Music, Education and Innovation
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Luleå University of Technology Department of Music and Media Music, education ISBN 978-91-7439-127-5 and innovation Festschrift for Sture Brändström Cecilia Ferm Thorgersen & Sidsel Karlsen (Eds.) Cecilia Ferm Thorgersen & Sidsel Karlsen (Eds.) Music, education and innovation FESTSCHRIFT FOR STURE BRÄNDSTRÖM Luleå University of Technology Department of Music and Media 1 Distribution: Luleå University of Technology Department of Music and Media Box 744 941 28 Piteå Sweden Telephone: 0046 911 726 00 Fax: 0046 911 726 10 Published electronically at http://epubl.ltu.se Cecilia Ferm Thorgersen and Sidsel Karlsen (Eds.) Music, innovation and education: Festschrift for Sture Brändström ISBN: 978-91-7439-127-5 © The editors and the authors own the copyright of their respective contributions Cover layout: Elisabeth Sandin Printed at: University press, Luleå University of Technology, August 2010 2 CONTENTS Cecilia Ferm Thorgersen & Sidsel Karlsen: Fifteen years of innovative leadership: Professor Sture Brändström and the development of the research environment at the Department of Music and Media in Piteå............................................................................................................................................5 Christer Wiklund: Tal till Sture............................................................................................................................ 13 KG Johansson: What chord was that? A study of strategies among ear players in rock music ........... 17 Cecilia Ferm Thorgersen: Inclusion and involvement: Special needs in music education from a life-world phenomenological perspective............................................................................................ 33 Johnny Wingstedt: Narrative media music – functions and knowledge ........................................................ 53 Ketil Thorgersen: Music education with ears wide open – some new sounds for some old ways of thinking? About open access and licensing of artistic and intellectual property and possible implications for music education........................................................................ 67 Geir Johansen: Educational quality and the selection of content – the views and opinions of Musikdidaktik professors...................................................................................................... 87 3 Ann-Christine Wennergren: Tyst kunskap i ljuset av verksamhetsutveckling............................................................. 103 Anna-Karin Gullberg: BoomTown Music Education – an introduction........................................................... 123 Cecilia Ferm Thorgersen & Ann-Christine Wennergren: How to challenge seminar traditions in an academic community............................... 145 Inga Rikandi, Sidsel Karlsen & Heidi Westerlund: Bridging practices in Nordic music education doctoral programmes: Theorising and evaluating the Finnish application of the Piteå model.................................................. 165 Sverker Jullander: The development of musical performance as a research subject at Luleå University of Technology .......................................................................................................................... 191 Åsa Unander-Scharin: Dancing machines............................................................................................................... 205 Lena Weman Ericsson: En musikalisk lärprocess på 1700-talet – en studie av J H Romans ornamentskisser till en violinsonat av A Corelli .......................................................................................... 225 Hans-Ola Ericsson: Dikt till Sture ....................................................................................................................... 243 List of contributors............................................................................................................. 245 Content of CD .................................................................................................................... 249 4 INTRODUCTION Fifteen years of innovative leadership: Professor Sture Brändström and the development of the research environment at the Department of Music and Media in Piteå Cecilia Ferm Thorgersen and Sidsel Karlsen What constitutes a strong leader, or a good one? What makes a leader successful? Or an even more complex question: What are the characteristics of the leaders who through their leadership enable innovation and change, allowing the persons they lead to thrive and grow both as individuals and a collective, whilst at the same time creating a vigorous and competent research community? Whatever these characteristics are, they are certainly to be found in professor Sture Brändström, a leader of research who not only possesses the strong ability to recognise fruitful research work in motion, but who also displays the rare skill of putting the processes and products in the foreground, even to the extent that he sometimes brackets his own authoritative position if that proves to be beneficial for the work in question. This skill must, however, not be mistaken for invisibility or weakness. Rather, some leaders become strong, good and successful, not by imposing their impressive persona upon their surroundings, but rather by carefully and thoughtfully preparing the nourishing soil for their community’s continuous growth by working calmly and tirelessly, always with an open mind towards the surrounding society as well as the needs and initiatives of co-workers. It is our experience and belief that Sture Brändström is a leader of this rare kind. It is also our conviction that the fact that the research environment at the Department of Music and Media in Piteå today, in 2010, 5 stands out as one of the most innovative of its kind, both in Sweden and internationally, is much due to his unique abilities and efforts. For the past 15 years, Sture Brändström has been the head of music education (ämnesföreträdare) at the Department of Music and Media, Luleå University of Technology as well as the driving force behind the development of this department’s research environment. His professional activities during those years can be summed up by the words that constitute the title of this Festschrift, namely: music, education and innovation. While the music and the education aspects have been evident since the beginning of his career, among other things through his training and work as a concert pianist and a piano teacher, the aspect of innovation is perhaps most visible if we take a closer look at his scholarly contributions and leadership. At a time when most of the Nordic music education community directed their research interests towards formal educational environments, Sture had the courage to support projects that went far beyond this scope, supervising research that for example aimed to investigate rock musicians’ ear playing strategies and musical socialisation, the learning outcome of music festival attendance as well as what youngsters learn musically while playing seemingly non-educational computer games. From being considered, by some, as existing out of the range of the music education research field, these approaches may today be seen as central to its further development. While other research leaders may seek to sharpen their community’s competence by narrowing down its field of interest, Sture’s strategy has been to allow for broad and rich influences through creating a community that not only includes researchers of music education, but also scholars from subject areas such as musical performance, audio technology and general education – a multi-disciplinary approach that is increasingly recognised as valuable. Being employed by a university which highlights and celebrates the concept of ‘entrepreneurialism’, Sture has certainly contributed his share in this domain by initiating a large number of successful research and developmental projects in collaboration with national, Northern and international partners. The aim of this anthology is hence, in honour of Sture’s work, to show 6 some of the fruits of his efforts by collecting contributions from most of the former PhD students who have graduated from the Department of Music and Media in Piteå and who were so fortunate to have Sture as a supervisor1, as well as former and current colleagues within the fields of musical performance and music education. In the following, we will provide the reader with an overview by briefly describing the book’s different sections and chapters as well as outlining some of the projects and interests that Sture has encouraged and supported throughout the past 15 years. Part one, Aspects of music education: Innovative approaches, presents four studies, philosophical as well as empirical, carried out within the field of music education. The first chapter, What chord was that? A study of strategies among ear players in rock music, summarises KG Johansson’s PhD thesis which he defended in 2002. The study widens the field of music education, as it includes and recognises ear playing among adult musicians as a field of interest. The aim of the study was to investigate which strategies ear players use when they are expected to play unfamiliar rock songs. Johansson concludes that ear playing is learned by playing by ear, and furthermore, that the learning is genre-specific. Knowledge of clichés, harmonic formulas and other stylistic traits of a genre seem to be crucial in order to be able to play unknown songs by ear. KG Johansson