arXiv:1410.6667v2 [physics.optics] 25 Dec 2015 okn ihaso aual bobr[,7 7 28], 27, 7, cen- pulse [1, the near absorber saturated just saturable is mode- absorption slow the passive where a common with the Unlike locking dramatically. pulse cee h liaelmto h us duration most pulse the the such on in limit Thus, exceptions, ultimate ab- mode-locking. the few Kerr-lens schemes and only case gain the with in the 7–9], as due [1, in sections arises saturation sorber pulses absorption/gain ultrashort the mode- of passively to existing generation of lasers most In placed locked achieve cavity. is laser medium to the absorbing order into saturable a In nonlinear is a pulses [1–6]. PML, optical (PML) ultrashort mode-locking method power well-known passive A high generating etc. for matter high- in a of processes in time-monitoring ultrafast applications real have communications, in- lasers optical principal Such bit-rate of area optics. an in is terest power peak and rates repetition eoyo h cl of scale the on memory uaincnb infiatysalrte h medium the then pulse the smaller time, below, significantly period coherence from be the limited [24– can because not arise duration case, is oscillations this oscillations Rabi In Rabi of and regime). (coherent scale duration, time 26] pulse the the on polariza- significantly medium of change the inversion that and strong, of tion so interaction is approach matter this with In light 23]. (CML), is [22, it sometimes mode-locking” as called mode-locking, “coherent 1(a)] (SIT) named Fig. self-induced-transparency [see or was 21] it [20, in where theoretically proposed was tion usual [15–19]. the saturation in regime still gain coherent is the medium of the gain regime enters the whereas absorber below) in the (see also valid when can is thus case This and the 7–14]. the field eliminated[1, that the adiabatically sense follows be the just in coherent polarization not medium is media absorber and τ ytemdu oaiainrlxto time relaxation polarization medium the by p eeomn futahr ae us ore ihhigh with sources pulse laser ultrashort of Development nte e a oaheeutahr us genera- pulse ultrashort achieve to way new Another & T 2 h neato fteplewt eoatgain resonant with pulse the of interaction The . c nttt fQatmOtc,LinzUiest Hannover, University Leibniz Optics, Quantum of Institute rpry eysal CL eiecnb elzdi nele mechanism an stabilization in dynamical non-l a realized the of be result from the can self-developing is is regime s regime regime we (CML) this article great stable and this geometry, the In very In of non-self-starting. a be Despite required. properly, to is believed width. setup sat is line complicated CML absorption gain a on the because based by experimentally allowed schemes limit conventional the to contrast in oeetmd-okn CL sssl-nue transparen self-induced uses (CML) mode-locking Coherent efsatn tbechrn oelcigi two-secti a in mode-locking coherent stable Self-starting .INTRODUCTION I. τ p ≪ a T TOUiest,Kovrsi rset 9 911S.Pet St. 197101 49, prospekt, Kronverkskiy University, ITMO 2 T n h rsneo h phase the of presence the and , 2 d hne h vlto fthe of evolution the changes a onIsiue a onSr a 28 eln Germany Berlin, 12489 2a, Str. Born Max Institute, Born Max laosaa1 erdoez t eesug180,Russ 198504, Petersburg St. Petrodvoretz, 1, Ulyanovskaya .M Arkhipov M. R. b aut fPyis t eesugSaeUniversity, State Petersburg St. Physics, of Faculty T 2 htis, that , a τ .V Arkhipov V. M. , p sset is n hnsol,o h iesaeo h ouainrelax- population the of scale time stat the time “absorbing” on ation to slowly, “amplifying” then from and switched also is tion etosaeol auae,wtotosto aioscillat absorber Rabi and of gain onset without (Φ both satu- saturated, case, only gain this are and In sections absorber demonstrated. saturable is slow ration a with mode-locking eun ako h us uaindsieo uhslower much of despite population duration the pulse absorber, time population the the relaxation the on In sections back sign. both returns its in changes oscillation); inversion Rabi whole (a a n c ept ffnaetlydffrn eaainra in [ relaxation absorber behavior different is the fundamentally absorber saturation of of the gain despite (c) of no and and similarity (a) lens) some wit Kerr Note mode-locking as (c), presented. (such In absorber appear. fast passage a pulse the after ing h osqec ftechrn regime. coherent the of consequence the I.1 h seta eal fchrn mode-locking coherent (a) of intensity details field mode-locking”). the “SIT essential of as dependence The to The refereed (sometimes (CML) 1. FIG. anscin( afo aioclain n 2 and oscillation) Rabi of half (a section gain version h M eie h us raΦ[e q 4]is (4)] Eq. [see Φ area pulse The regime. CML the ≪ π efnatn1317 anvr Germany Hannover, 30167, 1 Welfengarten b .I hscs,ln al fpplto neso relax- inversion population of tails long case, this In ). o hti h aiylnt sselected is length cavity the if that how sn tt.Tesaiiyo h pulsed the of stability The state. asing N .Babushkin I. , rsn u ofiiecvt-ieeffects. finite-cavity-size to due arising l rvostertclconsiderations theoretical previous all gain y(I)sltnfraint achieve, to formation soliton (SIT) cy T rto,tepledrtosbelow durations pulse the uration, 1 rms ti icl oraieit realize to difficult is it promise g , eun ak o oprsn n()passive (b) in comparison, For back. returns , etr w-eto ring-cavity two-section mentary N T T absorber 1 1 a a n()adisatnosi c] hc is which (c)], in instantaneous and (a) in fteasre eim h ansec- gain The medium. absorber the of rbr,Russia, ersburg, c,d ntegi n bobrscin in sections absorber and gain the in ia nlaser on I ( t n ouainin- population and ) π nteabsorber the in π nthe in ions tes h e 2 ter [see Fig. 1(b)], in the case of coherent interaction it mode-locking, makes its practical implementation rather is completely inverted, so that the population inversion difficult. crosses zero and changes its sign. As a result, such pulse In this article, we consider a simple scheme of CML- propagates without losses in the absorber in the regime based modelocking with the amplifying and absorbing of self-induced-transparency (SIT) (2π pulse), thus form- media being well separated spatially, forming rather ing a soliton. In the gain section the pulse takes all the usual two-section geometry. A possibility of the CML is energy from the medium (π pulse), making it highly ab- this case was shortly reported by us in [37]. In the present sorbing (that is, again, the population inversion changes article we focus on the problem of self-starting of CML it sign), in contrast to common lasers schemes, were the regime in such geometry and analyze in details charac- population inversion in the gain section either does not teristic behaviour of the system. We demonstrate that change significantly [as in Fig. 1(c)], or changes relatively if the cavity length is selected properly, we can cross the slightly, without crossing zero [as in Fig. 1(b)]. Because point where the non-lasing state is becoming unstable, of this, such SIT-induced solitons are fundamentally dif- nevertheless obtaining good fundamental CML regime. ferent in their dynamics from the pulses appearing in the That is, no need of a seed pulse is necessary anymore, in saturable schemes [27–29]. contrast to previous considerations [20–23, 30, 31]. The Contrary to the conventional passively mode-locked resulting pulsed attractor is stabilized globally due to lasers with a saturable absorber, CML lasers can generate finite-size effects in the cavity. We focus our attention on optical pulses with a duration much shorter than T2, i.e. the gaseous media with T2 in the range of nanoseconds, with the spectrum exceeding the bandwidth of the gain so that we have no need to approach single-cycle limit to medium. Moreover, it was predicted [20, 21, 30, 31] that overcome T2, which significantly simplifies the required pulse duration from CML lasers can approach the single model. Nevertheless, this scheme is very attractive as optical cycle limit despite of narrow-band gain and ab- a source of picosecond pulses with high power and high sorber, even in the presence of inhomogeneous line broad- repetition rate > 1 GHz. ening, dispersion, and the complex level structure [32]. Unfortunately, despite of the great promise, there was no experimental demonstration of CML in configuration II. THE MODEL proposed in [20, 21, 30, 31] up to now. However, gen- erating of short pulses shorter than T2 in mode-locked The ring-cavity configuration considered in this article argon-ion laser with active mode-locker and in self-locked is shown in Fig. 2a. Between the mirrors, only one of He-Ne laser was demonstrated experimentally in Refs. which is assumed partially reflecting with the reflection [33, 34] and [35], respectively. In our recent work [36] we coefficient R, and the others are “ideal” for simplicity, the have also shown experimentally a mode-locking regime gain and the absorber sections are placed. Both sections with a pulse duration less than T2 in the absorber. Also, consist of resonant nonlinear medium, tuned to the same in [22, 23] quantum cascade laser structures were pro- frequency. The coupling to the field, namely the dipole posed as candidates for experimental realization of CML moment of active “atoms” is different for both sections. regime. Theoretical study of CML performed in [20– The media and field are described in the two-level and 23, 30, 31] was carried out for a laser with the gain and slowly-varying envelope approximations respectively [26, absorber implemented within the same sample, that is, 38, 39]: as a “homogeneous mixture” of the amplifying and ab- sorbing media. Such proposals have, however, some im- P (z,t) d12(z) ∂tP (z,t)= − + ∆ρ(z,t)A(z,t), (1) portant disadvantages. First, the pulsed regime can not T2(z) 2~ develop spontaneously from a non-lasing state. Namely, ∆ρ(z,t) − ∆ρ0(z) d12(z) to ensure the stability of the pulse one have to suppress − − ∂t∆ρ(z,t)= ~ F (z,t), (2) the background fluctuations far away from it, thus auto- T1(z) 2 matically making the non-lasing steady state stable and ∂tA(z,t) − c∂zA(z,t)=4πω12d12(z)N0(z)P (z,t). (3) the whole laser non-self-starting. That is, to initiate a soliton, one needs a seed pump pulse injected to the laser. Here P (z,t) is the slowly-varying envelope of the non- The necessity to make CML lasers non-self-starting fol- diagonal element of the density matrix describing the lows thus from a solitonic character of the coherent mode- two-level atom in the absorber (for 0
∞ t+4τp d1 2 d1 2 Φ(z,t)= , A(z, τ)dτ ≈ , A(z, τ)dτ, ~ −∞ ~ − Z Zt 4τp (4) where τp is the pulse duration; that is, we integrate in the region around the pulse to get practically useful measure in the case when other pulses are present.
III. RESULTS OF NUMERICAL SIMULATIONS FIG. 2. (a) The scheme of the ring-cavity laser with an ab- sorber (A) and gain (G) sections. (b) The output field A(L, t) According to the original idea of the coherent soli- evolution in dependence on time during a buildup of a stable ton mode locking [20–23, 30, 31], the dipole moments pulsed regime from a vicinity of the non-lasing state. (c) The map in a plane of the pulse area Φ(L, tn) and field A(L, tn) of the gain is two times smaller than in the absorber, in the time moments tn = t0 + nτ, where n = 1, 2 . . . and t0 which ensures, together with the “mixed” character of is a constant chosen to align tn to the pulse maxima at large the medium, that fluctuations in the near of the non- tn. Black arrows show the attracting or repelling character lasing state decay. Such situation can be described from of every steady-state. Green arrows show the direction of the the point of view of nonlinear dynamics [46] in the follow- system evolution. In the inset the corresponding dynamical ing way: the stable pulsed regime exists and is well sep- picture for the configuration from [20] is shown. The laser arated in the phase space (see inset to Fig. 1c) from the parameters are given in Table I. non-lasing steady state, which is also stable. That is, the system is attracted to the regime, in which vicinity it is located initially. Other regimes may exist but they are ir- approximation of the pulse duration. Better approxima- relevant for our consideration. To achieve a stable pulsed tion is possible using the equations given in [20, 23]. regime in this situation one needs a large-intensity “per- We assume the lengths of the gain and absorber sec- turbation”, that is, a seed pulse, which makes the scheme tions Lg and La, larger than the pulse length cτp La,Lg > more complicated from the practical point of view. cτp. Importantly, we also assume that the cavity is small Although in the infinite-length, “mixed” medium the enough to prevent the population difference to relax to ≪ soliton will be shortened until it reaches single-cycle their equilibrium states, that is τ T1g,T1a. The last regime, in the cavity geometry with the limited cavity condition is crucial and makes the pulse propagating in the cavity essentially non-solitonic as we will see later. length the pulse duration achieves its stationary value τp, which is determined by the cavity parameters. The or- The important parameter G0 determining the gain-loss balance for low-intensity fluctuations and thus the sta- der of magnitude of τp, e.g. in absorber, can be obtained bility of non-lasing state is defined as: from the requirement Φ ≈ 2π leading to Aτp ≈ 2π~/d. Using also the energy balance in the gain section, that L is, assuming that the energy of the pulse produced by G0 = ln R exp α(z)dz , (6) the atoms w ≈ ~ω12LgNg is fully transferred to the field, " ( 0 )# 2 Z that is, w ≈ A τp/8πc, we will finally obtain: 2 where α(z) = −2πd12(z)ω12N0(z)∆ρ(z)T2(z)/c~ is the ~ 2 τp ≈ πc /(daω12NgLg), (5) gain/loss coefficient for low-intensity fluctuations. We chose Na and Ng (see Table 1) in such a way that G0 > 0, which gives for the parameters we use the order of tens facilitating growth of low-frequency fluctuations in the picoseconds. We note that Eq. (5) gives only very raw vicinity of nonlasing state and thus making it unstable. 4
TABLE I. Parameter values used in the numerical simulations
Parameter Gain (La central transition wavelength λ12 = 0.6 µm λ12 = 0.6 µm length of the medium Lg = 15 cm La = 15 cm 13 −3 13 −3 concentration of two-level atoms, N0(z)= N0g = 4.0 · 10 cm N0a = 0.8 · 10 cm . . . transition dipole moment, d12(z)= . . . d12g = 0.5 Debye d12a = 1 Debye population difference at equilibrium, ∆ρ0g = −1 ∆ρ0a = 1 ∆ρ0(z)= . . . population difference relaxation time, T1g =6 ns T1a =6 ns T1(z)= . . . polarization relaxation time, T2(z)= . . . T2g = 0.5 ns T2a = 0.5 ns The parameters for our numerical simulations are ≈ (a) shown in Table I. One can see that G0 9.0 > 0, that − (kV/cm) is, the non-lasing state is strongly unstable. We start ρ − ∆ the simulations from its vicinity, assuming the field close (b) to zero, the population differences at their equilibrium values and the polarization to be zero, and track the (kV/cm) ρ evolution of the field in the cavity with time. An ex- ∆ − emplary trajectory is shown in Fig. 2b, where we have started from the a short probe pulse of the the duration − Absorber Gain (c) 7 (gain) τp0 = 100 ps and initial pulse area is Φ0 = 10 π. (absorb.) ) After a short but irregular transient process up to t/τ ∼ 20 a stable regime with the pulse duration τp = 80 ps is born, which is significantly smaller that the relax- (d) (nJ/mm ation time T2, thus corroborating the coherent character of the mode-locking regime in this case. (cm) We tested numerically the achievability and stability of the pulsed regime, preforming many simulations starting FIG. 3. Pulse shapes in the amplifier (a) and absorber (b) initial conditions randomly selected every time in large sections in the stationary regime. The field amplitude A(z) range of pulse shapes, with or without initial noise. All (red line) as well as the polarization Ps(z) (green dashed line) the trajectories were attracted to the single stable steady- and population difference ∆ρ(z) (blue dashed line) are shown for the parameters in Table I. Note the difference in sign in state identical to the shown in Fig. 2b,c up to a time shift comparison to Ngain, Nabsorber in Fig. 1. In (c) and (d), the and sign of the output field. pulse area Φ (c) and the pulse energy flux w (d) in the gain The details of the resulting steady-state regime are and absorber sections are shown. shown in Fig. 3, where the pulse shapes in the absorber Fig. 3(a) and amplifier Fig. 3(b) sections are shown, to- gether with the pulse area Φ in the cavity Fig. 3(c). As Importantly, the population difference before the pulse on can see, the pulse area in absorber, initially (at z = 0) is far from its equilibrium value, and rather close to zero being reduced to around 1.9π by the losses at the mirror, (although remains negative), that is, the medium is in approaches quickly it’s stable value 2π. The population slightly amplifying regime before the pulse. After the difference is positive before the pulse, becomes negative pulse, the gain medium is switched to slightly absorbing at its leading edge, and at the trailing edge is restored to regime. As the relaxation time T1g ≫ τ, the gain sec- the initial value demonstrating dynamics which is typical tion has no time to achieve its stationary value after the for 2π-pulses. In addition, despite of the lossy character pulse. In contrast, the population difference in the ab- of the absorbing medium, the pulse energy does not de- sorber remains comparable to its equilibrium value. As a creases upon the propagation in the absorber, as it is result, the gain-loss balance for the small perturbations shown in Fig. 3(d), which is also typical for 2π pulses. In becomes negative, protecting the pulse against destroy- the gain section, the pulse area is close to π, as seen from ing. Namely, G0 in the such pulsed regime (obtained Fig. 3(c). Typically for such pulses, the population inver- by integrating everywhere outside of the pulse in Eq. 6) sion changes its sign after the pulse propagation. Also, becomes negative, in particular for parameters in Fig. 2 as seen from Fig. 3(d), the pulse “eats” the energy from G0 ≈−1.0. the gain medium, so its full energy increases. Then, the This dynamics is rather typical for wide range of the energy obtained in the gain section is radiated thought parameters as far as the conditions La,Lg > cτp and L ≪ the mirror at z = L. cT1g,cT1a, G0 > 0 (and is not very large, G0 / 20) are 5 satisfied. For instance, in Fig. 4 the dependence of pulse duration and the peak intensity on the dipole moment of absorber d12a is shown, assuming the other parameters except N0a being unchanged, the later is scaled such that G0 remains constant. The pulse durations are far from the single-cycle limit but nevertheless are significantly smaller than the phase coherence time. 130 1.0 120 0.9 A(L,t), kV/cmA(L,t), 110 ) 1 0.8 2 100 0.7 90 0.6 (ps) 80 p 0.5 τ 70 (MW/cm 1 60 0.4 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 peak 50 0.3 I t , roundtrip times 40 0.2 0.8 0.9 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 d12a (Debye) FIG. 5. The field dynamics at the laser output A(L, t) in dependence on time for different cavity lengths L = 50 cm (blue solid line), L = 20 cm (red dashed line), L = 18 FIG. 4. The pulse duration τp (red line) and the peak inten- cm (green dash-dotted line). The other parameters are as in sity Ipeak (blue line) in dependence on the d12a in the station- ary regime, changing the concentration in absorber section in Fig. 1. such a way that G0 remains the same, and keeping all other parameters as in Table I dition, the cavity round-trip time τ must be chosen to be Now let us briefly consider what happens if we cross significantly smaller than the population difference relax- these cavity length limits in various directions. If Lg ap- ation time T1g but still significantly larger than the pulse proaches cT1g, the population difference is able to recover duration. In this case, during the onset of generation before the pulse returns. In the other words, now more process, initial fluctuations start to grow until the laser than one such pulse can propagate inside the cavity. In enters significantly nonlinear and even coherent regime this situation, according to our simulations, the number with Φ ∼ 1. This initiates a chaotic behaviour with, typ- of pulses in the cavity is indeed larger than one. The icaly, a train of several irregular pulses propagating in pulses typically interact with each other, leading to a the cavity. This is a point where our stabilization mech- complicated dynamics, so that the perfect mode-locking anism starts to work. After a passage of the strongest does not take place anymore. An example of such regime pulse the population inversion starts to restore on the is presented in Fig. 4 (blue line) for L = 50 cm. In the time scale of T1g. If the cavity lengths is selected prop- case when L decreases and becomes erly, this pulse makes the full roundtrip and returns back comparable with τp, the soliton-like structure can not just at the point when the restoration is (almost) com- anymore exist, and either (a spatially inhomogeneous) pleted, whereas the other pulses “fill” smaller gain and steady-state, or periodic regime with the low modulations thus are depleted. In this way, the mode-locking regime depth appears, as shown in Fig. 4 (green and red lines) with only one pulse per roundtrip time is stabilized. for L = 18 cm and L = 20 cm, correspondingly. In the other words, the mechanism considered here sta- bilizes the fundamental modelocking regime against the multiple pulses per roundtrip time. In this respect, we IV. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION are also free from the necessity to consider development of the fluctuation dynamics at the lasing threshold, as it In conclusion, we have shown numerically that a stable is typically made for self-starting modelocking schemes self-starting CML allowing pulse durations significantly in the cases when the fundamental modelocking is devel- smaller than T2 can be obtained in a laser with absorber oping from the non-lasing steady state [16, 47–56]. In the and gain sections separated in space. No seed pulse same way it is clear that the mechanism described here and no complicated, difficult to realize artificial geometry gives the modelocking with the probability one. We re- considered in previous works on CML is needed. Rather mark also that, because of the instability of the off state, trivial ring-cavity two-section laser with properly selected the regime considered here also can not be described as parameters makes the stable mode-locked regime being a temporal cavity soliton [57]. automatically self-started from the non-lasing state. This We considered here a case of a diluted gas with typi- is a significant advantages over the previous approaches cal T2 in the range of nanoseconds, which makes the de- to CML which were all non-self-starting. To achieve self- scription of the problem rather simple even if the pulse starting the non-lasing state must be unstable and, in ad- duration τ ≪ T2. In our case τ is in the range of tens 6 of picoseconds. In particular, dispersion of the cavity el- for instance, typical for semiconductor lasers. Neverthe- ements play no role and can be neglected. Also, because less, to describe such system more comprehensive model- the Rabi frequency is also very small in comparison to ing is needed which will be subject of our future studies. ω12, the two-level approximation considered here is also R. Arkhipov would like to acknowledge the support of rather good. EU FP7 ITN PROPHET, Grant No. 264687. Authors Nevertheless, even in the present case, far from the also thank Dr. I. A. Chekhonin for helpful discussions. single-cycle limit and with rather low density of the ac- tive atoms, CML-based scheme demonstrates impressive pulse repetition rate in the range of GHz and high power density. We remark that our preliminary simulations show the possibility of such stable CML regime for large REFERENCES range of parameters (cavity length, dipole moments etc), [1] H. A. Haus, Mode-locking of lasers, IEEE J. Sel. Topics [16] V. P. Kalosha, M. M¨uller, J. Herrmann, Theory of in Quant. Electron. 6 (6) (2000) 1173–1185. solid-state laser mode locking by coherent semiconductor [2] Y. I. Khanin, Fundamentals of laser dynamics, Cam- quantum-well absorbers, J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 16 (1999) bridge Int. Science Publ., 2006. 323–338. [3] E. U. Rafailov, M. A. Cataluna, W. Sibett, Mode-locked [17] C. R. E. Baer, O. H. Heckl, C. J. Saraceno, C. Schriber, quantum-dot lasers, Nat. Photon. 1 (2007) 395–401. C. Kr¨ankel, T. S¨udmeyer, U. Keller, Frontiers in pas- [4] E. U. Rafailov, M. A. Cataluna, E. Avrutin, Ultrafast sively mode-locked high-power thin disk laser oscillators, Lasers Based on Quantum-dot Structures: Physics and Opt. Express 20 (2012) 7054–7065. Devices, WILEY-VCH Verlag, 2011. [18] J. D. Harvey, P. F. Curley, C. Spielmann, J. M. Dud- [5] P. G. Kryukov, Continuous-wave femtosecond lasers, ley, F. Krausz, Coherent effects in a self-mode-locked ti: Physics Uspekhi 183 (2013) 897–916. sapphire laser, Optics letters 19 (13) (1994) 972–974. [6] D. Arsenijevi´c, M. Kleinert, D. Bimberg, Passive mode- [19] M. A. Talukder, C. R. Menyuk, Quantum coherent sat- locking of quantum-dot lasers, IEEE Photon. J. 6 (2013) urable absorption for mid-infrared ultra-short pulses, Op- 0700306. tics express 22 (13) (2014) 15608–15617. [7] H. Haus, Theory of mode locking with a slow saturable [20] V. V. Kozlov, Self-induced transparency soliton laser via absorber, IEEE J. Quant. Electron. 11 (9) (1975) 736– coherent mode locking, Phy. Rev. A 56 (1997) 1607–1612. 746. [21] V. V. Kozlov, Self-induced-transparency soliton laser, [8] F. X. Kartner, I. D. Jung, U. Keller, Soliton mode-locking JETP Lett. 69 (12) (1999) 906–911. with saturable absorbers, IEEE J. Sel. Topics in Quant. [22] C. R. Menyuk, M. A. Talukder, Self-induced trans- Electron. 2 (3) (1996) 540–556. parency mode-locking of quantum cascade lasers, Phys. [9] F. X. Kurtner, J. A. der Au, U. Keller, Mode-locking with Rev. Lett. 102 (2) (2009) 023903. slow and fast saturable absorbers-What’s the difference?, [23] M. A. Talukder, C. R. Menyuk, Analytical and compu- IEEE J. Sel. Topics Quant. Electron. 4 (2) (1998) 159– tational study of self-induced transparency mode locking 168. in quantum cascade lasers, Phys. Rev. A 79 (6) (2009) [10] H. A. Haus, Theory of mode locking with a fast saturable 063841. absorber, Journal of Applied Physics 46 (7) (1975) 3049– [24] S. L. McCall, E. L. Hahn, Self-induced transparency, 3058. Phys. Rev. 183 (2) (1969) 457. [11] G. H. C. New, Pulse evolution in mode-locked quasi- [25] P. G. Kryukov, V. S. Letokhov, Propagation of a light continuous lasers, IEEE Journal of Quantum Electronics pulse in a resonantly amplifying (absorbing) medium, 10 (2) (1974) 115–124. Physics-Uspekhi 12 (5) (1970) 641–672. [12] A. G. Vladimirov, D. Turaev, Model for passive mode [26] L. Allen, J. H. Eberly, Optical resonance and two-level locking in semiconductor lasers, Physical Review A 72 (3) atoms, Wiley, New York, 1975. (2005) 033808. [27] I. N. Duling III, Compact sources of ultrashort pulses, [13] R. Arkhipov, A. Pimenov, M. Radziunas, D. Rachinskii, Vol. 18, Cambridge University Press, 2006. A. Vladimirov, D. Arsenijevi´c, H. Schmeckebier, D. Bim- [28] U. Keller, Ultrafast solid-state laser oscillators: a success berg, Hybrid mode-locking in semiconductor lasers: sim- story for the last 20 years with no end in sight, Applied ulations, analysis and experiments, IEEE Journal of Se- Physics B 100 (1) (2010) 15–28. lected Topics in Quantum Electronics 19 (2013) 100208– [29] L. F. Mollenauer, R. H. Stolen, The soliton laser, Optics 1100208. Letters 9 (1) (1984) 13–15. [14] R. M. Arkhipov, A. Amann, A. G. Vladimirov, Pulse [30] V. V. Kozlov, N. N. Rosanov, S. Wabnitz, Obtaining repetition-frequency multiplication in a coupled cav- single-cycle pulses from a mode-locked laser, Phys. Rev. ity passively mode-locked semiconductor lasers, Applied A 84 (5) (2011) 053810. Physics B 118 (4) (2015) 539–548. [31] V. V. Kozlov, N. N. Rosanov, Single-cycle-pulse [15] V. V. Vasilev, V. S. Egorov, I. A. Chekhonin, Stationary passively-mode-locked laser with inhomogeneously waves by the spectrum condensation in intra-resonant broadened active medium, Phys. Rev. A 87 (4) (2013) spectroscopy, Opt. Spectr. 80 (1986) 64. 043836. 7 [32] N. V. Vysotina, N. N. Rosanov, V. E. Semenov, Ex- doi:10.1103/PhysRevA.81.023819. tremely short dissipative solitons in an active nonlinear [45] M. V. Arkhipov, R. M. Arkhipov, S. A. Pulkin, Effects medium with quantum dots, Optics and Spectroscopy of inversionless lasing in two-level media from the point 106 (5) (2009) 713–717. of view of specificities of the spatiotemporal propagation [33] J. D. Harvey, R. Leonhardt, P. D. Drummond, S. Carter, dynamics of radiation, Opt. Spectr. 114 (6) (2013) 831– Superfluorescent generation of mode-locked π pulses, 837. Physical Review A 40 (8) (1989) 4789. [46] H. Haken, Synergetics: an introduction : nonequilibrium phase transitions and self-organization in physics, chemistry, and biology ; with 724 figures, [34] J. M. Dudley, J. D. Harvey, R. Leonhardt, Coherent pulse Springer series in synergetics, Springer-Verlag, 1977. propagation in a mode-locked argon laser, JOSA B 10 (5) URL https://books.google.de/books?id=rqY0AAAAMAAJ (1993) 840–851. [47] E. Ippen, L. Liu, H. Haus, Self-starting condition for [35] L. Lis, Self-locking and other modes of the laser oscil- additive-pulse mode-locked lasers, Optics letters 15 (3) lations, Acta Physica Polonica-Series A General Physics (1990) 183–185. 85 (3) (1994) 531–540. [48] F. Krausz, T. Brabec, C. Spielmann, Self-starting passive [36] M. V. Arkhipov, R. M. Arkhipov, A. A. Shimko, mode locking, Optics letters 16 (4) (1991) 235–237. I. Babushkin, Mode-locking in a laser with a coherent [49] H. Haus, E. Ippen, Self-starting of passively mode-locked absorber, JETP Letters 101 (4) (2015) 232–235. lasers, Optics letters 16 (17) (1991) 1331–1333. [37] R. M. Arkhipov, M. V. Arkhipov, I. V. Babushkin, On [50] J. Herrmann, Starting dynamic, self-starting condition coherent mode-locking in a two-section laser, JETP Let- and mode-locking threshold in passive, coupled-cavity or ters 101 (3) (2015) 149–153. kerr-lens mode-locked solid-state lasers, Optics commu- [38] A. A. Klykanov, N. A. Loiko, I. V. Babushkin, Sponta- nications 98 (1) (1993) 111–116. neous and stimulated radiation in semiconductors and [51] F. Krausz, T. Brabec, Passive mode locking in standing- multiplasmon optical transitions, Laser physics 11 (3) wave laser resonators, Optics letters 18 (11) (1993) 888– (2001) 318–329. 890. [39] A. Klyukanov, N. Loiko, I. Babushkin, Spontaneous and [52] C.-J. Chen, P. Wai, C. Menyuk, Self-starting of passively stimulated radiation in semiconductors and multiplas- mode-locked lasers with fast saturable absorbers, Optics mon optical transitions, Laser physics 11 (3) (2001) 318– letters 20 (4) (1995) 350–352. 329. [53] A. Gordon, B. Fischer, Phase transition theory of many- [40] A. Chatak, Optics, Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Com- mode ordering and pulse formation in lasers, Physical pany Limited, 2009. review letters 89 (10) (2002) 103901. URL http://books.google.de/books?id=fZSVXt0e8WAC [54] A. Komarov, K. Komarov, F. Mitschke, Phase- [41] I. Babushkin, Y. A. Logvin, N. Loiko, Symmetry break- modulation bistability and threshold self-start of laser ing in optical dynamics of two bistable thin films, Quan- passive mode locking, Physical Review A 65 (5) (2002) tum Electronics 28 (2) (1998) 104–107. 053803. [42] I. Babushkin, Y. A. Logvin, N. Loiko, Interrelation of [55] J. Soto-Crespo, N. Akhmediev, G. Town, Continuous- spatial and temporal instabilities in a system of two non- wave versus pulse regime in a passively mode-locked laser linear thin films, J. Exp. Theor. Phys. 90 (1) (2000) 133– with a fast saturable absorber, JOSA B 19 (2) (2002) 143. 234–242. [43] J. Sch¨uttler, I. Babushkin, W. Lange, Labyrinthine pat- [56] A. Gordon, O. Gat, B. Fischer, F. X. K¨artner, Self- terns on an inhomogeneous background in a nonlinear starting of passive mode locking, Optics express 14 (23) optical system, Phys. Rev. A 78 (3) (2008) 035802. (2006) 11142–11154. [44] M. Schulz-Ruhtenberg, I. V. Babushkin, N. A. Loiko, [57] M. Marconi, J. Javaloyes, S. Balle, M. Giudici, How las- K. F. Huang, T. Ackemann, Polarization proper- ing localized structures evolve out of passive mode lock- ties in the transition from below to above las- ing, Physical review letters 112 (22) (2014) 223901. ing threshold in broad-area vertical-cavity surface- emitting lasers, Phys. Rev. A 81 (2) (2010) 023819.