BEZALEEL WELLS Founder Of
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
BEZALEEL WELLS Founder of CANTON a d STEUBENVILLE, OHIO By EDWARD THORNTON HEALD Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts. Copyright 1948 EDWARD T. HEALD Department of History Western Reserve University May 15, 1942 Canton, Ohio Groshan Graphic Arts Co. 1948 Published by The Stark County Historical Society Canton, Ohio First Edition, 1948 ERRATA Preface p. viii, line 2, "privleges" should be "privileges." Page 12, line 32, "50" should be "500". Page 34, line 1, "1880" should be "1800." Page 35, line 29, "such" should be "much." Page 102, line 6, "purchases" should be "purchasers." Line 25, "his" should be '%im," after giving. Page 109, line 4, "Septembr" should be "September." Page 112, line 9, "writen" should be "written." Page 135, line 33, "Charleston" should be "Charles- town." Page 138, in foot notes 17 and 18, page "55" should be "29." Page 139, in foot note 19, page "189" should be "101," "190" should be "102," "173" should be "91" and "174" should be 92." These page numbers in foot notes 17, 18 and 19 are the pages of the typewritten MSS and were not changed for the new paging of the printed book. Page 162, the word "was" should be inserted at the end of line 20. Page 225, "Dueble" should be "Deuble." The possessive of Wells misspelled on page 69, line 29 page 89, lines 18 and 20: page 99, line 25: page 101, lines 1 and 6: page 107, line 1: page 113, line 30; page 131, line 14; page 140, line 31; page 162, line 15, TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE List of Illustrations and Town Plats -- - -- V Preface - - - - - - - - VII CHAPTER I. Frontier Life in Maryland and Pennsylvania -- 1 II. Settlement of Ohio to 1796 -- --- - 17 III. Founding of Steubenville 1796-1801 - - - - 23 IV. Ohio Constitutional Convention and First Legislature, 1802-1804 - - - - - - - - 43 V. • Founding of Canton, 1805-1809 - - - - 60 VI. Madison, the Town that Foundered, 1806-1814 - - 89 VII. Canton's Founder-Philanthropist, 1809-1814 - - 101 VIII. Canton's Growth in the Rural Scene, 1815-1830 - 113 IX. Steubenville and the Industrial Revolution, 1805-1830 - 134 X. The Merino Wool Capital, 1810-1830 - - - 152 XI. Cultural and Religious Foundations - - - 181 XII. Appraisal - - - - - - - - 188 Bibliography - - - - - - - - - - 195 Appendices - - - - - - - - - - 205 III List of Illustrations and Town Plats Bezaleel Wells - frontis niece Mrs. Sally Wells - - - frontis piece Courtesy of the Western Reserve Historical Society. Photographed by Frick Art Reference Library, New York City. Plat of Steubenville 26 Taken from Jefferson County Deed Record A, p. 274 Plat of Canton - - - - - 70 Taken from Canton Plat Book at the City Hall, Canton. Plat of Madison - 93 Taken from Stark County Indenture Record A, p. 3. Plat of Canton Showing Location of the 150 Lots Given by Bezaleel Wells to the Stark County Commissioners in 1814. Courtesy of the Canton Repository. -- Opp. Page 106 PREFACE The starting point of the research and thesis on Bezaleel Wells was n article by Dr. Louis Wirth in the American Journal of Sociology in j 1y 8-ln-' ba z ation as a Way of Life." It summarized Dr.Wirth's survey of over 300 cities wic~h c1tedirectedor the American Govern- meint. Several of his statements impressed me forcibly, but more than others these two: first, that thus far there had been more research of country life than of the city in America, despite the fact that the greater population and problems are now to be found in the city; and second, that thus far no American city had been adequately researched from its founding to the present time, with suitable interpretation of the various factors that have gone into the development of the city, economic, social, religious, political, and perhaps most important of all, the biographical. This hit a responsive chord. The Y.M.C.A has been the product of the city. No organization has more reason to be vitally concerned about the city than the Young Men's Christian Association. As a professional group Y.M.C.A secretaries can not master their field without knowing their city. Having already lived in Canton ten years, and having come to love the city, as well as being aware of the fact that Canton was generally regarded as a typical American city, were considerations impelling me to take up the reasearch of the city with a view to putting the results into readable form. The research has taken me to the public libraries of Canton, Steuben- ville, Washington, Pennsylvania, Pittsburgh, Baltimore, Philadelphia, Cincinnati, and Cleveland. In Washington, D. C. it extended to the Congressional Library, the Archives Building, and the Division of Sur- verys, Department of Interior. In Pennsylvania it included the Pennsyl- vania Historical Library at Philadelphia and the Western Pennsylvania Historical Society at Pittsburgh. In Baltimore it took me to the Maryland Historical Society, and to first-hand research at St. Thomas Parish, where Miss Catherine Cradock kindly reviewed the first chapter for corrections and suggestions. 1 In Cleveland the Western Reserve University Library and the Library of the Western Reserve Historical Society proved most helpful. In Columbus the State Historical Library, the Supreme Court Law Library, and the Ohio State Archaeological and Historical Museum gave valuable help. In Cincinnati the Ohio Philosophical and Historical Society Library yielded useful material. In Massillon Frank Harrison, Curator of the Museum has been particularly helpful in placing the Horatio Wales manuscripts at my disposal, including about twenty letters between William R. Dickinson, Bezaleel Wells's partner, and Thomas Rotch, and also one letter from Wells to Rotch that is perhaps the most significant new material discovered. At Canton the Law Library in the Court House had a complete set of the Laws of Ohio, as well as a photostat copy of the Journal of the Con- stitutional Convention of 1802, which saved me numerous trips to Co- lumbus, and I wish to acknowledge my grateful thanks to the attorneys 1 Through an oversight the Enoch Pratt Free Public Library of Baltimore was omitted in the thesis list. VII of Canton and to the Librarian, Miss Pauline Weber, for their courtesies in extending the privilges of the library to me. To the Repository I am indebted for the privilege of looking through the microfilmed copies of the Ohio Repository for the years 1815 to 1830, which yielded a wealth of material on the early days of Canton, presenting a difficult problem of selection. Steubenville is less fortunate in surviving newspaper issues, due to ' estruction by fire, but the Library of the Western Reserve Historical ciety contains the files of the Western Herald from 1806 to 1808, in- usive, and of the Western Herald and Steubenville Gazette from August 1830 to December 1833 inclusive. The unpublished diary of the painter Char Christ William Gallwitz of Canton for the period 1820 to 1824 is a classic gem unusually rich in local color, for the perusal of which the writer is indebted to the painter's granddaughter, Mrs. C. W. Fretz, of Canton. Perhaps most fascinating of all was the unfolding of the days of the forgotten merino sheep domain of Wells and Dickinson, in Stark County through the recollections of descendants of the shepherds who tended the flocks of the famous partners. Mrs. Elta Michener, Mrs. Theo- dore Freymark, Mr. Corwin McDowell, and Miss Alice McDowell, all of Canton, were kind and helpful with their information and interest. Present descendants of many of the early families in Canton have likewise been helpful, but too numerous to mention. The disappearance of direct de- scendants of Bezaleel Wells, or of any family collection of letters or documents by him, despite following up many rumors and clues, has made this search most elusive. A few letters have been preserved in the Ohio State Archaeological and Historical Museum at Columbus and in the Archives at Washington, D. C. Of less personal and more laborious character has been the searching of the county records-both in the recorder's office and court records, of Stark, Jefferson, Columbiana and Wayne Counties, Ohio, and of Brooke County, West Virginia, and Wash- ington County, Pennsylvania. I regret that the limitations of time, aggravated by the increased Y.M.C.A executive responsibilities caused by America's entry into the war, have prevented me from finishing numerous lines of research, par- ticularly the tracing of possible letters and documents that might be in the possession of collateral descendants of the Wells family, the identifi- cation of present day land-marks of the Bezaleel Wells period, the records of the federal court in the case leading to the $120,000 judgment against Wells and Dickinson, and confirmation of the facts regarding a loan said to have been made by the government to Wells to build his factory at the time of the War of 1812, and reputed to have been called by the government during the Presidency of Andrew Jackson, thus causing the financial ruin of Wells and Dickinson. The pursuit of this research and writing has been an enjoyable and re- warding hobby. It has been my hope and expectation, if the reception of this study be not too discouraging and expensive, to continue the Canton research up to the present time. My primary interest is in the individuals who have been builders of the city, interpreting their careers in terms of their city, and studying the reaction between leadership and community VIII environment. It is hoped that these more detailed studies will provide the material out of which primers and readers and brief biographies can be written of interest and challenge to school children and young men and women, stimulating them to the cooperative and service attitude with reference to their city, state and nation.