Historical Archaeology of the Delaware Valley, 1600-1850
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Historical Archaeology of the Delaware Valley, 1600–1850 Historical Archaeology of the Delaware Valley, 1600–1850 Edited by Richard Veit and David Orr THE UNIVERSITY OF TENNESSEE PRESS / KNOXVILLE f Copyright © 2014 by The University of Tennessee Press / Knoxville All Rights Reserved. Manufactured in the United States of America. First Edition. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Historical archaeology of the Delaware Valley, 1600–1850 / edited by Richard Veit and David Orr. — First edition. pages cm Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-1-62190-028-3 1. Delaware River Valley (N.Y.-Del. and N.J.)—Antiquities. 2. Delaware River Valley (N.Y.-Del. and N.J.)—History, Local. I. Veit, Richard Francis, 1968– II. Orr, David Gerald, 1942– F157.D4H56 2013 974.9—dc23 2013010717 Contents Acknowledgments xi Introduction xiii Richard Veit and David Orr 1. American Indian Archaeology of the Historic Period in the Delaware Valley 1 R. Michael Stewart 2. Charles Conrad Abbott’s Archaeological Investigations at a Seventeenth- Century House on Burlington Island, New Jersey 49 Carolyn Dillian, Charles Bello, Richard Veit, and Sean McHugh 3. Marcus Hook, Pennsylvania: Working Toward the Preservation of a Significant Historical Landscape 75 Joseph R. Blondino 4. Unearthing Wistarburgh: America’s First Successful Glasshouse 93 Damon Tvaryanas and William B. Liebeknecht 5. Transculturation and Ethnogenesis: Material Culture from an Eighteenth- Century Pennsylvania German Farmstead/Distillery 125 Patricia Gibble 6. The Archaeology of Food in Colonial Pennsylvania: Historical Zooarchaeological Exploration of Foodways on the Stenton Plantation 151 Teagan Schweitzer 7. The Roosevelt Inlet Shipwreck, An Eighteenth-Century British Commercial Vessel in the Lower Delaware Bay: A Framework for Interpretation 171 Daniel R. Griffith and Charles Fithian 8. The Archaeology of Quakerism in Philadelphia and Beyond: Identity, Conformity, and Context 185 John M. Chenoweth 9. The Baker and the Quaker: Ongoing Research from the National Constitution Center Site 205 William Hoffman and Deborah Miller 10. Rediscovering Franklin: The Archaeology of Benjamin Franklin in Philadelphia 227 Patrice L. Jeppson 11. The Early Poor in Philadelphia: A Preliminary Report on the Philadelphia City Almshouse Privy Excavation 249 Mara Kaktins and Sharon Allitt 12. The Root of the Matter: Searching for William Hamilton’s Greenhouse at the Woodlands Estate, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 273 Sarah Chesney 13. “He Will Be a Bourgeois American and Spend His Fortune in Making Gardens”: An Archaeological Examination of Joseph Bonaparte’s Point Breeze Estate 297 Richard Veit and Michael Gall 14. Historical Archaeology in Trenton: A Thirty-Year Retrospective 323 Richard W. Hunter and Ian Burrow 15. It Takes a Village: Archaeology and Identity at Timbuctoo 375 Christopher P. Barton Contributors 393 Index 399 Illustrations Figures Figure 1.1. Map of the Delaware Valley 3 Figure 1.2. Pennsylvania Portions of the Study Area Showing Counties 16 Figure 1.3. New Jersey Portions of the Study Area Showing Counties 17 Figure 2.1. Charles Conrad Abbott 50 Figure 2.2. Burlington Island, New Jersey 51 Figure 2.3. Glass Beads from the “Dutch Fur-Trader’s House” Collection 58 Figure 2.4. Tobacco Pipes from the “Dutch Fur-Trader’s House” Collection 60 Figure 2.5. 1876 Map of Burlington Island 62 Figure 2.6. 1893 USGS Topographic Quadrangle 63 Figure 2.7. December 29, 1937, Aerial Photograph of Burlington Island 64 Figure 2.8. 2009 Aerial Photograph of Burlington Island 65 Figure 3.1. The Marcus Hook Plank Log House 76 Figure 3.2. Interior View of the Marcus Hook Plank House 80 Figure 3.3. Excavation Unit of the Marcus Hook Plank House 83 Figure 3.4. Shovel Testing in the Median of Market Street 88 Figure 4.1. An Eighteenth-Century Glassworks Producing Cylinders for Windows 104 Figure 4.2. Fragments of Ceramic Pots and Blowpipes 106 Figure 4.3. Glass Shards from the Manufacture of Cylinder Glass 108 Figure 4.4. Mid-Eighteenth-Century Map Showing the Wistarburgh Glassworks and Other Associated Structures 111 Figure 4.5. Bottle Finish Fragments Recovered from the Wistarburgh Site 113 Figure 5.1. Crew Excavating the Original Section of the Alexander Schaeffer Farm/ Distillery 128 Figure 5.2. Exposed Eighteenth-Century Brick and Tile Firebox Bases 133 Figure 5.3. Excavation Grid Showing the Basement Distilling Room and Farmhouse Exterior 134 Figure 5.4. Artifacts from a Sheet Midden Deposit 135 Figure 5.5. Slip-Decorated and Plain Glazed Domestic Redware 138 Figure 5.6. Original Section of the Alexander Schaeffer Farmhouse 143 Figure 6.1. South-Facing Façade of the Stenton Main House 152 Figure 6.2. Stenton Archaeological Site Plan 155 Figure 7.1. 1756 Map of Lower Delaware Bay Showing Shipwreck Location 172 Figure 7.2. Frankfurter Ware 173 Figure 7.3. Hand Painted Creamware 174 Figure 7.4. Dutch Tobacco Pipes 175 Figure 9.1. Two Privy Features from the NCC Site during Excavation 209 Figure 9.2. China Glaze Wares from Feature 193 213 Figure 9.3. Children’s Cups from Feature 91 219 Figure 10.1. First Excavations Undertaken in 1953 228 Figure 10.2. Conjectural Drawing of Franklin’s Mansion by W. C. Campbell, Circa 1963 229 Figure 10.3. The Franklin Mansion “Ghost House” Sculpture 230 Figure 10.4. Mastodon Tooth Discovered in 1959 and Drawing of the Now-Extinct Mammut americanum 236 Figure 10.5 The Independence Park Unit of Franklin Court 240 Figure 10.6. Franklin Court Field Slide Taken in 1962 243 Figure 11.1. Plan View Showing the Almshouse Complex Superimposed on a Modern Aerial Photograph of Philadelphia 251 Figure 11.2. Base of a Locally-Produced Redware Chamber, Incised with the Letters “CM” 262 Figure 11.3. Base of a Locally-Produced Redware Chamber Pot, Incised with the Letter “X” 263 Figure 11.4. Fragments of a Scratch Blue Stoneware Tea Set 265 Figure 11.5. A Wine Bottle Bearing the Seal of John Pole 267 Figure 12.1. Portrait of William Hamilton and Anne Hamilton Lyle 275 Figure 12.2. The Greenhouse Complex at the Elgin Botanic Gardens, New York, circa 1801 276 Figure 12.3. Composite Map of the Historic Core of The Woodlands 279 Figure 12.4. Brick and Mortar Cistern at The Woodlands 280 Figure 12.5. Overall Photo of Unit Three Showing Both Brick Drains, the Cistern, and the Partial Foundation of the Greenhouse 284 Figure 13.1. Point Breeze on the Delaware, Thomas Birch, 1818 298 Figure 13.2. Students excavating at Point Breeze 299 Figure 13.3. Point Breeze 1823 301 Figure 13.4. Surface and Subsurface Features Identified Near the Site of the First Mansion 308 Figure 13.5. French Earthenware Plate with a Fine Transfer Print 312 Figure 13.6. Fragment of an Early-Nineteenth-Century Teapot 314 Figure 13.7. Early-Twentieth Century Postcard Showing the Entrance to Joseph Bonaparte’s Point Breeze Estate 316 Figure 14.1a and b. Historical Archaeological Sites Investigated in Trenton, circa 1980–2010 334 Figure 14.2. The Lambert/Douglas House, circa 1701–1790 339 Figure 14.3. The Petty’s Run Archaeological Site 344 Figure 14.4. William Richards’ Stoneware Pottery Kiln, circa 1774–1776 347 Figure 15.1. Location of Timbuctoo 376 Figure 15.2. 1849 Map of Timbuctoo and Mount Holly, New Jersey 379 Figure 15.3. Map of Greenwich Line of the Underground Railroad 381 Figure 15.4. The “Battle of Pine Swamp” 382 Figure 15.5. Feature Thirteen after Excavation 386 Tables Table 1.1. Some Historic Developments of the Delaware River Basin and Environs 8 Table 1.2. American Indian Sites of the Historic Period in the Delaware River Basin and Environs 9 Table 5.1. Material Culture from Contiguous Deposits, 1760–1810 136 Table 5.2. Ceramic Types and Forms, 1760–1820 137 Table 6.1. Distribution of Bones in Feature 14 159 Table 7.1. Goods Recovered from the Roosevelt Inlet Shipwreck 179 Table 7.2. Re-export Items Recovered from the Roosevelt Inlet Shipwreck 180 Table 13.1. Mapped and Identified Surface Features 309 Acknowledgments We are indebted to a number of people and organizations for their assistance during the preparation of this book. We particularly appreciate the assistance of Lu Ann De Cunzo and an anonymous reviewer who helped us refine our arguments and better organize the volume. The patience and guidance of editor Thomas Wells was invalu- able as we moved this volume toward publication. Michelle Hughes prepared the in- dex. We also appreciate the endless encouragement of our students and colleagues at Monmouth and Temple universities as we discussed various aspects of this volume. We also owe a debt to our colleagues and friends, whose research on the Delaware Valley and its archaeological history inspired this work, especially, Bernard Herman, Anthony N. B. Garvan, John Cotter, Herbert Kraft, Robert Schuyler, and Marshall Becker. The volume was improved by our discussions with Sherene Baugher, Michael Gall, Adam Heinrich, and Michael Stewart. Finally, the support and forbearance of our wives, Terri Veit and Linda Orr, and our families, as we spent our days with the shades of Dutch settlers on Burlington Island, pirates and their lasses in Marcus Hook, Ben Franklin and the Great American Incognitum, Casper Wistar and his glass- blowers in South Jersey, William Hamilton at The Woodlands, African-Americans fighting for their freedom at Timbuctoo, and many others, is truly appreciated. Introduction Historical Archaeology of the Delaware Valley, 1600–1850 is meant to be a selec- tive reader on the archaeology of one of colonial America’s great cultural hearths. Historical archaeologists have been studying sites in the Delaware Valley for over a century (see Abbott 1892, 1894; Mercer 1897; Cadzow 1936; Allen 1991), and sev- eral excellent books have been published on the historical archaeology of the region’s major city, Philadelphia (Cotter, Roberts, and Parrington 1993; Yamin 2008).