Medicaid Services

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Medicaid Services SUCCESSFUL RURAL HEALTH PROGRAMS IN PERSISTENT POVERTY COUNTIES IN THE SOUTHEAST UNITED STATES By SUSAN WHEATLEY MORFIT A DISSERTATION PRESENTED TO THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF THE UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA 2008 1 © 2008 Susan Wheatley Morfit 2 To my beloved Parents who watch over me, and to my husband who loves and nourishes me. 3 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I thank Leslie Lieberman, my friend and mentor. She has been an inspiration to me since the moment I met her in 1990. We have worked together, laughed together, and cried together. Her enthusiasm and encouragement have been unwavering. Leslie offered me the opportunity and experience to work on collaborative interdisciplinary research projects, where applied anthropology came to life. Many others have guided and supported me through the process of the dissertation. Foremost, members of my committee have generously provided valuable insight and guidance. Dr. Michael Reid, professor at the College of Public Health at University of South Florida and the Office of Rural Health Policy staff were invaluable in aiding my understanding of the political process of health policy at the federal level. Dr. Robert Brehl, a global health systems expert and dear friend, listened when I was confused, offered editorial suggestions when my logic failed me, and championed my work when I needed it the most. Most of all, I thank my husband, Van. Ultimately, this dissertation is a product of my loving husband’s support, guidance, and encouragement. He has endured years of my graduate studies, absences while I was in the field, read all of the early drafts. And for the last stages of the dissertation, he has cooked, cleaned, and taken care of me so that I may finish my degree. And then there are my beloved Irish Wolfhounds . Brenainn, Cearbhall, and Campbell. 4 TABLE OF CONTENTS page ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ...............................................................................................................4 LIST OF TABLES .........................................................................................................................10 LIST OF FIGURES .......................................................................................................................13 ABSTRACT ...................................................................................................................................16 CHAPTER 1 OVERVIEW ...........................................................................................................................17 Introduction .............................................................................................................................17 Statement of the Problem ........................................................................................................17 Theoretical Framework ...........................................................................................................17 Methods ..................................................................................................................................22 Original Ethnographic Policy Project, 1993-1994: Successful Rural Health Programs in Persistent Poverty Counties in the Southeast United States ....................22 Contract research and the PLI research team ...........................................................23 Development of case studies ....................................................................................23 Fieldwork methods ...................................................................................................26 Dissolution of the research team ..............................................................................27 Supplemental Research on Migrant Farmworkers, 1994-1999 .......................................27 Migrant Farmworker Health Centers ...............................................................................27 Archival Research, 2002-2007 ........................................................................................29 Addendum Data, 2008 .....................................................................................................30 Case Study Organization ........................................................................................................30 2 THE RURAL SOUTH: A PROFILE DERIVED FROM FEDERAL POLICIES .................34 Introduction .............................................................................................................................34 Race and Ethnicity and U.S. Policy of Enumeration ..............................................................34 Sociodemographic and Socioeconomic Characteristics of the South .....................................39 Poverty .............................................................................................................................39 Per Capita Income ...........................................................................................................41 Unemployment Rates ......................................................................................................42 Educational Attainment ...................................................................................................42 Access to Health Insurance .............................................................................................43 Health Outcomes 2003-2005 ..................................................................................................44 Mortality Rates, all Causes ..............................................................................................44 Heart Disease Mortality Rates .........................................................................................44 Cancer Mortality Rates ....................................................................................................45 Cerebrovascular Mortality Rates .....................................................................................45 5 Suicide Rates ...................................................................................................................45 Diabetes Mortality Rates .................................................................................................46 3 FEDERAL POLICIES, EXECUTIVE AGENCIES, AND PROGRAMS .............................51 Introduction .............................................................................................................................51 National Forces and the Health Policy Process ......................................................................52 National Legislative Structure .........................................................................................52 Genesis of health initiatives: Illustration from the executive office ........................53 Changing the rules: special interest groups transmuting health care policy ............53 Participatory democracy and policy process ............................................................54 Transmuting health laws through the judicial system ..............................................56 Health Care Policy Implementation: The Department of Health and Human Services ........................................................................................................................57 United States Health Care Payment Structure ........................................................................57 National Policies, National Health Care Programs, and National Health Care Funding .......60 Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services ...................................................................60 Medicare ...................................................................................................................61 Medicaid ...................................................................................................................62 State Children’s Health Insurance Program (SCHIP) .....................................................63 Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) ................................................65 The Office of Rural Health Policy (ORHP) .............................................................65 Bureau of Primary Health Care (BPHC) ..................................................................67 Maternal and Child Health Bureau (MCHB) ...........................................................69 In Summary ............................................................................................................................71 4 BEBÉ SANO ..........................................................................................................................76 Introduction .............................................................................................................................76 Sociodemographic and Socioeconomic Indicators .................................................................78 Selected Catchment Area Sociodemographic Indicators, 1990 ......................................79 Selected Catchment Area Socioeconomic Indicators, 1990 ............................................80 Poverty rate ..............................................................................................................80 Per capita income .....................................................................................................81 Unemployment rate ..................................................................................................81 Educational
Recommended publications
  • William Seraile Email: [email protected] Rank
    William Seraile Email: [email protected] Rank: Professor Emeritus Degrees: B.A. Social Science, Central Washington University, 1963; M.A. Teaching of History, Teachers College, Columbia University, 1967; Ph.d City University of New York, 1977 Awards: Assoc. for the Study of Afro-American Life & History Award for “Unsung Historian,” 1983. Beyond War Award (former Peace Corps Volunteer) 1987. Marcus Garvey Memorial Foundation-Carter G. Woodson-William Leo Hansberry Award for contributions in history, 1989. Lehman College Teacher of the Year, 1991. George N. Shuster Fellowship for academic research, 1991. Central Washington University Outstanding Alumni Award, 2009. Central Washington University Distinguished Alumni Award, 2012. Garfield (Seattle, Washington) high school Hall of Fame inductee, 2013 Books: Angels of Mercy: White Women and the History of New York’s Colored Orphan Asylum, Fordham University Press, 2011 (2013) Bruce Grit: The Black Nationalist Writings of John Edward Bruce, University of Tennessee Press, 2003 (2011) New York’s Black Regiments During the Civil War, Routledge, 2001 Fire In His Heart: Bishop Benjamin Tucker Tanner and the AME Church, University of Tennessee Press, 1998 Voice of Dissent: Theophilus Gould Steward and Black America, University of Tennessee Press, 1991 Articles: (selected) “The Civil War’s Impact on Race Relations in New York State, 1865-1875,” Afro- Americans in New York Life & History, 25:1, January, 2001, 57-89 “Saving Souls on the Frontier: A Chaplain’s Labor,” Montana: The Magazine of Western
    [Show full text]
  • Safundi: the Journal of South African and American Studies
    Peter Cole & Lucien van der Walt Crossing the Color Lines, Crossing the Continents: Comparing the Racial Politics of the IWW in South Africa and the United States, 1905–1925 Safundi: The Journal of South African and American Studies Vol. 12, No. 1, January 2011, 69–96 ABSTRACT In two of the planet’s most highly racialized countries, South Africa and the United States, the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW, or “Wobblies”), were remarkable. A key revolutionary syndicalist current operating globally, aspiring to unite the world's working class into a revolutionary One Big Union against capitalism, the state and economic and social inequality, the Wobblies operated in contexts characterized by white supremacy and deeply divided working classes. Yet they not only condemned racism and segregation in theory, but actively engaged in the challenging work of organizing workers of color including black Africans, African Americans, Asians, Coloureds and Latinos, against both economic exploitation and national/ racial oppression. Although the literature on race, ethnicity, and labour in both countries is voluminous, remarkably little has been written regarding the IWW on race matters. Yet the Wobbly tradition’s impressive commitment and achievements largely unappreciated; the myth that left anti-racism started with Marxist communism in the 1920s remains pervasive. This article develops a comparative analysis of these two IWW experiences, bridging the North/South and industrialized/developing country divides in the (labor) historiography, and deepening our understanding of IWW politics and of labor, race and the left in countries with heterogeneous working classes. Given the centrality of sailors and dockers in the Wobbly movement, particular attention is paid to Philadelphia (US) and Cape Town (SA).
    [Show full text]
  • Pearson on Cole, 'Ben Fletcher: the Life and Times of a Black Wobbly'
    H-Labor Pearson on Cole, 'Ben Fletcher: The Life and Times of a Black Wobbly' Review published on Saturday, June 26, 2021 Peter Cole. Ben Fletcher: The Life and Times of a Black Wobbly. Oakland: PM Press, 2020. 352 pp. $39.49 (cloth), ISBN 978-1-62963-832-4. Reviewed by Chad Pearson (Collin College) Published on H-Labor (June, 2021) Commissioned by David Marquis (The College of William & Mary) Printable Version: https://www.h-net.org/reviews/showpdf.php?id=56652 I have too often heard the following critiques: labor history is simply the study of white men in unions, and labor historians have done a poor job of exploring divisions and identities other than class. These claims ignore more than half a century of “new labor history” scholarship—loads of books and articles by Herbert Gutman, David Montgomery, Jacqueline Jones, Tera Hunter, Joe Trotter, and many others that examine the historical experiences of racially and ethnically diverse working men and women both in and outside of workplaces—that disproves these sorts of statements. Moreover, labor historians such as Theodore W. Allen, Noel Ignatiev, and David Roediger were more responsible for introducing and popularizing “whiteness studies” in the 1990s than any other group of scholars, and one does not need to look far to find the enduring significance of this historiographical intervention. Phrases like “white skin privilege” and “the wages of whiteness” are regularly made in seminar rooms as well as in activist circles. Yet perhaps this overemphasis of white laborers’ racism without properly addressing the ways employers have historically promoted white supremacy, combined with an underappreciation of class struggles across racial and gender lines has harmed the place of labor studies in the academy, leading to the near erasure of the subject in numerous higher educational institutions.
    [Show full text]
  • “Speak out Now When Others Grow Silent”: the Messenger, the IWW and Debates Over New Negro Radicalism
    “Speak out now when others grow silent”: The Messenger, the IWW and debates over New Negro radicalism George Robertson ________________________________________________________________________ “Ere long the country may look forward to full (sic) fledged Negro radicals who will measure up to the standards of modern economic and political radicalism.” Messenger, December 1919. “We have constantly maintained that the solution to the Negro Problem rests with the alliance of Negroes with radical organizations.” Messenger, February 1920. “Negroes and Industrial Workers of the World have interests not only in common, but interests that are identical.” Messenger, October 1919. The social and economic cleavages created during World War I facilitated a world- wide political left-turn, with increasing numbers of workers, both white and black, questioning the political and economic status quo and embracing social movement organizations devoted to the dismantling or overthrow of capitalism. In the United States, one of the most potent symbol and manifestation of this insurgency was the increasingly close relationship between African Americans and white leftist groups.1 The specter of Red- Black cooperation provoked a convergence of racist and anti-radical reactionary forces in the summer of 1919, with angry urban mobs seeking to punish recalcitrant blacks, and J. Edgar Hoover’s Bureau of Intelligence effectively race-baiting and imprisoning radicals of both races. In the context of this pervasive violence and repression at home, and American imperialist intervention abroad, many black radicals argued the need for new thinking, new tactics and new leadership that eschewed liberal reformism, challenged blind patriotism and 1 1 Rod Bush, We Are Not What We Seem: Black Nationalism and Class Struggle in the American Century (New York: New York University Press, 1999), 90.
    [Show full text]
  • Individual Contracts Undercut Equal
    Rebuilding the IWW at NYC campaigns winning, Atom Spies, Horizontalism Armed men break Streetlight shelter but face stiff resistance and IWW history strikes in Philippines 5 7 8-9 10 INDUSTRIAL WORKER OFFICIAL NEWSPAPER O F T H E I N D U S T R I A L W O R K E R S O F T H E W O RLD November 2007 #1701 Vol. 104 No. 11 $1 / £1 / €1 Individual contracts undercut equal pay By Australian Council of Trade Unions The research shows the unfair The pay gap between men and industrial relations laws have women has widened under the Liberal particularly hurt women on AWA Party of Australia government led by individual contracts. Women on AWAs John Howard. Women on Australian only earn 81 cents for every dollar Workplace Agreements (AWA)— earned by men on AWAs. Women individual contracts between worker and on collective agreements fare better, boss—are falling furthest behind. earning 90 cents for every dollar earned Australian Council of Trade Unions by men. (ACTU) President Sharan Burrow “Women on AWAs are earning on revealed the findings of this study at the average $87 less per week than their national conference, Shaping the Future counterparts on collective agreements of Women in Australia, in Sydney on and for part-time women, the difference October 10. can be as much as $140 per week,” said The most recent data shows the gap Burrow. between men's and women’s earnings Australia’s booming economy is has widened in the past three years. also leaving women worse off.
    [Show full text]
  • Global Labour Column
    Global Labour Column https://globallabourcolumn.org | Number 369, February 2021 Black-led, antiracist unionism: Ben Fletcher and the IWW By Peter Cole Benjamin Harrison Fletcher ranks among the greatest African Virginia. In a sense, one might compare the migration of Americans of his generation and the top echelon of Black Fletcher’s parents to Philadelphia as similar to the many Sicilian unionists and radicals in all of US history. In his time, the early immigrants escaping desperate poverty, or to Jews fleeing the 20th century, Fletcher helped lead a groundbreaking union that murderous, anti-Semitic pogroms in Russia. In the working-class quite possibly was the most diverse and integrated organization slums of south Philadelphia, African Americans such as the – not simply union – in an era rampant with racism, anti- Fletchers lived on the same streets as East European Jews and unionism, and xenophobia. Italians, as well as poor and working-class Poles and Lithuanians, Irish and Irish Americans, and others. Although long nicknamed Fletcher and thousands of his fellow Philadelphia dockworkers ‘the City of Brotherly Love,’ Philadelphia was anything but, belonged to Local 8, whose membership was roughly one-third especially for African Americans. Multiple ‘race riots’ had African American, one-third Irish and Irish American, and one occurred in the 19th and early 20th centuries. third European immigrant (particularly Italians, Poles and East European Jews). Chartered in 1913, amidst a successful two- Fletcher was one of the many thousands of young men who week strike that shut down one of the country’s five busiest walked to the Philadelphia waterfront looking for work to ports, Local 8 belonged to the Industrial Workers of the World support themselves and their families, as in port cities across the (IWW).
    [Show full text]
  • Ben Fletcher-Watson Phd Thesis
    “MORE LIKE A POEM THAN A PLAY”: TOWARDS A DRAMATURGY OF PERFORMING ARTS FOR EARLY YEARS Ben Fletcher-Watson A Thesis Submitted for the Degree of PhD at the Royal Conservatoire of Scotland & University of St Andrews 2016 Full metadata for this item is available in Research@StAndrews:FullText at: http://research-repository.st-andrews.ac.uk/ Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: http://hdl.handle.net/10023/8974 This item is protected by original copyright This item is licensed under a Creative Commons Licence “More like a poem than a play”: towards a dramaturgy of performing arts for Early Years Ben Fletcher-Watson PhD in Drama Date of submission: 26/01/2016 © Ben Fletcher-Watson 2016 Abstract This thesis aims to further our understanding of the emergent phenomenon of Theatre for Early Years (TEY) in Scotland. It interrogates a series of artistic practices – traditional, postdramatic, participatory – with the aim of proposing a possible dramaturgy of arts for the very young. Practice typically precedes theory in new fields of performance. TEY currently lacks a coherent theoretical framework or dramaturgy, instead drawing on interdisciplinary strands of psychology, pedagogy and existing dramaturgical practices from older forms of theatre for children. This study explores artists’ embodied knowledge as a repository of skill, while also recognising external factors that impact on creative production, from belief systems to training, the search for funding and the struggle for recognition. Using Grounded Theory as a method to analyse interviews with 26 leading Scottish practitioners, this project undertakes a qualitative investigation of current practice in the devising and production of performing arts for very young audiences.
    [Show full text]
  • Book Reviews 145 Peter Cole, Ben Fletcher
    Book Reviews 145 Peter Cole, Ben Fletcher: The Life and Times of a Black Wobbly, Revised and Expanded 2nd Edition (Oakland, CA: PM Press, 2021). 352 pp. Paperback $24.95. Native-born working-class Black radicalism in the United States during the 1910s- 20s is a challenging object of historical investigation. One approach to this topic is through Harlem, New York, a hotbed of Caribbean-influenced radicalism. Biographies of A. Philip Randolph, for example, provide a window into early experiments there with reading groups, unions, and revolutionary politics. Few industrial cities in the United States had significant numbers of African American workers prior to the First World War, but Philadelphia, Chicago, St. Louis, Pittsburgh, Kansas City, Indianapolis, and Cincinnati have hosted sizable Black populations since at least the turn of the twentieth century. How did politically engaged Black workers outside of Harlem interpret white supremacy, imperialism, capitalism, and the relations between them? How did they organize among themselves, and how did they relate to trade unions, industrial unions, white revolutionaries, and professional African Americans? Peter Cole’s indispensable biographical essay on Ben Fletcher provides fascinating insights into these questions for Black longshore workers in Philadelphia. The essay is followed up with nearly 100 primary-source documents, allowing readers to fully understand Fletcher’s life. Born in Philadelphia in 1890, Fletcher helped lead the powerful Industrial Workers of the World’s Local 8 of the Marine Transport Workers during the 1910s and beyond. About one third of the members were Black, making it one of the most successful attempts by the IWW to attract African American members.
    [Show full text]
  • The Reds and the Wobs Research Paper.Docx
    Michigan State Journal of History Volume 7, 2015 1 Table of Contents Letter from Editor 2 The Death of an Army, the Birth of a Legion 3 Connor McLeod The Reds and the Wobs 22 Duncan Tarr French Africa and the Second World War 46 Caitlin McGee Bleeding Kansas: The Fight for Political Rights 70 Kevin Cunningham The Meiji Restoration: A Transition into a Modern Japan 88 Ali Kalam Essay Submission Policy 102 Staff of the Michigan State Journal of History Editor-in-Chief Kevin Cunningham Board of Editors Renee Brewster Kolt Ewing Nathaniel Medd Design Editor Kevin Cunningham Website Manager Elyse Hansen & Kevin Cunningham Faculty Advisor Dr. Glen Chambers 1 LETTER FROM THE EDITOR My first experience with the undergraduate academic journal was as a freshman History major. The scholarship in the Journal established a realistic standard for academic excellence in my mind. Publishing a piece of scholarship in the MSU Undergraduate Historian was from then on a goal of my collegiate career. Unfortunately, the journal did not continue after the publication of Volume 5 in Spring 2010. As a young, aspiring historian I joined the history club, HAMS, and listened to upper classmen discuss the potential for a future production of the academic journal. This task was not accomplished until the Journal returned from a long hiatus and Volume 6 of the Michigan State Journal of History was published in May 2014. I had the pleasure to serve as an editor and help return the Journal to a functioning state. Since the return of the undergraduate journal there has been a great deal of interest and the academic spirit of undergraduate historians has strengthened and grown at Michigan State University.
    [Show full text]
  • Clara Lemlich Awards for Social Activism
    Work History News New York Labor History Association, Inc. A Bridge Between Past and Present Volume 38 No 2 Summer/Fall 2021 Clara Lemlich awards for social activism By Abbe Nosoff In Praise of Older Women: The Clara Lemlich Awards celebrates these incredible women who changed the world with their activism: Barbara Dane, Suelika Cabrera Drinane, Debby King, Wilhemina Perry, Muriel Tillinghast. The awards event presented via Zoom included inspiring Muriel Tillinghast Barbara Dane Suelika Cabrera Drinane music and speeches hosted by movement organizer. She discussed the struggles of Black people Labor Arts and the Remember the Triangle Fire Coalition, denied their voting rights. What an inspiring and uplifting story supported by the Museum of the City of New York, the Puffin of doing the right thing. She questioned whether this is being Foundation and the 21st Century ILGWU Heritage Fund. echoed today in denying democracy and voting rights. Begun by chanteuse Cara Noel of SEIU 1199 singing “Wind BARBARA DANE, almost 94 years young, regaled us with Beneath My Wings” to call attention to our heroes, these 5 her history as a singer on the picket lines in Detroit. Music activists were honored on May 10. We were further entertained could move people as she played her guitar on the lines. Her by the NYC Labor Chorus singing “The Union Makes Us takeaway to young singers: Don’t stop, keep doing it. We’re Strong/ Solidarity Forever.” listening. Use your voice and music to propel your ideals. We were presented with a short history of the youthful Poetry and music enlightened us all.
    [Show full text]
  • Chad Pearson on Peter Cole
    Peter Cole. Ben Fletcher: The Life and Times of a Black Wobbly. Oakland: PM Press, 2020. 352 pp. $39.49, cloth, ISBN 978-1-62963-832-4. Reviewed by Chad Pearson (Collin College) Published on H-Labor (June, 2021) Commissioned by David Marquis (The College of William & Mary) I have too often heard the following critiques: ways employers have historically promoted white labor history is simply the study of white men in supremacy, combined with an underappreciation unions, and labor historians have done a poor job of class struggles across racial and gender lines of exploring divisions and identities other than has harmed the place of labor studies in the class. These claims ignore more than half a cen‐ academy, leading to the near erasure of the subject tury of “new labor history” scholarship—loads of in numerous higher educational institutions. Sadly, books and articles by Herbert Gutman, David few know about the combative struggles of Black Montgomery, Jacqueline Jones, Tera Hunter, Joe and interracial unions, and most have never Trotter, and many others that examine the histor‐ heard of Ben Fletcher (1890-1949), the influential ical experiences of racially and ethnically diverse and militant African American longshoreman and working men and women both in and outside of proud Industrial Workers of the World (IWW) workplaces—that disproves these sorts of state‐ member. ments. Moreover, labor historians such as Maybe that will change thanks to Peter Cole’s Theodore W. Allen, Noel Ignatiev, and David Roedi‐ wonderful investigative work. Cole, the author of ger were more responsible for introducing and two important books about the intersections of popularizing “whiteness studies” in the 1990s than class and race in the labor movement, has re‐ any other group of scholars, and one does not need cently re-released this edited collection, Ben to look far to find the enduring significance of this Fletcher: The Life and Times of a Black Wobbly, historiographical intervention.
    [Show full text]
  • Download Download
    THE POLITICS OF LABOUR AND RACE IN THE USA B ILL F LETCHER, JR . AND F ERNANDO G APASIN nderstanding the question of race and labour in the USA can be helped by Ureference to a story. In the mid-1700s there was a slave conspiracy in the New York colony. Like many slave conspiracies this was uncovered before it could be hatched. What was unusual about this particular conspiracy was that the rebels were both Africans and Irish. Prior to their execution, the rebels were interviewed and asked about the objectives of the planned uprising. The Africans answered that they sought to kill all the white people. No surprise there. The Irish were interviewed as well. They answered, in turn, to kill all the white people – i.e. Irish people in the Americas had yet to become what we know as ‘white’. The ironic contrast, of course, can be found one hundred years later in the New York 1863 Draft Riots, where Irish immigrants conducted a pogrom/mass lynching targeted at freed Africans, as a way of venting their anger about the Civil War and the unfair draft laws. By the mid-1860s, the Irish were well on their way to becoming ‘white’.1 While the Irish, as Europeans, could become ‘whites’, what is fascinating is that they were not immediately assumed to be white.2 In other words, a process had to unfold in order for the Irish to become white, at least in the manner in which we have come to understand that term. Thus, whiteness, like racial iden- tity in general, must be understood as a socio-political construct rather than anything fundamentally rooted in biology.
    [Show full text]