT M&S Developments (NI) Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 20 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1006/F Full Date Valid 27/04/2007 LOCATION 13 Dunluce Avenue, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 7AW PROPOSAL Conversion of existing House in Multiple Occupancy (HMO) to three self- contained apartments APPLICANT Mr J Stephens REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal would, if permitted, harm the local amenity of the area as it fails to make adequate provision for accessible refuse storage. 2 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD1 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 7: Residential Extensions and Alterations in that it would, if permitted, harm the character and appearance of the area through its inappropriate scale, form and design and would set a precedent for further such inappropriate development in the locality.

ITEM NO 21 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1031/F Full Date Valid 30/04/2007 LOCATION 111 Upper Lisburn Road, Ballyfinaghy, Finaghy, BT10 0LG PROPOSAL Proposed two storey side extension to existing dwelling. APPLICANT Mr & Mrs J & T Macklin REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 15

ITEM NO 22 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1058/F Full Date Valid 02/05/2007 LOCATION 234 & 234a Ballysillan Road, Old Park, Belfast, BT14 6QZ PROPOSAL Demolition of existing single storey retail units and erection of 3 storey building with credit union office on ground floor and 2 apartments on floors above.

APPLICANT Court Credit Union REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO23 Deferred APPLIC NO Z/2007/1072/F Full Date Valid 02/05/2007 LOCATION 58-80 (even numbers) Peter's Hill, 77 Brown's Square and 19, 21, 23 and 25 Gardiner Place, Belfast, BT13 PROPOSAL Erection of 51 apartments and 1 retail unit with associated site works and parking APPLICANT Hagan Homes Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 24 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1161/F Full Date Valid 11/05/2007 LOCATION 13 Knockburn Park, Ballycloghan, Belfast, BT05 7AY PROPOSAL Demolition of existing house and erection of 9no apartments APPLICANT Mr B Fraser REPRESENTATIONS 6 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD1 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 7: Quality residential environments in that in that it would if permitted result in overdevelopment of the site and would cause unacceptable damage to the character and residential amenity of the area through inappropriate scale, form, massing, layout and design and would result in dominance and overshadowing and loss of light to 11 Knockburn Park.

Page 16

ITEM NO 25 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1210/DCA Demolition within Date Valid 17/05/2007 LOCATION 67 Malone Avenue, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 6EP PROPOSAL Demolition of existing two storey apartment building APPLICANT Malone Holdings REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy BH14 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 6: Planning, Archaeology and the Built Heritage in that the existing building makes a material contribution to the character and appearance of the Malone Conservation Area and no exceptional reason has been demonstrated to justify its demolition.

ITEM NO 26 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1226/F Full Date Valid 16/05/2007 LOCATION 414A, Whitewell Road, Drumnadrough, Belfast, BT36 7RY PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of 10 apartments over 2.5 storeys

APPLICANT Mr & Mrs D McErlean REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 27 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1237/F Full Date Valid 18/05/2007 LOCATION 225 Crumlin Road, Town Parks, Belfast, BT14 7DY PROPOSAL Change of use of 1 mid terrace dwelling into three 2 bed apartments to include 3 storey rear extension, new wall and front alterations APPLICANT Mr I McNulty REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 17

ITEM NO 28 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1332/F Full Date Valid 30/05/2007 LOCATION 3A Green Road, Ballycloghan, Belfast, BT05 6JA PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwelling and construction of 9no apartments with new entrance access (to replace existing) and associated car parking. APPLICANT Barwood Properties REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 29 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1337/F Full Date Valid 30/05/2007 LOCATION 24 Easton Crescent, Town Parks, Belfast, BT14 6LJ PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwelling and construction of 4 self-contained apartments APPLICANT Lynbourne Developments REPRESENTATIONS 8 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 30 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1340/F Full Date Valid 30/05/2007 LOCATION 45 Carmel Street, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT07 1QE PROPOSAL Erection of first floor extension and new roof dormer to rear of existing HMO including internal alterations APPLICANT c/o Total Architecture & Design Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 18

ITEM NO 31 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1378/F Full Date Valid 04/06/2007 LOCATION 3 Chesham Park, Ballynafoy, Belfast, BT06 8GS PROPOSAL Erection of two storey side extension to dwelling APPLICANT Ms T Alexander REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 32 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1400/F Full Date Valid 07/06/2007 LOCATION 12 Broughton Gardens, Belfast, BT6 0BB PROPOSAL Two storey extension to rear of dwelling and replacement detached garage to rear APPLICANT Mr & Mrs J Owen REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 33 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1418/F Full Date Valid 08/06/2007 LOCATION 2 Knock Eden Park, Ballynafoy, Belfast, BT06 0JF PROPOSAL Two storey side and rear extension to dwelling and detached store to rear APPLICANT Mr & Mrs M Maitland REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 34 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1428/O Outline Date Valid 11/06/2007 LOCATION 64 Silverbirch Court, Belfast, BT13 2JJ PROPOSAL Erection of detached two storey dwelling in garden of existing dwelling APPLICANT Mr W Moffett REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 19

ITEM NO 35 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1483/F Full Date Valid 18/06/2007 LOCATION 7 Castlehill Park West, Belfast, BT4 3GT PROPOSAL Single storey porch to front of dwelling and single storey extension to rear of dwelling (amendment to previous approval Z/2006/2108/F) APPLICANT Mr & Mrs K l Redmond REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 36 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1495/F Full Date Valid 19/06/2007 LOCATION 8 Lewis Gardens, Belfast, BT4 1EP PROPOSAL Roof space conversion to dwelling with dormers to front elevation APPLICANT Mr C McAuley REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 37 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1498/F Full Date Valid 19/06/2007 LOCATION 1 Sharman Way, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 5FU PROPOSAL Erection of single storey extension to rear of dwelling house APPLICANT Mr W Wong REPRESENTATIONS 4 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 20

ITEM NO 38 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1593/F Full Date Valid 27/06/2007 LOCATION 4 Clonallon Park, Belfast, BT4 2BZ PROPOSAL Replacement workshop to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr S Pavis REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal to provide a new building within the curtilage of the dwelling for use as a computer workshop is contrary to Draft Planning Policy Statement 4 - 'Industry, Business and Distribution' in that for home working to be considered ancillary to the residential use it should be carried out totally within the building. As this is a separate building therefore the use is not considered to be ancillary to the dwelling and thus does not comply with Policy EXT1 of Addendum to PPS7 'Residential Extensions and Alterations' in that 'the use of the extension is not for a purpose ancillary to the existing dwelling'

ITEM NO 39 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1660/F Full Date Valid 05/07/2007 LOCATION 102 Kensington Road, Knock, Belfast, BT05 6NH PROPOSAL Proposed single storey and two storey side and rear extension to dwelling APPLICANT Ms D Nickels REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 40 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1681/F Full Date Valid 06/07/2007 LOCATION 21 Norwood Drive, Strandtown, Belfast, BT04 2EA PROPOSAL Proposed two storey side extension and single storey rear extension to dwelling APPLICANT Mr & Mrs P Topping REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 21

ITEM NO 41 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1708/F Full Date Valid 10/07/2007 LOCATION 6 Castleorr Manor, Belfast, BT4 3QJ PROPOSAL Single storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr G Truesdale REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 42 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1711/F Full Date Valid 10/07/2007 LOCATION 20 Lille Park, Belfast, BT10 0LR PROPOSAL Two storey extension to side of dwelling and demolition of existing single storey rear return APPLICANT Mr D McVeigh REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO43 Deferred APPLIC NO Z/2007/1719/F Full Date Valid 11/07/2007 LOCATION 38 Wellington Park, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 6DN PROPOSAL Extension to form new entrance hall and disabled ramp APPLICANT Belfast Islamic Centre REPRESENTATIONS 18 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy BH 12 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 6: Planning, Archaeology and the Built Heritage in that it would, if permitted, harm the character and appearance of the area through its inappropriate scale, form and design.

Page 22

ITEM NO44 Deferred APPLIC NO Z/2007/1761/O Outline Date Valid 19/07/2007 LOCATION 12a Knocklofty Park, Strandtown, Belfast, BT04 3NA PROPOSAL The proposal is for the erection of a detached 2 storey dwelling in the side garden of no. 12 Knocklofty Park APPLICANT Mr E McKay REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD1 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 7: Quality residential environments in that in that it would if permitted result in overdevelopment of the site and would cause unacceptable damage to the residential amenity of the area through inappropriate layout and would result in inadequate amenity space for existing and prospective residents as well as overlooking, dominance and loss of privacy to neighbouring residents.

ITEM NO 45 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1803/F Full Date Valid 20/07/2007 LOCATION 144 Malone Road, Malone Upper, Belfast, BT09 5LH PROPOSAL Demolition of rear outbuildings, single-storey rear extension, widening of entrance gates and alterations to existing dwelling. APPLICANT Mr & Mrs Woods REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 46 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1865/F Full Date Valid 30/07/2007 LOCATION 207 Ravenhill Avenue, Ballynafoy, Belfast, BT06 8LF PROPOSAL Proposed two-storey extension to the rear of dwelling house APPLICANT Yeates Estates REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 23

ITEM NO47 Withdrawn by applicant APPLIC NO Z/2007/1869/F Full Date Valid 30/07/2007 LOCATION 148 Connsbrook Avenue, Strandtown, Belfast, BT04 1JX PROPOSAL Change of use from dwelling to 3 no. self contained apartments with 3 storey extension to rear and associated alterations including the demolition of existing 2 storey return. APPLICANT M.K.R. Developments Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 1 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 This proposal is contrary to the Belfast Urban Area Plan 2001 and Development Guidance Note 4 in that the site lies outside of the designated flat conversion areas and would, if permitted, result in the loss of family size accommodation and set an undesirable precedent for further flat conversions, resulting in a change in the character of the area.

ITEM NO 48 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1903/F Full Date Valid 03/08/2007 LOCATION 13 Sandymount Street, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 5DP PROPOSAL Proposed two-storey extension to rear of existing HMO dwelling APPLICANT Mr B McCourt REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 49 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1904/F Full Date Valid 03/08/2007 LOCATION 11 Newington Avenue, Town Parks, Belfast, BT15 2HP PROPOSAL Change of use from dwelling to 2 No. apartments including metal staircase to rear with front and rear dormer windows. APPLICANT Mr N Segerdahl REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to DGN4: Control of Flat Conversions in that the site is not considered appropriate for subdivision into multiple dwelling units for the following reasons: -to protect existing housing stock still considered suitable for single family accommodation, -additional traffic generation,-adequacy of parking facilities,- increased levels of noise, nuisance and disturbance.

Page 24

ITEM NO 50 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1911/A Advertisement Date Valid 06/08/2007 LOCATION Musgrave Cash and Carry, 1-15 Dargan Crescent, Low-Wood Intake, Belfast, BT03 9JP PROPOSAL Framed impaco aluminium sheet signage APPLICANT Musgrave Wholesale Services REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT

ITEM NO51 Deferred APPLIC NO Z/2007/1945/F Full Date Valid 08/08/2007 LOCATION 733, 733a, 733b and 735 Antrim Road, Greencastle, Belfast, BT15 4EL PROPOSAL Erection of 3 Apartment buildings comprising 55 units with communal gardens, basement car parking for 61 spaces and 16 surface car parking spaces. APPLICANT Broomesdale Investment REPRESENTATIONS 14 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposed development is contrary to Planning Policy Statement PPS7 - Quality Residential Environments Policy QD1 in that: a) the development does not respect the surrounding context and is not appropriate to the character and topography of the site in terms of layout, scale, proportions, massing and appearance of buildings, structures and landscaped and hard surfaced areas. b) adequate provision has not been made for public and private open space and landscaped areas as an integral part of the development. c) the design and layout would create conflict with adjacent land uses and there would be unacceptable adverse effect on existing properties in terms of overlooking, noise or other disturbance.

ITEM NO 52 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2022/F Full Date Valid 16/08/2007 LOCATION 39 Oakland Avenue, Ballyhackamore, Belfast, BT04 3BW PROPOSAL Erection of single storey extension and rear boundary wall (Retrospective) APPLICANT Mr & Mrs P Logan REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 25

ITEM NO 53 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2036/F Full Date Valid 17/08/2007 LOCATION 7 Ardenlee Avenue, Ballynafoy, Belfast, BT06 0AA PROPOSAL Single storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr R Martin REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 54 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2050/F Full Date Valid 20/08/2007 LOCATION 7 Greenwood Park, Ballycloghan, Belfast, BT04 3JN PROPOSAL Single storey rear extension and internal refurbishment APPLICANT Mr D Cooper REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 55 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2066/A Advertisement Date Valid 22/08/2007 LOCATION Co-op Food Store, 191 Lisburn Road, Belfast, BT9 7EJ PROPOSAL 1 no. single sided fascia sign and 1no. double sided projecting sign with illuminated lettering APPLICANT CWS Retail Financial Services REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT

ITEM NO 56 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2071/F Full Date Valid 22/08/2007 LOCATION Great Northern Mall, Great Victoria Street, Belfast, BT2 7AD PROPOSAL Conversion of external area to outdoor terrace for the existing adjacent cafe APPLICANT Glenbank Estates Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 26

ITEM NO 57 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2094/F Full Date Valid 24/08/2007 LOCATION Royal Belfast Academical Institution, College Square East, Belfast, BT1 6DL PROPOSAL Extension to existing fitness room, providing new fitness suite facility within the undercroft of the existing common hall APPLICANT RBAI Board of Governors REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 58 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2102/F Full Date Valid 24/08/2007 LOCATION 12 Sandhurst Gardens, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 5AW PROPOSAL Two storey rear extension to dwelling APPLICANT Mr D Mason REPRESENTATIONS 6 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 59 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2108/F Full Date Valid 28/08/2007 LOCATION 197 Holywood Road, Strandtown, Belfast, BT04 2DG PROPOSAL Proposed residential development consisting of 13 no. dwelling units as mews court with undercroft car parking. APPLICANT Oaklyn Properties REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD1 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 7: Quality Residential Environments and associated guidance, in that it would, if permitted, result in overdevelopment and would cause unacceptable damage to the local character of this area through inappropriate layout, scale, massing and design. The proposal would also harm the living conditions of existing and proposed residents by reason of poor outlook, loss of privacy and dominance. The proposal would fail to provide a quality and sustainable residential living environment.

Page 27

ITEM NO 60 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2117/O Outline Date Valid 29/08/2007 LOCATION Land adjacent to 1 Clara Road, Ballycloghan, Belfast, BT05 6FN PROPOSAL 2 storey detached house APPLICANT W R Holdings REPRESENTATIONS 6 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 61 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2119/F Full Date Valid 30/08/2007 LOCATION 12 Ashmount Park, Ballymisert, Belfast, BT04 2FJ PROPOSAL Single storey detached garage. APPLICANT Mr M Allison REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 62 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2127/F Full Date Valid 31/08/2007 LOCATION 58 Quarry Road, Belfast, BT4 2NQ PROPOSAL Alterations to existing vehicular entrance to dwelling to include new entrance pillars and gates APPLICANT Mr & Mrs P French REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 28

ITEM NO 63 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2134/F Full Date Valid 31/08/2007 LOCATION 19 Lisburn Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 7AA PROPOSAL Change of use from dwelling to office and alterations including demolition of existing garage APPLICANT Praxis Care Group REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 64 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2146/A Advertisement Date Valid 03/09/2007 LOCATION Lands adjacent to Harbour Exchange Retail Park, Airport Road West, Belfast. PROPOSAL Siting and display of advertising banners and flags APPLICANT Ikea Properties Investment Ltd. REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT

ITEM NO 65 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2151/F Full Date Valid 04/09/2007 LOCATION 2 Deramore Gardens, Ballynafoy, Belfast, BT07 3FN PROPOSAL Two storey side and rear extension to dwelling and new domestic garage APPLICANT Ms B McCabe REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy EXT 1 of the Department's Draft Addendum to Planning Policy Statement 7: Residential Extensions and Alterations in that the erection of the proposed extension in advance of the established building line in Ailesbury Drive would, if permitted, harm the character and appearance of the area through its inappropriate scale, form and design resulting in an unduly obtrusive feature in the street scene thereby harming the visual qualities of this area and would set a precedent for further such inappropriate development in the locality. 2 The proposal is contrary to Policy EXT 1 of the Department's Draft Addendum to Planning Policy Statement 7: Residential Extensions and Alterations in that it would, if permitted, harm the living conditions and residential amenity of adjacent neighbours in terms of overshadowing and dominance due to the insubordinate nature of the extension and the inappropriate scale, mass, form, siting and design of the extension.

Page 29

ITEM NO 66 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2153/F Full Date Valid 04/09/2007 LOCATION 92 Ebor Street, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT12 6NP PROPOSAL Erection of 1no 2 storey dwelling APPLICANT Messrs Sam Patterson & Martin McIlhome REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 67 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2156/F Full Date Valid 03/09/2007 LOCATION 66A, Ballygomartin Road, Ballymagarry, Belfast, BT13 3NE PROPOSAL Change of use from existing vacant retail unit to taxi booking depot and new aerial APPLICANT Mr M Pollock REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 68 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2173/F Full Date Valid 06/09/2007 LOCATION 20 Carolhill Gardens, Ballymisert, Belfast, BT04 2FS PROPOSAL Single storey rear extension APPLICANT Ms S Kelly REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 30

ITEM NO 69 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2181/F Full Date Valid 07/09/2007 LOCATION 7 Dunluce Avenue, Belfast, BT9 7AW PROPOSAL Replacement of existing dormer with new larger dormer to front of property APPLICANT Mr J Stephens REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD1 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 7: Residential Extensions and Alterations in that it would, if permitted, harm the character and appearance of the area through its inappropriate scale, form and design and would set a precedent for further such inappropriate development in the locality.

ITEM NO 70 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2189/F Full Date Valid 07/09/2007 LOCATION 54/64 Eglantine Avenue, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 6DY PROPOSAL Conversion of second floor rear roofspace to office accommodation and 4No. velux windows to south east roof slope. APPLICANT Mr B Macklin REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO71 Deferred APPLIC NO Z/2007/2212/F Full Date Valid 11/09/2007 LOCATION 21 Eglantine Avenue, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 6DW PROPOSAL Conversion from 10 bedroom guest house to 1 no. 2 bed flat and 4 no. 1 bed flats including alteration/extension and replacement store. APPLICANT Mr J Devlin REPRESENTATIONS 28 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is unacceptable in that it would, if permitted, harm the living conditions and residential amenity of adjacent neighbours in terms of overshadowing and dominance due to the insubordinate nature of the extension and the inappropriate scale, mass, form, siting and design of the extension. 2 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD 1 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 7: Quality Residential Environments and Policy BH12 of Planning Policy Statement 6: Planning, Archaeology and the Built Heritage in that the proposal would, if permitted, result in overdevelopment of the site and would cause harm to the local character and environmental quality of the Malone Conservation Area in terms of scale, layout, massing, design and inadequate provision of private amenity space for prospective occupants.

Page 31

ITEM NO 72 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2226/F Full Date Valid 12/09/2007 LOCATION 17 Hillside Park, Belfast, BT9 5EL PROPOSAL Single storey extension to rear and side of dwelling including demolition of existing detached garage APPLICANT Mr D McGale REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 73 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2227/F Full Date Valid 12/09/2007 LOCATION 7 Motelands, Belfast, BT4 2JH PROPOSAL Roofspace conversion with 5 no. velux windows in rear elevation to include raising the roof ridge level by 1 metre APPLICANT Mr J Tipping REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 74 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2232/F Full Date Valid 12/09/2007 LOCATION 64 King's Road, Ballycloghan, Belfast, BT05 6JL PROPOSAL Demolition of existing garage and yard wall and erection of two storey side extension with garage, lean-to canopy, new fencing, gates and external paving.

APPLICANT Aston REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 32

ITEM NO 75 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2238/F Full Date Valid 13/09/2007 LOCATION 127 Upper Newtownards Rd, Ballyhackamore, Belfast, BT04 3HW PROPOSAL Two storey rear extension and roof space conversion to dwelling. APPLICANT Mr J Campbell REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 76 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2239/F Full Date Valid 12/09/2007 LOCATION 30 Malone Heights, Malone Upper, Belfast, BT09 5PG PROPOSAL Roofspace conversion to include rear dormer window APPLICANT Mr & Mrs Houston REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 77 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2248/DCA Demolition within Date Valid 13/09/2007 LOCATION 64 King's Road, Ballycloghan, Belfast, BT05 6JL PROPOSAL Demolition of existing yard wall and garage APPLICANT Mr & Mrs Aston REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT

ITEM NO 78 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2253/A Advertisement Date Valid 10/09/2007 LOCATION CO-OP Food Store, 59-61, Cregagh Road, Ballymaconaghy, Belfast, BT06 8PY PROPOSAL 1x single sided fascia sign. APPLICANT CWS Retail Financial Services REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT

Page 33

ITEM NO 79 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2259/F Full Date Valid 13/09/2007 LOCATION 6 Shrewsbury Park, Malone Upper, Belfast, BT09 6PN PROPOSAL Single storey extension to side and rear, and two storey rear extension to dwelling APPLICANT Mr & Mrs S Leonard REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 80 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2280/F Full Date Valid 17/09/2007 LOCATION Land adjacent to 1 Devon Drive, Strandtown, Belfast, BT04 1LF PROPOSAL Erection of two storey dwelling APPLICANT Lisleen Properties Llp REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 81 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2292/F Full Date Valid 19/09/2007 LOCATION 5 Vidor Court, Strandtown, Belfast, BT04 1QP PROPOSAL Single storey rear extension to dwelling APPLICANT Mr N McBride REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 34

ITEM NO 82 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2294/F Full Date Valid 19/09/2007 LOCATION 25 Camden Street, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 6AT PROPOSAL Demolition of existing building (front facade retained) and construction of 6no. apartments with 3 storey rear return APPLICANT Croob Properties Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD1 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 7: Quality Residential Environments and associated guidance in that it would, if permitted, result in a poor living environment for prospective residents through a poor outlook due to the siting and design of the development. The proposal would therefore fail to provide a quality and sustainable residential environment. 2 The proposal is contrary to Planning Policy Statement 3, Development Control: Roads Considerations in that it would, if permitted, result in inadequate parking arrangements thereby prejudicing the free flow of traffic and conditions of general safety.

ITEM NO 83 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2301/O Outline Date Valid 19/09/2007 LOCATION 4 Arizona Street, Ballymurphy, Belfast, BT11 8AG PROPOSAL Erection of 3 storey dwelling APPLICANT Kieran Macoscar & Caroline Donaghy REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 84 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2311/A Advertisement Date Valid 17/09/2007 LOCATION 10-12 Kings Road, Belfast, BT5 6JF PROPOSAL Pole mounted signage within curtilage to front of property APPLICANT Abbeyfield Belfast Society REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy BH 13 of PPS 6 'Planning Archaeology and the Built Heritage' and would if permitted be an unduly prominent and intrusive feature in this street scene and harm the visual character of this predominantly residential area within the King's Road Conservation Area.

Page 35

ITEM NO 85 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2316/F Full Date Valid 20/09/2007 LOCATION 4 Gibson Park Avenue and 44 Gibson Park Gardens, Ballymaconaghy, Belfast, BT06 9GL PROPOSAL Erection of single storey garage extension - between 4 Gibson Park Avenue, 44 Gibson Park Gardens, and the creation of a new driveway for No. 44. APPLICANT Mr G Ardill REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 86 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2320/F Full Date Valid 20/09/2007 LOCATION 146 Glen Road, Ballydownfine, Belfast, BT11 8BN PROPOSAL Erection of 2no. portacabins in rear garden. APPLICANT Ms M McDonagh REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 87 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2337/F Full Date Valid 21/09/2007 LOCATION 5-9 Channing Street, Ballymacarret, Belfast, BT05 5GP PROPOSAL Demolition of existing commercial premises and erection of six apartments along with associated site works. APPLICANT Woodvale Services REPRESENTATIONS 12 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposed development is contrary to Policy PCP1 of Planning Policy Statement 12 (Housing in Settlements) as the scheme fails to take account of local character, environmental quality and amenity, as the form, scale and mass of the proposed development does not respect that of adjacent housing, and will result in a detrimental impact on of existing residents. 2 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD1 of Planning Policy Statement 7, Quality Residential Environments, the Department's Design Guide "Creating Places" and Development Control Advise Note 8 Housing in Existing Urban Areas in that the development as proposed fails to provide a quality residential environment.

Page 36

ITEM NO 88 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2339/F Full Date Valid 21/09/2007 LOCATION St Dominic’s High School, 135-137 Falls Road, Town Parks, Belfast, BT12 6AE PROPOSAL Erection of temporary 1.2 metre security fence on top of existing wall and replacement of existing double gate with 2.4 metre fencing. APPLICANT The Trustees of St Dominic's High School REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 89 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2387/F Full Date Valid 01/10/2007 LOCATION 2 Halstein Drive, Belfast, BT5 6JQ and 43 Sandown Road, Belfast, BT5 6GT PROPOSAL Erection of two storey rear extension at 2 Halstein Drive and extension to existing two storey rear extension at 43 Sandown Road APPLICANT Northern Ireland Housing Executive REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 90 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2389/F Full Date Valid 01/10/2007 LOCATION 39 Stormont Park, Ballycloghan, Belfast, BT04 3GW PROPOSAL Two storey extension to side and single storey extension to rear of existing dwelling house APPLICANT Messrs B & R Andrews REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 37

ITEM NO 91 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2405/F Full Date Valid 01/10/2007 LOCATION Lands adjacent to 20-22 Prince Regent Road, Belfast, BT5 6QR PROPOSAL Change of use of land from wasteland to parking for lands adjacent to 20-22 Prince Regent Road, Belfast APPLICANT Belfast Education and Library Board REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 92 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2458/LB Listed Building Date Valid 09/10/2007 LOCATION W Block, Royal Belfast Academical Institution, College Square East, Belfast, BT1 6DL PROPOSAL Demolition of existing single storey extension to W block. New single storey extension in similar location to provide new classroom. Internal alterations to W block to provide additional classrooms. APPLICANT Royal Belfast Academical Institution REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT

ITEM NO93 Deferred APPLIC NO Z/2007/2460/F Full Date Valid 09/10/2007 LOCATION 1-5 Belmont Road, Strandtown, Belfast, BT04 2AA PROPOSAL Mixed use redevelopment consisting of ground floor retail and residential above with undercroft car parking and associated works and access. APPLICANT Jerlag Properties REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal would, if permitted, result in overdevelopment of the site and would cause unacceptable damage to the character and appearance of the area through inappropriate scale, form and massing; and would harm the living conditions of residents in Dundela Street through visual dominance.

Page 38

ITEM NO 94 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2464/F Full Date Valid 10/10/2007 LOCATION 12 River Terrace, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT07 2EN PROPOSAL Erection of 1 no. 2 storey dwelling in the side garden APPLICANT Mr T McReynolds REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 95 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2475/A Advertisement Date Valid 11/10/2007 LOCATION 354 Lisburn Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 6GJ PROPOSAL Free standing advertising signage with corporate logo APPLICANT Mr M Sutton REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT

ITEM NO96 Deferred APPLIC NO Z/2007/2479/F Full Date Valid 11/10/2007 LOCATION 697 Lisburn Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 7GU PROPOSAL Change of use to a hot food bar/sandwich bar/cafe with sit in facilities APPLICANT Mrs B Hanif REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposed change of use of these premises to a hot food bar / sandwich bar / cafe would, if permitted, harm the living conditions of the nearby residents by reason of noise nuisance inconvenience and general disturbance. 2 The proposal is contrary to Policy DGN 1E Control of Hot Food Bars in Cranmore Area of Lisburn Road Belfast in that the use of these premises for a hot food bar/sandwich bar/ cafe for the reason that proliferation of these uses will have an adverse effect on the character and residential amenity of the area.

Page 39

ITEM NO 97 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2481/F Full Date Valid 12/10/2007 LOCATION 5 Greenview Park, Malone Upper, Belfast, BT09 6TZ PROPOSAL Single storey side extension and alterations to dwelling APPLICANT Mr D Diamond REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 98 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2493/F Full Date Valid 12/10/2007 LOCATION 41 Hillhead Crescent, Ballymoney, Belfast, BT11 9FS PROPOSAL Roof alteration to side and dormer window to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr & Mrs O'Reilly REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 99 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2548/F Full Date Valid 17/10/2007 LOCATION 28 Bedford Street, Town Parks, Belfast, BT02 7FE PROPOSAL Proposed internal alterations to building, including work to open an existing entrance to Franklin Street and fitting photovoltaic panels to roof valley. APPLICANT Bryson Charitable Group REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 100 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2561/F Full Date Valid 18/10/2007 LOCATION 65 Diamond Gardens, Ballyfinaghy, Belfast, BT10 0HE PROPOSAL Retention of two and a half storey extension to rear of dwelling erected in non- compliance with planning approval reference - Z/2003/1428/F APPLICANT Mr C Press REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 40

ITEM NO 101 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2562/LB Listed Building Date Valid 19/10/2007 LOCATION Bryson House, 28 Bedford Street, Town Parks, Belfast, BT02 7FE PROPOSAL Proposed internal alterations to building including opening an existing entrance to Franklin Street and fitting photovoltaic panels to roof valley. APPLICANT Bryson Charitable Group REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT

ITEM NO 102 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2572/F Full Date Valid 22/10/2007 LOCATION 20 Harberton Drive, Malone Upper, Belfast, BT09 6PF PROPOSAL Two-storey rear extension and roof space conversion to dwelling and erection of single-storey building along the northern boundary. APPLICANT Eillis McDermot REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 103 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2575/F Full Date Valid 22/10/2007 LOCATION 11 University Street, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT07 1FY PROPOSAL Change of use from office accommodation to dental surgery APPLICANT Green & Montgomery REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 41

ITEM NO104 Withdrawn by Applicant APPLIC NO Z/2007/2581/F Full Date Valid 23/10/2007 LOCATION 43 Glen Road, Belfast. PROPOSAL Demolition of existing detached dwelling and construction of 18no 2-bed apartments in 2no blocks. APPLICANT Bailey Management Llp REPRESENTATIONS 13 Objections 0 Support 1 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD1 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 7: Quality Residential Environments and associated guidance, in that it would, if permitted, result in unacceptable damage to the local character, residential amenity and environmental quality of this established residential area by reason of over development resulting in: - A development that fails to respect the surrounding context and the characteristics of the site in terms of layout, scale, form and design. - Inadequate provision of private amenity space for prospective residents. - Unacceptable adverse impacts on existing properties due to overlooking and loss of privacy, which would fail to create a quality and sustainable residential environment.

ITEM NO 105 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2600/F Full Date Valid 24/10/2007 LOCATION 159 Dunluce Avenue, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 7AX PROPOSAL Two-storey rear extension and alterations to dwelling APPLICANT Mr M King REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 106 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2620/F Full Date Valid 25/10/2007 LOCATION 1 Ravenhill Park Gardens, Ballynafoy, Belfast, BT06 0DH PROPOSAL Amendment to previous approval Z/2007/1728/F "Demolition of existing garage and construction of proposed two storey and single storey extension to the rear and side of dwelling" to include window alterations. APPLICANT Mr R Christie REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 42

ITEM NO107 Withdrawn by Applicant APPLIC NO Z/2007/2637/F Full Date Valid 29/10/2007 LOCATION Site adjacent to No. 2 Harland Park, Ballyhackamore, Belfast, BT04 1HZ PROPOSAL Two-storey detached dwelling APPLICANT Mr M Colton REPRESENTATIONS 3 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD 1 of Planning Policy Statement 7 "Quality Residential Environments" in that it would, if permitted, result in overdevelopment of the site, which is too restricted to permit the erection of a dwelling of reasonable design and dimensions and with adequate amenity space.

2 The Department considers that insufficient information has been provided to demonstrate an acceptable arrangement for accommodating the parking of vehicles for the new and existing dwellings.

ITEM NO 108 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2638/F Full Date Valid 29/10/2007 LOCATION Seaview Primary School, Seaview Drive, Belfast, BT15 3NB PROPOSAL Erection of two-storey extension which will provide for a new lift within central courtyard of school. APPLICANT BELB REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 109 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2639/LB Listed Building Date Valid 29/10/2007 LOCATION Seaview Primary School, Seaview Drive, Belfast, BT15 3NB PROPOSAL Erection of two-storey extension which will provide for a new lift within central courtyard of school. APPLICANT BELB REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT

Page 43

ITEM NO 110 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2646/F Full Date Valid 30/10/2007 LOCATION 59 Ainsworth Avenue, Edenderry, Belfast, BT13 3EN PROPOSAL Two-storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Elite Homes & Construction REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO111 Deferred APPLIC NO Z/2007/2647/F Full Date Valid 30/10/2007 LOCATION 113 Bloomfield Avenue, Ballyhackamore, Belfast, BT05 5AB PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of 3 no 1 bed apartments with car parking on street APPLICANT Mr S McCann REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD1 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 7: Quality Residential Environments and associated guidance, in that it would, if permitted, result in unacceptable damage to the local character of this area through inappropriate layout, scale, massing and form.

ITEM NO 112 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2649/F Full Date Valid 31/10/2007 LOCATION 6 Rosepark South, Ballymiscaw, Belfast, BT05 7RJ PROPOSAL Single-storey porch to front of dwelling APPLICANT Mr & Mrs C McKay REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 44

ITEM NO 113 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2656/F Full Date Valid 31/10/2007 LOCATION 51 Castlehill Road, Ballycloghan, Belfast, BT04 3GP PROPOSAL New entrance porch, single-storey rear extension, garage extension and alterations to dwelling. APPLICANT Mr & Mrs S Torrans REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO114 Withdrawn by Applicant APPLIC NO Z/2007/2659/F Full Date Valid 31/10/2007 LOCATION 220 Springfield Road, Edenderry, Belfast, BT12 7DR PROPOSAL Change of use from vacant office/stores to 7no apartments with a 3-storey extension to the rear of the property. APPLICANT RGM Developments Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to PPS7 and DGN4 for the following reasons: - the scheme constitutes overdevelopment of the site as it proposes an excessive number of residential units- the proposed extension is not considered subordinate to the existing building- the scheme, because it does not provide in-curtilage parking raises issues of parking amenity for the immediate area- bin storage is both inadequate and inaccessible for prospective residents.

ITEM NO 115 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2669/F Full Date Valid 01/11/2007 LOCATION 3 Distillery Street, Town Parks, Belfast, BT12 5BJ PROPOSAL Single-storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mrs E Owens REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 45

ITEM NO 116 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2683/F Full Date Valid 02/11/2007 LOCATION 103 Willowvale Avenue, Ballymoney, Belfast, BT11 9JY PROPOSAL Single storey extension to rear of dwelling with new windows to gable APPLICANT Mr F Murray REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 117 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2684/F Full Date Valid 02/11/2007 LOCATION 342 Antrim Road, Skegoneill, Belfast, BT15 5AB PROPOSAL Conversion of 3no existing apartments to 8no apartments by demolition of existing 2-storey return and construction of a new 3.5-storey extension to the rear including elevational changes. APPLICANT Mr C&E Cassidy REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to PPS7 and DGN4 for the following reasons: - the scheme constitutes overdevelopment of the site as it proposes an excessive number of residential units- the proposed extension is not considered subordinate to the existing building- the scheme, because it does not provide in-curtilage parking raises issues of parking amenity for the immediate area

ITEM NO 118 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2691/F Full Date Valid 02/11/2007 LOCATION 9 Seamount Parade, Skegoneill, Belfast, BT15 3NS PROPOSAL Two-storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Ms J England REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 46

ITEM NO 119 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2693/F Full Date Valid 05/11/2007 LOCATION 59 Orangefield Crescent, Multyhogy, Belfast, BT06 9GJ PROPOSAL Erection of dwelling in side garden APPLICANT Mr & Mrs A Long REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD 1 of Planning Policy Statement 7 "Quality Residential Environments" in that it would, if permitted, result in overdevelopment of the site, which is too restricted to permit the erection of a dwelling of reasonable design and dimensions and with adequate amenity space. The proposal would result in development forward of the building line, which is out of character with the surrounding townscape, in terms of built form and urban grain, which would cause unacceptable damage to local character. The proposal would result in unacceptable damage to the living conditions of adjacent residents by reason of dominance, overshadowing and loss of light.

2 The applicant has not demonstrated how vehicles which will be attracted to the new house will be safely accommodated. 3 The applicant has not demonstrated how vehicles which will be attracted to the existing house will be safely accommodated. 4 The proposed access does not provide a safe arrangement onto the public road as the access is located too close to Orangefield Crescent. The access is not compliant with the Department guidance "Creating Places para. 16.25".

ITEM NO 120 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2694/A Advertisement Date Valid 05/11/2007 LOCATION Junction of Lombard Street and High Street, Belfast PROPOSAL One wall mounted 48 sheet, up-right light box APPLICANT Clear Channel NI Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy BH13 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 6: Planning, Archaeology and the Built Heritage in that the site lies within the Belfast City Centre Conservation Area and the advertisement sign would, if permitted, adversely affect its appearance and detract from the architectural character of the building upon which it is to be displayed by reason of its inappropriate location which is unduly prominent and its inappropriate size.

Page 47

ITEM NO 121 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2695/F Full Date Valid 05/11/2007 LOCATION 7-9 Brae Hill Park, Ballysillan, Belfast, BT14 8FP PROPOSAL Demolition of existing structures and construction of 14no. apartments. APPLICANT Messrs G&K Speers & Bennett REPRESENTATIONS 3 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD1 of PPS7 in that the proposed development does not provide a quality, sustainable living environment for the following reasons: - design out of keeping with immediate area- no useable on-site amenity space- no provision for on-site parking- proposal constitutes overdevelopment of the site

ITEM NO 122 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2707/F Full Date Valid 06/11/2007 LOCATION 832 Crumlin Road, Ballysillan Lower, Belfast, BT14 8AE PROPOSAL Demolition of existing church and erection of new 2-storey church APPLICANT Elim Pentecostal Church REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 48

ITEM NO 123 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2709/F Full Date Valid 07/11/2007 LOCATION Site at 129-131 Finaghy Road South, Belfast, BT10 0BZ PROPOSAL Demolition of existing 2 no dwellings and construction of a 2 1/2 storey apartment development, consisting of 9 no apartments. APPLICANT JMC Contracts Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 8 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD1 of Planning Policy Statement 7, Quality Residential Environments, the Department's Design Guide "Creating Places" and Development Control Advise Note 8 Housing in Existing Urban Areas in that the development as proposed fails to provide a quality residential environment. 2 The proposed development is contrary to Policy PCP1 of Planning Policy Statement 12 (Housing in Settlements) as the scheme fails to take account of local character, environmental quality and amenity, as the form, scale and mass of the proposed development does not respect that of adjacent housing, and will result in a detrimental impact on of existing residents. 3 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD1 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 7: Quality residential environments in that in that it would if permitted result in overdevelopment of the site and would cause unacceptable damage to the character and residential amenity of the area through inappropriate scale, form, massing, layout and design and would result in overlooking, overshadowing and loss of privacy to neighbouring residents.

ITEM NO 124 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2717/F Full Date Valid 07/11/2007 LOCATION 6 Ormonde Avenue, Ballyfinaghy, Belfast, BT10 0LQ PROPOSAL Single-storey rear extension to dwelling for disabled access APPLICANT Mrs R Rush REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 49

ITEM NO 125 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2719/A Advertisement Date Valid 07/11/2007 LOCATION Human Rights Commission NI, Temple Court 39 North Street, Belfast, BT1 1NA

PROPOSAL Erection of banner sign to rear elevation. APPLICANT Human Rights Commission NI REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposed sign is contrary to PPS17 Control of outdoor advertisements. The proposed signage would be, if permitted, an unduly prominent feature in the street scene detracting from the appearance of the conservation area and would be detrimental to visual amenity by virtue of its size, appearance and form.

ITEM NO 126 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2721/F Full Date Valid 07/11/2007 LOCATION 4 Orkney Street, Town Parks, Belfast, BT13 3GR PROPOSAL Erection of 2 storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Elite Homes & Construction REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 127 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2724/F Full Date Valid 08/11/2007 LOCATION Sites 1-48, 50, 52, 54, 56 Glenbryn Drive and 1-56 Glenbryn Park BT14 PROPOSAL Change of house types to sites 37 to 47 (inclusive) to form 8no semi- detached and a terrace of 3no dwellings. APPLICANT Quayside Construction Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 50

ITEM NO 128 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2731/F Full Date Valid 08/11/2007 LOCATION 48 Elaine Street, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 5AR PROPOSAL Single storey side extension & alterations to ground floor flat APPLICANT PPD REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 129 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2739/F Full Date Valid 09/11/2007 LOCATION 30 Adelaide Park, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 6FY PROPOSAL Lift Installation and alterations to building and new front boundary treatment APPLICANT Belfast & Lisburn Women's Aid REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 130 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2754/A Advertisement Date Valid 13/11/2007 LOCATION 12 Torrens Avenue, Belfast, BT14 6HZ PROPOSAL Printed Banner APPLICANT PSNI ESBU REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 131 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2760/A Advertisement Date Valid 13/11/2007 LOCATION 280 Antrim Road, Skegoneill, Belfast, BT15 5AA PROPOSAL Printed Banner APPLICANT PSNI ESBU REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT

Page 51

ITEM NO 132 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2765/F Full Date Valid 14/11/2007 LOCATION 9 Parkmount Road, Low-Wood, Belfast, BT15 4EQ PROPOSAL Erection of single-storey extension and dormer window to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr C O' Kane REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 133 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2766/F Full Date Valid 14/11/2007 LOCATION 21 Springvale Park, Ballysillan Lower, Belfast, BT14 8DD PROPOSAL Two-storey and single-storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr McMullan REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 134 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2796/A Advertisement Date Valid 19/11/2007 LOCATION Unit 9A, Boucher Retail Park, Belfast BT12 PROPOSAL Erection of 3no signs - front fascia sign, projecting sign and high-level sign. APPLICANT Birthdays REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT

ITEM NO 135 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2843/A Advertisement Date Valid 26/11/2007 LOCATION 309 Cavehill Road, Ballyaghagan, Belfast, BT15 5EY PROPOSAL Two fascia signs APPLICANT BTW Shiells REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT

Page 52

ITEM NO 136 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2844/F Full Date Valid 26/11/2007 LOCATION 27 Suffolk Crescent, Belfast, BT11 9JT PROPOSAL Erection of single storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr Rice REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 137 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2845/F Full Date Valid 26/11/2007 LOCATION 21A Coolnasilla Park, Belfast, BT11 8PT PROPOSAL Erection of two storey extension to side of dwelling APPLICANT Mr & Mrs Rushe REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 138 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2848/F Full Date Valid 26/11/2007 LOCATION 11 York Drive, Belfast, BT15 3QY PROPOSAL Erection of single storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mrs A Gilliland REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 139 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2856/F Full Date Valid 27/11/2007 LOCATION 8 Gransha Park, Belfast, BT11 8AU PROPOSAL Erection of single storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Ms Sloan REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 53

ADDENDUM ITEM NO1

APPLIC NO Z/2007/2185/F Full Date Valid 07/09/2007 LOCATION 31 Riga Street, adjoining workshop and storage yard on corner of Riga Street and Snugville Street, Towns Park BT13 1NZ PROPOSAL Erection of 2.5-storey apartment block to include 14no apartments and associated works APPLICANT Mr & Mrs D & V Smyth REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objection 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Weekly List Of Planning Applications Registered

For the 25/12/07 to: 31/12/07 For: Belfast Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2007/3050/F 20 North Parade, Erection of single storey extension Full Building Mr & Mrs Gibson 18 Mr Duffy , 186 Lisburn Ballynafoy, Belfast, to rear of property Extension/Alterat Wellington Park, Belfast, Road, Belfast, BT9 6AL Northern Ireland, BT07 2GG ion BT9 6DJ Z/2007/3000/F 4 St Judes Crescent, Two and a half storey and single Full Building Kearney 4 St. Judes Belfast, BT6 storey rear extensions including Extension/Alterat Crescent, Belfast, BT7 2GW conversion of existing garage, roof ion space conversion and alterations. Z/2007/3001/F 34 Deramore Gardens, Erection of granny flat extension to Full Building Mrs A Byrne 34 Deramore Ballynafoy, Belfast, rear of dwelling. Extension/Alterat Gardens, Belfast, BT7 3FN Northern Ireland, BT07 ion Page 54 Z/2007/3002/F 20 Castlehill Park, Erection of single-storey extension Full Building Mr P Magee C/o John Mr J O'Connor , 17 Ballycloghan, Belfast, to side and rear of existing dwelling Extension/Alterat O'Connor, 17 Knocklofty Knocklofty Park, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT04 ion Park, Belfast, BT4 3NA BT4 3NA Z/2007/3003/F 2 Brackenwood Lane, Erection of extension to existing Full Building Mr & Mrs P Walsh 2 McVeigh Brown Upper Malone Road, swimming pool and sauna Extension/Alterat Brackenwood Lane, Architectural Partnership, Belfast, BT9 ion Upper Malone Road, 20 Mount Charles, Belfast, BT9 Botanic Avenue, Belfast, BT7 1NZ Z/2007/3008/F 184 Upper Newtownards Conversion and extension of Full Change of Use Mkr Developments Ltd John Palmer Riba , The Road, Ballyhackamore, existing dwellinghouse into three C/o John M Palmer RIBA, Mount, 2 Woodstock Link, Belfast, Northern Ireland, The Mount, 2 Woodstock Belfast, BT6 8DD Agenda Item5 BT04 3ES Link, Belfast, BT6 8DD Z/2007/3017/F 155-177 Lisburn Road, 16 Mixed use development of 59 no. Full Erection of Largie Developments C/o Mclornan RPP Architects Ashley Avenue, 3-7 Tates private apartments with on site Building(s) RPP Architects LTD, Ltd, Clarence Gallery, Avenue, Belfast, BT9 parking and 3no. retail units to Clarence Gallery, Linenhall Street, Belfast, ground floor Linenhall Street, Belfast, BT2 8BG BT2 8BG

15 January 2008 Page 1 of 2 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2007/3021/F 60 Myrtlefield Park, Demolition of vacant dwelling, Full Erection of Edenbrook Developments Des Ewing- Chartered Malone Lower, Belfast, erection of a pair of semi detached Building(s) C/o Agent Des Ewing, Architect, The Studio, 13 Northern Ireland, BT09 dwellings The Studio, 13 Bangor Bangor Road, Holywood, Road, Holywood, Co Co Down, BT18 ONU Down, BT18 ONU Z/2007/3022/DC 60 Myrtlefield Park, Demolition of existing vacant Demolition Demolition Edenbrook Developments Des Ewing- Chartered Malone Lower, Belfast, dwelling, erection of a pair of semi within Cons Area C/o Agent Des Ewing, Architect, The Studio, 13 Northern Ireland, BT09 detached dwellings The Studio, 13 Bangor Bangor Road, Holywood, Road, Holywood, BT18 Co Down, BT18 ONU ONU Z/2007/3031/F 25 Palmerston Road, Demolition of existing dwelling and Full Erection of Urban Space Mr M Colwell , 80 Strandtown, Belfast, erection of eight apartments Building(s) Developments C/O Edenderry Village, Northern Ireland, BT04 Agents Michael Colwell, Shaw's Bridge, Belfast, 80 Edenderry Village, Belfast, BT8 8LQ Page 55 Z/2007/3032/F 86 Fitzroy Avenue, Malone Conversion from three apartments to Full Change of Use M & M King C/o 12 Mr M King , 12 Cleaver Lower, Belfast, Northern four apartments including the Cleaver Gardens, Belfast, Gardens, Belfast, BT9 Ireland, BT07 1HX addition of an extra storey to the BT9 5HZ existing rear return Z/2007/3044/F 7 Castlekaria Manor, Two storey and single storey Full Building Mr & Mrs Gray 7 Consarc Design Group, Belfast, BT4 3QL extension to rear of dwelling Extension/Alterat Castlekaria Manor, The Gas Office, 4 Cromac ion Belfast, BT4 3QL Quay, Ormeau Road, Belfast, BT7 2JD TOTAL:- 12

15 January 2008 Page 2 of 2 Weekly List Of Planning Applications Registered

For the 01/01/08 to: 07/01/08 For: Belfast Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2007/1508/F Lands west of Residential housing development Full Erection of Hagan Homes Ltd 181 Footprint Architectural Mountainview Parade, comprising 222 private and 35 Building(s) Templepatrick Road, Design, 181 Ingledale Park & to the social housing units, accessed off Ballyclare, BT39 0RA Templepatrick Road, rear of Glencairn Crescent, new road constructed under Ballyclare, BT39 0RA adjacent to Forth River approval Z/2001/0990/RM. Primary School & accessed adjacent to 113 Ballygomartin Road. Z/2007/3012/LD 6 Slemish Way, Single-storey extension to rear of LD Certificate Building Mr J O'Neill 6 Slemish Robert Bryson, 18 Ballydownfine, Belfast, dwelling. Proposed Extension/Alterat Way, Belfast, BT11 8GW Gransha Park, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT11 8GW ion BT11 8AU Page 56

Z/2007/3015/F East of 55 Garnerville Erection of 6 two-storey duplex Full Erection of Mr A Martin 6 Mr Hutcheson Hutcheson Road, Ballymaghan, dwellings Building(s) Craigdarragh Road, Irvine Partnership, Studio Belfast, Northern Ireland, Helen's Bay, BT19 1UA 48 Grays Hill, Bangor, BT04 2QQ BT20 3BB Z/2007/3038/LB 41-51, Royal Avenue, Refurbishment & extension to Listed Building Building Deramore Holdings Ltd Todd Architects, 41-43 Town Parks, Belfast, existing premises to provide Consent Extension/Alterat C/O Todd Architects, 41- Hill Street, Belfast, BT1 Northern Ireland, BT01 additional retail & office space & ion 43 Hill Street, Belfast, 2PB change of use from storage to office. BT1 2PB Z/2007/3059/LD 72 Balholm Drive, Single-storey extension to rear of LD Certificate Building Ms R Wilkinson 72 Mr P Jenkins , 40 Mount Edenderry, Belfast, dwelling. Proposed Extension/Alterat Balholm Drive, Belfast Merrion Park, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT14 ion BT6 0GB Z/2007/3062/F 7-11 Linenhall Street, Change of use from newsagents to Full Change of Use Mr J Mccoubrey 31 Mrs C Murray Soon Belfast coffee shop. Linenhall Street, Belfast, Interiors, 9-13 Waring BT2 8AB Street, Cathedral Quarter, Belfast, BT1 2DW

15 January 2008 Page 1 of 5 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2007/2999/F Sites 3 and 4 Citylink Residential development Full Erection of Dellway Investments Ltd FW Consulting, Unit 2 Business Park, Albert comprising a total of 200no units Building(s) Garvagh House, Bellsbridge Office Park, Street, Belfast, BT12 within 2 apartment blocks; Stanley Donaghmore, BT70 3LS 100 Ladas Drive, Belfast, Tower on 15 levels and plant over 2 BT6 9FH levels of basement parking; Albert Tower on 12 levels and plant over 2 levels of basement parking. Z/2007/3005/F 24 Knockbreda Road, Conversion of existing house and Full Change of Use Mr J Mezza 24 Kevin Fennell Design, 2A Ballynafoy, Belfast, rear dwelling to 3no self contained Knockbreda Road, Dorchester Park, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT06 apartments including first floor rear Belfast, BT6 BT9 6RH extension and roofspace conversion with rear dormers. Z/2007/3011/F Northlink Playing Fields, Replacement of existing bowtop Full Engineering Mr A Hassard Parks And Mr G Wright , Facilities Andersonstown Road, fencing and entrance gates with Operation Leisure Services, Belfast Management Section, Belfast new 2.4m high mesh panel fencing City Counil, 4-10 Duncrue Complex, and gates. Linenhall Street, Belfast, Duncrue Road, Belfast, Page 57 BT2 8BP BT3 9BP Z/2007/3019/F 7 Houston Drive, Erection of two storey & single storey Full Building Mr R Adamson 7 Houston Multyhogy, Belfast, rear extensions & replacement Extension/Alterat Drive, Multyhogy, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT05 garage. ion BT5 6AZ Z/2007/3023/F 31 Thornhill Park, Roofspace conversion including Full Building Mr T Mehaffey 31 Andy McDowell Design, Ballycloghan, Belfast, change of roof from hipped to Extension/Alterat Thornhill Park, Belfast, 26 Bellevue, Bangor, Co Northern Ireland, BT05 ion BT5 7AR Down, BT20 5QW Z/2007/3026/F 29 Thornhill Park, Roofspace conversion including Full Building Mr & Mrs Baxter 29 Andy McDowell Design, Ballycloghan, Belfast, change of roof from hipped to Extension/Alterat Thornhill Park, Belfast, 26 Bellevue, Bangor, Co Northern Ireland, BT05 ion BT5 7AR Down, BT20 5QW Z/2007/3047/F 3 Knockhill Park, Erection of replacment garage Full Building Mr J Carson 3 Knockhill Ballycloghan, Belfast, Extension/Alterat Park, Belfast, BT5 6HX Northern Ireland, BT05 ion Z/2007/3049/F 143 Alexandra Park Change of use from dwelling to 3 Full Change of Use Mr P Coyle 29 Chatsworth S W Marcus MCIAT, 48 Avenue, Belfast, BT15 no. apartments including 3 storey Street, Belfast, BT5 4QL Sand Road, Galgorm, extension to rear. Ballymena, BT42 1DL

15 January 2008 Page 2 of 5 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2007/3051/LD 18 Downfine Gardens, Single-storey extension to rear of LD Certificate Building Ms A Nolan 18 Downfine Mr P Jenkins , 40 Mount Ballymurphy, Belfast, dwelling. Proposed Extension/Alterat Gardens, Belfast Merrion Park, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT11 ion BT6 0GB Z/2007/3054/LD 27 Trench Park, Single-storey extension to rear of LD Certificate Building Ms S King 27 Trench Mr P Jenkins , 40 Mount Ballymoney, Belfast, dwelling. Proposed Extension/Alterat Park, Belfast Merrion Park, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT11 ion BT6 0GB Z/2007/3056/F 158 Finaghy Road South, New retaining wall, fence and Full Building Mr J Armstrong 158 D Morris Dominic Morris Ballyfinaghy, Belfast, infilling and levelling of garden. Extension/Alterat Finaghy Road South, Architects, Elmwood Northern Ireland, BT10 ion Belfast, BT10 0DH House Business Centre, 44-46 Elmwood Avenue, Belfast, BT9 6AZ Z/2007/3060/F Lands between Exchange New public arts centre including 350 Full Erection of Old Museum Arts Centre Hackett & Hall , Unit Street, Exchange Street seat and a 120 seat auditoria, art Building(s) 7 College Square North, B112, Portview, 310 West, to include Hector galleries and associated ancilliary Belfast, BT1 6AR Newtownards Road, Street (all to the North East accomodation. Proposed alterations Belfast, BT4 1HE of St Annes Cathedral) to Exchange St and Edward St to Page 58 provide level 'shared' surface Z/2007/3061/F 24 Cabinhill Gardens, Single storey rear extension to Full Building Mr & Mrs Farrelly 24 S Brown , 57 Springhill Belfast BT5 dwelling. Extension/Alterat Cabinhill Gardens, Road, Bangor, BT20 3PD ion Ballycloghan, Belfast, BT5 7AP Z/2008/0001/F 30 Mount Eden Park, Two storey and sinlge storey Full Building Ms F Mc Auley C/o MC2 MC2 Architects, The Malone Upper, Belfast, extension to rear of dwelling Extension/Alterat Architects, The Northern Northern Bank Building, Northern Ireland, BT09 ion Bank Building, 14a Broad 14a Broad Street, Street, Magherafelt, Co Magherafelt, Co Londonderry, BT45 6EA Londonderry, BT45 6EA Z/2007/2995/F 10 Massey Park, Belfast, One and a half storey extension to Full Building Mr & Mrs G Hartin 10 Noteman Mc Kee BT4 2JX side and rear of dwelling to include Extension/Alterat Massey Park, Belfast, BT4 Architects, 60 Malone new basement garden store and ion 2JX Road, Belfast, BT9 5BT cantilevered deck to rear Z/2007/3028/LD 45 Earlswood Road, Removal of some internal rear walls LD Certificate Minor Works/Env. Mr M Cole Belfast, BT4 C.R.DESIGN, 25 Glennor Strandtown, Belfast, within the curtilage of the existing Proposed Improve. Crescent, Carryduff, Northern Ireland, BT04 dwelling Belfast, BT8 8HW

15 January 2008 Page 3 of 5 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2007/3046/A 136 Albertbridge Road, Creche shopfront signage Advertisement Display of East Belfast Sure Start Crothers , Design Matters, Belfast, BT5 4GS Advertisement 122 Albertbridge Road, 8 Wellington Park, Belfast, BT5 4GS Belfast, BT9 6DJ Z/2007/3048/F Unit 3, M2 Business Park, Proposed ancillary office Full Building Eurocables 1 Westbank Mr S Hawthorne Duncrue Street, Belfast. accomodation with associated Extension/Alterat Road, Belfast, BT3 9JL Hawthorne Associates, 2 external alterations to existing ion The Beeches, Grove warehouse. Road, Spa, Ballynahinch, Co Down, BT24 8RA Z/2007/3063/F 1-4 Herdman Channel Proposed extension to workshop Full Building Hireco (Ni) Ltd 1-4 Structural Design & Road, Low-Wood Intake, including undercover washbay. Extension/Alterat Herdman Channel Road, Detailing, A12B Belfast, Northern Ireland, ion Belfast, BT3 9BL Knockmore Business BT03 9BL Centre, 162 Moira Road, Lisburn, BT28 1JA Z/2008/0003/F 22 Penrose Street, Malone Extension to existing two storey rear Full Building L&E Properties C/O Total Total Architecture & Lower, Belfast, Northern return and alterations to existing Extension/Alterat Architecture & Design Ltd, Design Ltd, 23 University Page 59 Ireland, BT07 1QX House in Multiple Occupancy ion 23 University Street, Street, Belfast, BT7 1FY Belfast, BT7 1FY Z/2007/3020/F 76 Shandon Park, Knock, Two storey rear extension, roof Full Building Mr & Mrs Cotter 76 A Mc C Mc Conville Daly, Belfast, Northern Ireland, space conversion to dwelling and Extension/Alterat Shandon Park, Belfast, O'Neill & Associates, 23 BT05 6NZ part conversion and alterations to ion BT5 6NZ William Street, existing garage. Portadown, BT62 3NX Z/2007/3030/F 51 Martinez Avenue, Single storey rear extension and Full Building Mr Stewart C/O JWA JWA Design, 1 Bramble Ballyhackamore, Belfast, alterations to dwelling. Extension/Alterat Design, 1 Bramble Grove, Grove, Old Carrick Road, Northern Ireland, BT05 ion Newtownabbey Newtownabbey, BT37 0GE

Z/2007/3033/F 123 Finaghy Road South, Two-storey rear extension and Full Building Mr D Beatty 123 Finaghy Mr J M Taggart Taggart Ballyfinaghy, Belfast, alterations to dwelling. Extension/Alterat Road South, Belfast, Design, 133a Coolreaghs Northern Ireland, BT10 ion BT10 0BZ Road, Cookstown, County Tyrone, BT80 9QD Z/2008/0005/A 9 Kings Road, Belfast, BT5 Display of free standing sign Advertisement Display of Abbeyfield Belfast Blamphin & Associates, 6JF Advertisement Society 430 Lisburn 80 Malone Avenue, Road, Belfast, BT9 6GN Belfast, BT9 6ES

15 January 2008 Page 4 of 5 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0007/F 80 Annadale Crescent, Single storey rear extension to Full Building Nihe The Housing Centre, Design Services, 32/36 Ballynafoy, Belfast, dwelling for disabled access. Extension/Alterat 2 Adelaide Street, Great Victoria Street, Northern Ireland, BT07 ion Belfast, BT2 7BA Belfast, BT2 7BA Z/2008/0008/F 24 Palestine Street, Two storey extension & new roof Full Building L&E Properties C/O Total Total Architecture & Malone Lower, Belfast, dormer to rear & internal alterations Extension/Alterat Architecture & Design Ltd, Design Ltd, 23 University Northern Ireland, BT07 to existing HMO. ion 23 Univerity Street, Street, Belfast, BT7 1FY Belfast, BT7 Z/2008/0009/F 42 Ormiston Crescent, Single storey extension to rear to Full Building Ms Benson 42 Ormiston Mr P Jenkins , 40 Mount Strandtown, Belfast, provide disabled facilities Extension/Alterat Crescent, Belfast Merrion Park, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT04 ion BT6 0GB Z/2008/0010/A 699 Lisburn Road, Malone Shop sign Advertisement Display of Ms R Little 1 Hampton Lower, Belfast, Northern Advertisement Place, Belfast, BT1 3BZ Ireland, BT09 7GU Z/2008/0012/RM Single field to the North of Proposed housing development of Reserved Erection of S Crowther Designs Mr K Mcclure Bradley Lyndhurst View Park off 86no dwellings. Matters Building(s) Matter, 8 Wellington Park, McClure Architects, 184- Page 60 Ballymagarry Lane, Belfast Belfast, BT9 6DS 186 Lisburn Road, Belfast, BT9 6AL Z/2008/0017/LD 39 Houston Park, Single storey rear extension to LD Certificate Building Ms K Topping 39 Houston Ian Kennedy, 48 Multyhogy, Belfast, dwelling. Proposed Extension/Alterat Park, Belfast, BT5 6AT Kirkliston Park, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT05 ion TOTAL:- 36

15 January 2008 Page 5 of 5

Page 61 Page 62 Agenda Item 6a

APPLICATIONS DEFERRED FROM PREVIOUS MEETING

ITEM NO D 1 APPLIC NO Z/2004/2301/F Full Date Valid 01/10/2004 LOCATION 'The Orchard' 89A and 89B Knock Road, Knock, Belfast, BT05 6LF PROPOSAL Proposed amendments to previously approved application Z/2003/0621 including house types and layouts. (amended scheme). APPLICANT Brandenburg (Sfpd) REPRESENTATIONS 9 Objections 0 Support 1 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD1 of PPS 7 in that the development would not create a quality residential environment. The proposal fails to meet the requirements of QD1 in that the proposal would result in a prominent built form which is out of character with the surrounding townscape and would cause unacceptable damage to local character. The proposal would result in unacceptable damage to the living conditions of adjacent residents by reason of dominance, overshadowing and loss of light. The proposal fails to provide adequate viable amenity space for site 1. 2 Change of opinion to refuse.

ITEM NO D 2 APPLIC NO Z/2006/2654/F Full Date Valid 15/11/2006 LOCATION Brookfield and Rosebank Business Centre, Brookfield Mill, 309-355 Crumlin Road, Belfast PROPOSAL Change of use from business units to apartments (former Mill Building) and redevelopment of remainder of the site to provide 174 No apartments, car parking and commercial / office units. APPLICANT NMC Developments REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL 1 Deferred by Cllr Wilson on behalf of Cllr D Dodds for office meeting - 20/09/2007. 2 Opinion remains to approve.

ITEM NO D 3 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0267/F Full Date Valid 30/01/2007 LOCATION Pirrie House, Pirrie Road, Belfast, BT04 3NN PROPOSAL Proposed demolition of existing dwelling and erection of two detached and four semi-detached dwellings with detached garages and associated siteworks. APPLICANT Lacuna Developments REPRESENTATIONS 3 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL 1 Deferred by Cllr Long for office meeting - 06/12/2007. 2 Opinion remains to approve. Page 63

ITEM NO D 4 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0668/F Full Date Valid 28/02/2007 LOCATION 72 Kansas Avenue, Skegoneill, Belfast, BT15 5AX PROPOSAL Conversion of existing terrace house into 3 No. apartments with fire escape to rear and bin store in rear yard (amended description). APPLICANT A & D Mc Gibbon & Cooper REPRESENTATIONS 5 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to DGN4: Control of Flat Conversions in that the site is not considered appropriate for subdivision into multiple dwelling units for the following reasons: to protect existing housing stock still considered suitable for single family accommodation, additional traffic generation, adequacy of parking facilities, and increased levels of noise, nuisance and disturbance. 2 Change of opinion to refuse.

ITEM NO D 5 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1212/F Full Date Valid 17/05/2007 LOCATION 289 & 291 Belmont Road and 1 Tweskard Park, Ballymaghan, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT04 2LB PROPOSAL Residential development of 6 semi-detached dwellings and 3 apartments. APPLICANT Alisa Properties Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 33 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL 1 Deferred by Cllr Long for office meeting - 08/11/2007. 2 Opinion remains to approve.

ITEM NO D 6 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1952/F Full Date Valid 08/08/2007 LOCATION 42 Downview Avenue, Low-Wood, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT15 4FB PROPOSAL Erection of 2no. semi-detached houses (amended drawings). APPLICANT Mannix Mc Alister REPRESENTATIONS 4 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL 1 Deferred by Cllr Lavery for office meeting - 22/11/2007. 2 Change of opinion to approve.

Page 64

ITEM NO D 7 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2172/F Full Date Valid 06/09/2007 LOCATION 47 Hopefield Avenue, Skegoneill, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT15 5AP PROPOSAL Erection of three apartments to rear of existing building. APPLICANT K+T Developments REPRESENTATIONS 7 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD1 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 7: Quality Residential Environments and associated guidance, in that it is not demonstrated that a quality sustainable development will be created on site due to inadequate parking provision and its negative affect on the amenity of existing residents, the proposal does not provide adequate private amenity space in the form of bin storage and the proposed development would harm the living conditions of residents in 45 Hopefield Avenue by reason of overlooking and consequently lack of privacy. 2 Deferred by Cllr Cobain - to be back on next schedule - 06/12/2007. 3 Opinion remains to refuse.

Page 65 Agenda Item 6b

DEPARTMENT OF THE ENVIRONMENT

PLANNING (NI) ORDER 1991

APPLICATIONS FOR PLANNING PERMISSION

COUNCIL Belfast Date 24-Jan-08

ITEM NO 1 APPLIC NO Z/2002/2815/F Full Date Valid 07/02/2003

LOCATION Land to the rear of 162 Castlereagh Road, Belfast. PROPOSAL Variation of condition no 2 of previous planning permission Z/2001/2068/F APPLICANT Mr P Young REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal is contrary to WM1 of Planning Policy Statement 11 Planning and Waste Management in that it would if approved have an unacceptable impact on human health by virtue of the adverse noise levels that would be produced if the facility was approved. 2 The proposal is contrary to WM1 of Planning Policy Statement 11 Planning and Waste Management in that it is incompatible with the character of the surrounding area and adjacent land uses. 3 The proposal is contrary to WM2 of Planning Policy Statement 11 Planning and Waste Management in that it does not fulfill the locational criteria in WM2 as the proposed development is not suitably located in an industrial area. 4 The proposal is contrary to WM2 of Planning Policy Statement 11 Planning and Waste Management in that the sorting and processing of waste are not being carried out within a purpose built or appropriately modified existing building.

ITEM NO 2 APPLIC NO Z/2006/0457/F Full Date Valid 02/03/2006

LOCATION Land at Annadale Embankment, bound by Annadale Crescent and Annadale Drive, Belfast PROPOSAL Residential development of 216 no. apartments and associated works (amended scheme) APPLICANT The Carvill Group REPRESENTATIONS 42 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 66

ITEM NO 3 APPLIC NO Z/2006/1260/F Full Date Valid 01/06/2006

LOCATION 43 Kings Road, Belfast, BT05 6JH PROPOSAL Erection of dwelling within existing garden. APPLICANT Mr & Mrs D Acton REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal is contrary to Policy BH12 of Planning Policy Statement 6 Planning, Archaeology, and the Built Heritage, and Policy QD1 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 7 Quality Residential Environments in that the proposal involves intensification of site usage and coverage and would, if permitted, result in overdevelopment of the site due to its inappropriate layout, form, and design causing harm to the character and appearance of the Kings Road Conservation Area. The proposal also fails to provide adequate private amenity space, and would be harmful to the living conditions of prospective residents through overlooking from adjacent properties.

ITEM NO 4 APPLIC NO Z/2006/1745/F Full Date Valid 20/07/2006

LOCATION 1-7 Skegoneill Street, York Road, Belfast, BT15 3JL PROPOSAL Demolition of premises at 1-7 Skegoneill Street and construction of 1no. retail unit, 3no. light industrial units and associated carparking/landscaping works (amended scheme). APPLICANT The Sawel Trust REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 5 APPLIC NO Z/2006/2860/F Full Date Valid 11/12/2006

LOCATION 16 Floral Park, Drumnadrough, Newtownabbey, BT36 7RU PROPOSAL Two storey extension to side and rear and single storey to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr P Lynch REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal is contrary to Draft PPS7 Residential extensions and alterations in that the extension would, if permitted, adversely affect the amenities of the neighbours by reason of its unsympathetic scale and form and its impact on the character and appearance of the surrounding area. 2 The proposed extension would, if permitted, harm the living conditions of residents in No. 18 Floral Park by reason of an overbearing and crowding affect.

Page 67

ITEM NO 6 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0005/F Full Date Valid 20/12/2006

LOCATION Site No.s 19-36 Housing Development at Cherryvalley Nursery, Kings Road Belfast BT5 7BU PROPOSAL Proposed housing development of 18 No. dwellings comprising 2No. blocks of 9 apartments, basement carpark and other associated site works. APPLICANT Dingles Builders (Ni) Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 7 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0031/CA App within Date Valid 21/12/2006

LOCATION 71 Somerton Road, Skegoneill, Belfast, BT15 4DE PROPOSAL Demolition of existing parochial house and adjacent caretakers house. APPLICANT Trustees Of St Therese'S Church REPRESENTATIONS 7 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal is contrary to Policy BH14 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 6: Planning, Archaeology and the Built Heritage in that the building makes a material contribution to the character of the Somerton Road/ Chichester Park Conservation Area and no exceptional reason has been demonstrated which, in the judgment of the Department, justifies its demolition.

ITEM NO 8 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0049/F Full Date Valid 28/12/2006

LOCATION 16 Cliftonville Road, Belfast, BT14 PROPOSAL Construction of 2 No. apartments with access and parking provision on property to the rear of 16 Cliftonville Road (amended scheme). APPLICANT Mr A Osborne REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 68

ITEM NO 9 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0136/F Full Date Valid 12/01/2007

LOCATION 41 Eglantine Avenue, Belfast, BT09 PROPOSAL Demolition of building in 3no. HMO flats with retention of front facade and erection of 4no. 1 bedroom flats and 1no. 2 bed flat with 2 storey store to rear. APPLICANT Power And Devine REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD1 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 7: Quality Residential Environments and Policy BH12 of Planning Policy Statement 6: Planning, Archaeology and the Built Heritage in that the proposal would, if permitted, result in overdevelopment of the site and would cause harm to the local character and environmental quality of the Malone Conservation Area due to inappropriate form, bulk, height, detailing and materials and inadequate provision of private amenity space for prospective occupants. 2 The proposal is unacceptable in that it would, if permitted, harm the living conditions and residential amenity of adjacent neighbours in terms of overshadowing and dominance due to inappropriate form, bulk and design of the proposed development.

ITEM NO 10 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0139/DCA Demolition Date Valid 12/01/2007

LOCATION 41 Eglantine, Avenue, Belfast, BT09 PROPOSAL Demolition of existing building in 3no. HMO flats with retention of front facade. APPLICANT Power And Devine REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal is contrary to Policy BH14 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 6: Planning, Archaeology and the Built Heritage in that the existing building makes a material contribution to the character and appearance of the Malone Conservation Area and no exceptional reason has been demonstrated to justify its demolition.

ITEM NO 11 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0268/F Full Date Valid 08/02/2007

LOCATION 7 Camberwell Terrace, Belfast, BT15 3AS (Amended address). PROPOSAL Change of use from dwelling to three apartments including three-storey rear extension (Amended plans). APPLICANT Mr P Coyle REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 1 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 69

ITEM NO 12 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0610/F Full Date Valid 09/03/2007

LOCATION 115 / 117 Belmont Road, Strandtown, Belfast, BT04 2AD PROPOSAL Erection of 2nd floor extension to rear to provide sterilization suite. APPLICANT Mr I Mc Comb REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 13 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0704/F Full Date Valid 21/03/2007

LOCATION 35 Irwin Crescent, Ballyhackamore, Belfast, BT04 3AQ PROPOSAL Two-storey rear extension to dwelling. APPLICANT Mr & Mrs A Mc Kee REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 14 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0927/F Full Date Valid 17/04/2007

LOCATION 362 Newtownards Road, Ballymacarret, Belfast, BT04 1HG PROPOSAL Retrospective change of use from retail unit to taxi depot. APPLICANT Mr G Marshall REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 15 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1025/F Full Date Valid 30/04/2007

LOCATION 1 & 3 Olympia Drive, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT12 6NG PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of two dwellings. APPLICANT Mr J Curry REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 70

ITEM NO 16 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1181/F Full Date Valid 14/05/2007

LOCATION 81-85, Chichester Street and 127 Victoria Street, Town Parks, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT01 4JE PROPOSAL Proposed new railings and fixed furniture to form new external smoking area. APPLICANT Ultimate Leisure Group Plc REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 17 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1201/A Advertisement Date Valid 16/05/2007

LOCATION 19-21 James Street South, Town Parks, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT02 7GA PROPOSAL Projecting sign APPLICANT Gowdy Property Consultants REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal is contrary to Policy BH13 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 6: Planning, Archaeology and the Built Heritage in that the site lies within the Linen Conservation Area and the advertisement sign would, if permitted, adversely affect its appearance and detract from the character of the building upon which it is to be displayed] by reason of its inappropriate location which is unduly prominent and obtrusive. its inappropriate size and form. the creation of a proliferation of signs.

ITEM NO 18 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1323/F Full Date Valid 29/05/2007

LOCATION Odyssey Centre, 2 Queens Quay, Belfast, BT3 9QQ PROPOSAL Change of use of four concourse areas to "smoking areas" with 2000mm high glazed screens along the perimeter's and four No Jumbrella’s. APPLICANT Odyssey Trust Co REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 71

ITEM NO 19 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1358/F Full Date Valid 31/05/2007

LOCATION 10 & 12 Pim's Avenue, Strandtown, Belfast, BT04 1PJ PROPOSAL Demolition of existing properties and erection of 4no. apartments (non hmo) APPLICANT Mr S Mc Cann REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 20 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1464/F Full Date Valid 14/06/2007

LOCATION 42, 44 & 46 Cherryville Street & 193, 195 & 197 Woodstock Road, Belfast, BT6 8AD PROPOSAL Construction of 18 no. 1 bedroom apartments & associated works. APPLICANT Mr. Smallwall REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 1 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 21 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1520/F Full Date Valid 20/06/2007

LOCATION 346 Beersbridge Road, Ballyhackamore, Belfast, BT05 5DY PROPOSAL Change of use from sandwich bar and offices to ground floor shop and 4no apartments on upper floors including 3 storey rear extension, roof terrace and dormer APPLICANT Mr J Donaghy REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD1 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 7: Quality residential environments in that in that it would if permitted result in overdevelopment of the site and would cause unacceptable damage to the character and residential amenity of the prospective residents through poor outlook.

Page 72

ITEM NO 22 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1541/F Full Date Valid 21/06/2007

LOCATION 9 Annadale Avenue, Galwally, Belfast, BT07 3JH PROPOSAL Demolition of existing detached house and proposed residential development of 9 No. 2 beroom apartments including associated siteworks. APPLICANT Linvale Developments Ltd. REPRESENTATIONS 4 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 23 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1551/F Full Date Valid 25/06/2007

LOCATION 30 Kimberley Street, Ballynafoy, Belfast, BT07 3DY PROPOSAL Two storey extension to rear of dwelling. APPLICANT Mr H Mooreland REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 24 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1558/A Advertisement Date Valid 25/06/2007

LOCATION 128a Upper Lisburn Road, Finaghy, BT10 0BE PROPOSAL 1 no. illuminatred box sign on fascia of building APPLICANT Cheque Centre Properties Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION CONSENT

ITEM NO 25 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1568/F Full Date Valid 25/06/2007

LOCATION 141 Dunluce Avenue, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 7AX PROPOSAL Change of use from dwelling to 2no. apartments, with front and rear dormers, and two storey rear extension. APPLICANT Mr Toner REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 73

ITEM NO 26 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1569/F Full Date Valid 25/06/2007

LOCATION 23 Wansbeck Street, Belfast, BT9 5FQ PROPOSAL Two storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr B Garland REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 27 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1609/F Full Date Valid 29/06/2007

LOCATION 38 Wandsworth Road, Belfast, BT4 3LT PROPOSAL Single storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Ms D Kinghan REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 28 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1616/A Advertisement Date Valid 29/06/2007

LOCATION 21 Bedford Street, Town Parks, Belfast, BT02 7EJ PROPOSAL Two awnings to front of bar. APPLICANT Carmichael Group Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal is contrary to Policy BH9 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 6: Planning, Archaeology and the Built Heritage in that the building is listed under Article 42 of the Planning (NI) Order 1991 and the advertisements would, if permitted, detract from character of the building and result in a loss of its architectural integrity by reason of Their inappropriate location which would obscure the architectural detailing of the building. Their detailed design which is out of keeping with the architectural design of the building in terms of size, scale and materials.

Page 74

ITEM NO 29 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1643/F Full Date Valid 02/07/2007

LOCATION 211-213 Woodstock Road, Belfast, BT6 8PQ PROPOSAL First floor extension to existing retail unit APPLICANT Mr R Goody REPRESENTATIONS 3 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 30 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1666/F Full Date Valid 06/07/2007

LOCATION 17-21 Battenberg Street, Town Parks, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT13 3AT PROPOSAL Removal of storage unit and construction of 9 no. townhouses. APPLICANT Site Express REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 31 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1676/F Full Date Valid 06/07/2007

LOCATION 52 University Street, Malone Lower, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT07 1HB PROPOSAL Retention of use as offices for counselling and assessment (amended description) APPLICANT N I A M H REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 32 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1680/F Full Date Valid 06/07/2007

LOCATION 41 Surrey Street, Malone Lower, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT09 7FR PROPOSAL Two storey extension to the rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr A O'Neill REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 75

ITEM NO 33 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1683/F Full Date Valid 06/07/2007

LOCATION 29 Rosetta Avenue, Belfast, BT7 3HG PROPOSAL Single storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr & Mrs H Mc Callum REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 34 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1753/A Advertisement Date Valid 17/07/2007

LOCATION Bloomfield Congregational Church 84-90 Bloomfield Avenue, Ballyhackamore, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT05 5AE PROPOSAL Erection of signage & noticeboards. APPLICANT Bloomfield Congregational Church REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION CONSENT

ITEM NO 35 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1767/F Full Date Valid 19/07/2007

LOCATION Site between 32 & 34 Wellington Park, Malone Lower, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT09 6DN PROPOSAL Erection of electrical substation. APPLICANT Mc Ginnis Developmets Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 1 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 76

ITEM NO 36 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1815/F Full Date Valid 25/07/2007

LOCATION 2 Dunville Street, Town Parks, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT12 4NF PROPOSAL Conversion from HMO to 3 No. flats including alterations & 3 storey return. APPLICANT T & D Properties Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal is contrary to policy QD1 of Planning Policy Statement 7: Quality Residential Environments, policy H8 of the Belfast Urban Area Plan 2001 and the guidance within DGN4: Control of Flat Conversions in that the property is not within a designated Flat Conversion Zone and would, if permitted, result in the loss of a house suitable for single family occupation, and would adversely effect the predominantly residential character of the area as it would establish a precedent for further conversions in the locality. The development would fail to provide adequate private amenity space for bin storage and would, through precedent, harm the character, environmental quality and residential amenity of the area.

ITEM NO 37 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1818/F Full Date Valid 25/07/2007

LOCATION 9 Bloomfield Gardens, Belfast, BT5 5JU PROPOSAL Single storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr R Willock REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 38 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1833/F Full Date Valid 26/07/2007

LOCATION 27 Claremont Street, Belfast, BT9 6AP PROPOSAL Single storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr C Smyth REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 77

ITEM NO 39 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1866/F Full Date Valid 30/07/2007

LOCATION 23 Galwally Avenue, Breda, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT08 7AJ PROPOSAL Two-storey extension to the rear of existing dwelling house APPLICANT Lavin Developments REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 40 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1891/F Full Date Valid 03/08/2007

LOCATION 32-34 Rosetta Park, Ballynafoy, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT06 0DL PROPOSAL Erection of 2 storey extension to rear of no34 Rosetta Park to provide 2no new apartments, demolition of existing garages, and provision of car parking/landscaped area. APPLICANT Pineridge Developments REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal is contrary to policies ATC 2 of PP6 and QD 1 of PPS7 in that the proposed site is located within the Rosetta Park Area of Townscape Character and the proposal would, if permitted, result in overdevelopment of the site due to intensification of site usage and site coverage causing unacceptable damage to the character and appearance of the area due to inappropriate layout, scale and massing, and fails to provide adequate private amenity space for existing and prospective residents.

ITEM NO 41 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1892/F Full Date Valid 03/08/2007

LOCATION 7 Kimberley Street, Belfast, BT7 3DY PROPOSAL Two storey and single storey extensions to rear of existing HMO dwelling APPLICANT Mr B Mc Court REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal is contrary to Policy HMO5 of the Draft HMO Subject Plan of Draft BMAP 2015 in that, if the proposal were allowed, it would create intensification of the use as an existing HMO by way of an increase in the number of bedrooms and Policy HMO8 in that the proposal exceeds 4 bedrooms and encroaches on more than 50% of the existing rear yard area.

Page 78

ITEM NO 42 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1971/F Full Date Valid 09/08/2007

LOCATION 77 Orby Road, Ballyrushboy, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT05 5HN PROPOSAL Proposed development to include 4 no apartments with associated car parking and landscaping. APPLICANT Mr I Barr REPRESENTATIONS 5 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD1 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 7: Quality residential environments in that it would result in overdevelopment and would cause unacceptable damage to local character and residential amenity through inappropriate scale, layout and design, and would harm the living conditions of adjacent residents through loss of privacy and dominance.

ITEM NO 43 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1980/F Full Date Valid 10/08/2007

LOCATION 18 Dundela Avenue/Dundela Crescent, Ballyhackamore, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT04 3BQ PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of six 2 bed apartments. APPLICANT Daymore Enterprises Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 44 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1989/F Full Date Valid 13/08/2007

LOCATION 9 Castlehill Drive, Ballycloghan, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT04 3GS PROPOSAL Single-storey front, side and rear extensions to dwelling and retention of roof form over built extension. APPLICANT Mr G Browne REPRESENTATIONS 4 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 79

ITEM NO 45 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1991/F Full Date Valid 14/08/2007

LOCATION Lothair Avenue, Belfast even nos.4-42, Pacific Avenue Belfast even nos.12, 14, 34, BT15 2HT. PROPOSAL Group repairs to private dwellings to include replacement of dormer windows, roof coverings etc (Amended plans). APPLICANT Nihe REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 46 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2000/F Full Date Valid 14/08/2007

LOCATION Plot 4, Gasworks, Ormeau Road, Belfast. PROPOSAL Rooftop extension to existing office building including rooftop plant room. (Amended drawings received.) APPLICANT Tullyraine Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 47 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2003/F Full Date Valid 14/08/2007

LOCATION 4 Eversleigh Street, Belfast, BT6 8BY PROPOSAL Two storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr P Arlow REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 80

ITEM NO 48 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2014/F Full Date Valid 15/08/2007

LOCATION Lands between Shankill Parade and North Boundary Street, Shankill Ward, Shankill Road, Belfast, BT13. PROPOSAL Relocation of existing Shankill Healthcare GPs and Pharmacy to create 2 medical surgeries, pharmacy associated accommodation and car parking and 14 no. apartments with 1 no. car parking space per unit and associated private/shared amenity space. APPLICANT Clear Healthcare REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 49 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2085/F Full Date Valid 23/08/2007

LOCATION Greenwood Manor, Ballycloghan, Belfast, BT04 3JJ PROPOSAL Single storey rear extension to office to link existing garage which is to be converted into offices with first floor mezzanine area, inc. garage roof raised. APPLICANT Image Zoo REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 50 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2107/F Full Date Valid 24/08/2007

LOCATION 1 Castlehill Park West, Ballycloghan, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT04 3GT PROPOSAL First floor extension to side of dwelling and alterations APPLICANT Mr & Mrs T Mc Quoid REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 81

ITEM NO 51 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2115/A Advertisement Date Valid 28/08/2007

LOCATION Co-Op Bank, 18 Donegall Square East, Town Parks, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT01 5HE PROPOSAL Two externally illuminated fascia signs APPLICANT Cws Retail Financial Service REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal is contrary to Policy BH9 and BH13 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 6: Planning, Archaeology and the Built Heritage in that the building is listed under Article 42 of the Planning (NI) Order 1991 and located within the Belfast City Centre conservation area and the signs would, if permitted, detract from its appearance and result in a loss of its architectural integrity by reason of their detailed design which is out of keeping with the age architectural style of the building in terms of size, materials and the use of an inappropriate means of illumination.

ITEM NO 52 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2138/F Full Date Valid 31/08/2007

LOCATION 18 Rugby Avenue, Malone Lower, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT07 1RG PROPOSAL Change of use from dwelling to 3 no. flats and three storey rear extension APPLICANT Mr C Mc Swiggan REPRESENTATIONS 13 Objections 0 Support 1 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposed development would, if permitted, harm the living conditions and amenity of adjacent residents by reason of overshadowing and dominance.

ITEM NO 53 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2150/F Full Date Valid 04/09/2007

LOCATION Apartments 1+2, 61 Willowbank Gardens, Skegoneill, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT15 5AJ PROPOSAL Erection of single storey extension to rear of ground floor apartment and alterations to ground and first and second floor apartments. APPLICANT C&E Cassidy REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 82

ITEM NO 54 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2163/F Full Date Valid 04/09/2007

LOCATION 70 Connsbrook Avenue, Strandtown, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT04 1JW PROPOSAL Demolition of existing structure and erection of 2No 2 bedroom apartments. APPLICANT Mr G Speers REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 55 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2203/F Full Date Valid 10/09/2007

LOCATION 6 Delhi Parade, Ballynafoy, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT07 3AU PROPOSAL Two storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr & Mrs M & J Clarke REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 56 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2213/F Full Date Valid 11/09/2007

LOCATION Channel Commercial Park, Queens Road, BT3 9DT PROPOSAL Erection of new 27m x 9.6m modular building for staff amenities (Amended description). APPLICANT Howden Uk Ltd. REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 57 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2215/F Full Date Valid 11/09/2007

LOCATION 38 Summerhill Avenue, Ballycloghan, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT05 7HD PROPOSAL Erection of two-storey end terrace in side garden. APPLICANT Hydebank Developments Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 83

ITEM NO 58 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2219/F Full Date Valid 11/09/2007

LOCATION 64-66 Upper Church Lane, Town Parks, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT01 4QL PROPOSAL Erection of air conditioning unit on external wall of first floor. APPLICANT Kennedys Solicitors REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal is contrary to Policy BH12 of Planning Policy Statement 6 Planning, Archaeology, and the Built Heritage in that the site lies within the Belfast City Centre Conservation area and the development would, if permitted, detract from its character and appearance as: it is not in sympathy with the characteristic built form of the area and does not conform with the guidance set out in the Belfast City Centre Conservation Area document. Its scale, form, proportions, height and detailing does not respect the characteristics of adjoining buildings and does not conform with the guidance set out in the Belfast City Centre Conservation Area document. It would introduce a use out of keeping with the conservation area and would give rise to increased noise and visual clutter.

ITEM NO 59 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2220/F Full Date Valid 11/09/2007

LOCATION 49 Lenadoon Avenue, Englishtown, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT11 9GQ PROPOSAL Erection of 2 storey side extension and alterations. APPLICANT Mr S O'Rouke REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 60 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2254/F Full Date Valid 13/09/2007

LOCATION 14 Woodland Avenue, Town Parks, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT14 6BY PROPOSAL Change of Use from single dwelling to 5 apartments, including 2 storey rear extension. APPLICANT Mr & Mrs Rodgers REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 1 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal is contrary to policy QD1 of Planning Policy Statement 7: Quality Residential Environments, policy H8 of the Belfast Urban Area Plan 2001 and the guidance within DGN4: Control of Flat Conversions in that the property is not within a designated Flat Conversion Zone and would, if permitted, result in the loss of a house suitable for single family occupation, and would adversely effect the predominantly residential character of the area as it would establish a precedent for further conversions in the locality. The development would fail to provide adequate private amenity space for bin storage and would, through precedent, harm the character, environmental quality and residential amenity of the area.

Page 84

ITEM NO 61 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2261/F Full Date Valid 14/09/2007

LOCATION 27 Westland Gardens, Old Park, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT14 6NF PROPOSAL Erection of 2no detached dwellings in rear garden. APPLICANT Ms N Mullaghan REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 62 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2266/F Full Date Valid 14/09/2007

LOCATION 54 Rosemount Gardens, Skegoneill, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT15 5AG PROPOSAL Demolition of existing HMO with retention of front facade & erection of 3No. 1bedroom flats. APPLICANT T & D Properties REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 1 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal would, if permitted, have detrimental impact on both visual and residential amenity. 2 The proposed development, if permitted, could set an undesirable precedence that would be detrimental to the character of the area.

ITEM NO 63 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2284/F Full Date Valid 18/09/2007

LOCATION 295A, Ballygomartin Road, Ballymagarry, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT13 3QX

PROPOSAL Erection of covered smokers balcony. APPLICANT Ulster Quaker Service Committee REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 85

ITEM NO 64 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2288/F Full Date Valid 18/09/2007

LOCATION 36A & 36B Twaddell Avenue, Edenderry, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT13 3LF PROPOSAL Demolition of existing retail unit and provision of new residential development comprising 3no. 2 bedroom apartments. APPLICANT Lets Do It Up Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD1 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 7: Quality Residential Environments, in that it would, if permitted, result in unacceptable damage to the local character and residential amenity of the area by reason of over development resulting in: a development that fails to respect the surrounding context and characteristics of the area and; unacceptable adverse impact on No.1 Crumlin Gardens due to inadequate separation distances, overshadowing, and loss of privacy.

ITEM NO 65 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2318/F Full Date Valid 20/09/2007

LOCATION Unit C, 81 Sydenham Road, Ballymacarret Intake, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT03 9DJ PROPOSAL Extension to existing office building APPLICANT Royce Developments Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 66 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2347/F Full Date Valid 24/09/2007

LOCATION Land adjacent to 104 Circular Road, Ballymisert, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT04 2GF PROPOSAL Construction of new single dwelling house and associated site works. APPLICANT Mr & Mrs R Acheson REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 86

ITEM NO 67 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2364/F Full Date Valid 26/09/2007

LOCATION 8 Knockmount Park, Knock, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT05 6GR PROPOSAL Erection of two bedroom dwelling house and garden area APPLICANT Mr C Mc Master REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD 1 of Planning Policy Statement 7 "Quality Residential Environments" and associated guidance in that it would, if permitted, result in overdevelopment of the site, which is too restricted to permit the erection of a dwelling of reasonable design and dimensions and with adequate amenity space and which would harm the residential amenity of adjoining premises.

ITEM NO 68 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2377/F Full Date Valid 01/10/2007

LOCATION 37 Ann Street (part of Victoria Square Regeneration Project), Town Parks, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT1 4EB PROPOSAL Erection of 4no. sheet steel public artwork figures ranging in height from 2.8m to 3.3m. APPLICANT Multi Development Uk Ltd. REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 69 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2385/F Full Date Valid 26/09/2007

LOCATION 25/27, Ann Street, Town Parks, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT01 4EB PROPOSAL Installation of new shopfront. APPLICANT Jjb Sports Plc REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 87

ITEM NO 70 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2392/LB Listed Building Date Valid 01/10/2007

LOCATION Morrisons Bar, 21 Bedford Street, Town Parks, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT02 7EJ PROPOSAL 2no advertising awnings at bar frontage APPLICANT Carmichael Group Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal is contrary to Policy BH9 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 6: Planning, Archaeology and the Built Heritage in that the building is listed under Article 42 of the Planning (NI) Order 1991 and the advertisements would, if permitted, detract from character of the building and result in a loss of its architectural integrity by reason of Their inappropriate location which would obscure the architectural detailing of the building. Their detailed design which is out of keeping with the architectural design of the building in terms of size, scale and materials.

ITEM NO 71 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2415/F Full Date Valid 15/10/2007

LOCATION 20 Castle Gardens, Low-Wood, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT15 4GB PROPOSAL Two storey and single-storey extension to rear of dwelling with double doors and guardrail at first floor level (Amended Scheme). APPLICANT Mr S Corrigan REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 72 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2423/F Full Date Valid 04/10/2007

LOCATION 1-5 Donegall Lane, Town Parks, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT01 2LZ PROPOSAL Inclosure of former fire escape with provision of external smoking area. APPLICANT Outside REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 88

ITEM NO 73 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2427/F Full Date Valid 04/10/2007

LOCATION 24 Cromwell Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT07 1JW PROPOSAL Demolition of 2 existing flats with retention of front facade and erection of building to accommodate 7 one bed flats APPLICANT M.Meenan & J.Doherty REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD 1 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 7: Quality Residential Environments and associated guidance in that the proposal would result in overdevelopment of the site with its form causing inadequate provision of outlook for potential tenants.

ITEM NO 74 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2468/O Outline Date Valid 10/10/2007

LOCATION Lands adjacent to 742 Antrim Road, Green Castle, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT15 4EL PROPOSAL Construction of 1no dwelling and associated site works. APPLICANT Fortwillian Estates Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 75 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2510/F Full Date Valid 15/10/2007

LOCATION 189 & 191 Ligoniel Road, Legoniel, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT14 8DT PROPOSAL Extension of existing units and change of use from retail outlet to hot food outlet. APPLICANT Mr F Eastwood REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 89

ITEM NO 76 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2511/F Full Date Valid 15/10/2007

LOCATION 348 Beersbridge Road, Ballyhackamore, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT05 5DY PROPOSAL Erection of 2 storey extension to the rear for retail unit at ground floor & 2 bedroom apartment above with new entrance door to apartment. APPLICANT Mr M Holmes REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 77 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2512/F Full Date Valid 15/10/2007

LOCATION 7 Belmont Church Road, Ballycloghan, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT04 3FF PROPOSAL Two storey rear extension to dwelling and new garage/store. APPLICANT Jt & Py Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 78 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2520/A Advertisement Date Valid 15/10/2007

LOCATION Unit 6, Tolgate House, 51 Bradbury Place, Malone Lower, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT07 1RR PROPOSAL ATM Ulster Bank Sign. APPLICANT Hendersons Plc REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION CONSENT

ITEM NO 79 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2531/F Full Date Valid 16/10/2007

LOCATION 45 Rose Park, Belfast, BT5 7RH. PROPOSAL Re-roofing to existing garage to form new pitched roof APPLICANT Mr & Mrs Irwin REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 90

ITEM NO 80 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2537/F Full Date Valid 16/10/2007

LOCATION 8 Orpen Avenue, Ballyfinaghy, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT10 0BS PROPOSAL Proposed single storey sun room extension to rear of dwelling. APPLICANT Mr M Crossan REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 81 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2552/F Full Date Valid 18/10/2007

LOCATION 42 Frenchpark Street, Malone Lower, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT12 6NX PROPOSAL Erection of 2 storey rear extension. APPLICANT Mr K Black REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 82 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2560/F Full Date Valid 16/10/2007

LOCATION 38 Brookvale Avenue, Town Parks, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT14 6BW PROPOSAL The refurbishment and conversion of an existing three storey building to provide three self contained apartments. APPLICANT Mr G & H Wall REPRESENTATIONS 6 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal is contrary to Development Guidance Note Nos.4 & 4a, in that the development lies outside the designated Flat Conversion Zone Area in the Antirm Road Area of North Belfast and would, if permitted, lead to a loss of family sized accommodation and harm the character of the existing residential area by reason of increased density and result in traffic and parking congestion.

ITEM NO 83 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2566/F Full Date Valid 19/10/2007

LOCATION Royal Belfast Academical Institution, College Square East, Belfast, BT1 6DL PROPOSAL Demolition of existing extension to W block, erection of single storey extension to provide new classroom and internal alterations to provide additional classroom space. APPLICANT Board Of Governors REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 91

ITEM NO 84 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2576/F Full Date Valid 18/10/2007

LOCATION 3 Fairway Drive, Malone Upper, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT09 5ND PROPOSAL Single storey extensions to existing dwellinghouse and alterations to access APPLICANT Mr M Jennings REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 85 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2577/F Full Date Valid 22/10/2007

LOCATION 330-332 Donegall Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT12 6FX PROPOSAL Demolition of existing building and erection of a 3-storey building comprising 9no apartments. APPLICANT Clear Homes REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 86 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2586/F Full Date Valid 22/10/2007

LOCATION Ground beside pedestrian bridge on Westlink at Roden Street, Belfast, BT12. PROPOSAL Installation of 15m high CCTV pole. APPLICANT PSNI REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 87 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2590/F Full Date Valid 23/10/2007

LOCATION 145 Deerpark Road, Old Park, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT14 7PX PROPOSAL Erection of two storey extension and single storey extension to side of dwelling

APPLICANT Mr D Rogers REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 92

ITEM NO 88 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2601/F Full Date Valid 24/10/2007

LOCATION 12 Mount Vernon Park, Low-Wood, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT15 4BG PROPOSAL 1st floor extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr & Mrs Stewart REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 89 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2605/F Full Date Valid 24/10/2007

LOCATION (On footpath to front of) 150 Castlereagh Road, Belfast, BT5 5FS. PROPOSAL Erection of bus shelter on public footpath. APPLICANT Clear Channel Ni Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 90 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2606/F Full Date Valid 24/10/2007

LOCATION Sandown Road, Approx. 5m south-east of Sandown Park South, Belfast BT5 6GU. PROPOSAL Erection of replacement bus shelter on public footpath. APPLICANT Clear Channel Ni Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 91 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2619/F Full Date Valid 26/10/2007

LOCATION Floor 3, Pilot Point, 21 Clarendon Dock, Belfast, BT1 3BG PROPOSAL Single storey extension to apartment and the creation of additional windows. APPLICANT Varo Estates Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 93

ITEM NO 92 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2621/F Full Date Valid 26/10/2007

LOCATION 109 Duneden Park, Edenderry, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT14 7NE PROPOSAL Proposed change of use and 2-storey extension to form 2no apartments. APPLICANT Mr B Mc Givern REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal is contrary to DGN4: Control of Flat Conversions in that the site is not considered appropriate for subdivision into multiple dwelling units for the following reasons: to protect existing housing stock still considered suitable for single family accommodation, additional traffic generation, increased levels of noise, nuisance and disturbance.

ITEM NO 93 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2640/O Outline Date Valid 29/10/2007

LOCATION 31 Ravenhill Park, Ballynafoy, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT06 0DG PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwelling and garage and erection of a pair of semi- detached dwellings APPLICANT Mr & Mrs T Burns REPRESENTATIONS 4 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 94 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2651/F Full Date Valid 31/10/2007

LOCATION 330 Donegall Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT12 6FQ PROPOSAL Erection of a 3-storey building comprising 6no apartments. APPLICANT Clear Homes REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 95 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2652/F Full Date Valid 31/10/2007

LOCATION 32 Cairnburn Road, Ballymaghan, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT04 2HR PROPOSAL Erection of single storey extension to rear of dwelling and new boundary wall APPLICANT Mr P Martin REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 94

ITEM NO 96 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2655/F Full Date Valid 31/10/2007

LOCATION 8 Commedagh Drive, Ballydownfine, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT11 8GH PROPOSAL Single storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mrs F Toner REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 97 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2664/F Full Date Valid 01/11/2007

LOCATION 58 Crumlin Road, Town Parks, Belfast BT14 6AB PROPOSAL Change of use to Western section of ground floor office/store to facilitate relocation of opthalmic clinic from main hospital building. APPLICANT Belfast Hss Trust (Mater Hospital) REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION TEMPORARY APPROVAL

1 Temporary approval - 5 years.

ITEM NO 98 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2675/F Full Date Valid 02/11/2007

LOCATION 31 Stewartstown Road, Ballymoney, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT11 9FZ PROPOSAL Change of use from dwelling to mortagage shop. APPLICANT Mr P Ferrin REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposed development would, if permitted, create an undesirable precedent for further non-residential uses and would contribute to an unacceptable change in the character of this residential area.

ITEM NO 99 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2703/F Full Date Valid 06/11/2007

LOCATION 23-25 Tavanagh Street, Malone Lower, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT12 6JL PROPOSAL Change of use from one dwelling to two dwellings, with associated two storey extension to rear. APPLICANT Qmac Contracts REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 95

ITEM NO 100 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2704/F Full Date Valid 06/11/2007

LOCATION Windsor Women's Centre, 136-144, Broadway, Malone Lower, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT12 6HY PROPOSAL Erection of second floor extension to rear of building for after schools room, including 2 No. solar panels on new extension roof. APPLICANT Windsor Women's Centre REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 101 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2744/F Full Date Valid 12/11/2007

LOCATION Windsor House, 10-12 Bedford Street, Belfast, BT2 PROPOSAL Installation of telecommunications equipment consisting of 12 omni antennas on pole-mounted 'Y' headframe, 2 equipment cabinets, 4 power amplifiers and ancillary development. APPLICANT Personal Broadband Uk Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 102 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2745/A Advertisement Date Valid 12/11/2007

LOCATION Quaygate, 15 Scrabo Street, Ballymacarret, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT05 4BD PROPOSAL Suspended 8.2m x 9.6m mesh advertising banner. APPLICANT Mc Kay (Newtownards) Limited REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposed sign would be visually intrusive and distract the attention of rad users, thereby prejudicing the safety and convenience of traffic on this main traffic route. 2 The proposed sign contravenes the following points within Planning Policy Statement 17 (PPS 17) Control of Outdoor advertisements: Policy AD1 "Amenity and Public Safety" - Guidance on High Level Signs- Guidelines on Shroud Advertisement Displays.

Page 96

ITEM NO 103 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2746/F Full Date Valid 12/11/2007

LOCATION 30 Evelyn Gardens, Skegoneill, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT15 5DA PROPOSAL Alterations and refurbishment of 3 No. apartments to 4 No. apartments including two storey extension at rear. APPLICANT Evelyn Developments REPRESENTATIONS 3 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal is contrary to policy QD1 of Planning Policy Statement 7: Quality Residential Environments, policy H8 of the Belfast Urban Area Plan 2001 and the guidance within DGN4: Control of Flat Conversions in that the property is not within a designated Flat Conversion Zone and would, if permitted, result in the loss of a house suitable for single family occupation, and would harm the character, environmental quality and residential amenity of the area.

ITEM NO 104 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2751/A Advertisement Date Valid 13/11/2007

LOCATION 27 Talbot Street, BT1 PROPOSAL Erection of projecting sign. APPLICANT Mr A Lowry REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION CONSENT

ITEM NO 105 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2757/A Advertisement Date Valid 13/11/2007

LOCATION Unit 2, 36-40 Ann Street, Town Parks, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT01 4EG PROPOSAL Fascia and projecting sign. APPLICANT Specsavers Opticians REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION CONSENT

ITEM NO 106 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2785/F Full Date Valid 16/11/2007

LOCATION 143 Deerpark Road, Old Park, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT14 7PX PROPOSAL Erection of 2 storey extension to side of dwelling. APPLICANT Ms J Donnelly REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 97

ITEM NO 107 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2786/F Full Date Valid 16/11/2007

LOCATION 19 Massey Park, Killeen, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT04 2JX PROPOSAL Extension to existing garage APPLICANT Mr J P Henderson REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 108 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2790/F Full Date Valid 16/11/2007

LOCATION 6 Houston Court, Ballyhackamore, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT05 6JW PROPOSAL Provision of a ramp to the front of the property APPLICANT Frame REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 109 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2793/F Full Date Valid 19/11/2007

LOCATION 21 Tweskard Park, Ballymaghan, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT04 2JY PROPOSAL Retention of amended siting- and first floor front fenestration- of dwelling erected in non-compliance with planning approval reference - Z/2006/1173 APPLICANT Mr & Mrs G Reid REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 110 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2801/F Full Date Valid 19/11/2007

LOCATION 7 Benbradagh Gardens, Ballydownfine, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT11 8JS PROPOSAL Erection of 2 storey extension to side of dwelling APPLICANT Mr Maxwell REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 98

ITEM NO 111 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2810/F Full Date Valid 20/11/2007

LOCATION Land adjacent to (West of) 118 North Street, Belfast, BT1 PROPOSAL Reinstatement of entrance to existing car park (entrance only). APPLICANT Mr E Mc Cann REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal would, if permitted, prejudice the safety and convenience of road users since the proposed access is located in close proximity to two signal- controlled road junctions where the slowing down and turning movements of vehicles entering the access would conflict with traffic movements at the junctions.

ITEM NO 112 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2814/F Full Date Valid 20/11/2007

LOCATION Belfast City Hall, Donegal Square, Belfast PROPOSAL Erection of Korean Memorial APPLICANT Belfast City Council REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 113 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2850/F Full Date Valid 26/11/2007

LOCATION 32 Somerton Park, Belfast, BT15 4DP. PROPOSAL Erection of single storey extension to side, two storey extension to rear and installation of two windows in gable wall APPLICANT Ms P Coyle REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 114 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2862/F Full Date Valid 28/11/2007

LOCATION 31 Ava Street, Ballynafoy, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT7 3BS PROPOSAL Proposed single storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr P Mc Grath REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 99

ITEM NO 115 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2872/F Full Date Valid 29/11/2007

LOCATION 1 Cheltenham Park, Ballynafoy, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT06 0HR PROPOSAL Proposed two storey extension to rear of dwelling with single storey garage to side APPLICANT Ms L. Heaney REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 116 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2874/F Full Date Valid 29/11/2007

LOCATION 8 Clifton Crescent, Town Parks, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT14 6LF PROPOSAL Change of use from single dwelling to 2no apartments. APPLICANT Mr M O'Neil REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal is contrary to DGN4: Control of Flat Conversions in that the site is not considered appropriate for subdivision into multiple dwelling units for the following reasons: to protect existing housing stock still considered suitable for single family accommodation, additional traffic generation, adequacy of parking facilities, and increased levels of noise, nuisance and disturbance.

ITEM NO 117 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2875/F Full Date Valid 29/11/2007

LOCATION 16 Cliftonville Street, Town Parks, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT14 6LP PROPOSAL Single storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mrs M Jackson REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL ITEM NO 118 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2884/F Full Date Valid 29/11/2007

LOCATION 29 Andersonstown Crescent PROPOSAL Provision of a pitched roof to existing single storey extension to rear. APPLICANT Mrs E Mc Nameh REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 100

ITEM NO 119 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2890/A Advertisement Date Valid 30/11/2007

LOCATION 165,167 and 169 Ormeau Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT07 1SQ PROPOSAL Painted facade signage APPLICANT The Crescent Arts Centre REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION CONSENT

ITEM NO 120 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2925/F Full Date Valid 29/11/2007

LOCATION 197 Lisburn Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT09 7EJ PROPOSAL Change of use from former charity shop to estate agents office APPLICANT Property Link N.I.Ltd. REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 121 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2926/LB Listed Building Date Valid 05/12/2007

LOCATION Belfast City Hall, Donegal Square, Belfast, BT1 5GS PROPOSAL Erection of Korean memorial in the grounds of the Belfast City Hall. APPLICANT Belfast City Council REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION CONSENT

ITEM NO 122 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2937/F Full Date Valid 06/12/2007

LOCATION 214 Duncairn Gardens, Town Parks, Belfast BT15 2GP PROPOSAL Change of use from dwelling to 3no apartments including 3-storey extension and metal staircase to rear and additional front dormer window. APPLICANT C/O A Gregg REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION REFUSAL

1 The proposal is contrary to DGN4: Control of Flat Conversions in that the site is not considered appropriate for subdivision into multiple dwelling units for the following reasons: to protect existing housing stock still considered suitable for single family accommodation, additional traffic generation, adequacy of parking facilities, and increased levels of noise, nuisance and disturbance.

Page 101

ITEM NO 123 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2992/F Full Date Valid 12/12/2007

LOCATION 12 St Jude's Avenue, Ballynafoy, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT7 2GZ PROPOSAL Proposed extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Gavan & Elinor Mc Alinden REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 124 APPLIC NO Z/2007/3050/F Full Date Valid 18/12/2007

LOCATION 20 North Parade, Ballynafoy, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT07 2GG PROPOSAL Erection of single storey extension to rear of property APPLICANT Mr & Mrs Gibson REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions

OPINION APPROVAL

Page 102 Agenda Item 6c

APPEAL DECISIONS NOTIFIED COUNCIL Belfast ITEM NO 1 APPLIC NO Z/2005/2000/F PAC NO 2006/A1109 RESULT OF APPEAL Upheld

APPLICANT Mr A Wood LOCATION 1 Pirrie Lane, Off Pirrie Road, Belfast, BT4 PROPOSAL Amendment to previous approval Z/2000/1588 for a single dwelling - Retrospective

ITEM NO 2 APPLIC NO Z/2005/2247/A PAC NO 2006/A1125 RESULT OF APPEAL Upheld

APPLICANT Arena Advertising LOCATION 61 - 63 Holywood Road, Ballyhackamore, Belfast, BT04 3BA PROPOSAL Display of advertising hoarding (Retrospective) ITEM NO 3 APPLIC NO Z/2005/2600/F PAC NO 2006/A1080 RESULT OF APPEAL Dismissed

APPLICANT Mr P Morgan LOCATION 33 Upper Malone Road, Malone Upper, Belfast, BT09 6TY PROPOSAL Erection of 6 no. apartments. ITEM NO 4 APPLIC NO Z/2006/0500/F PAC NO 2006/A0976 RESULT OF APPEAL Upheld

APPLICANT Mr G Treacy LOCATION 23 Ireton Street, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT07 1LH PROPOSAL Demolition of existing building with retention of front facade and erection of 3 no. HMO flats to include new three storey rear return

ITEM NO 5 APPLIC NO Z/2006/0925/A PAC NO 2006/A1121 RESULT OF APPEAL Upheld

APPLICANT Clear Channel N.I Ltd LOCATION North-west boundary of Park & Ride car park at junction of York Street and York Link, Belfast PROPOSAL 48-sheet display panel

Page 103

APPLICATIONS DEFERRED FROM PREVIOUS MEETING ANDSTILL UNDER CONSIDERATION

APPLIC NO Z/2002/2135/F APPLICANT Mr M McBride LOCATION Land adjacent to Ford Visteon Plant, Finaghy Road North, Belfast, BT11 PROPOSAL Proposed housing development comprising of 44no. townhouses and 12no. semi-detached dwellings (amended plan received). 1 Deferred by Cllr. Maskey under reason 5 - 03/11/05.

APPLIC NO Z/2005/1104/F APPLICANT Hunterswood Properties Ltd

LOCATION Site to rear of 68-74A Ligoniel Road, Ballysillan Lower, Belfast, BT14 8BY PROPOSAL Demolition of existing warehouses and erection of 48 No. residential units. 1 Deferred by Cllr McCausland for office meeting - 10/01/2008.

APPLIC NO Z/2005/1837/F APPLICANT Belfast City Council LOCATION Site of existing football changing pavilion at Strangford Avenue playing fields, Belfast, BT9 PROPOSAL Erection of single storey building N.E. of existing football changing pavilion to provide additional changing and showering facilities. 1 Deferred by TPC for Parks Department to speak to residents - 08/12/05.

APPLIC NO Z/2005/2186/F APPLICANT Mr P Jackson LOCATION 121 Fortwilliam Park, Skegoneill, Belfast, BT15 4AS PROPOSAL Alterations of ground levels to form patio and construction of retaining wall and timber fence to the rear of dwelling (amended plans Page 104

received)

1 Deferred by Cllr McCausland for deputations - 20/09/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2005/2433/F APPLICANT Mr & Mrs Graham APPLIC ADDRESS 110 Malone Road, Belfast, BT9 5HQ LOCATION Land adjacent to 110 Malone Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 5HQ PROPOSAL Erection of dwelling. 1 deferred by Cllr.Maginness - 07/12/06

APPLIC NO Z/2006/0599/O APPLICANT Knock Golf Club LOCATION Land at Knock Golf Club, Upper Newtownards Road, Belfast PROPOSAL Development at Knock Golf course incorporating a residential development (revised scheme) with access to Stoney Road, car parking, formal and informal open space, the retention of a 9-hole golf course and conversion of existing clubhouse to community use

1 Deferred for deputations/office meeting - 21/06/07.

APPLIC NO Z/2006/1845/F APPLICANT Mr C Tilson LOCATION 68 Upper Malone Road, Malone Upper, Belfast, BT09 5PD PROPOSAL Replacement of existing bungalow with new two & half storey dwelling.

1 Deferred by Cllr Hanna for office meeting - 04/10/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2006/2231/DCA APPLICANT Belfast South Methodist Church Page 105

LOCATION Lisburn Road Methodist Church, 238-266 Lisburn Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 6GF PROPOSAL Demolition of church, hall, ancillary accommodation, front gates and railings. 1 Deferred by Cllr Hanna - 17/05/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2006/2332/F APPLICANT Belfast South Methodist Circuit LOCATION Lisburn Road Methodist Church, 238-266 Lisburn Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 6GD PROPOSAL Replacement of existing church and halls with new church and halls.

1 Deferred by Cllr. Hanna - 17/05/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2006/2501/F APPLICANT Mr O' Kane LOCATION 322 Stranmillis Road, Malone Lower, Belfast. BT9 5EB PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of dwelling with vehicular access. 1 Deferred by Cllr McCarthy for office meeting - 22/11/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2006/2715/O APPLICANT Mr R Wilson LOCATION Side garden of 194 Upper Malone Road, Belfast, BT17 9JZ PROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and detached garage.

1 Deferred by Cllr. Hanna - 17-05-2007

APPLIC NO Z/2006/2771/F APPLICANT Charioteer Ltd LOCATION 739-745 Antrim Road, Belfast, BT15 4EL PROPOSAL Demolition of existing buildings and erection of a residential development of Page 106

57 No. apartments with associated landscaping and underground car park (Amended scheme).

1 Deferred for deputations - 04/10/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2006/2878/F APPLICANT Huxely Properties Ltd LOCATION 40,42,44,46,48,50 Park Avenue, Belfast PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwellings and erection of 40 apartments and associated car parking. 1 Deferred by Cllr Long for office meeting - 06/12/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/0117/F APPLICANT Ms D McCartney LOCATION 32 Cardigan Drive, Belfast, BT14 PROPOSAL Change of use of ground floor dwelling to day nursery (first floor to be retained as living accommodation) with associated alterations and erection of two storey extension to rear (amended scheme). 1 Deferred by Cllr Long for office meeting. Cllr Maginness to be informed of any amendments - 20/09/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/0154/F APPLICANT Messrs GML Developments LOCATION Lands at 1-3 Glenhoy Mews, Belfast, BT05 5LH PROPOSAL Construction of sixteen studio apartments with associated soft and hard landscaping. 1 Deferred by Cllr. Wilson for office meeting - 18/10/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/0225/F APPLICANT M&M Property LOCATION 57 Ashley Avenue, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 7BU PROPOSAL Erection of two-and-a-half storey development containing Page 107

3no apartments including demolition of an existing dwelling. (Amended description).

1 Deferred by Cllr Hanna for office meeting - 08/11/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/0279/F APPLICANT North + West Housing LTD LOCATION 13-29 Glenluce Walk, Belfast, BT04 2QR PROPOSAL Erection of 17 dwellings for social housing.

1 Deferred by Cllrs Rodgers and Rodway - 21/06/07.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/0283/F APPLICANT Iconic Developments Ltd LOCATION 8 Castle Park, Ballyaghagan, Belfast, BT15 5FF PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwelling house and erection of 9no two bedroom apartments in two blocks with associated parking and amenity spaces. (Amended Scheme).

1 Deferred by Cllr McCausland for office meeting - 20/09/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/0603/F APPLICANT Mr T Robinson LOCATION 2 Hawthornden Gardens, Ballycloghan, Belfast, BT04 2HF PROPOSAL Proposed third floor rear extension to dwelling and extension to existing garage.

1 Deferred by Cllr.Long for office meeting - 18/10/2007

APPLIC NO Z/2007/0608/F APPLICANT Mr G McCann LOCATION 52 South Parade, Belfast, BT7 2GP PROPOSAL Single storey extension to rear of dwelling with balcony over at first foor level

1 Deferred by Cllr Reilly for office meeting - 06/12/2007. Page 108

APPLIC NO Z/2007/0753/F APPLICANT ABM (NI) Limited LOCATION 1 Henderson Avenue, Skegoneill, Belfast, BT15 5FL PROPOSAL Erection of 2No. commercial units and 4No. apartments (amended scheme).

1 Deferred by Cllr McCausland for office meeting - 10/01/2008.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/0858/F APPLICANT NMC Developments

LOCATION 22 & 22a Fruithill Park, Ballydownfine, Belfast, BT11 8GE PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwellings and erection of 12no apartments and 2no duplex units, with associated car parking and access

1 Deferred by Cllr McCarthy for office meeting - 16/08/2007

APPLIC NO Z/2007/0907/F APPLICANT Mr G Gareth LOCATION Lands to the rear of 120 Eglantine Avenue, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 6EU PROPOSAL Erection of detached 2-storey dwelling to rear.

1 Deferred by Cllr. McCausland for office meeting - 18/10/2007

APPLIC NO Z/2007/0932/F APPLICANT Mr A Williams LOCATION 27 Brookhill Avenue, Town Parks, Belfast, BT14 6BS PROPOSAL Change of use from dwelling to three apartments and erection of two storey rear extension

1 Deferred by Cllr Cobain for office meeting - 20/09/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/0975/F APPLICANT Mr M Gribbon LOCATION 28 Cranmore Gardens, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 6JL Page 109

PROPOSAL Erection of two storey extension to rear of dwelling, two storey detached garage, new boundary wall and alterations to access

1 Deferred by Cllr. Kelly for office meeting. 18/10/2007

APPLIC NO Z/2007/1027/F APPLICANT Mr J Bittles LOCATION 135 Cavehill Road, Skegoneill, Belfast, BT15 5BL PROPOSAL Demolition of garage and erection of 2-storey dwelling attached to existing dwelling. 1 Deferred by Cllr Lavery for office meeting - 06/12/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/1072/F APPLICANT Hagan Homes LTD LOCATION 58-80 (even numbers) Peter's Hill, 77 Brown's Square and 19,21,23 and 25 Gardiner Place, Belfast, BT13 PROPOSAL Erection of 51 apartments and 1 retail unit with associated siteworks and parking (amended scheme).

1 Deferred by Cllr D Dodds for office meeting - 10/01/2008.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/1075/F APPLICANT Mr T Connolly LOCATION 42 Florenceville Avenue, Ballynafoy, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT07 3GZ PROPOSAL Change of use from 2no apartments to 4no apartments including two storey rear extension, roofspace conversion and alterations to existing dwelling. (Amended description) 1 Deferred by Cllr Patterson for office meeting - 08/11/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/1084/F APPLICANT Mr J Gilleece

LOCATION 'Treetops', 50 Antrim Road, Ballygolan, Newtownabbey, Page 110

Northern Ireland, T36 7PL PROPOSAL Erection of 21no. apartments - a block of 9 and a block of 12. 1 Deferred by Cllr Lavery for office meeting - 18/10/2007

APPLIC NO Z/2007/1140/F APPLICANT Dr. D Mc Auley LOCATION 37 Deramore Drive, Malone Lower, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT09 5JS PROPOSAL Demolition of attached garage, erection of two storey side extension and alterations to dwelling.

1 Deferred by Cllr Kelly for office meeting - 22/11/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/1144/F APPLICANT Mr J Smyth T/A Keens LOCATION 163 Templemore Avenue, Ballymacarret, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT05 4FQ PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwelling & proposed 3 storey extension to retail premises for retail use & provision of covered passageway to form new shop front to side elevation. 1 Deferred by Cllrs Empey & Stoker for office meeting - 04/10/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/1207/F APPLICANT T & D Properties

LOCATION 5 Violet Street, Edenderry, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT12 7AN PROPOSAL Two-storey extension and dormer window to rear of dwelling.

1 Deferred by Cllr Attwood for office meeting - 06/12/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/1236/F Page 111

APPLICANT Ms E Mc Cullough LOCATION 50 Manna Grove, Ballyrushboy, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT05 6AJ PROPOSAL Erection of first floor conservatory to rear of dwelling. 1 Deferred by Cllr Wilson for office meeting - 04/10/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/1318/F APPLICANT Connswater Homes LTD LOCATION 36A-38A Park Avenue, Strandtown, Belfast, BT04 1JJ PROPOSAL Demolition of 3 No. existing detached houses and new build development of 24 No. 'lifetime' 3 person 2 bedroom apartments including associated siteworks. (amended drawings) 1 Deferred by Cllr Rodway for office meeting - to be back on next schedule - 06/12/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/1423/F APPLICANT Emo Developments

LOCATION 34 Knightsbridge Park, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 5EA PROPOSAL Erection of two semi-detached dwellings. 1 Deferred by Cllr Patterson for office meeting - 04/10/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/1444/F APPLICANT Messrs G & J Davison & Johnston LOCATION Land adjacent to 2 Epworth Street, Belfast, BT5 4QR PROPOSAL Construction of two storey end terrace dwelling 1 Deferred by Cllr Kyle for office meeting - 22/11/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/1518/F APPLICANT Mr B Morrison LOCATION 1 Northbrook Gardens, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 7EA PROPOSAL Two storey extension to side and rear of dwelling.

Page 112

1 Deferred by Cllr Wilson for office meeting - 18/10/2007

APPLIC NO Z/2007/1598/F APPLICANT Carrmor Developments LOCATION 77 Galwally Avenue, Breda, Belfast, BT08 7AJ PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwelling and construction of one two-storey apartment block to include 4 apartments and one three-storey apartment block to include 6 apartments.

1 Deferred by Cllrs McCarthy and Patterson - 06/12/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/1621/F APPLICANT Mr & Mrs N Boomer LOCATION 23 Norwood Drive, Strandtown, Belfast, BT04 2EA PROPOSAL 2 storey extension to front and side of dwelling, single storey rear extension and rear dormer window.

1 Deferred by Cllr Empey for office meeting - 08/11/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/1719/F APPLICANT Belfast Islamic Centre LOCATION 38 Wellington Park, Malone Lower, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT09 6DN PROPOSAL Extension to form new entrance hall and disabled ramp 1

1 Deferred by Cllr Rodgers for office meeting - 10/01/2008.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/1761/O APPLICANT Mr E McKay LOCATION 12a Knocklofty Park, Strandtown, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT04 3NA PROPOSAL The proposal is for the erection of a detached 2 storey Page 113

dwelling in the side garden of no. 12 Knocklofty Park

1 Deferred by Cllr Rodway for office meeting - 10/01/2008.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/1792/F APPLICANT Lynbourne Developments LOCATION 29-31 Brookhill Avenue, Town Parks, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT14 6BS PROPOSAL Alteration and extension of 2 no.dwellings to form 6 no. self contained apartments.

1 Deferred by Cllr Maginness for office meeting - 22/11/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/1915/F APPLICANT Mc Cullagh & Mc Grath Developments LOCATION Site for 699 and 707 Antrim Road, Low-Wood, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT15 4EH PROPOSAL Additional 2 No. one bedroom apartments to development previously approved under Z/2007/0692/F for 6 No. apartments. (Revised scheme)

1 Deferred by Cllr Cobain for office meeting - 04/10/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/1945/F APPLICANT Broomesdale Investment LOCATION 733, 733a, 733b and 735 Antrim Road, Green Castle, Belfast BT15 4EL PROPOSAL Erection of 3 Apartment buildings comprising 55 units with communal gardens, basement car parking for 61 spaces and 16 surface car parking spaces.

1 Deferred by Cllr Smyth for office meeting - 10/01/2008.

Page 114

APPLIC NO Z/2007/2139/F APPLICANT Mr M Taylor LOCATION 9 Trossachs Park, Ballyfinaghy, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT10 0AX PROPOSAL Two-storey front extension, single-storey side & rear extension, new roofspace accommodation with increased ridge height to dwelling.

1 Deferred by Cllr Rodgers for office meeting - 08/11/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/2197/F APPLICANT Ms D Trew LOCATION 265 Falls Road, Ballymurphy, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT12 6FD PROPOSAL Change of use from terrace dwelling to a coffee shop at ground floor level with a single-storey extension to the rear and 1no apartment on the upper floors (Amended scheme).

1 Deferred by Cllr Hartley for office meeting - 06/12/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/2200/F APPLICANT Mr T Haller LOCATION 18 Willowbank Gardens, Skegoneill, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT15 5AH PROPOSAL Change of use from dwelling to 2no apartments with 2- storey extension to rear.

1 Deferred by Cllr Smyth for office meeting - 08/11/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/2212/F APPLICANT Mr J Devlin Page 115

LOCATION 21 Eglantine Avenue, Malone Lower, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT09 6DW PROPOSAL Conversion from 10 bedroom guest house to 1 no. 2 bed flat and 4 no. 1 bed flats including alteration/extension and replacement store.

1 Deferred by Cllr McCarthy for office meeting - 10/01/2008.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/2267/F APPLICANT J Kabir LOCATION 28 Dunkeld Gardens, Old Park, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT14 6NT PROPOSAL Erection of 2-storey extension to rear of dwelling (amended proposal).

1 Deferred by Cllr Cobain for office meeting - 22/11/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/2460/F APPLICANT Jerlag Properties

LOCATION 1-5 Belmont Road, Strandtown, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT04 2AA PROPOSAL Mixed use redevelopment consisting of ground floor retail and residential above with undercroft car parking and associated works and access.

1 Deferred by Cllr Rodway for office meeting - 10/01/2008.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/2478/F APPLICANT M&M Properties LOCATION 1 & 1a Penrose Street, Malone Lower, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT07 1QX PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwelling (with retention of front facade) and rear store and erection of 3 No. flats.

1 Deferred by Cllr Reilly - to be back on next schedule - 06/12/2007.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/2479/F Page 116

APPLICANT Mrs B Hanif LOCATION 697 Lisburn Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT09 7GU PROPOSAL Change of use to a hot food bar/sandwich bar/cafe with sit in facilities

1 Deferred by Cllr Patterson for office meeting - 10/01/2008.

APPLIC NO Z/2007/2647/F APPLICANT Mr S Mc Cann LOCATION 113 Bloomfield Avenue, Ballyhackamore, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT05 5AB PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of 3 no 1 bed apartments with carparking on street

1 Deferred by Cllr Stoker for office meeting - 10/01/2008.