181 Electlon of Deputy Speaker ASADHA 21, 1918 (Sake) Felicitations to Depuly Speaker 182

[English] The question is , SHRl JAG MOHAN (New ) : Sir, I second "That Shri Suraj Bhan, a Member of this the Motlon. House, be chosen as the Deputy-Speaker of this House" SARDAR SURJIT SlNGH BARNALA (Sangrur) : Gir, I beg to move : The Motron was adopted "That Shri Suraj Bhan, a Member of this MR SPEAKER . I declare that Shrl Suraj Bhan House, be chosen as the Deputy-Speaker of has been chosen as the Deputy Speaker of this this House.' House. SHRl MADHUKAR SARPOTDAR (Mumbai North. 12.33 hrr. West) : Sir, I second the Motion. (Shrl Suraj Bhan was conducted to h~sseat by SHRI GEORGE FERNANDES (Nalanda) . Sir, I the Prime Mtn~ster.Shrr H.0 Deve Gowda, the Leader beg to move : of the House Shrt Ram Vilas Paswan, the Leader of the Oppos~tlon.Shr~ and Shri "That Shrl Suraj Bhan, a Mcmber of th~s Santosh Mohan Dev House, be chosen as the Deputy-Speaker of this House."

SHRI NlTlSH KUMAR (Barh) : Sir, I second the 12.34 hrr. Motlon. FELICITATIONS TO DEPUTY SPEAKER [Translation] THE MINISTER OF RAILWAYS (SHRI RAM VlLAS SHRI JAI PRAKASH (Hlssar) Mr Speaker, Sir, PASWAN] Mr Speaker. Slr as the leader of the I beg to move House, I on behalf of the House. thank and "That Shr~Suraj Bhan a member of th~s congratulate Shr~Suraj Bhan, who IS a Senior House, be chosen as the Deputy Speaker of Member of the and IS l~kemy brother, for th~sHouse.' havlng been the post of Deputy Speaker Thls IS the democracy that desplte all d~tferences,we have SHRI 0 P JINDAL (Kurukshetra) Mr Speaker, always been respectful to the conventions and Sir I second the Motion demands of democracy and have expressed our faith In Parl~amentarydemocracy The day Shri Suraj Bhan was nominated for the post of Deputy Speaker and SHRI SANTOSH KUMAR GANGWAR (Bareilly) as soon as my colleague, the M~nlster of Str I beg to move Parl~amentaryAffa~rs. Shri Jena suggested h~sname + to the Pr~meMlnlster, lmmod~atelythe Pr~meMinister "That Shr~Suraj Bhan. a Member of th~s had expressed his satlsfactlon over it and said that House, be chosen as the Deputy Speaker of th~sIS very good and should be done. thls House" We have had a long standing assoclatlon In [Translatron) 1977 when I f~rstjomed the Parhamen!, Shr~Surrj Bhan was an experienced member even at that time DR SATYANARAYAN JATlA (Ujla~n) Slr, I We gct an opportunlty to work together We were second the Mot~onon behalf of Shrl Jagat Vlr Smgh members of Committee on the Welfare of Scheduled Drona Castes and Scheduled Trlbes Aga~nwe worked together In the Parl~amentaryForum and wherever SHRI CHANDRA SHEKHAR (Ballla) Slr l beg atrocrties wer comm~ttedon the poor, we went to move - there together and worked for them Even when he 'That Shrl Sural Bhan, a Memher of 1h1s was not an elected M P, the way he handled tho House, be chosen as the Deputy Speaker ol work In the states was commendable It IS not th~rHouse' because he belongs to the Scheduled Caste but I have seen that Shrt Sural Bhan jl IS well-endowed JE npllsh, w~thwhat we call talent He 1s a very talented person He is M A B L He goes deep In the subject whatever SHRl PRAMOD MAHAJAN (Mumbai Notlh-East) ~t may be Shri Suraj Bhan 1s a very capable person Slr, I recond the Motlon tn th~sregard He IS a lawyer by protesslon and ts MR. SPEAKER . Since Ihrre rrr r number of well known as a soc~alactlvtst I belleve that tho Motlona moved, I will put the fcrrt Mollon moved by emlnence of thsi post will rlso further when he takes Shrl Shrrrd Prwrr to the vote of the House charge end on behalf of the Qovrrnment and the

185 Felrcitalions to Deputy Speaker ASADHA 21, 1918 (SaW Febotatrons to Deputy Speaker 186 played a very useful role. Like Shri Shivraj Patil who time to know each of them personally, but when will always be remembered as a very good Speaker, names will be known, then I tully hope that new we remember and miss today Shri Mallikarjunalah members w~llget opportunity to raise the~rissues who was a very good Deputy-Speader. I am sure and they w~llb glven adequate opportunities Shri Suraj Bhan will also prove to be a very good I congratulare Shrl Surajbhanji on my behalf and Deputy-Speaker. I am sure Shri Suraj Bhan will follow on behalf of my party and hope that he will do good his policy, his decis~onsand h~swisdom. He has thlngs commensurate w~ththe post of Deputy seen what the Zero Hour 1s. I wish him all the best Speaker of Lok Sabha and do hope that he will get [Translation] opportunltles to do good thlngs In future. SARDAR SURJIT SlNGH BARNALA (Sangrur) SHRl BASU DEB ACHARIA (Bankura) : Mr Mr Speaker. Sir I feel very happy on the unanimous Speaker, Slr, I would like to congratulate Shri Suraj elect~onof Shr~Sura! Bhan today, and I congratulate Bhan as he is being elected unanimously today for him Earl~eryou were also elected unan~mously.Now the olfice of the Deputy Speaker I am very happy he has been elected In the same manner. It IS a that today such a member who has vast experience good trad~tlonthat IS be~ngestabl~shed in the House and who is an active person, has been elected lor After t11s unanlrnous elect~on,ent~:e House expects this post He IS known to us since 1980. when he him to be ~rr~part~alEveryone would be treated was elected tor the f~rstlime for the Seventh Lok equally by him Every Member has such expectations Sabha He 1s aware as to how the problems of tbe 'ro~h~m Just as ycu preslde over the House, we general people of the country have to be raised In expect the same frsrr~hrm also Lok Sabha He dSed to ralse serlous issue in the House as per procedure At present aboul hal! of Shrl Suraj Bhan has been a Member of thls House the strength of Lok Sabha 1s of new members 3f earlier also Thsi trne he has been elected for the course, they would like to ralse here the probierns fourth 11me He was a Member along wi!h me In 01 the~rrespectwe const~tuenc~esWe hope !ha! Sr;:l 1977 He is a very sober person He welghs every Sura] Bhan will be lmpartlal Thus our convenllon word befcre speaking He never talk unnecessarily w~llbe maintained and the dign~tyof this House hi11 be !aiks less Urllke you re seldom laughs In this further be crPengthened after h~sele;!~on for the connec!~on we cerlalely t,ave a minor complaint offlce of De,.,~ty Speaker Our party will glve lull against him cooperatron lo him We hope that you w~llsafeguard I now hlm also because he IS my nelghbourer the cclnvent~onof this House I conclude my speech He belongs to Ambala Therefore I know hls private with areetlng Shrl Suraj Bhan Irfe a;so T~ISIS h~sfoilrth term In thls House HIS SHRl MADHUKAR SARPOTDAR (Mumbal Nc:th. present mater~al~s:~cccndlt~on remalns the same as West) Mr Speaker SI~today I feel happy tr~atMr 11 was when he was eiected Member of this House Surajbhan who has gct fa~lhIn Maryada Purosotham for the first time l think that I! 1s a great qual~tythat ',as become the Deputy Speaker o' :fils House We a person even a!ter be~ngere-' &,ed~ Member for the are v,>re lub~l~antLecause the erit~re Hoi~sehas !;li:lt: t~rr,e remains uncnanged-s pie and honest elected h~m I mean he is the unanimous ch3i:e o! Sucr is h~squality his style ot w~rkingand his the ent~reHouse MI Speaker Srr, you were also decency !ha! not only the people of the Backward clocted in the same way I fully hope Ihat the Hcuse Classes but everyone has falth In hlm will functron properly w~ttibcth of you at !he helm o! I feel happy that he has been elected affairs May be that we will fight among ourselves unanlm~usly I expect h~mto work In the House because of our problems trgt wh~leyou are pres~dlng cheerlully and treat every Member equally WI~P we expect lust~cefrom you and a balanced think~~g Irnniense ;ongratula!ions. I take rhy seal Whatever is our prohlenl is a problem ol our people SHRl GEORGE FERNANDES (Naland?.) Mr Mr Surajban w~llrun tti~sHouse In the same w~yas Speaker, Sir I rlse to congratulate Shri Sura] Bhan you run the House Irr order to reach Ihe common I recall my experionce of the Fourlh LC.. Sabha At man end w~llIry to runder lustice to our cause When that tme Shri Raghunath Rao Khandelkar was the celled lor More than th~s 287 new members have Speaker During those days we used to Walt for the been elected here th~st~me 7 here is a r!eed to take moment when Mr Speaker would leave the Chalr care 01 them all What I see 1s that the niembbrs hera and Deputy Speaker would occupy the Charr The !ell tempted lo rats@the11 issues but they do no! gel reason for th~swas because the :)pporlun~tyto this effect Gradually they will gel 1h1s Speaker has got vast powers and once he says 'no means we cannot opportunity As the dnys PASS !!ley w~llgel opportuw say anything after that It has been notlced that how to rnlse niatlers much light hearted he may be how much soclable he may be but once he sils on the Chaw we have to he afrald of hlnl but when the Deputy Speaker usell 10 s11 on the same Cha~r,we used to raise 187 ' Felicitations to Deputy Speaker JULY 12, 1996 Fellclfaflons to Deputy Speaker 188 those issues promptely that could not be raised in the Members in thls House, Ilkewise, I hope, there the morning. Though there was nothing like Zero are aspirations that Suraj Bhan Jl would also Hour, but after lunch, the same process continued to appreciate the urges and feelings of the Members be there for half an hour. With the Deputy Speaker who represent the under-privileged and deprived in the Chair, we used to feel very easy in raking section of the society. Issues related to our areas. 13.00 hrr. I am recalling that. Just now Shri Santosh Mohan Dev has mentioned the name of the former Deputy I am sure that he would offer opportunities to all Speaker, Shri Mallikarjunnaiah. He also managed to irrespective of political persuasions and beliefs. I dispose the business of the House properly and think his contribution will further strengthen the efficiently. glorious traditions of this House and create new Though, today he is not a Member of this House conventions and create new perceptions about the but I hope that he will return soon to this House and functioning of this House. the entire House will get his contribution. I expect Sir, I join all of our colleagues in congratulating from Shri Suraj Bhan that he will maintain the dignity hlm on my behalf and on behalf of my party. of the office of the Deputy Speaker for which he has MR. SPEAKER : It is one o'clock now. With the been elected unanimously and will glve his permission of the House, we will dispose of thls contribution to run the business ot the House item. Shri 0.0.Swell. properly. SHRl PRAMOTHES MUKHERJEE (Berhampore): (Interruptions) Mr. Speaker, Sir, I welcome the spirit of unanimity in MR. SPEAKER : I will come to you, do not worry respect of elect~onto the Chair ot Deputy Speaker. Everybody will get a chance. On behalf of my Party, RSP, I rise to welcome Shri Suraj Bhan. I express my pleasure and greetings, SHRl G.G SWELL (Shillong) . Mr Speaker, I am and I believe that his elevation to the Chalr of Deputy delighted that Shri Sura] Bhan has been elected to Speaker will add to the glory of this House. the h~ghoffice of the Deputy-Speaker He has been a friend of long standlng SHRl GEETA MUKHERJEE (Panskura) : Sir, I also join all my hon. colleagues In expressing our Many many years ago when we were joy at the unanimous election of Suraj Bhan Ji About younger, we travelled this country together There his ability, much has already been said, with which was never more of a gentleman than Shrl Sura] Bhan, I fully agree. Coming from the backward section, I there was never a warmer friend, there was never a am sure that as Deputy Speaker. he will not only more courteous person and what I liked about hlm show care for every Member but will also show care most was h~sd~sarm~ng smde Ever since, whenever particularly for women who are also among the we met, whether he was the Member of thls House backward sections. or whether I was a Member of thls House, he had always received me wlth warmuers I am sure that Sir, I also join my friends who have expressed this personal~ty of his will emanate and Imbue the their appreciation of Mallikarjunaiahji. He also had spirit of this House I have no doubt that he will do all these qualities. I am sure, Suraj Bhan JI will add h1s duty as well as efflclently as you have done and to the glory of this high position. With these words, I am sure that his dlsarmlng smile will disarm many I wlsh hlm all success to his Deputy Speakership. of US even when we are seued with temper over SHRl CHITTA BASU (Barasat) : Slr, I join the varlous ISSUBS distinguished colleagues of mine In thls House to congratulate Shri Sura] Bhan JI on this auspicrous I w~shhlm well and as far a8 I am concerned, 1 occasion of being unan~mouslyelected as the Deputy will glve hlm all the support and cooperrlion that he Speaker of this august House Sir, he is an old friend needs In order to run thls House properly just as I of mine. Not only I appreciate hls frlendshlp but also have been glvlng you the same support and the cause he f~ghtsfor He belongs to the Scheduled cooperallon The dlgnlty and the authority of the Caste communlty and he has always been articulate Chalr must be upheld at all timen In order that thls In ralslng the Issues whlch atfllct his communlty House will run to order, Broadly speaking. he IS very aRlculate In ra161ngthe SHRI E AHAMED (Manjeri) . I asroclate mynelf issues whlch relate to the under.prlvileged, the with the sent~mentsexprerred in tel~cltatlngthe deprlved and the lowes! of the low Th~s1s the new Deputy-Speaker by the leaderr ol Ihe Housr and I tlme whlch demands that those volces and hearts avail of th~sopportunity on my behall rr well a6 on should be heard earlier and heard wllh sympathy behalf of my party, the lndlan Unlon Murlim League and perception Therefore, I lee1 when tle rlts there, to congralulatr Shri Suraj Bhan for havlng barn he 18 a powerful as you are Sir as you have shown elected unanimously an !he Deputy-Speaker of the your ability or capaclty to understand the leolmgr of House 189 FoNcllatlons fo Deputy Sprrkrr ASADHA 21, I918 (Saka) Fehcrtat~ons to Deputy Speakrr 1 90

Llke you, Mr. Speaker Slr, the former Speaker Speaker, Shri Suraj Bhan, who in known to all of us and the Deputy-Speaker were a180 very much He is a man of great character, a man of great sensitive to the issues ralsod here, especially for the principles, a man who could ~mplementhis princ~ples down trodden, particularly of the mlnority and a person who has been working for a long c~mmunitiesand I am sure that Shri Sura) Bhan - number of years for the poor and the downtrodden. though I did have the opportunlty lo know him, our I congratulate h~mon th~soccasion. acquaintance with hlm is limited will a180 follow - I would like to add one more point. The job of a the footsteps of his predecessor8 as well a8 you, Mr. pereon, who slts In the Chair. at a time when the Speaker teiev~sionis always looking on us in this electronic I may also remind him of his predecessor Shrl medla, 1s golng to be very tough. The people have Mallikarjunaiah. He had conducted the House with seen the llve telecast of two Motions whlch we had great dignity without fear or favour and also with recently There IS a feel~ngamongst the people of affect~onand w~thoutill-w~ll to any of the Members that th~sHouse, whlle transacting business, is I am sure, that Shri Suraj Bhan wlll alro follow much always going beyond the iimlts when the Members more than that Shr~Mallikarpnaiah had done* are shoutlng at each other or when the Members are On thls occasion, I extend all the cooperatlon to rlslng above the l~mitswhlch are expected from the Shri Suraj Bhan and I am sure that he will a180 take Members of Parl~ament every member, especially the smaller partles into Slr. I thlnk th~sis golng to be a very great duty the active consideration In tho d~sposalof the which the person who sits on the Cha~rwill have to functions as the Deputy-Speaker. take up and we assure the Deputy Speaker, as I wish him all success in h~snew assignment Chalrman ol th~sHouse when he presides over. all ,A our suppon and we also felrc~tatohim for his glorious [Translation] olect~onIn the most bef~ttlngmanner by all sides SHql JAI PRAKASH (Hlssar) Mr Speaker Sir, together at the outset I would like to thank all the Members So, I also join on lh~sonerous occaslon to thank of thls House lor follow~ngthe heallhy democrat~c P1lm and to thank the House convenllon of electing Shrl Suraj Bhan as Depu!y Speaker unanimously Though Shr~Suraj Bhan DR PRABIN CHANDRA SARMA (Guwahati) . Mr belongs to Bhantya Janta Party but we had alliance Speaker, Str. I also ]om the other learned Members wlth 0.J P In the state of several tlmes At of the House In lel~cltatingShri Suraj Bhan, the present also there IS a Governmont of BJP - Haryana Deputy Speaker of thls dlgnlfied House. The very Vikaa Party In Haryana manner In whlch Shrl Suraj Bhan has been elected as the Deputy Speaker of thls House speaks volumes He has done commendable work In Parl~amenl of hls integrity, of h~sgreat personahty and also as 43also outslde for Party's programmes and publlc a learned Member of thls Parliament L'i. as well Therefore, i would l~keto make a submisli~onto Shri Surajbhan as I had requested I, on my behalf and on behalf of the A G P, like you also, that newly elected Members should be to congratulate and fel~cltateShr~ Sural Bhan 1 am pald spec~alattention because senlor Members of hopeful that Shrl Sural Bhan will be able to rnalntaln the House are always glven a chance lo speak even the d~gnltysnd honour of tb onerous responslb~lity If they false lhe~rhand for once Therefore. ~t IS your bestowed upon hlm respon8iblllty to safeguard the Interest of the newly I. as a new Member, will expect that Shri Sura] elected Members Shrl George was saylng that Bhan will glve due tac~lltleslo express our vrewpolnts Members used to raise long pending Issues before In thls blg and most d~gnlfledHouse of the People's the Deputy Speaker Mr Speaker, Str. I would expect reprosentatlves Sir, small partles do not have scdpe from you that under your leadersh~pnew Members to express thelr viewpo~nts I do not know the log~c should be given more chances behlnd 11 as to why the small paflies get lesser time I thank a11 Members of me House once agaln than the blgger partles If lh~sIS the logic. then I and cong!alulate Shrr Sure1 Bhan for h1s electlon as thmk that thls loglc IS illogical and I belleve that a Deputy Speaker 1 also thank the leaders of Bhartiya modus operand1 or a rule should be framed by which Janata parly tor Introduc~ngsuch a popular candldale these small parties will have equal amount of say to Is accepted 10 the entire House I also thank represent the v~ewpo~ntsol the people they Shri Atal B~hariValpayer tor thls represent. That IS why my urgent request to the new Deputy Speaker and also to the hon Speaker will be that they glve enough scope to the Members of SHRl PC THOMAS (Muvattupuzhr) Slr, on new and small panles lo repraaenl their viewpotnls behall on my Party. Jhe Kerrla Congress. I would We are not very much conversant with the procedure ah0 Ilke lo rxlend all fel1cllrlton8 to the new Deputy and the modus opsrandi of the House and rI time8 Fehcitabons to Deputy Speaker JULY 12. 1996 Fel~crtabonslo Deputy Speaker 192

we fumble. Whenever there is an agenda placed august House. I join you, Sir, in congratulating Shri before the House, this agenda has been fluctuated Suraj Bhan who has fdled up that post and I am sure very many different tlmes. We come prepared for an he w~lluphold the dignity and decorum of this august agenda here In the House and sometimes it IS not House and also keep in mind, as has been said d~scussed.. .(lnferruptrcnsI earlier by some of our friends, that there are bigger and smaller and medium political parties and there MR. SPEAKER . Please. do not go ~ntoall these are some hon Members who do no1 belong to any Issues now This 1s about fel~c~tationWhy are you pol~t~calparty and he may keep in mlnd these things. going Into all those th~ngs' Shri Atal Blhar~Vaipayeej~ was saylng this. I think he DR. PRABIN CHANCRA SAGMA Sir, sometimes was touchlng that aspect yesterday He just did that we see that the agenda is d~ftered Therefore, we a I~ttleyrs!eruay want that there should be a plcredure by which we may come prepared I congratulate Shrt Suraj Bhan and joln the entire House In w~sh~nyhlni all success In future We are thankful 1: the hon Speaker that tomorrow at d day after :Pete w~llbe an orlentatlon SHRI TIRUCHI SlVA (Pudukkottai) Hon Speaker. programme Slr I conter my teilcltat~ons profusely on Mr Suraj Bhan for hls havlng been elected as Deputy Speaker MR SPEAKER Flease ~hyare you bring~ngIn unan~mouslyThls House has once again establ~shed ail those th~ngs? tts uniqueness of elect~ngthe Deputy Speaker from the Opposltlon s13e and the happlest part of this is that the halls from a suppressed community Making DR PRABiN CHANDRA SARMA Slr, on behalf use of thls happy occaslon of lel~c~tatlnghim, I would of myself and on behalf cf rry party A G P.. I extend say that we. the new-comers expect more chances our felicltat~onsto !he new Depu:y Speaker for ourselves to speak, especially the youngsters as SHRI HARBHAJAN LAKHA (Phillaur) Slr, I on well as the backbenchers We are sure that durmg behalf of my party congratulate Shri Suraj Bhan on your reglme we wl!I establish a new history and his unanlmous electlcn as the Deputy Speaksr from work for the welfare of th~snatlon Once agam we that caste wh~chwas ccnstdered as maok and mum. promise our fuliest cooperat~clnwh~ch the Members but by receiving good education and pol~tlcalrlghts could give to the Chalr and we expect the Cha~rto wlih :he great sir"gg1e of Gabasaheb Dr. Ambedkar. have a soft corner towards us - youngsters and new. he has reached !o this b'ery respectable posltlon I comers wlsh hlm success in life MR SPEAKER Hon Members I would l~keto SHRI S BANGARAFPA 1Sh!n;3gal . Slr, I am not ]oln the whole House ,* congratula:.ng MI Suraj In the hablt of often ralsln3 my Ptand I will just show Bhan on his unaimcus P4ectlrJr as Cepbty Speaker my hand I have been aoocte:! t8eel In th~saugust of th~saugust House FS;ri l!,e t~rne! was elecled as House , i;r;terrup?icns; I t13pe S,r you w11l k~ndly Speaker I was th~nk~ogsr,ly abou! ?wc th~ngs. hob ccns~der. ts conduct the tuslness of !PIIS Hglise a?d who was MR SPEAKER Yes yci; speaK golng to be a colleague of milre Everyday I was tPdr,klng abcut I! SYFi! S BANSARAPPA !Sh:rr.:ga! Mr Speaker. S,: 1 JOIE w1t9 trle feellr,gs of th~senrlre House In crrigra!ula:ing Shri Suraj Bhan who has been MR SPEAKER In fact I was very cur~ousand eleva?edts the post of Deputy Speaker of th~saugust even qurelly wanted to know lrom !PIIS s~Jeand !hat Ho~ise01 course. I do not know h~mperscnally well s~dewho was gcrlng to be the Deputy Speaker When Eul I war.! to make a little d~st~ncllonon lhls All the I ultimately came to know that there was only ono hcri Merr.bers of the august House have a!!eady name and that was of Mr Sural Bhan . the men who expressed about the great quailties ttlat 5hr1 Suraj IS so seasoned who has a lot of experience In Me Brian 1s kavlr,g I am now golng to jotn a11 my fr~ends - I was very happy Sitting over t'ere in congratulating Shr~Suraj Bhan Cerlalr~lythese parties will appeal lo the new I have known Mr Sural Bhan slnco 1977 when Members who are eiected to this House to extend I came to th~sHouse for ihe l~rstllme In the S~xthLok co3perar13n to the new Deputy Speaker Sabha I can tell you today !hat lrom naw onwards, I am leel~ngvery much relwed Mr Suraj Bhon wlll As far as tte d~goity decorum convent~onsand tradlrlons o? this augus! House are concerned, all be a great strength, il blg support to mo I loof lcrward to workrng together and conductlng lhu these thtcgs ark ceqalnly going to be upheld and busmess of the House together these have been very rrquch kepl n tact by our predecessors also Therefr~rewe will cerlalnty give Once again, I extend my hearllssl congratulrllons all the co9peratlon that 15 required, to Shri Sura] to Mr Suraj Bhan and wlsh hlm 811 the beel and Bhan In the matter of conducl~ngthe busmess of th16 BUCCeSS ASADHA 21. 1918 (Saka) Demands lor Excess Grants 194 (General) 1993-94

[Translation] Minister lo the House The Minlster was abroad when MR DEPUTY SPEAKER Mr Speaker, Sir, before introduction was done last t~me. saylng somethmg on my elect~on.I would like to THE PRIME MINISTER (SHRI H D DEVE quote an Urdu couplet : GOWDA) . Mr. Speaker. Sir, with you klnd permlsslon "Pathar kl Bhl Takd~rBadal Sakti Hai, I would hke to introduce my colleague Shr~Blrendra Shart Yeh Hal KI Karme Se Tarasha Jaye" Prasad Ba~shya.Minister of Steel and Mlnes, to the House Fortunately. I have got tralnlng from a reverend person like Shr~ Vajpayeeji and you have emtlell~sted me further Whatever has been said about me for a wh~leI was thlnkmg as to lor whom all th~sIS being sa~dl would hke to lhank all of you [Tra nslar~on] Desp~ted~tference of opinion In pol~t~calmatters the precedent of the electlon of Hon'ble Speaker has SHRI GEORGE FERNANDES (Nalandaj Mr been repeated once agaln. by electlng me Speaker, Sir I would llke to ralse .n urgent Issue unan~mouslyas Deputy Speaker in lhis august regarding the safety of Me cf a person as the House House Th~sin ~tsellIS a unlque exposition of the wlil adjourn today for two days and will meet agaln dignity of the House My heartlest thanks to all of on Moqday you This IS a very great achievement of my pol~tical CBi has filed a case In the court the w~tnessof life In this regard, mot~onshave been moved by top wp rh IS St,ri Lakkk,u 9ha1 Pathak HIS I~feIS In leaders of the country wh~chInclude the names of JaPge: It ras tee- pzved when he was be~ng reverend Vajpayeell Rajmatal~ Shrl hcnc~lredby the ns!11~!1onworklng for ant^. Chandrasekharjl Bhai Ram Vilas Paswan 11 Shr~ ccrrdptlon It IS a ques!ion of a person s l~feIn th~s ealasubramoniyan 11 Shr~Sharad Pawar JI Shrl case ovldence o! Chandrasfiarni who IS IT! jail at Santosh Mohan Dev 11, reverend Dr Murli Manohar present, 1s being reccrded It is bul na?iira!that people Josh! 11, Shn Surl~tSlngh Barnala j~ Sr'ri Madk.ukar wil; be afra13 dire tc unlrsual thmgs takmg place In Sarpotdar JI Shri Gecrge Fevnandes ji Sp,r lai the entire case When he was being honoured a bld Prakash 11 Shri Om Prakash Jinda! ;I Sbf, N~tish 13 exchange biws 1033 place there ilnrerruptrons) Kumar 11 Shrl Pramod Mahajan J! Shr1 Ja)r,chan 11 i ~cuidlike 13 add cne more sentence Shr~Santosh Kun:ar Gangwar 11 and S5.l Jaga? Vlr S~nghDrona (fE'1gi,s"! All of you !dave pven me th~sPcc?ur a?d Cave h49 SPEAKER lu'r Fernanaes the whole patter expressed yobf faith IT! .;e I hape !Cat ycl! wll :s be!ore !he :curt Why shouig we anttclpate things coope!aqe and gu13w me ,n :c,ncfdcling :b8e tdslress I? :he wodse ilke !h,a:3 of Ihe House In discharg~ng!h,s respz'~l,k,:~lyVV tinanimous elect~cnhas awakened rre 13 oo my o~ly ,':.a ?s:a:~;n; wili cons~derI! ry duty to safeguard tp)e Interests of hon ble Members wh81e conducli-3 tke kds;ness SHGI GEROGE FERRANDES Sir, on behalf of Cai thal perscn IS t;eing asked lo leave the country Of Ihe House and for lhat 1 w~liSI! or !!?IS Ckalr as your representallve I pray tc tke Gad to give me strength so that I cap d~schargemy duyies properly

lnd~aIS the largest demscracy of the warid Somehmes doubts are rased about the exls!en;e ct lh~sdemocracy but the unanimous elecl~cn:.' ''.e hon'ble Speaker and Deputy Speaker tiils o.i,e 13.23 hrs agaln cleared these doubts and the democracy has been strengthened further Trtdnks to all DEMANDS FOR EXCESS GRANTS (GENERAL) 93-94

iEngiish] THE MINISTER OF FINANCE AND MINISTER OF 13.21 hrr. COMPANY AFFAIRS (SHRI P CHIDAMBARAM) Slr. I beg to present a statement (H~ndiand Engllsh INTRODUCTION OF MINISTER versions) show~ng!he Demands tor Excess Grants In lespect of the Budget (General\ for 1993-94 [Englreh) THE MINISTER OF WELFARE (SHRI BALWANT MR SPEAKER Before we adjourn tor lunch. SINGH RAMOOWALIAI Mr Speaker. Slr I have to tho Pflmo Miniator wlll klndly Introduce one more Introduce a Bill