Terrestrial Impacts of Cruise Tourism in Belize

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Terrestrial Impacts of Cruise Tourism in Belize Cruise Tourism in Belize: Perceptions of Economic, Social & Environmental Impact Researched and written by CENTER ON ECOTOURISM AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT CESD Headquarters: Stanford University Office: 1333 H Street, NW 450 Serra Mall Suite 300 East Tower Bldg 360, Rm 362K Washington, DC 20005 Stanford, CA 94305 Tel: 202-347-9203 www.ecotourismcesd.org Tel: 650-723-0894 In collaboration with November, 2006 TABLE OF CONTENTS List of Tables......................................................................................... 4 List of Figures ....................................................................................... 6 Acknowledgements .............................................................................. 7 Executive Summary.............................................................................. 9 Foreword.............................................................................................. 15 The Purpose .............................................................................................................15 Methodology .............................................................................................................16 CHAPTERS 1. BACKGROUND................................................................................ 20 Caribbean Cruise Tourism......................................................................................20 Cruise vs. Stayover Tourism in Belize..................................................................21 Tourism Village..................................................................................................26 2. Government Policies and Public Debates .................................... 32 Blackstone Report....................................................................................................32 Cruise Ship Policy, 2000 and 2003.......................................................................33 Carnival Cruise Contract and Cruise Tourism Impact Forum, 2004.........36 Debate at the 2004 Cruise Tourism Impact Forum.....................................38 A Clarification Agreement................................................................................41 White Paper, 2005 ...................................................................................................41 3. Survey Results and Analysis ......................................................... 44 Cruise Passengers...................................................................................................44 Cruise Ship Passenger Surveys.....................................................................44 Results................................................................................................................45 Cruise Vacation Characteristics .....................................................................46 Cruise Tourist In-port Activities.......................................................................48 Tour Expenditures ............................................................................................50 Non-Tour Expenditures....................................................................................53 Factors Influencing Cruise Tourists’ Decision to Disembark in Belize57 Cruise Tourists’ Opinion of Belize..................................................................59 Sensitivity to Changes in Travel Costs...................................................60 Willingness to Support Local Conservation...........................................62 Comparisons of Cruise and Stayover Tourists....................................................64 2003 Airport Survey Results ...........................................................................66 2 4. Interview Results and Analysis .................................................... 73 Belize Government Officials............................................................................74 Port Authorities..................................................................................................74 Local Businesses..............................................................................................74 Stayover Lodges ...............................................................................................75 Farmers and Fishermen ..................................................................................75 Protected Areas & Mayan Archeological Sites ............................................75 Tourism Sector Organizations ........................................................................75 Limitations..........................................................................................................76 Economic Impacts....................................................................................................76 General Tourism ...............................................................................................76 Cruise Tourism..................................................................................................77 “Stayover” Tourists vs. Cruise Tourists..................................................78 The Trickle-down Effect............................................................................81 Socio-Cultural Impacts ............................................................................................82 Environmental Impacts............................................................................................84 Maximum Capacity ...........................................................................................85 Habitats in Danger............................................................................................87 Waste..................................................................................................................91 Concluding Remarks ...............................................................................................92 5. Conclusions and Recommendations ............................................ 94 Conclusions...............................................................................................................94 Recommendations...................................................................................................99 APPENDICES A. About CESD and INCAE……………………………………………..106 B. Cruise Tourist Survey Instrument............................................... 108 C. Natural/Archaeological Destinations Interview Form ............... 113 D. Hotel/ Lodge/Resort Interview Form........................................... 121 E. Business Interview Form ............................................................. 125 F. Farmers/Fishermen Interview Form ............................................ 127 G. Government Officials Interview Form ........................................ 130 H. Port Authorities Interview Form.................................................. 133 I. Tourism Sector Interview Form .................................................... 135 Bibliography ...................................................................................... 139 3 LIST OF TABLES Table page Table A: Comparison of Cruise and Stayover Sectors.......................................14 Table B: Stakeholders Interviewed in Belize.........................................................18 Table 1.1: Stayover and Cruise Ship Arrivals to Belize, 1998 – 2005 .............24 Table 1.2: Monthly Cruise Tourist Visits to Belize, 1998-2005..........................25 Table 1.3a: Leading Cruise Line and Passenger Arrivals into Belize, 2004..26 Table 1.3b: Leading Cruise Line and Passenger Arrivals into Belize, 2005 .26 Table 2.1: Annual Stayover Tourism Arrivals in Central America, 2004........42 Table 2.2: Total Increase in Stayover Tourism, 2000-2004 ................................42 Table 3.1: Cruise tourists in Belize: Demographic information .......................46 Table 3.2: Travel habits of cruise tourists to Belize ............................................47 Table 3.3: General cruise vacation travel expenses, 2005, in US $*** ............48 Table 3.4: Cruise tourist activities and excursions in Belize............................50 Table 3.5: Prices of Tours Sold to Cruise Visitors in Belize by Vendor Type51 Table 3.6a: Amount spent (per person) while off of the ship, in US $ 2005 (excluding tour purchases) – All responses................................................53 Table 3.6b: Amount spent (per person) while off of the ship, in US $ 2005 (excluding tour purchases) – Nonzero responses.....................................54 Table 3.7: Factors contributing to cruise tourists’ decision to disembark in Belize ......................................................................................................................58 Table 3.8: Cruise tourists’ evaluation of their Belizean experience................60 Table 3.9: Maximum increase in total costs per person and still take this cruise ..................................................................................................................................61 Table 3.10: Maximum increase in total costs per person to still disembark in Belize ......................................................................................................................62 Table 3.11: Measures of sensitivity to changes in cruise costs and willingness to pay for conservation in Belize ....................................................................62 4 Table 3.12: Maximum willingness to pay for investment in Belizean culture and nature......................................................................................................................63
Recommended publications
  • Support for the Implementation of the National Sustainable Tourism Master Plan (NSTMP) BL-T1054
    Destination Development Plan & Small Scale Investment Project Plan Specific Focus on the Toledo District, Belize 2016 - 2020 Prepared for: Table of Contents Table of Figures ............................................................................................................................................ 4 Table of Tables.............................................................................................................................................. 5 Table of Annexes .......................................................................................................................................... 5 Glossary: ....................................................................................................................................................... 6 FOREWORD ................................................................................................................................................... 7 Executive Summary: ..................................................................................................................................... 8 Introduction: ................................................................................................................................................. 9 Background: ........................................................................................................................................ 10 Community Engagement: ..................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Sunday, February 14, 2021
    Vol. 24 No. 7 Sunday, February 14, 2021 Page 2 THE GUARDIAN Sunday, February 14, 2021 people also, just as important, people that are prepared to Briceño’s forked tongue cooperate with the government. Appearing on 7 News on Many instances we have a lot Tuesday, February 9 was Prime of people within government Minister John Briceño. He was because they pledge allegiance questioned on a number of issues to the previous government or but the one that stuck on us was to the UDP. They do every and his answer to the possibility of anything to undermine the work persons losing their jobs after of the government and many the Belize Bank completes of these people, we saw this the purchase of Scotiabank in happening, and so it was felt that Belize. Answering the question in the interest of the bus industry he stated that, “Well, I have not and to be able to provide proper seen that report. So I can’t really service to the public that that comment with certainty. But I they had to be released.” can tell you that one job loss is Absolutely no consideration one too much. And we hope that was given to the fact that these in the consolidation that they do very people were not phantom not move quickly to try to let go and in fact were at the terminals of people. But also to have some Prime Minister John Briceño when they were given their sort of social conscience that at was after hearing Briceño’s there by the previous minister.
    [Show full text]
  • Belize Factsheet IV – Maritime and Coastal Tourism
    Evidence-based and policy coherent Oceans Economy and Trade Strategies1. Sector data factsheet2: Belize Maritime and coastal tourism 1. INTRODUCTION The project “Evidence-based and policy coherent Oceans Economy and Trade Strategies” aims to support developing countries such as Barbados, Belize and Costa Rica, in realizing trade and economic benefits from the sustainable use of marine resources within the framework of the 1982 United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS). This data factsheet presents detailed sectorial information of one (of the four) ocean sectors selected in Belize to facilitate the identification and informed selection of key sectors to be considered for the next phase of the project: Sector 1 Sector 2 Sector 3 Sector 4 Marine fisheries Aquaculture Seafood manufacturing Tourism 1.1. THE MARITIME TOURISM SECTOR Tourism is the largest of all ocean economic sectors, generating more than a USD 1.6 trillion globally in 2017. International tourist arrivals grew by 7% reaching a record of 1,323 million arrivals in 2017. It is expected that international arrivals will reach to 1.8 trillion by 2030 (UNWTO, 2018), outperforming all other services sectors with perhaps the exception of financial services. Tourism is also the sector that contributes the most to the GDP of Small Island Developing States (SIDS), but also of coastal developing countries. These countries enjoy a special geographical situation, outstanding natural endowments and cultural heritage richness that make them unique for visitors. At the same time, they confront several challenges and vulnerabilities including remoteness, low connectivity, limited economic diversification, small internal markets, as well as adverse, perhaps recurrent climate events.
    [Show full text]
  • Environmental Statistics for Belize, 2012 Is the Sixth Edition to Be Produced in Belize and Contains Data Set Corresponding to the Year 2010
    Environmental Statistics for Belize 2012 Environmental Statistics for Belize 2012 Copyright © 2012 Lands and Surveys Department, Ministry of Natural Resources and Agriculture This publication may be reproduced in whole or in part and in any form for educational or non-profit purposes without special permission from the copyright holder, provided acknowledgement of the source is made. The Lands and Surveys Department would appreciate receiving a copy of any publication that uses this report as a source. No use of this publication may be made for resale or any other form of commercial use whatsoever. DISCLAIMER The information contained in this publication is based on information available at the time of the publication and may require updating. Please note that all efforts were made to include reliable and accurate information to eliminate errors, but it is still possible that some inconsistencies remain. We regret for errors or omissions that were unintentionally made. Lands and Surveys Department Ministry of Natural Resources and Agriculture Queen Elizabeth II Blvd. Belmopan, Belize C. A. Phone: 501-802-2598 Fax: 501-802-2333 e-mail: [email protected] or [email protected] Printed in Belize, October 2012 [ii] Environmental Statistics for Belize 2012 PREFACE The country of Belize is blessed with natural beauty that ranges from a gamut of biodiversity, healthy forest areas, the largest living coral reef system in the world, ancient heritage and diverse cultures. The global trend of industrialization and development for economic development has not adequately considered the natural environment. As a result, globally our natural resources and environment face tremendous pressures and are at high risk of further disruption.
    [Show full text]
  • Annual Report 2011 - 2012
    PROTECTED ARE A S C ONSERV A T I O N T RUST A NNU A L R E P ORT 2011-2012 Annual Report 2011 - 2012 Published by: The Protected Areas Conservation Trust Design and Layout - Protected Areas Conservation Trust, Belize Printed in Belize, Central America PHOTOS Copyright © 2012, The Protected Areas Conservation Trust © 2012, The Protected Areas Conservation Trust, Belize Note: All dollar figures in this report are in Belize Dollars. $2 BZ Dollars is equivalent to $1 US Dollar. PROTECTED ARE A S C ONSERV A T I O N T RUST A NNU A L R E P ORT 2011-2012 S LEE P I N G G I A NT Hummingbird Highway N A TURE ’ S T A TTOO table of C O N T EN ts Message from the Minister of Forestry, Fisheries, and Sustainable Development. ..i Message from the Chair of the Board of Directors. ii Message from the Acting Executive Director. .. iii Board of Directors and Advisory Council. iv PACT Staff.....................................................................v Organizational Chart...........................................................v Mission, Vision and Guiding Principles. .. vi What is PACT?...............................................................vii Highlights...............................................................2 Grants Program me.....................................................2 New Grants...........................................................2 Grants Application, Selection and Approval Process. 3 Large Grants Program. 4 Medium-Sized Grants. 6 Small Grants Program. 8 Environmental Support Grants. 10 Capacity Building Program.
    [Show full text]
  • A New Culinary Culture in Colombia: Equality and Identity in the Interpretation of Traditional Cuisines
    A New Culinary Culture in Colombia: Equality and Identity in the Interpretation of Traditional Cuisines A Dissertation Presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School of Cornell University In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy by Juliana Duque-Mahecha May 2017 © 2017 Juliana Duque-Mahecha A New Culinary Culture in Colombia: Equality and Identity in the Interpretation of Traditional Cuisines Juliana Duque-Mahecha, Ph. D. Cornell University 2017 Abstract Cooking responds to this double entendre of a past that is collected, interpreted and then projected on to a present that then overcomes it. New food trends necessarily imply questions about social and cultural equality and identity. That which is novel is exciting and refreshing; it implies learning and broadening boundaries, which are often geographical and social and always cultural. However, the process also entails the inherent challenge to define and answer what is lost and valued in a new scenario and to understand to what purpose. Some categories that have been used to understand such historical processes of cultural production in social systems are class, race, ethnicity and gender, as well as concepts associated with territory, differentiation, integration and democratization, authenticity and exoticization. My purpose in conducting an analytical approach to the development of the gastronomical and culinary subject in Colombia and of building a diagnostic map of it, responds to the wish to contribute to the understanding of the function of food research in solving specific questions of inequality, estrangement, and deracination, as well as understanding new senses of belonging and appropriation that emerge because of urban reconfigurations.
    [Show full text]
  • COVID-19 Update
    Friday, February 19, 2021 AMANDALABelize Page 1 NO. 3439 BELIZE CITY, FRIDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2021 (64 PAGES) $1.50 Dr. Manzanero accepts demotion? BELMOPAN. Thu. Feb. 18th, that he is still receives 2021 the same salary. In an On Thursday, February 18 the interview with CTV-3 Ministry of Health and Wellness’ via phone, the CEO Teenager CEO, Deysi Mendez informed local shared that changes media that Dr. Manzanero had been intended by the Ministry informed of the Ministry’s intention required a different killed in to “strengthening” and approach to public “restructuring” prior to his going health. on sick leave. As is known widely, “Dr. Manzanero holds Lords Bank Dr. Marvin Manzanero, was a post as an established infected with the coronavirus after Director of Health nine months of being on the front Services. This thing is, line of the pandemic in Belize. what we are going Reports are that he has accepted a post back with the HIV/AIDS Please„ turn to program inside the newly restructured MOHW. Reports are Page 53 Vicente says COVID-19 update errors were by Kory Leslie (freelance writer) made LORD’S BANK, Tue. Feb. 16, 2021 In a week of increased gun violence and crime, there is yet Please turn to„Page 55 Violence erupts on Cleghorn Street BELIZE CITY, Mon. Feb. 15, 2021 During the afternoon session of the Commission of Inquiry proceeding on the sale of government assets, Ruperto Vicente, who is the manager of Government’s Assets and Utilities Management Unit, of which the BELIZE CITY, Thurs. Feb. 18, 2021 Vehicle Care Unit is a part, answered The Ministry of Health and Wellness (MOHW) is concerned that the the initial questions posed by the population may begin to let their guard down, given the lower COVID-19 members of the commission.
    [Show full text]
  • 26Th March 2015, in the National Assembly Chamber, !Belmopan, at 10:18 AM
    !1 BELIZE ! No. HR26/1/11 ! HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES! th Thursday, 26 ! March, 2015 10:18! A.M ------! Pursuant to the Direction of Mr. Speaker on the 15th March 2015, the House met on Thursday, 26th March 2015, in the National Assembly Chamber, !Belmopan, at 10:18 AM. ! ! Members Present: The Hon. Michael Peyrefitte, Speaker The Hon. Dean O. Barrow (Queen’s Square), Prime Minister, Minister of Finance and Economic Development The Hon. Gaspar Vega (Orange Walk North), Deputy Prime Minister, Minister of Natural Resources and Agriculture The Hon. Erwin R. Contreras (Cayo West), Minister of Trade, Investment Promotion, Private Sector Development and Consumer Protection The Hon. Patrick J. Faber (Collet), Minister of Education, Youth and Sports The Hon. Manuel Heredia Jr. (Belize Rural South), Minister of Tourism and Culture The Hon. Anthony Martinez (Port Loyola), Minister of Human Development, Social Transformation and Poverty Alleviation The Hon. John Saldivar (Belmopan), Minister of National Security The Hon. Wilfred P. Elrington (Pickstock), Attorney General and Minister of Foreign Affairs The Hon. Rene Montero (Cayo Central), Minister of Works and Transport The Hon. Pablo S. Marin (Corozal Bay), Minister of Health The Hon. Santino Castillo (Caribbean Shores), Minister of State in the Ministry of Finance and Economic Development The Hon. Hugo Patt (Corozal North), Minister of State in the Ministry of Natural Resources and Agriculture The Hon. Herman Longsworth (Albert), Minister of State in the Ministry of Education, Youth and Sports The Hon. Mark King (Lake Independence), Minister of State in the Ministry of Human Development, Social Transformation and Poverty Alleviation The Hon.
    [Show full text]
  • 302232 Travelguide
    302232 TRAVELGUIDE <P.1> (118*205) G5-15 DANIEL V2 TABLE OF CONTENTS 2 INTRODUCTION 5 WELCOME 6 GENERAL VISITOR INFORMATION 8 GETTING TO BELIZE 9 TRAVELING WITHIN BELIZE 10 CALENDAR OF EVENTS 14 CRUISE PASSENGER ADVENTURES Half Day Cultural and Historical Tours Full Day Adventure Tours 16 SUGGESTED OVERNIGHT ADVENTURES Four-Day Itinerary Five-Day Itinerary Six-Day Itinerary Seven-Day Itinerary 25 ISLANDS, BEACHES AND REEF 32 MAYA CITIES AND MYSTIC CAVES 42 PEOPLE AND CULTURE 50 SPECIAL INTERESTS 57 NORTHERN BELIZE 65 NORTH ISLANDS 71 CENTRAL COAST 77 WESTERN BELIZE 87 SOUTHEAST COAST 93 SOUTHERN BELIZE 99 BELIZE REEF 104 HOTEL DIRECTORY 120 TOUR GUIDE DIRECTORY 302232 TRAVELGUIDE <P.2> (118*205) G5-15 DANIEL V2 302232 TRAVELGUIDE <P.3> (118*205) G5-15 DANIEL V2 The variety of activities is matched by the variety of our people. You will meet Belizeans from many cultural traditions: Mestizo, Creole, Maya and Garifuna. You can sample their varied cuisines and enjoy their music and Belize is one of the few unspoiled places left on Earth, their company. and has something to appeal to everyone. It offers rainforests, ancient Maya cities, tropical islands and the Since we are a small country you will be able to travel longest barrier reef in the Western Hemisphere. from East to West in just two hours. Or from North to South in only a little over that time. Imagine... your Visit our rainforest to see exotic plants, animals and birds, possible destinations are so accessible that you will get climb to the top of temples where the Maya celebrated the most out of your valuable vacation time.
    [Show full text]
  • The Transference of Cuisine and Michelin Rated Restaurants: a Chef’S Perspective of Japaneseness in Hong Kong
    特集号 『社会システム研究』 2017年 7 月 33 The Transference of Cuisine and Michelin Rated Restaurants: A Chef’s Perspective of Japaneseness in Hong Kong Watson M. Baldwin, DHTM * Introduction At present there has been research done with respect to the history of Japanese cuisine, the outlook of Hong Kong’ restaurants as it relates to tourism, and its relationship to culinary tourism, and Michelin rated restaurants. However, there is a significant gap with the recent phenomenon of the rise of Japanese Michelin rated restaurants and their emergence into the Chinese market. For this market there are numerous opportunities and avenues because Hong Kong is the gateway into the China market and Asia. These restaurants bring a certain heir of class and respect to Hong Kong as a “Culinary Destination.” Like many countries, Japan has many different styles of cuisines through the various prefectures and regions of the country. Previous researchers have often times looked at the introduction of sushi and sashimi into other areas and cultures because of its lore of being raw and uncooked fish, mollusks or shellfish products. For most countries raw fish is not consumed so it is understandable why this would be such an important item and factor into transferring Japanese cuisine. It is because of this that this paper will not look at sushi in that same capacity of introduction but rather by technique and flavor composition. Moreover, this research will include a look at four other areas of Japanese cuisine that are just as important as sushi. The first being kaiseki or the most formal and seasonal of Japanese cuisines, second is yakitori/yakiniku or grilled chicken, beef and barbecue style restaurants that specialize in preparing all parts of the chicken or cow, thirdly is ramen, traditionally a spinoff of a Chinese noodle soup but has become a staple of recognizing Japanese food, lastly there are izakayas which are the Japanese version of pubs (Cwiertka, 2006; Ashkenazi & Jacob, 2000; Lee, 2009; Barber, 2009).
    [Show full text]
  • 2013 Economic Impact of Flats Fishing in Belize
    2013 ECONOMIC IMPACT OF FLATS FISHING IN BELIZE Prepared for: Bonefish and Tarpon Trust P.O. Box 644257 Vero Beach, FL 32964 Prepared by: Anthony J. Fedler, Ph.D. Human Dimensions Consulting 9707 SW 55th Road Gainesville Florida July 2014 2013 ECONOMIC IMPACT OF FLATS FISHING IN BELIZE Executive Summary Belize is a world‐class flats fishing destination that has grown in popularity over the past decade. The protection of bonefish, permit and tarpon from commercial harvest was a cornerstone in this advancement and has been a key message in marketing the country’s fishing experiences throughout North America and Europe. However, fishing lodge owners, fishing guides and conservationists are concerned about persistent and spreading threats to the quality of flats fishing in Belize. These concerns have focused on inadequate fisheries management and enforcement, deterioration of water quality, and habitat destruction. The sport fishery supports an extensive array of independent fishing guides, fishing lodges and hotels, and other support services in Belize. A 2007 study of flats fishing in Belize showed that the economic impact totaled $56 million (BZD) and comprised about 6.3% of all tourist expenditures (Fedler 2008). Because of changes in both the economy and enhanced perception of flats fishing in Belize since the 2007 study and growing concerns over fisheries sustainability and habitat protection, a new economic study was undertaken to update the understanding and value of flats fishing to the tourism economy of Belize. This study of 2013 flats fishing in Belize used interviews with independent fishing guides, tour operators, and fishing lodge owners and managers to identify the number of anglers and their days fishing in Belize.
    [Show full text]
  • What Makes a Restaurant Ethnic? (A Case Study Of
    FORUM FOR ANTHROPOLOGY AND CULTURE, 2017, NO. 13 WHAT MAKES A RESTAURANT ETHNIC? (A CASE STUDY OF ARMENIAN RESTAURANTS IN ST PETERSBURG) Evgenia Guliaeva Th e Russian Museum of Ethnography 4/1 Inzhenernaya Str., St Petersburg, Russia [email protected] A b s t r a c t: Using restaurants in St Petersburg serving Armenian cuisine as a case study, the article studies the question of what makes an ethnic restaurant ethnic, what may be learnt about ethnicity by studying a restaurant serving a national cuisine, and to what extent the image of Armenian cuisine presented in Armenian restaurants corresponds to what Armenian informants tell us. The conclusion is that the composition of the menu in these restaurants refl ects a view of Armenian cuisine from within the ethnic group itself. The representation of ethnicity is achieved primarily by discursive means. Neither owners, nor staff, nor customers from the relevant ethnic group, nor the style of the interior or music are necessary conditions for a restaurant to be accepted as ethnic. However, their presence is taken into account when the authenticity or inauthenticity of the restaurant is evaluated. Armenian informants, though, do not raise the question of authenticity: this category is irrelevant for them. Keywords: Armenians, ethnicity, ethnic restaurants, national cuisine, authenticity, St Petersburg. To cite: Guliaeva E., ‘What Makes a Restaurant Ethnic? (A Case Study of Armenian Restaurants in St Petersburg)’, Forum for Anthropology and Culture, 2017, no. 13, pp. 280–305. U R L: http://anthropologie.kunstkamera.ru/fi
    [Show full text]