In the High Court of Karnataka at Bengaluru
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
R IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 21 ST DAY OF JUNE 2016 PRESENT THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE N.KUMAR AND THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE B.VEERAPPA W.P.No.27674/2012 c/w W.P.Nos.41366/2012, 27730/2012, 43718 & 43720 – 43732/2012, 4297/2013 & 1733/2013 (GM – PIL) In W.P.No.27674/2012: BETWEEN : 1. Khaleel Ahmed K.R., S/o Late Rasool Sab Aged about 58 years, C/o Azeez Khan No.2584, Idgah Mohalla Chikkaballapur-562 101. 2. Veeranna S/o Ramaiah V., Aged about 43 years, Sasalu Post-572 122 Honnudike, Tumkur District. 3. Shameer K. Gaonkar S/o Kamalakar Gaonkar Aged about 41 years, Behind KPTCL, Post Vandige Ankola-581 314, Uttara Kannada District. 4. Jayashekharappa S/o Halage Gowda - 2 - Aged about 41 years, Machenahalli Post Chikkamagalur Taluk & District. 5. Rajkumar Naik S/o Late Monappa Naik Aged about 42 years, Plot No.87, NGO Colony, Jewargi Road, Gulbarga-585 102. 6. K.S.Dakshayani Devi D/o Sidda Shetty K.S. Aged about 41 years, No.191, LIG 2 ND Stage, Kuvempunagara, Mysore-570 073. 7. Subraya Shambhu Hegde S/o Shambhu S. Hegde Aged about 41 years, Mudakani Post, Honnavara, Uttara Kannada – 581 395. 8. Khaleel Ahamed S/o Late Khalendar Saheb Aged about 43 years, No. 697/75, East End, Tilkanagar, Bangalore-560 011. 9. Leelavathi T. Raju D/o T.Kondaiah Aged about 46 years, Balaji Nivas, S.S.Puram, Tumkur. 10. D.Lakshminarayana S/o Devendrappa Aged about 41 years, No.77, Sri Ganesha, Gandhibazaar, Shimoga-577 202. - 3 - 11. M.N.Krishnachar S/o Late Narsimhachar Aged about 41 years, D.M.Palya, Don Basco Road Sira Gate Post, Tumkur. 12. Ravishankar K. S/o Jayarama Rao S. Aged about 40 years, Shettyhalli Road Fort Malavalli-571 430, Mandya District. 13. Chandrahasa H.R. S/o Rudrappa Aged about 43 years, Mugabla Village & Post Hosakote Taluk, Bangalore-562 114. 14. V.Vijaykumar S/o Late M.Venkataramana Aged about 45 years, No.413/16, 13 th Main, Lakkasandra Layout, Bangalore-560 030. 15. R.VenkateshReddy S/o Ramappa, Aged about 42 years, Nayandanahalli, Herikattigenahalli, Chitamani Chikkaballapura District-563 128. 16. Shivamurthy B.T. S/o Simha Shetty B.T. Aged about 43 years, S.Bidare Post, Kadur Taluk Chikkamagalur District. 17. Hanumatharaya T.V. S/o Late Eranna - 4 - Aged about 49 years, No.2988, 1st Main, ‘C’ Block Rajajiangar, Bangalore-560 021. 18. H.S.Veena D/o H.B.Shivanna Aged about 41 years, No.40, Nalme, 3 rd Main Vidyanagar, Tumkur-572 103. 19. Kalefulla H.S. S/o Late Shafifullah Aged about 47 years, No.612/1, 15 th Cross, K.T.J.Nagar Davanagere-577 002. 20. Vijayakumar Reddy B.R. S/o Ramakrishna Reddy Aged about 37 years, No.38, 1st Floor, 11 th Cross 16 th Main, BTM Layout, Bangalore-560 029. 21. Vijaykumar Naik S/o Nonaya Naik Aged about 39 years, R/o Bailu House Kadandale Village & Post , Karkala Taluk – 574 277. 22. A.Ananda S/o Annegowda Aged 42 years, Kalkere Village, Doddabelalu Post, Piriyapatna, Mysore District. 23. S.Devaraju S/o L.Shivashankar Aged about 44 years, PNR Palya, - 5 - Sira Gate Post, Tumkur-572 016. 24. Chandregowda S/o Late Jogi Gowda Aged about 49 years, Badur Post, Arsikere Taluk, Hassan District. 25. Liaqat Ali H.R., S/o Abdul Gaffar Sab Aged about 44 years, Haralipura Village Marabana Halli Post, Channagiri Taluk Davanagere – 577 551. ...PETITIONERS (By Sri M.B.Nargund, Senior Counsel along with Sri VikramPhadke, Adv.) AND : 1. The State of Karnataka Rep. by its Chief Secretary Vidhana Soudha, Bangalore-560 001. 2. The Principal Secretary Department of Personnel & Administrative Reforms (DPAR) Vidhana Soudha, Bangalore-560 001. 3. The Karnataka Public Service Commission Udyoga Soudha, Bangalore-560 001 (As per order dated 12.08.2013). 4. Sri Hidayatullah, Officer of Special Duty Department of Health &Family Welfare, Vidhana Soudha, Bangalore-560 001. - 6 - (Impleaded vide order dated 19.02.2014). 5. Sri Mohamed Rafi Pasha S/o Mohamed Yusuf Khan Aged about 33 years, No.4/1, Kareem Enclave, Flat No.2B, 2nd Floor, 13 th Cross, Jayanagar, Bangalore-560 011 (Impleaded vide order dated 20.08.2014). 6. Sri Bhaskar Naik S/o Late Neelakant S. Naik Aged about 44 years, No.153, 5th ‘A’ Cross, Yelahanka New Town Bangalore-560 064. (Impleaded vide order dated 20.08.2014). 7. Smt.Salma Firdose W/o Jameel Ahamed Pasha Aged about 40 years, Assistant Registrar of Co-operative Societies Bangalore (Impleaded vide order dated 20.08.2014). 8. Smt.Asha Parveen D/o Mohammed Pasha Aged about 39 years, No.62, 2nd Cross, J.S.Nagar Saraswathipura, M.Nandini Layout, Bangalore -560 096 (Impleaded vide order Dated 20.08.2014). 9. Sri Natesh D.B. S/o Basavarajappa Aged about 38 years, No.3/1, 7th A Main Road, Muthyalanagar, Bangalore-560 054 (Impleaded vide order Dated 20.08.2014). - 7 - The following Respondents are impleaded vide order dated 16.09.2014 Post: Assistant Commissioner Group-A 10. Satheesha B.C. Veterinary Officer Canine Rabies Control Unit, Dhanvantri Road Mysore – 570 001. 11. Nagaraju N.R. C/o Dr. S.M.Byregowda No.20/2, Krishna Kuvempu Road, Hebbal Kempapura, Bangalore-560 024. 12. Basavarajendra H., No.382, 13 th Main, RMV Extn., Sadashivanagar, Bangalore-560 080. 13. Gopalakrishna H.N. C/o Rajanna R., Door No.74, Behind Subramanya Temple, Banagiri Nagar, BSK 3 rd Stage, Bangalore-560 085. 14. Raghavendra Suhasaa H.G. S/o H.T.Govinda Gowda 250, 3 rd Main, 1 st Cross, BHCS Layout, Chikkalasandra Bangalore-560 061. 15. Shivashankara N., C/o Rame Gowda No.40, 5 th B Cross, 1 st Main, Defence Colony, Hesaraghatta Road, T.Dasarahalli, Bangalore-560 073. - 8 - 16. Arundati Chandrashekar D/o Dr. T.Chandrashekar No.22, “Anugraha”, 2 nd Main, Muneshwara Block, Harinagar Cross, Konankunte Bangalore-560 062. 17. Ravi M.R. No.271, Belaku, Behind Water Tank, Alanahalli Extension, Mysore-570 011. 18. Ravindra P.N. S/o P.H.Ningappa A.M.G.H.P.S., Kallenahalli, Thyagadhakatte Post Tarikere Taluk-577 549. 19. Jyothi K. No.823, 6 th Cross, 5th Main, M.C. Layout, Vijayanagar, Bangalore-560 040. 20. Meena Nagaraj C.N. No.606/614, New Kamakshi Layout 1st Stage, 1 st ‘A’ Main Road, Basaveshwara Nagar Bangalore-560 079. 21. Akram Pasha S/o Nanne Jan, C/o Riyaz Basha, No.564, Darga Mohalla Chickballapur-562 101. 22. Leelavathy K. D/o G.N.Kamanna No.61, 3 rd Cross, Nanjareddy Colony - 9 - HAL Post, Bangalore-560 017. 23. Vasanthakumar P., S/o Puttamadaiah No.1718/A, 11 th Main, Bayyanna Garden, Prakash Nagar Bangalore-560 021. 24. Karee Gowda, S/o Sidde Gowda Chikkona Hally, Kelaghatta Post, Maddur Taluk, Mandya District – 571 419. 25. Shivanand Kapashi S/o Bhimappa Kapashi Guru Kripa, Basavanagar, Gokak, Belgaum District-591 307. 26. Gangubai Ramesh Manakar D/o Ramesh Manakar Near Bus Stand, Sindagi Bijapur District – 586 128. 27. Kavitha S. Mannikeri No.191, 8 th Cross, Shakthiganapathi Nagar Basaveshwaranagara, Bangalore-560 079. 28. Peddappaiah R.S. S/o Sanjeevarayappa Ramachandra Pura P.O., Gowribidanur Taluk, Kolar District. 29. Rushibendra Murthy G.C., No.91/A, MES Colony, Konena Agrahara, HAL Bangalore-560 017. - 10 - Post: Assistant Controller Group-A. 30. Hanumanthegowda T.S. S/o Sambulinge Gowda T.Gollahalli, Kodihalli Post, Kanakapura Taluk, Bangalore District-562119. 31. Shivanand G. Navi S/o Gurupadappa Y. Navi, At Post Yadhalli, Bilgi Taluk, Bagalkot District-587 117. 32. Kankaraja D. No.5, “Shreyas Nilaya”, Padma Film Theatre Road Amruthahalli, Sahakara Nagar Post, Bangalore-560 092. 33. Sidrameshwar Ukkali S/o Mahadev Bapuri Lane, At PO Rabkavi, Bagalkot-587314. 34. Raghu G.P., S/o Puttegowda G.A. Boovanahally Post, Hassan Taluk & District-573 201. 35. Khadar Pasha A. S/o Ahmed Hussain MIG-II, 454, 1 st Stage, 3 rd Cross, Rajeev Nagar, Mysore-570 019. 36. Srikanth Rao K. C/o Shivashankar Rao Excel ELEL, No. C-142, Near Post Office, Peenya 2 nd Stage Bangalore – 560 058. - 11 - 37. Vasantha Kumar B.V. S/o Venkataramanappa Bendiganahalli, Hoskote Taluk, Bangalore Rural District-562 129. 38. Manjunatha Swamy G.N. C/o Rangaswamy, No.375, 8th Block, Mallappa Reddy Layout Koramangala, Bangalore-560 095. 39. Revanna R. S/o Ramakrishnappa Nagannana Palya, Sira Gate, Tumkur-572 106. 40. Roopashree B.V. No.92, II Main, Binny R.P.C. Layout Vijayanagar II Stage, Bangalore-560 040. 41. Raghavendra V. S/o S.Venkatraman, No.51, 16 th Cross, 33 rd Main Road, J.P.Nagar 6 th Phase, Bangaore-560 078. 42. Sangappa Upase, At Post Anjutagi Indi Taluk, Bijapur District-586 204. 43. Sheik Lathief, S/o Sheik Pakir Sahib Odala House, Ujire Post, Belthangady Tq., D.K. District-574240. 44. Ramesha Reddy B. S/o Bali Reddy N., Digavachinatapalli, Addagal P.O., - 12 - Srinivasapura Taluk, Kolar District-563 134. 45. Mahantesh S., C/o Gangadhar, Advocate, 2nd Main, Near Jain Temple, Hosadurga – 577527. 46. Gangadhara B.K. S/o Kempegowda Bandihalli, Sulekere Post Arasikere Taluk, Hassan District-573 103. 47. Santhavva Kadi D/o Basalingappa Kadi C/o T.Shivalingappa State Bank Colony, Near KEB, Badami, Bagalkot-587 201. 48. Mohammed Iqbal M. Mirza S/o Mohammed Baig G. Mirza PHC K., Salwadagi P.O., B.Bagewadi Taluk, Bijapur District-586 208. 49. Sheela Thomas D/o Thomas Gabriel No.659, 3rd Cross, 3 rd Main, 1st Block, Ramakrishnanagar Mysore-570 022. 50 Channappa A., Sri Gurumahanteshwara Nilaya 163/1039, Vijayavittalanagara Siruguppa, Bellary District– 583121.