DOCSLIB.ORG

A Day (Nearly) Like Any Other: Healthcare Work in an Influenza Pandemic

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
A Day (Nearly) Like Any Other: Healthcare Work in an Influenza Pandemic A DAY (NEARLY) LIKE ANY OTHER: HEALTHCARE WORK IN AN INFLUENZA PANDEMIC CAROLINE SAINT A THESIS SUBMITTED IN FULFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY FACULTY OF LAW UNIVERSITY OF SYDNEY JANUARY 2017 I ABSTRACT The World Health Organization has long anticipated an outbreak of a highly pathogenic influenza. Fear of a highly virulent influenza has been compounded by the 2003 outbreak of Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS) where some health workers refused to work. In light of this, the question has been asked whether healthcare workers would continue to work during an influenza pandemic. Worryingly, surveys suggest that many would not. The thesis explores past experience of some ‘new’ infectious diseases and how these impacted on the health workforce. It considers evidence from the 1918 influenza pandemic, where (for the most part) nurses were not over-represented in the death statistics. It is argued that all infectious disease is not the same and a one-size approach by way of either compulsion or incentives to work should not be adopted. In situations where a healthcare worker faces a higher risk of infection and serious illness than the general population and attending at work could expose their family to additional risk (as was the case in SARS) consideration may need to be given to incentives to encourage work performance rather than any form of compulsion. However, the thesis argues that the health workforce would not be at greater risk during an influenza pandemic and the common law contract of employment sufficiently compels work performance, with public sector employees having a greater obligation to work than might their private sector counterparts. During an influenza pandemic workloads may increase but it will be a day (nearly) like any other. i II ACKNOWLEDGMENTS There are so many people I need to thank, but particular mention goes to the following individuals: Professor Belinda Bennett (since 2014 at QUT) and Emeritus Professor Terry Carney (AO) thank you for the opportunity, and an ARC Scholarship that enabled me to undertake this project. Your patience, support and encouragement, even at times when it seemed I would never finish, was always appreciated. Thank you for both staying the distance. To A/Professor Shae McCrystal; I have the privilege of being your first PhD completion. Thank you for accepting me as a student. It was much appreciated that you made time to meet when you were in Tasmania. Your encouragement (even before becoming my supervisor), direction and structural suggestions have been invaluable: thank you. Professor Cameron Stewart, thank you for taking the time to read though a very rough draft of this paper; your comments were extremely helpful. This experience would have been considerably more difficult without the support of the First Tuesday Thesis Club (FTTC) which, despite its name, hardly ever met on a Tuesday! Debates flourished as wine was drunk and friendships formed. While the first to start, I am the fourth to finish. Congratulations to Dr Nuncio D’Angelo; Dr Amanda Porter; Dr Felicity Bell with Tanya Mitchell to soon fly the nest. Thank you all for your emotional support during some difficult years as well as lots of interesting face-to-face and email discussions. Tony and Judy Anderson, thank you for your friendship. Thank you for caring so much for Jill before, and while, she was unwell. Your gentle encouragements and constant reminders that Jill would have wanted this finished, helped get me to this point. Elizabeth, the best sister ever: thanks for everything. This thesis is the culmination of a long journey that started many years ago with an undergraduate degree after Jill Meikle said ‘you should go to university’. For over twenty years Jill was my anchor in life and I still find it hard to believe she is not here to see this part of the journey finally finished. Thank you Jill for your love, generosity of spirit, boundless enthusiasm and constant encouragement: as well as several exciting sailing adventures. ii III DECLARATION OF ORIGINALITY I hereby certify that this thesis is entirely my own work and that any material written by others has been acknowledged in the text. The thesis has not been presented for a degree or for any other purposes at The University of Sydney or at any other university or institution. Signed: Date: 30 June 2016 iii IV TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTER ONE - INTRODUCTION I Introduction ............................................................................................................. 6 Key argument and scope of thesis ........................................................................... 7 II What is meant by ‘Pandemic’? ................................................................................. 11 III Infectious disease and health care work ................................................................ 13 IV Why is this discussion important? ........................................................................ 20 Chapter Outline ...................................................................................................... 25 CHAPTER TWO - INFLUENZA I Introduction ........................................................................................................... 30 II The Influenza A Virus ............................................................................................. 31 Cellular invasion and replication of the influenza virus ...................................... 32 III Influenza A - illness in the human population ..................................................... 34 Zoonosis a human risk ........................................................................................... 37 Highly pathogenic avian influenza (H5N1) ........................................................... 40 Seasonal Influenza .................................................................................................. 43 Pandemic Influenza ................................................................................................ 44 IV Estimating rates of influenza ................................................................................. 46 Surveillance for influenza ...................................................................................... 49 International Health Regulations .......................................................................... 52 V The pandemic of 2009 ........................................................................................... 53 Mortality rates in 2009 .......................................................................................... 55 Pre-pandemic exposure of health workers ........................................................... 56 VI Conclusion .............................................................................................................. 57 1 CHAPTER THREE - INFLUENZA 1918 I Introduction ........................................................................................................... 60 Science and infectious disease prior to 1918 .......................................................... 61 Australian efforts to exclude or contain influenza in 1918 ................................... 64 Border control 1918 ............................................................................................. 64 Vaccination ......................................................................................................... 66 Masks ............................................................................................................... 68 The 1918 influenza pandemic ................................................................................. 69 II Influenza and limited medical care 1918 ................................................................ 71 III The Australian Nursing Workforce ....................................................................... 76 Nursing workforce at the time of the 1919 pandemic ....................................... 76 Employment of nurses during the pandemic .................................................... 78 Compulsory inoculation of healthcare workers............................................. 80 Influenza mortality rates 1918 and healthcare workers ................................. 80 IV The once ‘forgotten’ 1918 influenza pandemic ...................................................... 82 V Influenza and SARS ................................................................................................ 85 VI Conclusion .............................................................................................................. 89 CHAPTER FOUR - CONTRACTUAL OBLIGATION TO WORK I Introduction ............................................................................................................ 91 Infectious diseases: a note ................................................................................. 92 II Healthcare Workers –willingness to work – survey responses ............................ 95 Other approaches to promote work compulsion .............................................. 97 III Common law contract of employment (Australia) ............................................. 100 IV Lawful and reasonable direction ......................................................................... 102 Would it be lawful and reasonable to expect HCWs to work during an influenza pandemic? ................................................................................................ 104 What might be the consequences
Load more

Recommended publications
  • WIDER Working Paper 2020/124-The Great Influenza Pandemic of 1918
    WIDER Working Paper 2020/124 The Great Influenza Pandemic of 1918–20 An interpretative survey in the time of COVID-19 Prema-chandra Athukorala1 and Chaturica Athukorala2 October 2020 Abstract: The Great Influenza Pandemic of 1918-20—commonly known as the Spanish flu— infected over a quarter of the world’s population and killed over 50 million people. It is by far the greatest humanitarian disaster caused by infectious disease in modern history. Epidemiologists and health scientists often draw on this experience to set the plausible upper bound (the ‘worst case scenario’) on future pandemic mortality. The purpose of this study is to piece together and analyse the scattered multi-disciplinary literature on the pandemic in order to place debates on the evolving course of the current COVID-19 crisis in historical perspective. The analysis focuses on the changing characteristics of pathogens and disease over time, the institutional factors that shaped the global spread, and the demographic and socio-economic consequences. Key words: Spanish flu, COVID-19, pandemic, infectious JEL classification: F50, I10, O50, Z19 Acknowledgements: The authors are grateful to Sisira Jayasuriya for stimulating their interest in this subject and to Wishnu Mahraddhika and Wannaphong Durogkaveroj for assistance with accessing Indonesian- and Thai-language literature, respectively. They thank Soma Athukorala for help with the literature search and gratefully acknowledge comments received from Tony Addison, Hal Hill, and the participants of the Trade and Development Seminar in the Arndt-Corden Department of Economics, Australian National University. 1 Arndt-Corden Department of Economics, Crawford School of Public Policy, Australian National University, Canberra, Australia; corresponding author: [email protected]; 2 Department of Medical Imaging, The Canberra Hospital, Australia, [email protected] This study has been prepared within the UNU-WIDER project on Academic excellence.
    [Show full text]
  • Behind the Mask
    BEHIND THE MASK: Determinants of Nurses’ Adherence to Recommended Use of Facial Protective Equipment to Prevent Occupational Transmission of Communicable Respiratory Illness in Acute Care Hospitals by Kathryn Anne Nichol A thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Institute of Medical Science University of Toronto © Copyright by Kathryn Anne Nichol (2010) BEHIND THE MASK: Determinants of Nurses’ Adherence to Recommended Use of Facial Protective Equipment to Prevent Occupational Transmission of Communicable Respiratory Illness in Acute Care Hospitals Kathryn Anne Nichol Doctor of Philosophy Institute of Medical Science University of Toronto 2010 Abstract (max 350w) Background - Communicable respiratory illness is a serious occupational threat to healthcare workers. A key reason for occupational transmission is failure to implement appropriate barrier precautions. Facial protective equipment, including surgical masks, respirators and eye/face protection, is the least adhered to type of personal protective equipment used by healthcare workers, yet it is an important barrier precaution against communicable respiratory illness. Objectives - To describe nurses‘ adherence to recommended use of facial protective equipment and to identify the factors that influence adherence. Methods - A two-phased study was conducted. Phase 1 was a cross-sectional survey of nurses in selected units of six acute care hospitals in Toronto, Canada. Phase 2 was a direct observational study of critical care nurses. ii Results – Of the 1074 nurses who completed surveys (82% response rate), 44% reported adherence to recommended use of facial protective equipment. Multivariable analysis revealed four organizational predictors of adherence: ready availability of equipment, regular training and fit testing, organizational support for health and safety, and good communication.
    [Show full text]
  • Global Effort Pays Off.. Smallpox at Target "Zero"
    DXIEIJMECIX: CENTER FOR DISEASE CONTROL ATLANTA, GEORGIA 30333 VOLUME 11, NO. 10 Zero Smallpox Issue This issue of DATELINE: CDC is devoted to the story of the eradi­ cation of smallpox and CDC's in­ volvement. Inside stories include: • Historical vignettes • Pictures of field work • The last case of U.S. smallpox • An early campaign to eliminate the disease • Technology of eradication • Future of the smallpox virus • Chronology of smallpox, and others ft#***#*####*#****#*#*********** Throughout this issue are scattered stories o f "unsung heroes" from many nations who worked with CDC staff in V A R IO LA MAJOR'S last case Rahima Banu, AFTER RECOVERY, Ali Maow Maalin, the fight against smallpox. We have a little girl in Bangladesh who survived. will have chance for normal life. asked the staffers who worked with them to write about them, and all Global Effort Pays Off.. represent true stories o f the eradica­ tion battle. Smallpox at Target "Zero" -ft****************************** The last documented, naturally occurring case of smallpox was diagnosed in Physicians Challenged Merka, Somalia, in 1977. On October 26, 1979, the world celebrated its second anniversary free from smallpox transmission. Smallpox in 1844 A li Maow Maalin, then 23, was a of confidence among a trained army of The WHO campaign against small­ cook in Somalia when he came down smallpox fighters from most of the pox wasn't the first time war had been with smallpox. When he recovered, nations of the world — confidence that declared on the disease. he became the last recorded case of they could be successful in combat In 1844 the progress of a vaccina­ variola minor, a less severe form of with an old enemy.
    [Show full text]
  • The Great Influenza Also by John M
    THE GREAT INFLUENZA ALSO BY JOHN M. BARRY Rising Tide: The Great Mississippi Flood of 1927 and How It Changed America Power Plays: Politics, Football, and Other Blood Sports The Transformed Cell: Unlocking the Mysteries of Cancer (with Steven Rosenberg) The Ambition and the Power: A True Story of Washington THE GREAT INFLUENZA The Epic Story of the Deadliest Plague in History JOHN M. BARRY VIKING VIKING Published by the Penguin Group Penguin Group (USA) Inc., 375 Hudson Street, New York, New York 10014, U.S.A. Penguin Books Ltd, 80 Strand, London WC2R 0RL, England Penguin Books Australia Ltd, 250 Camberwell Road, Camberwell, Victoria 3124, Australia Penguin Books Canada Ltd, 10 Alcorn Avenue, Toronto, Ontario, Canada M4V 3B2 Penguin Books India (P) Ltd, 11 Community Centre, Panchsheel Park, New Delhi – 110 017, India Penguin Books (N.Z.) Ltd, Cnr Rosedale and Airborne Roads, Albany, Auckland, New Zealand Penguin Books (South Africa) (Pty) Ltd, 24 Sturdee Avenue, Rosebank, Johannesburg 2196, South Africa Penguin Books Ltd, Registered Offices: 80 Strand, London WC2R 0RL, England Copyright © John M. Barry, 2004 All rights reserved Photograph credits appear on Back Matter. LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOGING-IN-PUBLICATION DATA Barry, John M. The great influenza: the epic story of the deadliest plague in history / John M. Barry. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references. ISBN: 1-101-20097-9 1. Influenza—History—20th century. I. Title. RC150.4.B37 2004 614.5'18'09041—dc22 2003057646 Without limiting the rights under copyright reserved above, no part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in or introduced into a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means (electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise), without the prior written permission of both the copyright owner and the above publisher of this book.
    [Show full text]
  • Conference Transcripts
    SARS in the Context of A New York Academy of Sciences Conference, Emerging Infectious Threats May 17, 2003 CONFERENCE TRANSCRIPT Welcome Ellis Rubinstein, Chief Executive Officer, New York Academy of Sciences An Academy Tradition of Convening Scientists Welcome to the New York Academy of Sciences. I think we have a packed room, so I think we should start. I am Ellis Rubinstein, the chief executive officer of the Academy, and it is a pleasure to welcome you all here. As some of you may know, I've been CEO here for only six months. That's in contrast to the fact that this place has been here for 186 years and, some people might not know, is the third oldest, I think, sci- entific society that's been continuously running, and it's had an extremely wonderful history in many ways. Thomas Jefferson was a member, and Darwin was a member, so it's been global for a long time. I guess in my mind some of the best things it has done is to convene people across disciplines and barriers on important topics. Some people here may or may not know that the Academy was the first organiza- tion to run a major meeting on AIDS. The meeting that we're going to hold here today is in keeping with a tradition that has gone back for some time of doing these kinds of important convening tasks. I would say, I think quite safely, that never in the history of the Academy could they have produced a meeting as rapidly as this one was done.
    [Show full text]
  • Article Effectiveness of a Mobile Short-Message-Service–Based Disease Outbreak Alert System in Kenya (M
    BOOKS AND MEDIA Adventures of a Female Investigation surprises abound in Dr. Guinan’s ac- count. Some involve the investigator herself. “I don’t think Medical Detective: In Pursuit anyone grows up wanting to be a physician who specializes of Smallpox and AIDS in sexually transmitted diseases.” “I was never the most important leader. A medical detective has a small part in a Mary Guinan, PhD, MD, with Anne D. Mather; team effort, usually a very large team….the medical detec- Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD, USA, 2016; tives who collect clues, analyze data, investigate suspected ISBN-13: 978-1-4214-1999-2; Pages: 144; Price: $24.95 cases, and carry out their public health mission.” ight-hearted and easy to read, Mary Guinan’s account Some surprises involve the context of the investiga- Lof her career as an epidemiologist accomplishes its tion: for example, the Mujahideen in an Afghan refugee goal, “To help readers better understand and value the pub- camp asking Dr. Guinan for weapons to fight in the Haj lic health system that exists for the protection of the na- in 1980. She worked in the cramped quarters of a hotel tion’s health and for the prevention of disease and injury.” in the Tenderloin District of San Francisco, identifying From the early definition of the “hole in the sole,” the epi- what would eventually be called the first AIDS cases. She demiologist’s trademark, to the description of the Sherlock later had to explain to the public that “nice” women can Holmes method, the epidemiologist’s approach to public get AIDS.
    [Show full text]
  • Maladies Infectieuses Émergentes » Actualités Et Propositions
    Actes du 5e séminaire « Maladies Infectieuses Émergentes » Actualités et propositions 22 mars 2016 Propositions prioritaires 1. Encourager la recherche sur la prévision, le dépistage et la détection précoces des nouveaux risques infectieux 2. Développer la recherche et la surveillance sur la transmission des agents infectieux entre l’animal et l’humain, en les renforçant, en particulier dans les zones inter- tropicales, « points chauds » (« hotspots ») pour le risque infectieux, grâce à des aides publiques 3. Poursuivre, dans ces zones, le développement et le soutien des actions de prévention et de formation des acteurs de santé locaux et favoriser la culture du risque dans les populations 4. Prendre en charge les patients de façon adaptée afin de favoriser l'adhésion aux soins et aux mesures visant à réduire la diffusion d'une épidémie 5. Développer la sensibilisation et l’entraînement des acteurs politiques et sanitaires, afin de mieux les préparer à la réponse aux crises de typologie nouvelle 6. Réviser les logiques de gouvernance en s’appuyant sur tous les modes de communication disponibles, intégrant les nouveaux outils d’information collaborative 7. Développer les recherches économiques sur la lutte contre les MIE, tenant compte des déterminants spécifiques afin d’équilibrer les démarches préventives et curatives 1- Introduction première a été donnée par le Dr Peter Daszak (Président d’EcoHealth Alliance et La 5ème édition du séminaire de l'Ecole du responsable du programme USAID-EPT- Val-de-Grâce avait pour objectifs PREDICT), et l'autre par le Dr. Patrick l’approche globale de l’émergence de Lagadec (ancien directeur de recherche à nouveaux agents infectieux, la mise en l'Ecole Polytechnique).
    [Show full text]
  • Mount Sinai Hospital
    Toronto Invasive Bacterial Diseases Network CONSENT TO PARTICIPATE IN A RESEARCH STUDY - STAFF/CAREGIVER TIBDN CO-ORDINATING INVESTIGATOR: Dr. Allison McGeer 416-586-3123 Study Title: Immunogenicity of COVID-19 Vaccines in Long Term Care Study Doctors: Dr. Anne Claude Gingras, Sinai Health System Dr. Allison McGeer, Sinai Health System Dr. Mario Ostrowski, Unity Health Dr. Jen Gommerman, University of Toronto Dr. Sharon Straus, Unity Health Toronto RESEARCH ASSOCIATES: Mr. Agron Plevneshi Funding Source: Canadian Immunity Task Force Ms. Nadia Malik Ms. Mare Pejkovska Ms. Asfia Sultana Introduction: Ms. Amna Faheem You are being asked to take part in a research study. Please read the information about Ms. Saman Khan Mr. Kazi Hassan the study presented in this form. The form includes details on the study’s risks and Ms. Tamara Vikulova benefits that you should know before you decide if you would like to take part. You Ms. Gloria Crowl Ms. Zoe Zhong should take as much time as you need to make your decision. You should ask the study Ms. Lubna Farooqi doctor or study staff to explain anything that you do not understand and make sure that all of your questions have been answered before signing this consent form. Before you RESEARCH TECHNOLOGISTS: make your decision, feel free to talk about this study with anyone you wish. Participation Ms. Aimee Paterson in this study is voluntary. Ms. Angel Xin Liu Purpose: The purpose of this study is to better understand the body’s immune response to COVID- MAIN OFFICE: Mount Sinai Hospital 19, including which factors protect against COVID-19 infection, and how vaccines work 600 University Avenue against COVID-19, an infection due to a new coronavirus.
    [Show full text]
  • COVID-19 CALTCM Weekly Rounds 04062020 Handout
    COVID-19: CALTCM Weekly Rounds 4/6/20 Preparing for the Next Wave CALTCM is a non-profit association. Please consider supporting our efforts with a donation to CALTCM and/or by joining/renewing your membership today. Visit: caltcm.org Non-Profit Status The California Association of Long Term Care Medicine (CALTCM) is currently exempt under section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code. Contributions or charitable donations made to our non-profit organization are tax-deductible under section 170 of the Code. April 6, 2020 To request a copy of our 501(c)(3) status letter or current Form W -9, please contact the CALTCM Executive Office at (888) 332-3299 or e-mail: [email protected] 1 2 Webinar Faculty & Moderator Webinar Faculty Michael Wasserman, MD, CMD Allison McGeer, M.D., FRCPC Geriatrician, President, CALTCM, Microbiologist, Infectious Disease Physician Medical Director, Eisenberg Village, Sinai Health System in Toronto Los Angeles Jewish Home April 6, 2020 April 6, 2020 3 4 Webinar Faculty Webinar Faculty Deborah Milito Pharm D, BCGP, FASCP Jay Luxenberg, MD Director of Clinical and Consultant Services Chief Medical Officer, On Lok LTC Division/Chief Antimicrobial Stewardship CALTCM, Wave Editor-in-Chief Officer Diamond Pharmacy Services; Chair ASCP Antimicrobial and Infection Prevention and Control Committee; Member ASCP COVID-19 Task Force April 6, 2020 April 6, 2020 5 6 1 COVID-19: CALTCM Weekly Rounds 4/6/20 Preparing for the Next Wave Webinar Faculty Dolly Greene RN, BSN©, CIC Preparing for Infection Prevention & Control Resources Expert Stewardship the Next Wave April 6, 2020 7 8 Objectives What is new with COVID19 this week? • What is new with COVID-19 this week?; Long term care outbreaks • Review NEJM article; • Discuss asymptomatic and pre-symptomatic viral shedding; Asymptomatic infection • Latest update on masks; Masks • Update on pharmacology and deprescribing.
    [Show full text]
  • How the Horrific 1918 Flu Spread Across America
    How the Horrific 1918 Flu Spread Across America The toll of history’s worst epidemic surpasses all the military deaths in World War I and World War II combined. And it may have begun in the United States An emergency hospital at Camp Funston, Kansas, 1918. “Of the 12 men who slept in my squad room, 7 were ill at one time,” a soldier recalled. (New Contributed Photographs Collection / otis historical Archives / National Museum of Health and Medicine) By John M. Barry Smithsonian Magazine November 2017 Haskell County, Kansas, lies in the southwest corner of the state, near Oklahoma and Colorado. In 1918 sod houses were still common, barely distinguishable from the treeless, dry prairie they were dug out of. It had been cattle country—a now bankrupt ranch once handled 30,000 head—but Haskell farmers also raised hogs, which is one possible clue to the origin of the crisis that would terrorize the world that year. Another clue is that the county sits on a major migratory flyway for 17 bird species, including sand hill cranes and mallards. Scientists today understand that bird influenza viruses, like human influenza viruses, can also infect hogs, and when a bird virus and a human virus infect the same pig cell, their different genes can be shuffled and exchanged like playing cards, resulting in a new, perhaps especially lethal, virus. We cannot say for certain that that happened in 1918 in Haskell County, but we do know that an influenza outbreak struck in January, an outbreak so severe that, although influenza was not then a “reportable” disease, a local physician named Loring Miner—a large and imposing man, gruff, a player in local politics, who became a doctor before the acceptance of the germ theory of disease but whose intellectual curiosity had kept him abreast of scientific developments—went to the trouble of alerting the U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Las Vegas, Nevada 89127 – (702) 385-1291 –
    ___________________________________________________________________________________ Mission: To protect and promote the health, the environment and the well-being of Clark County residents and visitors. ____________________________________________________________________________________ M I N U T E S CLARK COUNTY HEALTH DISTRICT DISTRICT BOARD OF HEALTH MEETING 625 Shadow Lane Las Vegas, Nevada 89106 Clemens Room Thursday, March 27, 2003 - 8:00 A.M. Chairman Reese called the meeting of the District Board of Health to order at 8 a.m. and the Pledge of Allegiance was held. He noted that he had been provided with the Affidavits of Posting and Mailing of Agenda meeting notices, as required by Nevada’s Open Meeting Law. The Affidavits will be incorporated into the Official Minutes. Board Members Present: Gary Reese Chairman, Councilman, Las Vegas Jim Christensen, MD Physician Member At-Large Andrea Anderson Councilman, Boulder City Sherry Colquitt, RN Appointee, Las Vegas Susan Crowley Appointee, Henderson Robert Eliason Councilman North Las Vegas Donna Fairchild Councilwoman, Mesquite Paul Henderson Councilman, Mesquite Donalene Ravitch, RN Appointee, Boulder City Rory Reid Commissioner, Clark County Stephanie Smith Councilwoman, North Las Vegas Absent: Steven Kirk Councilman, Henderson Chip Maxfield Commissioner, Clark County Executive Secretary: Donald S. Kwalick, MD, MPH Legal Counsel: Stephen Minagil, Esquire Staff: Karl Munninger; Glenn Savage; Fran Courtney, RN; Jane Shunney, RN; Rory Chetelat; Angus MacEachern; Ed Wojcik; Doug Joslin; Paul Klouse; Lonnie Empey; Rose Bell, PhD; Jeanne Palmer; Nicole Bungum; Marlo Tonge; Jennifer Sizemore; David Tonelli; Leo Vega; and Recording Secretaries Diana Lindquist and Montana Garcia P. O. Box 3902 – Las Vegas, Nevada 89127 – (702) 385-1291 – www.cchd.org Board of Health Minutes Page 2 of 8 March 27, 2003 ATTENDANCE: Irene Battle Sista to Sista Fred Couzen Las Vegas Tribune, Las Vegas Mercury Reva Anderson Sista to Sista Mary Guinan Nevada Public Health Association Uri Clinton Harrah’s Laughlin, Inc I.
    [Show full text]
  • CITATION: Ontario Nurses Association V. Eatonville/Henley Place, 2020 ONSC 2467 COURT FILE Nos: CV-20-639606-0000 and CV-20-639605-0000 DATE: 20200423
    CITATION: Ontario Nurses Association v. Eatonville/Henley Place, 2020 ONSC 2467 COURT FILE NOs: CV-20-639606-0000 and CV-20-639605-0000 DATE: 20200423 SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE – ONTARIO RE: ONTARIO NURSES’ ASSOCIATION, VICKI MCKENNA, RN and BEVERLY MATHERS, RN, Applicants – and – EATONVILLE CARE CENTRE FACILITY INC., ANSON PLACE CARE CENTRE FACILITY INC., HAWTHORNE PLACE CARE CENTRE FACILITY INC., RYKKA CARE CENTRES GP INC., RYKKA CARE CENTRES II GP INC., RESPONSIVE MANAGEMENT INC. and 2020 ONSC 2467 (CanLII) RESPONSIVE GROUP INC., Respondents – and – ATTORNEY GENERAL OF ONTARIO, Intervener AND RE: ONTARIO NURSES’ ASSOCIATION, VICKI MCKENNA, RN and BEVERLY MATHERS, RN, Applicants – and – HENLEY PLACE LIMITED AND PRIMACARE LIVING SOLUTIONS INC., Respondents – and – ATTORNEY GENERAL OF ONTARIO, Intervener BEFORE: E.M. Morgan J. COUNSEL: Kate Hughes, Philip Abbink, Janet Borowy, Danielle Bisnar, Tyler Boggs, Marcia Barry, Nicole Butt, for the Applicants Ian Dick, Sean Sells, and Mitchell Smith, for the Respondents Daniel Gutman, Andrea Bolieiro, and Kristen Smith, for the Intervener HEARD: April 22, 2020 APPLICATION FOR INJUNCTIVE RELIEF 2 I. Nursing staff and long-term care homes [1] The Applicants represent Registered Nurses employed by the long-term care (“LTC”) homes named as Respondents in these two companion Applications. They seek, on an urgent basis, mandatory Orders addressing what they describe as serious health and safety problems at these facilities. [2] The Applicants ask this court for an injunction requiring the Respondents to refrain from ongoing breaches of Directives issued by the Chief Medical Officer of Health for Ontario (“CMOH”) on March 30 and April 2, 2020. The Directives pertain to practices and procedures in LTC facilities and to the supply of personal protective equipment (“PPE”) – including the most 2020 ONSC 2467 (CanLII) protective N95 respirator masks – in those facilities, during the current COVID-19 pandemic.
    [Show full text]