DOCSLIB.ORG

INTRODUCTION W Hat Better Way to Start an Article Than Saying You Are Not Qualifie

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
INTRODUCTION W Hat Better Way to Start an Article Than Saying You Are Not Qualifie Francine M. Schlingmann1 THE ENGLISH LEGAL PROFESSION Divided they fall? INTRODUCTION What better way to start an article than saying you are not qualified to write it! I am neither a barrister nor a solicitor. I am admitted to practice as "advocaat" in the Netherlands, where there is no division of the legal pro- fession which is comparable to the division of the English legal profession into barristers and solicitors. Practising Dutch law in the London branch office of a Dutch law firm I sometimes come across this idiosyncratic feature of the English legal system, e. g. when a Dutch client wishes to institute legal proceedings against a customer in England who fails to pay under a contract for the sale and purchase of tulip bulbs. I refer such a client to a solicitor who, subsequently, instructs counsel (a barrister) to act on behalf of the Dutch client in the High Court. Usually, the Dutch client can only see the disadvantages of the system. However, there must also be advantages and surely, it is not just a matter of advantages and disadvantages; developed over the centuries in a legal tradition that very much differs from the civil law system in continental Europe, the division of the English legal profession deserves a much more subtle approach. As always, this requires knowledge of how the system works. In this article I will describe some basic features of both professions. It may prove that not being a barrister or solicitor - and therefore perhaps not qual- ified to write about all this - is an advantage and leads to an unprejudiced view. BRIEF HISTORICAL NOTE The reason for the division of the legal profession is historical. The predecessors of the barristers and solicitors such as we know them today were a mixed group of professionals with different titles and functions over the centuries. In the thirteenth century there were lawyers who pleaded in the King's courts on behalf of litigants and there were court officials, acting as "attorneys ", who helped people who were involved in court proceedings, which included appearing in court. Both the pleaders ("barristers and ser- ' Attorney at law, De Brauw Blackstone Westbroek, London, UK. jeants ") and "attorneys " pleaded in court. Both types of professionals could receive clients direct. In the mid-fourteenth century lawyers organised them- selves into the Inns of Court. From then onwards a gradual separation of functions developed. Eventually, "attorneys were excluded from the Inns of Court and the higher courts reserved the right of audience for "barristers and serjearas ". Also other types of lawyers appeared. There were "solicitors" who dealt with property matters and appeared in the chancery courts. The word "solicitor" is derived from "soliciting" the chancery court into pursuing matters, which would in these courts otherwise continue for a long time. In the ecclesiastical and admiralty courts the so called "proctor" had appeared. In 1875 the functions of "solicitors ", "proctors and "attorneys were merged. They adopted the single title of "solicitor ". After the "serjeants" profession ceased to practise under that name, only "barristers remained as representatives of the branch of the legal profession that dealt with pleadings in court. THE BARRISTER How to qualify as a barrister? Normally, at least a second-class degree (not necessarily in law) is required. The barrister-to-be joins one of the Inns of Court (Gray's Inn, Lincoln's Inn, The Inner Temple or The Middle Temple) and has to dine there three times in each quarterly "dining term" for a period of two years. The most important year is that of the Bar examinations and the vocational training course at the Inns of Court School of Law. In this vocational year aspiring barristers have to take part in mock trials and advocacy exercises which are conducted by experienced barristers. This course also consists of lectures and seminars in which the more practical aspects of the work of a barrister are dealt with. After having passed the Bar exams and after having been called to the Bar, it is necessary for a barrister who wants to practise at the Bar to do twelve months of so called "pupillage" in chambers (the term for barristers' offices). During this pupillage, the barrister attends conferences with his "pupil master", a more senior barrister, goes to court hearings with him,. researches points of law for him and does general paper work. During the pupillage the barrister is not paid. However, in the second half of the pupillage year the young barrister is allowed to take on work of his own. There are discussions about the question as to whether the pupillage as it is today is a good means of introducing a barrister to his profession. Some criticisms are that it is actually only open to those that can afford it and that pupillage is not very secure, because the pupil does not receive any guarantee that he will be able to stay in the same chambers after the year of pupillage has been completed. It is only possible for a barrister to practise if he is offered a "seat" or "tenancy" in a set .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Legal Profession in the Middle Ages Roscoe Pound
    Notre Dame Law Review Volume 19 | Issue 3 Article 2 3-1-1944 Legal Profession in the Middle Ages Roscoe Pound Follow this and additional works at: http://scholarship.law.nd.edu/ndlr Part of the Law Commons Recommended Citation Roscoe Pound, Legal Profession in the Middle Ages, 19 Notre Dame L. Rev. 229 (1944). Available at: http://scholarship.law.nd.edu/ndlr/vol19/iss3/2 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by NDLScholarship. It has been accepted for inclusion in Notre Dame Law Review by an authorized administrator of NDLScholarship. For more information, please contact [email protected]. "Copyright in the Pound lectures is reserved by Dean Emeritus Roscoe Pound, Harvard Law School, Harvard University." II THE LEGAL PROFESSION IN THE MIDDLE AGES 1 PROCTORS AND ADVOCATES IN THE CIVIL AND THE CANON LAW W E have seen that in Roman law the three functions of V agency or representation in litigation, advocacy, and advice -the functions of procurator or attorney, advocate, and jurisconsult-had become differentiated and had each attained a high degree of development. Also we have seen how by the time of Justinian the jurisconsult had become a law teacher, so that for the future, in continental Europe, the advocate's function and the jurisconsult's function of advis- ing were merged and the term jurisconsult was applied only to teachers and writers. Germanic law brought back into western Europe the ideas of primitive law as to representation in litigation. Parties were required to appear in person and conduct their cases in person except in case of dependents.
    [Show full text]
  • February 2019
    February 2019 – Vol.39 No.1 Embracing tradition and transformation | The X7 Factor Guarding the rights of all Queenslanders ADVERTISEMENT QLD developers and their lawyers embrace e-Conveyancing Complimentary to a wider digital cheques going missing in the post or liaising WHAT IS PEXA PROJECTS? transformation initiative, QM Properties with the ATO for confirmation of receipt." has made the decision to incorporate It allows lawyers and electronic property transactions, Chloe also shared that "Quinn and conveyancers to manage large "e-Conveyancing", into its digital strategy. Scattini understood QM's digital vision scale projects (i.e. multi-lot QM Propertiessees e-Conveyancing as an from the outset and they took this developments) and efficiently integral component of this digital strategy. opportunity to get involved and embrace complete the online property digital conveyancing like their peers in exchange process. Chloe Fadden, Sales Administration neighbouring states." Manager at QM Properties shared QM's experience to date and that of its lawyers Duncan Murdoch, a Director at Quinn SPEED Quinn and Scattiniduring the transition. and Scattini, shared his thoughts on the process thus far. EFFICIENCY ''The timesaving benefitswere evident from the beginning. Currently, our Trust "As a legal practice, Quinn & Scattini VISIBILITY Accountant dedicates a significant regards it important to not only be on top amount of time to collecting, banking and of legislativechanges but also to embrace receipting of settlement cheques. When technological enhancements in order to it's a PEXA settlement, this isn't required. deliver the best outcomes for its clients. Now, we are able to handle a greater PEXA's electronic conveyancing platform volume of settlementswith far less has allowed Quinn & Scattini to assist manual intervention", said Chloe.
    [Show full text]
  • A COSEY, DOSEY, OLD-FASHIONED, TIME-FORGOTTEN, SLEEPYHEADED LITTLE AF MILY PARTY", 39 La
    Louisiana Law Review Volume 39 | Number 3 The Work of the Louisiana Appellate Courts for the 1977-1978 Term: A Faculty Symposium Spring 1979 "A COSEY, DOSEY, OLD-FASHIONED, TIME- FORGOTTEN, SLEEPYHEADED LITTLE FAMILY PARTY" Frederick Bernays Wiener Repository Citation Frederick Bernays Wiener, "A COSEY, DOSEY, OLD-FASHIONED, TIME-FORGOTTEN, SLEEPYHEADED LITTLE AF MILY PARTY", 39 La. L. Rev. (1979) Available at: https://digitalcommons.law.lsu.edu/lalrev/vol39/iss3/26 This Book Review is brought to you for free and open access by the Law Reviews and Journals at LSU Law Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Louisiana Law Review by an authorized editor of LSU Law Digital Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. BOOK REVIEW "A COSEY, DOSEY, OLD-FASHIONED, TIME-FORGOTtEN, SLEEPY- HEADED LITTLE FAMILY PARTY"* Frederick Bernays Wiener** Probably few among today's youth ever read the novels of Charles Dickens. But most of those who are now seniors at the bar did so when they were young and thus first became ac- quainted with the courts and lawyers of Dickens' time, before the Judicature Acts reshaped virtually all English tribunals in 1875. Pickwick Papers dealt with the Court of Common Pleas and with the serjeants and attorneys. Bleak House described the unreformed High Court of Chancery and its barristers and solicitors. David Copperfield portrayed the third branch of English law, the realm of the civil law courts, whose jurisprud- ence was founded on Roman law and where counsel were advo- cates holding doctors' degrees and, in the lower branch, were proctors.
    [Show full text]
  • October 2019 | Vol.39 No.9 | Voluntary Assisted Dying
    PROCTOR OCTOBER 2019 | dying assisted Voluntary OCTOBER 2019 NOT A SIMPLE MATTER OF LIFE OR DEATH Navigating the complexities of implementing voluntary assisted dying laws in Queensland MENTAL HEALTH MONTH INNOVATION IN LAW Balancing a legal Meeting regulatory demands – career with life How small innovations can add value Where Work Flows. A winning legal team is made up of many important parts. Our team can help you keep them all moving. Document & Production Support The Law In Order Difference — Established 1999 eDiscovery Services — 24/7, 365 days a year — Servicing Law Firms, Corporates and Government Agencies Forensic Data Specialists — Unparalleled quality — Secure and confidential practices Managed Document Review to protect you and your clients — Realtime job tracking via our website eHearing Solutions — Latest document technology Working with us, makes working with your clients easier. Talk to us about support and solutions for your team. 1300 096 216 [email protected] lawinorder.com BRISBANE • SYDNEY • MELBOURNE • PERTH • SINGAPORE • HONG KONG • INDIA FEATURES 18 Voluntary assisted dying Not a simple matter of life or death Should it be legalised in Queensland? Voluntary assisted dying law reform for Queensland Death and the rule of law Four issues to consider when legislating for medically assisted dying Voluntary assisted dying: Perspectives and issues 28 Innovation in law Practical steps to the tech starting line Meeting regulatory demands 36 October is Mental Health Month Balancing a legal career with life Beating the burnout
    [Show full text]
  • How to Distinguish and Translate Synonymous English Legal Terms1
    Proceedings of INTCESS 2021 8th International Conference on Education and Education of Social Sciences 18-19 January, 2021 HOW TO DISTINGUISH AND TRANSLATE SYNONYMOUS ENGLISH LEGAL TERMS1 Vladimir Ozyumenko Associate Prof., Dr, Peoples’ Friendship University of Russia (RUDN University), RUSSIA, E-mail [email protected], [email protected] Abstract The article deals with the problem of teaching and learning legal terminology at the lessons of professional English for law students. It focuses on the lexical-semantic group LAWYER, characterized by a high nominative density in English and includes several scores of lexemes, nominating professionals representing defendants’ interests in courts, e.g., attorney, barrister, solicitor, advocate, counsel, legal practitioner, litigator, jurist, procurator, trial lawyer, counselor, counselor-at-law etc. This fact poses considerable difficulty for Russian ESL learners as in Russian there is only one term with the corresponding meaning advokat. The article pursues the goal to explore semantic and functional differences in legal terms under consideration and suggests some techniques for their teaching and learning. The study aims to answer the questions: (1) how to differentiate the English legal terms, and (2) how to translate them. The data were taken from various sources: dictionaries, legal documents, and Internet resources. Comparative, semantic and cultural analysis was implemented. The findings show that due to the developed system of the English law (Common law) and its long history English possesses a considerable set of terms denoting the lawyers representing clients’ interests which do not have their lexical counterparts in Russian. The paper argues that to distinguish between English synonymous legal terms and find their translation equivalents the following aspects should be taken into consideration: (1) cultural variability of the English language, i.e.
    [Show full text]
  • Doctor's Commons
    LEGAL HISTORY Doctor’s Commons By Kevin Tang For half a millennium the separation between the spiritual law Origins - α and the temporal law assured the livelihood and existence of The institution ‘Doctors’ Commons’ arose out a band of practitioners known as the Doctors’ Commons in of a seminary or sacerdotal college known as London. The jurisdiction grew out of the early episcopal courts Jesus Commons which operated in St Paul’s recognised by William I in 1072. It was a bastion of Canon and Cathedral churchyard in the City of London before 1400. Doctors ‘Commons refers to the Ecclesiastical Law. A distinct strain of Canon Law developed learned specialists in Canon and Ecclesiastical in England after the Reformation. This was the quintessential law trained in the Roman law (civilian law) tra- spiritual jurisdiction as distinct from the temporal courts and its dition and procedures. Doctors’ Commons, as profession. In a blaze of glory, Doctors’ Commons came and went. a title, was in use by 1532. It was conceived as a voluntary society for practitioners and scholars to live and practice amongst one another and to keep a ‘common table’ and as scholars they ‘commoned’ on site. In this respect, it was sim- ilar to the Inns of Court but Doctors’ Com- mons was exclusively for those who practised in the Ecclesiastical and the Civil law courts in London. It was never a teaching institution. This was the age when Civil law, Canon law and theology were pre-eminent university subjects. The common law was an orderless sci- ence the apprenticeship of which was lengthy.
    [Show full text]
  • TRINITY HALL the Milestones Lectures
    TRINITY HALL CAMBRIDGE The Milestones Lectures In celebration of 650 years of education and learning (2001) 4 Trinity Hall and the Relations ofEuropean and English Lawfrom the Fourteenth to the TIventy-First Centuries Professor John Langbein hose ofus who are Trinity Hall lawyers relate to the antiquity ofthis place in a special T way, on account of Trinity Hall's renown as a law college. Trinity Hall is the only college in either Oxford or Cambridge that was founded exclusively for the study oflaw. We lawyers may be tempted to regard the rest ofyou people as latecomers, and very late at that. Not until the university reforms of the mid-nineteenth century did Trinity Hall take on its modern breadth, as a college whose fellows and students are drawn from all the academic disciplines. But the non-lawyers would have a potent response to pretensions of this sort on the part of the lawyers. In truth, we lawyers are as much newcomers to the traditions of Trinity Hall as are the chemists or the classicists. The subject that we studied at Trinity Hall, English law, was introduced here at the same time that Trinity Hall began to teach chemistry and classics and medicine and English literature - that is, in the last decades of the nineteenth century. The long line of royal judges, queens' counsel, and eminent barristers and solicitors of the common law who have poured forth from Trinity Hall ­ that line actually extends back only to late Victorian times. What Trinity Hall purveyed for its first five centuries ,was not the English common law, but rather the common law ofEurope, also called the ius commune or the civil law.
    [Show full text]
  • Northwestern California University Catalog
    NORTHWESTERN CALIFORNIA UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF LAW 2014 Catalog NWCU SCHOOL OF LAW Message from the Dean “One thing more expensive than education is the lack of it.” Michael Patrick Clancey Dean of Northwestern California University Northwestern California University is a non-traditional law school. It arose from the needs of those who desired to study law but because of financial limitations, family responsibilities, geographic location, time constraints, etc., could not attend a regular classroom type law school. History is filled with the names of famous American lawyers and jurists who, for one reason or another, came to the Bar after having been essentially self-taught in law. Persons like Abraham Lincoln, Thomas Jefferson, U.S. Supreme Court Chief Justice John Marshall, Daniel Webster, Henry Clay, (Harvard) Dean Roscoe Pound, Robert Jackson (U.S. Supreme Court Justice and Chief U.S. Prosecutor at Nuremberg ), Clarence Darrow, and many more, either spent little time in law school or, in the example of Lincoln, never even saw the inside of a law school. They had in common a burn- ing desire to learn law and mentors to guide them in their quest. I strongly encourage those of you who can attend a regular classroom type law school to do so. I realize, however, that this is not possible for many. The strongly motivated, who are unable to attend class, can still obtain an excellent education in law through enrollment in our program. The information you will find in the pages that follow will give you a sense of all our School of Law has to offer its students.
    [Show full text]
  • Maryland Law Component Subject Matter Outlines
    MARYLAND LAW COMPONENT SUBJECT MATTER OUTLINES TABLE OF CONTENTS Acknowledgements 3 Important Notice – Please Read 6 Maryland Courts – Jurisdiction and Procedure 8 Criminal Law and Procedure 20 Estates and Trusts 29 Evidence 34 Family Law 42 Torts 62 Professional Responsibility 73 2 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS After extensive hearings, meetings, and thoughtful recommendations by the Advisory Committee to Explore the Feasibility of Maryland’s Adoption of the Uniform Bar Exam (“Advisory Committee”), Maryland’s highest court, the Court of Appeals, decided that Maryland would join the many states that administer the Uniform Bar Examination. However, Maryland has significant distinctions from Federal law and the law of other states, which are critical to the successful practice of law in this state. At the request of the Court of Appeals, the Maryland Law Component Sub-Committee was tasked with seeking the assistance of distinguished expert practitioners in many areas of law to draft materials for use by Maryland bar applicants to prepare for the Maryland Law Component. On behalf of the Maryland Court of Appeals, and myself, I would like to thank the following attorneys, professors, and judges without whom this outline would not be possible. The following persons contributed drafts, materials, and/or thoughtful comment in their respective areas of expertise without any compensation beyond a hearty thank you and this recognition and acknowledgement. Thank you for sharing your hard-earned expertise. Maryland Courts – Jurisdiction and Procedure Jonathan A. Azrael, Esq.* Lead David E. Ralph, Esq. Chair, State Board of Law Examiners Member, State Board of Law Examiners Senior Partner, Azrael, Franz, Schwab & Lipowitz In-House Counsel, Exelon Corporation Professor John Lynch, Esq.
    [Show full text]
  • "I Quit This Court.": Is Justice Denied in Arthur Miller's the Crucible?
    The University of Chicago Law School Roundtable Volume 2 | Issue 2 Article 11 1-1-1995 "I Quit This Court.": Is Justice Denied in Arthur Miller's The rC ucible? David R. Samuelson Follow this and additional works at: http://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/roundtable Recommended Citation Samuelson, David R. (1995) ""I Quit This Court.": Is Justice Denied in Arthur Miller's The rC ucible?," The University of Chicago Law School Roundtable: Vol. 2: Iss. 2, Article 11. Available at: http://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/roundtable/vol2/iss2/11 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by Chicago Unbound. It has been accepted for inclusion in The nivU ersity of Chicago Law School Roundtable by an authorized administrator of Chicago Unbound. For more information, please contact [email protected]. "I Quit This Court.": Is Justice Denied in Arthur Miller's The Crucible? DAVID R. SAMUELSON "I denounce these proceedings, I quit this court."' Thus, at the end of Act Three, the Reverend John Hale punctuates the painful climax of The Crucible, Arthur Miller's memorable play about the Salem witch trials. And who in the audience would fault Hale's condemnation? Denied fair judgment, protagonist John Proctor has fallen the court's latest victim in a witch hunt that has already claimed Proctor's wife, his friends, and his neighbors. Proctor and the others, none of them witches, will hang with Salem's approval and at its behest on the basis of "spectral evidence" produced by frightened children and a vengeful young woman.2 The accusers, in turn, have been spurred to their ruinous false charges by a rapacious, petty, and vindictive citizenry.
    [Show full text]
  • Legal Ideology and Incorporation III: Reason Regulated - the Op St-Restoration English Civilians, 1653-1735 Daniel R
    Boston College Law School Digital Commons @ Boston College Law School Boston College Law School Faculty Papers March 1987 Legal Ideology and Incorporation III: Reason Regulated - The oP st-Restoration English Civilians, 1653-1735 Daniel R. Coquillette Boston College Law School, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://lawdigitalcommons.bc.edu/lsfp Part of the Legal Ethics and Professional Responsibility Commons, and the Legal History Commons Recommended Citation Daniel R. Coquillette. "Legal Ideology and Incorporation III: Reason Regulated - The osP t-Restoration English Civilians, 1653-1735." Boston University Law Review 67, (1987): 289-361. This Article is brought to you for free and open access by Digital Commons @ Boston College Law School. It has been accepted for inclusion in Boston College Law School Faculty Papers by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ Boston College Law School. For more information, please contact [email protected]. IDEOLOGY AND INCORPORATION III: REASON REGULATED-THE POST-RESTORATION ENGLISH CIVILIANS, 1653-1735t DANIEL R. COQUILLETTE* Thus are the civilians excluded both from Publick and Private Business. As for my self, I have done my Part in showing how highly the Civil Law was once esteem'd and regarded by the English, and that both the English and French Lawyers, Forcatulus and Chopinus, were true Prophets; in foretelling, that one time or other, the Civil Law would be no longer in use in this Kingdom.** Dr. Arthur Duck, D.C.L. "The Law in all Jurisdictions is but Reason Regulated .... Dr. John Godolphin, LL.D. This Article is the third in a four-part series entitled Legal Ideology and Incorpora- tion.
    [Show full text]
  • U.S. Reports: Tilghman V. Proctor, 125 U.S. 136 (1888)
    OCTOBER TERM, 1887. Syllabus. of the section levying the duty of twenty per centum ad val- 2'em, unless they were shown to have been used exclusively for that purpose, is not insisted upon by the Solicitor General in this court. It was very properly abandoned, the charge of the court upon that point being, in our opinion, clearly right. The judgment of the 0ircuit Court is accordingly Afflmmd- TILG AN v. PROCTOR. PROCTOR v. TILGHMANI. .APPEAS FRSOM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THEl UNITED STATES FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO. Nos. 537, 545. Argued November, 3,4, 5, 188G.-Declded March 19, 1888. One having an interest in all fees and other sums to be recovered under a patent, but not shown to have any interat, legal or equitable, in the patent itself, need not be made a party to a bill in equity for its infringe- ment. Upon a bill in equity by the owner against infringers of a patent, the plaintiff, although he has establishe, license fees, is not limited to the amount of such fees, as damages; but may, instead of damages, recover the amount of gains and profits that the defendants have made by the use of his invention, over what they would have had in using other means then open to the public and adequate to enable them to obtain an equally beneficial result. Upon a bill in equity for infinging a patent, if the de;endauts have gained an advantage by using the plaintifrs invention, that advantage is the meisure of the profits to be accounted for, even if from other causes the business in which the invention was employed by the defendants did not result in profits; and if the use..of a patented process produced a definite saving in the cost of manufacture, they must account to the patentee for the amount so saved.
    [Show full text]