At Downloaded From

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

At Downloaded From Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.40.219, on 02 Oct 2021 at 05:46:11, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0841820900000333 Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.40.219, on 02 Oct 2021 at 05:46:11, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0841820900000333 C . J . L . J . TABLE OF CONTENTS Sujit Choudhry and Constitutional Theory and Robert Howse The Quebec Secession Reference 143 Nathalie Des Rosiers From Quebec Veto to Quebec Secession: The Evolution of the Supreme Court of Canada on Quebec-Canada Disputes 171 Chaim Gans National Self-Determination: A Sub- and Inter-Statist Conception 185 Will Kymlicka Federalism and Secession: At Home and Abroad 207 Margaret Moore The Ethics of Secession and a Normative Theory of Nationalism 225 Daniel M. Weinstock Toward a Proceduralist Theory of Secession 251 Announcements 265 Faculty of Law University of Western Ontario London, Ontario Canada Volume XIII, Number 2 alis volat propriis July 2000 Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.40.219, on 02 Oct 2021 at 05:46:11, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0841820900000333 Editors Sujit Choudhry (B.Sc, McGill; B.A. (Oxon.); LL.B., Toronto; LL.M., Harvard, 1998) is Assistant Professor at the Faculty of Law P.G. Barton at University of Toronto. His research interests are in constitutional R.N. Bronaugh law and theory (especially comparative constitutional law and fed­ eralism). E-mail: [email protected] Nathalie Des Rosiers (LL.B., Montreal; LL.M., Harvard) is Professor of Law at the University of Western Ontario. Her Consulting Editors research and teaching interests are in constitutional and tort law. She was a member of the Premier's Advisory Committee for the Anne Bayefsky Charlottetown Accord. She recently became President of the Jerome Bickenbach Law Commission of Canada. She has co-authored (with Louise Alan Brudner Langevin) L' indemnisation des victimes de violence sexuelle et Bruce Chapman conjugate, which is now being translated into English. David Dyzenhaus Chaim Gans (LL.B., Jerusalem; B.A., M.A., Tel Aviv; D.Phil., Leslie Green Oxford, 1981) is Associate Professor of Jurisprudence, Faculty of Michael Hartney Law, Tel Aviv University. He is author of Philosophical Anarchism Barry Hoffmaster and Political Disobedience published in 1992 (Cambridge). He is Michael Milde currently completing a book on nationalism (for Cambridge). Dennis M. Patterson E-mail: [email protected] Stephen Perry Robert Howse (B.A., LL.B., Toronto; LL.M., Harvard, 1990) is Denise Reaume Professor of Law at the University of Michigan. He has taught at Arthur Ripstein the University of Toronto, been a visiting professor at Harvard Law Mark Thornton School and at the Academy of European Law of the European Wil Waluchow University Institute, Florence. He most recently co-edited (with Kalypso Nicolaidis) The Federal Vision, forthcoming from Oxford. Will Kymlicka (B.A., Queen's [Canada]; D.Phil., Oxford, 1987) is a Queen's National Scholar at Queen's University, and a recur­ Student Editors rent visiting professor in the Nationalism Studies program at the Central European University in Budapest. He is the author of five Gila Bell books all published by Oxford: Liberalism, Community, and Randall Stephenson Culture (1989), Contemporary Political Philosophy (1990), Multicultural Citizenship (1995), Finding Our Way: Rethinking Ethnocultural Relations in Canada (1998), and Politics in the Vernacular: Nationalism, Multiculturalism and Citizenship (2000). French Language E-mail: [email protected] Editor Margaret Moore (B.A., M.A., University of Western Ontario; Ph.D., London School of Economics, 1989) is Associate Professor Michael Hartney of Political Science at the University of Waterloo. She is the author of Foundations of Liberalism, published by Oxford, and, also with Oxford, forthcoming, The Ethics of Nationalism and edited National Self-determination and Secession published in 1998. Business Manager E-mail: [email protected] Daniel Marc Weinstock (B.A., M.A., McGill; D.Phil., Oxford, Amy Jacob 1991) is Associate Professor, Department of Philosophy, University de Montreal. He has published on issues in liberalism, nationalism, and multiculturalism and is currently working on a project on the normative foundations of institutional choice in multination states. E-mail: [email protected] Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.40.219, on 02 Oct 2021 at 05:46:11, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0841820900000333.
Recommended publications
  • District Name
    District name Name Party name Email Phone Algoma-Manitoulin Michael Mantha New Democratic Party of Ontario [email protected] 1 416 325-1938 Bramalea-Gore-Malton Jagmeet Singh New Democratic Party of Ontario [email protected] 1 416 325-1784 Essex Taras Natyshak New Democratic Party of Ontario [email protected] 1 416 325-0714 Hamilton Centre Andrea Horwath New Democratic Party of Ontario [email protected] 1 416 325-7116 Hamilton East-Stoney Creek Paul Miller New Democratic Party of Ontario [email protected] 1 416 325-0707 Hamilton Mountain Monique Taylor New Democratic Party of Ontario [email protected] 1 416 325-1796 Kenora-Rainy River Sarah Campbell New Democratic Party of Ontario [email protected] 1 416 325-2750 Kitchener-Waterloo Catherine Fife New Democratic Party of Ontario [email protected] 1 416 325-6913 London West Peggy Sattler New Democratic Party of Ontario [email protected] 1 416 325-6908 London-Fanshawe Teresa J. Armstrong New Democratic Party of Ontario [email protected] 1 416 325-1872 Niagara Falls Wayne Gates New Democratic Party of Ontario [email protected] 1 416 212-6102 Nickel Belt France GŽlinas New Democratic Party of Ontario [email protected] 1 416 325-9203 Oshawa Jennifer K. French New Democratic Party of Ontario [email protected] 1 416 325-0117 Parkdale-High Park Cheri DiNovo New Democratic Party of Ontario [email protected] 1 416 325-0244 Timiskaming-Cochrane John Vanthof New Democratic Party of Ontario [email protected] 1 416 325-2000 Timmins-James Bay Gilles Bisson
    [Show full text]
  • Director of Advancement
    Director of Advancement Table of Contents The Opportunity ................................................................................................... 2 About Massey College ......................................................................................... 2 Advancement at Massey College ......................................................................... 5 Key Duties & Responsibilities .............................................................................. 6 Qualifications & Competencies ............................................................................ 6 Massey College Leadership ................................................................................. 7 Organizational Chart ............................................................................................ 9 FOR MORE INFORMATION KCI Search + Talent has been retained to conduct this search on behalf of Massey College. For more information about this opportunity, please contact Tara George, Partner / Lead, KCI Search + Talent, by email at [email protected]. Interested candidates are invited to send a resume and letter of interest to the email address listed above by July 26, 2021. All inquiries and applications will be held in strict confidence. The target hiring salary for this position is $115,000 to $140,000 plus benefits and U of T pension. Massey College is committed to diversity within its community and especially welcomes applications from racialized persons, persons of colour, women, Indigenous People of North America, persons
    [Show full text]
  • Legal Tensions Are Rising
    February 2021 Published since 1940 | Vol.69 No. 9 Legal Tensions Are Rising By Nathalie Des Rosiers and Zoe Sebastien Synopsis The pandemic has imposed a multitude of challenges on democratic societies - including legal ones. The challenges extend to issues at the border but at the core are efforts to ensure that the courts continue to exercise an accountability function and that legal doctrines of Charter compliance and reasonability prevail. This essay identifies and discusses five key legal challenges that have been brought about by COVID-19 which are likely to persist even after the pandemic is conquered. download at thecic.org A CIC publication | thecic.org Nathalie Des Rosiers is Principal of Massey AboutCollege and the the co-editor,Author withs Peter Oliver and Patrick Macklem, of the Oxford Handbook of Canadian International Council the Canadian Constitution (2017). She taught “Pandemics and the Law” at the Faculty of Law, University of Toronto and Trinity College earlier this academic year. Previously, she has President and Research Director / Ben Rowswell been Dean of Law, (Common Law and Droit Civil) at the University of Ottawa, President of Programming Manager / Daniel Lis the Law Commission of Canada and the Operations Manager / Catherine Hume General Counsel to the Canadian Civil Liberties Chair of the Board / William C. Graham Association Copyright 2021 by the Canadian International Council. Zoe Sebastien is a JD candidate at the University of Toronto Faculty of Law and will The opinions expressed in this publication are be articling next year at Osler, Hoskin & those of the author and do not necessarily reflect Harcourt LLP.
    [Show full text]
  • Government Relations Report
    COCA GOVERNMENT What’s COCA Scores Another Win; Bill 108 The make-up of Legislature About to RELATIONS REPORT Inside Addresses Executive Officers in Change Construction Premier’s Poll Numbers Collapsing WSIB Review Underway May 2019 COCA SCORES ANOTHER WIN; BILL 108 ADDRESSES EXECUTIVE OFFICERS IN CONSTRUCTION Bill 108 is titled the “More Homes, More Choice Framework comes into effect on January 1, Act, 2019”. In total it amends 15 statutes. Buried 2010. in the Bill is Schedule 13, which if passed, will Save for these proposed amendments, executive amend the Workplace Safety and Insurance Act. officers would have been assessed at the same It proposes to give the Workplace Safety and premium rates as their construction trades Insurance Board the authority to establish workers. These Bill 108 amendments allow the premium rates for partners and executive WSIB to recognize executive officers in the new officers of construction companies who do not Rate Framework and assess a commensurate perform construction work and who are not premium rate. exposed to the risks of construction work. We are led to believe that the WSIB already has Under the current scenario, construction the policy solution developed, possibly the companies can identify one executive officer creation of another construction class in the who doesn’t perform construction work, who new Rate Framework for executive officers, and is exempt from the compensation system and that the premium rate will be commensurate may have other executive officers who don’t with the risk profile of the class, possibly slightly perform construction work who are classified higher that the current Rate Group 755.
    [Show full text]
  • 2018 Election Liberal Party of Ontario Candidates
    2018 Election Liberal Party of Ontario Candidates NAME RIDING WEBSITE LINK Joe Dickson Ajax [email protected] Naheed Yaqubian Aurora-Oak Ridges- [email protected] Richmond Hill Ann Hoggarth Barrie-Innisfil [email protected] Robert Quaiff Bay of Quinte [email protected] Arthur Potts Beaches-East York [email protected] Safdar Hussain Brampton Centre [email protected] Dr. Parminder Singh Brampton East [email protected] Harinder Malhi Brampton North [email protected] Sukhwant Thethi Brampton South [email protected] Vic Dhillon Brampton West [email protected] Ruby Toor Brantford-Brant [email protected] Francesca Dobbyn Bruce-Grey-Owen Sound [email protected] Eleanor McMahon Burlington [email protected] Kathryn McGarry Cambridge [email protected] Theresa Qadri Carleton [email protected] Margaret Schleier Stahl Chatham-Kent-Leamington [email protected] Cristina Martins Davenport [email protected] Michael Coteau Don Valley East [email protected] Shelley Carroll Don Valley North [email protected] Kathleen Wynne Don Valley West [email protected] Bob Gordanier Dufferin-Caledon [email protected] Granville Anderson Durham [email protected] 1 | P a g e NAME RIDING WEBSITE LINK Mike Colle Eglinton-Lawrence [email protected] Carlie Forsythe
    [Show full text]
  • Ontario Election 2018 Platform Guide
    ONTARIO ELECTION 2018 PLATFORM GUIDE Where the parties stand on everything from hydro bills to taxes to transit PLUS: PAUL WELLS ON THE PROBLEM WITH PARTY PROMISES & PROFILES OF THE LEADERS CONTENTS Introduction PLATFORM PRIMERS DEFICITS WORK AND TAXES HYDRO HEALTH CARE DRUGS AND ALCOHOL EDUCATION ENVIRONMENT AND ENERGY TRANSPORTATION FEATURES Paul Wells on the problem with party promises Kathleen Wynne feels your pain Are you ready for Premier Ford? How far can Horwath go? lection day in Ontario—June 7—is fast approaching, and voters face a stark Echoice in the three main candidates. Kathleen Wynne and the governing Liber- als are campaigning on the record of their 15 years in office and a budget plan that calls for a massive expansion of government spending and deficits. Andrea Horwath is taking the Ontario NDP into her third elec- tion as party leader by presenting the NDP as the real progressive choice for voters. Meanwhile Doug Ford, the newly-minted and maverick head of the Ontario Progres- sive Conservative Party hopes to harness taxpayer outrage to propel his party to victory. Yet sifting through the platforms to find where the parties stand on key issues can be daunting. To make that task easier, Maclean’s has assembled this platform cheat sheet. Visit Macleans.ca/Ontario2018 for updates. NOTE: Much of the Liberal platform comes from the 2018 Ontario budget, while the NDP have posted their platform online. However, large parts of the Ontario PCs platform remain unknown since the party has not indicated which parts of former leader Patrick Brown’s People’s Guarantee platform are being retained.
    [Show full text]
  • Collard Wins in Ottawa-Vanier
    Check with the organizers if events are still on. Vérifiez auprès des organisateurs si leurs évènements ont toujours lieu. MARS / MARCH 2020 VOL. 17, N04 Collard Wins in Ottawa-Vanier Family Day Ontario Liberal candidate Lucille Collard Winter byelection collectively received 450 votes or 2.26%. won the Ottawa-Vanier byelection held Page 10 February 27, 2020. This win combined “I discovered during the campaign that * Percentages are rounded to the nearest with Stephen Blais’s who was the Ontario bad weather doesn’t really exist. Only two decimals. Liberal candidate in Orleans made wrong choices of winter clothing and interim Liberal Leader John Fraser boast accessories to deal with weather condi- With 100,190 registered electors on the that “We are going to trade in our mini- tions,” said Lucille Collard. list only 19.89% of them voted. van and buy something bigger.” Winter conditions did have an impact on The byelections were necessary af- With 124 seats in the Ontario legislature, the voter turnout. ter former MPP’s Nathalie Des Rosiers here is the scorecard after both Liberal and Marie-France Laonde both step- wins: Progressive-Conservative with 73 Results Ottawa-Vanier ped down in 2019. Nathalie des Rosiers seats; NDP with 40; Liberal with 8 and decided to make a professional move one Green Party MPP. Lucille Collard (Lib.) and started working for the University 10,404 votes or 52.22% of Toronto while Marie-France Lalonde “I want to recognize the incredible Myriam Djilane (NDP) now represents a federal riding since the work of a small executive team that 5,031 votes or 25.25% October 2019 election.
    [Show full text]
  • The Regional Municipality of Durham COUNCIL INFORMATION PACKAGE March 9, 2018
    If this information is required in an accessible format, please contact 1-800-372-1102 ext. 2097. The Regional Municipality of Durham COUNCIL INFORMATION PACKAGE March 9, 2018 Information Reports 2018-INFO-40 Commissioner of Planning and Economic Development – re: Durham Tourism E-Newsletter- March 2018 2018-INFO-41 Director of Emergency Management – re: Provincial Nuclear Emergency Response Plan (PNERP) – Update 2018-INFO-42 Commissioner of Planning and Economic Development – re: Durham Climate Change Symposium 2018-INFO-43 Commissioner of Planning and Economic Development – re: The Region of Durham Business Count (Employment Survey) 2018 2018-INFO-44 Commissioner of Works – re: Strategic Road Safety Action Plan for the Regional Municipality of Durham Early Release Reports 2018-COW-** Commissioner of Planning and Economic Development – re: Public Meeting Report Proposed Regional Official Plan Amendment – Implementation of Key Transportation Network Changes Recommended in the Transportation Master Plan, File: OPA 2018-002 Modification to the Durham Regional Official Plan to Resolve Deferral 7 Early release reports will be considered at the April 4, 2018 Committee of the Whole meeting. Staff Correspondence 1. Memorandum from Roger Anderson, Regional Chair and CEO, Regional Municipality of Durham - re: Certificate proclaiming the week of March 18-24, 2018, as Canada Water Week in Durham Region Council Information Package March 9, 2018 Page 2 of 2 Durham Municipalities Correspondence 1. City of Oshawa and Municipality of Clarington – re: Correspondence to Andrea Horwath, MPP, Leader, New Democratic Party of Ontario, Vic Fedeli, Leader, Progressive Conservative Party of Ontario, Mike Schreiner, Leader, Green Party of Ontario, and Kathleen Wynne, Leader, Ontario Liberal Party regarding Ontario Expanding GO Rail Service 2.
    [Show full text]
  • Queen's Park Notes
    Queen’s Park notes FOLLOW US @Mobilepk For the week of February 21–24, 2017 After a two-month winter recess, the Ontario Legislature resumed with Premier Kathleen Wynne’s Liberals facing continued pressure on hydro-electric prices. Since her mea culpa late last year that she “took her eyes of the ball” on hydro-electric prices, Premier Wynne promised to focus her energies on this file and to make hydro more affordable for Ontarians. In the Legislature’s first week back, the opposition parties wasted no time and effort in making sure that the political heat was kept on the Liberals, with Question Period being dominated by this topic. NEW BILLS INTRODUCED BILL 91, STOPPING ELECTRICITY beyond their current expiry date. The previous DISCONNECTIONS IN THE WINTER ACT, legislation did not allow for collective 2017 agreements to be extended. Despite the In their effort to embarrass the Liberals Minister’s praise for her new bill, two on hydro-electric prices and the cut-off of education unions, OSSTF/FEESO and CUPE, customers who could not pay their bills, PC argued that the new bill does not help the MPP Todd Smith (Prince Edward—Hastings) process, In fact, OSSTF/FEESO says that the brought a bill forward to stop cut-offs. Minister did not consider any of its proposed amendments. BILL 92, SCHOOL BOARDS COLLECTIVE BARGAINING AMENDMENT ACT, 2017 BILL 93, GASOLINE TAX FAIRNESS FOR ALL Education Minister Mitzie Hunter ACT, 2017 (Scarborough— Guildwood) introduced this PC MPP John Yakabuski (Renfrew— bill that would amend the previous legislation Nipissing—Pembroke) introduced a bill that regarding collective bargaining in the would help municipalities recover a portion of education-sector.
    [Show full text]
  • Nathalie Des Rosiers CV English
    CURRICULUM VITAE Nathalie DES ROSIERS O.C., O.O., F.R.S.C., L.S.M. EXPERIENCE: Principal, Massey College (2019 - …) MPP, Ottawa-Vanier (2016 – 2019) Minister of Natural Resources and Forestry, (Jan 2018 – June 2018) Parliamentary Assistant – Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs (2017-2018) Parliamentary Assistant – Minister of Energy (2017 -2018) Parliamentary Assistant – Minister of Women’s Issues (2016 – 2017) Parliamentary Assistant – Minister of Housing (2016 – 2017) Dean, Faculty of Law, Common Law Section, 2013 – 2016 General Counsel, Canadian Civil Liberties Association, 2009 – 2013 Vice-President – Governance , University of Ottawa, 2008-2009 Dean, Faculty of Law, Civil Law Section, 2004- 2008 President, Law Commission of Canada, 2000-2004 (Vice-President 1997 -2000) Professor, Faculty of Law, University of Western Ontario, 1987-2001 Full Professor, 2000 Associate, 1993 Lerner & Associates, 1984-1987 Supreme Court of Canada – Law Clerk to Justice J. Chouinard, 1982-1983 Ogilvy, Renaud (now Norton Rose Fulbright), 1981-1982 INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT: Expert – Ministère de la justice, Programme de réforme judiciaire, Mali (2006) (CIDA funded project) Expert - PIAP, Comité des affaires sociales de l’Assemblée nationale du Vietnam – Loi sur l’égalité entre les sexes, Gender Equality Act (2006) Expert – Bengladesh – Law Reform Commissions (funded by Department of Justice – Canada, 2003) Nathalie DES ROSIERS PART-TIME OR VOLUNTEER CONTRIBUTIONS: Elections Web Commentator CTV News (2019) Member of Rhodes Scholars Selection Committee
    [Show full text]
  • 2018 Ontario Candidates List May 8.Xlsx
    Riding Ajax Joe Dickson ‐ @MPPJoeDickson Rod Phillips ‐ @RodPhillips01 Algoma ‐ Manitoulin Jib Turner ‐ @JibTurnerPC Michael Mantha ‐ @ M_Mantha Aurora ‐ Oak Ridges ‐ Richmond Hill Naheed Yaqubian ‐ @yaqubian Michael Parsa ‐ @MichaelParsa Barrie‐Innisfil Ann Hoggarth ‐ @AnnHoggarthMPP Andrea Khanjin ‐ @Andrea_Khanjin Pekka Reinio ‐ @BI_NDP Barrie ‐ Springwater ‐ Oro‐Medonte Jeff Kerk ‐ @jeffkerk Doug Downey ‐ @douglasdowney Bay of Quinte Robert Quaiff ‐ @RQuaiff Todd Smith ‐ @ToddSmithPC Joanne Belanger ‐ No social media. Beaches ‐ East York Arthur Potts ‐ @apottsBEY Sarah Mallo ‐ @sarah_mallo Rima Berns‐McGown ‐ @beyrima Brampton Centre Harjit Jaswal ‐ @harjitjaswal Sara Singh ‐ @SaraSinghNDP Brampton East Parminder Singh ‐ @parmindersingh Simmer Sandhu ‐ @simmer_sandhu Gurratan Singh ‐ @GurratanSingh Brampton North Harinder Malhi ‐ @Harindermalhi Brampton South Sukhwant Thethi ‐ @SukhwantThethi Prabmeet Sarkaria ‐ @PrabSarkaria Brampton West Vic Dhillon ‐ @VoteVicDhillon Amarjot Singh Sandhu ‐ @sandhuamarjot1 Brantford ‐ Brant Ruby Toor ‐ @RubyToor Will Bouma ‐ @WillBoumaBrant Alex Felsky ‐ @alexfelsky Bruce ‐ Grey ‐ Owen Sound Francesca Dobbyn ‐ @Francesca__ah_ Bill Walker ‐ @billwalkermpp Karen Gventer ‐ @KarenGventerNDP Burlington Eleanor McMahon ‐@EMcMahonBurl Jane McKenna ‐ @janemckennapc Cambridge Kathryn McGarry ‐ Kathryn_McGarry Belinda Karahalios ‐ @MrsBelindaK Marjorie Knight ‐ @KnightmjaKnight Carleton Theresa Qadri ‐ @TheresaQadri Goldie Ghamari ‐ @gghamari Chatham‐Kent ‐ Leamington Rick Nicholls ‐ @RickNichollsCKL Jordan
    [Show full text]
  • Connectionconnection
    A magazine for alumni and friends of vox communitatis|2003 TheThe “down“down under”under” connectionconnection JoeJoe Arvay,Arvay, humanhuman rightsrights championchampion BuildingBuilding CampaignCampaign receivesreceives $1$1 millionmillion boostboost DennisDennis O’ConnorO’Connor honouredhonoured [ Contents ] Features A PLUMBER WITH WORDS ...................................................................... 10 Joe Arvay uses the Charter as a tool to advance human rights LEARNING “DOWN UNDER” .................................................................... 14 Western Law has forged strong academic ties with Australia and New Zealand THE JANUARY TERM ................................................................................ 17 Simon Evans, University of Melbourne, describes his month-long stay at Western Law HONORARY DOCTORATE FOR CHIEF JUSTICE O’CONNOR..................... 18 Former Western Law professor is honoured at convocation NEVER A DULL MOMENT ......................................................................... 20 In an anything-but-conventional career, Ron Atkey has found a way to combine his many interests INFORMATION & TECHNOLOGY LAW AT WESTERN ............................... 23 Q&A with Professor Margaret Ann Wilkinson JUDGE-IN-RESIDENCE ............................................................................. 25 Madame Justice Lynne Leitch reflects upon her year at Western Law FINAL ARGUMENT .................................................................................... 47 Democratic Deficit: Is it
    [Show full text]