DOCSLIB.ORG

EVALUATING RECORDED PERFORMANCE an Investigation

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
EVALUATING RECORDED PERFORMANCE an Investigation EVALUATING RECORDED PERFORMANCE An investigation of music criticism through Gramophone reviews of Beethoven piano sonata recordings Elena Alessandri Submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy at the Royal College of Music, London September 2014 Declaration I hereby confirm that the entire submission is my own work and has not been submitted for a comparable academic award. 2 ABSTRACT Critical review of performance is today one of the most common professional and commercial forms of music written response. Despite the availability of representative material and its impact on musicians’ careers, there has been little structured enquiry into the way music critics make sense of their experience of performances, and no studies have to date broached the key question of how music performance is reviewed by experts. Adopting an explorative, inductive approach and a novel combination of data reduction and thematic analysis techniques, this thesis presents a systematic investigation of a vast corpus of recorded performance critical reviews. First, reviews of Beethoven’s piano sonata recordings (N = 845) published in the Gramophone (1923-2010) were collected and metadata and word-stem patterns were analysed (Chapters 3 and 4) to offer insights on repertoire, pianists and critics involved and to produce a representative selection (n = 100) of reviews suitable for subsequent thematic analyses. Inductive thematic analyses, including a key-word-in-context analysis on ‘expression’ (Chapter 5), were then used to identify performance features (primary and supervenient) and extra-performance elements critics discuss, as well as reasons they use to support their value judgements. This led to a novel descriptive model of critical review of recorded performance (Chapters 6, 7, and 8). The model captures four critical activities – evaluation, descriptive judgement, factual information and meta-criticism – and seven basic evaluation criteria on the aesthetic and achievement-related value of performance reliably used by critics, plus two recording-specific criteria: live-performance impact and collectability. Critical review emerges as a highly dense form of writing, rich in information and open to diverse analytical approaches. Insights gained throughout the thesis inform current discourses in philosophy of art and open new perspectives for empirical music research. They emphasise the importance of the comparative element in performance evaluation, the complexity and potentially misleading nature of the notion of ‘expression’ in the musical discourse, and the role of critics as filters of choice in the recording market. Foremost, they further our understanding of the nature of music performance criticism as a form of reasoned evaluation that is complex, contextual and listener specific. 3 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS My first thanks go to my advisor, Aaron Williamon, for the support throughout this work, endless readings of chapter drafts and for the always straightforward and reassuring attitude in difficult moments. Your flexibility and openness made this research journey possible beyond distance and logistical constraints. Thank you for your warm hospitality and friendship, and for treating me as a researcher, and not as a student, from the beginning on. I owe the utmost gratitude to my second supervisor, friend and mentor Hubert Eiholzer. His contribution impregnates this whole work and extends far beyond it. You saw the path I was supposed to go far before I did, and supported me throughout the way with disarmingly altruism. Thank you for all our absorbing discussions, debating everything from artistic integrity to wine tasting. You nurtured my curiosity, passion for research, and thirst for clarity. Thank you for inspiring me. I would like to thank my practical consultant, Olivier Senn, for the personal and institutional support to this research, and for trusting me with a research outside your field of expertise, allowing me the freedom necessary to carry on with the project. Your careful, thoughtful readings and almost painstaking obsession with graphs and diagrams significantly improved this work in the final stage. A special thank you goes then to my ‘fourth’ de facto advisor, Vicky Williamson. During your ten months in Lucerne you have given invaluable inputs to this research and helped me understand what it means to be an academic, and what kind of academic and person I would like to become. I would love to be one day half as good as you are in dealing with colleagues, students, and busy schedules! Thank you for the endless chats on the most disparate research (and off-research) topics, for your patience with my thousands questions and for all the intense hours spent on the review texts. This project has been partially supported by the Swiss National Science Foundation, the Swiss State Secretariat for Education, Research, and Innovation, the Conservatorio della Svizzera italiana, and, in larger part, from my current institution, the Lucerne University of Applied Sciences and Arts, School of Music. 4 The whole research would have not been possible without the Gramophone permission to access and study their published material so extensively. I am thus most grateful to Luca Da Re and the magazine commission for their collaboration. I would also like to thank Prof. King and the Institute for Quantitative Social Science at Harvard University for permission to use their text analysis algorithms and for the methodological support in this regard, and Alessandro Cervino for his assistance in collecting data. Many other persons have contributed to the completion of this work in different ways over these four years. Thank you to Dorottya Fabian, Thüring Bräm, and Daniel Leech-Wilkinson for their valuable comments and inspiring conversations. Thanks to Noola Griffiths and Ivan Hewett for their feedback on the first part of the thesis, and to Rosie Perkins and David Weasley for their advice on methodology and data analysis. I would also like to thank Jürg Huber for taking me on concerts, and letting me experience first-hand the process of critical review writing and the challenges, even ethical ones, that this work may entail. Finally, I would like to thank the people that have encouraged and supported me with their friendship and love. Thank you Lisa, Geordie, Liliana, Sara, Louise and all the CPS staff for letting me feel part of the group although I was so rarely there. Thank you Ruta for your PhD-fellow advices and for forcing me out of the office on sunny days (and not giving up on me not answering calls and messages). Most of all, my gratitude and appreciation go to my family. To my mom and dad, who have always been there for me and my brother, and supported all my unconventional choices. To Sim, who is unarguably the best brother one could wish for, and Angela, for her enthusiasm whenever we meet, and her reluctance to let me go every single time. And to my Holger. He dealt with all my ups and downs with infinite patience and loving care, always reminding me of the beauty waiting outside the doorstep. Your love and genuine simplicity make me so much stronger. I love you all dearly. Elena Alessandri 5 TABLE OF CONTENTS List of Publications _______________________________________________ 13 List of Tables and Figures _________________________________________ 14 Introduction _____________________________________________________ 19 ON THE VALUE OF MUSIC PERFORMANCE ______________________ 23 The Standard of Taste _____________________________________________ 25 Modalities of evaluation __________________________________________ 26 The Reasoning Model __________________________________________ 26 Holistic versus Segmented schemes _______________________________ 27 The agreement of experts _________________________________________ 31 Judges’ consistency ____________________________________________ 31 Judges’ reliability _____________________________________________ 33 The role of expertise ___________________________________________ 35 Open concerns __________________________________________________ 36 The Process of Performance Evaluation ______________________________ 37 McPherson and Schubert’s model of performance assessment ____________ 38 Non-musical factors _____________________________________________ 40 Gender and race _______________________________________________ 40 Order of performances _________________________________________ 41 Extra-musical factors _____________________________________________ 42 Performer-related aspects _______________________________________ 42 Context-related aspects _________________________________________ 45 Evaluator-related aspects ________________________________________ 47 Musical factors _________________________________________________ 52 Explanatory and non-explanatory reasons __________________________ 52 General principles of musical value _______________________________ 54 Value(s) of musical performances _________________________________ 57 Performance as event ____________________________________________ 60 Music Criticism __________________________________________________ 63 6 Seeking further understanding _____________________________________ 63 Quantitative assessment versus Verbal feedback _____________________ 63 Verbalization of music perception ________________________________ 65 Focus on music critics __________________________________________ 68 Criticism as evaluation ___________________________________________ 69 Historical grounds _____________________________________________
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Elaine Fitz Gibbon
    Elaine Fitz Gibbon »Beethoven und Goethe blieben die Embleme des kunstliebenden Deutschlands, für jede politische Richtung unantastbar und ebenso als Chiffren manipulierbar« (Klüppelholz 2001, 25-26). “Beethoven and Goethe remained the emblems of art-loving Germany: untouchable for every political persuasion, and likewise, as ciphers, just as easily manipulated.”1 The year 2020 brought with it much more than collective attempts to process what we thought were the uniquely tumultuous 2010s. In addition to causing the deaths of over two million people worldwide, the Covid-19 pandemic has further exposed the extraordinary inequities of U.S.-American society, forcing a long- overdue reckoning with the entrenched racism that suffuses every aspect of American life. Within the realm of classical music, institutions have begun conversations about the ways in which BIPOC, and in particular Black Americans, have been systematically excluded as performers, audience members, administrators and composers: a stark contrast with the manner in which 2020 was anticipated by those same institutions before the pandemic began. Prior to the outbreak of the novel coronavirus, they looked to 2020 with eager anticipation, provoking a flurry of activity around a singular individual: Ludwig van Beethoven. For on December 16th of that year, Beethoven turned 250. The banners went up early. In 2019 on Instagram, Beethoven accounts like @bthvn_2020, the “official account of the Beethoven Anniversary Year,” sprang up. The Twitter hashtags #beethoven2020 and #beethoven250 were (more or less) trending. Prior to the spread of the virus, passengers flying in and out of Chicago’s O’Hare airport found themselves confronted with a huge banner that featured an iconic image of Beethoven’s brooding face, an advertisement for the Chicago Symphony Orchestra’s upcoming complete cycle Current Musicology 107 (Fall 2020) ©2020 Fitz Gibbon.
    [Show full text]
  • Fantasia for Piano
    letter from englaNd faNTaSia for piaNO Joyce Hatto’s incredible career. by MaRK SiNgER n the summer of 1989, in Royston, music labels that helped establish the England, a man named William Bar- form—known as the “super-bargain” rington-CoupeI cheerfully received a classical LP. Such recordings, which visitor from Germany: Ernst Lumpe, a retailed for roughly a dollar apiece, were high-school teacher, fervent music a wellspring of artful pseudonyms— lover, and record collector. For a couple Paul Procopolis, Giuseppe Parolini, the of years, the two men had sustained a Cincinnati Pro Arte Philharmonic, the correspondence that consisted mainly of Munich Greater State Symphony— Barrington-Coupe, a former classical- and Barry is credited with coining the music agent and a peripatetic record wittiest of all: Wilhelm Havagesse (con- producer, responding to Lumpe’s ques- ducting Rimsky-Korsakov’s “Schehe- tions about the authenticity of various razade,” as rendered by the spurious arcane LPs. Zurich Municipal Orchestra). The During the nineteen-fifties and six- small labels that Barry worked at had a ties, a number of record companies in tendency to run aground financially, England and America had a practice— but perhaps his most dependable asset questionable but nodded and winked was his resilience—a facility for dusting at—of repackaging LPs by established himself off and moving on to the next artists as the work of fictitious perform- venture. ers and selling the recordings at a deep Among Lumpe’s fifteen thousand discount. Barrington-Coupe, known LPs, many of which he bought second- to familiars as Barry, worked at several hand, were about five hundred of murky Above left: an undated photograph of Joyce Hatto.
    [Show full text]
  • Beethoven's 250 Anniversary
    PIANO MAGAZINE WINTER 2020–2021 | VOL 12 | NO 5 CELEBRATING TH BEETHOVEN’S 250 ANNIVERSARY AND MUSICAL INNOVATORS WINTER 2020–2021 Anne-Marie Commissioning Stories McDermott: Composition & Celebrating | VOL 12 | NO 5 $12.99 VOL of Pianists’ Creativity Artist, Leader, Innovator Underrepresented Composers CLAVIERCOMPANION.COM / a magazine for people who are passionate about the piano PIANO MAGAZINE PUBLISHER The Frances Clark Center for Keyboard Pedagogy EDITOR-IN-CHIEF / CHIEF CONTENT DIRECTOR WHAT YOU’LL Pamela D. Pike FIND INSIDE SENIOR EDITOR / DIRECTOR OF DIGITAL CONTENT Andrea McAlister • SENIOR EDITORS Steve Betts RESOURCES TO SUPPORT Craig Sale OUR COMMUNITY IN COLUMN EDITORS MUSICAL ENGAGEMENT Linda Christensen, Technology & ADVOCACY Vanessa Cornett, Healthy Playing, Healthy Teaching Barbara Kreader Skalinder, Teaching • Artina McCain, Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Nicholas Phillips, Recordings COVERAGE OF THE Suzanne Schons, Books, Materials, and Music NEWEST TRENDS & IDEAS Helen Smith Tarchalski, Keyboard Kids IN PERFORMANCE Jerry Wong, International Richard Zimdars, Poetry Corner AND PEDAGOGY EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR & CEO • Jennifer Snow PRACTICAL SOLUTIONS DESIGN & PRODUCTION FOR PIANO TEACHING studio Chartreuse & LEARNING PROFILES COPY EDITORS Rebecca Bellelo • Kristen Holland Shear THOUGHT-PROVOKING DIGITAL OPERATIONS Shana Kirk IDEAS FROM A RANGE OF CONTRIBUTORS ADVERTISING COORDINATOR Anna Beth Rucker • CUSTOMER SUPPORT Morgan Kline REVIEWS OF THE LATEST MUSIC, RECORDINGS, CIRCULATION The Frances Clark Center for Keyboard Pedagogy BOOKS, TECHNOLOGY, & EDUCATIONAL EDITORIAL BOARD Nancy Bachus PRODUCTS Alejandro Cremashi Barbara Fast Rebecca Grooms Johnson Scott McBride Smith Winter Issue 2020-2021 Vol 12 No 5 / 1 CONTENTS Anne-Marie McDermott: ARTIST, LEADER, INNOVATOR by Andrea McAlister 12 Photo: Group lesson at NSMS (1960s) EXPLORE LEARN TEACH 9 EDITOR’S LETTER 32 THE GIFT OF NEW 36 BECOMING WEAVERS: Pamela D.
    [Show full text]
  • Proyecto Fin De Carrera Plan 2000       
    PROYECTO FIN DE CARRERA PLAN 2000 TEMA: ANLISIS DE M SICA GRABADA TÍTULO: ANLISIS DE M SICA GRABADA: BALADAS Y SCHERZOS DE CHOPIN AUTOR: ÁNGEL ESTEBAN VICENTE TUTOR: JORGE GRUNDMAN ISLA Vº Bº. DEPARTAMENTO: DIAC Miembros del Tribunal Calificador: PRESIDENTE: WALDO PÉREZ AGUIAR VOCAL: VOCAL SECRETARIO: ANTONIO MÍNGUEZ OLIVARES DIRECTOR: Fecha de lectura: 30 DE SEPTIEMBRE DE 2.014 Calificación: El Secretario, RESUMEN DEL PROYECTO: Anlisis de múltiples grabaciones de las cuatro baladas y los cuatro scherzos de Chopin realizadas por diversos int rpretes. El objetivo del proyecto ser determinar las diferencias objetivas existentes entre las diferentes ejecuciones y respecto a una partitura de referencia. ANÁLISIS'DE'MÚSICA'GRABADA:'BALADAS'Y'SCHERZOS'DE'CHOPIN' ! ! ! ! ! 3! ANÁLISIS'DE'MÚSICA'GRABADA:'BALADAS'Y'SCHERZOS'DE'CHOPIN! ! ! ! ! ! 4! ! ANÁLISIS'DE'MÚSICA'GRABADA:'BALADAS'Y'SCHERZOS'DE'CHOPIN' ! 1 !Índice' 1! !ÍNDICE! 5! 2! INTRODUCCIÓN! 7! 3! ANÁLISIS!DE!LA!MÚSICA!GRABADA! 11! 3.1! HISTORIA!DE!LA!MÚSICA!GRABADA!Y!DESARROLLO!TÉCNICO! 11! 3.1.1! JUSTIFICACIÓN!DEL!ANÁLISIS!DE!MÚSICA!GRABADA! 17! 3.1.2! EL!FRAUDE!DE!JOYCE!HATTO! 21! 3.2! EL!CHARM! 23! 4! HERRAMIENTAS!DE!SOFTWARE! 25! 4.1! SONIC!VISUALISER! 25! 4.2! MICROSOFT!EXCEL! 32! 4.3! APPLE!LOGIC!PRO!9! 33! 4.4! MATHWORKS!MATLAB! 35! 5! METODOLOGÍA!DE!ANÁLISIS! 37! 5.1! TÍTULO!DE!LA!OBRA! 38! 5.1.1! ANÁLISIS!FORMAL! 38! 5.1.2! ANÁLISIS!DE!LA!INTERPRETACIÓN!DE!VLADIMIR!ASHKENAZY! 39! 5.1.3! COMPARACIÓN!CON!LAS!EJECUCIONES!DE!OTROS!INTÉRPRETES! 44! 6! ANÁLISIS! 49! 6.1!
    [Show full text]
  • The Rachel S. Thaler Concert Pianist Series, Angela Hewitt, Pianist
    Ithaca College Digital Commons IC All Concert & Recital Programs Concert & Recital Programs 9-28-1999 The Rachel S. Thaler Concert Pianist Series, Angela Hewitt, pianist Angela Hewitt Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.ithaca.edu/music_programs Part of the Music Commons Recommended Citation Hewitt, Angela, "The Rachel S. Thaler Concert Pianist Series, Angela Hewitt, pianist" (1999). All Concert & Recital Programs. 7773. https://digitalcommons.ithaca.edu/music_programs/7773 This Program is brought to you for free and open access by the Concert & Recital Programs at Digital Commons IC. It has been accepted for inclusion in All Concert & Recital Programs by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons IC. Since her triumph in the 1985 international Bach piano competition in Toronto, and her subse- quent Bach recording for Deutsche Grammophon, Angela Hewitt has been hailed as "one of the outstanding Bach pianists of our time" (Sunday Times [London], 1997). In 1994 she embarked on a 10-year project to record all the major keyboard works by Bach for the Hyperion label. She has performed throughout North America and Europe, as well as in Japan, Australia, China, Mexico, and the former Soviet Union. Born into a musical family, Hewitt began her piano studies at the age of 3, performing in public at 4 and a year later winning her first scholarship. She also studied violin, recorder, singing, and classical ballet. At 9, she gave her first recital at Toronto's Royal Conservatory of Music, where she studied from 1964 to 1973. Hewitt then studied with French pianist Jean-Paul Sevilla at the University of Ottawa, from which she earned her bachelor of music degree at the age of 18.
    [Show full text]
  • The Dahlhaus Project and Its Extra-Musicological Sources
    The Dahlhaus Project and Its Extra-musicological Sources JAMES HEPOKOSKI It is probably no overstatement to say that Carl the surface of its compact, often oblique prose, Dahlhaus's Nineteenth-Century Music' could and it presumes a readership involved in meth- alter the horizon of English-language musi- odological disputes taken for granted in West cology. Whether we wish to take issue with it Germany in the 1960s and 70s. Not surpris- or to build upon it, the book provides a needed ingly, the American response to date has been focus for discussion, and it seems likely to re- to sidestep the contextual engagement of its ar- main for some time the single broad argument guments in favor of noting the disturbing con- about the century that professionals will be ex- trast between the brilliance of Dahlhaus's pected to have confronted. Yet the book is not intellectualist approach to the history of music self-explanatory, particularly for American and the vexing reality of his apparent unwill- readers. Much of its raison d'etre lies beneath ingness to consider non-Germanic music on its own terms, his rigorously judgemental pro- nouncements, and his occasional errors of fac- 19th-Century Music XIV/3 (Spring 1991). ? by the Regents tual detail. Thus Philip Gossett, Dahlhaus's of the University of California. sharpest American critic to date, recently con- For responses to an early version of this paper, as wellcluded as that "the errors [of Nineteenth-Century for corrections and suggestions, I am grateful to Manuela Music] reveal a systemic failure. Dahlhaus's Jahrmirker, Andrew Jones, Sanna Pederson, Ruth Solie, and Richard Wattenbarger.
    [Show full text]
  • Andrea Lucchesini SCHUBERT • LATE PIANO WORKS VOL
    Andrea Lucchesini SCHUBERT • LATE PIANO WORKS VOL. II Franz Schubert Late Piano Works • Vol. II Piano Sonata No. 21 in B-flat major, D. 960 I. Molto moderato 21:54 II. Andante sostenuto 10:38 III. Scherzo. Allegro vivace con delicatezza – Trio 4:11 IV. Allegro, ma non troppo 9:05 Three Piano Pieces, D. 946 I. Allegro assai 14:36 II. Allegretto 13:08 III. Allegro 5:16 “The sad «very last» one” – Schubert’s Sonata in B-flat major “A musician visiting Vienna for the first time may well be amused for a while by the convivial hustle and bustle in the streets, and he will often stop in amazement in front of the tower of St Stephen’s Cathedral; but soon he is reminded of the city’s proximity to a churchyard which is more important to him than anything else the city has to offer, where two of the most magnificent of his fellow artists are laid to rest only a few paces from each other. So, like me, many a young musician may soon have wandered out after the first noisy days to the Währinger Kirchhof, to lay a floral offering on those tombs, even if it were a wild rose bush, as I found planted on Beethoven’s grave. Franz Schubert’s resting place was unadorned.” No more than eleven and ten years respectively had passed since the deaths of Beethoven and Schubert when Robert Schumann visited the Währing cemetery in Vienna. But the traveller from Leipzig did not content himself with merely visiting the graves: Schumann also called on Ferdinand Schubert, who looked after a wealth of unpublished manuscripts by his brother Franz.
    [Show full text]
  • 14Th Annual Peggy Glanville-Hicks Address 2012
    australian societa y fo r s music educationm e What Would Peggy Do? i ncorporated 14th Annual Peggy Glanville-Hicks Address 2012 Michael Kieran Harvey The New Music Network established the Peggy Glanville-Hicks Address in 1999 in honour of one of Australia’s great international composers. It is an annual forum for ideas relating to the creation and performance of Australian music. In the spirit of the great Australian composer Peggy Glanville-Hicks, an outstanding advocate of Australian music delivers the address each year, challenging the status quo and raising issues of importance in new music. In 2012, Michael Kieran Harvey was guest speaker presenting his Address entitled What Would Peggy Do? at the Sydney Conservatorium on 22 October and BMW Edge Fed Square in Melbourne on 2 November 2012. The transcripts are reproduced with permission by Michael Kieran Harvey and the New Music Network. http://www.newmusicnetwork.com.au/index.html Australian Journal of Music Education 2012:2,59-70 Just in case some of you are wondering about I did read an absolutely awe-inspiring Peggy what to expect from the original blurb for this Glanville-Hicks Address by Jon Rose however, address: the pie-graphs didn’t quite work out, and and I guess my views are known to the address powerpoint is so boring, don’t you agree? organisers, so, therefore, I will proceed, certain For reasons of a rare dysfunctional condition in the knowledge that I will offend many and I have called (quote) “industry allergy”, and for encourage, I hope, a valuable few.
    [Show full text]
  • Die Relationen Der Musik Hören. Zu Wilhelm Furtwänglers Interpretationskunst Henrik Holm
    IZPP. Ausgabe 1/2016. Themenschwerpunkt „Demenz und Ethik“. Henrik Holm: „Die Relationen der Musik hören.“ Herausgeber: Wolfgang Eirund und Joachim Heil ISSN: 1869-6880 IZPP | Ausgabe 1/2016 | Themenschwerpunkt „Demenz und Ethik“ | Arbeiten zu anderen Themen Die Relationen der Musik hören. Zu Wilhelm Furtwänglers Interpretationskunst Henrik Holm Zusammenfassung Die Aufnahmen mit Furtwängler am Dirigentenpult rufen monumentale und faszinierende Hörerfahrungen hervor, besonders die aus den Kriegsjahren. Warum erfährt Furtwängler immer noch eine bewundernde Wert- schätzung? In diesem Aufsatz möchte ich Furtwänglers Interpretation von Beethovens neunter Symphonie vor dem Hintergrund seines interpretationsästhetischen Denkens thematisieren. Das Ziel ist es, Furtwänglers Interpretationskunst als eine Sache der ästhetischen Erfahrung zu verorten. Schlüsselwörter Musikphilosophie, Ästhetik, musikalische Interpretation Abstract Still today, the German conductor Wilhelm Furtwängler fascinates and causes monumental listening-experi- ences, especially through the recordings of his wartime-concerts. Why do we appreciate them to such a degree? What kind of listening-experience is this? In this article, I will discuss Furtwänglers interpretation of the beginning of Beethoven’s ninth symphony on the background of his thinking about musical interpretation and performance. My aim is to understand Furtwänglers interpretation as a genuine case of aesthetic experience. Keywords Philosophy of music, aesthetics, musical interpretation Einleitung Wilhelm Furtwängler
    [Show full text]
  • « Leopold Godowsky's Fifty-Three Studies on Chopin's Études »
    « Leopold Godowsky’s Fifty-Three Studies on Chopin’s Études » by « Younggun Kim » A thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the degree of « Doctor of Musical Arts » « Graduate Department of Music » University of Toronto © Copyright by « Younggun Kim » « 2017 » Leopold Godowsky’s Fifty-Three Studies on Chopin’s Études Younggun Kim Doctor of Musical Arts Graduate Department of Music University of Toronto 2017 Abstract Leopold Godowsky (1870-1937) composed works that require pianistic fluency of an exceptional order, including fifty-three Studies based on twenty-six of Frédéric Chopin’s twenty-seven Études. The purpose of this dissertation is to examine the significance of these Studies and to reveal the compositional techniques that Godowsky used to create them. This dissertation consists of a foreword and seven chapters. The foreword describes the unique position that Godowsky’s Studies occupy in the piano literature and argues that they deserve further scholarly research. Chapter one discusses Godowsky’s life and the composition of the Studies, and it provides a review of relevant literature. Chapter two is divided into ii two sections. The first section proposes five compositional techniques that are used to create the Studies: switch, condensation, superimposition/addition, reconstruction and merging. The second section examines Godowsky’s classification of the Studies into five categories: Strict Transcriptions, Free Transcriptions, Cantus Firmus Versions, Versions in Form of Variations and Metamorphoses. Chapters three, four and five are case studies of selected Studies, arranged by the compositional techniques presented in Chapter two. Chapter three deals with Studies that are composed using switch, superimposition/addition and merging technique.
    [Show full text]
  • Joyce Hatto and Chopin's Mazurkas
    Annual newsletter Issue 3 (May 2007) HARM (the AHRC Research Centre for the History and Analysis of Recorded Music) came into being on 1 April 2004, and this Newsletter looks back on our third year of activity. A partnership C of Royal Holloway, University of London, King's College London, and the University of Sheffield, CHARM is funded through a five-year grant from the AHRC, and its principal activities include a major on-line discographical project, a series of specialist symposia, and a portfolio of recordings-related research projects. For details of CHARM please visit our website at http://www.charm.rhul.ac.uk, where you can register with us to be informed of upcoming events – and next year’s newsletter! PURELY COINCIDENTAL? JOYCE HATTO AND CHOPIN’S MAZURKAS Since 15 February 2007, everyone has heard of Joyce Hatto. That was the day the story was broken by Gramophone magazine, up to then an ardent supporter of Hatto, the septuagenerian pianist who, in the years immediately preceding her death in 2006, had released a tide of recordings of the great pianistic warhorses. Issued on the Concert Artists/Fidelio label, owned by her husband William Barrington- Coupe, these recordings were the very embodiment of wish fulfilment: they told of a pianist who, forced by cancer to retire from the concert platform in the 1970s, had achieved an incredible feat of heroism against the odds in the recording studio. It seemed too good to be true. As it turned out, it was too good to be true. Gramophone's story was prompted by someone putting the Hatto recording of Liszt's Transcendental Studies into his computer and the iTunes software identifying it as a recording by Lászlo Simon.
    [Show full text]
  • September 2008 Ausstellungen Menschen Im Strom Der Stadt – Fotografien Von Bis 27.9
    mberSeptemberSept Der Gasteig im September 2008 Ausstellungen Menschen im Strom der Stadt – Fotografien von bis 27.9. Martin Schellenberger Bibl / Ebene 2.1 + 2.2 Martin Schellenberger fotografiert Menschen in München: Eintritt frei Der Künstler sucht mit seiner exzellenten Beobachtungs- gabe nach alltäglichen Geschehnissen und Situationen in der Großstadt München und bildet die Menschen auf der Straße auf Porträts ab, die zum Nachdenken anregen. Er sieht seine Aufgabe darin, den Wandel der Zeit und das Thema der Vergänglichkeit – mithilfe von Momentaufnahmen von Menschen – fotografisch umzusetzen. (Bibl) 70. Jahrestag – Entzug der Approbation jüdischer 25.9.–16.10. Ärztinnen und Ärzte im Nationalsozialismus Glashalle, 1. OG Unter der Schirmherrschaft von Charlotte Knobloch, Präsidentin Eintritt frei der Israelitischen Kultusgemeinde München Am 30. September 2008 jährt sich zum 70sten Mal, dass Eröffnung: jüdischen Ärztinnen und Ärzten per Gesetz vom 25. Juli 1938 Mi, 24.9., 19.00 Uhr verboten wurde, ihren Beruf weiter auszuüben. Was darunter zu verstehen war, wie sich das Berufsverbot in Gesetzen, Verordnungen und praktisch-politischer Umsetzung niederschlug, wie Lebensgeschichten banal bürokratisch zer- stört wurden, dokumentiert diese Ausstellung. Im Gedenken an alle diese Menschen und ihre Familien werden Einzel- schicksale exemplarisch porträtiert, indem sie selbst zu Wort kommen in Dokumenten, Briefen und Erinnerungen. (Dr. Hansjörg Ebell, München, in Zusammenarbeit mit ÄKBV, KVB, KZVB, ZBV, KR) Die Kinderbuchbrücke – 26.9.–30.10. Über die Anfänge der Internationalen Jugend- Glashalle, 1. OG bibliothek in der Münchner Nachkriegszeit Eintritt frei Die 1949 in der Kaulbachstraße eröffnete Internationale Jugendbibliothek war in der Münchner Nachkriegszeit eine Eröffnung: demokratische, weltoffene Insel für Kinder und Jugendliche. Hier wurde Do, 25.9., 19.00 Uhr lange Verbotenes gelesen und über Literatur und Politik diskutiert.
    [Show full text]