Coumarin) BMJ: First Published As 10.1136/Bmj.307.6911.1037 on 23 October 1993
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Treatment offilarial lymphoedema and elephantiasis with 5,6-benzo-oL-pyrone (coumarin) BMJ: first published as 10.1136/bmj.307.6911.1037 on 23 October 1993. Downloaded from J R Casley-Smith, C T Wang, Judith R Casley-Smith, Cui Zi-hai Abstract drugs that have been studied do this by increasing both Objective-To study efficacy of treatment the numbers of macrophages and their normal pro- of ifiarial lymphoedema and elephantiasis with teolysis per cell.' These drugs thereby provide another 5,6-benzo-a-pyrone. path by which protein and its osmotically held water Design-Randomised, double blind, placebo con- can be removed from the tissues. Removing the excess trolled study with matching for grade and duration of protein also reduces the chronic inflammation, which disease, age, and sex. Treatment was given for 367 results from the simple chronic accumulation of excess days, and subjects were followed up for another plasma proteins and the consequent excess fibrosis.''0 year. All benzopyrones have similar effects on high protein Setting-A town in Shandong Province, China. oedemas, most can be taken orally, they are of low Subjects-104 men and women with chronic toxicity, and their actions persist for several days.' unilateral filarial lymphoedema or elephantiasis of The cheapest and simplest is 5,6-benzo-ot-pyrone the leg: 64 were randomised to benzopyrone and 40 (coumarin). This is available in large amounts of high to placebo. By the end of the study 19 patients had purity, and has been tested in more clinical trials than dropped out of the treatment group and two out of any other.' While its chemical name is coumarin and it the placebo group. is the parent molecule of the dicoumerol anticoagu- Interventions-Two 200 mg tablets of 5,6-benzo- lants, it has no anticoagulant activity itself.' The ac-pyrone or two placebo tablets given daily. benzopyrones have no relation to the benzopyrenes Main outcome measures-Volumes ofthe affected and have a different chemical structure. and normal legs estimated every three months, and Various benzopyrones have been shown to reduce daily listing ofany side effects. human postmastectomy, primary, and other lympho- Results-Benzopyrone reduced oedema for all edemas' 11-1" and to improve the results obtained with grades oflymphoedema during the year oftreatment physical treatment.20 They also decrease the incidence (pWO.001) and the follow up year (p=0.026). During of secondary acute inflammation by removing the treatment the mean monthly reductions in leg "incubation medium" for bacteria.' "'1-37-'9 However, volume were 0.62% (95% confidence intervals 04% the effects of these drugs on the massive lymphoedema to 0.85%), 1.1% (0.71% to 1.6%), and 16% (0.89% to and elephantiasis caused by filariasis had not been 2 33%) ofthe volume ofthe normal leg for grades 1, 2, studied. A trial was therefore conducted of 5,6-benzo- and 3-5 (elephantiasis) oflymphoedema respectively. a-pyrone on filarial lymphoedema and elephantiasis in Ping-Yi County, Shandong, China. A similar trial During follow up the mean monthly reductions were http://www.bmj.com/ 0.18% (0-01% to 0 35%), 0-54% (0-27% to 0.820/6), was conducted simultaneously in India.2' In India and 0-87% (0.51% to 1.2%). At the end ofthe trial the reinfestation with filariae is frequent,2' but in total reduction in oedema was 100%, 95%, and 45% Shandong, where bancroftian filariasis used to be for grades 1, 2, and 3-5. Symptoms and complications endemic, a campaign of mass treatment with diethyl- were considerably reduced, including attacks of carbamazine and other measures have reduced the secondary acute inflammation, while side effects prevalence of microfilaraemia to 0 01%, compared were minor and disappeared after one month. In the with 20-30% 30 years ago.22 While many patients still had elephantiasis, the lack of reinfestation permitted placebo group there were no changes in the severity on 5 October 2021 by guest. Protected copyright. oflymphoedema. evaluation of the effectiveness of the drug after its Conclusions-5,6 - benzo - a - pyrone reduces the administration ceased. oedema and many symptoms of filarial lympho- edema and elephantiasis. It has few side effects, and its relatively slow action makes it ideal for use Patients and methods without compression garments. Altogether 104 patients were chosen who had Henry Thomas chronic lymphoedema or elephantiasis in one leg and Laboratory, University of one apparently normal leg. The patients were initially Adelaide, Box 498 GPO, SA Introduction divided into eight groups of 13, each group being 5001, Australia 45 suffer from filarial matched as closely as possible for grade of lympho- J R Casley-Smith, reader Over million people lympho- Judith R Casley-Smith, edema and elephantiasis, including hydrocele.'-3 An edema, duration of the disease, age, and sex (in chairman ofLymphoedema equal number are asymptomatic but are infested with decreasing order of importance). Random number Association ofAustralia filariae. Such patients often have damaged lymphatic tables were then used to assign the patients to treat- systems and are likely to develop lymphoedema and ment with benzopyrone or placebo. At the Chinese Shandong Institute of elephantiasis.45 Effective treatments for lymphoedema ethics committee's insistence, randomisation was Parasitic Disease, Jining, and elephantiasis are now available,' 6-9 but patients in weighted to assign more people to the treatment than Shandong 272 133, China developing countries can seldom afford them. Of to placebo: 64 patients received treatment and 40 C T Wang, director these, the first choice is adequate physical treatment.6 received placebo. Blood specimens were taken from Ciu Zi-hai, research medical This is non-invasive and gives large, rapid, and lasting the patients, and, although blood films revealed no officer reductions of swelling, but compression garments are microfilariae, diethylcarbamazine 6 mg/kg/day was Correspondence and essential. These are impractical in hot, wet, or dirty given to each patient for 12 days before the trial as a reprint requests to: conditions such as paddy fields. precaution. No other treatment was used (including no Dr J R Casley-Smith. The benzopyrone group of drugs have many actions compressive bandaging) except that antibiotics were but all appear to reduce all forms of acute and chronic given for any bacterial infections. For the next 367 days BMJ 1993;307:1037-41 high protein oedema in animals and humans. Those the treatment group received 400 mg 5,6-benzo-ox- BMJ VOLUME 307 23 OCTOBER 1993 1037 pyrone a day (as two 200 mg tablets) while the other thick and coarse), grade 4 (grade 2 or 3 with frequent group received placebo. Village doctors gave the warts and papillomas), and grade 5 (grade 4 with a tablets to the patients each day and ensured that they true elephantoid appearance, an enormously thickened were swallowed so that patient compliance was 100%. and leathery skin and all the usual limb curvatures When this was completed the patients were followed obliterated). Thus grades 2 to 5 are all included in the up for a further year. International Society for Lymphology grade 2, with BMJ: first published as 10.1136/bmj.307.6911.1037 on 23 October 1993. Downloaded from While receiving tablets, the patients were asked grades 3 to 5 being elephantiasis. daily about possible side effects of the drug. The Statistical analysis-The volumes of the patients' patients were also examined every three months, apparently normal legs did not change significantly during which the circumferences of both legs of each during the trial and were used as controls. Although patient were measured at five points, at 10 cm intervals such legs often have abnormal lymphatic systems,45 from the heel. The volume ofeach leg was estimated as their use as controls still reduces SE/mean compared the sum of four truncated cones,23 which gives a value with the use of other subjects as controls."' 1719 A value almost identical with that from water displacement.24 for the oedema in each patient's affected leg was The patients were also examined clinically and asked provided by calculating the volume of the patient's about possible symptoms and complications during the oedematous leg as a percentage of the volume of the previous three months. Features such as the condition normal leg. The results were analysed by means of an of the skin, hair growth, and ulcers were noted, as was unbalanced repeated measures model with structured the frequency and severity of secondary acute inflam- covariance matrices (BMDP version five), with group- Treatment Benzopyrone mation (because of confusion in terminology, the ing factors of treatment, grade of disease (three levels), --- Placebo Intemational Society for Lymphology recommends and time, and individual linear regressions were Grade of lymphoedema that this neutral term be used for any acute inflammation calculated against time. Paired t tests were used to * Grades 3-5 of the affected tissues6). Each clinical feature was assess the significance of the differences between * Grade2 catagorised as severe, moderate, mild, slight, or none. individuals' initial and final values from zero and 170- A Grade I In addition, all the patients had chest radiographs and between the treatment and placebo groups for the 160- electrocardiograms taken and complete blood and individual grades. urine examinations made. Ten patients in each group The results ofthe clinical examination were reported 1~.50! -~ - - were tested for bleeding and coagulation times and for as remained bad (severe or moderate), remained good 140- liver and kidney function. (mild to none), worsened (started as good and became Classification of lymphoedema and elephantiasis-The bad), or improved (started as bad and became good). 130- Intemational Society for Lymphology classifies They were analysed with X2 tests ofhomogeneity, using 120 lymphoedema as grade 1 (pitting of skin and oedema Yates's correction if required.