The Soundscape Planning of Mountain Park in Holyoke, Massachusetts
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of Massachusetts Amherst ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst Landscape Architecture & Regional Planning Landscape Architecture & Regional Planning Masters Projects 5-2010 The oundS scape Planning of Mountain Park in Holyoke, Massachusetts Brian Clayton Giggey University of Massachusetts - Amherst, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.umass.edu/larp_ms_projects Part of the Landscape Architecture Commons Giggey, Brian Clayton, "The oundS scape Planning of Mountain Park in Holyoke, Massachusetts" (2010). Landscape Architecture & Regional Planning Masters Projects. 1. Retrieved from https://scholarworks.umass.edu/larp_ms_projects/1 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Landscape Architecture & Regional Planning at ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst. It has been accepted for inclusion in Landscape Architecture & Regional Planning Masters Projects by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst. For more information, please contact [email protected]. THE SOUNDSCAPE PLANNING OF MOUNTAIN PARK IN HOLYOKE, MASSACHUSETTS A Master’s Project Presented by Brian C. Giggey Submitted to the Graduate School of the University of Massachusetts Amherst in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE May 2010 Department of Landscape Architecture and Regional Planning THE SOUNDSCAPE PLANNING OF MOUNTAIN PARK IN HOLYOKE, MASSACHUSETTS A Master’s Project Presented by Brian C. Giggey Approved as to style and content by: _______________________________________ Michael Davidsohn, Committee Chair _______________________________________ Mark Hamin, Committee Member ____________________________________ Elizabeth Brabec, Department Head Department of Landscape Architecture and Regional Planning TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTER PAGE Acknowledgements ..................................................................................................1 List of Figures ..........................................................................................................2 List of Images ..........................................................................................................3 1. Introduction Introduction to Soundscape Planning ............................................................4 Goals and Objectives .....................................................................................7 Justification of Project Study .........................................................................7 2. Literature Review and Case Studies Acoustic Basics ............................................................................................15 Amphitheater Design ...................................................................................19 Landscape Media .........................................................................................24 Materials ......................................................................................................31 Case Study: Tanglewood Music Shed .........................................................35 Case Study: Red Rocks Amphitheater .........................................................41 Case Study: Mayan Temples of Tikal ..........................................................46 3. Non-Site Specific Application Methodology ................................................................................................50 Landscape Setting ........................................................................................52 Program Specifications of Amphitheater Design ........................................55 4. Mountain Park Site Project Site History ......................................................................................60 Site Analysis ................................................................................................66 5. Design Proposals and Recommendations Overview ......................................................................................................85 Conceptual Design .......................................................................................89 Conclusion ...................................................................................................99 6. Appendix ..............................................................................................................101 7. References ............................................................................................................102 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Thank you to my committee chair, Mike Davidsohn, for your countless hours of insight and direction. Your easy-going nature and constant feedback were the driving force in me finishing this project on time. You kept me motivated throughout the entire process, pushing me to dig deeper and make this project the best that it could possibly be. I cannot say thank you enough for all you have done for me in my time here at UMass, including the support you have given in regards to the disc golf proposal, and I am truly grateful that we got to work together on this project. Thank you to my committee member, Mark Hamin, for your help and direction in editing towards writing my paper and in the realm of regional planning. As my time here at UMass progressed, my interest in planning grew tremendously, starting with your city planning class and now terminating in this project. I thank you for your time and insight as your passion for the profession has helped spark mine. Thank you to Zeena Hutchinson for your patience and support throughout this project. Your willingness to listen to me ramble on and geek out over amphitheaters, music, concerts and sound will never be forgotten. I cannot thank you enough for being there to bounce ideas off of and just listen. From the never-ending writing sessions to the sleepless nights spent dreaming about the future, thank you for being there every step of the way. I greatly appreciate your help proofreading and rendering the perspectives as well as the food you provided for my defense. And finally, thank you to my family, especially my Mom, for your continued support through not only my three years here at UMass, but my lifelong obsession with friends, travel and music. You have all had to listen to one too many stories about my adventures and I cannot thank you enough for that. Mom, I cannot even begin to put into words how much you mean to me and everything you have done for me. I will never forget the annual sprint to the fence at SPAC with you and your willingness to listen to my on-going stories. From seeing some of the music Meccas of the world to traveling around Europe together, every second spent together is absolutely priceless and means the world to me. Your guidance in the creation of this project is the reason I was able to fulfill this dream of researching soundscape planning and of designing Mountain Park. 1 LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1: Reverberation time diagram (Source: Beranek, 2004) Figure 2: Sound reflections diagram (Source: Beranek, 2004) Figure 3: Sound energy with orchestra shell graph (Source: Ando and Noson, 1997) Figure 4: Sound energy without orchestra shell graph (Source: Ando and Noson, 1997) Figure 5: Sound processes diagram (Source: White and White, 1980) Figure 6: Double wall construction diagram (Source: White and White, 1980) Figure 7: Absorptive spacing diagram (Source: White and White, 2004) Figure 8: Tanglewood Music Shed plan (Source: Beranek, 2004) Figure 9: Tanglewood Music Shed orchestra shell (Source: Beranek, 2004) Figure 10: Tanglewood Music Shed case study board (Source: Tanglewood, 1976) Figure 11: Red Rocks Amphitheater case study board (Source: Red Rocks, 2009) Figure 12: Mayan Temples of Tikal case study board (Source: Escobar, 2010) Figure 13: Regional context of Mountain Park (Source: MassGIS, Matt Medeiros) Figure 14: Zoning around Mountain Park (Source: MassGIS, Matt Medeiros) Figure 15: Land use around Mountain Park (Source: MassGIS, Matt Medeiros) Figure 16: Landform and acoustic levels site analysis (Source: Brian Giggey) Figure 17: Vegetation and wetlands site analysis (Source: Brian Giggey) Figure 18: Circulation and significant features site analysis (Source: Brian Giggey) Figure 19: Composite site analysis (Source: Brian Giggey) Figure 20: Intervisibility map of Mountain Park (Source: Brian Giggey) Figure 21: Master plan of Mountain Park (Source: Brian Giggey) Figure 22: Focus area plan of Mountain Park (Source: Brian Giggey) Figure 23: Mountain Park site section (Source: Brian Giggey) Figure 24: Amphitheater section (Source: Brian Giggey) Figure 25: Buffer treatment section (Source: Brian Giggey) Figure 26: Promenade section (Source: Brian Giggey) Figure 27: Perspective rendering (Source: Zeena Hutchinson, Brian Giggey) Figure 28: Perspective rendering (Source: Zeena Hutchinson, Brian Giggey) Figure 29: Perspective rendering (Source: Zeena Hutchinson, Brian Giggey) Figure 30: Perspective rendering (Source: Zeena Hutchinson, Brian Giggey) 2 LIST OF IMAGES Image 1: Historic bird’s eye view of Mountain Park (Source: Ducharme, 2008) Image 2: Historic plan view of Mountain Park (Source: Ducharme, 2008) Image 3: Historic image of Mountain Park (Source: Ducharme, 2008) Image 4: Historic image of Mountain Park (Source: Ducharme, 2008) 3 INTRODUCTION 1.1 - Introduction to Soundscape Planning The soundscape of a place is simply its acoustic environment, with the listener situated within the center of the sonic landscape (Porteous and Mastin, 1985). Soundscapes can be adjusted with proper planning,