sustainability Article Do We Need a New Florence Charter? The Importance of Authenticity for the Maintenance of Historic Gardens and Other Historic Greenery Layouts in the Context of Source Research (Past) and Taking into Account the Implementation of the Sustainable Development Idea (Future) Marzanna Jagiełło Department of Architecture Conservation and Restoration of Cultural Landscape, Faculty of Architecture Wrocław, University of Science and Technology, 50-317 Wrocław, Poland;
[email protected] Abstract: This year, 40 years have passed since the adoption of the basic document for the protection of historic gardens, i.e., the Florence Charter. During this time, its recommendations have been verified by both conservation and researchers’ actions, who in various environments discussed its meaning as well as its essential shortcomings. Some of the provisions of the Charter were criticized in the context of the effects of their use, especially those relating to the issue of historic gardens fundamental protection, namely to authenticity in its various scopes with particular emphasis on the use of source research which raises many reservations for conservation actions. Moreover, Citation: Jagiełło, M. Do We Need a their excessively superficial interpretation, which was demonstrated by the example of the most New Florence Charter? The popular plant used in regular gardens, namely boxwood. This article presents and analyzes the Importance of Authenticity for the Maintenance of Historic Gardens and most important theses of these discussions and the main axes of the dispute, dividing them into Other Historic Greenery Layouts in two parts, i.e., the first relating to authenticity and the other to the use of sources.