Ship Emissions and Technical Emission Reduction Potential in the Northern Baltic Sea
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
SHIP EMISSIONS ANDTECHNICAL EMISSION RED REPORTS OF FINNISH ENVIRONMENT institUte 8 | 2006 Ship emissions and technical emission reduction potential in the Northern Baltic Sea Johanna Wahlström, Niko Karvosenoja and Petri Porvari U CTION POTENTIAL INTHE NORTHERN BALTIC SEA FINNISH ENVIRONMENT INSTIT ISBN 952-11-2276-5 (nid.) ISBN 952-11-2277-3 (PDF) ISSN 1796-1718 (pain.) U TE ISSN 1796-1726 (verkkoj.) Finnish Environment Institute REPORTS OF FINNISH ENVIRONMENT INSTITUTE 8 | 2006 Ship emissions and technical emission reduction potential in the Northern Baltic Sea Johanna Wahlström, Niko Karvosenoja and Petri Porvari Helsinki 2006 Finnish Environment Institute REPORTS OF FINNISH ENVIRONMENT INSTITUTE 8 | 2006 Finnish Environment Institute Research Programme for Global Change Page layout: Ritva Koskinen Cover photo: Mikko Nurmi The publication is alvo available in the Internet: www.environment.fi/publications Edita Prima Ldt, Helsinki 2006 ISBN 952-11-2276-5 (nid.) tai (sid.) ISBN 952-11-2277-3 (PDF) ISSN 1796-1718 (pain.) ISSN 1796-1726 (verkkoj.) FOREWORD This study was carried out in the Finnish Environment Institute at the Research Programme for Global Change (GTO) during years 2005 and 2006. The focus was, firstly, to develop national integrated assessment modeling framework of air pollutants, and secondly, to enhance the general understanding of the magnitude of ship emissions and reduction potentials in the sea areas near Finland. The work was funded by the Ministry of the Environment and the KOPRA project in the technological programme ”FINE Particles - Technology, Environment and Health 2002-2005” of the National Technology Agency of Finland (Tekes). The authors gratefully acknowledge the financial support. There are plenty of valuable existing information and data bases about ship movements, emissions and reduction technologies which this study utilized to a great extent. The most important data source for the baseline emission factors was the calculation system for the Finnish waterborne traffic, MEERI. The authors wish to acknowledge Kari Mäkelä from VTT Building and Transport for collaboration. The ship movements were estimated based on information from several sources. We thank Heli Haapasaari, Meri Hietala and Samuli Neuvonen from the Finnish Environment Institute, Kaj Forsius from HELCOM, Harry Federlay from the Finnish Maritime Administration, Eve Tuomola-Oinonen from the Port of Helsinki and Mirva Lehtonen from the Port of Hamina for their helpful attitude and delivery of information. Furthermore, we wish to acknowledge Nicola Robinson from European Commission Environment Directorate-General and Jan Hulskotte from TNO Built Environment and Geosciences for the discussions and information about emission reduction technologies and costs. The study was also Johanna Wahlström’s master’s thesis work. The supervisor professor Carl-Johan Fogelholm from Helsinki University of Technology is acknowledged for his instructions and valuable comments. We are also grateful to Carita Nybom from the Information Service of the Finnish Environment Institute for correcting the English and Swedish abstracts. Reports of Finnish Environment Institute 8 | 2006 SYMBOLS AND ABBREVIATIONS E Energy consumption EM Amount of emissions f Emission factor FC Fuel consumption M Ship movements maver Average fuel consumption mS Amount of sulphur in fuel P Engine power s Sailed distance t Time v Average sailing speed x Proportion of a engine type y Proportion of a fuel type AIS Automatic Identification System CASS Combustion air saturation system DWI Direct water injection EGR Exhaust gas recirculation EPA U.S. Environmental Protection Agency EU European Union FMA Finnish Maritime Administration FRES Finnish Regional Emission Scenario model HAM Humid air motor HFO Heavy fuel oil IMO International Maritime Organisation LNG Liquefied natural gas MARPOL Convention for the Prevention of Pollution from Ships MDO Marine diesel oil MGO Marine gas oil SCR Selective catalytic reduction SNCR Selective non-catalytic reduction STID Steam injected diesel CO Carbon monoxide CO(NH2)2 Urea CO2 Carbon dioxide H2O Water H2SO3 Sulphurous acid H2SO4 Sulphuric acid HC Hydrocarbons N2 Nitrogen NH3 Ammonia NO Nitric oxide NO2 Nitrogen dioxide NOx Nitrogen oxides O2 Oxygen OH Hydroxyl radical PAH Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons PM Particulate matter SO2 Sulphur dioxide SO3 Sulphur trioxide SO4 Sulphate SOx Sulphur oxides Reports of Finnish Environment Institute 8 | 2006 CONTENTS Foreword ............................................................................................................................ Symbols and abbreviations ......................................................................................... 1 Introduction ...............................................................................................................7 2 Background ................................................................................................................9 2.1 Ship types ................................................................................................................9 2.2 Ship engines .............................................................................................................9 2.2.1 Engine sizes and rating ............................................................................9 2.2.2 Engines in cargo and passenger ships .................................................10 2.3 The main ports at the Gulf of Finland and the Gulf of Bothnia ...............12 2.4 Automatic Identification System (AIS) ............................................................12 3 Methods and materials ........................................................................................1 3.1 Ship movements ...................................................................................................1 3.2 Engine sizes and fuel and energy consumption ............................................17 3.3 Emission calculation ...........................................................................................18 3.3.1 Sulphur dioxide emissions .....................................................................18 4 Ship emissions in 2000 .........................................................................................20 4.1 Emissions on the sea routes ...............................................................................21 4.1.1 Gulf of Finland .........................................................................................21 4.1.2 Gulf of Bothnia .........................................................................................2 4.2 Emissions in ports, inland waters and from smaller vessels ................................. 25 4.3 Uncertainties and data gaps ...............................................................................26 5 Techniques for reducing emissions from ships .........................................27 5.1 Formation of emissions in marine diesel engines ........................................27 5.1.1 Sulphur dioxide emissions .....................................................................28 5.1.2 Nitrogen oxides emissions .....................................................................28 5.1.3 Particulate matter emissions and smoke ..............................................28 5.1.4 Carbon monoxide and hydrocarbon emissions ..................................29 5.2 Reduction by internal engine adjustments ....................................................29 5.2.1 Combustion optimization ......................................................................0 5.2.2 Fuel injection optimization ....................................................................1 5.2.3 Common rail technology .......................................................................2 5.2.4 Turbo-charging and charge-air after-cooling ..................................... 5.2.5 Miller cycle ............................................................................................... 5.2.6 Lubrication technology ........................................................................... 5.2.7 Combinations of internal engine measures ......................................... 5.3 Reduction by engine process modifications ...................................................5 5.3.1 Water injection .........................................................................................5 5.3.2 Selective non-catalytic reduction ..........................................................8 5.3.3 Exhaust gas recirculation .......................................................................9 Reports of Finnish Environment Institute 8 | 2006 5 5.4 After-treatment technologies .............................................................................0 5.4.1 Seawater scrubbing ..................................................................................0 5.4.2 Selective catalytic reduction ...................................................................0 5.4.3 Particulate filters ......................................................................................2 5.4.4 Oxidation reactor .....................................................................................2 5.5 Alternative fuels and energy sources .............................................................. 5.5.1 Low-sulphur fuels ................................................................................... 5.5.2 Alternatives for diesel fuels ..................................................................