Gujarat Pollution Control Board Regional Office, Belgium Square, Silver Plaza Complex, Opp. Linear Bus Stand, Ring Road, Surat -395 003 Website: www.gpcb.gov.in ISO9001 and ISO 14001 certified organization PUBLIC HEARING PROCEEDINGS It is hereby informed that as per the Ministry of Environment and Forests & Climate Change, Government of India, New Delhi vide its notification no. S.O. 1533 dated 14/09/2006 and its subsequent amendment S.O. 3067 (E) dated 01/1212009, Public Hearing is arranged for MIs. Rajhans Fila Textile Park (CETP), for proposed Common Effluent Treatment Plant (CETP) - Total Capacity 2.5 MLD, located at Block No. 78, 79, 80, 85, 88, 96, 99 & 294, Viii : Lindiyad, Ta. Mangrol, Dis!. Surat (Gujarat) covered under category "B" as mentioned in their request application.
A copy of the draft Environment Impact Assessment Report and the Summary of Environment Impact Assessment Report was sent to the following authorities or offices to make available the draft EIA report for inspection to the public during normal office hours, till the Public Hearing is over.
1. The District Collector Office, Surat 2. District Development Office, Surat 3. District Industry Centre, Surat 4. Taluka Development Office, Tal: Mangrol, Dist.: Surat 5. The Chief Conservator of Forests, Ministry of Environment and Forest, GOI, Regional Office 0Nest Zone), Kendriya Paryavaran Bhavan, E-5, Arera Colony, Link Road-3, Ravisankar Colony, Bhopal- 462016. 6. Regional Office, Gujarat Pollution Control Board, Belgium Square, Silver Plaza Complex, Opp. Linear Bus Stand, Ring Road, Surat - 395 003.
Other concerned persons having plausible stake in environmental aspects were requested to send their responses in writing to the concerned regulatory authorities.
The Public Hearing was held on 25/07/2017 at 11:00 hrs. at Project site, MIs. Rajhans Fila Textile Parik (CETP), Block No. 78, 79, 80, 85, 88, 96, 99 & 294, ViII: Lindiyad, Ta. Mangrol, Dis!. Surat (Gujarat).
An advertisement in English was published in "The Times of India" on 19/05/2017 and in Gujarati in "Gujarat Samachar" dated 19/05/2017 initially for conducting the said public hearing on 20-06-2017 which was postponed due to unavoidable circumstances. The advertisements for postponement of public hearing and intimation about new date was published in "The Times of India" on 19/06/2017 and in Gujarati in "Gujarat sarnachar' dated 19/06/2017. Gujarat Pollution Control Board Regional Office. Belgium Square. Silver Plaza Complex, Opp. Linear Bus Stand, Ring Road, Surat -395 003 Website: www.gocb.gov.in ISO 9001 and ISO 14001 certified organization Shri S.D.Vasava (GAS), Resident Additional District & Additional District Magistrate, Surat supervised and presided over the entire public hearing process.
A statement showing participants present during the public hearing is enclosed as Annexure A.
A statement highlighting issues raised by the participants and responded to by the representative of the applicant during the public hearing in English and GUjarati Languages is enclosed as Annexure Band B1 respectively.
A copies of responses received in writing from other persons having plausible stake and written representation received during Public Hearing in environmental aspects are enclosed herewith collectively as Annexure C-1 and C-5, the replies by applicant to the same are enclosed herewith collectively as Annexure 0-1 and 0-5.
~.,/I"'" ~ ~~ Place: Lindiyad, T. B. SHAH S. D. VASAVA (GAS) Ta: Mangrol Regional Officer, Resident Additional Collector Dis\.: Surat GPCB, Surat, and Date: 25/07/2017 Committee Member, Additional District Magistrate, Representative of the Surat Member Secretary, GPCB
Encl: 1 Annexure A, S, S1, C-1 to C-5, 0-1 to 0-5 and E as above. 2 Video CO of public hearing GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, SURAT 338, Belgium Square, Typkal l" Floor, Opp. Linear Bus Stand, Ring Road, Surat.
ANNEXURE-A A statement showing participants present during the public hearing
As per the Ministry of Environment & Forests, Government of India, New Delhi vide its notification number S.O. 1533 dated 14 September 2006 and subsequent amendment S.O. 3067(E) dated 1st December 2009, Public Hearing was fixed for MIS Rajhans Fila Textile Park (CETP) for proposed establish Common Effluent treatment plant (CETP) capacity - 2.5 MLD at Block No. 78,79,80,85,88,96,99 & 294, Village: Lindiyad, Ta: Mangrol, Dist-5urat.
The statement showing participants present during the public hearing held on 25.07.2017 at 11 :00 hrs at project site Block No. 78,79,80,85,88,96,99 & 294, Village: Lindiyad, Ta: Mangrol, Dist-Surat is as under.
QU Sr. No. Name and Designation OrganizationI Village Name Signature s l-llS alll-l ~~ ~El ~Nll/Jlll-l oj aUl-l ~~, ~8'\£~~ ~) ~ Cl ~~ .n~1<-~ .---.. J~> ~ Su-nl' s . tJ;b~ ~ 'Y..?":"":'- ' \ ~t~1, Jit,'ff~~9 JjM' :;7" -l.1' 3 I -c ~r(JNO . t: (--t; 1 }J./'0 ~ - GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, SURAT 338, 8elgium Square, Typleal l " Floor, Opp. Linear BusStand, Ring Road, Surat. Sr. No. Name and Designation Organization I Village Name Signature €Il{Lli a1.ll{ ~;;), ~at ~~l/Jlll{ oj a1.ll{ tl~ w~v1'av ~~ .- ~~'eN s..~ e: s-: o' .,.{"'~'Ill'&1.\ ~ t,l1~ «' «,j/ W1II~ Ohd ),JP f:. S 1).'1l<.Li ~ ~ ...... ,....,..., '" \- '~.j- r ' "-"IV: 1.'" <, ~j 'IV\~ ~""Y1....<... 'Y t\ '-' "'""'\,... S 1. 1\. f\ A.. CD~eJJ, ~i5+r, ~ ot:s:»; ~- 0 \ ~Cb\l \G\ f\l\j "--<\" I L -e , ~~'fJUI~ ~ Cf-P- i11~t0 'f"f'~ st.J,~ - rep JCl( h POYl~'utt i\ , ~WV\. L'4\,'(\, ~ b~ . ~ s'"'Cl-I.-f. ~~~ ~-rn~ vislt.~ !(\ ~. S"~~ ( tV rJ ltil\)1, I..Y1 Jlt-- ~ r< ~.l r ~ ~ .1)' Pi PdkL 5~ \1.:]/" ..:::> S~ Meet· I' ® . ;VY' @ (1'1.1 )1 ~II ~, ~ t{1v~cL< \ (fd~' "- @ .:<.{) EJ:< (t:rI //ftp '1/1.11 '-.:<1 o<..f)V·ZJ0 tt1AI/ I tLtf/ • dJ) ~r/~j ~. ffl;"~ ...-.. P1lpcP-cP4 {jej)' ~i'Y'~\-' \~ ~ ~ O\r7"r UlI"* ILIJ./~ <,.- GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, SURAT 338, HelgiumSquare. Typical pi Floor, Opp. Linear Bus Stand, Ring Road. Surat. Sr. No. Name and Designation Organization / Village Name Signature il{lS "Ul{ ~~ ~fil ~Wl/;)lll{ aj alll{ ~A / .• -j [£ ~. [tVVI~fOAJ 30. 3) . AA'J"HA,.f..S PI LA le,(nLl= fA~t:::. :n. GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, SURAT 338, Uelgium Square, Typieal l " Floor, Opp. Linear Bus Stand, Ring Road. Surat. Sr. No. Name and Designation Organization I Village Name Signature zl{l!i "HI{ ~~ ~~ ~~l/;)lll{ oj a1.ll{ ~~ qr£':lJ <.'"11 \S' ~I H '{'i7? 33, "-'l~1 I'=d d~" ~~~ ~,~~~I.v ~l. 0''''1(...... , tf q,:a.f'W C4S1Q4 1T1 c;I? .,.D 3~ r~ ,..s ;),.\ "f'fY\) 38 a. _,.J t1,JI /1'111 r7A"" ";-r ~?/~4: 1 ./"A?7 M~sA 3~ EfSJ..' 'n 'n'1~"'n~ ~clll ~lt\ l , ttl) ~"'-i11 J~a.u.J. s~ ~(,.,' 1.A':: 41 setrtl.:r nJ= lu_Tcf leS h Pc.P?S,'t,\'J.-III '/ l.I~ ~,~«vl ~(l r- '"d-I ~\.T ~ 1 l~ :;;. c:23~ ,,~ ~,~~. tj3 ;5, .Jr11J"\{ , 01.1>~ \l kh.tn A~ ~rn(1 ~~ ""tel C-f7..fllf I n !L/ , 1 .. <;L\ lot(n 61<'1 'V 5>'1. "1 '2- VI 'Y'I~ 1(~ I 4S ~.~ <, ~ ("t'\a,Cl. \ \ "" V\\ '<:..4.. , r<;;.\ H'7. 1I6 c(p' t"'I\ ,.) ~ GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, SURAT 338, Belgium Square, Typical til Floor, Opp. Linear Bus Stand, Ring Road. Surat. Sr. No. Name and Designation Organization I Village Name Signature jJ.tL.!'J a1.lJ.t ~~ ~61 ~ ~l/JllJ.t oj a1.lJ.t ~~ '"' ~~ ~, V, r\u-{tl\.£. f i l? 0 d.u-..rc.A... W l.>4<"- 4+ ~~ 4t PI'P~~ ;4rt}}./jif (:0. ?~ tf.e;"r;2 r~p'l. ~~ ~J.ftltQ\ Pi ~ 'Y'\~'O~c( 1>),,'.;.- >\J ~ ,~\'evt:U r \ 5"1 ~ (~, ~. ~~LJ. ~ f.1 '1->1/:> I r... ,"::') ..) '- ... -- 52- ~ I&" i 5'3 ~1" 2~\ .IS? <"1S"\,,!,\ _ 11 ..s ,.,.}....'"" ~ 1,41"" r: VV1. r~ '!,")/1 6\~ ~ I ~ sS ~ I'n'~, '4'> ~ ,.r.. J\A fiJI .., I ,,1\-,,':. . ?, . ....r .'11. •J ...J • V. bW~J - LiciJwxf 0.1. ,Jr,- 51 (""'~;J-<.YY ~-<" S t-( vw( 1(61 ~ ~>-~fJ 58 Pir~J~ ~ .,,\ ~,:s .rt.t ()'\;~ . rj . f~ FI'ro oolM.t.- 5" .('l\' ~t> ~wrK p;urf:; Sr. No. Name and Designation Organization I Village Name Signature 5ll{lli "Ul{ ~~ ~~ ~~U;)lll{ aj "Ul{ ~dl lCl'v1vl'2 ~,~ t?>~-w1 '" -5~ p .., ~~~ f1A<-<'· ---.S:"'uh J. ~0- ~"3 ~ I·Je~t..., fClJ.eJ. r''-l ~ I~ ,,~ fttlkl~~ ~f?tL£ S\-1~~ cA·~~ ~ bS""' '8!h-CVY) ~CfCtMJ S~ /~~; (,t, \J j~, {S~()J' \f'lmrD u ~~,~ ~~ \ h':f- ~wJ\ ~'"{\~ ~~ C"'V\' \ G'8 c:J-i!>q d~lj=< g< Gil re, S>l!'Y :7./'1, cAal,u:z} 6'1. n7 CH' -'~ ca/' 4/)_2''-e-Wl.4 - ~~, ~\8\S '---. J z»: 10 5\ ' c.pe-!5 , s;:,,, c.+ . M' .s. l'(,c,J-v1 fsIPc..(Q Ll1'of ~'l1' 1-1 .s ~ ~p.. 'sL'J~ ,s.o.:, S~r-e-. ~ ~ ~, fYJ7/"- M~ / / ANNEXURE - B (English) A statement showing issues raised by the participants and responses by the representative of the applicant during the public hearing As per the provisions of Notification No. S.O. 1533 dated 14/09/2006 and its subsequent amendment S.O. 3067(E) dated 01/12/2009, Ministry of Environment, Forests & Climate Change, Government of India, New Delhi, public hearing is conducted for M/s. Rajhans Fila Textile Park (CETP), for proposed Common Effluent Treatment Plant (CETP) - Total Capacity 2.5 MLD, The Public Hearing held on 25/07/2017 at 11.00 hrs. At Project site of M/s. Rajhans Fila Textile Park (CETP), Block No. 78, 79, 80, 85, 88, 96, 99 & 294, ViII: Lindiyad, Ta. Mangrol, Dist. Surat (Gujarat)., which is covered under category "B" of above referred Notification under the supervision of Shri S.D.Vasava (GAS), Residential Additional Collector & Additional District Magistrate, Surat and Chairman of public hearing committee. Shri T.B.Shah, Regional officer, GPCB Surat and Committee Member, Representative of Member Secretary GPCB; welcomed all present to the Public Hearing. He outlined the various provisions of the Notification and briefed about the procedural details for conducting this Public Hearing, including actions taken by GPCB for wide publicity of this Public Hearing and the advertisement published earlier in the local daily newspaper. He announced that as per the provision of Notification, only affected persons will be allowed to make their representation in the Public Hearing while others having plausible stake may submit their representation in writing which would be included in proceedings. He also made it clear to the gathering that the Committee is responsible only for preparation of proceedings of the meeting covering all the concerns raised during the Public Hearing. He then opened the public hearing after due permission from Chairman of Public Hearing and the invited the Project Proponent to make the presentation oftheir project in local language. Then representative of M/s. Rajhans Fila Textile Park (CETP) Shri Dharmesh Vyas, President welcomed all and gave introduction of the project and Technical representative presented the technical information about project, company introduction, CETP capacity, impact on environment due to proposed project, environmental management system, mitigation measures & socio economic responsibilities in local language. After the presentation by project proponent, Representative of GPCB with the due permission of Chairman of Public Hearing opened the forum for representations/ suggestion/ objections/ questions from the locally affected people. 1 The statement showing issues/suggestions/objections/opinion raised by participants during the Public hearing and responded to by representative of the project proponent during the public hearing is as under... Sr. No. Name and Point Represented and/or written Replies by Concerned Address submission Project Proponent 1. Shri Bhagubhai • He represented that, first time Patel (Vimal) such textile park is going to be Ex-Minister, developed, in which there will Environment be CETP plant. There are many and local leader. water jet plants in Surat district which discharge polluted water but sufficient staff is not available to monitor it. Water recycle will be carried out in this plant, there will be no air pollution and there is no issue of solid waste, so there will be negligible chancesof pollution. • He further represented that, under this project, there will be 75 water jet unit and 1100 other units, so employment opportunity will arise for around 2000 to 3000 people of nearby villages. It is my request to company's management to provide employment to local people. Employment should be provided specially to unemployed people of Lindiyad village and nearby villages and training should also be given as per requirement. He added that, necessary funds should be allocated for development of villages. 2 • He further represented that, it is the responsibility of the company to prevent air, water and land pollution in the area where project is established and to provide employment to local villagers. • He further represented that, skill development training should also be provided especially to women i.e. sewing, computer, beauty parlour and others, so that they can be self employed. • He further represented that, this company is giving new direction to people, government and industries by developing this textile park. They are creating pollution free area and will provide employment to local so I welcome this project. 2. Shri Jayeshbhai • He represented that, this • Company's Dhansukhbhai textile park which is going to representative Patel, established in our village will welcoming the Vice Chairman of be very useful to us. We didn't suggestion replied that, Kamrej Sugar imagine that we will get on behalf of Factory, pollution free project. management of ViiI.: Pipodara, Company should take care of company I assure you Tal.: Mangrol, employment to our village company will register Dist.: Surat. people because when all such agencies company is in its initial stage present in nearby they show willingness to villages so that they provide employment to local can ask the vendors but later they don't provide. who get contract for So it is my request to company project to give the that people of nearby villages contract for should get employment. transportation, sand, grit, bricks and other, to local agencies 3 • He further represented that, registered here and will people from scheduled tribes also put all efforts for are living in Lindiyad village employment and nearby villages. They opportunities to local. should also get the employment. It is my suggestion that there will be new construction in the plant, so transportation of material required for construction should be availed through local people at company's stipulated rate. He suggested to consider this matter carefully. 3. Shri Kanabhal l e He represented that, my • Company's Babubhai village is consisting of 90% representative Vasava, scheduled tribe people. It is accepting suggestions Deputy my request that, labourers for replied that, I assure Sarpanch, this project should be taken you to organize ViiI.: Lindiyad, from our village so that separately for the Tal.: Mangrol, villagers get employment. employment of Dist.: Surat. schedule tribe employees of local villages in our project. Chairman informed to the people present, to ask any question or any information related to project if any. Chairman greeted to all those who remained present in public hearing and informed that, as discussed earlier, times are changing, industries are developing which is necessary too. Nowadays there are many colleges and schools, people are completing graduation, they need employment so development is necessary. Public Hearings are conducted so that along with the development, environmental issues and public health issues are prevented and path finding decisions to be taken and local people should be aware of the activity to be carried out. This public hearing is scheduled with the same object, so whatever suggestions are given here should be kept in mind by the project proponent. It is the responsibility of the project proponent to take care of the environment irrelevant of the representation not made during the public hearing. I hope that company would operate it's treatment plant successfully keeping in view whatever shown by company in it's presentation. Care should be taken so that issue related to air or water pollution does not arise affecting people of nearby villages. Suggestions 4 given related to employment should also be kept in mind so that objective of the project gets fulfilled. Before the Public Hearing, the Board has received total five written representations from (1). Shri. Bhavesh Mecwan, Tarsadi, (2). Shri. Mahesh Pandya (Paryavaran Mitra), Thaltej, Ahmedabad, (3). Shri Jitendra Babalbhai Patel, Ankleshwar, (4) Shri Hashmukh Vora, Surat and (5) Shri. Dharmesh Mishtry, Bharuch. These representations and replies given by the project proponent will be covered in proceeding. Shri T.B.Shah, Regional Officer, GPCB Surat summarized the proceedings and public hearing was concluded with the vote ofthanks. v\~ /v(-.v-- a \ Place: Lindiyad, T.B.SHAH ASAVA(GAS) Ta: Mangrol Regional Officer, Resident Additional Collector Dist.: Surat GPCB, 5urat, and Additional District Date: 25/07/2017 Committee Member, Magistrate, Surat Representative of the Member Secretary, GPCB 5 ~~et.~ - c.(l '\ (~L"l(~ldl.) C-U!l ~<>llCl.g{l €.~(il~l<>l el'l(~ c-uBl lil~l ~'l( !l~Cl.ll{i ~lqC-l lj~l~ ~.;). ~~'l(€.l~<>ll \l(ct[;lro. lil~l ~l~Cl.ll{i ~lqC-l 'l(cue.t l1ll ~. il.c.O..tlle, \ll~IDB ~lUBl~, O!'l(~lct \l~1:t~ Rci.?l~ c.i1.s, ~ ceu.~c.uE ctl{~ ~l:2l.at~all \t~etlalOnlO. C-UB ~allet~.u \ll~l1l B~etl~ ~laC-l. ct~?A \t~m'l(allBl~~ ctl{all ~mct \t~m'l(aU lCl.il. wlRB l1ll1:tll{i l{l~dl ~'l( B~eu ~laC{. il.~~ ~l'l(b~ $lC{l aatal8C{ \tl!! (~.8.il.l.fi.) all \llrtRlil. ~ Uiltl CCl.l~, il~sere lAl~l B\tall.u \t~~ll, G~\tlEal ~5lall l{l~lrt, aBallBC{ l{l~lrt, ~letaU~ ~mct \t~m'l(alllO. \t 1 1.l.(hil.'ll'otllil~otl \l.lrtRlU Ql~l ~~let 'Y.~{ 2.l~l &llE \l.lE~li ~lUlil~~, :lJ'll'~let \l.ftl~ R2.i.?l~l c.ig otl \l.lrtRlU Ql~l ~~Ill~aO. 1.l.~cUot:la2.0. wlRli ~~~:l.lM c-uBlaO. ~~l C-Uli ~otlet~ E~~lot ~l~ ~&C-l c-uBl Ql~l JU[i;tlil.l.i ~~ li~etll.l.i ~lClc-l \l.fluetil:.l.lRt..~otUl.{etat rtl.l.'ll' ~~'ll'El~otl \l.lrtRlU Ql~l ~l1.l.etll.l.i ~lClC-l \l.~"11.~ aO.~ l;i'll'&l ~: &1.l.aO.oti \l.lrtRlU IOl ~l ~lUetC-l \l.~et~ \ ~ (!l:lJ(ille • rtl.l.~ ~~let liMl ~llqi B, 1.l.ac-l(lCll.l.c-l), 1.l.&c.(l etl>let ~l \l.lil~oU ae;:leC-l I.l.l~ I.{?O.~, 1.l.l§ &laO. ~(ii1. ~ ~i ~.e.il..l!l. 1.l.~{et~~ ~~ \.C-ll.e 2.le ~(ii1. ~. ~M ~c<-lll.l.i wlRli ~l51.etlot t.l~U &ll:.l.l eUz~ ~z \.C-ll.e ~, ~lll.et lU~aoU RlilC-l li~ ~ 1.l.~l rtotl l.{taO.Zf[:ll I.l.la iil.zc-u &lW ~l$ ot2.0.. ~l \.C-ll.el.l.i eUz~ ~~l~liC-l 2.letloj ~ rtl.l.'ll' ~etloj ~"tl~l 2.letloj ot2.0. ~~ ~@S Cl~oU 1.l.~l \l.fl ot2.0. iil.za \l.~"tl~oti \l.fU otcAetet ~. • rtl.l.~ et~l.l.i ~~let li~etl ~uqi B, ~l \.C-ll.el.l.i ,,4. eUz~ ~Z ~Rz ~~ c.O.'ll1. \ \00 ~Rz ~ rt2.0. ~l~&ll~oti :lUl.l.oti ~OOO 2.0. 3000 c-uBl~ ~'l{;)U~ l.l.ilI. rteO. etBl crl!O. 2.letlaO. ~. rt2.0. ~ &1.l.aO.oti ~ ~lC-lBl~ lClaictl liS !.? B, wlRli I.l.l~l~~ ~'ll':lll~ ~l1.l.etll.l.i ~lCl. rtl.l.'ll' @S~lE :lUI.l. B rtaO. ~l~&ll~oti :lUl.l.oti I.l.l~l~ ~ (;l~'l{;)U ~ ~etloU ~ rt~ »u ~ ~'l{;)U ~ ~l1.l. etll.l.i ~l Cl ~~ ~~ \l.l.l.l~ etlC.(l1.l. 1.l.~l ~l1.l.etll.l.i ~lCl. 2 £ 12~ ~~A.~ v~ ~llQ 1}"hlj Ii ltli ~1~ ~'UJ1q 1}"hlj ))~~: o~ -v~ a~ ~ llt'l!tlle ~llt ~ ~~ lJDlt ~lleA.~ ~~lt' 'l-'~ 1ellt : 01)) llD~l'l'l~llQ Ii ~ ]lDltlle ]lD~l'l'l~llQ l~lltlQ °lP~ '1~31!tl}\ : ltlle n.1lQ ~~~1'l'l ~lt)) lD l)Dh.-)q lP~ ~'UJlt 2q~l!'- ))qft 'lDl!~~ ~(;~)) ;?"l!A.~l! ~R11'i. ~ltlQ o~ Ue~hil A. 'l'ltrt ~alP llD~2q~ ]lD1}"hlj ~ 'Ii ~IlM ~llt ltlle l~lltlQ ~ ~ \!!l~ 1}"1'> ~le~ A.~lt1q ll>~)g'b1lQ lD12~ ~lh l-'a1~~ 1lQ lltltlle l~lltlQ 'l-'~h all~lf\~lD~ ~13:nj~l'i. 1}"hlj • 'Ii ~1~ ll>~q ))1~~ @lt~ • all~l~~A. 1)& I ~ o~ ~lqp1lQ ~1}"hlj ~~ ~h1lQ ~lleA.~ ~q1j1m ~lQ ~ 11~ lP1lD'l'l 112~~ J.>Sft ~R11'i. '~ 11~ l}\llQ n~'V lPlD ~lel!lil ~lQ ~~W~~ '~~lt' lP1lD1'> ~lh l-'a1~~ 1lQ 1}"hlj 1lQ 'Ii ~1~ l))~q ))1~~ llt~p '@lt~ • °li1~ lP'UJl! ~1lcA.~~ ~~ ~~ ~llQ ]lt1ph1lQ ltn-'ll> 1}";?"l!hlt'p~ l-)~ llt~~p ~t)1hlf~ '~2hltt~ 'l~p~ ~~1l-)l1lt ~~q 1HIIl. llt~ ~llQ llt1ph1lQ ~h ltn-'ll> 1}"~~ ;?"l!hlt'P~ l-'~ 'Ii ~1~ l))~q ))1~~ llt~p '@lt~ • °'t!llQ ~lleA.~ ~~lt' ~lQ ~1l21'> ~~R11'i. ~lfl1h 'lp~ 'lP~n Ii ~ 1211l ~131'>lpA. q~llt1~ 1}"~ ~lW ~l}\lm 1el!lil ~h 'UJm ~ 'Ii ~11M l))~q ))1~~ llt~p '@lt~ • '~llQ llt1ph1lQ 1!D1(; ~EA. ~llt ~lq~ 11"lt1lc 1~" 1}"hlj 'Ii ~l!il '@lt~ ~))fa>l'i. l-'~lhlQ ft l)D~~ "'lQ Itl)D ~l1lft l-,~q ))1~~ o c IWi 1~" 13l1j~1\ 11"1}"hlj fa~l)D~q ~~ tift l1lil <1' ll ~. : ij ~C-lOl ~lm'l(ol ll~t.i. aLUllll~'li1. ~l'l« ~Ullll~'li1. C{lll ijollCl~){i ~'l« rt){l){ c{l&\;( ~lCllll ~){ ~~ ~. ~~~ ~lec.{l e.tlll &\aodl ~, 4 ~c{l ~, c{lBl 5).~iile 2U lCl.BHl..Q ~l;). ~;). 'It ~leO. c{lB ijallClt:lO. ~lIllCUll.i ~la ~ B~ 21.~ ll.l:ltE~tB Rt:ll ~laC-t i} iilecA ~ Bie ij~..u ~l'ltCllll.i ~laC-t ~ a~ \I.~'l{Bl I:. 'It 'l{CllCllEl~ ~. ~~ B'lt..Qiil V.:>l~~lalll.i ~ B~C{ ~ a~ I:. ~~lC{al B~ aeO. ~ ~illlll ~l".l ~ ~~ ~l~e.u~ali :lllll.ali c{lBl~ 'ltlt:lll B ~Cllali ~'tlt:llali 13al (3~ll al mll. aol 'ltt:ll I:.U~..Q CIllCllrlll.i 'ltt:ll ~ ~~lc1l 21.e ~ a~ \I.~'l{Bll:. c{lB ijallClt:lO. ~:lll(3 §e-t 'lti~ (Il) cA6il.rl ~~lc1l ll.m.C{ ~. ~ (') .,(l ~lla~l ilBCllal, rl~~lSl, (~) .,(lll.~~l 1.iS1U ('It 'ltac{, ~5C1.~~, (11) .,(l ~~1311l eU~l, ij~rl ~~ (Il) .,(l \:l.i(~l (it~, ~~~ rl~~20. ll.m.C{ ~. ~l ~~lc1l~ all.'l{ 'lt~~'l{allBl~all \I.~"rl~..u BldCll~ oU\:l.ll.i ~ll.la~l B~Cllll.i ~lClil.. ~rlll.i .,(l, ~.c.(l.~ll~. \l.le.(il.B ~ID.Bl~. :l.l- \I.. R. c.U~ Ql~l BldCll~..u ~l~itl ~~ B~ ~1:. ~~~ ~ N.l.Ul: :lUll. : lalS eus, ~.c.ll.~ll~ iil~~lc:ll :':;>AK), rll. ll.i:ll~c{, \l.le.(il.B ~ID.Bl~. ~:lihll.c.ll .• RCll~ ~ID.B BcA5e~ ~~ ~c<{l: ij~rl ij~rl ~~ ~(itlrtali ~~, ~~ ~ID.B ~C<{l il~~e.,(l, rll~lIl: ~1l/0"/~O'" ~(ilCl.,(l ~.1.il.~.c.ll all ij~rl \l.lrtRID. 5 t: ;, ::-' I !R E-C- .1. To, Regional Officer, Gujarat pollution control board, 338 , Belgium square, New delhi gate ,Ring road, SURAT. Sub: Public hearing for Common Effluent Treatment Plant ( CETP ) of Rajhans Fila Textile Park. Respected sir, With reference to public hearing for common effluent treatment plant ( CETP ) of Rajhans Fila Textile Park, my representation is as under. 1. Rajhans Fila Textile Park has proposed to use canal water hence provide a copy of Permission from Irrigation Department. 2. Provide a pipeline diagram for reuse of R.O. reject water for toilet flushing by their Member units. After toilet flushing, R.O. reject water will met underground strata Then it will not increased salinity level of soil ? 3. Monitored value of PM10 and PM2.5 is already high or on boarder line then provide Your action plan to maintain Air Quality. - 4. Provide the details of CSR activities to be carried out as well as plan for employment To local people. You are requested to provide above details as early as possible so that I can represent the case in public hearing. Thanking you, ~rI'-:V \'l:J\ Bhavesh Mecwan PARYAVARANMITRA 5Ci:? \ Raj Avenue, n~~EdKs~ka f\i?J;1i;-;r Hoac~ r'~r Th~jtt;jl Cross floud, Thaltej. Ahmedabad - 380 059 Ptwtle; (Vi'S) 2685132; Email: paryaviJran'nitra'Jvahoo.cofl1 We!)site . '1Up:liparyavaranmitra.org.in Ref: PMlMPIEPH/2802/2017 . , '., ~ I ':C" •• ,- [ r _2..,Date: 15/06/2017 • "I I•" .. ' .• \ • ~ \.0J To, Member Secretary Gujarat Pollution Control Board Gandhinagar Sub: Environmental Public Hearing of M/s. Rajhans Fila Textile Park (CETP), at Block No. 78, 79, 80, 85, 88, 96, 99 & 294, Village: Lindiyad, Ta: Mangrol, Dist. Surat, to be scheduled on 20th June 2017 Sir, We have studied the draft EIA report of the above-mentioned project. Following are our observation/comments/questions regarding project and draft EIA report. lYours truly, 1. Collector, Surat 2. Regional officer, GPCB Surat O~ Rd': I' \ 1/\1 PIE I'll( '/2S 111/21117 "'.IRE "C,--JJalr: /'111711117 '.,1.\ "~-Lc. 0"; 10. vlcmber ~l'crelal"\ Gujar.n PollLl/lull ('()ll1rnl Board (J :UH.l hj !la~:~tr Sub: Em ;1'11/1 IIIl'/I1,,1 Public Ikar i/l~ or '\lIs, Rajh.urs Fil:o "('",tile 1"11"1- (tT 11'), at lllud, No, 7S, 79, KII, K5, KK, '16, 9') cx 29-1, Village: Lindiyud, Tu: ;\Iall;':"ol. DIS!, xurut. 10 be scheduled un 25'" ,July 2017 Sir. \\l' kl\\'-.:llldll\! Ill!.' (11':11"1 1·1 \ I",'pnrl td" til ....., dhU\-,'-illcnti\i!]I..:d project. l\dr'T\\i!;.~ 1:',-' 1,'Ui" t l h s c n ; l l l l l ll 'C\):llll h.' Il ! > q Ui-'Sl i t ) l b h':~~',;lrdjll~~ pru.iL'ct WH.l dr,l!"t 1:1"\ 1\'ll11rt. \\ !h.'il \\'a.-; ('I"!\irtlllllH,:"lltLlll'lc,lr;111c"-'!~II' this jXIljl'ct !Jl l orn: I ;lppli-:d',l \\'kll is the' st::lus ofNOC applic.niuu t» (il'Cll Ior this Im'le',r !lJc'dS...' Si\(' \..',\;\\":1 dak::i of :!l""!1!-,i()11 ;1::' '-1l1~t!it:. :surbc;,: \\:_~kT gr(llllh.i \\'all..:1'. 111':'-;\ !ii\'!! ~Urll!g '''lei sud qualit) 11ionitorillS, 1 ~. \\'hat l.ind, o! IX\"'i..:;lltli()Il~; \\ ili L'l.: tul.cn rill" ~;ll"lr,l~:l' ~L1H.l tr.mxport.niuu llf 11:1/~lrddll:' !n:lTl~l'iJi :llld \\ .t-, tl-' '.) ~ \\'Il:n F'll'll\l,sioIlS \\J!I he I,Jl\\.TI in:« ,.,L1llSidcl"iJlion III Lle1-:' Ilk' JlIU..'[ll,ltlonc:; u ihv !'",!!uU(ln lo.u.l dlUJ qu.uuiti...,s_ at individu.il 11h'll!hi...r indusuic-,'.' (\ l~ there all; cU:-;I-h':lh:lit i.li1i.d\:,i:'l L:dlTied out Jill' pl"llJ1il :(';1 ;'rl'jccl-'~ hell•."ll-. \ '-'1' ~ .... l'US; stem includilig Ilor.r. luun.r dlh.l '. L~:":ldti(lI1·.) 7 rka~;l..' give !la11K' ,)! I'c"J"kri..,;j rcl\nlT~ 1,_\ \\ l:'Jrn 1".:~:c.:J..J,'..)il '.,,:'): (;< ::C;r1 I~}l" ;;i,;j'\l:-,i;' ~ l)k':l--;i..' gi\\.' 11,UllC \)1";111 :llItlh)I:/,-d \'-':!li\ll" III \\llIlill dililli 1'1;1;...1,,, \\1\1 ht' ';0)1,.1. 0. \\'I1;ll 1'1 Illl' I\.'~'lli:lr lllC)llilUIII\~:' j11.:i1 tlu: ~kdl b,: i.';ilTJ,-\.i ('In!(li IhJlj" \\ l l:c pn.JjL'clpHJllUlll'lli " Ill. Pk\.lSC juslil'y domcsu;: wuur rl'lIUin.:lll\.'llllnpp{l~,L'Jproject. I I. 11\,,, IJlall) locul pl'OPic' will sctcl1lpl\\\l1lcnt through Ihis pro,iect'.' !~_ \\'kil will he ,lctj,il1 pL.111 fur :'Ul·jlJt..YOlilJlllic dl'\C]OPllll.'nT d!:1!l (I I"l': 1 1"'.\ !1t'0JL' ..:t Pj'OPl\l:';ll'~) 1,~. \\ 'hal acti\ iti l.'~ ; 111.1 Wi\l'\ \\ iii (.lkl." up ;l.'. ..I pdrl \) j' ( 'S1':::1Li \\1::-1: 'I.'] hi.." hI.' !1\1, t;'\~t ; t .:: i l ; Yoi.rs trulv. U' \ ~ f'lia,<~1( .... ~~, ~~~~ ttieiH'l< ~ ~o ~ -q«r ~ ql.,:a f'lia""'!iql( ...."'ql{ ~ 3/if;#p ---_. __..__. ~ 'l'dr-l;'(;'"',,''.'.'8 ·::rdT) ! ~~ H<" ",~'1C - f::;v/ .. ;) 15(6 1<' 0 -\"J ~'v --VS-tr--'oN ~\;r/\} OiTV,"NI ~ it}- ,~l) y' "1,l '63 lV!if>l'R:!il- ~ ~ > 1 '&3 ~!i .t>e UCtll.'ll,?-l!i1,? V'l<:0~ (l:llt~ 1£~ ~ '@ 'F.lel~ ]ltlbl UClll.'llF :'>_lMlfIj"'?"lr':"C1£::;:~=-'U~lCl;';:b-':;ll>:1'~"!i1MJ;~;"h"''Llcl';;:e'L-bl'''h:;-'ll.''lr~(d"~'"3"'JT'") l1Mll.;:-:;::'F.lr;~lVi?;;::'R:7"!i?;-;l;:;::'F.l::o;tJ"'R:'C<}'l;:-;~;:;l::;-e -;-::h"'h"""eJ ~ l EJnS -- 'PEOll gum 'pUElS sng JEilUn ill!SoddO 'J00I.~hs 1IEJ!dA~ 'ilJEnbs Wn!glila '8t£ 'JilJillO IEUO!gilll 'O~ 1,-:)-3 ~:Hl X -'{, " .., 3) Annexure-a C lj,llll'f>l !sll\~l<::\k <)llll':t~ !sl!s~l~l~ llll'~~ll !siol <>l~llll't.H 4) !s~~~2~2:bi ~~~l~ 5) TOR lj,,,,l .{f>l~ n lj,llll'f>l, I:J..~ ~i !sl~ !s~t1.l !S1{ 6) 'I.~l~2 ~ 3 Ort:U.~12~ -Il &~l ~i ~~ ~L 7) <)~~~~1't~ ~21 ~hl2ii~2 ~etl~l 'I.e:tl~2 ~-<>ll(32 *~~ ~i{e:tl i9 ~ ....-. '6'0 'b,-;;;r 'V'l::R ....., 'l,'F.ll$ltl 'l,2RTRt.'R lall-th.1!c 'n'l:: 1'1::1't> l .s:~ J10J ~l--- 6''bO'l::/~O/~ 'b : l ~ V'l::R : lola-<; ·~'t>lla~ 't @lhSi '@n'l:: 'F.l'2h.~1}'l ~Si 'l::m l't>tt tph.ll ~ : ~ ~ - 0 ,,- ~ 0 ~ " ~ :~~~~. (~-~)cfiT~ .~ em arrqfu am~l (1) (9) NABET-QCI ~ JIlt(f al~fMll!l11 ~ aiq.aU.aiq. -q &-=rr I (1 0) f ~.a). Rllli q;r ~""~!I H Cfl<~cmH 0llfcRr q;r ;nli, llG~ ~ q;r ;nli, lfflT, cj;;q;ft q;r ~ 1 ~ !ffi ~ ~ 'e ""HCflI{l1 (m. o ~-o ~-~ 0 U ~ m.~~-o\9-~o ~\9 ~) (12) cj;;q;ft if; ~ ~ q;r ~ ~ f.I (18) SLEAC CIit (Rlfi ~ cj;;q;ft qir AASQ: ToRq;r Compliance CIit liif>lCfl1'1100 lOlR't!l11'1 ~ ~ 'lU;:@ ~ ""HCflRll (19) SLEAC CIit (Rlfi ~ cj;;q;ft qir AA SQ: ToR q;r Compliance CIit \iif>lCfl1'1100 lOlR't!l11'1 ~ -ID m ~ ~ cj;;q;ft fl.1RslI'1 -q ~ Cfi't I (20) 8"G<;fi14 if; ;nli, lfflT aiq.aU.aiq. -q &-=rr I (21) cj;q;:jlil' c ~lOlR't!l11'1 ~ I.1Pn- qir <1""IIR W:rr ~ m~ w:uur ~ -q ~ CIit f.r;rffi'l (22) cj;;q;ft ~m~ ~ if; ;nli~i'reif;~~~-q auit ~ 851OlR't!l11'1 ~ I.1'rIT qir <1"" lll{l ~ -q auit I (23) cj;;q;ft if; ~~ -q GPCB CIit (Rlfi ~ cj;;q;ft oi<:: ~ CIit ~ ~ -q ~ -ID mcj;;q;ft ;r ~ ~ JIlt(f fcf;'lfI ~ ""HCflI{l1 ~ ~ JIlt(f ~ if; ~ fcf; lfl ~ ~ if; ~ ~ slq:gil"i! aiq.aU.aiq. -q ~ CIit fcRffi I ~ 'e ~~ ~ ~'* IEt~~·)~ t ,*,*1 I'*.-w '* ~.-wllf~~~~Z~_15' '1C I;r •• , ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ f i - ! '* j i .1& j ,*." i 'W .1& 1 '" !iil~~I~~ii~~:~li!~lll~iwll~ltttt ~ -~ -~ --~ 00 --m 0 ..... -N ------M V ~ ~ ~ 00 -----m 0 ..... N M --V ~ N N N N N M M M M M M M M M M V V V V V V ------~ ------. . ( ( ------(4) (46) ~ ~ if; ~ To, Bhavesh Mecwan, 18/19, Sahyog Society, Tarsadi Viii. Kosamba, Tal. Mangrol, Dist. Surat. Sub: Reply of Letter dated: 13-06-2017 Regarding EPH of CETP of Rajhans Fila Textile Park at Block No. 78, 79, 80, 85, 88, 96, 99, 294, Viii. Lindiad, Tal. Mangrol, Dist. Surat- 394 110, Gujarat Sr. Mentioned Subject Clarifications No. 1. Rajhans Fila Textile Park has Water requirement for the project will met proposed to use canal water hence through canal water. We have already provide a copy of Permission from applied for canal water permission from Irrigation Department Irrigation Dept. an acknowledgment copy is attached in Draft EIA Report, as Annexure-6, on oaae no. 174. 2. Provide a pipeline diagram for reuse Pipeline diagram is attached in Draft EIA of R.O. reject water for toilet flushing Report, as Annexure-2, on page no. 145. by their Member units. After toilet Total water requirement for flushing for flushing, R.O. reject water will met entire Rajhans Fila Textile Park will be underground strata Then it will not 348.75 KL, that will be met from RO increased salinity level of soil ? reject mixed with fresh water to fulfill the flushing need. TDS of the mixes water will be less than 1000 mgllit hence it will not affect the salinitv of soil. 3. Monitored value of PM10 and PM2.5 Proposed CETP project does not have is already high or on boarder line then any stationary source of air emission provide Your action plan to maintain except DG sets that will be use only in Air Quality. emergency hence no action plan reauired. 4. Provide the details of CSR activities to CSR activities to be carried out given in be carried out as well as plan for section 10.6.12.1, in chapter 10, Page employment to local people. no. 124 of Draft EIA Report. 22 Nos. of manpower will be required and same is given in section no. 8.2, chapter no. 8 on page no. in Draft EIA Report. We will give first preference to local people for 22 Nos. of manoower reauired. Authorized Signatory ~ Corporate Office: Rajhans Infracon (India) Pvt. Ltd. Rajhans Infracon (IndiarJSrlVate Ltd Rzqhans House. 3rd Fir" Opp. Gitanjali Petro! Pump. Varachha Road, Surat - 395006. (Guj.)India Tel:0261 2511129. 2553307. 2541456. 2503041/42 Fax: 0261 - 2541496 Realty I Entertainment I Textile I Hospitality I Confectionery Email: [email protected] Web.: www.raihans.co.m CIN NO.: U70102GJ201OPTC05995 1 ANNEXURE.D -2- ~ RAJHANS DESAI-JAIN GROUP To, Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502, Raj Avenue, Bhaikakanagar Road Thaltej, Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321 Sub: Reply of your Letter dated: 19-07-2017 Regarding EPH of CETP of Rajhans Fila Textile Park at Block No. 78, 79, 80, 85, 88, 96, 99, 294, Viii. Lindiad, Tal. Mangrol, Dist. Surat- 394 110, Gujarat Sr. Clarifications No. Mentioned Subject 1. When was environmental clearance Form-I with PFR submitted online on for this project in Form I applied? 02rd September 2016. 2. What is the status of NOC NOC application is not made yet. application to GPCB for this proiect? 3. Please give exact dates of ambient For ambient air monitoring date please air quality, surface water, ground refer Annexure-8, page no. 177-181, water, noise monitoring and soil noise monitoring was carried out quality monitoring. between 09-01-2017 to 17-02-2017, Ground water and surface water sample collected on 04-02-2017, and soil sample collected on 07-02-2017. 4. What kinds of precautions will be Hazardous material wiII be stored at taken for storage and transportation covered storage area & transported of hazardous material and waste? through cover truck to TSDF site/CPCB registered Refiners/ GPCB Authorized Vendors. 5. What provisions wiII be taken into Waste water generation will be from consideration to tackle the water jet looms only. Oils is the only fluctuations in the pollution load and contaminant and hence no fluctuation quantities, at individual member in quality and quantity envisage. industries? Corporate Office: Rajhans Infracon (India) Pvl Ltd. Rejhans House. 3rd Fir., Opp. Gitanjali Petrol Pump. Varachha Road, Surat- 395 006. (Guj.) lodia Tel:0261 2551 129.2553307. 2541456, 2503041/42Fax: 0261 - 2541496 Email: [email protected] Web.: www.rejbans.co.m Realty I Entertainment I Textile I Hospitality I Confectionery CIN NO.: U701 02GJ20IOPTC059951 ~ RAJHANS DESAI JAIN GROUP b. Is there any cost-benefit analysis Cost benefit analysis is not asked in carried out for proposed project's ToR approved by committee. benefits Vs loss of ecosystem including flora, fauna and vegetation? 7. Please give name of registered Yet not decided as project is in early refiners to whom used oil will be stage but we ensure that we will sent for disposal. dispose used oil to only CPCB Reoistered Refiners. 8. Please give name of an authorized The project is in early stage but we vendor to whom drum bags will be ensure that we will sold drum sold. bags/packing material to only GPCB Authorized vendors. 9. What is the regular monitoring plan No monitoring plan is proposed. Odor that shall be carried out for odor problems likely to occur during control by the project proponent? operation of plant because of leaks/spills of effluent, handling of sludge, can be anticipated and addressed by proper housekeeping and functioning of plants. 10. Please justify domestic water Domestic water requirement for requirement proposed project. propose CETP will be 1.0 KLD considering 22 person and 45 liter/person/day. 11. How many local people will get This CETP project wiII generate around employment through this project? 22 Nos. of employment. As far as possible maximum nos of local people wiII be oreferred based on their skills. 12. What will be action plan for For socio economic development socioeconom ic development of an please refer section 10.6.12 on page area bv oroiect oroponent? no. 124, in EIA report. 13. What activities industry will take up Different CSR activities will be carry as a part of CSR and what wiII be the out by project proponent in 2S lakhs budget for it? budget set for three year. For detail refer table 10.3 on page nO.124 in EIA Report. ~f1 Authortzed'Sl gnatOry Corporate Office: Rajhans Infracon (India) Pvt. Ltd. Rajhans House, 3rd Fir., Opp. Gitanjali Petrol Pump. Varachha Road.Surat. 39S 006. (Guj.) lnoa Tel:0261 . 2S51 129.2553307. 2541456. 2503041/42 Fax: 0261 ·2541496 Email: [email protected] Web.: www.rajhans.co.in Realty I Entertainment I Textile I Hospitality I Confectionery (IN NO.: U70102GJ201OPTC059951 ANNEXURE-D-3 .'. ~ RAJHANS DESAI-JAIN GROUP To, Jitendrakumar Babalbhai Patel A-4, Gajanan Park Society, Bth. RBL School, GIDC Ankleshwar, Dist. Bharuch - 393002 Sub: Reply of your Letter dated: 17-06-2017 Regarding EPH of CETP of Rajhans Fila Textile Park at Block No. 78, 79, 80, 85, 88, 96, 99, 294, ViII. Lindiad, Tal. Mangrol, Dist. Surat- 394 110, Gujarat Sr. Mentioned Subject Clarifications No. 1. What arrangement has been made Proper peripheral drainage system for contaminated storm water during connected with the sump so as to raining season wont flow outside the collect any accidental spills in roads or premises? within the storage yards as well as accidental flow due to fire fighting will be provided. For detail storm water management please refer the section no. 10.6.4 in chapter 10, page no. 119 in Draft EIA report. 2. Which types of trees to be planted? The detailed green belt plan given in Which types of gases those trees wiII section 10.6.10.4 in chapter 10, page absorb? no. 122 in Draft EIA Report. 3. During breakdown in CETP Plant During breakdown we will informed the what will be the effluent storage member units to stop production capacity in member units. Any activity. Additionally to overcome the provision has been made for the unforcen circumstances emergency same? underground sump of 850 KL storage capacity for incoming effluent will be provided in CETP. 4. How much storage capacity of the We wiII provide upto 70 tons covered Solid Hazardous waste will be solid hazardous waste storaae Corporate Office: RajhansInfracon Ondia) Pvt. Ltd. Rajhans House, 3rd FIr., Opp. Gitanjali Petrol Pump. Varachha Road, 5urat- 395 006. (Guj.) India Tel: 0261 2551 129. 2553307.2541456.2503041/42Fax: 0261 . 2541496 Email: [email protected].:...... -...vw.rajhans.co-in Realty I Entertainment I Textile I Hospitality I Confectionery CIN NO.: U70I02GJ20 1OPTC05995 1 ~ RAJHANS DESA.I-JAIN GROUP provided in plant? During monsoon capacity. season TSDF operator are not accepting any Hazardous Waste. 5. What effect wiII be on quality of The quality of water will not be water due to the repeated reuse? affected due to repeated reuse. One How many reuse cycle required for day basis upto 84 % water will be complete change of water. recycle and 16 % water will be fresh, hence water quality will not be affected. b. How much subsidy project 25 % from State Government and 25 % proponent will get? from Central Government. 7. Are those units are in operation No. which you have calculated? 8. Is project got NOC from GPCB? No. 3. What will be the source of water in There is no other source of water. case of canal water stoppage? What Fresh water for CETP will be source wiII be the storage capacity? from water Reservoir built by Mis. Rajhans Fila Textile Park having caoacitv 4000 KL. 10. What wiII be the quality of RO Reject The IDS of RO Reject water will be less water to be used for toilet flushing? than 2100 mgllit, which is mix with Is there any possibilities of getting fresh water for toilet flushing hence skin decease? there is no oossibil ities of skin decease. 11. You will be using lime. What you will Empty bags will be handed over to do with emotv bags? GPCB authorize vendor. 12. What arrangement has been made Proper peripheral drainage system for contaminated storm water during connected with the sump so as to raining season wont flow outside the collect any accidental spills in roads or premises? within the storage yards as well as accidental flow due to fire fighting will be provided. For detail storm water management please refer the section no. 10.6.4 in chapter 10, page no. 119 in Draft EIA report, 13. In case of non functionality of plant Our proposed CETP have storage what will be the effluent storage capacity of 850 KL. We wiII convey to capacity? Due to which member member unit to stop production in case units can continue their operations. of non-functionality of CETP. 14. Is there any guidelines for effluent 1 day effluent storage capacity wiII be storaae caoacltv for member units? provide by member units. 15. Is project proponent had any No. exoerience to run such tvoes of Corporate OffIce: Rajhans Infracon (India) Pvt. Ltd. Rajhans House, 3rd FIr., Opp. Gitanjali Petrol Pump, Varachha Road, Surat - 395 006. (Guj.)India Tel:0261 - 2551 129,2553307, 2541456, 2503041/42 Fax: 0261 - 2541496 Email: [email protected] Web.: www.rajhans.co.in Realty I Entertainment I Textile I Hospitality I Confectionery CIN NO.: U70I02GJ20 IOPTC059951 · . ~ RAJHANS DESAI-JAIN GROUP CETP? 16. What will you do for rainwater We will provide rainwater recharging harvestina? system in our oremises. Authorized Signatory Corporate Office: Rajhans Infracon (India) Pvt. Ltd. Rajhans Hoose. 3rd Fir.. Opp. Gitanjali Petrol Pump. Varachha Road, Surat- J9S 006. (Guj.) India Tel: 0261 2551129. 2553307. 2541456. 250J04I/42Fax: 0261 - 2541496 Email: [email protected] Web.: www.raihans.co.m Realty I Entertainment I Textile I Hospitality I Confectionery CIN NO.: U70102GJ201OPTC059951 ANNEXURE·D ~4 ~ RAJHANS DESAI-JAIN GROUP v.lct, eH1j"l ~~l ~\l, oil:~allU ~Hl~et m\l~I-QlI61 ~S ,~){~c·{l., ij~n-3~ll"l0" lCl.lt~: nl~"l \S-oS-~O\" \l?l aU "l(cU Oll){.ta~~IE, nl.){LOl~cn , ~.ij~n -3~ll"l \0, OJ''l(~ln "llrt ~laC-tl ~1"l(~H ~C-tl ~SH(mlC-t \lIA all ~tl'et1.{l all \l~tet~~~ C.u!s ijallet~(l ~5l.. i){ GC-c:).(i>ln lCl.lt~ ~\l"Gnl ai. \ e~leiil. ~"lil.~ lj"l( rt){"l( ~l){~aO. Bttl' V.lctHlE. aldl.. ~laO. ~lct EIA ~~CllC-t){L GC-c:).(i>ln aldl. 3 "!sl!s~l\ll~ "l(){all !sL61 al~~ lCl.eu01" ~i1. al~~oj \ll~ Corpo <>t. " etl~n 1\ H3/rll~lIt ~~ 'll' Gl~i! ~l~..u a~w.:>l !si!~. i!3/03/i!0\1.I. mrll <>t.i! 'i e~le~ Gl~rli!, e.til:t!sl){ rle.tS5'l Ei!~lGl eo!li! ~'I.ll~ Gll '!,1:6 <>t <'l 5 ~i! e.trlletetl){i ~l~..u' '6 ~C'Ue!sl~ ~~i! U~C{ ~Gl~e.O.~C{ ~){l~ ){l~ NABL \l){l~~?l «-Oi! (NABL) ~!U~rl ac.U~e~){idl i!0\" Gll ~'ll' ~){l\.rl u~ ~. ~){li!l ~~C{ltl'Gl ~(:L la~a'tl.~ !s?:l ~. e~le~ ac.U~e~oj ~c~i!sGl " dl , ~~~l~ ~~CUC{ lj'll'e.t, ~~C{leGl..u ~~l~ i!0\" Gll ~'ll' w.~?:l e<1 ~~ Gl.uacr.S cUei!, ~i!~~ cUei! scil.tail, ){lil ~~ ~(iC;l~~ ~i! ~).~C~ la~":l.'tl.~ la\ll~~l?l Gldl. [;l.~){lj'll'e.t, rll~lIt ~~ ~){~ ~lil Bltl' ~il.:>J.l~ e~le~ ~'I.ll~){i a~c{c.\:.i. Gldl. 1.1. il~~li! oi.. n lj'll'e.t, ~i!'ll'Eli! Qli!l ~il. ~~ am:>l ~!s){ ~l~dl e.ti~l:t~ et~){i ~!s etlltrl ~"t~~il.tl!s e~ elU C{tl'~ A ct~ C1~..a Gl~!s !sl){ !si!rll I:ti!etl ){le e.ti~l:t~ ~l~cO. il.tl'~ 'i !sl){Eli!..a ~"t~~il.tl!s !s~il !si!i\. c1~ Gl~!s !sl){ !si!i\. Corporate OffIce: Rajhans Infracon (India) Pvl. Ltd. Rajhans House.3nl Fir.. Opp. Git3njali Petrol Pump. Varachha Road. Sum • 395 006. (Guj.)India TeI,0261 2551129.2553307.2541456.2503041/42 Fox, 0261 ·2541496 Email: [email protected] Web.: www.rajnans.co.in Realty I Entertainment I Textile I Hospitality I Confectionery CIN NO.: U70 I02GJ20IOPTC059951 ~ RAJHANS n~c.AI. UI r.. oUP s Vlcise ~lltSedl. 3 l?s~..{l ~~l 6l~~ 'l( MoM l-li £l1ltC{ .'s~cO. c BltS 'll.~l ot.'s~lrl ot~ atlct~atl ~tS~~a{l !ill-lJn~ ~l~ lllat rt 'll.~C{l l?sffill-li, UlatC{ .'sll-l£l~~ Gl~GC{l-li otil. G'll.~l~ l-ll~ at~.'sa{l Gl~GC{ <:tl& rlC>tt1C{ !i~Clla{l "lAJlClltS ~c.HUrl "IA.sltS~. Vlcise <:tltlGdl. at~!ia{l l-llQ,& "Y.£lat .'sil. tI"lfPJ.M al.l&ctatl Gl~GC{ l?sl-l1ltlrt <:tlUcrll Gl~GC{ ~, ci <:tl~Cll~ l-ll~ Gl~GC{ Ill~l .'s~Clll-ll 1Jl.cise <:tltlGdl. ~£lci 7 l?s.J-(l. ~lqC.{l otlqC{ i>l.l{~~ (Clt\a{l l-llQ,& 'll.~l ~. "y'£lat .'sa. Corporate Office: Rajhans InfraalnOnclial Pvl Ltd. Rajhans House. 3rdRr" Opp. GiW1jai Petrol Pump. Varachha Road, Sural· 395 006. (Guj.) Ind~ Tel: 0261 2551129. 2553307. 2541456.2503041/42Fax: 0261 ·2541496 Email: info@rajhans,co.in Web.: www.rajhans.co.in Realty I Entertainment I Textile I Hospitality I Confectionery CIN NO.: U70I02GJ20 IOPTC059951 ~ RAJ HANS DESAI-JAIN GROUP To, Hasmukh Vora 25, Gopinth Society Chhapra-Bhatha Road, Amroli, Surat- 394107 Sub: Reply of your Letter dated: 16-06-2017 Regarding EPH of CETP of Rajhans Fila Textile Park at Block No. 78, 79, 80, 85, 88, 96, 99, 294, Viii. Lindiad, Tal. Mangrol, Dist. Surat- 394 110, Gujarat Sr. Mentioned Subject Clarifications No. t. As per EIA Report lime consumption During lime, handling appropriate PPEs will be 500 kg/day and this will be (hand gloves, facemask, gumboot, transported in covered truck that is goggles etc) will be provided for welcomed. But during operation worker. phase possibly lime will mix with We ensure that we will take enough ambient air and may create the care while lime slurry preparation, to problems in breathing as well as skin minimize impact on ambient air. irritation hence it is dangerous to human health. 2. The project proponent has applied to Till date the application is under Executive Engineer for the process. withdrawal of water from Kakrapar Canal through letter dated 18-07- 2016. However there is no response from Executive Engineer till date. Status of the same is not mentioned in EIA report. 3. Letter from "Kakrapar jernna Kantha We have applied for withdrawing canal Naher Vibhag" vide lettern No. water and it is under process. We will KJKCV/PB-1/NA Permission / Lindiad/ use canal water only after when Canal Block NO.88 vashi /1123/Dated. Water Authority permit us. Otherwise, 23/03/2015 letters conditions no. 2 tanker water will be used during that is present on page no. 216 of construction phase. EIA Report shows that during construction phase withdrawal of canal water is not allowed. As oer the aoolication letter dated Corporate OffIce: Rajhans InfrIcon Ondlal Pvt. Ltd. Rajhans House. Jrd Fir., Opp. Gitanjali I'I!IroI Pump, Var.Id1ha Road. Sural- 395 006. (Guj.) India Tel: 0261 - 255I129, 2553307, 2541456, 2503041/42 Fax: 0261 - 2541496 Email: [email protected] Web.: www.rajhans.co.in Realty I Entertainment I Textile I Hospitality I Confectionery CIN NO.: U70I02GJ20 IOPTC05995 I D A IUA ' ... s 18-07-2016 by pp to Executive DESAI-JAIN G 0 UP Engineer for withdrawal of canal 1 " water reflects that violating the above said conditions. 4. Consultant has collected the We have valid NABL certificate which baseline data analyze from expired on 22-02-2017, Our Laboratory Approved NABL Accreditated Assessment held on 07-08 th January Laboratory, As per EIA Report the 2017, and renewed NABL certificate is baseline study was between 1& valid till 22-02-2019 is attached as January 2017 to 31& March 2017. Annexure-I. But the validity of NABL certificate is upto 22-02-2017. Hence the Ground water, Surface Water quality, Soil and Ambient air samples analysis is not trustable. As per rule no photographs with date and time are not available in the EIA Report. 5. As per TOR No. 41, Undertaking has We will take undertaking from member to be given by applicant to carry industry unit that they will carry out Audiometric test once in a year who audiometric test of worker, works near will be workinq near looms. looms. b. 3 km radius from project site is a As per water treatment scheme buffer zone. Lindiad village is just maxi mum water wi II be reused. Hence, 0.5 km from the project. If this no significant impact on bore well. project got clearance then the health of villagers will be affected. During course of time there are chance of contamination of bore well water use for drinking purpose by the villagers. 7. Is Layout Plan approved by the We will take necessary approval. Industrial Safety Department? If so, approved Layout Plan copy to be included in PH MoM. 8. Please provide the information We will tie up with nearest Hospital for regarding provision of transferring treatment before put in operation of injured worker to the hospital in the CETP. The nearest hospital from case of any accident and causalities. project site is Sadhna Hospital located Also provide the information about in Kim Town, approximate 7 km from MOU made between hospital for the project site. treatment of injured person. Authorized Signator Corporate Office: Rajhans Infracon (India) Pvt. Ltd. Rajhans House.3rd Fir.•Opp. Gitanjali Petrol Pump, Varachha Road, Surat - 395 006. (Guj.) India Tel:0261 . 2551 129. 2553307. 2541456. 2503041/42Fax: 0261 - 2541496 Email: [email protected].:WV.oNoI.rajhans.co.in Realty I Entertainment I Textile I Hospitality I Confectionery CIN NO.: U70102GJ201OPTC059951 National Accreditation Board for Q Testing and Calibration laboratories (A ConstituentBoard-ofQuality Council of India) flRBL QCI CERTIFICATE OF ACCREDITATION EN·VISION ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES, TESTINGLABORATORV has been assessed and accredited in accordance with the standard ISOftEC 17025:2005 "General Requirements for the Competence of Testing &Calibration Laboratories" for its facilities at 301, Union Trade Centre (UTC), Udhna Darwaja, Surat, Gujarat in the field of TESTING Certificate Number TC-5304 (in lieu of T-3309) Issue Date 2310212017 Valid Until 22/0212019 This certificate remains valid for the Scope of Accreditationas specified in the annexuresubject to continued satisfactory compliance to the above standard & therelevarittequirements of NABL. (Tosee.thescope01accreditation.of-thls laboratory,you mayalsovisitNAllLwebsitewww.nabl-indla.erg) Signed for and on behalf of NABL N. Venkateswaran Ani! Relia Program Director Chief Executive Officer ANNEXURE-O-5 ~ RAJHANS DESAI.JAIN GROUP To, Dharmesh Mistry, Block No. 14, House No. 1340, Narmada Apartment, Opp. Mamlatdar Kacheri, Bharuch Sub: Reply of Letter dated: 21-07-2017 Regarding EPH of CETP of Rajhans Fila Textile Park at Block No. 78, 79, 80, 85, 88, 96, 99, 294, Viii. Lindiad, Tal. Mangrol, Dist. Surat· 394110, Gujarat Sr. Mentioned Subject Clarifications No. 1. Please give the name of approved Functional Area Declaration by expert Expert, which functional area they have worked as contributing to the EIA of well as their involvement with duration, sign and given in page no. III of Draft stamo. Also include above information's in MoM. EIA reoort. 2. Is functional Area Expert associated with consultant MIs. Envision Environmental are on regular pay? Please give information. Services (EES), Surat has already carried out EIA as oer NABET Guidelines. 3. Please include MOU with empanelled expert in MIs. EES already submitted MoM public hearing. relevant information to NABET/QCI. 4. In which EIA report with Public Hearing the MIs. EES has already approved empanelled Functional Area Expert had submitted to NABET/QCI. worked and sioned, 5. Please provide the information about fees paid to MIs. EES has already aoorove empanelled Functional Area Exoert. submitted to NABET/QCI. 6. What is the responsibility of consultant for public MIs. EES has carried out consultation process and the project? the legal documentations as , oer MoEF&CC Guidelines. 7. How much fees has been paid by project proponent Project proponent and EIA to EIA Consultant as well as the agreement consultant will mutually between them? Please out this information in MoM. understood and decide. 8. The other documents in place of Accreditation Accreditations Certificate is Certificate putted in EIA report is valid as on date attached in Draft EIA Report then, Please provide verified copy of the same from as Annexure-16 on page no. competent officer with signature and stamped. Also 192. include this in MOM. 9. Please include valid Accreditation Certificate bv Accreditations Certificate is Corporate Office: Rajhans Infracon (India) Pvt. Ltd. Rajhans House. 3rd Ar.. Opp. Gitanjali Petrol Pump. Va CoIporate Office: Rajhans InfnIcon (Indi1) Pvl Ltd. Rajhans House. 3rd FIr.. Opp. Gitanjali Petrol Pump. Varachha Road. Sum - 395006. (Guj.) Ind~ Tel,0261 2551129.2553307.2541456. 2503041/42F.,,, 0261 - 2541496 Email:jrno@rajl'lans.co.in Web.: www.rajhans.co.in Realty I Entertainment I Textile I Hospitality I Confectionery CINNO.: U70I02GJ20 1OPTC059951 ~ RAJHANS DESAI.JAIN ROUP 20. Please include the details of land losers in MOM. Not Applicable. 21. Please give in writing that company has given 85% We will try to give maximum employment to the local people. employment to local people. 22. Please give information about any fire accident, gas Not Applicable. leakages in the subsidiary/Parent Companies and if any death occurred during accident then give information about accident and compensation given to him. Include this in MOM. Please also give informations about any closure notice/ notices as per section 40 (2) issued by Industrial Safety and Health Department with copy of procedure done. Please give details of any penalties imposed for the same. 23. Provide details regarding the closure notice if Not applicable. issued any to the other units of the Company. If so, provide detailed documents along with the receipt of penalty paid to the Board regarding revocation of the same and minutized the same. 24. Please provide the details regarding the QCI- We can provide only NABET accreditation certificate application and QCIINABET Accreditated related documents prepared by EIA consultant in Certificate, Attached as MoM. Annexure-16 in page no. 192 of Draft EIA Report 25. Please provide details of person who is going to M/s. EES has already represent EIA report with his/her date of joining the submitted to QCI/NABET. orqanization. 26. Please provide the detailed responsibility regarding As per QCI NABET and the person responsible for the Public Consultation & MoEF guidelines M/s. EES EIA report presentation? will take the responsibilities. 27. How many people are aware about English Not Available. lanauaae in the affected area of this project? 28. Please provide details in MoM regarding population Already attached chapter 3, of various villages in affected area of this project. section 3.12 of Draft EIA Report. 29. Please provide status in MoM regarding educational Qualifications of local qualification of people living in various villages of people are not available. the affected area. 30. Please submit the dully notarizedundertaking by Not Applicable company or company's representative, which states that there shall be no pollution, fire hazards, other accidents or toxic aas leakaaes due to this orolect Co Corporate OffIce: Rajhans InfrIcon (Ind11l Pvt. Ltd. Rajha11s House.3rd fir" Opp. GilanjaJi Petrol Pump. Varachha Road. Sural- 395006. (Guj.) India Tel: 026I 2551129.2553307.2541456.2503041/42 Fax: 0261 ·2541496 Email: [email protected] Web.:www.rajhans.co.in Realty I Entertainment I Textile I Hospitality I Confectionery ON NO.: U701 02GJ20 IOPTC059951 ~ RAJ HANS company and why? 6 table 6.1 on pag~ ;td.' 90'Itl RO UP Draft EIA report. 42. Provide details regarding the off-site emergency Already covered in chapter regarding people of nearby villages and how it will 7, section 7.10, page no. be conveyed to the people? 105, in Draft EIA Report. 43. Can the police complaint be filled against the No. company's consultant, if any mistakes done by them in EIA report prepared for this proiect? 44. If the complaint can be filled against the company's Not applicable. consultant with respect to the point no.43, provide the details of section under the relevant act with reference to the same. 45. It shall be company's responsibilities in case of Not applicable. pollution, fire hazards, other accident or toxic gas leakages that may cause harm to people of affected areas or company's workers due to this project. The dully notarized undertaking of same by Company or its representative shall be prepared, minutized and represent to us. 46. It shall be company's responsibilities in case of Not Applicable. pollution, fire hazards, other accident or toxic gas leakagesthat may cause harm to people other than affected areas or company's workers due to this project.The dully notarized undertaking of same by Company or its representative shall be prepared, minutized and represent to us. Authorized Signatory Corporate OffIce: Rajhans Infracon (India) Pvt. Ltd. Rajhans House,3rd Fir., Opp. Gitanjali Petrol Pump. Yarachha Road. Surat- 395 006. (Guj.) India Tel: 0261 2551 129, 2553307. 2541456, 2503041/42F",,: 0261 .2541496 Email:[email protected].:W.IN.W".rajhans.co.in Realty I Entertainment I Textile I Hospitality I Confectionery CIN NO.: U70I02GJ20 1OPTC05995 1