DOCSLIB.ORG

Doing Justice Ver Final

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Doing Justice Ver Final Velasquez Valenzuela, Javier (2018) Doing justice: sentencing practices in Scottish sheriff courts. PhD thesis. https://theses.gla.ac.uk/39042/ Copyright and moral rights for this work are retained by the author A copy can be downloaded for personal non-commercial research or study, without prior permission or charge This work cannot be reproduced or quoted extensively from without first obtaining permission in writing from the author The content must not be changed in any way or sold commercially in any format or medium without the formal permission of the author When referring to this work, full bibliographic details including the author, title, awarding institution and date of the thesis must be given Enlighten: Theses https://theses.gla.ac.uk/ [email protected] Doing Justice: Sentencing Practices in Scottish Sheriff Courts Javier Velásquez Valenzuela Licenciado en Ciencias Jurídicas, Abogado & MSt en Derecho Penal Submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy School of Social and Political Sciences, College of Social Sciences University of Glasgow October 2018 2 Abstract This thesis is an examination of the sentencing practices of judges (known as Sheriffs) in criminal cases heard in the Scottish sheriff courts. Despite the importance of sentencing, there is little knowledge of how exactly Sheriffs deal with cases. In particular, little is known about why and in which cases they decide that a custodial sentence is appropriate in the context of summary court proceedings. This research aims to understand the rationales behind the Sheriffs’ sentencing practice and, through this exploration, tries to examine how Sheriffs currently understand their role as sentencers. To achieve this objective, I negotiated access with the Scottish Judiciary which allowed me to carry out my fieldwork during the winter of 2016/2017. I interviewed, observed and shadowed 16 Sheriffs in 14 different Sheriff Courts throughout the country. The observation entailed shadowing the Sheriffs during what is called the ‘remand court’(RC). This is a day where they deal with all the criminal business - most of it on summary procedure - concerning sentencing diets. By the end of my fieldwork, I had observed Sheriffs dealing with more than 400 cases. One of the key findings was to confirm the perception that different Sheriffs have distinctive sentencing styles. However, I also found that there were structural legal and non-legal factors that partially explained those differences. Critically, my findings stressed how the Sheriffs' practices are shaped by the distinctive local realities in which they practice. This contextualization of sentencing practices allowed me to explore how different social, economic and geographical differences impacted the Sheriffs’ decision-making. Furthermore, through the observation of the Sheriffs in court and in their chambers, I was able to describe the routines behind sentencing practices. This allowed me to explore at which stages of these routines the Sheriffs’ decision-making begins to differ from one another. As a consequence, I was able to outline two models of sentencing practices. The first one is a depiction of the observable stages of the sentencing process. The second one is related to the fundamental questions the Sheriff faces during the individualisation of punishment which allow us to highlight at which moment the different sentencing styles emerge. 3 Author’s Declaration I declare that, except where explicit reference is made to the contribution of others, that this dissertation is the result of my own work and has not been submitted for any other degree at the University of Glasgow or any other institution. Printed name: Javier Velásquez Valenzuela Signature: ______________________ 4 Acknowledgements This thesis is the final act of a very long journey that begun twelve years ago when I took the decision that I wanted to carry out a PhD. It took me eight years to start, first finishing my undergrad, qualifying as a lawyer, successfully completing a masters and acquiring enough academic and professional experience. Nevertheless, what this PhD has taught me is that this would not have been possible without the guide, help and life lessons that a lot of people taught me. To acknowledge why I am here, and why I was able to write this work, means to thank those people who provided me with the support when I needed it the most. However, I also need to thank those who challenged me and pushed me to go beyond what I thought my limits were. Bourdieu once wrote that the immigrant is "atopos", "absent both from his place of origin and his place of arrival". I moved to Scotland leaving everything behind; I arrived having nothing but my suitcases. I want to thank those I left behind, whose help made it possible for me to start the PhD: My mother, who never let me give up, and always pushed me to go for my goals despite my disabilities. My family who have always supported me, without whom I would have lacked the emotional support that I needed to go through the hardest moments. Legal scholars like Patricio Gonzalez and Fernando Londoño, who gave me the chance to be their teaching assistant and taught me so much about the "art" of being a lecturer. All the people I worked with at the Fiscala Metropolitana Centro Norte, that taught me so much about professional, intellectual and human matters. The prosecutors, the legal clerks, the technicians, who were not only colleagues but friends. There is so much of my understanding of the legal field and legal practices that came from of my experiences with them. Indeed, I would not be the person I am without their friendship. Godoy, Arancibia, Mayer, Meneses, Adasme, Vargas, Ledezma, Montes, the list continues. Also, I am very much indebted to my colleagues and staff of the former Unidad de Delitos Sexuales y Violentos and the Asesoria Juridica Unit. Anita, Sandra, Mauri, Karin, Pili, Donoso, Lautaro and again, I cannot list you all. Because "no man is an Island", I have always been part of a community, even if I was not aware of it. The loneliness that is part of being an immigrant, the distance, the absence, shed new light on how much indebted I am to them. Moreover, spending four years studying the Scottish penal field inevitably made me constantly re-think my experiences in the Chilean field. The more I analyse and understand Scottish practices, the more that I look back and look at my Chilean experiences in a new light. 5 Before I left Chile, I was talking with Londoño who said to me that I should not worry, that I would not be alone, that I would find people that care about me and support me in Scotland as I had in Chile. And I did. I cannot thank my supervisors enough for all that have done for me. While this, again may sound like a commonplace, I mean it. Fergus, Marguerite and Fiona, I would have never done this research, if they were not there to support, guide and continuously challenge me to do better, to dare to do more. During the hardest moments of my PhD, when I started to lose faith that I was going to be able to carry my out my fieldwork during the long process of negotiation, they supported me and kept me going. It is not an understatement that I have learned so much from them intellectually and on a human level. Also, how can I not acknowledge the people I met at the SCCJR and the University of Glasgow? How can I not thank Tim McBride, Sarah Anderson, David Usman, Caitlin Gormley, Annie Crowley, Anna Schliehe, Neil Cornish, Kirsty Deacon, Tim Winzler, Grant McPhail, Cyrus Tata or Bridget Fowler? Again, this list is too short and omits many, but I would not have survived these hectic years without them. It will be hard to say goodbye. I also need to thanks to Niklas Cedenheim and Gabriela del Rio for their invaluable help and friendship. Last but not least, I could not have survived the last two years of my PhD if it were not for the emotional support and help of my partner, Rhys Allardice. Again, words are not enough to say how much he contributed to this achievement, mainly because having to deal with a PhD student in their writing year is not always a pleasant experience. I am indebted to his family as well, Katy, Craig and Dean, who embraced with open arms and became the family I lacked. Again, as Donne said "No man is an Island", and to have completed this PhD is as an achievement that belongs as much to those have helped along the way as it does to me. This work was funded by the Chilean National Commission for Scientific and Technological Research, CONICYT PFCHA / Beca de Doctorado en el Extranjero, Folio 72150042. 6 Table of Contents Abstract ...................................................................................... 2 Author’s Declaration ....................................................................... 3 Acknowledgements ......................................................................... 4 Table of Contents .......................................................................... 6 List of Tables, Graphs and Diagrams .................................................... 9 Abbreviations/Glossary of terms ........................................................ 10 CHAPTER 1: Introduction ................................................................. 11 CHAPTER 2: Literature Review .......................................................... 16 2.1. Sentencing research: On Criminologists and Lawyers ...................... 16 2.2. ‘Et tu, Brute?’ - The pervasiveness of lawyers ............................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Translation Studies
    BACHELOR OF ARTS III YEAR ENGLISH LITERATURE PAPER – II: TRANSLATION STUDIES BHARATHIAR UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF DISTANCE EDUCATION COIMBATORE – 641 046. ADDENDUM B.A. English Literature – III year Study material of Paper II – TRANSLATION STUDES SL. No. Page No. Corrections Carried Over 1 -- Add the subject “Application of Translation in Tirukkural and the Odyssey” in Unit – V of the syllabus. 2. -- Add reference (16) Sri V.V.S. Aiyar. 2005. Tirukkural: English Translation. Sri Ramakrishna Tapovanam, (17) Homer – Allen Mandelbaum – Roman Maria Luisa – De. 1990. The Odyssey of Homer: a new verse translation. University of California Press. 3. 132 Add in Lesson – V – Place of Style in Translation under Unit-V. (f) Application of Translation in Tirukkural and the Odyssey. 4. 158 Add the title under Unit-V Annexure –I (i) Tirukkural (ii) The Odyssey Paper – II: TRANSLATION STUDIES Syllabus Objectives: The course is intended to initiate the student to the translation discipline, its chronological history and provide a better understanding of the different types of translations as well as its various theories and applications. It further aims to equip the student with a proper knowledge of the aspects of creative literature, the function of Mass media in society and the various issues involved in translation. Unit – I: History of Translation Nature of translation studies – The Function of language – Structuralist Theory and Application – Translation through the ages – Dryden’s classification of translation models. Unit – II: Theories of Translation Types of translation – Translation theories: Ancient and Modern – Nida’s three base models of translation – (Nida’s model Cont...)Transfer and Restructuring – Linguistics of translation.
    [Show full text]
  • “Daoism and Confucianism” In: Liu X. (Eds) Dao Companion to Daoist Philosophy
    Lai Karyn. (2015) “Daoism and Confucianism” In: Liu X. (eds) Dao Companion to Daoist Philosophy. Dao Companions to Chinese Philosophy, vol 6. Springer, Dordrecht, pp. 489-511. This is the post-print version. The definitive version is to be found at: https://link-springer- com.wwwproxy1.library.unsw.edu.au/chapter/10.1007/978-90- 481-2927-0_21 This chapter relies on a distinction between Confucianism and Daoism made during the Han dynasty (漢朝: 206 BCE–220 CE) and further perpetuated in Chinese intellectual history. It examines the connections between pre-Qin (秦朝: 221– 206 BCE) Daoist and Confucian philosophies, focusing on their differences as well as similarities. While it has been traditionally accepted that there are many tensions, and even antagonism, between concepts and approaches in Daoist and Confucian thought, the discussion here also focuses on the historical linkages and philosophical continuities that at times blur the distinction between the two. The primary comparison here will be conducted at three levels: the individual within its environment, the socio-political world, and the cultivation of the self. These three levels of analysis are organized in three sections, from the more inclusive to the more specific. However, the sections are only theoretical divisions, since both Daoist and Confucian philosophies emphasize a concept of selfhood that focuses on an individual’s relationships with others, within a larger natural and cosmic environment. To more fully understand these comparisons, it is important also to examine the intellectual climate within which interactions between so- called Daoism and Confucianism took place. These details, including information gleaned from relatively recently discovered texts, are not merely tangential to our understanding of both philosophies.
    [Show full text]
  • Sheriff Appeal Court [2019] Sac (Civ) 030 Edi-F1024-16
    SHERIFF APPEAL COURT [2019] SAC (CIV) 030 EDI-F1024-16 Sheriff Principal I Abercrombie QC Appeal Sheriff P J Braid Appeal Sheriff H K Small OPINION OF THE COURT delivered by APPEAL SHERIFF H K SMALL in appeal by CM Pursuer and Respondent against ME-M Defender and Appellant Appellant: M Clark, advocate; Brodies Respondent: Malcolm, advocate; Thorley Stephenson; 24 July 2019 Introduction [1] The parties to this action had a relationship which began in 2000 and ended in September 2015. There is one child of the relationship, “A”, born on 5 September 2011. Since separation A has lived with her mother (the defender and appellant). In August 2016 her father (the pursuer and respondent) raised the present proceedings seeking an order for contact with A in terms of section 11 of the Children (Scotland) Act 1995. There followed a 2 series of court orders permitting interim contact, but on a supervised basis, contact generally being supervised by the defender and/or her mother. [2] The pursuer’s application for contact was opposed. After sundry procedure, the case proceeded to proof at Edinburgh Sheriff Court over five days in 2018. In January 2019 the sheriff issued a judgement in which he held that contact with her father was in A’s best interest. He granted the pursuer’s crave for contact, initially on a supervised basis, but thereafter progressing, over a period of eight weeks, to unsupervised contact. The defender now appeals that decision to this court. [3] The sheriff made 75 findings-in-fact, which, in large part, are not challenged.
    [Show full text]
  • Consultation on the Departure from Retained EU Case Law by UK Courts and Tribunals
    Retained EU Case Law Consultation on the departure from retained EU case law by UK courts and tribunals This consultation begins on 2 July 2020 This consultation ends on 13 August 2020 Retained EU Case Law Consultation on the departure from retained EU case law by UK courts and tribunals A consultation produced by the Ministry of Justice. It is also available at https://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/departure-from-retained-eu-case-law- by-uk-courts-and-tribunals About this consultation To: The President of the Supreme Court The Lord Chief Justice of England and Wales The Lord President of the Court of Session The Lord Chief Justice of Northern Ireland The Senior President of Tribunals President of Scottish Tribunals President of Welsh Tribunals Judge Advocate General Scottish Government Northern Ireland Executive Welsh Assembly The Lord Advocate Attorney General for Northern Ireland Public Prosecution Service Northern Ireland International Law Committee The Law Society The Law Society of Northern Ireland The Law Society of Scotland City of London Law Society The Bar Council The Bar of Northern Ireland Faculty of Advocates Chartered Institute of Legal Executives Employment Lawyers Association Insolvency Lawyers Association Law Centre, Northern Ireland Director of Service Prosecutions British Chamber of Commerce Scottish Chamber of Commerce Northern Ireland Chamber of Commerce Confederation of British Industry Confederation of British Industry Scotland Confederation of British Industry Northern Ireland Institute of Directors Institute
    [Show full text]
  • A Theological Meditation on Augustine's De Trinitate and Laozi's Dao De Jing
    In Search of Transcendent Order in A Violent World: A Theological Meditation on Augustine's de Trinitate and Laozi's Dao De Jing Author: Chan Hiutung Persistent link: http://hdl.handle.net/2345/1989 This work is posted on eScholarship@BC, Boston College University Libraries. Boston College Electronic Thesis or Dissertation, 2009 Copyright is held by the author, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise noted. Boston College The Graduate School of Arts and Sciences Department of Theology IN SEARCH OF TRANSCENDENT ORDER IN THE VIOLENT WORLD: A THEOLOGICAL MEDITATION OF LAOZI’S DAODE JING AND AUGUSTINE’S DE TRINITATE a dissertation by Hiutung Chan Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy December 2008 1 © copyright by HIUTUNG CHAN 2008 2 IN SEARCH OF TRANSCENDENT ORDER IN A VIOLENT WORLD: A THEOLOGICAL MEDITATION OF LAOZI’S DAODE JING AND AUGUSTINE’S DE TRINITATE Abstract by Hiutung Chan This dissertation is a comparative study of spiritual cultivation in Early Daoism and the spiritual teaching of Augustine’s Christianity. My goal is to examine how early Daoism’s founder, Laozi, and the Christian bishop, Augustine of Hippo, characterize the fulfillment of humanity through religious transformation. My argument is that the metaphysical speculations that figure in their works---and which scholarly readers often emphasize---are offshoots of profound practical, soteriological concerns. These soteriological concerns reveal that the primary interest for both writers was to discover those spiritual and intellectual practices that could most effectively mediate between human experience and the manifestation of transcendent order. This study takes its inspiration from pioneering instances of comparative theology (particularly works by Francis Clooney S.J.
    [Show full text]
  • Cops Divert and “Soft” Cops Charge: Trait Attitudes Vs
    ABSTRACT Title of Dissertation: WHEN “TOUGH” COPS DIVERT AND “SOFT” COPS CHARGE: TRAIT ATTITUDES VS. STATE SITUATIONAL NARRATIVES IN A FOCAL CONCERNS PROCESS OF POLICE DECISION-MAKING Molly P. Slothower, Doctor of Philosophy, 2019 Dissertation directed by: Distinguished Professor Dr. Lawrence Sherman, Department of Criminology and Criminal Justice, University of Maryland Research Question Do police officers’ overall “tough” or “soft” attitudes toward crime and defendants determine how they handle discretionary cases, or does each officer look at the elements in each case to see whether they should act “tough” or “soft” in the given situation? This study tests whether police decisions to divert cases from prosecution into diversionary out-of-court disposals are driven by “trait attitudes”—each officer’s overall “tough” or “soft” attitudes toward defendants, which are stable characteristics of each officer regardless of the situation—versus officers’ “state attitudes”—their narratives about the meaning of specific elements present in each case as they make decisions. Methods Thirty-four officers in a large urban force completed attitudinal surveys and 20 case study vignettes. For each vignette, officers recorded: each relevant element (e.g. criminal history, alcohol involvement); whether each element pushed them toward prosecution or diversion, and why; and whether they would prosecute or divert the case. Officers recorded 2,241 elements across 645 case responses. Using primarily hierarchical logistic regression models, this study tests the impact of trait attitudes versus state narratives on recommended case outcomes. Results Officer decision-making was more influenced by officers’ interpretations of whether elements signaled each defendant was “reformable” or “incorrigible” than by their overall “tough” or “soft” attitudes.
    [Show full text]
  • Nicola Gilchrist | Arnot Manderson Advocates
    [email protected] 07884 060508 Year of Call NICOLA GILCHRIST 2011 Devil Masters Kate Dowdalls QC Gavin McColl QC Shelagh McCall QC @NicolaGilchrist on Twitter LinkedIn Profile Practice Profile Nicola is recommended in both the Chambers & Partners UK Bar and The Legal 500 UK Bar guides. Nicola specialises in family and child law, and is regularly involved in cases in the Court of Session and Sheriff Courts both in cases at first instance and in appeals to the Sheriff Appeal Court and the Inner House. She has experience across the board in litigation concerning divorce, financial provision, cohabitation and civil partnerships. Her expertise in child law encompasses all of its many facets, including complex jurisdictional issues, international child abduction, permanence orders and petitions for adoption. She has a particular interest in cases that involve sensitive cross-cultural issues, domestic abuse and matters affecting women and girls. She successfully appeared in the first forced marriage case to be heard in Scotland. Nicola was appointed as an Advocate Depute (Ad Hoc) in 2015 and she has been instructed as junior counsel in a number of criminal trials and has appeared in the High Court of Justiciary and in the Criminal Appeal Court for both the Crown and the Appellant. Nicola was appointed as a lead statement taker at the Scottish Child Abuse Inquiry in 2016. Nicola is a director of Relationships Scotland. Education & Professional Career to Date Trainee Solicitor - Balfour & Manson Solicitor - MMS Solicitor - HBJ
    [Show full text]
  • Civil Justice - Civil Courts and Tribunals (Republished)
    SPICe Briefing Pàipear-ullachaidh SPICe Civil Justice - Civil Courts and Tribunals (republished) Abigail Bremner The civil justice system enables people to protect or enforce their legal rights. This briefing looks at the structure of civil courts and tribunals in Scotland. Note that this briefing is a re-edited version of the SPICe briefing Civil Justice - Civil Courts and Tribunals, published in December 2016. 11 May 2017 SB 17/30 Civil Justice - Civil Courts and Tribunals (republished), SB 17/30 Contents What this briefing is about ________________________________________________4 Useful definitions _______________________________________________________5 What is civil justice? _____________________________________________________6 The civil courts are being reformed _________________________________________6 How devolution affects the civil courts _______________________________________7 Who's who in Scotland's civil court system __________________________________8 The role of the Lord President _____________________________________________8 The role of the Lord Justice Clerk __________________________________________8 The role of the Scottish Civil Justice Council __________________________________8 The sheriff courts ______________________________________________________10 Who's who in the sheriff courts ___________________________________________10 Summary sheriffs are likely to increase in number ____________________________ 11 Reforms enable sheriffs and summary sheriffs to specialise_____________________ 11 The Sheriff Personal
    [Show full text]
  • Scott Manson
    Advocates Library, Parliament House, Edinburgh, EH1 1RF Telephone: 0131 226 2881 Facsimile : 0131 225 3642 DX ED 549302, Edinburgh 36, LP3 Edinburgh 10 Scott Manson Year of Call: 2014 [email protected] 07834692296 Professional Career to date Devil Masters: Gordon S. Balfour; Gavin L. MacColl, QC; Thomas L. Ross, QC July 2014: Admitted to the Faculty of Advocates 2013 – July 2014: Devil, Faculty of Advocates 2012 – 2013: Solicitor, MacRoberts LLP 2009 – 2012: Solicitor, BTO Solicitors 2007-2009: Trainee Solicitor, BTO Solicitors Education & Professional Qualifications Faculty of Advocates’ Lord Reid Scholar (Joint Award) (2013-2014) Faculty Scholar (2013-2014) Postgraduate Diploma in Legal Practice, University of Glasgow (2007) LL.B (Hons) (1st Class), University of Glasgow (2006) Areas of Expertise Commercial Contracts Commercial Property Company, Corporate Finance and Tax Construction and Engineering Insolvency Intellectual Property Rights Product Liability Professional Liability Alternative Dispute Resolution Public Law, Judicial Review and Human Rights Professional Experience Scott is a "highly sought after junior" (Chambers UK Bar 2020) with a busy and wide-ranging practice focusing on a range of commercial disputes including commercial contracts, professional negligence, insurance and construction project litigation. He has also developed a growing practice in shipping, maritime and admiralty litigation; and also contentious trusts and executories. He is ranked in both Chambers UK Bar and the Legal 500 where instructing solicitors commend him for: having a "common sense, practical" and "commercial" approach; being "very good on strategy"; and being "excellent on his feet and very persuassive" in court. Scott is also listed as a "Future Leader" in respect of construction litigation in Who's Who Legal.
    [Show full text]
  • Newton Vs. Leibniz: Intransparency Vs. Inconsistency
    Newton vs. Leibniz: Intransparency vs. Inconsistency Karin Verelst Vrije Universiteit Brussel1 [email protected] The only way to avoid becoming a metaphysician is to say nothing E.A. Burtt Abstract Introduction The early modern debates on the nature of space enjoy a renewed interest in the recent philosophical literature. Focal points of the discussion are the opposition between the “absolute” vs. the “relational ” conception of space and the related issue of its presumed substantival nature. Quintessential formulations of the key positions in the debate remain the viewpoints attributed to Newton and Leib- niz. But scholarly disagreement concerning them remains stark. Especially with respect to Newton the defended interpretations range from anti-metaphysical readings (based on the notorious “I do not feign hypotheses”) to at first glance almost theological readings that have him speculate about the relation between God and world. Leibniz, on the other hand, is presented as Newton’s counter- part, who sets out tackling mechanical problems with an a priori metaphysical scheme — inherited from Descartes — already laid out in his mind. But Newton arXiv:1203.2292v1 [physics.hist-ph] 10 Mar 2012 clearly conceived of himself as a natural philosopher [52, p. 2], while Leibniz, certainly in his earlier years, would have insisted on his use of strictly mechanical concepts only [10, Introduction]. We believe that, in order to be able to judge on the “metaphysical degree” of the positions taken by our protagonists, we should understand more clearly what metaphysics itself is about. This question is often ignored. We shall show 1FUND-CLEA, Dept. of Mathematics.
    [Show full text]
  • The Judiciary in Scotland
    The Judiciary in Scotland The Judicial Office for Scotland provides support to the Lord President in his role as Head of the Scottish judges and tribunal presidents. He is supported by the second most senior judge in Scotland - the Lord Justice Clerk. All judges in Scotland are independent. They make their decisions based on the law and the circumstances of each case. Scotland has a unique justice system which is different to the rest of the UK. Criminal cases There are two types of criminal procedure in Scotland: solemn procedure for more serious offences and summary procedure. When a trial is held against a person accused of a crime, a jury decides the verdict in solemn cases. The judge decides the verdict in summary cases. There are three verdicts in Scotland: Guilty Not Guilty Not Proven The not proven verdict is unique to Scotland. When the verdict in a case is not guilty or not proven, the accused person cannot usually be retried in court for the crime (except in highly exceptional circumstances, for example if new evidence were found that was not available at the trial of a serious crime). In all cases where an accused person is convicted of a crime, the judge decides what the appropriate sentence should be. Sentencing There are a number of sentencing options in Scotland including prison; community payback; or a fine. Community Payback Orders can involve unpaid work; a compensation payment to a victim; supervision; and mental health, drug or alcohol treatment. Judges base their sentencing decisions on what they have heard in court from the prosecution and the defence about the circumstances of the crime (including the impact on any victims) and the personal circumstances of the offender.
    [Show full text]
  • SHERIFF APPEAL COURT [2021] SAC (Crim)
    SHERIFF APPEAL COURT [2021] SAC (Crim) 2 SAC/2020/000361/AP Sheriff N McFadyen Sheriff L A Drummond Sheriff F Tait OPINION OF THE COURT delivered by SHERIFF N MCFADYEN in Crown Sentence Appeal by PROCURATOR FISCAL, HAMILTON Appellant against JOHN DONNELLY Respondent Appellant: Edwards QC AD; Crown Agent Respondent: Laurie; Faculty Appeals Unit 9 March 2021 Introduction [1] In this case the Procurator Fiscal at Hamilton appeals under s 175(4) of the Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995 against a sentence of admonition imposed by a summary sheriff there and her decision not to impose a non-harassment order, both in respect of the assault to injury of the respondent’s ex-wife, aggravated in terms of section 1 of the Abusive Behaviour and Sexual Harm (Scotland) Act 2016. Such an appeal can be made on a point of 2 law (section 175(4A)(a)) or, for present purposes, where it appears to the Lord Advocate, that the sentence was unduly lenient or the decision not to impose a non-harassment order was inappropriate (section 175(4A)(b) (i) and (ii)). [2] The respondent went to trial on a charge that he did on 5 December 2017 at an address in Strathaven assault his former wife KD “and did strike her on the head and cause her to fall against furniture there, repeatedly strike her on the head and body with your hand, seize her by the clothing and pull her by same and cause her to strike her head against furniture there, kick her on the body and repeatedly seize her by the clothing and strike her body against the ground there, all to her injury and it will be proved in terms of section 1 of the Abusive Behaviour and Sexual Harm (Scotland) Act 2016 that the aforesaid offence was aggravated by involving abuse of your partner or ex-partner”.
    [Show full text]